THIS VIDEO IS A JOKE!!! NO HATE TO LIAM OR ANY OF THE BOYS!!! I don’t own rights to the video/music used!! All credits to owners!! For entertainment purposes only!
Here’s the thing, I genuinely believe it could be Niall. Like as much he’s the “baby” sweetest, kindest etc Niall had shown his attitude in random little clips. Do I think he’s the likely suspect, no, but I could see it and not in just the funny way 😂
It was definitely Harry. Louis would have actually fought him. Niall is too nice. They said Harry is the scariest mad. And Liam really didn’t want to say who it was cause harries would demolish him.
the reason I don’t think it was Louis or Niall is because they were friends with liam after the band and I don’t think liam is one to forgive and forget (clearly).
That interview where liam focuses very hard to understand and harry tries so hard to make him understand what's written on the paper will NEVER be not funny 🤣
Okay let’s think about this: If it was Lou he wouldn’t of cared about the “you’re never going to use those hands again” bs he would of threw hands so probably not. It wasn’t Niall. If it was Zayn then he probably would of hinted towards it because during the podcast he said some not good things about Zayn. It was probably our Harry because they’ve said that Harry is scary when he’s mad and I feel like Harry would of let go and not hurt him. Conclusion: it was Simon Cowell
Let’s be real it was def harry cus Liam would say smt abt someone else or a group of people or like Louis or Niall to the point he wouldn’t be able to control himself and like only push him against a wall and like that’s it but Louis also sus asf and if it was zany he would’ve name dropped
@@vis222after what liam said bout zayn in the interview, some ppl were speculating that liam had prolly said hurtful things to zayn that time too and harry got mad cuz of it and threw him up the wall💀 but i like zarry so slay🤩
@@DeMonfa13 bro he always want love from everyone.he even cried when he was 16..i mean if he was a bad person so why he would be treating everyone so nice for a long time its been 12 years now which is a longtime..he is more successful then other bandmates if he was a bad person so he would act bad and no one could stop him or can let his career down but he is still saying and spreading a message of TPWK. I saw many interviews where he always share his beautiful moments with his bandmates
I just can't take him seriously. . . he literally lowered his voice and said "you'll never use those hands again". There is nothing frightening or menacing about it. Seriously, who tf did he think he was scaring with that mess!? The amount of secondhand embarrassment I get from that clip is ridiculous.
I don’t even think he actually said that. Maybe he said something similar but I think he wanted to look ‘cool’ or whatever so he made that part up or changed the wording.
So... there's no way Louis, our smol bean could have done that, I mean look at him and then at liam and then tell me.. Harry is a hard-core tpwk.. Niall just sings, laughs and eats. He doesn't hit anyone.. Never in my wildest dream I can think zayn did it.. So, the only member left is Kevin!! Kevin hit him!!! But how 🤔
I think it was a management or label member, because Rebecca, who was on the X factor with them, said she witnessed a boy band member being thrown against a wall, for fighting against the label/management. And they all had the same people. I think Liam said something about it, in public, so that we’re less shocked when it’s revealed that it was Liam, because Rebecca said that everything from her legal battle, will be made public, with the wall incident included in that.
You remmebr that interview of how louis reenacts the way the pigeons scare him the bathroom? I'm guessing Kevin used the same technique to push liam up the wall
I'd say it was Harry. Zayn: If it was Zayn, Liam most likely wouldn't have said he was "on his side" about the drama with the Hadids. Zayn was falsely accused of domestically abusing Yolanda and Gigi, so if Liam was someone who Zayn had a history of being physically violent towards, he would most likely have believed Yolanda (and come forward about what Zayn did WHILE Yolanda was throwing the allegations around, so November last year). So there's almost no way it was Zayn. Likelihood rating: 0.5/10. Louis: Bearing in mind Liam has posted about gymgoing, Louis is too physically small to have literally thrown Liam up a wall without him doing something about it sooner. He also remained good friends with Liam after the band was finished, wishing each other on their birthdays most years, wanting their sons Freddie and Bear to meet, so I'd say probably not him. Likelihood rating: 2/10. Niall: Niall is similar to Louis in this, he has also remained good friends with Liam, and also he said in 2015 (so near the end of the band), that he had never been in a physical altercation, so unless this encounter happened near the end of the band, I'd say it was almost definitely not Niall. Likelihood rating: 1/10. And that just leaves Harry, whose likelihood rating I'm gonna automatically give an 8/10, so I'm strongly leaning towards it being Harry.
I think Zayn did shove Yolanda. I don't think he meant to hurt her I think he just lost his temper. I don't think he shoved her hard. If she was making it up I think she'd have made it more dramatic saying he hit her or something. I think Liam also believes that he did shove her based on his "that didn't age well comment". Obviously, that doesn't mean he was the one who fought with Liam but whoever it was I am sure Liam deserved it lol
As much as I am a huge Niall fan, I do not think we can always believe what he said in interviews. Just stating that he was always single when apparently that was not always true is enough to question just how honest he always was versus his “media training” as the Never Have I Evers said. 😂 (Despite my reply, I do actually believe him most of the time, including now!)
@@frances9975 why do you think zayn would shove her? do you know it was proved to be false + believe me if he really did that he wouldn’t have gotten 50% and they would’ve ordered for someone to be with zayn and his daughter when they meet which didn’t happen. I am surprised that people really believe Yolanda the attention seeker and she loves drama
i think it was harry mainly because liam had no problem name dropping the other members. the only person he didn’t was harry cause he knew harries are crazy lol
But Liam had bad-mouthed Harry in other interviews. It is possible that the negative attention he got after that kept him from name-dropping Harry this time but I don't know if he has the foresight for that.
As controversial as that podcast interview was, I'm glad it has given us some kind of new 1d content. I loved this video so much, it reminds me of times the fandom and the band were still active.
