The Finance Bill is 100% money bill (unlike financial bills I and II) One can check the official website of the parliament: sansad.in/ls/legislation/bills It clearly says that The Finance Bill, 2024 is a money bill. Rajya Sabha cannot reject the Finance Bill (which is a part of the Budget). Official documents from Rajya Sabha which I showed at (03:43) confirm it. That leaves us only with statement 3 to be of some doubt. While making this video in a hurry, I did not read the third statement well. Since The Finance Bill is a money bill, there should be no case of a joint sitting even if Rajya Sabha rejects it. Therefore statement 3 should also be wrong IMO. This means, there is one more question where UPSC OFFICIAL ANSWER KEY could be WRONG!
& because we can’t say with certainty that sambar deer is purely nocturnal, because it also is crepuscular ( active during twilight) I think that’s the reason upsc would have chosen Malabar civet to be nocturnal as it is purely so.
I do understand what you're saying here, I did say that sambar deer is crepuscular. Which is why perhaps UPSC went with only one. But, the question never says purely nocturnal, no animal is purely nocturnal, like no amimal is truly a herbivore. You'll find videos of horses chasing and eating chicks. In animal behavior, scientists focus on what the usual case is. And that's why sambar deer is mentioned all over the internet as nocturnal (but is also active during sunset)
In the mercury question, statement can be taken as incorrect. Because we usually do end up consuming mercury, through fish. And only when it becomes too much , above the safe limit does poisoning happen. This could be UPSC’s logic.
No. Finance and money bill UPSC answer key is right. A financial bill is not a money bill unless it fulfills the requirements of Article 110. So you can’t deviate from the norm, or generalised view, and say financial bill is also money bill. They are separate.
No, you're getting confused between financial bill (under article 117) and the annual Finance Bill (under the budget, mentioned in rules of procedure). They are completely different. The annual Finance Bill is certified as a Money Bill by the speaker himself. Check out parliament's official website. It says it's a money bill. sansad.in/ls/legislation/bills Head over to my telegram group where some good discussion has taken place on this.
Thank you for this video. Things have become really unpredictable now. In the last part of the video, you mentioned that we should avoid attempting only one type questions and questions where we are not sure . In my 2023 attempt, I tried to do the same and as a result I end up attempting only 65 questions which is a terrible attempt. Can you please guide on the safe attempt because it gets really difficult in exam hall to decide.
Yes, the sweet attempt is around 83-88. Maybe even slightly lower. But no less than 80. Agar aapne 80 se kam opt kiye hain then read through questions again and if you are able to eliminate even one option with 100% certainty, you opt. No random guessing. Don't opt any question where you could not eliminate even a single option. However, if the paper is easy or too tough, these numbers will nudge. I am myself guilty of guesswork and opting too many questions. This time I'll stick to my zone.
Sambhr deer crepuscular bhi hi, islie answer a mana h,mekin fir bhi upsc k answers ka kuch ata pata h nhi ,ab jo de diya h wo manna pdega , nothing can happen now
I disagree. The Finance Bill is 100% money bill (unlike financial bills I and II) Check the official website of the parliament: sansad.in/ls/legislation/bills It clearly says that The Finance Bill, 2024 is a money bill. Rajya Sabha cannot reject the Finance Bill (which is a part of the Budget). Official documents from Rajya Sabha which I showed in the video confirm it. That leaves us only with statement 3 to be of some doubt. Either UPSC has framed a wrong sentence here, or, in the case of The Finance Bill, unlike the Appropriation Bill, perhaps there can be a joint sitting. I have great doubts in this regard, though.
The Finance Bill is 100% money bill (unlike financial bills I and II)
One can check the official website of the parliament:
sansad.in/ls/legislation/bills
It clearly says that The Finance Bill, 2024 is a money bill.
Rajya Sabha cannot reject the Finance Bill (which is a part of the Budget). Official documents from Rajya Sabha which I showed at (03:43) confirm it.
