The judge was wrong. After all, the woman waited ten days or so to look at the damages. She also didn't allow the guy to make the repairs. He probably would have made the corrections. Again JM sided with Karen.
This guy was willing to fix what he had done wrong. Meanwhile, my neighbor takes a leaf blower every fall and blows his dead leaves and junk into an 8 food high pile for me to clean up every year, on my lawn.
Bag it up and then dump all the leaves on his porch, leave a note saying "I think this is yours. No need to thank me, just doing the neighborly thing and returning your property."
The defendant was negligent with respect to the varnish but I believe it was a legitimate mistake. But folks aren't neighborly in the way they use to be these days compared to how things were in the past. It's why I avoid as many people as possible these days. It's just not worth it.
A couple of months ago I had all my fences stained. He did it all with a brush. He told me that a sprayer doesn't do as good a job and always makes a mess. The fences look brand new and absolutely no stain got anywhere except on my fences. I hire this guy for everything outdoors and he is amazing. I'm so happy I have someone I can depend on to always do a fantastic job.
As soon as she said that about the snow, I got a bad feeling about her. I live in Maine and I let my neighbors push snow off their driveway onto my lawn. It would just be downright mean not to. There's nowhere else to put it.
I absolutely hate having neighbors. They would be fine if they would just stay within the confines of their own property. Life goal is to buy acreage away from close neighbors.
Doing that is a lovely idea, but remember someone is going to own land next to you. We have that problem actually. Have a cattle ranch in the mountains with a home on it, and have neighbors who don't have a house but have property near our 160 acres, and they have tried to cause problems aka trying to keep us from using the road to get to our property.
I 1000 PERCENT AGREE and I didn't realize it until I bought my first house next to two apartments complex and neighbors on the other side and back of me who I share a yard with🤦🏾♀️
Yessss!!! I don’t interact with my neighbors at all. I don’t want any neighbors so I am in the process now of finding a home with a few acres so I don’t have these problems. Lol
@@redgurl60 but she has a duty to mitigate her loss, in this instance the neighbours hired a contractor and she refused to let him do the work. Her claim ought to have been reduced to the amount the defendant had arranged a repairman at. She ought to have let him complete the work then sue if not happy
@@MW-kn1wp while every case is different tort law is very established. Whole mitigation is sometimes over used or misused I still feel that she acted unreasonable in this instance which is well here in Australia the true test.
Remove the Christian label and put a man in place of this woman... all of a sudden, it's a different picture. The scenario becomes: a man expects the neighbor to do a good repair job.
@@mabuhayPinay she had a chip on her shoulder ever since he ignored her complaint about the snow. And like the judge said She's not a siding expert. She should have let the repairman fix it
@@namewithheld7835 Go back at 5:11 and listen to how she made a request about the snow. It was said nicely and I don't think it's unreasonable to let a neighbor know if there are any issues with respect to keeping property in good order. It goes both ways. Allow a 'church lady' speak her mind... funny how people rise up in arms. Let's focus on how this fellow damaged her property and didn't have the nerve to knock on her door and take responsibility.
The judge should have looked at the estimates and picked one that is affordable and not only go with the one the plaintiff presented. Besides the defendant acted in good faith trying plan A to B to remedy the damage which he acknowledges. Judge Milan should have done better
People like her see the damage and smile because they got a chance to sue and manipulate the system to get more money. She’s probably done it a lot throughout her life.
She's right Abt wanting a contract. I don't blame her for that. He could sue her .and it's her house she can pick whoever she wants to fix. Not who the other person picks
I wouldn't want to be in the company of the plaintiff. She seems very argumentative and confrontational. She seems to be a horrible neighbor; tapping on the window to get someone's attention. I'm fortunate with neighbors and I know it; treat them well!
Please tell me alternatives for your neighbor to get your attention if your back is turned. Most people knock/tap on doors or windows. How is that messy?
@@panamafernandez4641 The man was outside and she was inside. She tapped on her window but he couldn't understand what she was saying. Many windows are double and triple-paned to cut down on the heat/cold/sound. It makes sense that he couldn't understand her. How about stepping outside to talk to him?
