As far as the plot hole, if i remember correctly, when Kaladin was talking to Navani, he suggested he could leave to a distance where he's able to fly and get news to Dalinar. Navani told him to stay put. Even if he could get to Dalinar, since the oathgates were hijacked and Radiant powers were supressed, it would be almost futile to try to mount a counter attack that way for they'd have to traverse the mountain ranges and would likely be unable to overtake fused without Radiant powers anyway. So, for the time being, she wanted him to stay at Urithiru, because their best hope was to deactivate the thing suppressing Radiant powers and having Kaladin there sneaking around would be useful for whatever plan Navani might come up with...
The guy who previously had the Aviar and who got killed by Mraize was named Gereh. He was noted in Navani’s prologue to be wearing lots of rings (that are now noted to be missing) and he worked at the palace back in the day. He was also killed in a way that could make you wonder whether any spikes were used… So basically a Feruchemist with an Aviar, and (some of) his powers were likely Hemalurgically stolen.
30:00 Why didn’t Kaladin leave? If Kaladin had left, the story ENDS in Chapter 30-something (I think 34) when the 1st node is discovered. Without Kaladin, Rabs Unmakes the Tower then and there, and that's Game Over.
Think of Urithiru as a massive stronghold built atop the Himalayan mountain range. You can walk there, like the king from Dalinars visions did in his book, but its extremely difficult. The Fused got in through a tunnel system that they traveled through for weeks.
10:20 re: number of Lights If Harmonium is a Godmetal (which IMO it is) while also being a combination of 2 Godmetals, then Towerlight is a type of Light in it's own right, while also being a combination of 2 Lights
I could be wrong, but I'm pretty sure there are only three primary colors as far as physics is concerned, which is blue, green, red. Other colors, i think, are considered secondary colors - combinations of those three
I'm afraid you are wrong, colors in physics are (mostly) defined by their wavelength, so there is an infinite number of colors. In color theory in art, RGB are the primary colors for additive synthesis, cyan magenta and yellow are the primary colors for substractive synthesis. Physics and art are very different regarding colors. Fun fact, magenta (among others) is actually not a color that has a wavelength, it is a combination of colors that our brain replaces with magenta.
23:30 Parshendi is wrong here, though there was a Parshendi in the infiltration party. Venli was a Parshendi, though the proper term is Listener. The attacking group (Raboniel and co) are Singers. So a Parshendi (Listener) was present, but she was working on the side of the Singers/Fused.
@NextChapterYT the Singers call her Last Listener as a title, but we the audience know that's incorrect because Rlain is also around (and he also thinks of himself as the last Listener, until he sees Venli)
Ok I’m sure you guys won’t mind another comment: You mentioned the combination of Surges creating some unique effects. (They can also a resonate btw.) These are the examples that I think we’ve seen. Windrunners can use both Gravitation and Adhesion to Lash things to a point they pick. So that’s Kaladin re-directing arrows and sticking them somewhere. Lightweavers, may, like Shallan at the end of Oathbringer be able to combine Illumination and Transformation to lend some substance to her illusions. Elsecallers appear to be able to combine Transformation and Transportation - we see Jasnah soulcast (Transformation) at a distance and make it carry over to other people (Transportation). Truthwatchers can combine Lightweaving and Progression, which I think we see when Renarin shows Moash an illusion (Illumination) of an ideal (healed on a spiritual level) version of himself. There may be some Fortune in there because his spren is Enlightened.
32:37 the nodes that can be fuelled by stormlight are a failsafe made by Milishi. He was the bondSmith who last bonded the sibling. I don’t think we know any more than that.
45:25 idk which book, but Wit/hoid talks about men who change the world. There are some who try to stop the boulder rolling down the hill and just get squashed along with everyone else. There are some who try to ______(I don't remember). And lastly, there are men who look at the boulder and it's trajectory, then nudge it slightly. The course of the boulder changes.
