It's live she never lost her voice her she was hiding her voice for a long time and rested the voice don't you heard always be my baby or shake it off if she goes higher at the and and when she haves there her old voice than she can sing the full song the voice what she's using now is her normal speak and new voice but if she goes higher with that than she can sing like in the last and there was no falsetto the D6 she was still going and at the end you here again here normal speak voice because you need air control box your voice and Mariah Carey make art with her voice it was not playback what everyone thought she sang live yes her voice chance sometimes first her old voice and her speak voice it's a wonder for her with 49 50 or 51 to sing like that nobody has that like her she's perfection
Laziness/lack of effort.....she didn't even lip sync to an updated studio version, just the 1998 one as if the audience was too dumb to not notice, it's an insult to our intelligence smhhh
Andre Valerio well then don’t attend. Simple as that. I don’t understand how you people really believe you’re true fans yet all you do is bash her. Grow up and get a life.
I'm usually not the one to be all mad and extra about lip syncing, but the fact that she couldn't do a song that the fans voted on atleast 50% live, or have the decency to pre-record NEW vocals is extremely disappointing.
+Priyanshu DFG oh. Thanks. I don't use twitter but I really really want to listen to Open arm again. I think she can sing this song 100% live. Hope lambs love it too and vote it ♡♡♡
MsDivaMC My point exactly, I mean she sung, (Can't let go). This is one of her most easiest songs she's ever made, but hey, I'm glad to see her back in business like she's supposed to be. At this point live, or not she's still the greatest of all, and still owns my ass.
I get that she's had vocal issues over the years and may need to lip-sync sometimes to preserve her voice, but she could have at least recorded a new vocal to lip-sync to
Home girl singing Make it Happen, Vision, of Love, and Can’t Let Go either 100% live or 98% which are MUCH more vocally challenging but yet lips this whole song (minus a few ad-libs). She could of handled it which is odd.
Sigh. I'm a little upset. I've been waiting so long for this. 😣😣😣 She could've adjusted the song and slayed it like Can't Let Go, this is much easier than Can't Let Go. I appreciated the end so much! 👑❤
Pink Panda are you crazy? We pay to see AND hear her sing! I don’t think many would pay that much to just SEE her stand there for over an hour doing nothing....
Joy of life im not. are you? if you wanna hear her then just open your itunes and play her songs. whats the difference between listening to a studio recorded song to a lipsynced performance?? now whos crazy? you dont have to argue with me. im a mariah fan but im not hypocrite. i say the truth.
As a vocalist and as a fan who has sung a lot of mariahs very difficult songs I can say that I can understand why she’d lip this song. It’s not nearly as easy as it appears and she probably just needed a break during the show. She sounded amazing this night and I don’t think that this song ruined that.
1.Wow she sounds SO amazing here! I can't believe she still sounds so great after all this time! Proves she's the ultimate Queen! 2. I wish she could've sang this at her show that I went to on my bday (Sep 10)
I love mariah but this is just wrong. Paying all that money to listen to the studio version We all know she doesn't sound anywhere like she did when she recorded it. It makes me feel cheated. She needs vocal rehab fast
Come on guys she's been doing the show 90 percent live for 4 DAYS STRAIGHT. Let her voice rest. And give her a chance. She didnt need to prove her self anymore :) Look at 2017. Good vocals but sounds tired. We're lucky for having her vocals recover :)
It's live she never lost her voice her she was hiding her voice for a long time and rested the voice don't you heard always be my baby or shake it off if she goes higher at the and and when she haves there her old voice than she can sing the full song the voice what she's using now is her normal speak and new voice but if she goes higher with that than she can sing like in the last and there was no falsetto the D6 she was still going and at the end you here again here normal speak voice because you need air control box your voice and Mariah Carey make art with her voice it was not playback what everyone thought she sang live yes her voice chance sometimes first her old voice and her speak voice it's a wonder for her with 49 50 or 51 to sing like that nobody has that like her she's perfection
This is the night I was there! I was thrilled that she chose to sing this song and change the setlist. She looked AMAZING (video doesn't do it justice). Mimi is trying to please the fans and I appreciate her effort. Maybe lipped at some points but, LIVE as well. Anyways it's a tribute to Brenda K. Starr--she mentioned her during the show
Every singer while on tour or at a damn residency has a playback song they do to actually rest their voice ,ESPECIALLY SINGERS who actually can sing ! Also the older they get with as many octaves it takes a tole u need more rest inbetween ,doesnt mean she cant sing it means shes been straining her instrument (voice) ! True fans sound so ridiculous getting mad ! U never see beyonce fans mad at all her playback shit she does ! Get over it already !
