ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 ก.พ. 2025
- Ayman Mohyeldin remembers his friend and colleague, Al Jazeera journalist Shireen Abu Akleh, who was killed today reporting on an Israeli military raid in the West Bank. “The killing of journalists, whether it’s in Mexico or Ukraine or the Occupied Palestinian Territories, that must be condemned and investigated - but not by the countries accused of allegedly killing them, but by independent bodies who claim to uphold free speech and the right to a free press as fundamental human rights.”
» Subscribe to MSNBC: on.msnbc.com/Su...
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, Meet the Press Daily, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House with Nicolle Wallace, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and more.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: on.msnbc.com/Re...
Subscribe to MSNBC Newsletter: link.msnbc.com/...
Find MSNBC on Facebook: on.msnbc.com/Li...
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: on.msnbc.com/Fo...
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: on.msnbc.com/In...
#MSNBC #ShireenAbuAkleh #Israel
![Why Are Palestinian Christians Leaving Jesus’ Birthplace? [Pt. 1]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pa6igKc1M9s/mqdefault.jpg)
Remember the death of Rachel Corrie, an American whose death was dismissed by the Israeli court as being solely her own fault. Added to that injustice, Israeli soldiers actually hosted a "Rachel Corrie Pancake breakfast," mocking the brave young woman. The only reason why such atrocities committed by Israel are dismissed is because of the unconditional support so lavishly showered upon Uncle Sam's little pet by the USA.
i remember her 💔💔💔 like yesterday
Don't forget USS Liberty
Exactly
I remember. The zionist terrorists need to be brought to account.
americans are paying their hard earned money as taxes to their government to help these nazis in is rail k**l other americans. Even youtube is helping in that by not letting us write the name of that nazi regime properly.
Ayman - thank you for this reporting - I am sorry for your personal loss as well as the loss to global journalism and this wonderful voice for the Palestinian people. You are literally the only US MSM source who has covered this story truthfully instead of trying to 'both sides' the issue. Rest in power Shireen xxx
I had the great pleasure of meeting Sherine twice in my career as a journalist. She was a genuinely nice and kind person. She was among the first female journalists to cover conflict zones for broadcast in the region and had an uncanny ability to pinpoint the story that should be told as opposed to the one everyone expects. She was fearless. God rest in her soul. Ayman, I’m genuinely sorry for your loss and thank you for giving others a glimpse of who she really was.
Americans don’t know how well respected Shireen was in the Middle East. Generations grew up watching her on TV. She was a role model and a brave woman who risked her life to deliver her sacred message as a journalist. I pray those who killed her be punished, and I pray that God grants Shireens would eternal peace. SHAME on Israel, and SHAME on the US
I have many Jewish friend , and I like them all
But mostly it’s not the people it’s the government that order the killing and making the policy even if we go back a few thousand year ago the king of Persia Cyrus allowed them to return to their promised land. The Jews praised the Persian emperor in scripture as a savior to whom God gave power over other kingdoms so that he would restore them to Jerusalem and allow them to rebuild their Temple.
But unfortunately the government of Israel is evil 👿 we as people of the world should all put stop in them since our government can’t and won’t do that , our government might act like they going say something time to time when there evil act come out in the news some how !!!
But they never can’t and would do anything to help the Palestinian people or any other people in the world that got destroyed because of the Israel evil government Politics , So it’s all up to each of us .
Remember this is the same government who help killing Jesus and even didn’t listen to a word of what God ( Jesus ) said, and they still are agents ✝️ christianity & Jesus even today between each other when they are alone they not respect Jesus and they don’t believe in who he is or what he said they even making fun of Jesus when they are together, believe me I know.
long with the sperite of Shireen
Dawn with the Israel government !
Antony Blinken is a Jew, Victoria Nuland is a Jew, Alejandro Mayorkas is a Jew , David Cohen is a Jew , Merrick Garland is a Jew , Avril Haines is a Jew , Janet Yellen is a Jew , CEO of Black Rock Larry Fink is a Jew , Rotshchilds are Jewish, Murdochs are Jewish, CEO of
Goldman Sachs David Michael Solomon is a Jew , Wife of James Dimon JPMorgan Chase CEO is a Jew , NBC Universal Chief Executive Jeff Zucker is a Jew , Toby Emmerich of Warner Bros. is a Jew , Robert A. Iger Executive Chairman of The Walt Disney Company is a Jew . Just connect the dots and everything will make sense.
