I think regional reservation would not fall in the category of vertical reservation. As explained, vertical reservation is always of the social backwardness. Categories like scheduled castes, schedule tribes, VJs, NTs OBCs etc. fall in vertical reservation.
My Name is Ravi Mandaliya. Sir, i have understood difference between rule and notice. This order for exanple states that- Learned APP WAIVES service of notice for and on behalf of the Respondent state. Means notice to be served on respondent state before admission stage. But my question is what is WAIVES OR WAIVER ? in Gujarat high court they used the term waives frequently... Thank you so much.
Sir Unreverved category post 39, and 1 for Exserviceman ( UR) . if No ex serviceman categories suitable candidates are available . then employer can recruit U.R category 39 person , means without exserviceman , eaither 38 person and 1 ex serviceman due to non availability of candidates to carried forward. Which process is correct ? Please telling ...
When women, ex-servicemen, and PH, all three are available as horizontal reservation, whether the gender of PH and ex-serviceman is considered while calculating the number of women in that category or not?
@@LegalInspiration to phir ye to general female ke sath sarasar anyay hain... general women ko bhi koi reservation hota hi nahi... aaj se please aisa kahe ki reservation to women is equals to reservation to st sc obc ews women only... In this country supreme court ne maan liya hain ki general women ab saksham ho gayi to unhe koi reservation nahi diya jaye..
Not easily. Every department has a process for doing so. Generally such things are not done, and if at all it is done, it is done only in accordance with the rules applicable for it.
@@LegalInspiration agar open category ke ex serviceman ki seat 10 hai bt total 5 candidate hi ex serviceman ke mile to vo 5 seat Ur(open) me add hoga...to 5 log AUR select ho sake merit k basic pe
Ola sir ne Khali amaj puchvu hatu ke phw matlab ke handicapped category ne sheet Jo genral sheet ma reservation reti hoy but koi pan handicapped category vadu candidate j na hoy to su a genrla sheet Khali Rai ke pachi koi pan normal person ne a sheet madi jai
Sir, my wife was selected in Rajasthan Police Recruitment 2019, but due to being pregnet at the time of physical test, filed a petition in the High Court and the High Court issued an order to keep a post vacant and the final hearing has not yet taken place, yet the police department appointed my wife after about 20 months after getting her physical test done. Sir, will no pay no work rule be applicable on my wife or not, will she get the benefits of other benefits.......?
Thank you Mr. Suraj Meena for reaching out to me with your question. As a practicing lawyer, I understand how important it is to have accurate and reliable legal advice when dealing with complex legal matters. While I appreciate your interest in seeking my advice, I would like to respectfully suggest that you direct your questions to your own legal counsel. They are in the best position to provide you with tailored advice based on the specific facts and circumstances of your case. Your own lawyer has a detailed understanding of your situation and is familiar with the relevant laws and regulations that apply to your case. This makes them the most qualified person to provide you with legal advice and guidance. Once again, I appreciate your interest in seeking my advice, and I wish you all the best with your legal matter. Thank you for your understanding.
Sir I am from AP. From two years I am fighting with encroachments on government land .Iam gathering information from RTI. Iam sixty years lady. In respect iam facing threatenings in that time my husband died in accident. So i filed NHRC complaint.in the enquiry DSP sir given a report abusing me with lot of words. Iam making several complaints and using RTI as a weapon .Only my obligation is why the employees do their work. I write a letter to CJ of High court . Recently from the High court i received a letter to the collector enquiry the matter and give report to the court. But one month gone the collector did not respond. I want you to answer my question sir ,what i do sir? Please answer me sir .
Hello Radha, I am sorry to hear about the difficulties you have been facing for the past two years in fighting encroachments on government land. It is commendable that you have been using the RTI as a tool to gather information and bring attention to this issue. I am deeply saddened to hear about the threatening situations you have been facing and the loss of your husband. It is unacceptable that you were abused by the DSP sir during the enquiry, and I can understand your frustration with the lack of action from the employees despite your efforts. I appreciate that you have taken the initiative to write to the CJ of the High Court and that the court has directed the collector to investigate the matter and provide a report. It is concerning that a month has passed, and there has been no response from the collector. As a legal expert, I understand that you have already engaged lawyers to help you with this matter, and therefore, I cannot provide any legal advice. However, I would like to offer my support and encouragement to you during this challenging time. Please continue to persevere in your fight for justice, and I hope that the collector will respond to the court's directive soon. Do not hesitate to reach out if there is anything else I can do to assist you. Adv. Nahush Khubalkar
@@LegalInspiration sir idid not take any help from lawyers. Iam a convent social teacher. So iam fighting with the employees with my knowledge. Iam very much thanks for your reply.once again thanks i didn't take any lawyer's advice .i buy a book from AMAZON about legal advice because iam very much interest about the subject 'LAW' Thankyou once again sir
I think yes. mujhe lagata hai ki haan. agar mahila opan category se sambandhit hai to haan vah doosare raajy mein bhee opan category mein horizontal aarakshan ka daava kar sakatee hai. lekin agar mahila aarakshit shrenee se sambandhit hai aur us vertical aarakshan ke bheetar horizontal aarakshan ka daava kar rahee hai, to yah us jaati shrenee ke sambandh mein laagoo niyamon par nirbhar karega. yah saamaany maargadarshan hai krpaya ise kaanoonee salaah ke roop mein NAHI len.
Thank you very much for making a video on this complicated topic Sir, on the coming videos on this topic plz explained the difference between compartment-wise and overall horizontal reservation also.