So it obviously wasn’t Niall, he’s just got too pure of a soul to throw Liam up a wall for whatever reason. If Louis threw “Daddy Direction” up a wall and then he said “if you don’t remove those hands there’s a high likely you’ll never use them again.” Lou would’ve been like tf you think you are threatening me, then he’d do worse then throw him up a wall Let’s be honest. He tiny but powerful. It’s down to Zayn and Harry for me. Ziam was one of my fave friendships and ik some ppl ship them but I’ve never met a Ziam in my life. But Zayn just seems like he was angry in 1D and ofc he still enjoyed it but idk, I wouldn’t be surprised if it was him. And Harry, it really depends on what era I think. If it was Fetus to early frat I don’t think he’d do it. But late frat through prince all the way to LLH I wouldn’t be surprised. All in all, if any of these boys threw Liam against a wall, it had to be for good reason and I doubt Liam wasn’t doing anything wrong when it happened. I really miss the old Liam 🥲
I feel like it was definitely Harry cause he name dropped Lou and Zayn but didn’t state who pushed him into the wall cause if he said it was Harry he knew people was attack him for it cause Harry has a stronger fan base. And Niall is to nice
I like how everybody is so confident that it wasn't Niall bcoz he is too sweet to do so 😍🇮🇪🇮🇪 & it can't be Louis coz he would have gone straight fighting and not just pinning to the wall 😂😂💙💙💙
I’m pretty surprised most are saying Harry, but I personally think it might have been Louis. I feel like he’s the only member that gets playfully aggressive but could also take it a bit farther? I also noticed that Louis gets very defensive of others. When Niall got mad on stage at Liam, he defended him and calmed him down. When Liam started saying something about buying lots of clothing, he defended by saying he brings no hair. He even defended himself against Liam saying “if thats how i like it deal with it & if you’re going to hold it against me then leave the band 💀”. And the whole ‘we hated each other at first thing’. Louis said “we used to be at eachothers throats” and Liam has mentioned multiple times about their rocky start. Anyways, thats just my opinion lol I’d love to hear yours
I think it was a joke. in the full clip after Louis and Niall walk away, they start cracking up and turn back like they just can't keep up the fake mad.
There is no way louis did that. I don’t know other boys as well as I know louis so I can’t comment on them but louis is such a pure soul. He doesn’t mind dragging people by his words
right louis once said in a interview that he always tries to patch things up with his friends because he doesn’t like fighting 🥺 -zayn saying louis is the most sensitive and listens to all the boys -louis following all the guys back on insta because he’s so pure and sweet and doesn’t want them to be on bad terms anymore 🥺 -louis saying “noooo” to harry encouraging the fans to fight
Holy shit. I used to be a huge directioner but I quit listening after Take Me Home.. holy shit some of these clips make me really sad, especially the Niall yelling at Liam clip at the end. Like holy shit I’ve never seen Niall lash out like that. They all were under so much pressure. Poor guys
I think it was harry because -louis would have just fought him -he probably would have said about zayn seeing as he was already saying shit about him -niall Is well... niall Plus liam said harry is really scary when angry and although he does have tpwk people can still get angry that's just human so as much as I don't want it to be harry, I think it is
didn't he say when Harry's angry he throws things and his voice gets deep yet I don't believe that cause he seems like he'd never hurt a fly yet I kinda do because he is human like us all I feel like the only time harry would get angry is if someone has mistreated a woman
i think it was harry cause if it was louis or zayn, liam would've name dropped and it definitely wasn't niall, so harry's left. plus they said harry is the scariest when mad and you can see that he doesn't really like liam.
when I saw the interview and the glasses of whisky I knew Liam wasn't in the right state of mind, which is also why I never blamed him. So happy he's sober AND putting new music out :)
"Well it wasn't Niall that's for sure, and I don't think it was Zayn neither, I think it's either Louis or Harry because Harry is very strong Guy next to Liam, Harry & Liam does most push Ups and excrises more In group from what I know, and Louis most likely to lose his temper more than any 1D member In group.
definitely harry. i’m sorry but louis loves him too much and would definitely NOT be able to throw him up against a wall, he’s too small. it could also be zayn but he was kinda a softie for liam tbh, i don’t see him doing that
Ok l LOVE how when he said about the fight in the podcast we were kinda shock and pissed off but after a while we settle down and make it as another just some one direction comedy
During Z and Li fight: Louis is me, being scared asf lol Harry is Olympic Coach examines it closely to see in what shape they are for Games lol Niall is just:get me out of here
I think it was either Louis or Zayn like Louis definitely got in fights and lost his temper and I can see him and Liam fighting. Zayn also was never truly happy in the band and seeing Liam take charge and being bossy I can see Zayn taking a swing
I think it was Harry. He took 1D very seriously and didn’t want to mess it up. I’m sure he would have something to say about it if Liam didn’t show up to something because he was shitfaced and being irresponsible with the band. I also think the pressure was building for a while since Liam was drinking a lot and often towards the end.
I’m convinced it was Harry, first off because Liam once said Harry is scary when he’s mad, second Louis would’ve boxed it out with him, Niall is too sweet and is automatically disqualified, and if it was zayn, Liam would’ve said it since he was already said saying things about him.
I'm sorry but it was definitely Niall. It was revealed by inside sources that Niall Horan's hit single 'slow hands' was previously supposed to be called 'no hands'. However he had to change the name due to the internationally successful artist, Liam Payne, and his song 'strip that down' which reached 1 billion streams in the first 5 seconds of release. I hope you all understand the emotional pain Niall went through and join his GoFundMe to save his hands.
