It’s funny how everyone says the Boks only win because of scrums and mauls but then when people actually talk about their props, all of a sudden they’re not actually that good??? Which is it?
Ive been watching rugby since the 70s but have never seen a more dominant prop than Ox Niche. Its amazing how many penalties he gets for his team game after game. He wasn't even mentioned.
These are all great players but Probably swapped Sheridan with Franks but no complaints. Graham Price , Jannie du Plessis, Tom Smith Soane Tongaʻuiha, Tony Woodcock Christian Califano would slso be in contention
So hard to do this and I can't imagine being able to limit it to just three per bracket. You're putting him right on the spot here! 😂 What a lovely guy though and I do miss seeing that absolutely majestically mane on a rugby field.
@@DannyCareYT Oh man, nevermind A-tier, he is S-tier elite! Literally one of my favourite people in the sport. Also, love your show and maybe this is just me, bit I would love to know more about the dark arts at scrum time. What dirty little tricks and traps they employ to lure a player into a foul etc. Lots of love from SA
I’m Welsh and he’s definitely one of the most overrated props ever to put on the Welsh number 3 jersey .Had one good game against the Beast and all of a sudden a legend .Laughable really .Not fit to lace Graham Price’s boots .
I don’t know what games you watched, or even if you know the game? The video was about out & out scrummagers 🤷🏻♂️, which Adam Jones in his pomp was right up there! Gethin Jenkins was a fair scrummager but far and above Adam as a footballer 🤷🏻♂️! Fgs read the brief 🤷🏻♂️
It’s funny how everyone says the Boks only win because of scrums and mauls but then when people actually talk about their props, all of a sudden they’re not actually that good??? Which is it?
To be fair none of the current springboks are included on here
Os surprisingly low .. another with two World Cup medals . Good video !!
Beast broke that guy into two pieces !
Who Adam Jones? I think it was the other way around. But then again Beast was young.
@ he has no right to rate beast ,he fucking broke him ,The end !
It's for the craic, fella. A wee bit of craic. Put "The Beast" against Carl Hayman and we'd have fierce craic. IN MY OPINION, ou seuntjie😊
Ox Nche. There has never been a scrummager like him.
@@theosokupa2861 no he didnt. he destroyed vickery and jones came on and sorted the problem. fact, the end
Ive been watching rugby since the 70s but have never seen a more dominant prop than Ox Niche. Its amazing how many penalties he gets for his team game after game. He wasn't even mentioned.
He didn't play against Adam Jones
Beast has been punished for being young when he played against Adam, and Os for being old. Prime Beast would have been interesting.
Great segment !! Really good fun.
Beast broke this guy!!!!
Not sure Jones played against him, but Tom Smith was brilliant.
Wee Pocket of Dynamite!
Great video! Nice to see the scrum and props get some love
Where can I pick up a copy of Caring About Care?
DC is working on the Foreword right now. Available in the bargain bins, in all good book shops in 2028.
Eventhough the Beast ripped a certain B&I Irish Lion a new one, now he's on the same level. Please! 😂
You may be thinking of Phil Vickery who the beast did a job on not Andrew Sheridan.
@@deon1978 Indeed realised that!
Sheridan crushed the 'beast' in the last test
@@kemuse1they are both loose heads never scrummaged against each other, I think vickery came back in for the 3rd test.
@@deon1978 Correct.
Os Du Randt and Carl Hayman would DESTROY the others on that list.
I seem to remember Os himself rated Olo Brown as his toughest ever opponent.
@@etienneb3305 You know your rugby fella. Sharp memory, fair-play.
That's my two props too!!!
Tier drops is a pretty universal podcast tool no?
Let’s hope so! 🤞
Can't believe he intially put Sheridan as a C for scrummaging!
These are all great players but Probably swapped Sheridan with Franks but no complaints. Graham Price , Jannie du Plessis, Tom Smith Soane Tongaʻuiha, Tony Woodcock Christian Califano would slso be in contention
Franks is definitely a better player but I think Sheridan is the better scrummager. Basically got England to a world cup final with his scrummaging.
Ox Nche? S-rier?
💣 with the hot takes 🔥
Os du Randt sal jou in jou naai skrum etter. 2 🏆
Os is suspiciously low. But then he did say that scrummaging has changed.
But where are the legends of the Pumas scrum from the 80s and early 90s?
Good luck when you tier drop locks flankers and wingers
It’s coming! Ball Carrying Eights next!
Great craic. Not to be taken seriously. So no need for silliness and rude language.
So hard to do this and I can't imagine being able to limit it to just three per bracket. You're putting him right on the spot here! 😂
What a lovely guy though and I do miss seeing that absolutely majestically mane on a rugby field.
One of our Tier Lists is ‘Greatest Rugby Lids’…is Bomb top tier? 🤣
@@DannyCareYT Oh man, nevermind A-tier, he is S-tier elite! Literally one of my favourite people in the sport.
Also, love your show and maybe this is just me, bit I would love to know more about the dark arts at scrum time. What dirty little tricks and traps they employ to lure a player into a foul etc.
Lots of love from SA
great insight from a great player and coach
I'm surprised he didn't say Tony Woodcock as an A that's missing
Great shout.
OS was os for a reason that means ox. A tier definitely
Salty northerners
🤣
Bitter boks! 😂😂 do ye're own videos if ye don't like "northerners". Ye're always up here moaning. BITTER BOKS 😂😂😂
Need an openside flanker category with it being getting to the breakdown soonest.
Stand up mr Neil Back.
Os with two RWC plus I remember Os barely ever lost a hit on his side but anyway always thought Adam Jones was overrated.
95 caps for Wales, 2 x Lions tours, 300 pro games. Yep, very overrated.
@@DannyCareYToh god forbid anyone has a go at Adam Jones. He was rating players. Why cant someone say they dont rate him
@@DannyCareYTyes extremely. The fact that you guys just brushed past the OS ranking shows how little you know about scrums.
There's a reason why Adam Jones is on the channel rating props and not random Saffa punters 😂@@yanikvanderveen8678
Adam Jones is quite knowledgeable on scrums.
Why isn’t Jones a Welsh coach. He has to be a great man motivator with that personality
Nobody in their right mind would take that job.
It's not just an issue of coaching, it's that the whole union is rotten from the inside.
I’m Welsh and he’s definitely one of the most overrated props ever to put on the Welsh number 3 jersey .Had one good game against the Beast and all of a sudden a legend .Laughable really .Not fit to lace Graham Price’s boots .
yeah I agree, I mean Os du Rant as C clearly shows how rubbish he is.
🤣
"most overrated" is pretty drastic. You watched him every week ? He was good
Jones was a very solid tighthead scrummager.
I don’t know what games you watched, or even if you know the game?
The video was about out & out scrummagers 🤷🏻♂️, which Adam Jones in his pomp was right up there!
Gethin Jenkins was a fair scrummager but far and above Adam as a footballer 🤷🏻♂️!
Fgs read the brief 🤷🏻♂️
Brilliant idea. Beast and Sheridan lower than you'd think! But no one knows better than Adam
Any we’ve missed off the list?
Phi Blakeway…would be a pen winner in the modern game.
@@DannyCareYT Alex Corbisiero and Julian White ?
Fatty Adam Jones and yes I’m Welsh !
Pascal Ondarts, Julian White, Kitshoff, Craig Dowd?