Rosie wrote the song and her team send it to bruno as they are label mates at atlantic records now. IT WAS HER IDEA . Pls give the credit where credit is due !
Yeah, and I think it's Bruno and his crew who produced mostly, as we can clearly hear his influence especially at the pre chorus. You can say that Rosé is the main writer while Bruno is the main producer. As even Rosé said in an interview that Bruno immediately provides and suggested instrumentals and even vocal coached her while they were recording this.
Rosé literally pitched him three demo songs and he picked APT, why are they acting like it was Bruno who came up with idea and made game into a song? 😅
Fun fact: they met through their label. Rosé mentioned she was a fan and Bruno asked for 3 songs, Rosé picked APT but the label and her team were completely against it, but she knew this was the sort of song he might enjoy! So kudos to Rosé for knowing what might appeal to him and to him for knowing what would appeal to the world!
*Rosé WROTE the song, its HER idea, she pitched three songs to Bruno, but he loved APT* (Bruno asked her to pitch 3 songs) stop discreading ROSÉ!! Its 2nd time I'm seeing this
it is so baffling how easily you guys get offended. they did not even disrespect rose and were just appreciating the influence bruno had with this song. smh yes rose first started writing the song but dont make it seem like she was the only one writing it and not to mention using live instruments instead of virtually produced sound like most kpop songs clearly means it was produced by bruno. there is a big reason why this is called a collaboration instead of a feature since both artists probably had equal contribution to this song.
@@JayZone23We are not overreacting. We are simply FACT-CHECKING their wrong assumption. When they did the reaction to the MV, they also assumed it was BRUNO’s idea, and people already in the comments corrected them. Now they are reacting to the live performance and still persisted on their wrong assumption. Talked for 30 seconds assuming that Bruno had the genius idea to turn a drinking game into a song, and Rosé just rode with it -and she sings as a feature. The fact is that it is not true - she had the curiosity and the idea to write a song about a drinking game and pitched it to Bruno. The other members of her team wanted to pitch other songs to Bruno, but she insisted in putting APT in the mix hoping he’d see the promise of the song. And he did. Bruno is a genius for recognizing the potential in the song, but it was in fact ROSE idea to write a song about the drinking game.
@@bidyosko i guess it is warranted then if they did not give any credit to rosie. Maybe give then another chance and dont easily get offended. I truly believe both artists should get credit but it is probably easier for non kpop fans to notice bruno's contribution since they are more familiar with him.
@@JayZone23 i was not offended at all, especially in the first instance. And in my separate comment I was also just fact-checking and reminded them that this was the 2nd time we fact-checked them. Bruno is taking her under his wing is a good thing for someone who wants to break through a global audience. Even Rosie is generous in her giving praise and thanks and credit to Burno. But in this case, as in any case in any workplace, I am uncomfortable when people are not credited for the work that they do -- even when already called out. Especially if it involves a successful man and a woman -- even in corporate offices, this happens. A young woman has a great idea, and finds a 'sponsor' to support it -- but everyone ignores the young woman and will be all praises to the sponsor, as if the originator of the idea did not exist. It's time to break the wheel -- whether it be in the office setting or in this case, pop music. If you watch how they said it -- "oh probably they were drinking and Bruno just thought of writing a song, and Rosie was surprised he'd even think of it -- and he's a genius because it turned out to be a hit." -- Like Rosie was a passive participant, when she clearly had the vision and was fortunate to find a like-minded person who helped her achieve that vision.
This was fun. But IT WAS ROSÉ IDEA TO WRITE APT AND PITCHED TO BRUNO - not the other way around. Bruno is a great producer and mentor for her, but I hope you give her the flowers and credit for this. I just noticed this was the 2nd time you miscredited the idea of APT to Bruno, instead of her. If you’re in the mood for a ballad full of feelings, you may also want to check out Rosé new song that dropped yesterday: Number One Girl. The genesis of the song is the night prior, Rosé was doom scrolling through negative comments about her on social media - and she decided to write about how that felt. Bruno is also a collaborator and producer of the song, even though Rosé is singing solo. Thank you.
The song is Rosé's idea..She pitched it to Bruno. Apt is her brainchild. I hope everyone stops discrediting her. I feel like Rosé gets underestimated a lot. For her vocal abilities, creative and songwriting abilities. Despite Apt's huge success I feel still she is being not being given the credit that is due.
actually rosie explained the was teaching the game to people in the studio and since they loved it she decided to write a song about it and then when their label connected them bruno asked her to send 3 songs and she included apt and he ended up choosing that one and produced it
Rosé was the one who wrote APT and was the one who pitched it to Bruno because she found out Bruno was also under Atlantic. She pitched 3 songs and he chose APT. Also… Anderson Paak IS Korean… well half at least.