Mariah have been speaking A lot lately that her voice have been healthy. And this is actually a full live. If you listen to 1:18 there is some vocal break which only happens when she sings this song live. I don’t know about y’all, but this song is not that vocally demanding, this is easy for her to sing. And to even sound like the studio, only Mariah can do… She’s a Queen, she can do what ever she wants.
It's definitely not, I'm a big lamb and this is obviously lipped until the last few notes. Idk why bc like you say, it's an easy one, she could sing this but I think she's scared that her voice will sound different than the record... Which is true bc it matured, but who cares, we want to hear her fully live!
I absolutely love Mariah Carey voice so beautiful and i love that song so much. Especially Mariah Carey version of the song. And i love how she song for the usa army troops ♥️♥️
THIS IS SADDDDD. WHY WOULD YOU INCLUDE THIS SONG IN THE SET LIST IF YOU CANT SING IT LIVE MARIAH?? LIKE WHY?? BY THE WAY THE ONLY LIVE PART CAME AFTER MIN THIS IS SADDDD 3:34. AS A FAN I'M EMBARRASSED.
LMAO. I can’t believe that Ms. Mariah Carey just made me sit through 3 minutes and 52 seconds to only sang 12 words live at 3:34. This is Mariah’s world and we are simply living in it. 😂
Jesus christ leave the woman alone already! Who cares if she sings it live or with playback EVERY SINGER USES PLAYBACK! She has been singing her whole life and she has to be very careful. I still love her and I still believe...💖🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋
It is such a shame this was lipped, you can’t fool the true lambs we know your vocals off by heart. Only the last 10 secs was sung live. I still love you Mariah no matter what, you are a legend. ❤️
You look in my eyes and I get emotional inside I know it’s crazy but you still can touch my heart And after all this time you think that I wouldn’t feel the same But time melts into nothing, nothing's changed I still believe Someday you and me Will find ourselves in love again I had a dream Someday you and me Will find ourselves in love again Each day of my life I’m filled with all the joy I could find You know that I I'm not the desperate type If there’s one spark of hope left in my grasp I'd hold it with both hands It’s worth the risk of burning To have a second chance No, no, no, no, no, no, I need you, baby I still believe that we can be together, no, no, no If we believe that true love never has to end Then we must know that we will love again I still believe Someday you and me Will find ourselves in love again Oh, baby, yeah-e-yeah I had a dream Someday you and me Will find ourselves in love again Ooh, baby, I do Just give me one more try I in love again I had a dream I miss your love Someday you and me Will find ourselves in love again Will find ourselves in love again Believe, I believe, I still believe I believe, believe, believe I believe, I still believe I believe, believe, believe I still believe I had a dream Someday you and me Find ourselves in love again I still believe Someday you and me [Incomprehensible] [Incomprehensible] I had a dream Someday you and me I still believe Yeah, still believe I still believe Someday you and me
It's live she never lost her voice her she was hiding her voice for a long time and rested the voice don't you heard always be my baby or shake it off if she goes higher at the and and when she haves there her old voice than she can sing the full song the voice what she's using now is her normal speak and new voice but if she goes higher with that than she can sing like in the last and there was no falsetto the D6 she was still going and at the end you here again here normal speak voice because you need air control box your voice and Mariah Carey make art with her voice it was not playback what everyone thought she sang live yes her voice chance sometimes first her old voice and her speak voice it's a wonder for her with 49 50 or 51 to sing like that nobody has that like her she's perfection
30#1s For Mimi I'm starting to feel the same way, I mean NYE gave her such a hard time and that was for her to stop lipping or just learn it and not doing it that much but I guess she didn't understand :(
disappointing that she didnt do this live! her die hard fans knows her back catalogue inside out. so she shouldnt insult her fans intelligence by popping this song in and mining it. MARIAH!!!
