I'm sorry this took so long. I got sick for days that I was unable to sit nor stand for too long... My conclusion on the Post-chorus is that it's all Sophiya. This is what I think everytime I listen to it "It sounds so much like Chae for it to be Dahyun but it sounds so soft for it to be Chae"
@@zuleta333nobody sing it in live, Dahyun lipsync in all choruses, Chaeyoung only lipsync in the last chorus and for the choreography Dahyun is center in 1st and 2nd choruses and Sana is the center in the last.
Yeah it is Sophia for sure, sadly for DubChae. This is one of those songs that no one can explain why producers would prefer use a background vocalist vocals when this could be perfectly sang by a member. In Brave I could barely understand why but here it just makes no sense.
Could be a lot of reasons maybe the girls don't have time to record all the layers of a song, maybe twice is not commited in terms fo recording but rather choose to put more time in the performance, maybe with a group so experimented it could be difficult to get some members do some things, maybe it's producers choice maybe they like the vibe given by the bg vocalists
Also i wanted to point out that a lot of TH-cam song production creators and analysts of recording love to analyse twice songs, you can find a lot of people who really like to analyze twice music but since late 2017 twice barely records bg vocals, most of the times are the bg vocalists doing those beautiful harmonies and things, i'm not saying anything but i find really interesting that people is interested so much in a group who barely have participation in the recording (excluding they are songwriters) I want to clarify it's not bad to participate less in the recording production, at the end of the day they record the main vocals who everyone love it
you've got to be kidding me, chaeng taking dahyun's first place in one more time is one thing but the fact that dahyun's first place in shadow was stolen by a fucking BACKGROUND VOCALIST boils my blood
@@corneiz_bp_tw8240 Just because some questionable lines happen to involve Dahyun it doesn't take away credibility, most of those times it also affects JeongMiTzu
You're taking line distributions way too serious, also is not like Chaeyoung herself pointed to the producer with a gun and told them to not include Dahyun in the brige on purpouse, let's add to the fact that it just makes it even the grouping of MoSaChae and JeongMiDah to have the repeated chorus and a extra line
People swearing this was Chaeyoung acting as if it was another love foolish case, just because she's last in this distribution are propably still thinking its chae even though its clearly Sofia, just proves the obsession they have with finding every line to be Chaeyoung's, i made a whole analysis on the Fancy post-chrous, and a solo stan still commented it was Chaeyoung and that i was hating on her, i had to delete it.
I mean the fact that Chae only had a verse while everyone else has either two lines or in SaMoTzu case, one line and something else, and Dahyun a line and a repeated line in the post chorus, considering how often DaChae get paired together, it just made sense to the post chorus to be supposedly Chae, turns out is no one in twice for some reason
@@Oliver-uz1fs Yes it would make sense structurally, however is still pointless to assume cause Twice's all lines parts are rarely sung by any other member with the exception of Nahyo, it's mostly the background vocalist, unfortunately though 😑
!["OXYGEN" by TWICE [트와이스] - Filtered Vocals (Lead, Hidden, & ad-libs)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Fw_ezcYDmzM/mqdefault.jpg)
!["OXYGEN" by TWICE [트와이스] - Filtered Vocals (Lead, Hidden, & ad-libs)](/img/tr.png)
!["MAKE ME GO" by TWICE [트와이스] - Filtered Vocals (Lead, Hidden, & ad-libs)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/CqUu3g_bM04/mqdefault.jpg)
![[REMAKE] TWICE (트와이스) - FORMULA OF LOVE | Album Distribution](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ebRUrJu0VzQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![PURPEECH - นี่ฉันเองคนที่... (It's me) [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/NuhHd0hOOg8/mqdefault.jpg)
I'm sorry this took so long. I got sick for days that I was unable to sit nor stand for too long...
My conclusion on the Post-chorus is that it's all Sophiya. This is what I think everytime I listen to it "It sounds so much like Chae for it to be Dahyun but it sounds so soft for it to be Chae"
Take care of yourself, hopefully you're feeling better
@@Oliver-uz1fs Thank u, I am feeling better now 🥰
@@AnDistribution at least Chae slngs it in the live version
@@zuleta333nobody sing it in live, Dahyun lipsync in all choruses, Chaeyoung only lipsync in the last chorus and for the choreography Dahyun is center in 1st and 2nd choruses and Sana is the center in the last.