This pre-recorded (everyone at the actual MAMA watched this on big screen) but nonetheless they still delivers! The most memorable one for this year MAMA goes to bigbang comeback! Their aura is jist different ❤
G Gragon,Taeyang and Daesung live stage at MAMA 2024 showed everybody whos the kings of kpop. Idols and the audience were on thier feet screaming the whole time. Please react to it. Thanks
actually rosé sneaked apt into the songs they pitched to bruno before they did some rearranging and rerecorded it as a collab. she knew bruno would like it when no one else thought he would.
it's pre recorded performance they were there at the show but they didn't perform on the MAMA stage i was so disappointed I waited like 4 hrs for them to perform like i was sooooo hyped .......
They were so smart to to record in a small venue because this is a dance bop song and MAMA is more conservative so it would be a different vibe. I love this!
It's actually Iconic because other than Bruno Mars and Rosé performing together, it's the first time æspa won an award in MAMA or something like that in the history of SM.
PLEASE react to MAMA SEVENTEEN performance & their speech as well. It will move you. Raw vocals, fresh performance of artists who are in this industry for 10 years!! ALSO react to Byeon Woo Seok performance in MAMA. He is a kdrama actor who has the most incredible voice 😍😍
1. Rosé said in one of her interviews that she never had high hopes that Bruno would agree to collaborate with her, but he's so kind he said yes, and of course, he loves APT (written by Rosé) as well. 2. Bruno and his team did the producing kinds of stuff. While Bruno mostly taught Rosé the vocals she should do. 3. PERFECT COLLAB!
Please react on TREASURE PERFORMANCE IN MAMA 2024 . THEY CHANGE IT INTO THEIR CONCERT Please react on TREASURE PERFORMANCE IN MAMA 2024 . THEY CHANGE IT INTO THEIR CONCERT
I noticed how recently you must have been doubting BP in general esp ROSIE. She must not be a fave but I hope you go some more info like you used to do. ROSE finished recording this last year November. When she finally decided to sign up with Atlantic, she learned that Bruno is also signed under the label and so she asked the label is Bruno would like to collab with her (she's not expecting a yes) but she received a message from Bruno's team to send 3 songs. Bruno after that asked her what APT. meant and then she said it was about a korean drinking game. He fell inlove with the idea. Then rest is history.
for those pips that kept saying it is lipsync well IT IS NOT! There's a band playing live, changing notes and lyrics and you're telling people it's lipsync. Plus these two, Rosé and Bruno are known to have such a good hella live performances soooo😭
Maybe it was live, but not live live. Cause the people that went there are expecting to see a live performance from Rosè and Bruno but then gets to watched a pre recorded video on a big screen instead. Can't blamed the fans feeling that they got scammed.
If you have just listened and stopped commenting over it you'd hear the note change ROSÉ did on 6:02 of your video. Also, please, she pitched the song to Bruno and he added his touch to it. You guys are supposed to be inclined to music, why do you not know ssht about bp. She's the main vocalist, have some respect.
I stopped watching your reaction videos when i noticed you have your favorite bp members. You're obviously biased when it comes to Rosé and always discredits her. One thing is for sure your bias in BP cant compete with Rosé when it comes to singing Live.
Bruno adjusted his schedule in Vegas to be in MAMA 2024 as Rosé plus one.. He is indeed a great mentor and thoughfull friend.
Rosie wrote the song and her team send it to bruno as they are label mates at atlantic records now. IT WAS HER IDEA . Pls give the credit where credit is due !
Yeah, and I think it's Bruno and his crew who produced mostly, as we can clearly hear his influence especially at the pre chorus. You can say that Rosé is the main writer while Bruno is the main producer. As even Rosé said in an interview that Bruno immediately provides and suggested instrumentals and even vocal coached her while they were recording this.
Ikr everyone should stop discrediting ROSÉ
@@craftycat3475 that is true but my point is the whole thing abt making a song out of this was her idea which is being overlooked
why are you not telling about performance being pre recorded?
@@RekhaSharma-hh1sv coz that’s not what I’m talking about?