I'm a die hard lamb, but come on, her mid belts are on FIRE up to D5 nowadays, and she showed it the same night belting great D5's and an incredible Eb5 during It's Like That, this song doesn't go higher than C5, the belts on "IIII still believe" are B4's, she could easily do it, maybe lowering the key they'd be Bb4's, which is basically her note. At the end she wanted to attempt the D6, but wasn't confident enough, and it would have probably been useless, cause everybody would have thought it was lipped cause she lipped all the rest... if she wouldn't have slayed so hard other songs that night like she did I'd have been disappointed
maybe she is saving her voice for the dardest song or she is just trying to save her voice don;t be so hard on her...everybody we see how better and better is doing day by day give her some time :)
labeti25 I don't wanna be hard on her at all. But if you still wanna preserve a bit your voice, then do the song when you're ready to sing it live, cause we all know she could easily NAIL it 100% live, she's The Songbird Supreme!!!
yes and i agree with you babe BUT do you really believe that the music intustry is giving her that time?????those phyco people started a war with her defenently the last 3 or 4 years....and the media are kissing their asses if you paid attension...the people stoped them a little bit and they start a little bit to say one good word...but other than that they just wait for one little mistake from her to her down...the nye perfomance it wans't ONLY from stella..."they set her up"literally...that's why mariah post her message on instagram...because she got the message....and that's why she changed her vegas show...
labeti25 Of course, I always thought that performance got sabotaged, never thought it was Mariah's fault. I'm just saying... if they bash you for lipping... lip only the high notes, do everything you can do live, and this song is one of the easiest songs for her, since her tone matured. For example I'm ok with the fact that she lips WBT's climax, Shake It Off's last part, Can't Take That Away last belts... but I Still Believe... come on... just no, especially since it's a fan favourite and one of the most requested songs.
Briar Foskey i was there and very excited when this song started but once the first line came out i knew. but i will say, the vocals she pulled out during the whole performance excused it for me, personally, this was an amazing show. sad that can’t take that away was cut for it though.
She sang this live in 2912. Her voice now is in much better condition now than it was back then. I have a feeling she and the entire band wasn't able to rehearse this song that's why it was totally lipped.
She’s clearly fully aware that she knows we can tell she’s miming. But hey, for the nostalgia i guess it dont matter as we would only be disappointed-if she did it live lets be honest. She’s just doing it for the lambs
People here be complaining about her lip-syncing to one song when she slayed the other songs live on the same night. People need to remember that other singers do it too, even more often than she does.
It's not like she lip-synced the whole concert. She only lip-synced to this song. And yes, call me crazy if it will make you happy but I'm still going to see her even if she lip-sync the whole concert. You know why? I love her so much. Her music helped me get through the darkest days of my life. Plus, she is a legend who had proven herself as one of the greatest singers to grace the world. She doesn't need to prove herself to anyone anymore. So if I were you, I'll just go support my favorite artist instead of posting hate comments on somebody you don't like. God bless.
I’m surprised she lipped this, because I remember her attempting it live in Morocco. I’m sure she would’ve done a much better job. Welp. We’ll see how it goes for future dates.
I believe she could of sang it live because the last two seconds where she actually sang sounds good...she probably needed to rest her voice some which is totally understandable she has been working really hard to prove herself and she has had some great live vocal moments...so lambs we have to be a little more understanding and we need to keep encouraging her she is slowly gaing her confidence back shes got enough haters...she doesn't need us bashing her too
I was at this show, and I was so excited when she said her next song was I Still Believe, but then when I heard the original studio recording I was severely disappointed (although I was in the front section and she is hiding her lipping really well these days). ISB is one of my favorite songs and I was so happy when it won the poll, but I MUCH would have preferred to hear her sing CTTA. Still, I'd say aside from this song 90% of the night was sung live and she sounded amazing.
I know most of you fans are disappointed. But remember she can only do so much as a singer. Lip syncing has existed for many years now and for sure I do agree with people that should of at least lowered the key but also she is living with vocal nodules when she was born. The voice can only do so much and you guys should realize that she is not a robot. She has only done 4 and she will probably do it live on a later show.
Raymond Salgado then don’t sing it then! If she gets tired then space the shows out! Don’t ask a shit ton of money from us then mime along to the original track! Disappointed
I don’t have a problem with it, but I wish she would own it. She used to say she would never lip sync. And now that she does, she won’t be honest about it. We know how hard it is to sing vocally demanding songs. I think it would be better to partially lip all the songs rather than lipping the entirety of two songs.