💯%👍Agree
Thank you for highlighting this story and telling us about your friend Shireen
This reporting is so incredibly important. We need more voices like his.
Thank you, Ayman, for your eloquent and truthful words about Shireen's death. So sorry for the loss of your friend. And condolences to Shireen's family.
Shireen would be alive if arab animals would not have butchered Jews a week ago forcing Soldiers enter arab section to confiscate weapons, shooting erupted, and Shireen was killed by a Muslim terrorist. In the video in Arabic the shooter is admitting, in real time, to shooting a person who fell down.
A muslim kills a Christian and Jews are blamed. Truth will prevail. Jews are the only indigenous natives living in their 3,000 year old ancestral land and arab colonialists who migrated to the region for economic gains (many from Bosnia per UN records) must learn to behave, as civilized people should
My condolences to this young lady’s family and friends specially to you Ayman, I am sorry for your lost. 💐peace on her soul.
If you are really sorry for her, stop supporting Apartheid.
@@zenzender3790 FAXX💯💯💯
😭😭
we grew up watching her bringing us the ugly truth of israeli occupation.
hard to concieve she is gone.
god bless her and may she rest in peace.
long live Palestine.
Now she is dead. She won't speak propaganda of lies anymore. She and the terrorist that shooting are same same.she even worst. She motivated them. Now she's gone and all the lies went with her.
@@dimon831 when you call us terrorists.. do you just repeat the word blindly or do u think of your words?
We are occupied by your military and your settlers are always stealing our lands and homes. We are defending ourselves. If you were a palestinian.... what would you do? I am curious to know.
@@r.a.8582 The killing of a clearly identified press worker in a conflict area is a violation of international law.
@@kalijasin who are you ? Violence of international law . Goshh you pathetic . She were in gunshot battle that btw Palestinian started .
@@kalijasin bullets don't see your identity if you are going into a conflict zone then go on your own responsibility.
Shireen was one of my favorite Al Jazeera reporters, and I will miss her stories. She helped change our view of the world. I grieve for her family and her untold stories.
Justice now, justice forever
It’s disgusting this happened. Holding Love and Light for her and her family.
Condolences to Shireen Abu-Akleh's family and friends on their loss.
And JUSTICE for her and other Palestinian victims of the wretched apartheid occupation.
@@waryaawariiri1812 exactly!
During urban combat, she was providing real time information on the Israeli locations to Palestinian combatants. That is a combatant. She was dealt with accordingly. Her name should tell you everything you need to know about her.
@@hendrickvanderdecken7926her name? Her Christian name? She's Christian u know 💀 also she wasn't, she was covering sheikh Jarrah occupation and the footage revealed show literally no combat literally none.
Finally some humanity shown towards Palestinians in American media.
American media doesn't know what humanity is when it comes to Palestinians, that's only for blonde hair blue eyes.
Nota Bene: "some"
Whoever thinks this story is anti-Semitic is wrong. Criticising a murder by an Israeli soldier is perfectly legitimate. Honoring a slain Palestinian journalist is perfectly legitimate. If an Israeli commits murder, acknowledging this is not anti-Semitic. I speak as someone who is careful not to be anti-Semitic.
You don’t have to fear calling out a radical far right Israeli government who massacres human lives because they’ll shout you down using the anti-Semitism card to benefit their own agenda. They bring nothing but shame on themselves, and degrade the collective experience of the millions of Jews who were slaughtered or survived under Nazi Germany.
So right.Seeing your last name i presume you might be Irish,who has known how hos people have Been suffering from wrongdoings for generations.Thank you for your emphaty
Exactly, it's not even a discussion.
Religion needs to be taken out of this.
@@sinetteiversen9978 you can't always tell by last names. My grandfather changed his last name because of discrimination against Jews who came to the USA. He was an accountant and he couldn't find work so he changed it to a British name. Many people did that.
Wow, Ayman is putting his job (in an American media outlet) on the line by shedding some necessary light on the reality of the Israeli occupation and violence in the Palestinian territories.