I'm mindblown over the negative comments about the Plaintiff. 1st of all she's as easy-going as they come, she had no attitude when she was told the neighbor caused damage. She took him at his word & didn't go looking to complain about any little thing. Meanwhile the Defendant lied & said he only damaged her fence. The Defendant didn't try to fix his mistake when it happened. If he had tried to pressure wash it happened, it might have come out, not 2 weeks or a month later. He didn't try to fix it until he was called out about it. He was absolutely out of order to send someone to work on her house without clearing with her first. This guy clearly has no respect, thinks he can do whatever he feels like & doesn't have to listen or ask for permission. Nevermind the sneaky that he tried to get it done when she wasn't home. The clear problem here is the majority trying to perpetuate the angry black woman bias, whenever she has the nerve to stick up for herself. The judge had the right ruling pay to fix her siding back to the way it was "before" you damaged it and you eat the costs for your arrogance. That's all folks
What did I miss? Was he throwing snow in her actual property? Or on the side of his own property? If it was his own, then what right does she have to tell her where he can put his snow? Just because her basement floods that her friggin problem not his. She obviously needed to pay someone to fix whatever her problem is. But if he tossed it onto her property then I understand.
Property Brothers is a bad TV show, not contractors or proof of good work. I'm with the lady. Nobody is going to work on my house without a contract. No, you don't let him work on your house without anything in writing.
i hate when litigants strategically use words like church or bible study during a court case . they are trying to help their case by trying to make the judge believe they are more honest than the average person but we all know better .
apart from the dudes at the back literally laughing so hard, did you see the lady in the front with pinkish red her at 1:02 dancing to the intro.🤣 that's a first for me
Ooohhhhh that lady just messed up BIG time. Now whenever it snows, he’s gonna push ALL the snow to that side. She should have just been more willing to be flexible.
Shes one of those elderly people that's been living in her house for decades And has an issue with anybody that moves in. Plus, didn't she say her daughter told her about the accident and she didn't immediately check in the beginning but then her daughter says he never said anything...😕. That was a bit off and surprised the judge didn't catch it
I mean I wouldn’t want someone to send a random man to work on my house unless I’ve seen reviews and references. I would want to find someone myself then get the quote myself and show it the guy. She may seem a little tough but she’s just not a slow old lady. I do think she could be a little nicer but she was in the right. Her husband should’ve been the one dealing with him IMO
did she say her husband was alive? she only indicated communications with her daughter, husband was in reference to the leaky basement, he could be deceased
Gotta say, I like the plaintiff. She’s an example of ‘she’s lived and learned’, ‘knowledge applied is wisdom’, and ‘an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure’. I have to respect her position on the defendant’s choice of contractor. She has to protect her property, and what could’ve gone wrong had he done a poor job. The defendant was very reasonable, a good guy. I hope they were able to be friendly, or at least civil, neighbors after this.
It is not cheap to get varnish off siding. Dude was into saving money and she knew it would cost. And even to replace the siding, it costs more if they can find the same type and color of the siding and install.
The defendant meant well by hiring a contractor to correct his mistake. The plaintiff is a Karen. Again, the judge was wrong. This gives the plaintiff more reason to be a jerk.
So the defendant ends up with $2200 less. I wonder how much it would have cost for a contractor to paint his fence? (Yet another victim of Bob Vila et al...)
They both seem like decent people. I tend to side more with the plaintiff on this one. As a homeowner, if you damage my property, specifically the siding on my house, you don't get to hire the cheapest person you can find. We're going with the original contractor.
I was thinking that’s what I would’ve done as well since she clearly was asking for a crap load of money for it, it’s like trying to meet her in the middle because we all know if he presented her with a $400-600 estimate she would’ve laughed in his face- she’s clearly even more picky than he expected
I still think us black people need to be more kinder to each other period and stop being so mean and rude to each other also and stop treating others better than we treat each other and stop being fake towards each other
She should invite him and his family to the next barbeque lol. He seems like a reasonable guy. Holding grudges with neighbours isn’t good. And she’s a Christian. What happened to love thy neighbour? 😄
You don’t have to like your neighbors, not all neighbors are likable, it’s not bad to hold grudges with neighbors or anyone else, people have the right to do so and they have the right to forgive someone or not , if they decide to forgive , they can do that on their own time, if they never forgive , then it’s their choice, depends on the two or more people involved and the situation
@@ebonyeyed08ti In the end being bitter or holding a grudge against anyone neighbor or not isn't a right of passage or healthy for anyone. Just because you can doesn't make it right or the high ground. People tend to treat each other the way that they want to be treated. Those that don't tend to be shunned or put in jail.