@@DDP121 my life is a lie 😭
Yeah it is Sophia for sure, sadly for DubChae. This is one of those songs that no one can explain why producers would prefer use a background vocalist vocals when this could be perfectly sang by a member. In Brave I could barely understand why but here it just makes no sense.
Could be a lot of reasons maybe the girls don't have time to record all the layers of a song, maybe twice is not commited in terms fo recording but rather choose to put more time in the performance, maybe with a group so experimented it could be difficult to get some members do some things, maybe it's producers choice maybe they like the vibe given by the bg vocalists
Also i wanted to point out that a lot of TH-cam song production creators and analysts of recording love to analyse twice songs, you can find a lot of people who really like to analyze twice music but since late 2017 twice barely records bg vocals, most of the times are the bg vocalists doing those beautiful harmonies and things, i'm not saying anything but i find really interesting that people is interested so much in a group who barely have participation in the recording (excluding they are songwriters)
I want to clarify it's not bad to participate less in the recording production, at the end of the day they record the main vocals who everyone love it
Now that you filtered it, it sounds so mucb like Sophia
you've got to be kidding me, chaeng taking dahyun's first place in one more time is one thing but the fact that dahyun's first place in shadow was stolen by a fucking BACKGROUND VOCALIST boils my blood
The One More Time thing isn't 100% confirmed tho
@@corneiz_bp_tw8240But in fact is like that , everyone saw It and all the line diatributions are taking chae first
@@Kpop_Thinghz all of that is based off of ONE vocal analysis video from a channel who already questioned Dahyun's lines before
@@corneiz_bp_tw8240 Just because some questionable lines happen to involve Dahyun it doesn't take away credibility, most of those times it also affects JeongMiTzu
You're taking line distributions way too serious, also is not like Chaeyoung herself pointed to the producer with a gun and told them to not include Dahyun in the brige on purpouse, let's add to the fact that it just makes it even the grouping of MoSaChae and JeongMiDah to have the repeated chorus and a extra line
People swearing this was Chaeyoung acting as if it was another love foolish case, just because she's last in this distribution are propably still thinking its chae even though its clearly Sofia, just proves the obsession they have with finding every line to be Chaeyoung's, i made a whole analysis on the Fancy post-chrous, and a solo stan still commented it was Chaeyoung and that i was hating on her, i had to delete it.
I mean the fact that Chae only had a verse while everyone else has either two lines or in SaMoTzu case, one line and something else, and Dahyun a line and a repeated line in the post chorus, considering how often DaChae get paired together, it just made sense to the post chorus to be supposedly Chae, turns out is no one in twice for some reason
Also this video proofs better as well how in studio is Nayeon too
th-cam.com/video/U1RUQozXQcw/w-d-xo.htmlsi=MCasgkCDFw83CFCi
@@Oliver-uz1fs Yes it would make sense structurally, however is still pointless to assume cause Twice's all lines parts are rarely sung by any other member with the exception of Nahyo, it's mostly the background vocalist, unfortunately though 😑
In my opinion the post chorus its chae or dahyun
I agree, it's definitely Dahyun or Chae
But sophia did this in Brave too, I'm confused😂
@@Nahyo.Sophiya sounds a lot like them that’s why we tend to hear DubChaeng
@@kpopythings614fr, here sounds clearly Sophia than in other filters from others videos
@@DDP121 yes it’s definitely Sophiya
Next plot twist: The "I love you, hate foolish" lines in Love Foolish are also Sophia's 🥴
No, that's clear all Chae
@@snsdgivemetwice is a joke
Thankfully Sophiya isn't anywhere to be found in LF, is Yeonseo
I know it 😂 that's obsv SOPHIYA PAE like in the song "BRAVE" ☕😌
Who is sophia? 🤣
She is the credited background vocalist for this song (According to the Album Credits)
The 10th member