They are lucky to have him appear on their network!
@@DEARRAEDDEAR They are lucky to have someone underscore double standards in American media and politics when it comes to threats to free press and reporting. If you are in Ukraine, you're a star, if you work in occupied Palestine, you side with "militants."
Interesting that MSNBC let Ayman speak the truth… maybe it’s just to obvious that they can’t silence him
He should call out USS Liberty killings
Don’t did Palestinians with this Palestinian territories enter Israel center this past month killing 19 Israelis civilians . Not just few day ago did 2 Palestinians murder with axe 🪓 3 Israelis civilians in Israelis territories and injured for life 5 more civilians . So who are you to talk ?
The U.S. Not condemning Israel for the killing speaks volumes.
Because Israel owns the USA
When have they ever condemned anything Israel has done
You need first to determine who killed her in order to condmn. It is not working automaticlly againat Israel like you like it too.
But seriously what do you expect the U.S to do?
@@peggywanjiku9638 stop giving billions of our tax dollars to that terrorist apartheid regime would be a good start
Her death is a loss for all the people who believe in justice, all with single grain of humanity mourn her passing.
A beautiful lady, inside and out.
Liberal males are considered women correct?
I am so sorry for your loss, Ayman. I'm not Palestinian. For a Puerto Rican, those who know me since childhood think I'm much too aware of the history of Israel and their cruelty not only to Palestinians, but anyone "armed" with a camera. I can't help it. My heart hurts for what humanity's experiencing. The camera and mic were Shireen's tools, not weapons, except to those in the Israeli government, who want to continue murdering and pillaging the Palestinian State. I didn't know her, only her news reports, but I actually wept when I heard the news.
Once my tears subsided, I tweeted out a few reminders to Naftali Bennet, the Knesset, the IDF and Biden. Whatever good that does, I'm simply too angry to stay silent. Because I study the history of this region, am a member of BDS, and familiar enough with the Bible to know of the religious hypocrisy of God's "chosen people," who think they've the divine right to murder people (especially children) and steal from the Palestinian community, I think it's also evident the US is helpless to do anything about it. A greater power with more money and influence resides in Israel, the Rothschild family, which no one dares mention. I know a bit about their history, which extends over 225 years, but I digress. May Shireen RIP. As she laid on the ground, dying from her wounds, I'm sure God's arms were already there to embrace her.
👍👍👍 good
Spot on. 🌷
Wow. 67 likes to my long post I didn't think anyone would read. I'm thrilled to know others agree with blatant truth, which will surely get me extradited from this platform or others (surprised Twitter hasn't done it yet). Thank you all.
this is and extremely anti-semitic post, sharine was a terrorist sympathizer. let me tell you this we Jews are God's chosen people and anyone who defies us is defying God himself. God created two people the Jews and the gentiles the Jews are God's true creation whereas the gentiles are nothing but beasts in human clothes.
Puerto Rico's homicide rate is 12 times higher than Israel.
Lovely words Ayman. ❤
Ever notice human beings don't really value their rights until they're taken away? Freedom of the press is one of these rights we can't afford to lose. Her life and work mattered even if some don't agree with the focus of her work. She was a courageous journalists who was shot down in the line of duty seeking to tell the truth. America must insists upon an independent investigation. It's only right. So sorry for her loss to the world of journalism. All journalists matter. 😟
SHE WAS WORKING IN A DANGEROUS AREA AND ALWAYS FACED THE POSSIBILITY OF INJURY OR DEATH EVERYDAY. SHE KNEW THE RISKS..
United Snakes itself is killer
@@__-si9ux 🇵🇰👡👡👡
@@armas754 🐂💩🇺🇲
@@__-si9ux 🇵🇰🐖🐖
US Government when Russia commit war crimes: "barbaric"
US Government when Israel commit war crimes: "i'll pretend i didn't see that"
Haha it’s happened all the time in gunshot battles with terrorists or war zone . American killed a lot in Afghanistan . More then 2600 journalists died in war zone . Especially in Yemen this past years . You just cry because it’s Israel . The only Jew state . Yet no one cry as much about this 2600 who died
@@mor43311 ni anak napa ya
Thank you 🙏
Thank You for speaking clearly, with strength and truth.
