+foaly8 talk about groundless, how do you know which nation arcadian lee and myself was referring to?? neither a lee nor myself mention taiwan. you are being presumptuous. you don't even know which nation arcadian lee is from. my statement is universally TRUE and VALID and can be applied to ANY nation on earth and you call it groundless????? BTW, i hope you know that taiwan is NOT a NATION!! perhaps IT IS YOUR statement that is groundless. IF MY NATION IS NOT UNIFIED, THEN IT IS NOT GREAT, THEN I HAVE A LESSER LOVE FOR IT. AGREE????
+biomed Because this concert was in Taiwan -- although Song is from China. And I looked at his profile, which seemed to suggest that he is indeed from Taiwan. So while I can of course not be certain, it seems a reasonable -- at least not groundless -- assumption. :) Moreover, it seemed like you were trying to imply that it is not, but rather ought to be reintegrated into China. Yes, I still call it groundless. You make a statement which you claim to be "universally true and valid", without backing it in any way. Also, while the definition of a "nation" is not undisputed, one common one -- and the one I tend to use -- is something like "a government which controls a specific territory, which may or may not be associated with any particular ethnic group" (here somewhat synonymous with "state"). This certainly is the case for Taiwan, although many other nations refuse to consider it as such for the sake of the Chinese Yen. (See what I did there? I backed my claim with an argument, so it is not groundless anymore. ;)) And no, I strongly disagree. First and foremost because I find "love for a nation" to be a quite laughable idea; in part since borders are not a fact, but a human invention fluctuating with time. But also because there may be many forms of "great" (another very ambiguous term) which a non-unified nation might achieve -- China might be a good example, since certain parts "of it", like Tibet or Hong Kong, have a to some degree autonomous (but not really sovereign) status, and so one could count it as not unified. Still, one might find quite a few measures according to which China can be described as "great" (; and -- some might argue -- also several according to which it would be not so "great"). Of course, we can agree that you will have a lesser love for your nation in case it happens to be not unified, and you believe others should feel the same way. However, they do not. :)
+foaly8 are you trying to tell me that a divided nation is more loved by its citizens than a unified nation??? now tell me which SOCIETY (i am not even referring to a nation) throughout world history that my prior statement is NOT true and invalid.
In China everything is politics .Once you are in different group without your fault ,you are gone .it appeared 宋祖英 was the blue eye singer of former CHAIRMAN JIANG who had lost power ,Hence she is completely eliminated any singing performance . I love her singing ,golden sweet voice .with such pretty lady from minor ethics group . Hope that can listen to her again .God bless her .
赞美给宋祖英👍👍👍
宋祖英的打扮很美，是国宝級人物。
宋祖英這首歌唱的非常好聽，那千里之外就要再家油。
宋祖英，完美歌唱家！了不起！
歌唱家宋祖英宿主國的一塊寶大家來珍惜宋祖英素歌唱的天才大家團結愛他
宋祖英名付其实人靓声甜🌻
宋祖英,周华健兩位唱的真好! 雖是唱別人的歌,也另有一番風味,真是實力派唱將.
為了廣闊草原！ 宋！唱清水流高樹青葉歌！從哪里來！ 不可問！故鄉從何方來， 為甚麼要流浪！流浪何方！非常極受！ 可以單獨唱！ 聲言向高草原飛奏琴！
宋祖英不唱歌，是我們大家的損失，她唱得太好聽了。
中國民瑤高山青！ 唱言清把山麥整座， 天空白雲輕輕飄高而飄慥！ 怡然！阿里山姑娘美好水呀！！
华健大哥太赞了！
唱的真好....
Song Zuying & Chau Wakin >>>>>>>> are " VERY GOOD " !!
great song, great duet. unbeatable performance.