ROSÉ WORTE THE SONG AND SHE WAS THE ONE WHO COME UP WITH THE IDEA OF IT
Rosé literally pitched him three demo songs and he picked APT, why are they acting like it was Bruno who came up with idea and made game into a song? 😅
rosé had the idea and wrote the demo showed to him, he loved then they finished together
Fun fact: they met through their label. Rosé mentioned she was a fan and Bruno asked for 3 songs, Rosé picked APT but the label and her team were completely against it, but she knew this was the sort of song he might enjoy! So kudos to Rosé for knowing what might appeal to him and to him for knowing what would appeal to the world!
So the song is Rosé's, she wrote the song and got Bruno to feature on it.
*Rosé WROTE the song, its HER idea, she pitched three songs to Bruno, but he loved APT* (Bruno asked her to pitch 3 songs)
stop discreading ROSÉ!!
Its 2nd time I'm seeing this
Ikrrr dont disrespect our GIRL
it is so baffling how easily you guys get offended. they did not even disrespect rose and were just appreciating the influence bruno had with this song. smh
yes rose first started writing the song but dont make it seem like she was the only one writing it and not to mention using live instruments instead of virtually produced sound like most kpop songs clearly means it was produced by bruno. there is a big reason why this is called a collaboration instead of a feature since both artists probably had equal contribution to this song.
@@JayZone23We are not overreacting. We are simply FACT-CHECKING their wrong assumption. When they did the reaction to the MV, they also assumed it was BRUNO’s idea, and people already in the comments corrected them. Now they are reacting to the live performance and still persisted on their wrong assumption. Talked for 30 seconds assuming that Bruno had the genius idea to turn a drinking game into a song, and Rosé just rode with it -and she sings as a feature. The fact is that it is not true - she had the curiosity and the idea to write a song about a drinking game and pitched it to Bruno. The other members of her team wanted to pitch other songs to Bruno, but she insisted in putting APT in the mix hoping he’d see the promise of the song. And he did. Bruno is a genius for recognizing the potential in the song, but it was in fact ROSE idea to write a song about the drinking game.
@@bidyosko i guess it is warranted then if they did not give any credit to rosie. Maybe give then another chance and dont easily get offended.
I truly believe both artists should get credit but it is probably easier for non kpop fans to notice bruno's contribution since they are more familiar with him.
@@JayZone23 i was not offended at all, especially in the first instance. And in my separate comment I was also just fact-checking and reminded them that this was the 2nd time we fact-checked them. Bruno is taking her under his wing is a good thing for someone who wants to break through a global audience. Even Rosie is generous in her giving praise and thanks and credit to Burno. But in this case, as in any case in any workplace, I am uncomfortable when people are not credited for the work that they do -- even when already called out. Especially if it involves a successful man and a woman -- even in corporate offices, this happens. A young woman has a great idea, and finds a 'sponsor' to support it -- but everyone ignores the young woman and will be all praises to the sponsor, as if the originator of the idea did not exist. It's time to break the wheel -- whether it be in the office setting or in this case, pop music. If you watch how they said it -- "oh probably they were drinking and Bruno just thought of writing a song, and Rosie was surprised he'd even think of it -- and he's a genius because it turned out to be a hit." -- Like Rosie was a passive participant, when she clearly had the vision and was fortunate to find a like-minded person who helped her achieve that vision.
This was fun. But IT WAS ROSÉ IDEA TO WRITE APT AND PITCHED TO BRUNO - not the other way around. Bruno is a great producer and mentor for her, but I hope you give her the flowers and credit for this. I just noticed this was the 2nd time you miscredited the idea of APT to Bruno, instead of her. If you’re in the mood for a ballad full of feelings, you may also want to check out Rosé new song that dropped yesterday: Number One Girl. The genesis of the song is the night prior, Rosé was doom scrolling through negative comments about her on social media - and she decided to write about how that felt. Bruno is also a collaborator and producer of the song, even though Rosé is singing solo. Thank you.
The song is Rosé's idea..She pitched it to Bruno. Apt is her brainchild. I hope everyone stops discrediting her. I feel like Rosé gets underestimated a lot. For her vocal abilities, creative and songwriting abilities. Despite Apt's huge success I feel still she is being not being given the credit that is due.
actually rosie explained the was teaching the game to people in the studio and since they loved it she decided to write a song about it and then when their label connected them bruno asked her to send 3 songs and she included apt and he ended up choosing that one and produced it
Rosé was the one who wrote APT and was the one who pitched it to Bruno because she found out Bruno was also under Atlantic. She pitched 3 songs and he chose APT.