Okay on a serious note it can't be louis because after he hit him Liam said 'you better get your hands off me or theyll be broken' or something like that and if it was louis he isn't the type to listen to that bs he would brake his legs lmfao
You got me a "his album is called walls" hahaha!!! Joking aside, Louis did say that Walls doesn't have a deep meaning. He specifically said "a wall is wall". Now we know of which wall Louis was talking about
Uhhh, he was literally assaulted??? I think he has the right to talk about being assaulted. Yes, he's a prat, but he definitely didn't deserve to be assaulted. And the person I suspect DID assault him is WAY worse than him anyway, but nobody's ready for THAT conversation yet. And talking about Zayn was just... "There are many reasons I will always dislike Zayn, but many reasons I will also always be on his side." What could that possibly mean other than "This person I don't like has been through some terrible things, and that's really unfair, they shouldn't be going through that"? That sounds like maturity, putting your personal feelings and grudges aside to acknowledge someone is being treated unfairly (because Zayn is, and always has been). And him singing the first lines in a lot of the songs... well, that's... literally true. Vast majority of 1D songs, Liam did sing the first couple lines. I could name like 5 right now off the top of my head. What Makes You Beautiful, I Would, What a Feeling, Little Things, One Thing... list goes on. And how do we know that WASN'T for the reasons he stated? Maybe Simon DID say all that stuff, like genuinely, what I wanna know is why we aren't more mad at Simon here. The whole cheating on Maya though and being a stuck-up prat about his solo music, yeah, all that was on him. No way he's getting out of those. I just don't think we should be blaming Liam for anything other than those two things. That's all he did wrong. And that's not even the worst a 1D member has ever done, but again, you're not ready for that conversation yet.
Welcome to the fandom. Liam always spilled the beans on everything. Every change in every interview every single time. Give the guy a podium and he blurs everything out. WHY IS EVERYONE ACTING SURPRISED! No really why?!
I think it was harry, my 2nd guess louis. Although I think it was harry because one thing he does have is height and intimidation and he could have shoved liam up a wall. Louis probably would have gotten in a fist fight or tackled him when you think about it and he probably would have mocked liam if he told louis that he likely wouldn't use his hands again.
I think it was Harry because people have said he is hard to make mad but when he is mad he is TERRIFYING. I mean, just look at the Dont Worry Darling trailer, he is scary there. If Liam was doing something, Harry wouldn't be afraid to put him back in line, especially during the tension of Zayn leaving. Harry takes crap about himself, but I think if Liam said something about Niall, Louis, or Zayn, Harry would not let him get away with it. Also, Niall wouldn't do that, he isn't violent, if it was Zayn Liam just would have said so, and Louis wouldn't pin him up against the wall, he would go straight to fighting.
i love the way everyones like "its definitely not louis or niall" but for completely different reasons. nialls too nice n chill and louis would have fought him 😭
100% AGREE edit: okay but fr this entire time i felt like it was louis but so many of yall say its harry that I'm considering it. wowowow i WANT TO KNOWWWWW
I agree with many people here: - It's not Zayn. If it was, Liam wouldn't be scared to call him out because he already called him out many times in the interview. - It's also not Niall. Even though I can imagine him doing it, he wouldn't be the person who will do that UNLESS Liam went WAY too far, but in his 1D time he wouldn't do such a thing beside fooling around. - Louis would have definitely fought him. And don't say he's too small to even push a six year old to the wall, because we all know how strong he would be if he's angry. Harry is the only one left. He's the calm one most of the times, but we all know people who are that calm once will snap. And believe me, they are scary as hell when that happens.
Finally someone who gets it! Especially Louis part💯 just because Louis shorter than compared to other boys it doesn’t mean he’s WEAK. Being strong doesn’t equal being tall!
Plot twist : Liam actually shoVed himself up a wall And threatened himself he wouldn't be able to use his hand again and explains Liam's broken arm in 2014 he fought himself
OK I have a small theory. Liam was acting really cocky, was totally feeling himself with his inflated ego (pls don't even try to deny that). So, it may have just been a playful fight, like just teenagers messing about, but he wanted to look cool(maybe) and said this as if it was serious fight. It maybe Harry/Niall because Liam would've mentioned the name if it was Lou or Z since he already didn't hesitate talking crap about them. If it was Harry - He didn't mention the name coz he's just too popular rn and his fans would decimate Liam. If it was Niall - I don't think anybody would've believed him coz Niall is just too sweet, nice and uncontroversial.
Liam didn't "talk crap about Louis" Louis defended Liam after that interview. He simply said they didn't get along in the early x factor days. Liam was given alcohol by one of those "annoying Paul brothers" Liam has now apologised for his behaviour and said the other guys supported him through a dark time.
@@pinkballoon8181 yeah I'm alive, thank you. Don't need updates on that one. He DID NOT apologize (publicly) he may have done it personally 🤷♀. "Paul brothers gave him alcohol" huh, almost as if Liam was 30yr old man who could actually refuse stuff when he doesn't want 🤔 who knew?! Again, I can understand that he was going through a dark time, but doesn't mean rest of the world shouldn't comment on his shit show. He went on a podcast, which would be viewed by 1000s of people, naturally whatever he says will be judged. He's still immature, in my opinion, coz he didn't acknowledge he actually did insulting stuff, he's putting the blame on alcohol and other people. Alcohol or not own up to the shit you said and say "sorry". All he did was got defensive, not actually acknowledge the problematic behavior. I don't care if the other boys are cool with him 🤷♀
@@muppididivija4876 Well aren't you the triggered one, lol Liam did apologise actually. Did you see his YT video. It was an apology. And you stated the he talked crap about Louis when he didn't.
My sibling and I honestly think it could've been Louis. He was always one that communicated more through touch. Plus because he had such a good relationship with Liam he could've been more forward in arguments. But we also think Harry because Liam didn't want to really out whoever it was and even though I haven't seen it, I 100% believe that man is a nightmare when angry. So I think either Louis or Harry. But that's just what we think, it could've been any of them
@@homebody_96 no but honestly imagine if it was Niall the one we least expect and it’s just a side we never saw to him 😭😂 I mean I still think it was the least likely to be Niall but I would die to find out if it was actually Niall.
