i love ningning sm my eyes are always drawn to her theirs just something about her on stage and her style and vocals just everything !!!! TOTAL GIRL CRUSH!!!!
That's true, the strongest voices here are winter and Karina, next is ningning and Giselle just can't hear at all, but i like them everyone. Just don't understand why people keep saying Ningning has the strongest voice?
Im glad ningning is finally getting the recognition she deserves❤❤❤ Our ning yi zhuo indeed has amazing vocals and shes just so pretty... This is really her prime!! She gets prettier everytime but ningning is just stunning ❤
I've watched it as always these girls are impressive! and as a person who also sings, out of the four, Giselle's mic really is the lowest in volume even when Giselle's mic is near her mouth, she's literally screaming just to be heard! And the techs don't care! the technicians should balance the volume well especially they're a group and she has important rap parts to performed as chewy as possible. She always has great mic volume on their live stages, but now it's just... I felt so sorry for her voice. Aespa fighting!❤
kinda late but also when its her part they don't even direct the camera at her sometimes and is directed on another member giselle needs to be shown more equally! But they all slayed tho so yea
THE BEST FESTIVAL!!!! Nonton berpuluh-puluh kali. Tidak Bosan sama sekali dan keren sekali aespa disini. Cantik luar biasa!! Semoga tahun depan diundang lagi sama Yonsei University....
Aespa couldn't have a better leader than our dear Karina. She's not only pretty but her charisma, and the way she expresses herself towards her fans is next level 💙
Can’t take my eyes from ningning, she’s very main slayer. Ningning stage presence , facial expression and dance is ate always
Since debut ❤
Fr❤
Since Debut x2 she's very cute omg
Because she is Ning.Ning Yizhuo.
lol
why no one's talking about how stable Winter's vocal, it's sooo good.🥰
I like it❤❤
She's my dream girl
All of the girls slayed the stage, but Ningning really stood out the most to me. I loved her cute cat ears!!! ; )
yeees
Aespa I swear a rare group. These girls sing their songs live an it sounds the studio version. Their voices are next level
비쥬얼, 실력 모든 게 완벽하다 진짜
i love ningning sm my eyes are always drawn to her theirs just something about her on stage and her style and vocals just everything !!!! TOTAL GIRL CRUSH!!!!
Winter always the loudest and clear. I love 'em 4. They rock woth their live vocals as always
That's true, the strongest voices here are winter and Karina, next is ningning and Giselle just can't hear at all, but i like them everyone. Just don't understand why people keep saying Ningning has the strongest voice?
Ningning has such a strong voice! It’s so beautiful🩷
12:45 why do i feel like winter is extending her high note to tell us that they are live😂😂
Ningning is stunning as always she's just a different level❤
0:26 카리나 얼굴 공격에 바로 이어서 닝냥이 얼굴 공격.... 정신이 혼미해짐 너무예뻐 실화야?
Double heart attact kkk
윈터는 얇고 닝이는 굵고 지젤은 맑고 카리나는 중저음..각자 매력있음
근데 닝이는 모랄까 여러 소리를 낼수 있는 거 같은데
그러니 메인 보컬이죠! 닝이 ㅋㅋ
윈터도 대단한게 저음부분은 얇고
고음부분에는 단단하고 굵어짐..
그래서 윈터랑 닝이가 진짜 대단한듯..😊
DANCE TI THE SONG, WHY DO YOU CARE ABOUT THE WAISTS OF THE MEMBERS???????? WHAT THAT IS GOT TO THE MUSIC??????????? YOU ARE SO STUPID
Ningning always slaying even tho cam is not on her duuhh
voice is more important in the artist, hope i've helped
look on pictures elswhere, duh
Winter's high notes and visual 🙌✨
Her part in Regret of the Times! 🫠🔥🤟
완전 콘서트가 따로 없네 연세대분들 부럽습니다...
