I know he doesn't have millions of TH-cam views, but could you do a reaction to the video of Rory Gallagher performing Bullfrog Blues on The Old Grey Whistle Test, it is a hidden YiuTube gem. Thanks. 🙌✌️
Amen. Ive heard it thousands of times since I found the floyd in high school. We'd put darkside, wywh, and the wall on constant rotation at our party spot at night. Hearing the floyd always brings back long clouded memories.
I live in boston . Am also a huge celtics fan. Back in the early 90's reggie Lewis died unexpectedly . The next morning my clock radio came on to wake me. And it was playing this song. It was perfect for the sadness of the moment.
So, I had a pen pal from Germany back in high school, and he sent me a mixed cassette tape, and this was the first song on it. I wonder what happened to him.
I "enjoy" guitar players like Mark Knopfler, and am "impressed" by players like Steve Vai or Joe Satriani. Guitar shredders like Eddie Van Halen or Randy Rhodes are "killer" But the playing of David Gilmour, whether electric or acoustic, is the only guitar that takes my brain and my very soul to a whole other realm. I genuinely feel sorry for those who have never taken the time to listen to his artistry.
Agreed. The solo on Time-Live at Royal Albert Hall is sublime.And Echoes from the same show is extraordinay.I know other concerts get more attention but this show was fantastic.I came close to playing it everday for a few months.
"Just how did a band named for two Georgia bluesman, 'Pink' Anderson [1900--1974] and 'Floyd' Council [1911--1976], journey from England’s idyllic Cambridge to the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in Cleveland, Ohio? From its beginnings as an improvising blues-band psychedelic band with pop hit singles to a period when journalists insisted on describing 'Pink Floyd', mistakenly as “electronic rockers”; from the ubiquitous to being the first rock band played in space; from tales of an underwear thief to the doom and gloom of , 'Pink Floyd' have always been bigger, better and braver than the rest." ("Speech"---1996--Induction of 'Pink Floyd' into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.)
My friend went to a PF concert with his mom. They had a great night. Next day, she gets into an accident and dies. This song was played at her funeral. It's been over 30 years and still it gives me chills every time
@@calvinwboaz7085 Read Dave Gilmour lyrics to the song try Google. I am sure that it is different. Like Jimi Hendrix Scuse me while I kiss the sky. Some have heard as Scuse me while I kiss this guy. Totally different meaning and interpretation.
The best part of Unplugged is getting to hear the bones of the song, so to speak--the structure of it without the layers of studio tracks. It's not perfect, it's not smoothed-off edges and all that. It's the song and the singer, and the musicians all there creating it live. And this one is perfect for that. Sad, sweet, full of beauty and poetry. Love it.
@@user-yy4hl1no4x please, Lisa, don't. Please seek help, which is out there. I lost my dad as a 2 year old and my oldest brother just over a year ago. Both took their own lives. All I can say is, there is a solution to any problem, believe me.
@@user-yy4hl1no4x sometimes people do this and truly believe that their loved ones would be better off without them. Trust me, they aren't. They are devastated forever. Don't utilize a permanent solution for a temporary problem. It may not feel temporary right now, but it is in the long run. The long run most likely will include wonderful life events that you would be cheating yourself from experiencing. Please find help. If you can't afford it, there is plenty of free help out there. Call 800-273-8255
When you think about the music since Rock started, Dark Side of the Moon will be the only album people still listen to 300 years from now. The same way we listen to Mozart, Beethoven etc from 300 years ago. Your thoughts?
@@terriertz6837 Unfortunately your right. I Hope some find meaning in their last breath?? All you take from this world is your name and memories At least one memorable event happened in one's life??🤔💘💘👶🎂🎶
When I hear Floyd, I often remember my Dad. He was deaf in one ear, which made him picky about music he would listen to, then there was Floyd. He owned every album that the band released. I think that what made the difference for him was that Floyd was a full sensory experience,. You don’t just listen to Pink Floyd, you immerse yourself in them. Wish you were here, Dad.