I_Still_Believe.mp3 playing
At least its 2% live
SKSKSJDJKS well
BYE SKSKSKSKS
Deadset. I am so seriously disappointed with this, it actually hurts.
sim0an you thoguht she would sing it live lol
Andrew, fuck off
She looks amazing though
She's not singing.
tangled55 well she did some runs 😂
Beautiful gowns😭😂
she clearly didn't need to lip the entire song...
thecatfromsingapore yes i agree
It's live she never lost her voice her she was hiding her voice for a long time and rested the voice don't you heard always be my baby or shake it off if she goes higher at the and and when she haves there her old voice than she can sing the full song the voice what she's using now is her normal speak and new voice but if she goes higher with that than she can sing like in the last and there was no falsetto the D6 she was still going and at the end you here again here normal speak voice because you need air control box your voice and Mariah Carey make art with her voice it was not playback what everyone thought she sang live yes her voice chance sometimes first her old voice and her speak voice it's a wonder for her with 49 50 or 51 to sing like that nobody has that like her she's perfection
@@justinmalik8573 it’s not. You’re totally not a lamb
You saw how the live part sounded at the very end I highly doubt she would have been able to pull the whole song off fully live unfortunately
Why is she torturing lambs like this :( ?
Laziness/lack of effort.....she didn't even lip sync to an updated studio version, just the 1998 one as if the audience was too dumb to not notice, it's an insult to our intelligence smhhh
😣😣😣😣
@@NoName-cu2uk😂😂😂😂😂😂 that’s Americans. Yall were always dumb
First disappointment of The Butterfly Returns
Definely
Her vocals from first night had me kinda disappointed too as I was expecting more
Andre Valerio well then don’t attend. Simple as that. I don’t understand how you people really believe you’re true fans yet all you do is bash her. Grow up and get a life.
gabri raph it’s DEFINITELY. Learn to spell
I'm usually not the one to be all mad and extra about lip syncing, but the fact that she couldn't do a song that the fans voted on atleast 50% live, or have the decency to pre-record NEW vocals is extremely disappointing.
you mean she changed the list of songs every night for fans and her fans could ask her to sing any songs ? sorry for my poor english
Trong Nghia Huynh no... lambs voted for it on twitter😂
+Priyanshu DFG oh. Thanks. I don't use twitter but I really really want to listen to Open arm again. I think she can sing this song 100% live. Hope lambs love it too and vote it ♡♡♡
This is absolutely embarrassing!
Right?!
Why lipped tho?! She could've toned it down like Can't Let Go and adjusted the arrangements.
* sighs
MsDivaMC My point exactly, I mean she sung, (Can't let go). This is one of her most easiest songs she's ever made, but hey, I'm glad to see her back in business like she's supposed to be. At this point live, or not she's still the greatest of all, and still owns my ass.
Chance Hightower I would just appreciate her recreating her live performances, especially after seeing she is more than capable of doing it.
MsDivaMC I know.. she did it with the rest of the songs. I guess this might have been a last minute songs she decided to do..
Chance Hightower Welp, she shouldn't have done it. PERIOD.
Chance Hightower I mean even parts of can’t let go where lipped. Like 85% of the song was live.. and partially the whistle.
I just don’t know who she’s trying to fool. Like we haven’t played this song on repeat. Memorized every little run, every subtle moment. Sigh...
Chris Lawson totally agree!!! Like we don’t know her Voice before and now.
Merayah Carey please change ur name to something else. U drag Mariah in every comments section🤦🏿♀️
Every artist lol syncs so what...
@Mya Aguilar but she's charging money for a LIVE performance. we can listen to the studio version infinity times for FREE.
I get that she's had vocal issues over the years and may need to lip-sync sometimes to preserve her voice, but she could have at least recorded a new vocal to lip-sync to
Home girl singing Make it Happen, Vision, of Love, and Can’t Let Go either 100% live or 98% which are MUCH more vocally challenging but yet lips this whole song (minus a few ad-libs). She could of handled it which is odd.
i think CLG is 50% lipped. Which is okay, considering she prerecorded new vocals for it and not the 90s vocals
I love mimi a lot, but I felt as thought this could have been at least 50% live, or even drop the key considering it was a fan favorite.
What a mess.. why cut CTTA which she was getting better at every night to do a fully lipped to studio version of ISB?
Samantha McMahon IKR ☹️☹️☹️
Excuse meeeee?