Great reporting. Glad you cover this story the way you did. My condolences to you and those who share with you the same loss
MSNBC should be doing much much to cover injustices to Palestinians in Israel not only by the ISD but also by the government and yes...even some citizens who abuse the minority, often with impunity.
Well said. However, Palestinians are not a ‘’minority”
Thank you for reporting this important story. This deserves more international attention.
This is so wrong.
There must be accountability for this heinous act.
So sorry Ayman. Unnecessary and tragic. The world is going crazy.
This has been going for 70 years, and the west made sure to support and maintain it happening.
@@tkg3491 exactly where is the ppls rage???
The world is crazy naa the world is silent when its not white or European pple
My sincerest ⚘🤗 condolences on your loss Ayman. May GOD BLESS 🙏
Mrs. Shireen, her honesty and fact based reporting will surly be missed 😪
✝️🙏🙏🙏✝️
Thank you Ayman for being a voice for the voiceless, as your friend and colleague did. Lived in East Jerusalem from 1996-2006. Know well the truth she was trying to convey.
May her memory be eternal
You are so right. I'm an Israeli and I testify for numerous crimes of Israel in the occupied territories. I am joining your sorrow and rage. May she rest in peace and may this be a step towards the end of occupation, Amen
Thanks for your words. Isn't easy going against your own. But your voice might be the most important in this fight. God bless!
Respect, I know it's hard to be on the opposite side of your own people, and so I appreciate your honesty towards what you believe is right. Dont get upset if people are going to attack you here in the comments, it really wont change the fact that you've seen it all yourself. God bless you..!
We desperately need independent investigations by the UN of these very disturbing killings. My deepest sympathies to all her friends and families and above all, her countless fans & readers on Al Jazeera. She will continue to live in our hearts forever.
Wont happen especially when US veto's anything negative against israel in the UN.
@@ibidu1 There is a chance this time because she was a US citizen. Otherwise, you are right my friend!
I'm sad and proud for Shireen at the same time we need to see this for people to know what's going on in these parts of the world that go mostly unseen.
I am shocked you were allowed to make these comments and that TH-cam allowed these comments to be posted. Bravo for MSNBC!
Bravo Ayman!!
Especially since this (USA) government does not allow us to know both sides of the Ukrainian/Russian Conflict; we are cut off from RT and Sputnik.
RT & Sputnik? WTF? You really don't want to be grouping pro-Palestinian journalism with those propaganda outlets.
Ayman, sincere condolences to you on the loss of your friend and colleague, Shireen Abu Akleh. I admire, so much, your journalistic integrity, intelligence and "humanity" - MSNBC should be so proud to have you as a member of their team! Very best wishes from the UK 🇺🇦
I' truly sorry for the loss of your friend. Love to her family.
Thank you for sharing this difficult and personal story. Condolences to you and her family and friends and colleagues.
One of the best tributes I’ve seen and heard. Thank you .
I am not a Palestinian nor Israel fan, however we must stop sending American tax dollars to Israel. They can support themselves.
So sad for your loss, the loss of a loved one by her family and her journalist family. Rest in the power you gave the powerless and voiceless, Shireen A A.
May those who murdered her never find peace within.
Imagine losing a friend this way and then having to report it on air. I pray the truth will have a lasting effect to those who still have blinders on. My heart goes out to her family, friends and those she spoke up for. May she rest in peace..😢🙏
The entire arab world is shocked by her death. It's like losing your favorite celebrity. She was a brave soul and a symbol of freedom and real journalism. In a world full of lies we should protect journalists. RIP good Lady
I'm sorry you lost a friend!
It's good that these stories are finally getting the coverage they deserve. I'm honestly shocked that MSNBC would use language this direct against Israel, I know that they're considered the most progressive mainstream TV-news channel, but the fact that it's in the mainstream at all is incredible!
I'm sorry for your lost Ayman
When an evil is done to a fellow human being,the perpetrator regardless of their power or connection should be condemned and brought to justice.
Thanks for covering this.
Ah man, i am so so sorry about this. This tragedy is painful not only to the people close to Shireen who knew her, relied on her, and loved her...but to anyone with a pulse! For all people everywhere who value free speech and freedom of the press, regardless of their nationality or political leaning, Shireen is an angel and fearless global hero. My she rest in peace.