This song was written for Syd Barrett, the original singer of Pink Floyd. He left the band when he realized that he needed mental help. He got David Gilmore to front the band before he admitted himself to an insane asylum.
Well, the band moved on without him. They brought in Gilmour cuz they never knew what Barrett would do on stage. Some nights he would just stand there. And I don’t believe Syd ever admitted himself into any asylums.
Correct- he neither left the band nor realized he needed help. He lived for the rest of his life with very little treatment and never saw the inside of an asylum. Floyd didn’t pick him up for a gig, and that was that. The guilt they suffered over the situation led to some of the greatest music of all time.
This song has so much meaning to me. Besides the fact that I’ve seen them play this live & it was incredible, it was the band my dad (who was a musician) & I connected with together the most. He passed away suddenly last July & the last picture I have of us together he is wearing a Pink Floyd shirt. The day of his funeral, I was driving & this song came on & I knew it was him telling me he was still with us & everything was alright. This song was one of our faves & whenever I hear it now it’s like he is reminding me he is here each & every time. Such a beautiful song. 🙏🏼❤️
Love your pink floyd reaction vids. You're missing one big Pink Floyd song though so far, and it's one of my favs, "MONEY"!! Please do a reaction video of Pink Floyd's Money, it's a great song that ur missing from the pink floyd Playlist!👍
This lineup was 🔥... Michael Kamen on piano, Neill MacColl on the 12-string, Chucho Merchán on bass, the absolutely outstanding Caroline Dale on cello, Dick Parry on sax, and of course Gilmour himself. The DVD is called “David Gilmour in Concert” and is well worth the price.
My sons father had died, we couldnt bring ourselves to go to the grave site. We finally went. This song popped on as we entered the cemetery then as we left we heard "sailing away." He loved fishing. Was also in the Navy for 21 years. He is missed everyday.
One of my fave PF songs. Im in Texas freezing with no water, power outages, low on food, but Jamal is keeping me happy in the midst of this challenging time.. Thank you so much Jamal!
Hey Jamel! Your reactions are great, I look forward to them every day. I would like you to consider doing a reaction to Zeppelin unplugged "The Rain Song"
Led Zeppelin number one!! Pink Floyd number two , My all time favourite bands growing up!! Beautiful song! Thank you J for what you do ! I enjoy the memories you bring! 🥰
I absolutely love checking out young people's pages where they listen to my generation's music. I have nothing against beats and rhymes, but i believe 100% that my generations music was the best. Much love
Love your blog. I have a song idea for you. It's kd Lang singing Roy Orbisons Crying. I promise you you'll love it. I haven't seen anybody react to it. You'll thank me. It's a live recording at what looks like an award show. She's young and Awesome, powerful, amazing.
I shit you not... the last 3 funerals I've gone too I've turned on the radio in the car to the intro of this song. First time I was like, "huh, cool", the second time I thought it was pretty weird but the third time... just wtf.
Check out THETA TV they won’t block any of your videos. Also, check the Brave browser, you literally get paid for being on the internet. It’s what everyone will be watching on the new internet that’s being built. No one is talking about this.Let me know if you have any inquiries! Good to you and God bless!
And disciplinary remains mercifully Yes and um, I'm with you Derek, this star nonsense Yes, yes Now which is it? I am sure of it So, so you think you can tell Heaven from hell? Blue skies from pain? Can you tell a green field From a cold steel rail? A smile from a veil? Do you think you can tell? Did they get you to trade Your heroes for ghosts? Hot ashes for trees? Hot air for a cool breeze? Cold comfort for change? Did you exchange A walk-on part in the war For a leading role in a cage? How I wish, how I wish you were here We're just two lost souls Swimming in a fish bowl Year after year Running over the same old ground What have we found? The same old fears Wish you were here
Such a great song and I have always really loved David Gilmour's sound and playing style, just the way he's able to bend the strings and all. As I recall, they wrote this song as a dedication to Syd Barrett (the band's original singer/frontman) after he suffered a mental breakdown and eventually passed due to a drug overdose. Love the Channel, keep 'em comin' Jamel! Peace Out.
