ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 มิ.ย. 2024
- A post-pandemic surge in students using their phones in class has led to public schools in several states instituting an all-out ban on devices in school. Teacher and writer Erica Berry joined CBS News to explain why a total ban could be an overcorrection.
#news #education #publicschools
CBS News Streaming Network is the premier 24/7 anchored streaming news service from CBS News and Stations, available free to everyone with access to the Internet. The CBS News Streaming Network is your destination for breaking news, live events and original reporting locally, nationally and around the globe. Launched in November 2014 as CBSN, the CBS News Streaming Network is available live in 91 countries and on 30 digital platforms and apps, as well as on CBSNews.com and Paramount+.
Subscribe to the CBS News TH-cam channel: / cbsnews
Watch CBS News: cbsn.ws/1PlLpZ7c
Download the CBS News app: cbsn.ws/1Xb1WC8
Follow CBS News on Instagram: / cbsnews
Like CBS News on Facebook: / cbsnews
Follow CBS News on Twitter: / cbsnews
Subscribe to our newsletters: cbsn.ws/1RqHw7T
Try Paramount+ free: bit.ly/2OiW1kZ
For video licensing inquiries, contact: licensing@veritone.com
Why can't students set up an out of office on their phones when in the classroom? Adults should have OOO on when they're in meetings or driving. Students should be allowed to use their phone before/after school bell rings, between classes or at lunch time. If family has an urgency and must reach student during class time, parents can call the office to report it and allow student to use the phone.
My high school did it well. Phones in the classroom? Unless teachers said something eitherwise, they were expected to be put away. In the halls, cafeteria, ect- totally allowed. So I thought that was good
Lucky that isn’t even allowed at my school
I can see the benefits of an all out right ban but at the same time, school isn't always a safe place, and I can see why phones are good for emergency needs only.
I don't see why they were ever allowed.
This day and age I won't let my kids go to school without their cellphones.
@@iamme25yago don't believe everything you see on TV.
@@tcdahn7you know I would cite a couple things he said with hard evidence that has had years of research, but TH-cam would delete the links.
The idea that a policy against phone use would somehow still be in effect during a shooter emergency is so ridiculous.
Yessss the phones becoming a problem
Yes
A few of my teachers would have us put our phones on a wall organizer pouch and write our name on it. The reasoning was that on breaks or if you really need your phone, then you can find to it right away, but keep your phones away during lecture. Of course, this and the phone lockbox can easily be bypassed. Most people, most families have an old phone that they are not using anymore.
I think we should look at ways to allow phones in class, but limit it's capabilities. Maybe block cell signals on school buildings and have a relatively strong Wifi in the blocked regions. This way the school IT can block the apps like social media from connecting, while still allowing calls and educational tools. But this method is quite costly.
Teachers don’t want them to film there goose-stepping
lol more like the GOP doesn't want them filming evidence of white supremacist cultist terrorism
student bully student : meh
student use phones : discipline!
Phones should be considered safety measure.
Except that they aren't a safety measure, but they are a distraction, and kids have a hard enough time paying attention as it is.
@@reidflemingworldstoughestm1394 until a school shooter enters the building and the students have no way of contacting their parents
@@massarchives8721 Contacting their parents isnt going to protect them from a school shooter. By the time a shooter has his weapon and entered the school it is too late to think about safety. Sensible gun laws are what is needed to protect your children.
@@reidflemingworldstoughestm1394 Again Then The Parents Are Completely Oblivious To The Shooting
@@reidflemingworldstoughestm1394 well said
Good idea!
Her microphone is clipping. Turn it down🤣
Journalism education from where correct term act,invoke, mandate.
Ridiculous idea wonder if there’s a emergency at the school and need to get ahold of their families at home
I think it is a horrible idea to ban cellphones from school at this point. My children are expected to have them. They say that children are not required to have them. But the teachers text out assignments and kids cannot receive them if they don't have a phone. Plus if my children are in lockdown, or if there is a shooter, or for any other reason they need to call me or text me, I want them to have the phone.