I think it was probably Harry. BUT this video reminded me of how complicated these guys' relationships truly seem. On one hand, they all share the experience of being "One Direction" and going through those hardships. On the other hand, they're fundamentally different people from who look back on that experience with different levels of maturity, gratitude, and sadness. It's really sad to see how they were able to have strong connections that were forged, and ultimately destroyed, by the insane fame and pressure that came with being in One Direction.
I think it’s definitely Harry if it was Zayn I feel like he would’ve said because he was already talking trash about him. And it wasn’t Niall and it wasn’t Louis.
I know this is like low key serious and something ppl fight about a bit, but this video was just purely funny for me. The way you had to just give up and say that it straight up wasn’t Niall 😂
i think it was liam himself didn't he turn up with a broken wrist from breakdancing? suspicious...🤨 jokes aside though, i think it was the potato. niall and louis probably did some kind of experiment to make it grow arms, and they might have accidently mixed harry's long hair in the making of it. That's what made the potato so strong, and its also why the potato never went further in the fight because harry is kind. The potato is also a member of the band so it technically is one of the boys. I think the potato was originally going to attack salmon cowbell but since niall and louis forgot to give it eyes, it got the wrong person. It wasn't until it heard liam tell it to get off until it figured out that was liam. don't ask me how the potato can hear, ask one of the boys.
Love how we all agree it wasn't Niall but how funny it would be if it was him😂😂😂😂
It wouldn’t be bc Niall is the sweetest, kindest, most innocent human being ever 😂
@@RaniaBhatti I agree🥰🥰🥰😂😂
Niall is a total cupcake and a puppy he could never do it😂😂😂😂
I just pictured that and haha Niall could never do that he’s too nice
Here’s the thing, I genuinely believe it could be Niall. Like as much he’s the “baby” sweetest, kindest etc Niall had shown his attitude in random little clips. Do I think he’s the likely suspect, no, but I could see it and not in just the funny way 😂
It was definitely Harry. Louis would have actually fought him. Niall is too nice. They said Harry is the scariest mad. And Liam really didn’t want to say who it was cause harries would demolish him.
when did they say harry was the scariest mad though?
@@f4reva it was in an old interview, I can’t remember which one tho
Bruh Harry's an actual unapologetic biiitch...
@@bmartin6027 oh ok thank u
Could be Harry look how mad he gets when hes acting, i think hes letting out real life steam
imagine if it was niall and we were all wrong 😂
He would definitely be as scary as Harry when he would be angry 😅
the reason I don’t think it was Louis or Niall is because they were friends with liam after the band and I don’t think liam is one to forgive and forget (clearly).
yess this
I actually think that's why he didn't name the person, because he's good friends with them. But we all know it's not Niall, lol. 😙
@@TheEarthRealm im guessing it’s zayn
@@TheEarthRealm word
Neither is Louis 👀
That interview where liam focuses very hard to understand and harry tries so hard to make him understand what's written on the paper will NEVER be not funny 🤣
Which one are we talking about ? 😭
@@user-sk8js7lu8c 0:33 - 1:10 this one 😭
It's so painful to watch😭so much tension
Liam was so confused 😂
@@theoutsiderjess1869 wha you on lad
Okay let’s think about this:
If it was Lou he wouldn’t of cared about the “you’re never going to use those hands again” bs he would of threw hands so probably not.
It wasn’t Niall.
If it was Zayn then he probably would of hinted towards it because during the podcast he said some not good things about Zayn.
It was probably our Harry because they’ve said that Harry is scary when he’s mad and I feel like Harry would of let go and not hurt him.
Conclusion: it was Simon Cowell
Let’s be real it was def harry cus Liam would say smt abt someone else or a group of people or like Louis or Niall to the point he wouldn’t be able to control himself and like only push him against a wall and like that’s it but Louis also sus asf and if it was zany he would’ve name dropped
definitely simon cowell
definitely cowbell
@@vis222after what liam said bout zayn in the interview, some ppl were speculating that liam had prolly said hurtful things to zayn that time too and harry got mad cuz of it and threw him up the wall💀 but i like zarry so slay🤩
It was LHH..then he had an enlightenment and went hardcore TPWK to cover his past mistakes so that he doesn't lose his hands
Right?! 😆
Bruh 😂
Nah he was always kind. Just didn't show it more.
@@aditisk99 it's a joke
@@DeMonfa13 bro he always want love from everyone.he even cried when he was 16..i mean if he was a bad person so why he would be treating everyone so nice for a long time its been 12 years now which is a longtime..he is more successful then other bandmates if he was a bad person so he would act bad and no one could stop him or can let his career down but he is still saying and spreading a message of TPWK. I saw many interviews where he always share his beautiful moments with his bandmates
I just can't take him seriously. . . he literally lowered his voice and said "you'll never use those hands again". There is nothing frightening or menacing about it. Seriously, who tf did he think he was scaring with that mess!?
The amount of secondhand embarrassment I get from that clip is ridiculous.
I wasn’t happy when I saw it but he did apologize.
Well considering the guy who put his hands on him let him go shows you he knew Liam wasn’t playing
I don’t even think he actually said that. Maybe he said something similar but I think he wanted to look ‘cool’ or whatever so he made that part up or changed the wording.
Legit
I'm crying bro
wtf Liam 😭
fr 💀💀💀
So... there's no way Louis, our smol bean could have done that, I mean look at him and then at liam and then tell me..
Harry is a hard-core tpwk..
Niall just sings, laughs and eats. He doesn't hit anyone..
Never in my wildest dream I can think zayn did it..
So, the only member left is Kevin!!
Kevin hit him!!! But how 🤔
I think it was a management or label member, because Rebecca, who was on the X factor with them, said she witnessed a boy band member being thrown against a wall, for fighting against the label/management. And they all had the same people. I think Liam said something about it, in public, so that we’re less shocked when it’s revealed that it was Liam, because Rebecca said that everything from her legal battle, will be made public, with the wall incident included in that.
