René Descartes - Meditation #1 - The Method of Doubt
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 ก.ค. 2024
- I am writing a book! If you want to know when it is ready (and maybe win a free copy), submit your email on my website: www.jeffreykaplan.org/
I won’t spam you or share your email address with anyone.
This is a lecture about the first of Descartes' six Meditations on First Philosophy. It is part an introduction to philosophy course. In this meditation, Descartes explains his plan for all six meditations, then explains how his method of doubt will allow him to temporarily cease to believe all the things that he cannot know for certain, and finally executes the first part of that plan. He goes through the basic principles which underly his beliefs, doubts those basic principles, and then wipes clean all of his previous beliefs. Most notably, Descartes discusses dream skepticism, or the possibility that he is dreaming, and malicious demon skepticism, or the possibility that he is being deceived by an evil genius or malicious demon.
Finally someone, specific, methodological, smart, good teacher, and as if that were not enough, with a neon blackboard!!!!!!!
Thanks!
You all prolly dont care at all but does any of you know a way to log back into an instagram account?
I somehow forgot the login password. I appreciate any tips you can give me.
@Kingston Douglas instablaster ;)
He was dismissive on some facts. Not good.
Absolutely right man ...
This is what I call HIGH-QUALITY lecture material.
What makes these lectures unique and interesting for me is that Jeffrey explains concepts in simple terms, as they should be, without resorting to jargon or using "sophisticated" words merely to flex his intellectual ability, as many others do (either consciously or unconsciously).
This is one of the best explained philosophy videos on TH-cam. You clearly have a natural gift at teaching. Please keep up the videos. I truly hope they get the views they deserve. Well done!
Thanks for these kind words. You just made my day!
I'm a student of Philosophy from Pakistan and you, sir, are a life saver. This is by far the best explanation on the subject. Thank you so much!
Hello
This guy is the most outstanding teacher I have ever known!!!❤
I am considering to start a philosophy study in my 50s. Thanks to you sir!
Wish I had professors like you back in my time.
I’m starting at 65!!!! And loving it ❤
I’m starting it at 40, and enjoying it immensely 😁
If you are listening to this lecture, have you not already begun with your studies?
Or do you mean specifically that you intend to take formal courses at some institute?
I’m 19, listening to this for my creative writing.
I Usually don't comment on teaching videos but this vid. Is the defention of perfection.
You've literally saved my life!!! Thank you so much for "employing all your energies" to explain us philosophy!!! God bless you
dude Jeffrey I'm eternally grateful to u
I study Politics, philosophy and Law. When i had a Jurisprudence essay, I found you, and now, I have an essay on Cartesian Philosophy and here u are again, explaining, and simplyifing everything..
Tanks bro&keep it up
Glad that I could help! The videos are all organized in the playlist section of my TH-cam page, if that's helpful as well.
Great video! I'm learning about Descartes right now and this is by far one of the best explanations I have seen!
Thanks! Glad it was helpful.
Amazing work. You speak so naturally and makes things so simple that makes me suspect that even your "whatevers" are planned.
I went to Oregon state university back in 1985 and didn’t have to but took philosophy as my humanities elective. I wanted to expand my mind I wasn’t concerned about taking the easiest course for grades. The philosophy program there at the time was known for not being an easy A. I took 3 courses and got got 2 B’s and the 3 rd one was the philosophy of math and got a D. The instructors were terrible. They would say a bunch of nothing at lecture then make a test about who knows what and feel superior because they were hard on students. I may have got 2 B’s and a D but I give them an F. Now this professor Kaplan is outstanding instructor I give him an A+. Much more along the lines of what I was looking for when I took my philosophy back in college.
This man’s ability to write backwards on glass is amazing! When I realized that he was writing backwards so that the audience facing him could read it, I was floored.
I was thinking the exact same thing ! is he actually writing backwards ?
I believe he mirrors his videos, otherwise, what a talent this man has
Yep, the videos are mirrored
really embarrassed i couldn't figure out the mirroring edit trick in my mind, kinda silly considering the course is supposed to improve thinking and logic and i can't even figure that out lols
@@vytasffbismarck7001 thats what the omnipotent demon wants you to think
Thank you for helping me pass my exam today! Best wishes.😊
I've been to this text a lot, but I must say that I've also learned a whole lot more from this video series. You are such an excelent teacher! Those deep and continuous explanations really help to break the dense philosophical ideas that pertain to Descartes. Thank you!
Thank you so much. Your video has helped me understand the text way better than I did, I watched the video and went back to the text to understand it way better. Online classes haven't been the best but watching your videos has made kept me sane to date. Thank you, I hope I get to learn from professors like you next semester.
you are a god! thank you for being clear and thorough with your teaching! i wish more teachers are like you
thank you for this, I intend on watching them all. i like how when you don't know something, exact year etc, you just say..."whatever," it's comical, relatable and refreshing.
