Please bring him back on your show he is very straight to the point and very informative and entertaining at the same time. It’s a New York thing. Wassalam.
Extremely disturbed when religion adjacent figures sympathize with controversial figures just because theyre perceived to be 'islamic'. The speaker didn't mention once that joulani is ex-Al Qaeda, or that iran, as controversial/guilty they themselves are of being pro-Assad and demographic engineering, were supplying Hezbollah with weapons to fight Israelis. Even more disturbing that jalal didn't bring those up either, when almost every geopolitical analyst ive been listening to, whether pro-West or pro-South knows this. Theres nothing Islamic about whitewashing and misleading; these folks need to keep their emotions about Islam aside if those emotions are misaligned with Islamic principles or facts.
I agree. Jolani in particular is on the record in interviews looking g straight at the camera and lying about the existence of dark unofficial prisons where people are tortured. The brother himself acknowledged that they exist. Lying that obviously and blatantly aren’t characteristics of someone capable of governing justly, they more accurately describe a sociopath.
What makes you think these weapon shipments will stop? Hzb congratulated the new Syrian government. The old leadership has been wiped out, so maybe that's the beginning of a new alliance with the condition that Hzb stays where they are this time.
SUMMARY AND NOTES Introduction 00:00 The Syrian revolution has reached a new stage, with the rebel groups gaining control over major cities and the people feeling a sense of jubilation and appetite for change and unity 01:00 The optimism and positivity should be maintained, and not replaced with pessimism, as the challenges ahead are significant 01:12 The new government, led by HTS, faces the monumental task of delivering justice and reform to the Syrian people 03:40 HTS ideology 02:30 HTS has good elements, but also needs reform to be suitable for the task of governing the country 03:21 The group's ideology is rooted in Islamic governance, but it has been criticized for its past actions and whether it reflects the rich tapestry of Syrian society 02:52 Abu Muhammad Jolani, the leader of HTS, needs to reform the justice system and deliver justice to the people in order to gain their support 04:31 Justice - Islamic call 05:55 Justice is at the heart of Islamic governance, and HTS claims to be a group that calls for Islamic governance 06:00 The group has been criticized for its treatment of prisoners and its use of extraordinary measures, which is not in line with Islamic principles 06:57 The leader of HTS, Abu Muhammad Jolani, needs to deliver justice to the people and reform the governance structure in order to be successful 08:33 Jolani - positive? 08:41 Jolani's recent statements suggest he wants to be inclusive and broaden his platform, but the people care more about just leadership than inclusivity 09:50 The people want to see justice on the ground, and everyone in Syria wants Jolani to succeed in giving the people justice 11:41 The impression is that there has been a sea change in how the administration functions and services are delivered in Idlib 09:34 Bilal too pessimistic? 11:50 The revolution was about justice, and raising justice issues is not being pessimistic, but rather ensuring the revolutionary forces are about justice 12:12 If the people see justice, they will be all in, but if they don't, they will question the purpose of the revolution 13:11 A nation of 26 million people who are united and seeking justice cannot be held back by anyone 13:32 New Syria 14:34 There is a different atmosphere in Syria today that allows for open and strong criticism of injustice and advocacy for justice 14:56 The goal is to gather all people in Syria to rally behind the leadership that is moving in the direction of justice 16:17 Toleration of Journalists 16:31 The toleration of journalists like Bilal Abdul Kareem is a positive sign, indicating a shift towards a more open and just society 16:39 As someone who comes from a background of slavery, Bilal feels a responsibility to speak out and use his voice to advocate for justice 17:14 Capability to govern 17:49 Muhammad al-Basher has been invited to lead the new government as the interim Prime Minister, and he has experience running the administration in Idlib. 17:59 The current interim government has the ability to expand and attract good people, good thinkers, and technocrats. 19:11 Syrians are encouraged to volunteer and be part of the new government to help the country. 19:25 Israel 20:11 Israel has attacked multiple sites across Syria, including Damascus, to weaken Rebel forces and prevent them from taking advantage of new weaponry. 