That leaves us only with statement 3 to be of some doubt. While making this video in a hurry, I did not read the third statement well. Since The Finance Bill is a money bill, there should be no case of a joint sitting even if Rajya Sabha rejects it. Therefore statement 3 should also be wrong IMO. This means, there is one more question where UPSC OFFICIAL ANSWER KEY could be WRONG!
Dayummm you are right maah boiii
Why did you not do all the discrepancy questions?
& because we can’t say with certainty that sambar deer is purely nocturnal, because it also is crepuscular ( active during twilight) I think that’s the reason upsc would have chosen Malabar civet to be nocturnal as it is purely so.
I do understand what you're saying here, I did say that sambar deer is crepuscular. Which is why perhaps UPSC went with only one.
But, the question never says purely nocturnal, no animal is purely nocturnal, like no amimal is truly a herbivore. You'll find videos of horses chasing and eating chicks.
In animal behavior, scientists focus on what the usual case is. And that's why sambar deer is mentioned all over the internet as nocturnal (but is also active during sunset)
In the mercury question, statement can be taken as incorrect. Because we usually do end up consuming mercury, through fish. And only when it becomes too much , above the safe limit does poisoning happen. This could be UPSC’s logic.
It makes sense, but then why is that sentence so oft repeated at so many places "no safe level for mercury"?
No. Finance and money bill UPSC answer key is right.
A financial bill is not a money bill unless it fulfills the requirements of Article 110. So you can’t deviate from the norm, or generalised view, and say financial bill is also money bill. They are separate.
No, you're getting confused between financial bill (under article 117) and the annual Finance Bill (under the budget, mentioned in rules of procedure).
They are completely different. The annual Finance Bill is certified as a Money Bill by the speaker himself. Check out parliament's official website. It says it's a money bill.
sansad.in/ls/legislation/bills
Head over to my telegram group where some good discussion has taken place on this.
Thank you for this video. Things have become really unpredictable now. In the last part of the video, you mentioned that we should avoid attempting only one type questions and questions where we are not sure . In my 2023 attempt, I tried to do the same and as a result I end up attempting only 65 questions which is a terrible attempt. Can you please guide on the safe attempt because it gets really difficult in exam hall to decide.
Yes, the sweet attempt is around 83-88. Maybe even slightly lower. But no less than 80.
Agar aapne 80 se kam opt kiye hain then read through questions again and if you are able to eliminate even one option with 100% certainty, you opt. No random guessing. Don't opt any question where you could not eliminate even a single option.
However, if the paper is easy or too tough, these numbers will nudge.
I am myself guilty of guesswork and opting too many questions. This time I'll stick to my zone.
Thank you ❤
Bhai how to select best coaching as a beginner for foundation batch and for sociology for 2025ispe ek video banao naa please
Hi!
I'll try to make one after prelims. :)
Sambhr deer crepuscular bhi hi, islie answer a mana h,mekin fir bhi upsc k answers ka kuch ata pata h nhi ,ab jo de diya h wo manna pdega , nothing can happen now
bhai finance billl ko agar money bill maan k solve karenge to statement 1 galat ho jayega.
Aur Upsc ne statemen 1 ko sahi mana hai
I disagree. The Finance Bill is 100% money bill (unlike financial bills I and II)
Check the official website of the parliament:
sansad.in/ls/legislation/bills
It clearly says that The Finance Bill, 2024 is a money bill.
Rajya Sabha cannot reject the Finance Bill (which is a part of the Budget). Official documents from Rajya Sabha which I showed in the video confirm it.
That leaves us only with statement 3 to be of some doubt. Either UPSC has framed a wrong sentence here, or, in the case of The Finance Bill, unlike the Appropriation Bill, perhaps there can be a joint sitting. I have great doubts in this regard, though.
Guys attempt jyda kro ques. Iske karan
Bro finance bill wala thik hai yr do study more
Check the pinned comment.