@@LegalInspiration सर एक डाउट दूर करें जैसे किसी महिला का ईडब्ल्यूएस प्रमाण पत्र अवैध है और उसने ईडब्ल्यूएस श्रेणी से आवेदन किया था एवं उसका सिलेक्शन सिलेक्शन ईडब्ल्यूएस महिला कैटेगरी में हुआ है और उसके मार्क्स जनरल महिला कैटेगरी से अधिक हैं तो उसका सलेक्शन जनरल महिला श्रेणी में होगा या उसे अमान्य ईडब्ल्यूएस के कारण चयन प्रक्रिया से बाहर कर देंगे
Sir agar vacancies 1 0r 2 rahetho Vertical reservations se woh 2 bhi women hoga Ab horizontal apply karetho who vacants..women hoge or general hoge...pls reply me sir🙏
Sir what is the rules to go in gen catagory for other categories if any reservation catagory have 00 posts and 00 पोस्ट वाले कैटेगरी के कैंडिडेट ने age relaxation लिया है
Sir My name is Ravi Mandaliya.. My question are how to find judgement? So many books are there.. is it necessary that judgement that we found has to be similar to our present case? How many legal search engines are there? Do we need to read all ebc and air books? Thank you sir..
Is dual reservation(ST+PWD) is allowed in government job and banking job? if yes so in which job had allowed dual reservation ? Will have to used only one reservation for government job?
Sir jaisa ki apne bataya total women ki seat 11 hai aur obc k liye 2 lekin obc ki total seat 7 hai aur in 11 eligible women me 7 obc se ho th kya aisa ho sakta hai ki 7 obc post women ko diya jaye ...... women ko extra reservation pr focus krte hue ....women ko badhawa dene k liye ...aisa krna law k anusar shi ho sakta hai...sir plzzz reply
Agar kisi RTI me reply aya hai ki general female post= 0 hai par department ne 1 post par general female candidate ko select kiya hai jo ki ST catagory se hai requirement me total 4 post thi general catagory se mere mark us female candidate se jyada hai agar RTI me jawab diya hai general female ki post nhi thi phir select kese kiya or wo bhi St catagory ki female ko 🙏🙏
Hello sir, My issue is gujarat government exam merit problem , my merit high 73.25 or general merit 70.75 or sc merit 74.75 pirbhi mera selection nahi hu kyu ray de saktehe sir
Sir agar koi Ex serviceman ya PWBD category me se candidate he nahi hai, to UR me se unke lie kitne vacancies vacant rhenge and carry forward honge agle saal k lie??
If out of 7 seats 2 are reserved for SC then can sc candidates compete on the rest seats also like on general category seat ? Same for women ..if women got 33 reservation and she's SC so she'll be competing on SC women seat+ SC seat for all + general category seat ?
Sir, maze suspension 27/05/2019 la zale... Mazywar F. I. R zalela nahi.. Z. P. Chief executive officer yani mala suspend kalypasun 05/10/2019 Shocous notice tayyari keli.. Ani 13/11/2019 la send keli speed postane pan mi received keli nahi... Supreme Court judgment ajay kumar chudari v Union of india 16/02/2015. Ani G. R. 09/07/2019 tyni committee cha review 17/12/2019 la ghetala.. Ani aktarfi vibhageeya chukashi keli.. So.. Supreme Court judgment civil matter madhe lagu hot nahi ka? Maze suspension radda honar ka? Plez replay dy sir..
सुप्रीम कोर्ट जजमेंट तुमच्या केसला लागू होईल असे वाटते. परंतु तुमच्या प्रश्नातील माहितीप्रमाणे तुमच्या विरुद्ध विभागीय चौकशी झालेली आहे. त्यामध्ये तुमच्या विरुद्ध शिक्षा झाली का काय ते स्पष्ट होत नाही. तुमचा प्रश्न माझ्यापर्यंत पोहोचवल्याबद्दल धन्यवाद. तथापि, एक वकील म्हणून, मी सर्व संबंधित तथ्ये आणि परिस्थितींवर आधारित अचूक आणि योग्य सल्ला देतो याची खात्री करणे समाविष्ट आहे. या व्यासपीठाचे मर्यादित स्वरूप लक्षात घेता, अधिक माहितीशिवाय तुमच्या प्रश्नाचे पूर्ण उत्तर देणे मला शक्य होणार नाही. यामुळे होणाऱ्या कोणत्याही गैरसोयीबद्दल मी दिलगीर आहोत आणि मी सुचवू इच्छितो की तुम्ही कृपया तुमच्या पसंतीच्या वकिलाचा सल्ला घ्या. जर तुम्हाला माझा सल्ला घ्यायचा असेल तर तुम्ही तुमच्या प्रश्नावर अधिक तपशीलवार चर्चा करण्यासाठी माझ्याशी सल्लामसलत शेड्यूल करू शकता. तुम्ही माझ्या nahushkhubalkar.mojo.page/legalconsultation या वेबसाइटला भेट देऊन सल्लामसलत शेड्यूल करू शकता. तुमच्या समजून घेण्याच्या सहकार्याबद्दल धन्यवाद 🙏🏼
Respected sir, mi party in person case chalvty highcourt aurangabad la wp/7131/2019 sadhy matter due admission la ahe ani division bench la chalu ahe... Mala khup details madhe bolycha ahe.. Aapn mala reply dila tybaddal mi khu aabhari ahe.. Sir plez mala help kara.. tumala ligalconsultation. Page open karnycha try karty.. Pan mi tumala maza case no. Send karty...
Sir my female friend apply for sgpgi Lucknow for addmission there are 8 posts 4 UR 4 reserved 20% female quota in up every clg but they select 8 male candidates what should I do please guide sir 🙏🙏
Hello sir, mra ek doubt hein. Mene ek interview Diya tha usme 1 seat thi bs EWS ki. Sirf m hi gya tha dene k liye EWS se interview. And ek aur bnda gya tha..OH horizontal reservation se usne EWS m apply. Kiya tha..uske marks mgse to bhut Kam the.to ab kya wo meri seat le ja skta h kya?
Sr agr district level ki recruitment ho aur sc usme exception ho. Aur ek exserviceman sc ho. ...to kya vo dusri distt. ..mai apply krke double qouta benefit le skta hai ?? Plzzz. .muge clarify kre Sr its request..