20:15 The new government has been quiet on Israel's activities, but they are taking countermeasures and will wait to see what happens in the coming days. 23:23 Israel's attacks are not significant in terms of gaining a strategic advantage, and Rebel forces have 12 years of experience in handling new weaponry. 22:32 How far is Israel in Syria 23:30 Israel is not as close to invading Syria as some claim, and they are still 40 kilometers away from the Syrian capital. 24:06 Israel has taken the area of Ketra on the border, but their tanks are not rolling into Damascus. 24:21 There is no collusion between the rebellion and outside forces, including America and Israel. 25:15 Assad central to resisting Israel? 26:00 Assad's regime never attacked Israel, instead filing complaints with the UN Security Council and allowing Iranian presence to counter rebel forces 26:18 The Syrian revolution is about more than just a few leaders, and outside forces cannot control the entire movement 27:28 The situation in Syria is not in one person's hands, but rather spearheaded by various groups, including HTS 27:50 Where Islam fits? 28:06 After 14 years of fighting, Islamic fighters are the predominant force in Syria, and it will be hard to convince people to abandon the idea of real Islamic justice 28:59 HTS and other rebel forces want to see a progression towards Islamic justice, but it's not about oppressing minority rights or enforcing harsh punishments 30:34 The people of Syria want Islamic justice, which is not about cutting off hands or harsh punishments, but rather about establishing a tolerant and just society 31:04 New government and the West 33:28 The new government in Syria is attempting to present itself as non-threatening to the West, which may be seen as a bad sign symbolically for the future of the revolution 33:46 Islam provides a criterion for determining who is genuinely helpful and who is not, allowing Syrians to make informed decisions about their alliances 34:22 Western forces may try to influence Syria by offering economic incentives, but those with an Islamic foundation will be able to resist such temptations 34:59 Syrian Prisons 35:54 The conditions in Syrian prisons, such as Sednaya, have been horrific, with a complete disregard for human life and dignity 37:21 The concept of "humanity" refers to the ability to empathize with others and feel compassion, which was lacking in the treatment of prisoners 37:40 It is too early to tell whether the new government will reopen the old prisons or establish a new system of justice 36:54 SDF 39:38 The SDF, a nominally Kurdish force, is currently under attack by Turkish-backed rebel groups, with a recent lull in the offensive. 39:40 The role of the SDF in a future Syrian government is debated, with some viewing them as counterrevolutionary forces backed by the West. 40:12 The SDF's militia forces, such as the YPG and PKK, should be dismantled due to their role in the Aleppo siege and human rights abuses. 41:24 Iran and Hezbollah 43:35 Iran and Hezbollah have been criticized for their activities in Syria, with some arguing that they should not be allowed to return. 43:42 Iran has been accused of supporting the Assad regime and arming them, despite the regime's atrocities. 44:29 Hezbollah's role in Syria has also been criticized, with some arguing that they should focus on their own problems in Lebanon rather than interfering in Syria. 45:43 Iran’s role in Syria 46:25 Iran's primary objective in Syria was not to neutralize ISIS and Al-Qaeda, but rather to support the Assad regime. 46:47 Iranian militias did not fight ISIS, but instead supported the Assad regime and propped up Bashar Al-Assad. 47:50 Iran's support for the Assad regime has been criticized, with some arguing that they aided and abetted genocide. 48:50 Anti-Imperialist left 49:18 The argument that the Syrian rebellion is negative for the Syrian people and the Palestinian cause is countered by the fact that Bashar Al Assad's regime was not helping the Palestinians in any meaningful way 49:31. The rebellion may have weakened the region, but it is also possible that the Rebel forces could have helped the Palestinians if they had taken control of the country earlier 50:11. The current situation is not necessarily weaker than it was under Assad's rule, as he was not providing any substantial support to the Palestinians 50:42. Syrian Mindset 52:18 The Syrian people are feeling ecstatic but also worried about the future, as they have been ruled by an iron hand for years and are unsure if the dictator is truly gone 52:52. There is a sense of optimism among the people, as they see possibilities for the future, but they are also cautious and waiting to see what will happen 53:23. The standard of living in Syria is very poor, with limited access to basic necessities like Wi-Fi and modern technology, but there is hope for improvement 54:08.