I think it was in this concert that none other than Sir Bob Geldof himself got on the stage to give a rendition of Comfortably Numb, a track form the revolutionary movie he starred! It's worth the watch... or the other duet version with David Bowie!
Don't forget thisis a man in his 70's who plays guitar and sings not a singer and not 20 anymore. I have seen him many times and I adore Gilmour. Thank you for finding pink floyd
It's unbelievable PF was not in the top three! I could not believe it when I watched that video of your top five! It's unthinkable but it's your list, not mine.
If I had to pick a favorite Pink Floyd song, this would be the one. I’ve never heard this version though. Btw, I understand to each their own, but Pink Floyd is in my top 3 bands.
An underrated part of their musicality was their ability to jam. Their live versions are like completely different songs. Take “Embryo” studio v. BBC live. Perhaps David didn’t play on the original, but he does on the live and the addition of his guitar work greatly benefits the song.
this is my favourite version of this song. you haven't reacted to David's solo work, before, i don't think. there's a lot that has his unique vibe. there are 3 live concerts that are really great. one called, 'Remember That Night'. the song, On An Island, from that concert is really amazing. Crosby and Nash support him as backing singers. the second is the Gdansk concert. my favourite version of Echoes, The Blue, Fat Old Sun, Great Day For Freedom, are my favourites from that. Pompeii, 2016 includes, A Boat Lies Waiting [in memory of Richard Wright] In Any Tongue, What Do You Want From Me and Faces Of Stone are my favourites from that.
Michael Kamen playing piano..... one of the most incredible musicians who not enough people know..... he wrote orchestral parts for everyone. From Pink Floyd, to Queen, to Kate Bush.... then his film scores..... a truly truly wonderful man. Die Hard, Lethal Weapon, Robin Hood. Check out the film Highlander..... incredible score. RIP.
This isn't Pink Floyd it's a David Gilmour show (Not saying it isn't good) and Just my opinion Pink Floyd stopped being Pink Floyd when Roger Waters left.
Cant believe at your age nobody tried to get you to listen to what you are. Grew up as a foster kid, my adoptive fathers family history is German and he was a computer technician and worked on the modern wifi. He's still alive but burned out from work. But he always made me listen to a variety of music. From classical to rap to techno, and this was the late 80s early 90s
My parents grew up in the big band era and loved the bands and the crooners. We listened to their music but they encouraged us to stretch our wings and listen to whatever we wanted to. Whoever got to the radio or record player first had control . . . except Sunday afternoons when Mom did her baking. She had total control of the kitchen radio
Thanks for this one. We’re in Texas and have been without power, heat and fresh water, in freezing weather for days. It’s nice to see this as I come back online. ❤️❤️
@@jamelakajamal What's up dude? I just listened to the Darkstar, I am listening to the Eyes, and I'll probably end up watching the Morning Dew. If you are up for it I gotta ask you. Why no Pigpen? Hard to Handle. Good Lovin', Lovelight, Katie Mae. And I've been begging for months for an Other One(2-13-70). So enough of that. I want to offer mad props on the progress of your channel in just the past few months. You've got the grace of the band. That ain't nothin'. They could copyright your ass but you are on the bus. And you have covered almost every great tune in my old music catalog. The fact that you picked Rush is just crazy. Yeah. Like the channel:) Peace to you and yours.
‘JUST BE A GOOD HUMAN’ Shirts and More, Enter Promo Code ‘Jamel’ jamel-aka-jamal-youtube-store.creator-spring.com
You should listen to ‘my old friend’ by Paul McCartney and Carl Perkins. It’s about John Lennon. Very emotional video all round. Good stuff Jamel 🙌🙌
Toots and the mytals got to be tough the best song of 2020. Please such a great song.
Pink Floyd my favorite when I was a teenager.