Many people these days take advantage of older folks. And get tricked out of their money. Be glad that she is that way. Many have been conned out of their house and savings.
@@ebonyeyed08ti "You don't have to like your neighbors/not all neighbors are likable" I think you have the most grounded comment. I used to have a neighbor who operated an "unpermitted" home business and his customers would come and park in front of my house. Did it for years! After many attempts to change that, I finally called the County on him and he got fined over $1000 -- and then even more problems ensued. And then there's the other neighbor who was like family to us (we comforted her husband who died, pet-sitting, plant-sitting, food exchanges, etc). Neighbors come in all packages. And like you said, it's not bad to hold a grudge. At least, you KNOW you are holding a grudge. Awareness is everything. Real forgiveness is rooted in awareness, otherwise it's only dismissal because "you are not supposed to have a grudge; it's bad for your well-being."
He paid a contractor to fix the damage and she wasn't satisfied with that. She's money hungry she wants more money then the damage's worth should of took what he offered.
Idk why y’all mad at the plaintiff keep it real if she would’ve let him screw up her house without pressing for a contract y’all would’ve been saying it’s her fault and the judge knows this as well she would’ve been grilling her about tissue and crayon but when someone does it they get shit for it still smh
I had a grouchy neighbor overspray his fence, a fence he made clear was 3 inches in on his property so it was “his” fence and he killed my rose garden 😏. He didn’t offer to pay for anything so I refused him access on my property to spray the next time.
I think these two were some of he most reasonable people who aren't bad people. The guy paid for his inexperience in how air painters work...they are nice ,but only in the right place and or conditions,no wind,and or no other objects around that you don't want to get paint on.🤪👌
Those of you coming for the plaintiff must not be homeowners. Lol she was absolutely right lol that's why the judge ruled in her favor. I do hope they are neighborly and have moved past this
WHAT? It was just a few splashes of varnish (stain), yet he has to replace the whole siding, why not just repaint it? How is that reasonable, what about the age of her siding? Why isn't that taken into account. What is going on with the judge to award her $1700 to get rid of a few splashes of varnish?...
I believe in grace, forgiveness and honor when dealing with a neighbor and especially from a church lady. She lacks all of those things and she’s not a kindly person but expects the same from others. She’s a Karen and you can tell he’s above it just to keep the peace but honestly they don’t always have to get their way especially if they lack the grace to return a favor in kind. She’s an asshole.
He damaged her house. He hired a contractor to work on her house without her permission. He thought he could bully her into doing what he wanted. And the judge shut him down.
@@goblueinga I don’t think he tried to bully her, she may not have agreed with the person he chose but at least he tried to fix it and it was an honest mistake. Of course no one likes their things to be damaged by others but she’s not going to die from it and he did the right thing by trying to fix it, people only know how to fix it correctly if they have been in that situation clearly that was his first time and she was honestly just mean even the judge said she could have been more neighborly when she described the first incident.
Defendant, normally contractors will charge the innocent people for the work they do. That is what was she was afraid off. You need to work on being a neighbor and remember that older people do not trust others, so try to visit and build a friendship with her then offer to repair the damage. And she was smart to the cheap contractor that she needed a contract before he touched her house. I do not blame her for yelling at a fool who was willing to work without a contract.
Right. He may have heard the voice but couldnt understand what she was saying. She's definitely that nasty nice person that hides behind Christianity to seem innocent.
Lol everyone saying she should invite him over, he’s a nice guy. Man Americans sound nice 😂 in Australia everyone ignores their neighbours hahahah you say a hello in the driveway at most here 😂
Actually, it’s the same in the USA; many people don’t know their neighbors names. In rural neighborhoods and in the southern states, it’s different. They know EVERYONE and speak to everyone. The downside? They also know everyone’s business!😁
@@4everThoughtful exactly!! We know our neighbours names lol but that’s just because 35 years ago my parents and both neighbours built their houses all the same time and have always lived in the houses since without moving. But never have we ever had a meal with them 😆
The worst I ever had was neighbors in a condo building. The people for the most part were great except for the clunky people who made awful noise after 11pm. The building was horribly unsound insulated. My single family and twin house never had a issue
For someone who didn't bother to look at the damages as soon as it was presented to her, she surely made a big deal out of the whole process!!