I'm so glad to see people like Bilal Abdul Kareem on the thinking Muslim. For those who wish harm to our brothers and sisters wherever they are: “They wish to put His light out with their mouths. But He will perfect His light, even though the disbelievers hate it” -61:8
Nobody is wishing them bad. People is just stating the Truth of what is coming for Syria when it fell in hands of paid Usrael-NATO terrorists; Syria is not free it fell in hands of extremists while is Occupied by US, Turkey and Israel who is bombing and grabbing more Syrian land by the day. Many Muslims need to wake up to the reality, but they keep buying the script of the West.
Yes! Let the truth out. There would be no reason to intentionally hide and conceal the reality of AlQaeda and how Salafis like Bilal were part of US/Qatar funded project of regime change. The war is one of Sunni Supremacism which is a curse on the Ummah and the Deen.
My Lord, aid us and do not aid against us , and grant us victory and do not grant victory over us , plan for us and do not plan against us , guide us and facilitate guidance for us , grant us victory over those who transgress against us 🤲🏼
Why don't they ga free Jerusalem, I even saw videos they helped the Tel Aviv gov. So who are these people when they just go for Muslim land and ignore the struggle of the falastine people.
When the guest says people don’t care about inclusivity if they have justice, he proves he knows nothing about Syria and its communities. Syria as a whole is very different from Idleb!!
No he has not. I've been following him for over a decade. He is as much a Muslim reporter as your going to get. I wouldn't say he has the same journalistic standards as a western journalist but he genuinely cares for the people.
You didn't really press him enough on Jolani's history and his historical collusion with America and Turkey. Jolani does have a dubious background and you just parsed over it.
@@mozimmalhussain287 I wouldn't doubt it. Not once did he mentioned Joulani is ex-Al Qaeda much less the other guy who the transfer of power went too. He only praise those guys and denied Hezbollah and Iran was fighting Al Qaeda, but I understand why, It's because of the ex leaders of Al Qaeda and HTS is a terrorist org. and it's on the terrorist on the list. And also he very well Iran was arming Hezbollah and Hamas through Syria under the Assad Gov. everyone know this. So why deny it.
You all don't need to fight or name call. Everyone is entitled to their opinion. If you want someone to understand your perspective, it's better to address each other with respect.
Allah separated Haq and Batil in the world by Palestine issue. And he separated the two in Muslim world by the Syrian issue. God bless the people of Haq. And Alhamdulillah for we are not amongst the ضالین
Zolani's softly and delayed responses about evil israel are pathetic and questionable, he should at least condemn the satanic acts. Yes, Zolani is in bad condition to reply, but hope he will show some guts against the cursed of Middle East.
Please remember to subscribe - 70% of our viewers have not. This helps our channel grow organically.
Please bring him back on your show he is very straight to the point and very informative and entertaining at the same time. It’s a New York thing.
Wassalam.
Brother Bilal is a absolute blessing.
May Allah unite the ummah and grant us good pious leaders that will defend the Deen and ummah
May Allah Accept your works, and make it a means of acceptance and Guidance for the Ummah!
Extremely disturbed when religion adjacent figures sympathize with controversial figures just because theyre perceived to be 'islamic'. The speaker didn't mention once that joulani is ex-Al Qaeda, or that iran, as controversial/guilty they themselves are of being pro-Assad and demographic engineering, were supplying Hezbollah with weapons to fight Israelis. Even more disturbing that jalal didn't bring those up either, when almost every geopolitical analyst ive been listening to, whether pro-West or pro-South knows this. Theres nothing Islamic about whitewashing and misleading; these folks need to keep their emotions about Islam aside if those emotions are misaligned with Islamic principles or facts.
Agree...
I agree. Jolani in particular is on the record in interviews looking g straight at the camera and lying about the existence of dark unofficial prisons where people are tortured. The brother himself acknowledged that they exist. Lying that obviously and blatantly aren’t characteristics of someone capable of governing justly, they more accurately describe a sociopath.
What makes you think these weapon shipments will stop? Hzb congratulated the new Syrian government. The old leadership has been wiped out, so maybe that's the beginning of a new alliance with the condition that Hzb stays where they are this time.
Yes. Hezbollah being funded by Iran.. to massacre syrians.. they're somehow.. "good". Lol
What are the aims of Iran? What have been the aims of Iran throughout the centuries?
Especially since the Safavid times?
a very fair and balanced take from bro bilal. I would rather believe someone like him who has personal and direct experience in Idlib ❤
First time I hear of this brother. I hope you'll have him on again. Well spoken and knowledgeable.