공부좀 하지 ㅋㅋ
@@문영균-u6j너도 좀하지 넌 개념도
@@문영균-u6j이런애들 특 개지잡ㅋㅋ
@@히-t7e3c개지잡도 못 갈 씹 하위스펙 고딩이겠지 ㅋㅋ
@@문영균-u6j 안쓰럽다 수준티나는게
Ningning and her cat ears!I am sure all the girls love performing, but I can always feel Ningning in her element when the mic is on.
Ningning you will always be loved ❤
0:21 Supernova
3:51 Black Mamba
10:51 Regret of the Times (Remake)
16:42 Spicy
23:08 Next Level
Regret of time, remake.
@@AB-yk2pq thanks mate 👌🏼
tyy
Karina crowd interaction is insane
Someone pin this please
다른 멤버들도 진짜 잘하는데 닝닝이 보컬이 진짜 진국이다...
닝닝은 들을수록 진짜 바다느낌이 찐함.. SM계보 ㄷㄷ
스파이씨는 거의 생라네 ㅋㅋ
@@Hhhddddd이번에 대학축제 몇개들은 아예 inst만 깔고 했음ㄷ 관객쪽으로 마이크 하니까 노래 아예 안들렸음
신곡말곤 인스트로만 깐듯..
닝닝🤍
아니 닝닝왜케이뻐짐?
live vocal aespa bestttt
닝닝 예전보다 더 많이 알아줘서 너무 조아요 ❤❤
와…..닝닝 진짜 너무 잘하네.. 녹음 비하인드 영상 봤을때도 소름끼쳤는데
닝닝은 점점 이뻐지넹
Im glad ningning is finally getting the recognition she deserves❤❤❤ Our ning yi zhuo indeed has amazing vocals and shes just so pretty... This is really her prime!! She gets prettier everytime but ningning is just stunning ❤
Ningning is soo captivating!!!
Ningning main slayer
I honestly understood 10% only but I smiled throughout the performance. So so good. Disappointed that Giselle's mic sounded weaker though.
After getting lung surgery, winter voices still so stable, she always eat CD
As expected from main vocal
I love winter too but she’s lead vocal
She is main vocal too@@Celestialprincess1603
@@Celestialprincess1603 i am sorry sm has announce it official that aespa has 2 main vocals 😁
@@yesoryes2436where did they announce it? It remember winter saying she was just lead vocalist but that was a while ago
@@bjabbi7328 in weverse
Ningning is so attractive, i'm melting
Ningning is so pretty ❤
ningning is stage fairy .she really said this is how its done.
my bias ningning is killing it I love it this is the power of ningning since debut I am so happy she is getting so much attention
always obsessed with Winter’s highnote
닝닝 ㅈㄴ 예쁘다
나 중국인 좋아해ㅜ
that comment really helps with her voice
다른 가수들 다 봤는데 반응이 제일 좋네요 떼창이 엄청나네 .. 카리나가 은근 당돌해서 호응유도 잘함
Ningning good at singing live❤
Ningning and Karina, they're so pretty 🥰😍
Indonesian fans are here!!! We love you Karina Winter Giselle Ningning ❤
Aku juga ❤🎉
Here too
I got goosebumps because of Karina's voice. It's really loud and strong! Karina is crazy!
mbak ningning stop cakep bisa gaa, cantik banget gilaaa
에스파 짱이다ㅏㅏ 사랑해ㅐㅐ 지젤 잘한다! ㅠㅠ
닝닝이 노래도 잘하고 외모도 이쁘고
ningning always SERVES 😭❤
Nobody talk about giselle 🥺 she did great too.. She ATE!!!!!!
Ning Ning so beautiful😮
I've watched it as always these girls are impressive! and as a person who also sings, out of the four, Giselle's mic really is the lowest in volume even when Giselle's mic is near her mouth, she's literally screaming just to be heard! And the techs don't care! the technicians should balance the volume well especially they're a group and she has important rap parts to performed as chewy as possible. She always has great mic volume on their live stages, but now it's just... I felt so sorry for her voice. Aespa fighting!❤
kinda late but also when its her part they don't even direct the camera at her sometimes and is directed on another member giselle needs to be shown more equally! But they all slayed tho so yea
닝닝이 개이쁘고 개잘해...