The judge was wrong. After all, the woman waited ten days or so to look at the damages. She also didn't allow the guy to make the repairs. He probably would have made the corrections. Again JM sided with Karen.
He can’t dictate who fixes her property.
I just knew she was going to work in her "Bible study class" into her testimony😂
🤣
As if studying the Bible automatically makes you a decent person.
She looking like she the president of the 1st usher board and does church announcements.
I love how the audience fills with laughter because of the witty commentary at the beginning of each case.
lol a staple of the show
I like when they laugh at what they said🤣not he called grandma a gold digger😅
love your utube username
The plaintiff is unreasonable in my eyes
This guy was willing to fix what he had done wrong. Meanwhile, my neighbor takes a leaf blower every fall and blows his dead leaves and junk into an 8 food high pile for me to clean up every year, on my lawn.
Blow it right bak over 😂
@@angelslive9651 That's what I would do. And not in a neat pile, either. But I'm kind of petty.
Bag it up and then dump all the leaves on his porch, leave a note saying "I think this is yours. No need to thank me, just doing the neighborly thing and returning your property."
@@angelslive9651 U a dang fool 🤣🤣🤣🤣. But u shol' right!
Put your foot down that's just SO inconsiderate!!!
The defendant was negligent with respect to the varnish but I believe it was a legitimate mistake. But folks aren't neighborly in the way they use to be these days compared to how things were in the past. It's why I avoid as many people as possible these days. It's just not worth it.
Are you sure that it's not everyone else is avoiding you because...you know...you're a racist, sexist, opinionated fool?
Same here.
Same Adrian. I go to work and come home to enjoy my peace !
That's why I live way in the country..no one around for miles.
You sure you avoid people, or do people avoid you? 😉
The Plaintiff sounds like a "pain in the you know what".. I feel bad for the Defendant!!!😔
A couple of months ago I had all my fences stained. He did it all with a brush. He told me that a sprayer doesn't do as good a job and always makes a mess. The fences look brand new and absolutely no stain got anywhere except on my fences. I hire this guy for everything outdoors and he is amazing. I'm so happy I have someone I can depend on to always do a fantastic job.
This lady is something else.
As soon as she said that about the snow, I got a bad feeling about her. I live in Maine and I let my neighbors push snow off their driveway onto my lawn. It would just be downright mean not to. There's nowhere else to put it.
The tool he was using was appropriate for the job. Doesn't require a saw. Saw just makes it faster for a bigger job
Oh thank god somebody else caught that
I’d hate for her to be my neighbor 😂
5:18 If he could respond, he heard me 🤣
Petty. He may not have heard clearly, had on headphones, whatever. The plaintiff if crochety as the old people say😂
I absolutely hate having neighbors. They would be fine if they would just stay within the confines of their own property. Life goal is to buy acreage away from close neighbors.
Me too! That's my life's goal too
please say it again! this is also a life goal of mine! I love and value PRIVACY!
Doing that is a lovely idea, but remember someone is going to own land next to you. We have that problem actually. Have a cattle ranch in the mountains with a home on it, and have neighbors who don't have a house but have property near our 160 acres, and they have tried to cause problems aka trying to keep us from using the road to get to our property.
I 1000 PERCENT AGREE and I didn't realize it until I bought my first house next to two apartments complex and neighbors on the other side and back of me who I share a yard with🤦🏾♀️
Yessss!!! I don’t interact with my neighbors at all. I don’t want any neighbors so I am in the process now of finding a home with a few acres so I don’t have these problems. Lol
I don't agree with this ruling , the plaintiff didn't mitigate her damages or even try to
This wasn't something that required mitigation. The damage was already done.
@@redgurl60 but she has a duty to mitigate her loss, in this instance the neighbours hired a contractor and she refused to let him do the work.