Brother Bilal is a person of reality and realism will never sugarcoat the fact.
Finally, something that makes me feel at least a little bit at ease.
JazakumAllahu khayrun ya ikhwan.
SUMMARY AND NOTES
Introduction 00:00
The Syrian revolution has reached a new stage, with the rebel groups gaining control over major cities and the people feeling a sense of jubilation and appetite for change and unity 01:00
The optimism and positivity should be maintained, and not replaced with pessimism, as the challenges ahead are significant 01:12
The new government, led by HTS, faces the monumental task of delivering justice and reform to the Syrian people 03:40
HTS ideology 02:30
HTS has good elements, but also needs reform to be suitable for the task of governing the country 03:21
The group's ideology is rooted in Islamic governance, but it has been criticized for its past actions and whether it reflects the rich tapestry of Syrian society 02:52
Abu Muhammad Jolani, the leader of HTS, needs to reform the justice system and deliver justice to the people in order to gain their support 04:31
Justice - Islamic call 05:55
Justice is at the heart of Islamic governance, and HTS claims to be a group that calls for Islamic governance 06:00
The group has been criticized for its treatment of prisoners and its use of extraordinary measures, which is not in line with Islamic principles 06:57
The leader of HTS, Abu Muhammad Jolani, needs to deliver justice to the people and reform the governance structure in order to be successful 08:33
Jolani - positive? 08:41
Jolani's recent statements suggest he wants to be inclusive and broaden his platform, but the people care more about just leadership than inclusivity 09:50
The people want to see justice on the ground, and everyone in Syria wants Jolani to succeed in giving the people justice 11:41
The impression is that there has been a sea change in how the administration functions and services are delivered in Idlib 09:34
Bilal too pessimistic? 11:50
The revolution was about justice, and raising justice issues is not being pessimistic, but rather ensuring the revolutionary forces are about justice 12:12
If the people see justice, they will be all in, but if they don't, they will question the purpose of the revolution 13:11
A nation of 26 million people who are united and seeking justice cannot be held back by anyone 13:32
New Syria 14:34
There is a different atmosphere in Syria today that allows for open and strong criticism of injustice and advocacy for justice 14:56
The goal is to gather all people in Syria to rally behind the leadership that is moving in the direction of justice 16:17
Toleration of Journalists 16:31
The toleration of journalists like Bilal Abdul Kareem is a positive sign, indicating a shift towards a more open and just society 16:39
As someone who comes from a background of slavery, Bilal feels a responsibility to speak out and use his voice to advocate for justice 17:14
Capability to govern 17:49
Muhammad al-Basher has been invited to lead the new government as the interim Prime Minister, and he has experience running the administration in Idlib. 17:59
The current interim government has the ability to expand and attract good people, good thinkers, and technocrats. 19:11
Syrians are encouraged to volunteer and be part of the new government to help the country. 19:25
Israel 20:11
Israel has attacked multiple sites across Syria, including Damascus, to weaken Rebel forces and prevent them from taking advantage of new weaponry. 20:15
The new government has been quiet on Israel's activities, but they are taking countermeasures and will wait to see what happens in the coming days. 23:23
Israel's attacks are not significant in terms of gaining a strategic advantage, and Rebel forces have 12 years of experience in handling new weaponry. 22:32
How far is Israel in Syria 23:30
Israel is not as close to invading Syria as some claim, and they are still 40 kilometers away from the Syrian capital. 24:06
Israel has taken the area of Ketra on the border, but their tanks are not rolling into Damascus. 24:21
There is no collusion between the rebellion and outside forces, including America and Israel. 25:15
Assad central to resisting Israel? 26:00
Assad's regime never attacked Israel, instead filing complaints with the UN Security Council and allowing Iranian presence to counter rebel forces 26:18
The Syrian revolution is about more than just a few leaders, and outside forces cannot control the entire movement 27:28
The situation in Syria is not in one person's hands, but rather spearheaded by various groups, including HTS 27:50
Where Islam fits? 28:06
After 14 years of fighting, Islamic fighters are the predominant force in Syria, and it will be hard to convince people to abandon the idea of real Islamic justice 28:59
HTS and other rebel forces want to see a progression towards Islamic justice, but it's not about oppressing minority rights or enforcing harsh punishments 30:34