Check out “knocking at your back door” by deep purple you won’t regret it ✌🏼♥️
I know he doesn't have millions of TH-cam views, but could you do a reaction to the video of Rory Gallagher performing Bullfrog Blues on The Old Grey Whistle Test, it is a hidden YiuTube gem. Thanks. 🙌✌️
You should react to Rick Wakeman's Catherine Howard - Live version 1/16/73
th-cam.com/video/Cdt0tWIR1Eg/w-d-xo.html
One of the most beautiful and sad songs of all time.
Amen. Ive heard it thousands of times since I found the floyd in high school. We'd put darkside, wywh, and the wall on constant rotation at our party spot at night. Hearing the floyd always brings back long clouded memories.
I live in boston . Am also a huge celtics fan. Back in the early 90's reggie Lewis died unexpectedly . The next morning my clock radio came on to wake me. And it was playing this song. It was perfect for the sadness of the moment.
So, I had a pen pal from Germany back in high school, and he sent me a mixed cassette tape, and this was the first song on it. I wonder what happened to him.
So interesting how it is both at the same time. Floyd songs make u roll back in time in ur mind. Reminisce about the past.
My personal favourite Pink Floyd track
I "enjoy" guitar players like Mark Knopfler, and am "impressed" by players like Steve Vai or Joe Satriani. Guitar shredders like Eddie Van Halen or Randy Rhodes are "killer" But the playing of David Gilmour, whether electric or acoustic, is the only guitar that takes my brain and my very soul to a whole other realm. I genuinely feel sorry for those who have never taken the time to listen to his artistry.
Agreed. The solo on Time-Live at Royal Albert Hall is sublime.And Echoes from the same show is extraordinay.I know other concerts get more attention but this show was fantastic.I came close to playing it everday for a few months.
100% agree. I don't know what it is about that man and his strat, but there is something greater than the sum of the parts when he plays.
He's a tone poet. He can say more with twelve notes than shredders do with fifty.
There are guitarists then their are beings like David and Jimmy Page.
I agree. What about Jerry Garcia? He takes my troubles away whenever I turn to him.
Still one of the best songs ever written
amen to that
"Just how did a band named for two Georgia bluesman, 'Pink' Anderson [1900--1974] and 'Floyd' Council [1911--1976], journey from England’s idyllic Cambridge to the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in Cleveland, Ohio?
From its beginnings as an improvising blues-band psychedelic band with pop hit singles to a period when journalists insisted on describing 'Pink Floyd', mistakenly as “electronic rockers”; from the ubiquitous to being the first rock band played in space; from tales of an underwear thief to the doom and gloom of , 'Pink Floyd' have always been bigger, better and braver than the rest." ("Speech"---1996--Induction of 'Pink Floyd' into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.)
My friend went to a PF concert with his mom. They had a great night. Next day, she gets into an accident and dies. This song was played at her funeral. It's been over 30 years and still it gives me chills every time
Perhaps that was the last thing on her bucket list and she lived a full and happy life at the time of her passing.
Just Damn.
My favorite Pink Floyd song ever.
These lyrics get me every time.
"Did you exchange a walk-on part in a war for a lead role in a cage?"
@@calvinwboaz7085 if course it isn't
@@calvinwboaz7085 i think your hearing what you want to hear bud lol
@@d8l835 ignore it, they just want attention.
@@calvinwboaz7085 Read Dave Gilmour lyrics to the song try Google. I am sure that it is different. Like Jimi Hendrix Scuse me while I kiss the sky. Some have heard as Scuse me while I kiss this guy. Totally different meaning and interpretation.
@@calvinwboaz7085 lol we are snobs because you want a classic lyric to be written or sound more racist...gotchya. Dont reproduce
This is such a timely song right now in my life- lonely and living in my head. Thank you Mel. Gotta go for a walk now. It just makes me feel stuff.
Jamel, thank you for being such a good human. Need more Jamel's in the world.
The best part of Unplugged is getting to hear the bones of the song, so to speak--the structure of it without the layers of studio tracks. It's not perfect, it's not smoothed-off edges and all that. It's the song and the singer, and the musicians all there creating it live. And this one is perfect for that. Sad, sweet, full of beauty and poetry. Love it.