If there is a shooting your kids need to focus on getting out of the situation rather than calling you and texting you
As they should needs to be federally legislated this is absolutely perfect and will help kids now and in the future ban them all
"federally legislated?" I think a school-by-school rules and procedures are sufficient enough.
@@RudieObias wrong... u dont think, thus
Until A School Shooter Enters The Building And The Students Have No Way Of Contacting Their Parents
Good luck with that.
Better not ban my kid's phone 😡 Enough of the BANS, already
So you're against Dethsantis's book bans and don't say gay law, and that fake CRT ban?
Your kids are the ones that mindlessly scroll through addicting social media that shape their lives and influences.
You are not educators. Ask a real teacher!
Im a real teacher... FACT101: smart phones should have been banned in all schools 15 years ago... all they do is disrupt every single class daily...
@@tamehamehaprints3604 they meant a reasonable teacher with critical thinking skills
@@DaisyPusher well I am a building substitute teacher and have been in every classroom for multiple years and have seen the destruction and disruption the cell phones have caused. Well an outright van is probably an overage is the next logical step and probably needs to happen
@@davidkruse4030 I hope you’re not teaching grammar…
These kids will end up happier, now and in the long run. Thier “real life” social skills will be stronger in comparison to all other kids across the U.S.
We can ban cell phones but not assault rifles?!
That is an illogical statement. They’re talking about banning phones in school and by the way guns are prohibited in school regardless. Making a statement about assault rifles makes zero sense
@@davidkruse4030 pointing out the differences in how these 2 separate bans would be implemented doesn’t point out a false equivalency. It highlights the willingness to construct systems of accountability for what society prioritizes. If you can’t grasp my overall point then you’re not going to be able to debate it. You’re misrepresenting what I’m saying.
@@davidkruse4030illogical you say, yet you are spewing out pointless strawmen?
I think it's a ridiculous idea especially since we are living in times where our kids already aren't safe in schools
My school confiscated all cellphones from students and this was standard practice back in 2005. Idk why anyone thinks students should be allowed phones in school. Students have gone to school without personal phones or devices for decades before the rise of the smartphone. Not sure why "emergencies" have become a valid argument today. Life has always been subject to emergencies.
About time
With the daily school shootings banning cell phones is the worst idea .. If any thing cells should be required for students.. also if the teacher can't control the students ( cells in backpacks at all times) then teacher needs a different career.
Right. How effective are you at controlling other people's kids? Many kids aren't even taught to respect their parents, much less a teacher they have to deal with for a semester or year at most.
@@iamme25yago I'm sure you'll say something different when it's your kid you can't say goodbye too...
@@trinitylivingston1286He would move to a country with actual gun laws if he valued the safety of his children, assuming he isn’t in one already.
This would be interesting .... LOL 😆 Just turn them Off...
BAN WIFI TOO 19 AND UP
I'm sure this won't affect the high school dropout rate. I think if they're going to ban students from having their phones on them while at school, so should teachers. I mean, there have been times where some of my former teachers were on there's just as much if not more often then the students when I was in school.
Our kids are already defenseless at our unsafe schools, now they want them to be unable to communicate with the outside world even though they're risking their lives every day going there. Guns are allowed--the lack of any action whatsoever to prevent that is proof. At least give our kids the ability to try to call for help, for god's sake.
@@iamme25yago perhaps, in terms of calling for help, I’d say in the majority of cases that’s true. But from a different perspective, maybe the goodbye texts provided some small measure of comfort for those in their last moments or those on the other side who got to say I love you at least one more time. So yeah, useless as far as preventing or stopping it in most cases, but I think useful enough to allow students to have them.
It's a productive tool.
@iamme25yago Schools need to move into the digital age.
@@davidempire4874How about school issued devices that prevent students from doing non educational activities?
Ah right, they’ll just loophole around. I prefer banning.
lol good
Kids are nit safe without them to much going on in the world
Statistically your kids are safe for now than they were 50 years ago
This is prolly the smartest thing they could do.