The people of Syria want Islamic justice, which is not about cutting off hands or harsh punishments, but rather about establishing a tolerant and just society 31:04
New government and the West 33:28
The new government in Syria is attempting to present itself as non-threatening to the West, which may be seen as a bad sign symbolically for the future of the revolution 33:46
Islam provides a criterion for determining who is genuinely helpful and who is not, allowing Syrians to make informed decisions about their alliances 34:22
Western forces may try to influence Syria by offering economic incentives, but those with an Islamic foundation will be able to resist such temptations 34:59
Syrian Prisons 35:54
The conditions in Syrian prisons, such as Sednaya, have been horrific, with a complete disregard for human life and dignity 37:21
The concept of "humanity" refers to the ability to empathize with others and feel compassion, which was lacking in the treatment of prisoners 37:40
It is too early to tell whether the new government will reopen the old prisons or establish a new system of justice 36:54
SDF 39:38
The SDF, a nominally Kurdish force, is currently under attack by Turkish-backed rebel groups, with a recent lull in the offensive. 39:40
The role of the SDF in a future Syrian government is debated, with some viewing them as counterrevolutionary forces backed by the West. 40:12
The SDF's militia forces, such as the YPG and PKK, should be dismantled due to their role in the Aleppo siege and human rights abuses. 41:24
Iran and Hezbollah 43:35
Iran and Hezbollah have been criticized for their activities in Syria, with some arguing that they should not be allowed to return. 43:42
Iran has been accused of supporting the Assad regime and arming them, despite the regime's atrocities. 44:29
Hezbollah's role in Syria has also been criticized, with some arguing that they should focus on their own problems in Lebanon rather than interfering in Syria. 45:43
Iran’s role in Syria 46:25
Iran's primary objective in Syria was not to neutralize ISIS and Al-Qaeda, but rather to support the Assad regime. 46:47
Iranian militias did not fight ISIS, but instead supported the Assad regime and propped up Bashar Al-Assad. 47:50
Iran's support for the Assad regime has been criticized, with some arguing that they aided and abetted genocide. 48:50
Anti-Imperialist left 49:18
The argument that the Syrian rebellion is negative for the Syrian people and the Palestinian cause is countered by the fact that Bashar Al Assad's regime was not helping the Palestinians in any meaningful way 49:31.
The rebellion may have weakened the region, but it is also possible that the Rebel forces could have helped the Palestinians if they had taken control of the country earlier 50:11.
The current situation is not necessarily weaker than it was under Assad's rule, as he was not providing any substantial support to the Palestinians 50:42.
Syrian Mindset 52:18
The Syrian people are feeling ecstatic but also worried about the future, as they have been ruled by an iron hand for years and are unsure if the dictator is truly gone 52:52.
There is a sense of optimism among the people, as they see possibilities for the future, but they are also cautious and waiting to see what will happen 53:23.
The standard of living in Syria is very poor, with limited access to basic necessities like Wi-Fi and modern technology, but there is hope for improvement 54:08.
JazakaAllaah khairan for inviting Bilal
Islam = Justice
May Allah protect & bless you, Bilal karim
May Allah (SWT) grant justice, honour, and victory to oppressed brothers and sisters around the world. Ameen.
I was waiting to see when Bilal would be invited here. He seems like good source for reliable information from the ground💯
I'm so glad to see people like Bilal Abdul Kareem on the thinking Muslim. For those who wish harm to our brothers and sisters wherever they are: “They wish to put His light out with their mouths. But He will perfect His light, even though the disbelievers hate it” -61:8
Nobody is wishing them bad. People is just stating the Truth of what is coming for Syria when it fell in hands of paid Usrael-NATO terrorists; Syria is not free it fell in hands of extremists while is Occupied by US, Turkey and Israel who is bombing and grabbing more Syrian land by the day. Many Muslims need to wake up to the reality, but they keep buying the script of the West.
Yes! Let the truth out. There would be no reason to intentionally hide and conceal the reality of AlQaeda and how Salafis like Bilal were part of US/Qatar funded project of regime change. The war is one of Sunni Supremacism which is a curse on the Ummah and the Deen.
When I look at Bilal in Syria, I see Franz Fanon in Algeria.
He should take active part in the forming governments.