宋祖英唱出了流浪悠扬的感觉，要是她独唱整首，会更有触动感。
Jennie White
橄欖樹
霍尊母子唱橄榄树，他妈妈穿着很朴素甚至落伍，可搭配这首歌又用温馨的语气轻轻唱，怎么听怎么舒服还尽显气质高贵发自内心与众不同。不做作是大众最喜闻乐见的东西。光站在舞台上就是好的。。。风景线！这是一种修养，不刻意不强求。
同感。宋祖英炫耀华丽的服饰，与这首歌曲的含义相悖，一点都不配。即使声音再美，也不能把人带进那种遥远朴实的情景之中。
唱法不一樣各有特色，無法相提並論，就像有人愛吃鹹，有人愛吃甜ㄧ樣～
總覺得這首歌既然宋祖英唱，周華健是多餘的，不但沒有二重唱的效果，還被宋祖英完全壓在下面，因為宋的聲音太清徹明亮，太優美，流行歌手是無法與她比擬的。
An outstanding performers,tenderness and drive, just passion... Awesome good!!!
宋祖英唱的再好都有些人阴阳怪气地贬低，你们喜欢听垃圾口水歌还要把无知当纯洁。我喜欢宋祖英的歌声😎😎
Pananda Mao
Pananda Mao เพราะมาก
Pananda Mao wax xxx xxx
What an awesome performance!!!
Amazing video and great song!
spectacular
華健和 霍尊 和就對了。
Best version！！
非常好聽
不要政治，宋祖英唱得很好👍
唱的好！確實不錯！👍👍👍
💚💚
ชอบมาก
SONG ZUYING / CHAU WAKIN GOOD SONG
唱法不同，绝对不能单纯比嗓音。宋祖英嗓音无疑比很多通俗歌星嗓音好，但是唱通俗歌曲未必占优势。音乐就是音乐，不是以嗓音定胜负的。
宋祖英唱的这首流行歌曲比她其她流行曲已经是很有进步了，不错。服装怎么看都不像流浪者很搞笑。
ดีมากครับ
橄欖樹。齊豫，歌曲，李泰祥，歌词：三毛，
不要问我从哪里来，我的故乡在远方，为什么流浪，流浪远方 流浪，
为了天空飞翔的小鸟，为了山间轻流的小溪，为了宽阔的草原，流浪远方 流浪
还有还有，为了梦中的橄榄树 橄榄树，
不要问我从哪里来，我的故乡在远方，为什么流浪，为什么流浪远方，
为了我梦中的橄榄树，
不要问我从哪里来，我的故乡在远方，为什么流浪，流浪远方 流浪 [4
👍👍👍👍👍
宋唱的挺好
如果放在还珠格格们从皇宫里逃出来又回到以前流浪的生活环境那段戏里也许蛮出彩，想象真是好东西哈！
I love my nation, my people.
+Arcadian Lee agree, but in order for any nation to be GREAT, it must be unified.
+biomed Taiwan is pretty unified ;) Also, that statement is a very groundless claim; and it has nothing to do with what he said.
+foaly8 talk about groundless, how do you know which nation arcadian lee and myself was referring to?? neither a lee nor myself mention taiwan. you are being presumptuous. you don't even know which nation arcadian lee is from. my statement is universally TRUE and VALID and can be applied to ANY nation on earth and you call it groundless????? BTW, i hope you know that taiwan is NOT a NATION!! perhaps IT IS YOUR statement that is groundless. IF MY NATION IS NOT UNIFIED, THEN IT IS NOT GREAT, THEN I HAVE A LESSER LOVE FOR IT. AGREE????
+biomed Because this concert was in Taiwan -- although Song is from China. And I looked at his profile, which seemed to suggest that he is indeed from Taiwan. So while I can of course not be certain, it seems a reasonable -- at least not groundless -- assumption. :) Moreover, it seemed like you were trying to imply that it is not, but rather ought to be reintegrated into China.
Yes, I still call it groundless. You make a statement which you claim to be "universally true and valid", without backing it in any way.