This just hits me different. My father took his life 8 years ago, I can't hear this song and not think of him. I Miss you Dad...
Sorry for you lost.
😢🙏🏻✨
@@user-yy4hl1no4x please, Lisa, don't. Please seek help, which is out there. I lost my dad as a 2 year old and my oldest brother just over a year ago. Both took their own lives. All I can say is, there is a solution to any problem, believe me.
Will...so sorry to read of your loss. I hope that you are able to remember with more smiles and fewer tears as time goes on.
@@user-yy4hl1no4x sometimes people do this and truly believe that their loved ones would be better off without them. Trust me, they aren't. They are devastated forever. Don't utilize a permanent solution for a temporary problem. It may not feel temporary right now, but it is in the long run. The long run most likely will include wonderful life events that you would be cheating yourself from experiencing. Please find help. If you can't afford it, there is plenty of free help out there. Call 800-273-8255
One of my favorite Pink Floyd songs🔥
When you think about the music since Rock started, Dark Side of the Moon will be the only album people still listen to 300 years from now. The same way we listen to Mozart, Beethoven etc from 300 years ago. Your thoughts?
Not the only one, but it would be great to create a top ten or 100 in this vein.
Agreed. 100%
Yes! I've been saying this very thing for years now about all of their music.
I think you may be right....
"We're just two lost souls
Swimming in a fish bowl"
We're all lost souls???
Until were FOUND
@@johnboydTx And sadly, some souls are never found.
@@terriertz6837 Unfortunately your right. I Hope some find meaning in their last breath??
All you take from this world is your name and memories At least one memorable event happened in one's life??🤔💘💘👶🎂🎶
Gets me too Jennifer.. So much loss and pain in these lyrics.
The whole Wish You Were Here album is a masterpiece.... just as Floyd always is ❤️
There's nothing like the absolute purity of acoustic music. 👏🙌✌️
When I hear Floyd, I often remember my Dad. He was deaf in one ear, which made him picky about music he would listen to, then there was Floyd. He owned every album that the band released. I think that what made the difference for him was that Floyd was a full sensory experience,. You don’t just listen to Pink Floyd, you immerse yourself in them. Wish you were here, Dad.
This isn't Pink Floyd it's a David Gilmour solo show. Still beautiful though.
I think that was Rick Wright on the keyboard, too.
Gilmour won the right in court to keep the name PinkFloyd along with Richard Wright and Nick Mason against Roger Waters .
@@siriusstar99 Right, But when David Gilmour does a solo show like this he doesn't call it Pink Floyd.
@@neillenet291 True was distracted and did not listen before realizing it was his solo ✌️ I’ve seen them 5 times the best IMO .
A awesome show I watched the DVD 2 days ago. Lol again.
This song was just so good that its hard to describe. Unless of course we had some balloons, then of course we could talk for days.
99 luft balloons...? ;)
I believe the amount of requests Jamel gets has to be enormous, kind like God's prayer request list from North Dakota ?
June 1994 Philly Veterns Stadium 70,000 people singing this together. One of the best moments of my life
I was there. Amazing. Sat on the field ... was an incredible experience.
May 1994 Foxborough Massachusetts. Same thing! Amazing experience.
July 1994, RFK stadium in DC; 98,000+ people singing along
@@stevebengel1346 Yes! One of the best nights of my life!!!
@@Jrup2110 I was on the field about 30 (?) rows from the stage
This song was written for Syd Barrett, the original singer of Pink Floyd. He left the band when he realized that he needed mental help. He got David Gilmore to front the band before he admitted himself to an insane asylum.
Well, the band moved on without him. They brought in Gilmour cuz they never knew what Barrett would do on stage. Some nights he would just stand there. And I don’t believe Syd ever admitted himself into any asylums.
@@MikeB12800 I dont think he did either.