You remmebr that interview of how louis reenacts the way the pigeons scare him the bathroom?
I'm guessing Kevin used the same technique to push liam up the wall
oh my god i want to kill myself every time i hear people talk about louis that way
I think so too, but I'm really disappointed in kevin if that's true💔😶
Not Kevin!! 🐦😂
I'd say it was Harry.
Zayn: If it was Zayn, Liam most likely wouldn't have said he was "on his side" about the drama with the Hadids. Zayn was falsely accused of domestically abusing Yolanda and Gigi, so if Liam was someone who Zayn had a history of being physically violent towards, he would most likely have believed Yolanda (and come forward about what Zayn did WHILE Yolanda was throwing the allegations around, so November last year). So there's almost no way it was Zayn.
Likelihood rating: 0.5/10.
Louis: Bearing in mind Liam has posted about gymgoing, Louis is too physically small to have literally thrown Liam up a wall without him doing something about it sooner. He also remained good friends with Liam after the band was finished, wishing each other on their birthdays most years, wanting their sons Freddie and Bear to meet, so I'd say probably not him.
Likelihood rating: 2/10.
Niall: Niall is similar to Louis in this, he has also remained good friends with Liam, and also he said in 2015 (so near the end of the band), that he had never been in a physical altercation, so unless this encounter happened near the end of the band, I'd say it was almost definitely not Niall.
Likelihood rating: 1/10.
And that just leaves Harry, whose likelihood rating I'm gonna automatically give an 8/10, so I'm strongly leaning towards it being Harry.
I think Zayn did shove Yolanda. I don't think he meant to hurt her I think he just lost his temper. I don't think he shoved her hard. If she was making it up I think she'd have made it more dramatic saying he hit her or something. I think Liam also believes that he did shove her based on his "that didn't age well comment". Obviously, that doesn't mean he was the one who fought with Liam but whoever it was I am sure Liam deserved it lol
As much as I am a huge Niall fan, I do not think we can always believe what he said in interviews. Just stating that he was always single when apparently that was not always true is enough to question just how honest he always was versus his “media training” as the Never Have I Evers said. 😂 (Despite my reply, I do actually believe him most of the time, including now!)
@@frances9975 why do you think zayn would shove her? do you know it was proved to be false + believe me if he really did that he wouldn’t have gotten 50% and they would’ve ordered for someone to be with zayn and his daughter when they meet which didn’t happen. I am surprised that people really believe Yolanda the attention seeker and she loves drama
i think it was harry mainly because liam had no problem name dropping the other members. the only person he didn’t was harry cause he knew harries are crazy lol
But Liam had bad-mouthed Harry in other interviews. It is possible that the negative attention he got after that kept him from name-dropping Harry this time but I don't know if he has the foresight for that.
When I tell you I had to pause every now and then just to laugh and the number of times I replayed shit is too much your page is too creative😭
aw thank you!!
@@bigredbos895 you're welcome this is the fourth time I am watching this
Yeah this is great but I still don't know who did it. It's not Niall though. No way it would or could be .
“Louis' quite sassy actually” is a literal description of me lmao
As controversial as that podcast interview was, I'm glad it has given us some kind of new 1d content. I loved this video so much, it reminds me of times the fandom and the band were still active.
" his album name is "walls" " 🤣🤣🤣🤣pls i died
NOT GUILTY: Tiny LMAOOO
So it obviously wasn’t Niall, he’s just got too pure of a soul to throw Liam up a wall for whatever reason. If Louis threw “Daddy Direction” up a wall and then he said “if you don’t remove those hands there’s a high likely you’ll never use them again.” Lou would’ve been like tf you think you are threatening me, then he’d do worse then throw him up a wall Let’s be honest. He tiny but powerful. It’s down to Zayn and Harry for me. Ziam was one of my fave friendships and ik some ppl ship them but I’ve never met a Ziam in my life. But Zayn just seems like he was angry in 1D and ofc he still enjoyed it but idk, I wouldn’t be surprised if it was him. And Harry, it really depends on what era I think. If it was Fetus to early frat I don’t think he’d do it. But late frat through prince all the way to LLH I wouldn’t be surprised. All in all, if any of these boys threw Liam against a wall, it had to be for good reason and I doubt Liam wasn’t doing anything wrong when it happened. I really miss the old Liam 🥲
Can you pls remind me what it means LLH?:(
@@FanyTomlinson I meant LHH (Long haired Harry)
I feel like it was definitely Harry cause he name dropped Lou and Zayn but didn’t state who pushed him into the wall cause if he said it was Harry he knew people was attack him for it cause Harry has a stronger fan base. And Niall is to nice
I like how everybody is so confident that it wasn't Niall bcoz he is too sweet to do so 😍🇮🇪🇮🇪 & it can't be Louis coz he would have gone straight fighting and not just pinning to the wall 😂😂💙💙💙
I almost spit out my coffee when it said niall.
when it said about louis "more of a verbal abuser" i dieddd 😭😭😭
I’m pretty surprised most are saying Harry, but I personally think it might have been Louis. I feel like he’s the only member that gets playfully aggressive but could also take it a bit farther?
I also noticed that Louis gets very defensive of others. When Niall got mad on stage at Liam, he defended him and calmed him down. When Liam started saying something about buying lots of clothing, he defended by saying he brings no hair. He even defended himself against Liam saying “if thats how i like it deal with it & if you’re going to hold it against me then leave the band 💀”.
And the whole ‘we hated each other at first thing’. Louis said “we used to be at eachothers throats” and Liam has mentioned multiple times about their rocky start.
Anyways, thats just my opinion lol I’d love to hear yours
I don’t think it was Louis tbh
Nah Louis is too much of a softie for that, if he's fighting most likely with words. He's not the kind who would throw hands.
Na he's closest to lou
Tbf he didn’t actually say at what point it all happened so it could have been when they didn’t like each other
I don’t think it’s Louis until I start imagining it so hmmm either him or Harry oops.