This is a great example of the importance of choosing songs that suit the members' voices💜
닝닝 보컬 소리가 진짜 풍부함 음역대도 저음 고음 다 잘 내는데 보컬 스킬이 말이 안됨
닝닝잘했어
에스파 예쁘고 잘한다 다들❤ 닝닝 참 매력있게 예쁘네
Ningning slay despite you excluding her from your post.
She slayed those high notes omg
true such racist university
wait what??? what happened
wait wdym
What happened?
역시 스엠.. 제대로 보여줬네 최고다
ningnings cat ears too shes so mesmerising and captivating on stage !!!
No wonder why Hybe afraid of these ladies ,they are getting better with each comeback ❤
Ningningku😍😍
I like all members of Aespa. But I can't take my eyes off Ningning.
Ningning, all rounder. Vocal, dance, fotogenic, visual gorgeous, and beautifull heart ❤❤
26:25 지미니 자연스럽게 손바꾸는거 진짜천상아이돌❤❤
The hoops on Giselle is so 2000, I love it!
닝언니 사랑해
에스파가 축제의 짱이다
Aespa is so satisfying to watch! The presence, the vocals, the dance. If I had to pick and can only attend 1 kpop concert from 5gen, id choose aespa.
미쳤다 라이브….. 왜케 잘해
라이브는 에스파!!!
다 잘하는데 윈터는 진짜 똑같네요!!!
NINGNING ATE 🔥🔥
그냥 신이다 얘네는
Karina and Ningning so pretty 😍
ningning❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
닝닝 라이브 뭐야 ㅠㅡㅠ 캐리하네
닝닝이 진짜 존나예뻐
Ningningggg ate 👏👏👏👏
Ningninggggggg❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
닝닝 겁나잘해...그냥 wow
Ningning again ATE
Aespa just reminds me to Little mix, they both can sing live and the performance so boom
THE BEST FESTIVAL!!!! Nonton berpuluh-puluh kali. Tidak Bosan sama sekali dan keren sekali aespa disini. Cantik luar biasa!! Semoga tahun depan diundang lagi sama Yonsei University....
NINGNING SO WOOOOW
닝닝이 진짜 이뻐졌네 대박이다ㅋㅋ
라이브 미쳤네...ㅠㅠㅠㅠ❤❤
Aespa couldn't have a better leader than our dear Karina. She's not only pretty but her charisma, and the way she expresses herself towards her fans is next level 💙
Ningning❤❤❤
올해 다른 대학캠도 다 봤지만 연대만한 곳이 없다. 흥해라 연대 🎉
노랑머리 너무 귀엽자나
NINGNING MAIN SLAYER!!!!
NINGNING GOD❤❤❤
winters voice always stands out. she got the best live vocals among them
Ningning who's actually the best at live performances
@@eulalia3468winter is the most stable at live performances
@@yaryawoleng4154 nope many times she goes out of tune and nasal, Ningning executes her parts the best in every performance
@@eulalia3468 lol ning cant sing her highnote in savage too from many tour i went for aespa she depends on backtrack alot
@@eulalia3468ningning skips many high parts sometimes unlike winter who is stable at most of the time even when dancing
Ningning always pretty all members is pretty
CANTIK BGT NINGNING COKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK
멤버들 비쥬얼 미쳤네 너무 좋아 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
main slayer Ningning devouring as always🔥🔥🔥🥵
their vocals are amazing 😭😭😭 Aespa jjang
3:35 왜 요즘에는 닝닝이가 더 이쁜거같냐;; 진짜 ㅈㄴ자연스럽게 이쁘네..
응 아니야
카리나는 신이야
@@백토마 웅 너한테만
LOVE NINGNING!!!
i'm so sorry but my eyes just focus on ningning😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
NINGNING IS A MEMBER TOO 🗣️🗣️
SAY IT LOUDER!!!
대학축제 1티어 닝닝...
그러게 존나이쁘다
카리나 다시봣다 생각보다 라이브 좋은데ㅎㅎ
the live vocal is so insane
The backtrack is loud too 😂😂😂
Ningning kelihatan tambah SLAYYY, elegan bangett