30% reservation for women would depend upon the policy of the employer applicable to that particular recruitment. Generally such reservation is provided, and it is called horizontal reservation. As to your next question, the answer is yes. The women in other categories like other reserved categories can certainly claim a post or seat reserved for open female category on the basis of her own merit. This means that if she is more meritorious than the general category women who find place in the seats meant for open general category women, then even a reserved category woman who is more meritorious has a claim to a seat meant for open female category. This is because the law has clarified that open category means it covers within its sweep every type of candidate, in this case every type of woman candidate, irrespective of her social reservation.
सर हमारा अभी पुलिस का रिजल्ट आया उसमे 445 कुल पद थे। महिलाओं के लिए 133 पोस्ट थी और पुरुष 312 थी। लेकिन जब रिजल्ट आया तो 321 महिलाओं को लिया और 124 पुरुष । जबकि शारीरिक दक्षता के मानक दोनो के अलग होते है। क्या ऐसा हो सकता है???
This country has zero scope for improvements if reservation policies are not brought under control . This video is a shocking reveal in depth of the issue . And then people complain govt. servants don't do their job ? Why? coz it's filled with incompetent people gertting jobs through reservation !! Anyway ! It's a good video for understanding the difference b/w vertical and horizontal ! Thanks !
My name is Atul Tiwari Question - recommend good commentary on IPC, CRPC, and Evidence act and on all other criminal legislation which you think is very important for a fresh Criminal lawyer l. Thank you
Sir, aaj Junior Court Assistant exam ka result aaya mujhe usme typing ke behalf pe disqualify kiya hua h, mene typing test ke baad recheck kiya tha matter meri sirf 1 typing error thi (3% error allowed thi isme ) aur result me 80% error dikha raha h meri jabki technically mere 1% error bhi nhi h. Plz mujhe guide kijiye ki me kaha appeal karu aur kaise iss problem ko deal karu
If there is no post for disabled Candidate but he belongs to OBC category. Can he apply from OBC category mentioning his disability & will he be considered for OBC (general) & open (general)?
Though he is disabled still there is no restriction on claiming reservation benefits just like any other candidates, even if he mentions his disability.
If you are seeking legal advice and guidance, you may find it helpful to visit nahushkhubalkar.mojo.page/legalconsultation. This webpage offers consultation services that you may find useful in addressing your legal concerns. Please note that visiting the webpage does not imply a solicitation or retention of legal services, but rather is simply a resource that may be of assistance to you.
Sir agar horizontal reservation ki sheet for example girls ki minimum qualifying mark na pane ki wajah se khali reh jati h toh vo usi category ke boys se fill kr li jayengi ya khali jayengi. Sir plz... reply to me🙏🙏🙏
जी हां। ओपन जनरल कैटेगरी के पोस्ट पर कोई भी टाइप का कैंडिडेट अपने मेरिट के बलबूते पर स्थान पा सकता है। ओपन जनरल कैटेगरी का मतलब है कि इसमें सभी टाइप के कैटेगरी के लोग आ सकते हैं वह चाहे बैकवर्ड क्लास कैंडिडेट हो या महिला हो या प्रोजेक्ट अफेक्टेड पर्सन हो कोई भी कोई भी। अगर उस कैंडिडेट में ओपन जनरल कैटेगरी के कैंडिडेट्स के साथ अपने गुणवत्ता के आधार पर कंपीट करने की क्षमता है तो वह जरूर वहां स्थान पा सकते हैं। और पुरुष के लिए रिजर्वड कैटेगरी ऐसी कोई चीज नहीं होती। वह कैटेगरी ओपन जनरल ऐसी ही होती है और जैसे कि मैंने बताया इसमें किसी भी टाइप का कैंडिडेट गुणवत्ता के आधार पर बैठ सकता है। इसलिए इस भ्रम में ना रहे कि पुरुषों के लिए कोई रिजर्वड कैटेगरी होती है। हां महिलाओं की रिजर्वड कैटेगरी होती है और उसमें महिलाओं के अलावा और कोई आ नहीं सकता मतलब कि पुरुष बैठ नहीं सकते। तो आपके सवाल का जवाब है कि जी हां महिलाएं ओपन जनरल कैटेगरी में यानी कि जिसमें पुरुष और स्त्रियां दोनों शामिल है उसके स्थान पा सकती हैं।
जब सिलेक्ट लिस्ट बनती है उस वक्त सिलेक्ट लिस्ट मैं, रिक्रूटर की ही कानूनी तौर पर जिम्मेदारी होती है कि वह गुणवत्ता के आधार पर यानी कि मेरिट के बेसिस पर पहले ओपन जनरल कैटेगरी में मेरीटोरियस कैंडिडेट्स को, भले ही वह किसी भी कास्ट को बिलौंग करें या ओपन कैटेगरी का हो, उनका समावेश करना पड़ता है। तो भले ही कंपिटीटिव्ह एग्जामिनेशन पहले हो चुकी हो, मेरे ख्याल से सभी कैटेगरी के अंतिम परिणाम आने के बाद सिलेक्ट लिस्ट बनेगी, भले ही रिजर्व कैटेगरी का अंतिम परिणाम पहले आए और जनरल कैटेगरी का बाद में आए इससे कुछ फर्क नहीं पड़ता। जब सिलेक्ट लिस्ट बनेगी तब यह सब बातें देखी जाएगी, या कह सकते हैं देखी जाना अपेक्षित है।
Sir, I have a doubt regarding this horizontal reservation ( Is it horizontal reservation is representation of sub categories or its a definite reservation?) Lets take an example, Suppose in a recruitment there are 33 seats, out of which 9 seats (27% of 33) for women, 2 seats (6% of 33) for EX-Army, 2 seats (6% of 33) are considered. Female, EX-Army, PH are horizontal reservation. Now if suppose the gender of EX-Army and PH is also Female, then in that case total female in that category becomes 9+2+2=13. I agree that number of females can exceed the number 9 as stated but that has to be based on merit basis but here the female number is exceeding the limit using the reservation, and it is effecting the male candidates who have secured better marks. So my question is whether the horizontal reservation is representation of female or a definite reservation under the category. By saying representation I am saying that as in the above case, if 9 females has to be selected , then can we say that out of 33 seats, 5 seats goes to female + 2 seats to EXarmy Female + 2 seats to PH Female = 9 Seats reperestation of female in that category. In case of definite reservation, we have 9 seats of Female + 2 seats of Female EXARMY + 2 Seats of Female PH = 13 Seats representation of female out 33 seats,, which exceeds the 27% reservations limit based on reservation. So, is it not not appropriate to count the representation of female in that category as compared to definite reservation. According to Justice S. Ravindra Bhat Horizontal reservations on the other hand, by their nature, Justice Bhat clarified, are not inviolate pools or carved in stone. They are premised on their overlaps and are ‘interlocking’ reservations. They cannot be carried forward. In the above statement of Justice S. Ravindra Bhat, does the overlaps and interlocking means the same thing or is he saying that one has to count the representation not the actual seats
Hello sir..maine jharkhand judiciary ka exam diya tha. jisme category m bc2 dala tha but jharkhand judiciary k form m ak alg se column tha jisme pucha gya tha do u want to cliam vertical/horizontal reservation and maine by mistake usme no krdiya. Jb result aai to mera cutoff se lgbhg double marks aae h but mera roll no nhi tha. Bohot der bad mujhe ye cliam wala prblm smjh m aaya.. Kya mujhe high court m writ dalni chahiy?