Could you point me to your comments showing how upset you are that 3 hebrew Israelis where stabbed out of existence in tel Aviv, at the hands of an Arab a few days ago. Really shows what kind of person you are, zowie
@@talksmoke1190 what about the thousands of Palestinians you people slaughter on a daily basis? The ratio proportion is absurd and preposterous! Your government is the one hiding behind the ‘Hamas’ excuse. BS! And deep down your people know it.
@@talksmoke1190 so Russian invasion in Ukraine is ok because America invaded Afghanistan , Syria , Lydia ?
@@logic001 you're funny. When did america invade syria, let alone Lydia. I give you credit for choosing the name logic, when you so clearly have none
@@talksmoke1190 you are just dodging my question by using grammatical errors . stop being a hypocrite mate
So sorry for the loss of Shireen Abu Aqleh And I agree That the Israeli government should NOT INVESTIGATE her murder Great Reporting 😢😢😓Rest in Peace Shireen!💗❤️♥️💜💕🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾
I'm sad that you lost a friend. I'm sad we lost a wonderful, dedicated woman.
Thank you for truthful coverage of this ♥️🇵🇸
Rest in peace brave woman. My condolences to you and to all of Sherine's friends and colleagues.
They didn't let her live peacefully nor after her death. It break's my heart
Violent Israeli zionist army must pay for there crimes
Israeli mitary spokesman Ran Kachav said "They're armed with cameras". Israeli military view journalists reporting on their activity with Palestinians as a threat. Shireen Ablu Akleh shot in the head despite wearing a press marked flak jacket under a tree. Shot doing her job reporting on an Israeli raid on Palestinians investigating attacks on Israelis. Ali Samoudi, another Palestinian journalist, was shot in the back. Samoudi her producer said He the first shot missed them, then a second struck him, and a third killed Abu Akleh. He said there were no militants or other civilians in the area - only the reporters and the army. This should be investigated by third party investigators looking at eye witness accounts, trajectory and bullet.
At least y’all covered this. Cnn and fox hasn’t said a thing
Ayman Mohyeldin Thank You very much for your real and kind words on the Killing of Journalist Shireen Abu Akleh,
God bless you for your word of truthfulness.
Is the UN Human Rights Council remaining silent on this????
I respect with my bottom of my heart 🫡 and salute these brave and fearless journalists…
Great said, Ayman!! My condolences to her family and to you for losing your friend.
My condolences on the loss of your friend.
Please help us bring an end to this aparthied in Israel since past 70 years.
Thank you for revealing the reality and emphasizing the behaviors of this army. RIP Shirin
I was waiting for your comment . I have often watched in the past when you and shereen were on al Jazeera. I'm neither Muslim nor Palestinian and I am absolutely shocked by this murder and the Israeli behavior at her funeral . I am from New Zealand and even in this far corner I have tears for her.
It’s so easy to forget just how vital journalists are. People are nothing without our stories, and journalists are the ones who tell those stories. This is a tragedy and a travesty.
Respect for MSNBC for even reporting this, I thought all mainstream US media would completely ignore this.
Wtf this is so disgusting I can't believe the world is still so silent so quick to point out Russia but won't say anything to Israel double standards at it's finest. 🇵🇸💔
thank you for your great commentary. Peace to her soul 🙏 Israel should not be investigating the murder of Shereen. An independent investigation is a MUST!!
Thank you for this report. This is the firs time I have heard an honest report about Israel from an American TV Channel.
I'm so sorry for your loss! I cried for her too, such a lovely lady! I grew up watching her reports. Another horrific crime on the very very long list of Israeli crimes.
Thank you for sharing your memories, Ayman. My heart goes out to all of her friends and colleagues.
I am so sorry about the loss….murder….of your dear friend and beautiful soul Shireen Abu Akleh. I will never understand the loss of so many wonderful people when there are so many very, very evil bad people still breathing, laughing, enjoying their families and friends. That will never ever make sense to me. Prayers go out to Shireen’s family and friends.
So sorry for the loss of your friend and colleague. 🙏 🤲
So sad and tragic, from the passion in your voice she will be dearly missed by you and all others who's lives she touched. Please accept my heartfelt condolences and pass them along to those who will appreciate them. Also, thank you so much for sharing your friend with us.