@Greg King truth
Correct- he neither left the band nor realized he needed help. He lived for the rest of his life with very little treatment and never saw the inside of an asylum. Floyd didn’t pick him up for a gig, and that was that. The guilt they suffered over the situation led to some of the greatest music of all time.
@@MikeB12800 lol this is the more widely accepted story. I dont ever remember him checking himself in for help or bringing in gilmour to replace him
Gilmore is THE MAN!
Beautiful from start to finish. One of the best songs ever written..in my opinion that is!
Thank you.✌❤🎶😁
"Dark Side of the Moon" was on the Billboard chart for 14 years.
This song has so much meaning to me. Besides the fact that I’ve seen them play this live & it was incredible, it was the band my dad (who was a musician) & I connected with together the most. He passed away suddenly last July & the last picture I have of us together he is wearing a Pink Floyd shirt. The day of his funeral, I was driving & this song came on & I knew it was him telling me he was still with us & everything was alright. This song was one of our faves & whenever I hear it now it’s like he is reminding me he is here each & every time. Such a beautiful song. 🙏🏼❤️
That cello is an amazing addition! One of my all time favorite songs, but never heard this performance! Thanks so much for sharing!!💞
Comfortably numb is still hands down my favorite with this being second two masterpieces
"Did you exchange a walk on part in the war, for a lead role in a cage?" That line cuts me to my core every time!!!
and most of us had , against our own will and best interest
Yeah, this one has always hurt.
Sweet J!!! Love your videos brother! Every listen to some Iron Maiden?
Love your pink floyd reaction vids. You're missing one big Pink Floyd song though so far, and it's one of my favs, "MONEY"!! Please do a reaction video of Pink Floyd's Money, it's a great song that ur missing from the pink floyd Playlist!👍
This lineup was 🔥... Michael Kamen on piano, Neill MacColl on the 12-string, Chucho Merchán on bass, the absolutely outstanding Caroline Dale on cello, Dick Parry on sax, and of course Gilmour himself. The DVD is called “David Gilmour in Concert” and is well worth the price.
Alan Parsons did quite a bit of work with them!
My sons father had died, we couldnt bring ourselves to go to the grave site. We finally went. This song popped on as we entered the cemetery then as we left we heard "sailing away." He loved fishing. Was also in the Navy for 21 years. He is missed everyday.
💐💐
When a man’s best friend is lost in a fog of drugs and psychotic episodes...
Please do solo David Gilmour ~ "No Way Out Of Here", "Raise My Rent", "So Far Away" and "No Way".... I promise you will not regret it...!
What Nick says... treat your ears Jamel..
And Murder
So used to seeing Gilmour with his strat that it is nice to hear his acoustic playing.
He sold his black strat for around a mil.. for charity
Bought, "Wish you were here" new in 1975. It's still one of my favorite albums.
I still have the original....
One of my fave PF songs. Im in Texas freezing with no water, power outages, low on food, but Jamal is keeping me happy in the midst of this challenging time.. Thank you so much Jamal!
Hey Jamel! Your reactions are great, I look forward to them every day. I would like you to consider doing a reaction to Zeppelin unplugged "The Rain Song"
Shine on you crazy diamond and High Hopes from this same concert are both incredible and highly emotional
Led Zeppelin number one!! Pink Floyd number two , My all time favourite bands growing up!! Beautiful song! Thank you J for what you do ! I enjoy the memories you bring! 🥰
For the record, that's not actually Pink Floyd at all but their frontman David Gilmour doing an iconic Pink Floyd song.
I said when you where gifted the picture wish you where here was my favourite Floyd track . Love from England . Going to enjoy this with you brother
I absolutely love checking out young people's pages where they listen to my generation's music. I have nothing against beats and rhymes, but i believe 100% that my generations music was the best. Much love
How I wish...
Great song. Only my opinion "Dark Side of the Moon" their greatest album.
Never heard that version before. It is excellent 👏👏
This is how master musicians do it. David , you Are The Man. Sadly missin' Richard now.