Ek Bar form mein "no" bharane ke bad, aur uske natije bahar aane ke bad ab yah Karan dekar ki aapane galti se "no" bhara tha, writ petition mein kuchh hoga yah difficult lagta hai. Writ jurisdiction candidate ne ki Hui galtiyon ko sudhar kar fir mauka dene ke liye exercise nahin kiya jata. Uss galti ki jimmevari aapko leni hogi. Ab yah kahkar ki aapane galti se "no" likh diya, shayad hi aapko relief milega. Vah baat alag Rahi hoti agar aapka "no" likhna yah recruiter ke galti se hua hota. Per Aisa aapka kahana nahin hai. Isliye mere opinion mein aapke successful hone ke chances kam hai. Per fir bhi kyunki maine aapke sath detail me discuss nahin kiya hai, aur case papers vagaira nahin dekhe Hain, Jo kuchh maine yahan kaha use meri legal advice Na Mane. Aapke case ke legal advise aap apne level per aapke pasand ke vakil se mile, aur uske bad hi jo kuchh karna hai vah nirnay lein.
@@LegalInspiration Lekin sir dusre stae ki mhila hai to kis me count hogi ur male ya ur female es bat ko lekar bhut confuse krte hai log kyoki bihar me horizontal lagu hai female ko 35 fisdi diya gya pr dusre stete ki mhila ko kis me Kyu male female ki cut of me 8 number tk ka different rhta hai
Good explanation. I understand very easily .Thank you sir
Nice information
Please tell me sir🙏
Regional special reservetion treat as horizontal or vartical ??? Verdicts??
I think regional reservation would not fall in the category of vertical reservation. As explained, vertical reservation is always of the social backwardness. Categories like scheduled castes, schedule tribes, VJs, NTs OBCs etc. fall in vertical reservation.
Thank you so much sir. Very useful and well explained.
You are most welcome
Sir horizontal reservation other state ki female ko bhi milta h?@@LegalInspiration
Waiting for next video sir
Don't worry
Sir if a horizontal reservation candidate achieve more marks than vertical students then in which category they counted vertical or horizontal
Thank you sir❤😍🙏
My Name is Ravi Mandaliya.
Sir, i have understood difference between rule and notice. This order for exanple states that-
Learned APP WAIVES service of notice for and on behalf of the Respondent state.
Means notice to be served on respondent state before admission stage. But my question is what is WAIVES OR WAIVER ? in Gujarat high court they used the term waives frequently...
Thank you so much.
thanks sir.very nicely explained .
Most welcome
Sir plz explain the reservation provision for disabled person and ex-army man on direct recruitment and promotion applied on roster system...
Sir Unreverved category post 39, and 1 for Exserviceman ( UR) . if No ex serviceman categories suitable candidates are available . then employer can recruit U.R category 39 person , means without exserviceman ,
eaither 38 person and 1 ex serviceman due to non availability of candidates to carried forward. Which process is correct ? Please telling ...
Sir mere bhi yhi case ban rha h kya hua appko isme seat mili yh nhi UR category m ??
@@Manik91Bhowmik sir iska answer mila ho to reply dena
kuch puchna hai aapse about reservation uncertainty in a exam where I may
When women, ex-servicemen, and PH, all three are available as horizontal reservation, whether the gender of PH and ex-serviceman is considered while calculating the number of women in that category or not?
Yes. If the horizontal reservation is for women within such categories, then the gender is of course taken into account.
@@LegalInspiration How to contact you for consultancy?
@@LegalInspiration Yes sir, what about gender of Ex-servicemen and PH to count the number of women against women quota.
Nicely explained.
Very nice information sir
Ure voice s too good sir...
Well explained. Thank you very much. Please mention the citations in description for convenience of viewers.
Yes I will, in the forthcoming videos.
Gen female ke liye bhi reservation hai ya fir gen female me sabhi category ki female aati hai
जनरल फीमेल यानी कि ओपन जनरल फीमेल इनके अंदर सभी कैटेगरी के फीमेल उनके गुणवत्ता के आधार पर आ सकते हैं यह बात कानूनन बिल्कुल स्पष्ट है।
@@LegalInspiration to phir ye to general female ke sath sarasar anyay hain... general women ko bhi koi reservation hota hi nahi... aaj se please aisa kahe ki reservation to women is equals to reservation to st sc obc ews women only... In this country supreme court ne maan liya hain ki general women ab saksham ho gayi to unhe koi reservation nahi diya jaye..
hello sir, agar seat reserved hai or other category ke right candidate available hh , to seat general m aad nhi ho sakti hai kya
Not easily. Every department has a process for doing so. Generally such things are not done, and if at all it is done, it is done only in accordance with the rules applicable for it.