I'm going to be that guy: The pattern conversation was in Way of Kings with Kabsal. "Parshendi" was the name the humans gave them, kind of like the term "Indians" for the indigenous peoples. They call themselves Singers, and I do not think you hear Parshendi used at this time in the books. For Kaladin not leaving with the fabrial, i do not know if they say explicitly. My guess is that Kaladin would not know if the fabrial would not have enough distance to get out and back (the weights would be exhausted). I always enjoy you guys! I finished my reread just over a week ago and it improved my opinion of the book. There are certainly parts that drag, but I love the forward momentum and expanding of lore, both on Roshar and beyond!
45:00 time travel rules. It sounds like you're partially describing how time travel in Farscape works. Essentially, anyone can time travel without issue because the "river" of time will simply flow around the traveler and all of the outcomes remain the same, BUT if you Time Travel to a place you have already been to BEFORE you were there then the River basically flows back on itself and everything can go haywire. The fix for that is to study your surroundings, and the first thing you notice going haywire you fix and then get the heck outta dodge, because by fixing that thing you're redirecting the river back onto it's proper path. The resulting timeline won't be perfectly the same, but all of the "important" events will resolve themselves in the same way.
Electrons are particles who can act like waves. This makes the whole lesser Spren magic completely based on quantum mechanics and quantum theory... As you said, it makes the whole system easy to relate to, but it's also definitely a cheat 😊
I think your title with the parts covered is wrong?😄 Unless I'm confused, lol. Great video as always! I've been rereading also and am messing the end of part 4. It's all SO GOOD.
![ILLSLICK X YOUNGOHM - We're The same [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/yUJNkobYR0E/mqdefault.jpg)
As far as the plot hole, if i remember correctly, when Kaladin was talking to Navani, he suggested he could leave to a distance where he's able to fly and get news to Dalinar. Navani told him to stay put. Even if he could get to Dalinar, since the oathgates were hijacked and Radiant powers were supressed, it would be almost futile to try to mount a counter attack that way for they'd have to traverse the mountain ranges and would likely be unable to overtake fused without Radiant powers anyway. So, for the time being, she wanted him to stay at Urithiru, because their best hope was to deactivate the thing suppressing Radiant powers and having Kaladin there sneaking around would be useful for whatever plan Navani might come up with...
The guy who previously had the Aviar and who got killed by Mraize was named Gereh. He was noted in Navani’s prologue to be wearing lots of rings (that are now noted to be missing) and he worked at the palace back in the day. He was also killed in a way that could make you wonder whether any spikes were used…
So basically a Feruchemist with an Aviar, and (some of) his powers were likely Hemalurgically stolen.
I completely agree...
30:00 Why didn’t Kaladin leave?
If Kaladin had left, the story ENDS in Chapter 30-something (I think 34) when the 1st node is discovered. Without Kaladin, Rabs Unmakes the Tower then and there, and that's Game Over.
Think of Urithiru as a massive stronghold built atop the Himalayan mountain range. You can walk there, like the king from Dalinars visions did in his book, but its extremely difficult. The Fused got in through a tunnel system that they traveled through for weeks.
10:20 re: number of Lights
If Harmonium is a Godmetal (which IMO it is) while also being a combination of 2 Godmetals, then Towerlight is a type of Light in it's own right, while also being a combination of 2 Lights
Fair point!!
I could be wrong, but I'm pretty sure there are only three primary colors as far as physics is concerned, which is blue, green, red. Other colors, i think, are considered secondary colors - combinations of those three
That would make sense!
I'm afraid you are wrong, colors in physics are (mostly) defined by their wavelength, so there is an infinite number of colors. In color theory in art, RGB are the primary colors for additive synthesis, cyan magenta and yellow are the primary colors for substractive synthesis. Physics and art are very different regarding colors.
Fun fact, magenta (among others) is actually not a color that has a wavelength, it is a combination of colors that our brain replaces with magenta.