Ukraine supplies many great and timely analogies that are a severe correction to Western bigoted thinking regarding conflict and oppression elsewhere, but how tragic that even one analogy is needed. Shireen and all Palestinian journalists are 100% equal to all others that serve us, justice, truth, peace, elsewhere.
We desperately need reporting like this in the US. Thank you! I've seen too many murders of Palestinian civilians by Israeli troops, some even on film. And there are never any consequences to the perpetrators.
I'm not used to MSNBC reporting accurately on Chosanistan. Well done.
Thank you, Ayman and MSNBC
Lest we forget!
It matter's that she is american, USA we will support our own.
It matter's - her life matter's rest in pace our Palestinian, American, WOMAN😢
No when it comes to Israeli issues backing them comes first no matter what every they do. Remember USS Liberty and many intences over the dacades,
My Friend that sentiment is non existent in your leadership. They just signed a $40 billion aid package to a place thousands of miles away when there are literally millions of Americans homeless hungry and sick without any help from their so called country!!
I'm so sorry for the loss of your friend Ayman 😪💔
My most sincere condolences to her family , friends & co-workers ..... may your memories bring you some comfort in the coming days as you grieve with both tears & laughter .....
Zoe , Ca
Well said, thank you Ayman for your professionalism.
It’s refreshing to hear the words “occupation” and “occupied territories”. It’s incredibly rare for anyone on the major networks to mention them these days.
Well said!
Thank you Ayman for speaking out. My condolences to you and her family for your loss. May your memories of her bring you peace.
It's hard to put in words how well-known she was. Shereen was a household name in the Arab World (Middle East & North Africa). Back in days when Al-Jazeera Arabic service did not had competition, and pioneered the Pan-Arab news model, it was the only channel to watch everything on, including the fast-moving developments in the Palestinian-Israeli conflict. The hay days of 2nd Intifada. Shereen was the face of the news. Her deep voice was the voice of the news. And she was much more than that. She was role model to female journalists/ correspondents in a time when very a few were there.
I noticed how they skipped over the fact that Israel attacked the mourners and pallbearers at her funeral. Why?
Absolutely sickening how Israel continued to get away with their crimes
Thank you for bringing this to prominence. US helping Israel= complicit
Israeli Ethnic Cleansing Forces routinely do this & the US Govt. CIA, Military routinely assists Israeli Ethnic Cleansing Forces with their ethnic cleansing then assisting cove up of these vicious acts.
First accurate reporting of Shireen's death. Free Palestine
😞 I saw it too on the news. I was shocked. I was sad. I was angry. Humanity again have to answer for that.
This was an horrific assassination by the apartheid settler colonial Israeli regime. May Shireen rest in power. Palestinians are murdered on an almost daily basis and ethnic cleansing by Israeli continues relentlessly. Western MSM has been outrageously anti-Palestinian for decades, unable and/ or unwilling to objectively report on the many horrors of the Israeli occupation. This is a rare piece of MSM showing some objectivity for once. It's obviously a personal tragedy for the newsreader as he knew Shireen. If only they could report like this at all times.
This is so sad i hope that her family and friends find some light in this dark time. I find that we almost need to have a independent investigation team looking into all deaths of reporters if it be pulling some of the best from all over the world to do 1 job help the innocent during war.
About time you guys said this....
i disagree strongly with many msnbc tropes but i am grateful for this coverage. thank you
End Israel impunity.
People...
Russia/Ukraine: This is a despicable atrocity!
Israel/Palestine: But Jesus said... and they were throwing rocks!
Exactly! The western nations with the US as a lead are HYPOCRITES HYPOCRITES HYPOCRITES 🤬😠😡
she was not killed, she was murdered.
Well said are people listening to this wise man !
We need to stop sending aid to Israel.
Thank you Ayman for speaking the truth !! May God bless her soul !! The Israeli will always deny their wrongdoing .
Very sad to loose her as a great humanitarian and reporter
The occupiers of Palestinian land should be brought to justice for their brutal actions on the Palestinian land and people
May God bless shereen’s soul
Thank you for your honesting.. i am surprised coming from this news company.