@@LegalInspiration agar open category ke ex serviceman ki seat 10 hai bt total 5 candidate hi ex serviceman ke mile to vo 5 seat Ur(open) me add hoga...to 5 log AUR select ho sake merit k basic pe
Sir kya horizontal reservation fixed proportional me diya jana chahiye.... according to law
Ola sir ne Khali amaj puchvu hatu ke phw matlab ke handicapped category ne sheet Jo genral sheet ma reservation reti hoy but koi pan handicapped category vadu candidate j na hoy to su a genrla sheet Khali Rai ke pachi koi pan normal person ne a sheet madi jai
Sir horigontal reservation (female) post carry forward hota hai ki nh pls reply??
Excellent explanation
Horizontal reservation me jo jis category me hai usme hi select hoga kya Sir
Sir ,kya reservation pre exam me bhi follow hota hai ? Ya only mains exam ke baad hi ye rule laagu hota hai ?
sir what happen to ex army seats if some of them are left unfilled...?
does commercial courts Act provide for Summary Suit like order 37? If yes what is the provision?
Sir, my wife was selected in Rajasthan Police Recruitment 2019, but due to being pregnet at the time of physical test, filed a petition in the High Court and the High Court issued an order to keep a post vacant and the final hearing has not yet taken place, yet the police department appointed my wife after about 20 months after getting her physical test done. Sir, will no pay no work rule be applicable on my wife or not, will she get the benefits of other benefits.......?
Thank you Mr. Suraj Meena for reaching out to me with your question. As a practicing lawyer, I understand how important it is to have accurate and reliable legal advice when dealing with complex legal matters.
While I appreciate your interest in seeking my advice, I would like to respectfully suggest that you direct your questions to your own legal counsel. They are in the best position to provide you with tailored advice based on the specific facts and circumstances of your case.
Your own lawyer has a detailed understanding of your situation and is familiar with the relevant laws and regulations that apply to your case. This makes them the most qualified person to provide you with legal advice and guidance.
Once again, I appreciate your interest in seeking my advice, and I wish you all the best with your legal matter. Thank you for your understanding.
Sir I am from AP. From two years I am fighting with encroachments on government land .Iam gathering information from RTI. Iam sixty years lady. In respect iam facing threatenings in that time my husband died in accident. So i filed NHRC complaint.in the enquiry DSP sir given a report abusing me with lot of words. Iam making several complaints and using RTI as a weapon .Only my obligation is why the employees do their work. I write a letter to CJ of High court . Recently from the High court i received a letter to the collector enquiry the matter and give report to the court. But one month gone the collector did not respond. I want you to answer my question sir ,what i do sir? Please answer me sir .
Hello Radha,
I am sorry to hear about the difficulties you have been facing for the past two years in fighting encroachments on government land. It is commendable that you have been using the RTI as a tool to gather information and bring attention to this issue.
I am deeply saddened to hear about the threatening situations you have been facing and the loss of your husband. It is unacceptable that you were abused by the DSP sir during the enquiry, and I can understand your frustration with the lack of action from the employees despite your efforts.
I appreciate that you have taken the initiative to write to the CJ of the High Court and that the court has directed the collector to investigate the matter and provide a report. It is concerning that a month has passed, and there has been no response from the collector.
As a legal expert, I understand that you have already engaged lawyers to help you with this matter, and therefore, I cannot provide any legal advice. However, I would like to offer my support and encouragement to you during this challenging time.
Please continue to persevere in your fight for justice, and I hope that the collector will respond to the court's directive soon. Do not hesitate to reach out if there is anything else I can do to assist you.
Adv. Nahush Khubalkar
@@LegalInspiration sir idid not take any help from lawyers. Iam a convent social teacher. So iam fighting with the employees with my knowledge. Iam very much thanks for your reply.once again thanks i didn't take any lawyer's advice .i buy a book from AMAZON about legal advice because iam very much interest about the subject 'LAW' Thankyou once again sir
Sir horizontal reservation other state ki female ko bhi milta h ??
I think yes. mujhe lagata hai ki haan. agar mahila opan category se sambandhit hai to haan vah doosare raajy mein bhee opan category mein horizontal aarakshan ka daava kar sakatee hai. lekin agar mahila aarakshit shrenee se sambandhit hai aur us vertical aarakshan ke bheetar horizontal aarakshan ka daava kar rahee hai, to yah us jaati shrenee ke sambandh mein laagoo niyamon par nirbhar karega. yah saamaany maargadarshan hai krpaya ise kaanoonee salaah ke roop mein NAHI len.
@@LegalInspiration thnk u so much sir
@@LegalInspiration samny mahila me kar skte h na sir
Thank you very much for making a video on this complicated topic Sir, on the coming videos on this topic plz explained the difference between compartment-wise and overall horizontal reservation also.
Sure I will
@@LegalInspiration सर एक डाउट दूर करें जैसे किसी महिला का ईडब्ल्यूएस प्रमाण पत्र अवैध है और उसने ईडब्ल्यूएस श्रेणी से आवेदन किया था एवं उसका सिलेक्शन सिलेक्शन ईडब्ल्यूएस महिला कैटेगरी में हुआ है और उसके मार्क्स जनरल महिला कैटेगरी से अधिक हैं तो उसका सलेक्शन जनरल महिला श्रेणी में होगा या उसे अमान्य ईडब्ल्यूएस के कारण चयन प्रक्रिया से बाहर कर देंगे
Sir agar vacancies 1 0r 2 rahetho
Vertical reservations se woh 2 bhi women hoga
Ab horizontal apply karetho who vacants..women hoge or general hoge...pls reply me sir🙏
Sc ph quota k students ko general ph quota ki seat mil sakti hai on the basis of marks??