Her claim ought to have been reduced to the amount the defendant had arranged a repairman at.
She ought to have let him complete the work then sue if not happy
@@steviejpatrick you are using mitigation in the context you are using it completely wrong, maybe some real law classes would help you
@@MW-kn1wp while every case is different tort law is very established.
Whole mitigation is sometimes over used or misused I still feel that she acted unreasonable in this instance which is well here in Australia the true test.
It's kinds disgusting how these church ladies can talk a good game, but when they have to deal with it in real life it's a different story.
Remove the Christian label and put a man in place of this woman... all of a sudden, it's a different picture. The scenario becomes: a man expects the neighbor to do a good repair job.
@@mabuhayPinay she had a chip on her shoulder ever since he ignored her complaint about the snow. And like the judge said She's not a siding expert. She should have let the repairman fix it
Always been trash like that
@@namewithheld7835 Go back at 5:11 and listen to how she made a request about the snow. It was said nicely and I don't think it's unreasonable to let a neighbor know if there are any issues with respect to keeping property in good order. It goes both ways. Allow a 'church lady' speak her mind... funny how people rise up in arms. Let's focus on how this fellow damaged her property and didn't have the nerve to knock on her door and take responsibility.
Never trust a lady named Betty spelled “ Bettye “
Never trust dumb comments on TH-cam.
@@vadim7590 touché my friend lol
I know someone who insisted her name be spelled "Bettye". I thought "How uppity!" And she is as mean as a snake, just like this woman.
Tacos. ?
TACOS
Her brooch is adores💜
I also loved their jacket
He seems like a nice guy and she ms a nice woman, I hope they can put this all behind them once it's settled
She didn’t seem that nice to me. It’s not necessarily what you say but how you say it. Her tone was coming off as aggressive, IMO.
The judge should have looked at the estimates and picked one that is affordable and not only go with the one the plaintiff presented. Besides the defendant acted in good faith trying plan A to B to remedy the damage which he acknowledges. Judge Milan should have done better
Exactly she did agree to use his guy initially but kicked him off the property how is that the defendants fault.
I agree.
The reaction at 0:57 should be a meme of some sort.
She is not going to fix that lol 😂
People like her see the damage and smile because they got a chance to sue and manipulate the system to get more money. She’s probably done it a lot throughout her life.
She seems like a woman who just wants to keep her house in order
@@Ariel-uj3kk she seems like a bitter old woman
Nah, otherwise she would have checked the damage right away
Both plaintiff and defendant are dressed properly for court! I think this is a first!
She's right Abt wanting a contract. I don't blame her for that. He could sue her .and it's her house she can pick whoever she wants to fix. Not who the other person picks
I wouldn't want to be in the company of the plaintiff. She seems very argumentative and confrontational. She seems to be a horrible neighbor; tapping on the window to get someone's attention. I'm fortunate with neighbors and I know it; treat them well!
Exactly..U can tell she a Mess
Please tell me alternatives for your neighbor to get your attention if your back is turned. Most people knock/tap on doors or windows. How is that messy?
@@panamafernandez4641 The man was outside and she was inside. She tapped on her window but he couldn't understand what she was saying. Many windows are double and triple-paned to cut down on the heat/cold/sound. It makes sense that he couldn't understand her. How about stepping outside to talk to him?
🤨 don’t worry about the invitations to the barbecue sir. Peridot
Is it just me or did they take away all the skip videos to the ads and now you have to wait for them to end
I loved her reaction to the “gold digger” comment. I laughed out loud! 🤣
I'm mindblown over the negative comments about the Plaintiff. 1st of all she's as easy-going as they come, she had no attitude when she was told the neighbor caused damage. She took him at his word & didn't go looking to complain about any little thing. Meanwhile the Defendant lied & said he only damaged her fence. The Defendant didn't try to fix his mistake when it happened. If he had tried to pressure wash it happened, it might have come out, not 2 weeks or a month later. He didn't try to fix it until he was called out about it. He was absolutely out of order to send someone to work on her house without clearing with her first. This guy clearly has no respect, thinks he can do whatever he feels like & doesn't have to listen or ask for permission. Nevermind the sneaky that he tried to get it done when she wasn't home. The clear problem here is the majority trying to perpetuate the angry black woman bias, whenever she has the nerve to stick up for herself. The judge had the right ruling pay to fix her siding back to the way it was "before" you damaged it and you eat the costs for your arrogance. That's all folks
The plaintiff is so articulate.