I think it was Harry. 😬
TPWK is what inspired harry AFTER he fought liam with his bare hands
ive never seen those clips with Niall before, those are really interesting
Yes same I dunno what to think about it
I think it was a joke. in the full clip after Louis and Niall walk away, they start cracking up and turn back like they just can't keep up the fake mad.
@@kmarie935 Oh that makes much more sense, thanks !
This video is too funny 😭 but godbless this as a virtual chaotic niam/lirry/lilo/ziam compilation ❤️❤️❤️
There is no way louis did that. I don’t know other boys as well as I know louis so I can’t comment on them but louis is such a pure soul. He doesn’t mind dragging people by his words
So I think he wouldn’t physically abuse somebody
right louis once said in a interview that he always tries to patch things up with his friends because he doesn’t like fighting 🥺
-zayn saying louis is the most sensitive and listens to all the boys
-louis following all the guys back on insta because he’s so pure and sweet and doesn’t want them to be on bad terms anymore 🥺
-louis saying “noooo” to harry encouraging the fans to fight
The thumbnail lmao 🤣
Niall for sure wasnt. And i dont think louis did it. So i think long hair harry or zayn
Between the four of them, my money's on Harry
Holy shit. I used to be a huge directioner but I quit listening after Take Me Home.. holy shit some of these clips make me really sad, especially the Niall yelling at Liam clip at the end. Like holy shit I’ve never seen Niall lash out like that. They all were under so much pressure. Poor guys
THE EDITING IS KILLING ME LMAAAAOOO. I had a good laugh and that is thanks to you, AHAHAHAHA.
Maybe it was Niall. Liam saying "a chance you won't use those hands again" references Niall's guitar playing and how important his hands are... 🤔
When Louis’ picture appeared I thought:”omg his cheekbones” and then the next clip said:”his cheekbones🥵” and I died 🤣
this is possibly the best video i have ever watched. i laughed so many times. subbed!
Liam and Zayn fighting scared the shit out of me 😭.
It is Harry, Harry seems like the chill one but yknow chill people or terrifying when they are mad
i have never seen that clip of niall yelling at liam and i- 👁👄👁
Liam's emphasis on " if i was a GIRL, i'd date Louis" was very sus 😏🤣🤣🤣
Now i suspect H thew him against the wall, bc of JUST that
PLS I LOVE THIS SO MUCH YOURE SO CREATIVE
thank youu
HIS CHEEKBONES PART WAS ✨GOLDEN✨
I think it was harry because
-louis would have just fought him
-he probably would have said about zayn seeing as he was already saying shit about him
-niall Is well... niall
Plus liam said harry is really scary when angry and although he does have tpwk people can still get angry that's just human so as much as I don't want it to be harry, I think it is
didn't he say when Harry's angry he throws things and his voice gets deep yet I don't believe that cause he seems like he'd never hurt a fly yet I kinda do because he is human like us all I feel like the only time harry would get angry is if someone has mistreated a woman
“his album is called walls” LMAO
5:55 makes think off “get off me Liam that’s my hair”
i think it was harry cause if it was louis or zayn, liam would've name dropped and it definitely wasn't niall, so harry's left. plus they said harry is the scariest when mad and you can see that he doesn't really like liam.
I love that we've all kinda collectively decided it definitely wasn't Niall and it was probably Harry lol
THIS VIDEO IS SO FUDGING AMAZING!!!!THANK YOU FOR MAKING IT!!!MADE MY DAY
I love this video soo freaking much!! 😭❤❤❤ I think it was Hazza because Liam didn't really say anything about him in the interview!
100% NOT Niall
my money is on louis or zayn 👀
when I saw the interview and the glasses of whisky I knew Liam wasn't in the right state of mind, which is also why I never blamed him. So happy he's sober AND putting new music out :)
"Well it wasn't Niall that's for sure,
and I don't think it was Zayn neither, I think it's either Louis or Harry because Harry is very strong Guy next to Liam, Harry & Liam does most push Ups and excrises more In group from what I know, and Louis most likely to lose his temper more than any 1D member In group.
plot twist: it was niall
I love that they are like standing there 😂 like: 🧍🏻♂️🧍🏻♂️🧍🏻♂️ 😂😂 on 2:34
definitely harry. i’m sorry but louis loves him too much and would definitely NOT be able to throw him up against a wall, he’s too small. it could also be zayn but he was kinda a softie for liam tbh, i don’t see him doing that
Ok l LOVE how when he said about the fight in the podcast we were kinda shock and pissed off but after a while we settle down and make it as another just some one direction comedy
During Z and Li fight:
Louis is me, being scared asf lol
Harry is Olympic Coach examines it closely to see in what shape they are for Games lol
Niall is just:get me out of here
I don’t believe a word that leaves this man’s mouth 😂
I don't think Harry is as nice as people think.He has a mean streak. Thats why he never smiles. Look out for the quite ones.
It was obviously Harry getting back at him for the lilo kiss
My guess is Harry. He seems all tpwk
just got jump scared because 7:39 is my video from donny lmaooo
I think it was either Louis or Zayn like Louis definitely got in fights and lost his temper and I can see him and Liam fighting. Zayn also was never truly happy in the band and seeing Liam take charge and being bossy I can see Zayn taking a swing
it was literally louis or harry but my guess is lou
Damn y'all still harassing that man for shit? And then you'll cry and say "stop bullying" when he khs lol
I think it was Harry. He took 1D very seriously and didn’t want to mess it up. I’m sure he would have something to say about it if Liam didn’t show up to something because he was shitfaced and being irresponsible with the band. I also think the pressure was building for a while since Liam was drinking a lot and often towards the end.
just can't imagine nialler in this situation
I’m convinced it was Harry, first off because Liam once said Harry is scary when he’s mad, second Louis would’ve boxed it out with him, Niall is too sweet and is automatically disqualified, and if it was zayn, Liam would’ve said it since he was already said saying things about him.