Sir what is the rules to go in gen catagory for other categories if any reservation catagory have 00 posts and 00 पोस्ट वाले कैटेगरी के कैंडिडेट ने age relaxation लिया है
Uske andar low vision ki seat hi nahi di sir mujhe kya karna chahea sir koi suggest kare pls
Sir My name is Ravi Mandaliya..
My question are how to find judgement? So many books are there.. is it necessary that judgement that we found has to be similar to our present case? How many legal search engines are there? Do we need to read all ebc and air books?
Thank you sir..
nice sir, helpful
Thanks and welcome
Is dual reservation(ST+PWD) is allowed in government job and banking job? if yes so in which job had allowed dual reservation ? Will have to used only one reservation for government job?
Sir jaisa ki apne bataya total women ki seat 11 hai aur obc k liye 2 lekin obc ki total seat 7 hai aur in 11 eligible women me 7 obc se ho th kya aisa ho sakta hai ki 7 obc post women ko diya jaye ...... women ko extra reservation pr focus krte hue ....women ko badhawa dene k liye ...aisa krna law k anusar shi ho sakta hai...sir plzzz reply
Best🎉🎉
Agar kisi RTI me reply aya hai ki general female post= 0 hai par department ne 1 post par general female candidate ko select kiya hai jo ki ST catagory se hai requirement me total 4 post thi general catagory se mere mark us female candidate se jyada hai agar RTI me jawab diya hai general female ki post nhi thi phir select kese kiya or wo bhi St catagory ki female ko 🙏🙏
Hello sir,
My issue is gujarat government exam merit problem , my merit high 73.25 or general merit 70.75 or sc merit 74.75 pirbhi mera selection nahi hu kyu ray de saktehe sir
Sir agar koi Ex serviceman ya PWBD category me se candidate he nahi hai, to UR me se unke lie kitne vacancies vacant rhenge and carry forward honge agle saal k lie??
Sir Ex army me agar kisi ne join kiya aur turant chod diya to kya wo age ane wali vaccicy ke liye eligible rahega ki nahi
If out of 7 seats 2 are reserved for SC then can sc candidates compete on the rest seats also like on general category seat ? Same for women ..if women got 33 reservation and she's SC so she'll be competing on SC women seat+ SC seat for all + general category seat ?
Sir, maze suspension 27/05/2019 la zale... Mazywar F. I. R zalela nahi.. Z. P. Chief executive officer yani mala suspend kalypasun 05/10/2019 Shocous notice tayyari keli.. Ani 13/11/2019 la send keli speed postane pan mi received keli nahi... Supreme Court judgment ajay kumar chudari v Union of india 16/02/2015. Ani G. R. 09/07/2019 tyni committee cha review 17/12/2019 la ghetala.. Ani aktarfi vibhageeya chukashi keli.. So.. Supreme Court judgment civil matter madhe lagu hot nahi ka? Maze suspension radda honar ka? Plez replay dy sir..
सुप्रीम कोर्ट जजमेंट तुमच्या केसला लागू होईल असे वाटते. परंतु तुमच्या प्रश्नातील माहितीप्रमाणे तुमच्या विरुद्ध विभागीय चौकशी झालेली आहे. त्यामध्ये तुमच्या विरुद्ध शिक्षा झाली का काय ते स्पष्ट होत नाही.
तुमचा प्रश्न माझ्यापर्यंत पोहोचवल्याबद्दल धन्यवाद. तथापि, एक वकील म्हणून, मी सर्व संबंधित तथ्ये आणि परिस्थितींवर आधारित अचूक आणि योग्य सल्ला देतो याची खात्री करणे समाविष्ट आहे.
या व्यासपीठाचे मर्यादित स्वरूप लक्षात घेता, अधिक माहितीशिवाय तुमच्या प्रश्नाचे पूर्ण उत्तर देणे मला शक्य होणार नाही.
यामुळे होणाऱ्या कोणत्याही गैरसोयीबद्दल मी दिलगीर आहोत आणि मी सुचवू इच्छितो की तुम्ही कृपया तुमच्या पसंतीच्या वकिलाचा सल्ला घ्या.
जर तुम्हाला माझा सल्ला घ्यायचा असेल तर तुम्ही तुमच्या प्रश्नावर अधिक तपशीलवार चर्चा करण्यासाठी माझ्याशी सल्लामसलत शेड्यूल करू शकता. तुम्ही माझ्या nahushkhubalkar.mojo.page/legalconsultation या वेबसाइटला भेट देऊन सल्लामसलत शेड्यूल करू शकता.
तुमच्या समजून घेण्याच्या सहकार्याबद्दल धन्यवाद 🙏🏼
Respected sir, mi party in person case chalvty highcourt aurangabad la wp/7131/2019 sadhy matter due admission la ahe ani division bench la chalu ahe... Mala khup details madhe bolycha ahe.. Aapn mala reply dila tybaddal mi khu aabhari ahe.. Sir plez mala help kara.. tumala ligalconsultation. Page open karnycha try karty.. Pan mi tumala maza case no. Send karty...
Sir plz btaiye kya grils ka no jada h to vh genral me seat le skti h kya
Sir my female friend apply for sgpgi Lucknow for addmission there are 8 posts 4 UR 4 reserved 20% female quota in up every clg but they select 8 male candidates what should I do please guide sir 🙏🙏
Sir please a video on service matter wording..l demotion, transfer, please explain some other words in use service matter which is causes of case
Hello sir, mra ek doubt hein.
Mene ek interview Diya tha usme 1 seat thi bs EWS ki.
Sirf m hi gya tha dene k liye EWS se interview. And ek aur bnda gya tha..OH horizontal reservation se usne EWS m apply. Kiya tha..uske marks mgse to bhut Kam the.to ab kya wo meri seat le ja skta h kya?