The defendant is so sweet and polite!
I agree.
What did I miss? Was he throwing snow in her actual property? Or on the side of his own property? If it was his own, then what right does she have to tell her where he can put his snow? Just because her basement floods that her friggin problem not his. She obviously needed to pay someone to fix whatever her problem is. But if he tossed it onto her property then I understand.
Great judgement!!
Was it just ne or did anyone else thought he called her Betty Crocker?😄
I Thought That Too🤣😂🤣😂😂
If the defendant knew what he was doing he would have protected the other side of the fence from spray going over.
defendant. ;-)
Peace in the valley.. the plantiff wins.
Property Brothers is a bad TV show, not contractors or proof of good work. I'm with the lady. Nobody is going to work on my house without a contract.
No, you don't let him work on your house without anything in writing.
Exactly plenty of people have signed NDAs so they can't show the crappy work that is under it while it looks great
She should've got $800
He has more of a Christian attitude than her. She might need to do more homework in her Bible class
i hate when litigants strategically use words like church or bible study during a court case . they are trying to help their case by trying to make the judge believe they are more honest than the average person but we all know better .
She is a mess! He was nice!
We know all Good "Christians" are always nice and chipper!!
I thought judge said Betty Crocker 😂
apart from the dudes at the back literally laughing so hard, did you see the lady in the front with pinkish red her at 1:02 dancing to the intro.🤣 that's a first for me
I’m in the country so neighbors aren’t very close to each other. I’m on good terms with all my neighbors, thankfully.
Wow, I wouldn't sue my neighbor like she did. You've got to live beside each other and now it's going to go down. SMH
In which way has this woman not been neighborly?
Ooohhhhh that lady just messed up BIG time. Now whenever it snows, he’s gonna push ALL the snow to that side. She should have just been more willing to be flexible.
Shes one of those elderly people that's been living in her house for decades And has an issue with anybody that moves in. Plus, didn't she say her daughter told her about the accident and she didn't immediately check in the beginning but then her daughter says he never said anything...😕. That was a bit off and surprised the judge didn't catch it
Nice Defendant!
The plaintiff knows she ain’t gonna fix her house with any money that she would get! Can’t even be bothered to go and even look
Just like a car damaged by another driver in an accident, you get to choose where to get your repaired.
They guy has to walk the snow to the other side of his house? WHAT!!!!???
I didn’t understand that one either. And it sounds like she didn’t ask him nicely.
@@sushimitten yea and she said she just opened his window lol who does that 🤦🏾♀️
I mean I wouldn’t want someone to send a random man to work on my house unless I’ve seen reviews and references. I would want to find someone myself then get the quote myself and show it the guy. She may seem a little tough but she’s just not a slow old lady. I do think she could be a little nicer but she was in the right. Her husband should’ve been the one dealing with him IMO
did she say her husband was alive? she only indicated communications with her daughter, husband was in reference to the leaky basement, he could be deceased
Gotta say, I like the plaintiff. She’s an example of ‘she’s lived and learned’, ‘knowledge applied is wisdom’, and ‘an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure’. I have to respect her position on the defendant’s choice of contractor. She has to protect her property, and what could’ve gone wrong had he done a poor job.
The defendant was very reasonable, a good guy. I hope they were able to be friendly, or at least civil, neighbors after this.
I'd be happy to have defendant as a neighbor.
Are you single? 😂
It is not cheap to get varnish off siding. Dude was into saving money and she knew it would cost. And even to replace the siding, it costs more if they can find the same type and color of the siding and install.
Betty Crawford….such a timeless hollywoodesque name 😍😍😍
The defendant meant well by hiring a contractor to correct his mistake. The plaintiff is a Karen. Again, the judge was wrong. This gives the plaintiff more reason to be a jerk.
I think the judge is a Karen in real life.
She is a Karen but the judge isn’t wrong. The person who did the damage doesn’t get to tell you who will fix it or how much it will cost.
im a painter and this was a easy fix , and to paint the side of the house and the fence would have only probably cost around 800 total .