The top expert in syria bilal abdulkareem👍🏻 brother jalal any updates on when our muslim german voices will be presented by you?
جزاک اللہ خیرا
Shukran dear brothers great videos may Allah protect and preserve you both Ameen .
بارك الله في الاخ بلال .
Thank you for your perspective
My Lord, aid us and do not aid against us , and grant us victory and do not grant victory over us , plan for us and do not plan against us , guide us and facilitate guidance for us , grant us victory over those who transgress against us 🤲🏼
“ Syria is now free “ what are you smoking ?
Izrael is 15 miles from Damask cleansing Syrian territory and ahmak said Syria is free 🤨
Syria is free from the tyrannical regime that was on place for 50 years. Y'all need an education.
Why don't they ga free Jerusalem, I even saw videos they helped the Tel Aviv gov. So who are these people when they just go for Muslim land and ignore the struggle of the falastine people.
Who will go and free Jerusalem?
They are on America payroll every year Amerca give 1 billion to them they have to fight when they are told to fight no for Falestin
Bring sami hamdi plz i watched his views on liberation of syria and it was spot on eye opener n befitting reply to all naysayers
This is a great guest, someone who saw them first hand
JEWlani headhunter & Netanyahu Genocid3... Poor Syrian people 😢😢😢
When the guest says people don’t care about inclusivity if they have justice, he proves he knows nothing about Syria and its communities.
Syria as a whole is very different from Idleb!!
When is this al julani going to help Abu Obeida. They can go to the border and help. I wait what Abu Obeida has to say about Hts
Honest question, wasn't Bilal Abdul Kareem doing promotional videos for Jabhat Al Nusra aka HTS and ISIS the last time around?
No he has not. I've been following him for over a decade. He is as much a Muslim reporter as your going to get. I wouldn't say he has the same journalistic standards as a western journalist but he genuinely cares for the people.
Muslim thinker dropping grms i literally prayed dua that a video loke this drop
West and all external influences should stay out, only the Islamic Ummah would decide what to do.
Al jewlani works for west
U talking about Iran what about Israel and the US what about the US that supply Israel what kind of Muslims are u
so its justified for Iran to supply weapons to Assad and Hezb to kill Syrians because US supplies weapons to Israel?
don't trust jolani
This channel should be called The Unthinking Muslim
I'M OUT YOU PSYCHOS
You didn't really press him enough on Jolani's history and his historical collusion with America and Turkey. Jolani does have a dubious background and you just parsed over it.
Jak brother
Who is this Takfir?
This episode is my UNSUBSCRIBE moment, Goidbye The UNTHINKING Muslim show.
Same here
Bro you’re bringing this spy on your show oh hell no this channel is definitely a psyop
Spy for who?
Nonsence
@SilverfangSupreme-le5zz NATO!
@@mozimmalhussain287 I wouldn't doubt it. Not once did he mentioned Joulani is ex-Al Qaeda much less the other guy who the transfer of power went too. He only praise those guys and denied Hezbollah and Iran was fighting Al Qaeda, but I understand why, It's because of the ex leaders of Al Qaeda and HTS is a terrorist org. and it's on the terrorist on the list. And also he very well Iran was arming Hezbollah and Hamas through Syria under the Assad Gov. everyone know this. So why deny it.
Bilal is on the Wrong Side of History...Unfortunately😳
🤡 what do you want him to support the asad regime or the Iranian Buchers 😅😅😅😅😅😅 bilal was reporting for 12 year in Syria what bashar was doing
He is in the right side of history listen to 10:00 people want justice he is 100% RIGHT
What butchering show us the evidence from an independent source whe have Iranians ever massacred or hezbollah
Bills is an American spy that’s why he keeps being platformed
You all don't need to fight or name call.
Everyone is entitled to their opinion.
If you want someone to understand your perspective, it's better to address each other with respect.
Its not free, its occupied by Isis and Israel, but most dont know
Allah separated Haq and Batil in the world by Palestine issue. And he separated the two in Muslim world by the Syrian issue. God bless the people of Haq. And Alhamdulillah for we are not amongst the ضالین
Zolani's softly and delayed responses about evil israel are pathetic and questionable, he should at least condemn the satanic acts. Yes, Zolani is in bad condition to reply, but hope he will show some guts against the cursed of Middle East.