If OBC own merit seat is vacant so which category take this seat
Sr agr district level ki recruitment ho aur sc usme exception ho. Aur ek exserviceman sc ho. ...to kya vo dusri distt. ..mai apply krke double qouta benefit le skta hai ?? Plzzz. .muge clarify kre Sr its request..
dear sir
is there anyway to connect with you either on chat or mobile
Sir if a person has 40 marks Gen category and other has 30 in PWD GEN category will the pwd candidate get better seat?
Could SC employee (PWD) deserves to promote under pwds
Sir i want to know about 30%UR women reservation...is this for general women only??? Can women from other category take general category women seat?
30% reservation for women would depend upon the policy of the employer applicable to that particular recruitment. Generally such reservation is provided, and it is called horizontal reservation. As to your next question, the answer is yes. The women in other categories like other reserved categories can certainly claim a post or seat reserved for open female category on the basis of her own merit. This means that if she is more meritorious than the general category women who find place in the seats meant for open general category women, then even a reserved category woman who is more meritorious has a claim to a seat meant for open female category. This is because the law has clarified that open category means it covers within its sweep every type of candidate, in this case every type of woman candidate, irrespective of her social reservation.
@@LegalInspiration is this rule same for all states.
Sir kisi ko total vacancy ka 20% phr un sbko horizontal me distribution Krna shi h kya???
सर हमारा अभी पुलिस का रिजल्ट आया उसमे 445 कुल पद थे।
महिलाओं के लिए 133 पोस्ट थी और पुरुष 312 थी।
लेकिन जब रिजल्ट आया तो 321 महिलाओं को लिया और 124 पुरुष ।
जबकि शारीरिक दक्षता के मानक दोनो के अलग होते है।
क्या ऐसा हो सकता है???
This country has zero scope for improvements if reservation policies are not brought under control .
This video is a shocking reveal in depth of the issue .
And then people complain govt. servants don't do their job ?
Why? coz it's filled with incompetent people gertting jobs through reservation !!
Anyway ! It's a good video for understanding the difference b/w vertical and horizontal ! Thanks !
My name is Atul Tiwari
Question - recommend good commentary on IPC, CRPC, and Evidence act and on all other criminal legislation which you think is very important for a fresh Criminal lawyer l.
Thank you
Sir, aaj Junior Court Assistant exam ka result aaya mujhe usme typing ke behalf pe disqualify kiya hua h, mene typing test ke baad recheck kiya tha matter meri sirf 1 typing error thi (3% error allowed thi isme ) aur result me 80% error dikha raha h meri jabki technically mere 1% error bhi nhi h. Plz mujhe guide kijiye ki me kaha appeal karu aur kaise iss problem ko deal karu
M SC categrory k female hu to kya m horizontal reservation m sirf SC category m hi rahugi y mere marks high to UR female m count ho jaugi
Aap Open female category me ja sakti hai, on the basis of your own merit. If the rules do not prevent such migration then you can.
If there is no post for disabled Candidate but he belongs to OBC category. Can he apply from OBC category mentioning his disability & will he be considered for OBC (general) & open (general)?
Though he is disabled still there is no restriction on claiming reservation benefits just like any other candidates, even if he mentions his disability.
Sir good morning sir me bums(ayush) dr hu sir me low vision certificate rakhta hu par abhi ayurved ki post nikli u e
How to connect with U.
I have a legal matter for my service.
I want to appel in cat Mumbai.
I am from Pune.
If you are seeking legal advice and guidance, you may find it helpful to visit nahushkhubalkar.mojo.page/legalconsultation. This webpage offers consultation services that you may find useful in addressing your legal concerns. Please note that visiting the webpage does not imply a solicitation or retention of legal services, but rather is simply a resource that may be of assistance to you.
Explain EWS RESERVATION SIR
Ex servicemen horizontal hai ?
Yes
Horizontal aur vertical reservation me selected candidates ka seniority kaise nirdharit kiya jata hai
According to seniority rules applicable to rhe appointed candidates
क्या महिला उम्मीदवार पुरुष जनरल का कट ऑफ क्रॉस करती है तो क्या वह जनरल पुरुष कैटेगरी में आ सकती हैं
th-cam.com/video/remKTj_EXzo/w-d-xo.html यह वीडियो देख लीजिए
Sir agar horizontal reservation ki sheet for example girls ki minimum qualifying mark na pane ki wajah se khali reh jati h toh vo usi category ke boys se fill kr li jayengi ya khali jayengi.
Sir plz... reply to me🙏🙏🙏
सर क्या obc महिला obc पुरुष की सीट काट सकती है क्या?
जी हां। ओपन जनरल कैटेगरी के पोस्ट पर कोई भी टाइप का कैंडिडेट अपने मेरिट के बलबूते पर स्थान पा सकता है। ओपन जनरल कैटेगरी का मतलब है कि इसमें सभी टाइप के कैटेगरी के लोग आ सकते हैं वह चाहे बैकवर्ड क्लास कैंडिडेट हो या महिला हो या प्रोजेक्ट अफेक्टेड पर्सन हो कोई भी कोई भी। अगर उस कैंडिडेट में ओपन जनरल कैटेगरी के कैंडिडेट्स के साथ अपने गुणवत्ता के आधार पर कंपीट करने की क्षमता है तो वह जरूर वहां स्थान पा सकते हैं।
और पुरुष के लिए रिजर्वड कैटेगरी ऐसी कोई चीज नहीं होती। वह कैटेगरी ओपन जनरल ऐसी ही होती है और जैसे कि मैंने बताया इसमें किसी भी टाइप का कैंडिडेट गुणवत्ता के आधार पर बैठ सकता है। इसलिए इस भ्रम में ना रहे कि पुरुषों के लिए कोई रिजर्वड कैटेगरी होती है। हां महिलाओं की रिजर्वड कैटेगरी होती है और उसमें महिलाओं के अलावा और कोई आ नहीं सकता मतलब कि पुरुष बैठ नहीं सकते।
तो आपके सवाल का जवाब है कि जी हां महिलाएं ओपन जनरल कैटेगरी में यानी कि जिसमें पुरुष और स्त्रियां दोनों शामिल है उसके स्थान पा सकती हैं।
धन्यवाद गुरूजी
अगर रिजर्व कैटेगरी का अंतिम परिणाम पहले आ जाए और ओपन कैटेगरी का परिणाम नही आए तो रिजर्व कैटेगरी वाला कैंडिडेट ओपन कैटेगरी का लाभ कैसे उठा पाएगा सर 🙏
@@LegalInspiration sir general category me females k jo sits reserve hoti h un pr other category female ja skti h ???