Also, while the definition of a "nation" is not undisputed, one common one -- and the one I tend to use -- is something like "a government which controls a specific territory, which may or may not be associated with any particular ethnic group" (here somewhat synonymous with "state"). This certainly is the case for Taiwan, although many other nations refuse to consider it as such for the sake of the Chinese Yen. (See what I did there? I backed my claim with an argument, so it is not groundless anymore. ;))
And no, I strongly disagree. First and foremost because I find "love for a nation" to be a quite laughable idea; in part since borders are not a fact, but a human invention fluctuating with time. But also because there may be many forms of "great" (another very ambiguous term) which a non-unified nation might achieve -- China might be a good example, since certain parts "of it", like Tibet or Hong Kong, have a to some degree autonomous (but not really sovereign) status, and so one could count it as not unified. Still, one might find quite a few measures according to which China can be described as "great" (; and -- some might argue -- also several according to which it would be not so "great").
Of course, we can agree that you will have a lesser love for your nation in case it happens to be not unified, and you believe others should feel the same way. However, they do not. :)
+foaly8 are you trying to tell me that a divided nation is more loved by its citizens than a unified nation??? now tell me which SOCIETY (i am not even referring to a nation) throughout world history that my prior statement is NOT true and invalid.
중국나라의송주영가수,merry Christmas and Happy new year !
黄鶯出谷！
周華健成為累鳌赘。
宋的音色真的是天籁。彭丽媛早期的歌还不错有自己特色，后期就感觉声音越来越扁了。是退步了还是嗓子不好？宋的音色一直那么的清亮，真的难得。
Youran Li f. @
宋祖英歌聲甜美，台風很好
Youran Li f. @
宋祖英歌聲甜美，台風很好一一
真是从何说起啊？
不同的歌有不同的唱法吧？
看看齐豫唱不同的歌就知道会不同了。
想象让周深与宋祖英合唱，会是什么效果？明显的，华建和杰伦高音部分都上不去，还让祖英改过了。
我認為宋不必合唱因為她的高音有 甜味不用男和更好高甜淨。
想起来了，好像齐秦和齐豫都在唱过
1
宋祖英衣着华丽，珠光宝气，与这首歌曲的含义相悖，一点都不配。即使声音再美，也不能把人带进那种遥远朴实的情景之中。
宋祖英如果和费玉清合唱，应该很配。
Did Ms.Song Zuying sing solo for this song?
Song Title in English please! (and if possible lyrics).
Olive Tree, originally composed in Taiwan
若费玉清和宋祖英同台对唱还可一拼
覺得宋小姐唱的 加上表情 比較悲情
齊豫唱得比較空靈 感覺更佳
🙌🙌
今日來行天宮請示關聖帝君，必需請中東國家前往台灣會議災情才會好轉，連續多個聖杯，請各位善信大德一定要聽上天旨令行事，切勿妄自非為
美聲與通俗把男生比沒了
習慣用聲樂方式唱歌的就不要唱這種校園民歌，然後裝扮成那樣也不合適。華建不愧是民歌王子！
你們必需了解台灣政權若是落在歐洲手中就不是只有一對一那麼簡單而是一對數國，歐盟國家你們了解嗎，台灣這塊餅將很快被吞噬很快消失殆盡，台灣不再是台灣，很快就成為了歐洲國家殖民地，這是歐洲國家最擅長做的一切，你們要有心理準備
In China everything is politics .Once you are in different group without your fault ,you are gone .it appeared 宋祖英 was the blue eye singer of former CHAIRMAN JIANG who had lost power ,Hence she is completely eliminated any singing performance .
I love her singing ,golden sweet voice .with such pretty lady from minor ethics group .
Hope that can listen to her again .God bless her .
Can you listen the song only ?
這兩個人的音色音量的確不很適合放在一起
Not available , do not put on screen please.very trouble.
宋的这套衣服太珠光宝气了，不适合这首歌。 尤其是前面的珠子。其实袖子还好。衣服的料子改改，珠子去掉就会好很多啊！
厂之学忠
华健的声音怎么感觉哑了些啊。。。
为何周华健的播音比较弱，让他的歌声被盖过去，听不清楚？
通俗嗓在民歌嗓面前确实显得比较哑
华建的声音好听，只是唱这首歌时 东张西望，没有投入进去.........
这个打伴太雷人
宋祖英很投入，周华健有点心不在焉
周华健明显跟不上
宋的服装差评……在台上不自然
土
我想起了一句成语，弄巧成拙。
Yifu zhuangban Shang dique you Zhe yisi .
不好听