Love your blog. I have a song idea for you. It's kd Lang singing Roy Orbisons Crying. I promise you you'll love it. I haven't seen anybody react to it. You'll thank me. It's a live recording at what looks like an award show. She's young and Awesome, powerful, amazing.
I shit you not... the last 3 funerals I've gone too I've turned on the radio in the car to the intro of this song. First time I was like, "huh, cool", the second time I thought it was pretty weird but the third time... just wtf.
Check out THETA TV they won’t block any of your videos. Also, check the Brave browser, you literally get paid for being on the internet. It’s what everyone will be watching on the new internet that’s being built. No one is talking about this.Let me know if you have any inquiries! Good to you and God bless!
And disciplinary remains mercifully
Yes and um, I'm with you Derek, this star nonsense
Yes, yes
Now which is it?
I am sure of it
So, so you think you can tell
Heaven from hell?
Blue skies from pain?
Can you tell a green field
From a cold steel rail?
A smile from a veil?
Do you think you can tell?
Did they get you to trade
Your heroes for ghosts?
Hot ashes for trees?
Hot air for a cool breeze?
Cold comfort for change?
Did you exchange
A walk-on part in the war
For a leading role in a cage?
How I wish, how I wish you were here
We're just two lost souls
Swimming in a fish bowl
Year after year
Running over the same old ground
What have we found?
The same old fears
Wish you were here
Such a great song and I have always really loved David Gilmour's sound and playing style, just the way he's able to bend the strings and all. As I recall, they wrote this song as a dedication to Syd Barrett (the band's original singer/frontman) after he suffered a mental breakdown and eventually passed due to a drug overdose. Love the Channel, keep 'em comin' Jamel! Peace Out.
If you listen to a Pink Floyd Album from front to back you will put them top 3
David Gilmour being the voice of Pink Floyd really can't be better then this. He really is the voice of England tbh.
Beautiful song
Listen to early Pink Floyd!!!! Anything from 67-72
I think it was in this concert that none other than Sir Bob Geldof himself got on the stage to give a rendition of Comfortably Numb, a track form the revolutionary movie he starred! It's worth the watch... or the other duet version with David Bowie!
Don't forget thisis a man in his 70's who plays guitar and sings not a singer and not 20 anymore. I have seen him many times and I adore Gilmour. Thank you for finding pink floyd
It's unbelievable PF was not in the top three! I could not believe it when I watched that video of your top five! It's unthinkable but it's your list, not mine.
So cool watching you enjoy Pink Floyd. Probably my all time fav.
Loved it 45yrs ago....More beautiful Now....❤❤❤
If I had to pick a favorite Pink Floyd song, this would be the one. I’ve never heard this version though. Btw, I understand to each their own, but Pink Floyd is in my top 3 bands.
“Wots Uh, The Deal” is such an underrated Pink Floyd song.
I would love to see you enjoy it.
Childhoods End too. Love that album.
@@Uninvited72 nobody ever gives it any credit..
That album is next level. I have just discovered it and I love it.
The live version from 'Remember That Night' is incredible. Better than the studio version IMO.
An underrated part of their musicality was their ability to jam. Their live versions are like completely different songs. Take “Embryo” studio v. BBC live. Perhaps David didn’t play on the original, but he does on the live and the addition of his guitar work greatly benefits the song.
So Wyclef Jean covered this from Pink Floyd?! Wow, learned something new today. I only knew the Wyclef version from the 90s so far.
David Gilmore speaks to me with his guitar I can't explain it.
First time I've seen this unplugged version, stunning!!😁😁🇬🇧
I’m hooked your channel. I spend hours at night watching it.
When you can perform a song like that acoustic, perfectly, is a testament to just how gifted these musicians are.