Agree
I agree
Yes !!!!! Lmfao
agree
What video did Liam say Harry is scary when he gets mad?
I'm sorry but it was definitely Niall. It was revealed by inside sources that Niall Horan's hit single 'slow hands' was previously supposed to be called 'no hands'. However he had to change the name due to the internationally successful artist, Liam Payne, and his song 'strip that down' which reached 1 billion streams in the first 5 seconds of release. I hope you all understand the emotional pain Niall went through and join his GoFundMe to save his hands.
I think you mean "throw hands" as in Niall isn't afraid to throw hands 🤣
Lol
I snorted omfg
STOPP 😩😩💀💀
OMGGGG please this is too funny 😭
Okay on a serious note it can't be louis because after he hit him Liam said 'you better get your hands off me or theyll be broken' or something like that and if it was louis he isn't the type to listen to that bs he would brake his legs lmfao
Lmfao true
why u even discussing it, it’s so pathetic grow up
@@lucyoreilly7787 why are you on this video of you have this mindset 😭😭😭
Doing it the tommo way 😠
louis would listen bc he’s so sensitive. but would get harry to attack for him
You got me a "his album is called walls" hahaha!!! Joking aside, Louis did say that Walls doesn't have a deep meaning. He specifically said "a wall is wall". Now we know of which wall Louis was talking about
😂
ikr 😹💀
Nah Louis would have fought Liam so he wouldn't be it xD
I think its very bold of all of us to assume that Liam didn't make the entire situation up 😂😂
at the end of the day it could totally be that
LMAOOO
could be right ya know ahahaha
forreal LMAO
yeah
Liam was drinking the entire time
I actually don't understand why he said those things about zayn and the fight thing. It's just made me sad and I'm disappointed
he wanted attention tbh
And he was drunk
Uhhh, he was literally assaulted??? I think he has the right to talk about being assaulted. Yes, he's a prat, but he definitely didn't deserve to be assaulted. And the person I suspect DID assault him is WAY worse than him anyway, but nobody's ready for THAT conversation yet.
And talking about Zayn was just... "There are many reasons I will always dislike Zayn, but many reasons I will also always be on his side." What could that possibly mean other than "This person I don't like has been through some terrible things, and that's really unfair, they shouldn't be going through that"? That sounds like maturity, putting your personal feelings and grudges aside to acknowledge someone is being treated unfairly (because Zayn is, and always has been).
And him singing the first lines in a lot of the songs... well, that's... literally true. Vast majority of 1D songs, Liam did sing the first couple lines. I could name like 5 right now off the top of my head. What Makes You Beautiful, I Would, What a Feeling, Little Things, One Thing... list goes on. And how do we know that WASN'T for the reasons he stated? Maybe Simon DID say all that stuff, like genuinely, what I wanna know is why we aren't more mad at Simon here.
The whole cheating on Maya though and being a stuck-up prat about his solo music, yeah, all that was on him. No way he's getting out of those. I just don't think we should be blaming Liam for anything other than those two things. That's all he did wrong. And that's not even the worst a 1D member has ever done, but again, you're not ready for that conversation yet.
Welcome to the fandom. Liam always spilled the beans on everything. Every change in every interview every single time. Give the guy a podium and he blurs everything out.
WHY IS EVERYONE ACTING SURPRISED! No really why?!
@@bloodgutsandangelcake6079
It’s been two years. Do you think we are now ready for this conversation?
Because I am interested in what you think.
I think it was harry, my 2nd guess louis. Although I think it was harry because one thing he does have is height and intimidation and he could have shoved liam up a wall. Louis probably would have gotten in a fist fight or tackled him when you think about it and he probably would have mocked liam if he told louis that he likely wouldn't use his hands again.
I think it was Harry because people have said he is hard to make mad but when he is mad he is TERRIFYING. I mean, just look at the Dont Worry Darling trailer, he is scary there. If Liam was doing something, Harry wouldn't be afraid to put him back in line, especially during the tension of Zayn leaving. Harry takes crap about himself, but I think if Liam said something about Niall, Louis, or Zayn, Harry would not let him get away with it. Also, Niall wouldn't do that, he isn't violent, if it was Zayn Liam just would have said so, and Louis wouldn't pin him up against the wall, he would go straight to fighting.
Wait in which trailer did he act mad in
@@hazzahannah Don’t worry darling extended trailer he was steaming mad in that
@@rain4310 link?
@@hazzahannah th-cam.com/video/bW9aRVXIwaY/w-d-xo.html
@@hazzahannah th-cam.com/video/bW9aRVXIwaY/w-d-xo.html
i love the way everyones like "its definitely not louis or niall" but for completely different reasons. nialls too nice n chill and louis would have fought him 😭
I love how everyone collectively agrees that it wasn’t Niall
I mean… easy to say it’s not Niall.
my guesses in order
kevin - 100/10
harry - 9/10
louis - 7/10
zayn - 2/10
niall - 1/10
100% AGREE
edit: okay but fr this entire time i felt like it was louis but so many of yall say its harry that I'm considering it. wowowow i WANT TO KNOWWWWW
Not kevin 😂
We're still bringing up Kevin?? 😭
🤣
Pretty sure Simon Cowel has a motive too
I laughed way too much during the long hair Harry part, you made my day
I agree with many people here:
- It's not Zayn. If it was, Liam wouldn't be scared to call him out because he already called him out many times in the interview.
- It's also not Niall. Even though I can imagine him doing it, he wouldn't be the person who will do that UNLESS Liam went WAY too far, but in his 1D time he wouldn't do such a thing beside fooling around.
- Louis would have definitely fought him. And don't say he's too small to even push a six year old to the wall, because we all know how strong he would be if he's angry.
Harry is the only one left. He's the calm one most of the times, but we all know people who are that calm once will snap. And believe me, they are scary as hell when that happens.