Because people voted for ISB on that twitter poll... 🙄🙄🙄
Juan Rico Zamorano .. I voted for her to sing it 😂
Mariah is a Legend lolll... everybody thought she would've "sung" more than *13* words live... I counted it it's literally 13(14-ish)
1998 i still believe 😝
What a shame she did playback. Her voice was so healthy in this era. She could slay, we still love her ❤
Sigh. I'm a little upset. I've been waiting so long for this. 😣😣😣
She could've adjusted the song and slayed it like Can't Let Go, this is much easier than Can't Let Go.
I appreciated the end so much! 👑❤
I agree but do you think this is easier than anything. I think this is an incredibly hard song to sing 😰
Can't Let Go is also lipped.
She sounds so good I'm crying. Thank you for this video
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 she’s lip syncing to the original track
people pays to see her.. not to hear her lol n even if she lost her powerful voice mariah is still mariah after all. i still love her. shes an icon
Pink Panda are you crazy? We pay to see AND hear her sing! I don’t think many would pay that much to just SEE her stand there for over an hour doing nothing....
Joy of life im not. are you? if you wanna hear her then just open your itunes and play her songs. whats the difference between listening to a studio recorded song to a lipsynced performance?? now whos crazy? you dont have to argue with me. im a mariah fan but im not hypocrite. i say the truth.
she looks amazing
As a vocalist and as a fan who has sung a lot of mariahs very difficult songs I can say that I can understand why she’d lip this song. It’s not nearly as easy as it appears and she probably just needed a break during the show. She sounded amazing this night and I don’t think that this song ruined that.
Seems live to me.
Hope she does it live next time, not a difficult song for her now
she could always lower it
Who the fuck cares if she's lip-synced or not ? She still sings better in her bad days than any of the current pop girls.
I know she didn’t entirely lip to her 98 vocals .. no mam
i appreciated for what she did that night, lyps or not, doesn't matter. (she's a LEGEND). lots of love from Indonesia 🇮🇩
Even though is not live, it's still amazing to hear...
Love you Mariah! 😙😗😚😘
1.Wow she sounds SO amazing here! I can't believe she still sounds so great after all this time!
Proves she's the ultimate Queen!
2. I wish she could've sang this at her show that I went to on my bday
(Sep 10)
Wooooow this is my Mariah 😍
maro muñoz it's lipped
Andrew Martin why do u think that? 😶
Andrew Martin i was happy :( because she recover her versatility... Okey only an ilusion...
Andrew Martin no, u right, she can do it 😢 i noted that at the final, no vocal dynamism
maro muñoz check out Mariah's Theme, is obvious that she can do ISB love.
I love mariah but this is just wrong. Paying all that money to listen to the studio version
We all know she doesn't sound anywhere like she did when she recorded it. It makes me feel cheated. She needs vocal rehab fast
For some odd reason, I knew she was gonna do this when she released the polls.
can't believe she only started singing live from 3:35
how could she slay "can't let go" and not attempt this one
I love you MIMI no matter what happens! 💓 see you soon!!! -from the PHILIPPINES :*
wow mariah in 2018 sounds like so amazing, love this song
One of my fav. Song!! Whoa!!!
Mariah tell them hater boy buy u still got it and u never lost that beautiful voice so keep doing wat u do i got your back
Come on guys she's been doing the show 90 percent live for 4 DAYS STRAIGHT. Let her voice rest. And give her a chance. She didnt need to prove her self anymore :) Look at 2017. Good vocals but sounds tired. We're lucky for having her vocals recover :)
90% live my ASS.
Yes let's give her a break.
Just don’t do it then! If I’d been there I would have been so disappointed
Johnnu Pera Singing live isn't about PROVING anything, it's just what singers are supposed to do ^^
Too perfect . It's video version :-D😲. Last 2 seconds live . Oh Mariah , we know you 😉
Mariah , beautiful as always . You still killing it👍😉💋💋💋
At least she's better at lipping now unlike before when she uses all her force and throws her fist in the air when she's just hitting a mid belt.
It's live she never lost her voice her she was hiding her voice for a long time and rested the voice don't you heard always be my baby or shake it off if she goes higher at the and and when she haves there her old voice than she can sing the full song the voice what she's using now is her normal speak and new voice but if she goes higher with that than she can sing like in the last and there was no falsetto the D6 she was still going and at the end you here again here normal speak voice because you need air control box your voice and Mariah Carey make art with her voice it was not playback what everyone thought she sang live yes her voice chance sometimes first her old voice and her speak voice it's a wonder for her with 49 50 or 51 to sing like that nobody has that like her she's perfection
One of my favorite Mariah Carey songs!!!