Are you a homeowner? Would you let someone else choose who gets to work on your house?
how is she a karen?
shes talking about bibble school... someone in church never talk about forgiveness.. maybe in the same bibble. ahahahhah
So the defendant ends up with $2200 less. I wonder how much it would have cost for a contractor to paint his fence?
(Yet another victim of Bob Vila et al...)
Probably $500 😫😂
There’s satisfaction in doing a job yourself; even if you make a mistake and it costs you more money. At least you learn from the mistakes.
They both seem like decent people. I tend to side more with the plaintiff on this one. As a homeowner, if you damage my property, specifically the siding on my house, you don't get to hire the cheapest person you can find. We're going with the original contractor.
Right. Because if that was my house I would be the same way
Why would you pick the highest price ? … that’s when I couldn’t trust him anymore
I was thinking that’s what I would’ve done as well since she clearly was asking for a crap load of money for it, it’s like trying to meet her in the middle because we all know if he presented her with a $400-600 estimate she would’ve laughed in his face- she’s clearly even more picky than he expected
Her face and eye roll at the gold digger comment. 😂
Lol did she learn about “Love thy neighbour” at bible class😂😂
I still think us black people need to be more kinder to each other period and stop being so mean and rude to each other also and stop treating others better than we treat each other and stop being fake towards each other
When you are old and set in your ways you don't see yourself as being difficult you only see what you want plain and simple.
She should invite him and his family to the next barbeque lol. He seems like a reasonable guy. Holding grudges with neighbours isn’t good. And she’s a Christian. What happened to love thy neighbour? 😄
What happened to be a good Judge of Character.
You don’t have to like your neighbors, not all neighbors are likable, it’s not bad to hold grudges with neighbors or anyone else, people have the right to do so and they have the right to forgive someone or not , if they decide to forgive , they can do that on their own time, if they never forgive , then it’s their choice, depends on the two or more people involved and the situation
@@ebonyeyed08ti In the end being bitter or holding a grudge against anyone neighbor or not isn't a right of passage or healthy for anyone.
Just because you can doesn't make it right or the high ground.
People tend to treat each other the way that they want to be treated.
Those that don't tend to be shunned or put in jail.
Many people these days take advantage of older folks. And get tricked out of their money. Be glad that she is that way. Many have been conned out of their house and savings.
@@ebonyeyed08ti "You don't have to like your neighbors/not all neighbors are likable" I think you have the most grounded comment. I used to have a neighbor who operated an "unpermitted" home business and his customers would come and park in front of my house. Did it for years! After many attempts to change that, I finally called the County on him and he got fined over $1000 -- and then even more problems ensued. And then there's the other neighbor who was like family to us (we comforted her husband who died, pet-sitting, plant-sitting, food exchanges, etc). Neighbors come in all packages. And like you said, it's not bad to hold a grudge. At least, you KNOW you are holding a grudge. Awareness is everything. Real forgiveness is rooted in awareness, otherwise it's only dismissal because "you are not supposed to have a grudge; it's bad for your well-being."
When she finally saw what has happen she went for his tired azz
He paid a contractor to fix the damage and she wasn't satisfied with that. She's money hungry she wants more money then the damage's worth should of took what he offered.
Idk why y’all mad at the plaintiff keep it real if she would’ve let him screw up her house without pressing for a contract y’all would’ve been saying it’s her fault and the judge knows this as well she would’ve been grilling her about tissue and crayon but when someone does it they get shit for it still smh
I had a grouchy neighbor overspray his fence, a fence he made clear was 3 inches in on his property so it was “his” fence and he killed my rose garden 😏. He didn’t offer to pay for anything so I refused him access on my property to spray the next time.
I think these two were some of he most reasonable people who aren't bad people. The guy paid for his inexperience in how air painters work...they are nice ,but only in the right place and or conditions,no wind,and or no other objects around that you don't want to get paint on.🤪👌
Those of you coming for the plaintiff must not be homeowners. Lol she was absolutely right lol that's why the judge ruled in her favor. I do hope they are neighborly and have moved past this
If I were her neighbor, I’d avoid her like a case of monkey pox. Her tone is harsh and she kept interrupting. She seems confrontational.