Also… Anderson Paak IS Korean… well half at least.
you guys need to react GD and the boys, BIGBANG!! 🙌🙌🙌
Yaaah 🎉🎉🎉🎉
bruno produced her new song too...love their friendship
This pre-recorded (everyone at the actual MAMA watched this on big screen) but nonetheless they still delivers! The most memorable one for this year MAMA goes to bigbang comeback! Their aura is jist different ❤
G Gragon,Taeyang and Daesung live stage at MAMA 2024 showed everybody whos the kings of kpop. Idols and the audience were on thier feet screaming the whole time. Please react to it. Thanks
Wanna see other MOST ICONIC MAMA?? Goo watch TREASURE and BIGBANG'S MAMA 2024 HUHUH IT'S BEST! It's like their own concert!!
I guess ICONIC is not it? LEGENDARY (?) HAHAHA THE BESTTT
legendary 🔥🔥
@@JM_YG03legendary is not it we need another word for it hahah🎉😂
actually rosé sneaked apt into the songs they pitched to bruno before they did some rearranging and rerecorded it as a collab. she knew bruno would like it when no one else thought he would.
Hope you can react to BIGBANG and TREASURE also . They own the stage
Thissssss🩷🩷🩷🩷🩷
Did you guys notice the note change at 6:02? …”don’t you want me like I neeed you now!?”😮
rosé and bruno are labelmates. they are under atlantic records.
are u going to do number one girl?
please react to treasure and bigbang performance, pleaseeeeee
it's pre recorded performance they were there at the show but they didn't perform on the MAMA stage i was so disappointed I waited like 4 hrs for them to perform like i was sooooo hyped .......
Treasure MAMA2024 ❤😊😊😊
and there are still people who say they lipsync...they are so petty, it's obvious they sing without a recording,..they chemistry so lit
They were so smart to to record in a small venue because this is a dance bop song and MAMA is more conservative so it would be a different vibe. I love this!
Proud Filipino here. Your the goat Bruno
It's actually Iconic because other than Bruno Mars and Rosé performing together, it's the first time æspa won an award in MAMA or something like that in the history of SM.
Music connects us all wherever you are on this planet earth
Pls react to Treasure MAMA Performance too😢
로제.자랑스런 대한민국 가수.행복합니다.
Guys I love you but you gotta stop pausing sooo damn much. Please speak your mind after the reactttttt
I agree as well but I still love you guys
They do it to avoid copyright issues
One of the few ones who extend the video to 10 mins on a 3 min song lol they talk when they pause and then they still talk over the song lmao
I’m waleska in this video when I was watching the award show videos! I also love this combo so much
Rose’ number one song please
Proud to be Filipino ❤ Bruno is half Filipino ( Her Mom is Filipino ❤❤❤)
Waleska, you need to check out BIGBANG's Full Performance in MAMA 2024! The KINGS are back!!!!!!
WAITING FOR YOUR REACTION FOR GDRAGON WONDER STAGE. Always checking your reaction and i love how u two react.
Lv u guys , best reactors 😂, Rose and bruno r great tbh 😊, more seventeen reaction plz ❤
You gotta watch Katseye and BoyNextDoor's performances too! They stood out to me.
pls react to BIG BANG'S performance too it was PHENOMENAL...
Bruno is a musical genius
If we're talking MAMA performances, yall gotta see the BIGBANG stage
PLEASE react to MAMA SEVENTEEN performance & their speech as well. It will move you. Raw vocals, fresh performance of artists who are in this industry for 10 years!! ALSO react to Byeon Woo Seok performance in MAMA. He is a kdrama actor who has the most incredible voice 😍😍
React to Seventeen performance + speech 😭😭👏🏼 The artists who matter & are 1 in a million, there will never be another SVT!
1. Rosé said in one of her interviews that she never had high hopes that Bruno would agree to collaborate with her, but he's so kind he said yes, and of course, he loves APT (written by Rosé) as well.
2. Bruno and his team did the producing kinds of stuff. While Bruno mostly taught Rosé the vocals she should do.
3. PERFECT COLLAB!
Please react on TREASURE PERFORMANCE IN MAMA 2024 . THEY CHANGE IT INTO THEIR CONCERT Please react on TREASURE PERFORMANCE IN MAMA 2024 . THEY CHANGE IT INTO THEIR CONCERT
Everyone would never imagine that Bruno Mars would be performing in a kpop stage and that is this moment with our very own Rosie.
Next stop, die with a smile by Lady Gaga and Bruno Mars live on Las Vegas.. ❤😍
Numberonegirl when?