Yeah did we forget how Louis fought the paparazzi? That guy is strong fr
Finally someone who gets it! Especially Louis part💯 just because Louis shorter than compared to other boys it doesn’t mean he’s WEAK. Being strong doesn’t equal being tall!
it was long hair harry end of discussion
Plot twist : Liam actually shoVed himself up a wall
And threatened himself he wouldn't be able to use his hand again and explains Liam's broken arm in 2014 he fought himself
This video literally made my day😂 I’ve been laughing for 12 minutes straight
I love that the video says "srry it wasn't Niall" and everyone agrees on it, we know our Irish princess wouldn't do that😂
Prince or princess?
OK I have a small theory. Liam was acting really cocky, was totally feeling himself with his inflated ego (pls don't even try to deny that). So, it may have just been a playful fight, like just teenagers messing about, but he wanted to look cool(maybe) and said this as if it was serious fight.
It maybe Harry/Niall because Liam would've mentioned the name if it was Lou or Z since he already didn't hesitate talking crap about them.
If it was Harry - He didn't mention the name coz he's just too popular rn and his fans would decimate Liam.
If it was Niall - I don't think anybody would've believed him coz Niall is just too sweet, nice and uncontroversial.
I agree
Liam didn't "talk crap about Louis"
Louis defended Liam after that interview.
He simply said they didn't get along in the early x factor days.
Liam was given alcohol by one of those "annoying Paul brothers"
Liam has now apologised for his behaviour and said the other guys supported him through a dark time.
@@pinkballoon8181 yeah I'm alive, thank you. Don't need updates on that one. He DID NOT apologize (publicly) he may have done it personally 🤷♀. "Paul brothers gave him alcohol" huh, almost as if Liam was 30yr old man who could actually refuse stuff when he doesn't want 🤔 who knew?! Again, I can understand that he was going through a dark time, but doesn't mean rest of the world shouldn't comment on his shit show. He went on a podcast, which would be viewed by 1000s of people, naturally whatever he says will be judged. He's still immature, in my opinion, coz he didn't acknowledge he actually did insulting stuff, he's putting the blame on alcohol and other people. Alcohol or not own up to the shit you said and say "sorry". All he did was got defensive, not actually acknowledge the problematic behavior. I don't care if the other boys are cool with him 🤷♀
@@muppididivija4876 Well aren't you the triggered one, lol
Liam did apologise actually. Did you see his YT video. It was an apology.
And you stated the he talked crap about Louis when he didn't.
@@pinkballoon8181 if you think I'm triggered, then I guess you need to relearn the definition 🤷♀
My sibling and I honestly think it could've been Louis. He was always one that communicated more through touch. Plus because he had such a good relationship with Liam he could've been more forward in arguments.
But we also think Harry because Liam didn't want to really out whoever it was and even though I haven't seen it, I 100% believe that man is a nightmare when angry.
So I think either Louis or Harry.
But that's just what we think, it could've been any of them
probs defending the other 💙💚 or one of the other boys
Liam said Louis and Zayn name but not Niall and Harry, I can't imagine Niall did it, so... maybe... treat people with kindness 🕺✌
@@homebody_96 no but honestly imagine if it was Niall the one we least expect and it’s just a side we never saw to him 😭😂 I mean I still think it was the least likely to be Niall but I would die to find out if it was actually Niall.
@@madisonbusby1457 then that will be "Niall the church boy give it a rest, Niall the bad boy more like" 🤣
@@homebody_96 ahaha exactly 😂
I think it was probably Harry. BUT this video reminded me of how complicated these guys' relationships truly seem. On one hand, they all share the experience of being "One Direction" and going through those hardships. On the other hand, they're fundamentally different people from who look back on that experience with different levels of maturity, gratitude, and sadness. It's really sad to see how they were able to have strong connections that were forged, and ultimately destroyed, by the insane fame and pressure that came with being in One Direction.
No fooking way HAHA (Harry for sure that passive aggressive boy)
I think it might have been Harry. He's physically capable, and is so nice that if you really got him so mad he'd do that
I think it’s definitely Harry if it was Zayn I feel like he would’ve said because he was already talking trash about him. And it wasn’t Niall and it wasn’t Louis.
For sure
I know this is like low key serious and something ppl fight about a bit, but this video was just purely funny for me. The way you had to just give up and say that it straight up wasn’t Niall 😂
right?! hahah
I vote Harry because a) he hadn’t thought of tpwk yet and b) Liam was too scared to name him because he’s got the biggest fanbase and they’ll gut him
I cracked at the reason for Louis because "his album is called "Walls" HAHAHAHAHA THIS ISVERY FUNNY, LOVE THAT
Regardless of who Liam argued with I was choking on air laughing when he was talking
" his album is called 'walls' "🤣🤣🤣 pls i died
NOT GUILTY: Tiny LMAOO
Love the video walls part had me on the floor lol AND im like %90 sure it was harry
“Long haired Harry could take anyone down” 😭 no because it’s so true!!!!!!!!! Idk why but the hair changes the personality FR
This is a beautiful piece of work. Thank you for your services🙏😌
you are very welcome:)
i think it was liam himself
didn't he turn up with a broken wrist from breakdancing? suspicious...🤨
jokes aside though, i think it was the potato. niall and louis probably did some kind of experiment to make it grow arms, and they might have accidently mixed harry's long hair in the making of it. That's what made the potato so strong, and its also why the potato never went further in the fight because harry is kind. The potato is also a member of the band so it technically is one of the boys. I think the potato was originally going to attack salmon cowbell but since niall and louis forgot to give it eyes, it got the wrong person. It wasn't until it heard liam tell it to get off until it figured out that was liam. don't ask me how the potato can hear, ask one of the boys.
I love this and I love you
@@jFITF came here to say the exact same thing! 🤣
This is the correct answer 😌
This comment is gold lmao
I love you for this, couldn't give a better answer😭
I’m crying
the way they're all like "put niall down! put niall down! he's injury prone!"