Students should have to turn the cell phones in during the morning when they first arrive and then they pick them up when they leave. Teachers put them in some type of safe deposit box. Let the parents sign a form giving consent. No reason kids should have cell phones on them during the day. They can’t control themselves from going on them. Adults can’t control themselves, so how could kids be expected to? If the parent needs to reach the child during the school day, they do what they used to do which is called the main office.
Till public schools are safe for all i think all school should be online after 5 th grade. Weed out the bad seeds..tired of the violence, stabbings, assaults, shootings, bullying. Teachers can't even teach bc they are tied up with disciplinary stuff with certain kids....only one warning and on first offense depending on what it is they go to online from home without being allowed bk in public school...
I mean, elementary schools aren't much safer then middle or high schools.
Don’t punish all for the few plus the public school my child attends (K-12) uses laptops/tablets only sooooo that tech only🤔 so cell phone laptop same possible distraction but my kid knows I don’t play when it comes to school rules!
So what you're saying is the babysitter cannot expect children to obey ?
@@michaelsanger7795 I’m saying parents need to teach their kids to respect rules and authority period! So why punish all kids for a few that don’t follow the rules?
Why are Americans concerned with banning everything these days? Mind your business.
They should be learning NOT on social media.....🎉 just my opinion
As per the Noon news, Michigan has banned all Backpacks. Apparently a 3rd grade student took a gun to school in their backpack. Now What!!
Oh yeah, let’s mind our business. See how that goes. I mean, surely the generations to come can discipline themselves? While I agree this was a rather crude bandaid fix, some form of regulation is better than none. This is the right step.
Cell phones are the least of your worries. COVID was a wakeup call for schools to incorporate more/better ways for children to learn but instead of doing this everyone wants to stay stuck in the dinosaur days while technology continues to advance. Instead of taking cell phones away use them to the schools advantage.
@@iamme25yago you must be stuck in the dinosaur days
@@tamikathomas9392you must have zero rebuttals whatsoever because A. You genuinely have no clue or credibility on your proposal or B. You are young and have no idea what you’re spewing out. Perhaps a mix of both?
@@batteriesare_cool Jesus is coming back real soon. Will you be ready?
@@tamikathomas9392 will you learn when to face the truth and not shroud yourself in fairytales and think all will be well when your deus ex machina comes in and saves the day?
I have Life360 on my grandkids. I also have grandchildren with special needs. My grandchildren are not to be on their phones in class. But are not to be removed from their body.
@@iamme25yago No, but the Life360 gives me my grandchild's location, so in case of ANY emergency, their location can be found within three feet. With fires, floods, shootings, the Gods know what, my child leaves the classroom, leaves the school area, I can with my phone get within 3 feet of theirs. So, if had they been at school and a fire broke out, and been evacuated somewhere, I could locate my grandchild. That phone WILL NOT BE REMOVED
Phones are educational and important. Students take notes on the phones.
according to my teenage son, they also use them a lot to cheat, take photos of other kids in the bathroom, watch videos in class...
Hmm, i wonder what other materials that have been used for decades are beneficial to students? Or perhaps other devices that cannot be easily confined within one’s pockets that can still be used for research and other educational purposes
Lol when lil Bobby walks into the school with an AR 15 because he has mental issues and starts spraying I think students will need their phones. Let’s focus on financing armed security rather than sending billions to Ukraine
Green light, yellow light????Seriously, follow the F'en rules. You don't compromise with teenagers or terrorist.
Parents and children justify the use of cellphones saying "we need to be connected, for safety reasons", If so, why they don't just send their children to school only with basic phones? this crisis in education maybe will end when this young generation prohibits their children from using cell phones in classes some years later. These future parents will realise the damage caused by cellphones on their own lives and the ineptitude of their parents ( us ) in avoiding such damage. We shall be blamed.
15 yrs too late.. duh duh drool