Awesome 👍😊
23:30 Parshendi is wrong here, though there was a Parshendi in the infiltration party. Venli was a Parshendi, though the proper term is Listener. The attacking group (Raboniel and co) are Singers.
So a Parshendi (Listener) was present, but she was working on the side of the Singers/Fused.
Thanks for the help!! I was pretty sure the ‘parshendi’ term is gone now in favour of Fused/Singers, and she is technically the ‘Last Listener’ right?
@NextChapterYT the Singers call her Last Listener as a title, but we the audience know that's incorrect because Rlain is also around (and he also thinks of himself as the last Listener, until he sees Venli)
Ok I’m sure you guys won’t mind another comment:
You mentioned the combination of Surges creating some unique effects. (They can also a resonate btw.) These are the examples that I think we’ve seen.
Windrunners can use both Gravitation and Adhesion to Lash things to a point they pick. So that’s Kaladin re-directing arrows and sticking them somewhere.
Lightweavers, may, like Shallan at the end of Oathbringer be able to combine Illumination and Transformation to lend some substance to her illusions.
Elsecallers appear to be able to combine Transformation and Transportation - we see Jasnah soulcast (Transformation) at a distance and make it carry over to other people (Transportation).
Truthwatchers can combine Lightweaving and Progression, which I think we see when Renarin shows Moash an illusion (Illumination) of an ideal (healed on a spiritual level) version of himself. There may be some Fortune in there because his spren is Enlightened.
31:05 the glove has limits because of the weights there isn’t infinite weight for him to go infinite distance
32:37 the nodes that can be fuelled by stormlight are a failsafe made by Milishi. He was the bondSmith who last bonded the sibling. I don’t think we know any more than that.
45:25 idk which book, but Wit/hoid talks about men who change the world. There are some who try to stop the boulder rolling down the hill and just get squashed along with everyone else. There are some who try to ______(I don't remember). And lastly, there are men who look at the boulder and it's trajectory, then nudge it slightly. The course of the boulder changes.
17:50 you guys are talking about Kabsal's Cymatics demonstration from book 1
Yes!!! That was it!!
I'm going to be that guy: The pattern conversation was in Way of Kings with Kabsal. "Parshendi" was the name the humans gave them, kind of like the term "Indians" for the indigenous peoples. They call themselves Singers, and I do not think you hear Parshendi used at this time in the books. For Kaladin not leaving with the fabrial, i do not know if they say explicitly. My guess is that Kaladin would not know if the fabrial would not have enough distance to get out and back (the weights would be exhausted).
I always enjoy you guys! I finished my reread just over a week ago and it improved my opinion of the book. There are certainly parts that drag, but I love the forward momentum and expanding of lore, both on Roshar and beyond!
45:00 time travel rules.
It sounds like you're partially describing how time travel in Farscape works.
Essentially, anyone can time travel without issue because the "river" of time will simply flow around the traveler and all of the outcomes remain the same, BUT if you Time Travel to a place you have already been to BEFORE you were there then the River basically flows back on itself and everything can go haywire. The fix for that is to study your surroundings, and the first thing you notice going haywire you fix and then get the heck outta dodge, because by fixing that thing you're redirecting the river back onto it's proper path. The resulting timeline won't be perfectly the same, but all of the "important" events will resolve themselves in the same way.
Navani, Jasna and Hoid - favorite characters in the whole Cosmere!❤ And Pattern! Forgot Pattern...
Electrons are particles who can act like waves. This makes the whole lesser Spren magic completely based on quantum mechanics and quantum theory... As you said, it makes the whole system easy to relate to, but it's also definitely a cheat 😊
I think your title with the parts covered is wrong?😄 Unless I'm confused, lol. Great video as always! I've been rereading also and am messing the end of part 4. It's all SO GOOD.
Fixed it!! You’re totally right :)
Kal didn't leave because he wont abandon Teft
Marty undressing the book seemed highly inappropriate for some reason 😅
Hahaha hey! It’s a great book 😂😂
@@NextChapterYT 👀