So glad you put this stuff on youtube so everyone can see it really interesting for even us old non-students that never really thought about philosophy before.
Once again, I am so happy that you have made these lectures available. Thank you.
Jeffrey, thank you so much for putting time and effort into your content. I am studying philosophy in my senior year of high school and you have improved my understanding.
You are so animated, thank you for this wonderful breakdown of his first Meditation!
I've never taken too deep of a dive into most philosophers. This is my sixth video of yours without a break. Now I've got at least five more.
I started my new channel to pursue angles I hadn't before, came across this vid of yours because Descartes' philosophy was always such a fun ponder for me. What a great video, please continue pressing forward with your critical mind, the world needs it. Funny thing is I didn't even search Descartes, I was looking for more connections on two unrelated people. I love it!
What you're doing is very valuable, thank you very much.
"can he really write backwards?" that's when I know I need to take a break 😂 Thank you for the outstanding videos by the way!
They flipped the video. :)
@@hjominous Such a simple yet brilliant technique.
Thank you so very much! You're the best philosophy lecturer I've seen. 🌺
Thank you so much Jeffrey, you are opening a new world for me!
You’re a great teacher. Thanks for sharing these. Making my philosophy course easier and more interesting.
Explanation is at best , i think you are born to be the Master of Teaching , Great Work , Thanks a lot
We could be so much equipped with peace and happiness until such knowledge knocks our doors with a commander like you to impart the absolute beauty of wisdom and inculcate in us the very foundation of a reasoning ability which would serve as the absolute Lense of perceiving the world. The arsenal of thoughtfulness we synchronize our every breath with is undoubtedly the profoundness of a TEACHER in our lives.
Thank you, sir, for this. This here would be the sole proof fundamental in my persuasion of the world for how the social media could be so rewarding sometimes, such rewards are lifeward.
I wish you good health sir.
😄
Absolutely invaluable stuff here, much appreciated!!!
I also teach the méditations métaphysiques and would like to add a couple of points. Overall the work is one of the most extraordinary in literature because it operates on multiple levels. It is very frequently presented as a philosophical text; indeed it does present Descartes- philosophy, but it is also self evidently a work of fiction; he has invented the philosophical novel. To believe otherwise would be to believe that over a period of six days Descartes reconstructs the whole of philosophy (and presumably rests on the seventh day!).
More specifically on the malevolent demon, I think this is best read as an allegory for the possibility that the mind might be messed up, this could be by drugs, hypnotism possibly or more importantly by lesions to the brain that systemically produce mistakes. These are now well documented in clinical neuroscience.
By the way, thumbs up for your presentation.
@Chet Senior About any possible disorder to the mind.
The same Descartes believed in the separation of mind and body, and that god exists, leading me to think Descartes was being a magician, pretending to cast doubt on everything, then to sell us the existence of the soul, mathematics , and god. When none of them are real things. How ironic, if he was sincere. Don’t get me wrong, he was a good thinker, nevertheless deeply influenced by the doctrines of his time.
@@MugenTJ Persuaded by the primacy of thought over sensory experience, Descartes was a rationalist and a dualist, the rational existence of mathematics is inevitable; his account of the soul "je m´imaginais qu'elle était quelque chose d'extrêmement rare et subtil, comme un vent, une flamme ou un air très délié (rarefied)" portrays it as extremey insubstantial: it is as though he does not want to completely deny any material quality for it; for God he resorts (mostly) to a strange, rationalist, immaterial final cause argument. Did Descartes really believe his God arguments? We know he knew that denying God's existence would have been lethal, so it is hard to be sure at that level. He did, however, need to invoke God in order to escape the solipsism of his existence as 'a thinking thing'.
Where 'magic' is involved is in his dualism, how the immaterial world of ideas somehow manages to have material effects.
Prof. Kaplan is one of the most erudite guides into the otherwise impenetrable that I’ve had as a student.
A marvelous summation. Well done, sir, and thank you.
Very thorough and clear explanation done in the utmost logical order.
You are a great instructor, thank you for this philosophy video.
Time to learn philosophy! So grateful to have found the channel.
Thank you so much for this lecture! I didn't learn half as much in 6 Uni classes as i did in this 40 minute video.
Engaging personality and excellent teaching style. Thank you!
Mann,i am hooked to these lectures, I wish he was my professor, i would even attend University on Sundays,legit.
Jeffery you are adorable and brilliant, I love learning and listening to your lectures❤️
One of the best teacher you are ,thank you ,thank you going to consume you alot 🙏❤️
Thank you Professor, very interesting explanation
René Descartes - Meditation with The Method of Doubt 👍
Greetings from the BIG SKY. When I 1st attended Colorado College, I had to read Rene' Descarte's stuff. Hard reading for a Montana kid.
seriously Philosophy hasn't been this fun for me . I was literally laughing my ass out!. I have a humble suggestions for the audience that just go through the mediations before watching this for atleast once and listen Jeffrey Kalpan's great lecture you will obviously enjoying it. Hats of you Master! Thank you.