This is the night I was there! I was thrilled that she chose to sing this song and change the setlist. She looked AMAZING (video doesn't do it justice). Mimi is trying to please the fans and I appreciate her effort. Maybe lipped at some points but, LIVE as well. Anyways it's a tribute to Brenda K. Starr--she mentioned her during the show
This my song she really did it😍😍😍😍😭😭😭😭😭😭😭💁🏽♀️
huhuhuhuhuhu....playback queen but still love her!!!
Why she lip this one!? She can sing this 🤷🏽♂️
Live
Silly to lip this song the night she has sounded the best!! Just watch the other clips. She was on fire.
The worst part is that she isn't even using a prerecorded track she is using the studio version😂😭.
Mariah who are you trying to fool?
perfect..just perfect!
Omg amazing
Every singer while on tour or at a damn residency has a playback song they do to actually rest their voice ,ESPECIALLY SINGERS who actually can sing ! Also the older they get with as many octaves it takes a tole u need more rest inbetween ,doesnt mean she cant sing it means shes been straining her instrument (voice) ! True fans sound so ridiculous getting mad ! U never see beyonce fans mad at all her playback shit she does ! Get over it already !
Beautiful💝🌺
Mariah have been speaking A lot lately that her voice have been healthy. And this is actually a full live. If you listen to 1:18 there is some vocal break which only happens when she sings this song live. I don’t know about y’all, but this song is not that vocally demanding, this is easy for her to sing. And to even sound like the studio, only Mariah can do… She’s a Queen, she can do what ever she wants.
It's definitely not, I'm a big lamb and this is obviously lipped until the last few notes. Idk why bc like you say, it's an easy one, she could sing this but I think she's scared that her voice will sound different than the record... Which is true bc it matured, but who cares, we want to hear her fully live!
I absolutely love Mariah Carey voice so beautiful and i love that song so much. Especially Mariah Carey version of the song. And i love how she song for the usa army troops ♥️♥️
THIS IS SADDDDD. WHY WOULD YOU INCLUDE THIS SONG IN THE SET LIST IF YOU CANT SING IT LIVE MARIAH?? LIKE WHY?? BY THE WAY THE ONLY LIVE PART CAME AFTER MIN THIS IS SADDDD 3:34. AS A FAN I'M EMBARRASSED.
wat else can i say, its her song and shes my queen!
She gona do it #Live next time 😍 shes warming up #L4L
mariah is Mariah you know that Queen1's
Please upload more from this night!!!!
PERFECT!!!! nothing to say,
LMAO. I can’t believe that Ms. Mariah Carey just made me sit through 3 minutes and 52 seconds to only sang 12 words live at 3:34. This is Mariah’s world and we are simply living in it. 😂
OMG.. did you including that "yeah...yeah" for complete the 12 words 😁😁😁😁
She sounds great in that live part. If only she had sang the rest of the song live
Hi Britney! 😂😂😂
Kkkkkk
Playback!!! WHYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY?