Please react to her new song called number one girl
I noticed how recently you must have been doubting BP in general esp ROSIE. She must not be a fave but I hope you go some more info like you used to do. ROSE finished recording this last year November. When she finally decided to sign up with Atlantic, she learned that Bruno is also signed under the label and so she asked the label is Bruno would like to collab with her (she's not expecting a yes) but she received a message from Bruno's team to send 3 songs. Bruno after that asked her what APT. meant and then she said it was about a korean drinking game. He fell inlove with the idea. Then rest is history.
react rosé's number one girl guyss
GD Bigbang stage were crazy tonight 🔥
The most Mama memorable moment was the performance of Bts in 2019!
He helped her with the whole album he produced a solo song of her as well
Anderson Paak was front and centre cheering for Katseye’s MAMA performance in LA
WE NEEDED MAMAMOO FOR MAMA 2024
for those pips that kept saying it is lipsync well IT IS NOT! There's a band playing live, changing notes and lyrics and you're telling people it's lipsync. Plus these two, Rosé and Bruno are known to have such a good hella live performances soooo😭
리액션 잘 보고 갑니다 ^0^
I clicked in a blink! Coz of this video
And Gd and Bigbang starts the party
Actually the real most iconic was in day 2 guys! Please react to g dragon performance. You won't regret it. After years, finally mama is alive.
ill just hang out until the GD/BB mama reaction comes out, next level shit:)
Mama this year like🔥 rose and bruno and the kings of kpop big bang
Plz react to G-dragon mama performance after. Both Rose' & Gd are killing it this year!!
Zerobaseone 's Mama performance next plz
omgg can u react to Red Velvet Irene's Solo Debut
it just came out yesterday!
❤ ❤
❤
BIGBANG AND SEVENTEEN STAGES WERE MY FAV..THEY ATE..💎💎💎
Album out sixth December Rose’
You guys should react to seventeen performance was phenomenal &their winning speech
Please react to Gdragon and Big Bang MAMA 2024
YOU NEED TO REACT TO KATSEYE PERFORMANCE. IT WAS INSANE AND HANDS DOWN THE BEST 👌🔥🙏
You must watch bigbang,aespa and saventeen OMG
You guys need to react to GDragon's performance! ❤
I repeat my loves, Rosé made and wrote the song, not Bruno. Bruno helped produce but all ideas to make this song was Rosé's.😊
Maybe it was live, but not live live. Cause the people that went there are expecting to see a live performance from Rosè and Bruno but then gets to watched a pre recorded video on a big screen instead. Can't blamed the fans feeling that they got scammed.
YOU NEEEEEED TO CHECK KATSEYE PERFORMANCE AT MAMA!!!!!!
THEY ATEEEE SOOOOO HARD!!🎉🎉🎉
Please check Illit Baby its both feat Ava Max ❤
If you have just listened and stopped commenting over it you'd hear the note change ROSÉ did on 6:02 of your video. Also, please, she pitched the song to Bruno and he added his touch to it. You guys are supposed to be inclined to music, why do you not know ssht about bp. She's the main vocalist, have some respect.
U must also check the prfrmnce of bigbang
I stopped watching your reaction videos when i noticed you have your favorite bp members. You're obviously biased when it comes to Rosé and always discredits her. One thing is for sure your bias in BP cant compete with Rosé when it comes to singing Live.
Who is their bias?
@@beccab636 L and Jn
pleaseee reaction rosie-number one girl!!!!!
Please react to Romar ONTROERT ‘Time To Say Goodbye’ in Holland's Got Talent
Great performance, but i would say the biggest song this tear is did with a smile which is also a bruno song 😂
Its bruno mars of course it will be a hit.
Rosie wrote the song. Period
I was waiting for this 🥰
Please react to Treasure's performance. They ate and served ❤️
the song was rosie's... She wrote it with her ream and send it bruno...
It was so great but I wish they perform there. It will be more memorable.
You can obviously tell it was not performed at mama 2024. Mama stage is in a arena dome this venue apt is too small
이번의 gd 무대 12분짜리 올려 주세요🥰😆 자막사용가능도 좀 풀러주셔요.
두분의 APT리액션을 이제서야 보네요
Can you guys PLEASE react to the Bigbamg performance??? It was epic!!
I hope they perform live not per record
Please react to GD, Taeyang and Daesung MAMA 2024 performance it really GOAT
Wow.. y'all misunderstood the whole thing...need everyone to understand they don't favor rosé that much, it's actually obvious but whatever ig 😂
Reaction bigbang at mama 2024 please
reaction to Rosé Number One Girl when????