This has been my favorite Floyd tune since I was 7 and first heard them!
this is my favourite version of this song. you haven't reacted to David's solo work, before, i don't think. there's a lot that has his unique vibe. there are 3 live concerts that are really great. one called, 'Remember That Night'. the song, On An Island, from that concert is really amazing. Crosby and Nash support him as backing singers. the second is the Gdansk concert. my favourite version of Echoes, The Blue, Fat Old Sun, Great Day For Freedom, are my favourites from that. Pompeii, 2016 includes, A Boat Lies Waiting [in memory of Richard Wright] In Any Tongue, What Do You Want From Me and Faces Of Stone are my favourites from that.
Michael Kamen playing piano..... one of the most incredible musicians who not enough people know..... he wrote orchestral parts for everyone. From Pink Floyd, to Queen, to Kate Bush.... then his film scores..... a truly truly wonderful man. Die Hard, Lethal Weapon, Robin Hood. Check out the film Highlander..... incredible score. RIP.
Yeah, it's worth reminding people that this isn't Pink Floyd, this is David and band.
Yes, and did the backing orchestral arrangement for Comfortably Numb, too
My favorite version of my favorite Pink Floyd song!
One of my ALL TIME favorite songs!!
Probably my favorite song from Punk Floyd- I play this on guitar all the time...
Not to many string benders better than David!! Great Great band.
David Gilmour just doesn't get any better. The emotions he can bring out in someone with the sound of his guitar is magical.
One of my favorites 🎶I wish you could doToots (Hibbert) and the mytals got to be tough.
saw them in paris in 88 and in nashville in the 90s great live show
Try "Silent Lucidity" by Queensryche
This isn't Pink Floyd it's a David Gilmour show (Not saying it isn't good) and Just my opinion Pink Floyd stopped being Pink Floyd when Roger Waters left.
I’m just going by the title of the video I’m watching
Cant believe at your age nobody tried to get you to listen to what you are. Grew up as a foster kid, my adoptive fathers family history is German and he was a computer technician and worked on the modern wifi. He's still alive but burned out from work. But he always made me listen to a variety of music. From classical to rap to techno, and this was the late 80s early 90s
My parents grew up in the big band era and loved the bands and the crooners. We listened to their music but they encouraged us to stretch our wings and listen to whatever we wanted to. Whoever got to the radio or record player first had control . . . except Sunday afternoons when Mom did her baking. She had total control of the kitchen radio
That was incredible performance
I think his voice actually got better with age
Favorite song by Pink Floyd.
"Did you exchange a walk-on part in the war for a lead role in a cage." Very insightful. Everyone must make that choice.
Thanks for this one. We’re in Texas and have been without power, heat and fresh water, in freezing weather for days. It’s nice to see this as I come back online. ❤️❤️
Glad you made it through.!
...was gonna say more power to you...
Then I realized the pun . Not intended😉
🙏 blessings
So hard to have a top ten. Seems my top ten changes weekly depending on the mood.
I always say picking ten top songs is like picking your favorite breath of air, pretty much impossible.
@@5yearsout
Mind of I steal that. Good analogy.
one of the greatest songs I have heard brings in the emotions
Feeling the love from a awesome band.
I can't remember. Help. Didn't he react to Echoes Live at Pompeii?
Yes Just Search My Name and the song👍🏾
@@jamelakajamal What's up dude? I just listened to the Darkstar, I am listening to the Eyes, and I'll probably end up watching the Morning Dew.
If you are up for it I gotta ask you. Why no Pigpen? Hard to Handle. Good Lovin', Lovelight, Katie Mae. And I've been begging for months for an Other One(2-13-70).
So enough of that. I want to offer mad props on the progress of your channel in just the past few months. You've got the grace of the band. That ain't nothin'. They could copyright your ass but you are on the bus. And you have covered almost every great tune in my old music catalog. The fact that you picked Rush is just crazy.
Yeah. Like the channel:)
Peace to you and yours.
This song has easily one of the top 5 guitar intros. Beautiful!!
DAMN DUDE WISH I WAS THERE CLASSIC!!
Greatest band of all time no doubt
“Did you exchange a walk on part in the war for a lead role in a cage?” 😦
Simple but captivating . . .
Do you think you can tell!
"Oh how I wish I could tell heaven from hell.."