Yessssss
No
Aannndd this is why I sold my ticket back on stub hub 🙄🙄 but I still love me my Mariah
Ohhhh Mariah why lol.. She sounds so good on CLG & CTTA so why, just why lol.. Love her any way & she looks beautiful
Well, that piano might have been live at least :)
Jesus christ leave the woman alone already! Who cares if she sings it live or with playback EVERY SINGER USES PLAYBACK! She has been singing her whole life and she has to be very careful. I still love her and I still believe...💖🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋🦋
😭playback 😭😭
It is such a shame this was lipped, you can’t fool the true lambs we know your vocals off by heart. Only the last 10 secs was sung live. I still love you Mariah no matter what, you are a legend. ❤️
i'm sooooo disappointed
i hope she does it live in next dates
"The Time Has Come for You to Lip-Sync for Your Life ... Good luck and don't F*ck it Up "
In the live part, we can hear that her voice was pretty good and sustained. She could do it live 100%
You look in my eyes and I get emotional inside
I know it’s crazy but you still can touch my heart
And after all this time you think that I wouldn’t feel the same
But time melts into nothing, nothing's changed
I still believe
Someday you and me
Will find ourselves in love again
I had a dream
Someday you and me
Will find ourselves in love again
Each day of my life
I’m filled with all the joy I could find
You know that I
I'm not the desperate type
If there’s one spark of hope left in my grasp
I'd hold it with both hands
It’s worth the risk of burning
To have a second chance
No, no, no, no, no, no, I need you, baby
I still believe that we can be together, no, no, no
If we believe that true love never has to end
Then we must know that we will love again
I still believe
Someday you and me
Will find ourselves in love again
Oh, baby, yeah-e-yeah
I had a dream
Someday you and me
Will find ourselves in love again
Ooh, baby, I do
Just give me one more try
I in love again
I had a dream
I miss your love
Someday you and me
Will find ourselves in love again
Will find ourselves in love again
Believe, I believe, I still believe
I believe, believe, believe
I believe, I still believe
I believe, believe, believe
I still believe
I had a dream
Someday you and me
Find ourselves in love again
I still believe
Someday you and me
[Incomprehensible]
[Incomprehensible]
I had a dream
Someday you and me
I still believe
Yeah, still believe
I still believe
Someday you and me
It's live she never lost her voice her she was hiding her voice for a long time and rested the voice don't you heard always be my baby or shake it off if she goes higher at the and and when she haves there her old voice than she can sing the full song the voice what she's using now is her normal speak and new voice but if she goes higher with that than she can sing like in the last and there was no falsetto the D6 she was still going and at the end you here again here normal speak voice because you need air control box your voice and Mariah Carey make art with her voice it was not playback what everyone thought she sang live yes her voice chance sometimes first her old voice and her speak voice it's a wonder for her with 49 50 or 51 to sing like that nobody has that like her she's perfection
At least the beginning and the end was live. She’s still the Mariah
"At least the beginning and the end was live". I love her too, but do you realize how PATHETIC that sounds?
lov tis songgs
100% playback
She doesn't learn her lesson. After getting dragged by the media yesterday over her lipping fantasy and she does this. Girl seriously
preach.
Ikr?
Tbh I’m starting to believe Mariah doesn’t want to be famous anymore
30#1s For Mimi I'm starting to feel the same way, I mean NYE gave her such a hard time and that was for her to stop lipping or just learn it and not doing it that much but I guess she didn't understand :(
30#1s For Mimi And she doesn't even make new prerecorded vocals and uses it from 1998, does she think she can fool us?
disappointing that she didnt do this live! her die hard fans knows her back catalogue inside out. so she shouldnt insult her fans intelligence by popping this song in and mining it. MARIAH!!!
Mariah Carey I love you so much... Can't wait to see you here in Philippines......🇵🇭
Hi Ignacio😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
I Still Believe
It's hurts 😢😢😢😢😢😢
This was live!! Believe...
Rare occasion that she’s good at lipping. If it wasn’t for the comments I would have never thought she was lipping.
Still as good as day 1
Regardless i support Mariah Carey!!! #TheButterflyReturns
I'm a die hard lamb, but come on, her mid belts are on FIRE up to D5 nowadays, and she showed it the same night belting great D5's and an incredible Eb5 during It's Like That, this song doesn't go higher than C5, the belts on "IIII still believe" are B4's, she could easily do it, maybe lowering the key they'd be Bb4's, which is basically her note. At the end she wanted to attempt the D6, but wasn't confident enough, and it would have probably been useless, cause everybody would have thought it was lipped cause she lipped all the rest... if she wouldn't have slayed so hard other songs that night like she did I'd have been disappointed
maybe she is saving her voice for the dardest song or she is just trying to save her voice don;t be so hard on her...everybody we see how better and better is doing day by day give her some time :)
labeti25 I don't wanna be hard on her at all. But if you still wanna preserve a bit your voice, then do the song when you're ready to sing it live, cause we all know she could easily NAIL it 100% live, she's The Songbird Supreme!!!
yes and i agree with you babe BUT do you really believe that the music intustry is giving her that time?????those phyco people started a war with her defenently the last 3 or 4 years....and the media are kissing their asses if you paid attension...the people stoped them a little bit and they start a little bit to say one good word...but other than that they just wait for one little mistake from her to her down...the nye perfomance it wans't ONLY from stella..."they set her up"literally...that's why mariah post her message on instagram...because she got the message....and that's why she changed her vegas show...
labeti25 Of course, I always thought that performance got sabotaged, never thought it was Mariah's fault. I'm just saying... if they bash you for lipping... lip only the high notes, do everything you can do live, and this song is one of the easiest songs for her, since her tone matured. For example I'm ok with the fact that she lips WBT's climax, Shake It Off's last part, Can't Take That Away last belts... but I Still Believe... come on... just no, especially since it's a fan favourite and one of the most requested songs.