अगर रिजर्व कैटेगरी का अंतिम परिणाम पहले आ जाए और ओपन कैटेगरी का परिणाम नही आए तो रिजर्व कैटेगरी वाला कैंडिडेट ओपन कैटेगरी का लाभ कैसे उठा पाएगा सर 🙏
सर प्लीज बताइए🙏🙏🙏
जब सिलेक्ट लिस्ट बनती है उस वक्त सिलेक्ट लिस्ट मैं, रिक्रूटर की ही कानूनी तौर पर जिम्मेदारी होती है कि वह गुणवत्ता के आधार पर यानी कि मेरिट के बेसिस पर पहले ओपन जनरल कैटेगरी में मेरीटोरियस कैंडिडेट्स को, भले ही वह किसी भी कास्ट को बिलौंग करें या ओपन कैटेगरी का हो, उनका समावेश करना पड़ता है। तो भले ही कंपिटीटिव्ह एग्जामिनेशन पहले हो चुकी हो, मेरे ख्याल से सभी कैटेगरी के अंतिम परिणाम आने के बाद सिलेक्ट लिस्ट बनेगी, भले ही रिजर्व कैटेगरी का अंतिम परिणाम पहले आए और जनरल कैटेगरी का बाद में आए इससे कुछ फर्क नहीं पड़ता। जब सिलेक्ट लिस्ट बनेगी तब यह सब बातें देखी जाएगी, या कह सकते हैं देखी जाना अपेक्षित है।
Thank you so much sir😊
I am Nibedita Dey from West Bengal
Hi
Sir, I have a doubt regarding this horizontal reservation ( Is it horizontal reservation is representation of sub categories or its a definite reservation?)
Lets take an example, Suppose in a recruitment there are 33 seats, out of which 9 seats (27% of 33) for women, 2 seats (6% of 33) for EX-Army, 2 seats (6% of 33) are considered. Female, EX-Army, PH are horizontal reservation. Now if suppose the gender of EX-Army and PH is also Female, then in that case total female in that category becomes 9+2+2=13. I agree that number of females can exceed the number 9 as stated but that has to be based on merit basis but here the female number is exceeding the limit using the reservation, and it is effecting the male candidates who have secured better marks. So my question is whether the horizontal reservation is representation of female or a definite reservation under the category. By saying representation I am saying that as in the above case, if 9 females has to be selected , then can we say that out of 33 seats, 5 seats goes to female + 2 seats to EXarmy Female + 2 seats to PH Female = 9 Seats reperestation of female in that category. In case of definite reservation, we have 9 seats of Female + 2 seats of Female EXARMY + 2 Seats of Female PH = 13 Seats representation of female out 33 seats,, which exceeds the 27% reservations limit based on reservation. So, is it not not appropriate to count the representation of female in that category as compared to definite reservation.
According to Justice S. Ravindra Bhat
Horizontal reservations on the other hand, by their nature, Justice Bhat clarified, are not inviolate pools or carved in stone. They are premised on their overlaps and are ‘interlocking’ reservations. They cannot be carried forward.
In the above statement of Justice S. Ravindra Bhat, does the overlaps and interlocking means the same thing or is he saying that one has to count the representation not the actual seats
"Case is called out". ka kya matlab kya hai sir ?
Good discussion .
Sir I want to talk with you on a matter. So, please share number
Hello sir..maine jharkhand judiciary ka exam diya tha. jisme category m bc2 dala tha but jharkhand judiciary k form m ak alg se column tha jisme pucha gya tha do u want to cliam vertical/horizontal reservation and maine by mistake usme no krdiya.
Jb result aai to mera cutoff se lgbhg double marks aae h but mera roll no nhi tha. Bohot der bad mujhe ye cliam wala prblm smjh m aaya..
Kya mujhe high court m writ dalni chahiy?
Ek Bar form mein "no" bharane ke bad, aur uske natije bahar aane ke bad ab yah Karan dekar ki aapane galti se "no" bhara tha, writ petition mein kuchh hoga yah difficult lagta hai. Writ jurisdiction candidate ne ki Hui galtiyon ko sudhar kar fir mauka dene ke liye exercise nahin kiya jata. Uss galti ki jimmevari aapko leni hogi. Ab yah kahkar ki aapane galti se "no" likh diya, shayad hi aapko relief milega.
Vah baat alag Rahi hoti agar aapka "no" likhna yah recruiter ke galti se hua hota. Per Aisa aapka kahana nahin hai. Isliye mere opinion mein aapke successful hone ke chances kam hai.
Per fir bhi kyunki maine aapke sath detail me discuss nahin kiya hai, aur case papers vagaira nahin dekhe Hain, Jo kuchh maine yahan kaha use meri legal advice Na Mane. Aapke case ke legal advise aap apne level per aapke pasand ke vakil se mile, aur uske bad hi jo kuchh karna hai vah nirnay lein.
@@LegalInspiration mujhe v yhi feel huwa sir thatsy maine plan drop krdiya....but ye reh reh k bht pareahan krrha h.
Thankyou for ur suggestion sir.
@@LegalInspiration Lekin sir dusre stae ki mhila hai to kis me count hogi ur male ya ur female es bat ko lekar bhut confuse krte hai log kyoki bihar me horizontal lagu hai female ko 35 fisdi diya gya pr dusre stete ki mhila ko kis me Kyu male female ki cut of me 8 number tk ka different rhta hai