You’re my favorite person in this platform!
That was a great lecture. Thanks!
Amazing pedagogical skills! Thanks for these explanations.
Please tell me how you write everything backwards. I understand Descartes better than I understand how you are writing backwards.
thank you so much for this, much to learn!
You are hands down the funniest Philosopher 🤣 I was dying when you said "french pajamas or whatever".
Fantástico!!! I love this channel.
Truly the best channel
This is excellent!
Great lecture! This helped me a lot.
thought provoking presentation.
Very clear explanation. Thank you so much, Sir. This video was very helpful.
Thanks for this video. Keep up the great work!
Thanks, I will try!
Thanks a lot. You rocks!
Another amazing video. I'd like to add my voice to those that would welcome and be grateful for a lecture on Spinoza's ethics if you ever have the time and inclination.
Love you Sir ❤
Really helpful in understanding philosophy 💕
This was certainly useful!
Thank you! You explain it so much better than my philosophy professor. I wish you were my professor.
Thanks for the kind words. And glad I could help!
very enjoyable presentation great lecture makes one want to pursue this topic more and even read the book!
thank you so much!
Really great work! Thanks!
Glad you liked it!
This is the best thing on TH-cam. I want to take the exam, and I’m not even in the class!
(Just kidding… I don’t really want to take the exam)
You explained very well, thank you
Excellent, thanks much!
Love it❤️❤️
You are one of the best sir❤thank you
Sir i am frm India and firstly i watched the last meditation and it look like a awesome experience of descarts philosophy
Now i see all the lectures
Ujjwal bhai 🙏🙏🙏
How u know my name?
Many of the great movie in the last 100 years makes use of Decartes' "Method of Doubt" - Wizard of Oz, The Matrix, Inception, Fight Club etc
Don't forget Ridley Scott 's Blade Runner and Deckart ( Descartes).
I love you, respectively.
2:09 the funny thing is, meter is defined to be the distance light passes in 1/299 million something-something seconds, so technically that's guaranteed to be true; by definition.
i just found it really helpful from India
I don't believe anyone could write any better backwards, than this guy.
The video is flipped...he's right handed.
I have an exam about anthropology and Descartes first and second meditation tomorrow, this helped a lot. Thanks mate. PS: This made me laugh way harder then it should have 32:44
Glad I could help!
Thanks!
Enlightenment is the waking world equivalent of a lucid dream.
Ha! Without looking ahead on the list of lectures, I could see that "Cogito; ergo, sum" was coming next. (I'd thought about just that concept years ago.) I think I'm beginning to enjoy Philosophy thanks to Professor Kaplan.
love the channel
i absolutely love self educating since, being in an arts degree doesnt give me enough knowledge about philosophy and reading it is hard, being a non english speaker. so i really appreciate having free courses explained amazingly well :)
Funny thing, you can consider this work by Descartes as the kick off for a proces that eventually lead to the certainty that God does not exist. Good work, Rene. 😁😁
I've seen the number three.
It was a giant number three shouting at kids in a local park.
Anyways, this video lecture was fun and super interesting.
Off to the next video.
Cheers. :):)
This was so perfect, thank you so much. I understand the material so much better with your teaching style and tech.
Pedagogical wizard we salute you 🫡
I've never heard meditation 1 explained in more than a couple sentences, so this was nice. A question, though: why does it matter the respective rationales for the doubt? For example, it seems that everything could just be subsumed under "demon" and Descartes would lose nothing. Or, rather than being more specific, couldn't everything just be broadened: "Perception isn't always reality." What would be lost by just simplifying the reasons for doubt?
Loved the Video Professor Kaplan it helped a lot! - Michael Wiktorek
Glad it helped! check out the playlists section of my youtube channel for the organized list of the Descartes videos, and my other videos.
Estoy asistiendo por el subtitulo en español gracias por por el contenido!!
Thank u dr❤🇯🇴
This was funny and informative!
please make the audio mono. it's quite unsettling to listen the stereo boucing around unbalanced in this video :/
can you do the confessions of book 10 by saint augustine, and St. Auscln (something that which nothing is greater can be thought of)
love u bro
I too appreciate the clarity of the lecturer. After listening to the first lecture on Descartes First Meditation I think Ive got a grasp of Descartes project and his method of doubt. That said Im baffled by the lecturers conclusion that all Descartes beliefs have been doubted. Didn’t Descartes say that an all powerful demon might be able to deceive him but not God who is good. If I heard right then Rene has not doubted his belief in God. Or did I miss something which is quite possible. Id appreciate anyone correcting me if this is not so because if I got this right then Im not certain whether to believe the lecturer in his following lectures.
Well explained
Thank you❤
Michael Sugrue and Jeffrey Kaplan 👑