She isn’t saving her voice... it’s getting better as the dates go... but this song.. she could have sang those belts...
I was gonna say that she sounds incredible...but then I saw the comments
I can hear her (just a little) singing along with the track. At least she didn't lip the part 3:32 onwards
I sometimes wonder people in the audience are thinking when she lips like that? 🤔
Briar Foskey yeah you see nobody screamed when she hit those higher notes... cuz we know damn well she wasn’t singing.
Dwight Lavon and notice how literally half the audience was applauding at the end
Briar Foskey i was there and very excited when this song started but once the first line came out i knew. but i will say, the vocals she pulled out during the whole performance excused it for me, personally, this was an amazing show. sad that can’t take that away was cut for it though.
Well considering they are her fans and they know what to expect from her, they don't care. 😉
She sang this live in 2912. Her voice now is in much better condition now than it was back then. I have a feeling she and the entire band wasn't able to rehearse this song that's why it was totally lipped.
sherwin76502 Her voice was a lot better in 2012. One of her peaks this decade, aside from Beacon 2014.
She’s clearly fully aware that she knows we can tell she’s miming. But hey, for the nostalgia i guess it dont matter as we would only be disappointed-if she did it live lets be honest. She’s just doing it for the lambs
she’s used every song that she used on the poll except Mine Again and Underneath The Stars 😭😭✨🦋
yoitscris you know damn well she can’t sing mine again live.... she can do underneath the stars though... but mine again.... y’all crazy. 😂❤️
Love you, my fellow lambily 💋
She can sing .100.%
People here be complaining about her lip-syncing to one song when she slayed the other songs live on the same night. People need to remember that other singers do it too, even more often than she does.
So what's your point in bringing her name here? Don't be actin' like Mariah is the only one who does it.
It's not like she lip-synced the whole concert. She only lip-synced to this song. And yes, call me crazy if it will make you happy but I'm still going to see her even if she lip-sync the whole concert. You know why? I love her so much. Her music helped me get through the darkest days of my life. Plus, she is a legend who had proven herself as one of the greatest singers to grace the world. She doesn't need to prove herself to anyone anymore. So if I were you, I'll just go support my favorite artist instead of posting hate comments on somebody you don't like. God bless.
I’m surprised she lipped this, because I remember her attempting it live in Morocco. I’m sure she would’ve done a much better job.
Welp.
We’ll see how it goes for future dates.
Macau* wasn’t it
live! at the end :)
My thing is these are the records that we wait for u to perform it least lip sing to a live audio version mimi
I believe she could of sang it live because the last two seconds where she actually sang sounds good...she probably needed to rest her voice some which is totally understandable she has been working really hard to prove herself and she has had some great live vocal moments...so lambs we have to be a little more understanding and we need to keep encouraging her she is slowly gaing her confidence back shes got enough haters...she doesn't need us bashing her too
I was at this show, and I was so excited when she said her next song was I Still Believe, but then when I heard the original studio recording I was severely disappointed (although I was in the front section and she is hiding her lipping really well these days). ISB is one of my favorite songs and I was so happy when it won the poll, but I MUCH would have preferred to hear her sing CTTA. Still, I'd say aside from this song 90% of the night was sung live and she sounded amazing.
IDC IF SHE'S LIPPING THIS BUT IS THIS A CLIP FROM THE 90s? SHE LOOKS LIKE BUTTERFLY ERARIAH HERE WOW
I know most of you fans are disappointed. But remember she can only do so much as a singer. Lip syncing has existed for many years now and for sure I do agree with people that should of at least lowered the key but also she is living with vocal nodules when she was born. The voice can only do so much and you guys should realize that she is not a robot. She has only done 4 and she will probably do it live on a later show.
Raymond Salgado then don’t sing it then! If she gets tired then space the shows out! Don’t ask a shit ton of money from us then mime along to the original track! Disappointed
Sarah is absolutely right.
I don’t have a problem with it, but I wish she would own it. She used to say she would never lip sync. And now that she does, she won’t be honest about it. We know how hard it is to sing vocally demanding songs. I think it would be better to partially lip all the songs rather than lipping the entirety of two songs.