Eh. Plaintiff was a little too unreasonable and didn’t try to work with him at all.
I enjoy Judge Mil's cases but she over talks the litigants & cuts them off way toooo much 😩
WHAT? It was just a few splashes of varnish (stain), yet he has to replace the whole siding, why not just repaint it? How is that reasonable, what about the age of her siding? Why isn't that taken into account. What is going on with the judge to award her $1700 to get rid of a few splashes of varnish?...
I believe in grace, forgiveness and honor when dealing with a neighbor and especially from a church lady. She lacks all of those things and she’s not a kindly person but expects the same from others. She’s a Karen and you can tell he’s above it just to keep the peace but honestly they don’t always have to get their way especially if they lack the grace to return a favor in kind. She’s an asshole.
Lol I don’t know about the name lol but she definitely has a mean spirit
He damaged her house. He hired a contractor to work on her house without her permission. He thought he could bully her into doing what he wanted. And the judge shut him down.
@@goblueinga I don’t think he tried to bully her, she may not have agreed with the person he chose but at least he tried to fix it and it was an honest mistake. Of course no one likes their things to be damaged by others but she’s not going to die from it and he did the right thing by trying to fix it, people only know how to fix it correctly if they have been in that situation clearly that was his first time and she was honestly just mean even the judge said she could have been more neighborly when she described the first incident.
The guy at the end, what a real man, that woman needs to take some chill pills
please skip the tmz section . it’s not needed
Defendant, normally contractors will charge the innocent people for the work they do. That is what was she was afraid off. You need to work on being a neighbor and remember that older people do not trust others, so try to visit and build a friendship with her then offer to repair the damage. And she was smart to the cheap contractor that she needed a contract before he touched her house. I do not blame her for yelling at a fool who was willing to work without a contract.
Terrible church goer
He's not too bright or competent, but at least he's pleasant and honest
Finally people react to the commentary 🤣
Karma will come for her. She should be careful in her old age. If you’re wondering why I say this. It was that gotcha look and smirk at the end.
The guy behind the plaintiff in the glasses, looks like Mclovin from the movie Super Bad.
I think the judge screwed that up. The old lady was rude.
It was an accident.let him pay.thank you.have a good day.
The plaintiff is annoying af
Omg I would Not want her for my neighbor 🤦🏽♀️
She is a Karen.
That lady is a clear problem you can tell. I yelled Sir an he said he can’t hear me. If you replied then you can hear me 😑😑
Right. He may have heard the voice but couldnt understand what she was saying. She's definitely that nasty nice person that hides behind Christianity to seem innocent.
I hope they become good neighbors. They tried.
Judge Karen would have asked the plaintiff, Why are you telling me about Bible Class? ajajajajaja 😂
Plaintiff's name is a cross between Bette Davis and Joan Crawford, who were sworn enemies of each other!
“Invite him to the bbq” sound so racist to me 🤦🏾♀️
FOH
Lol everyone saying she should invite him over, he’s a nice guy. Man Americans sound nice 😂 in Australia everyone ignores their neighbours hahahah you say a hello in the driveway at most here 😂
Actually, it’s the same in the USA; many people don’t know their neighbors names. In rural neighborhoods and in the southern states, it’s different. They know EVERYONE and speak to everyone. The downside? They also know everyone’s business!😁
@@4everThoughtful exactly!! We know our neighbours names lol but that’s just because 35 years ago my parents and both neighbours built their houses all the same time and have always lived in the houses since without moving. But never have we ever had a meal with them 😆
The worst I ever had was neighbors in a condo building. The people for the most part were great except for the clunky people who made awful noise after 11pm. The building was horribly unsound insulated. My single family and twin house never had a issue
He ain't coming to the barbeque
she is rude and unreasonable.
I can’t believe the plaintiff won lol and she wanted her court costs too
I bet he put the snow on that side every time now so it leaks into her basement 1700 wow just to repair painted siding.
So her house is ruined, but it will cost $1700 to fix it?
If the snow is mommy propertyit ain’t my fault it melts and gets in ur house! Fix ur foundation
Lol the little sheers he was using is actually used to cut siding.
Yeah they are but she wasn't looking to fix the problem just make it worse until she ends up in court,it was never going to end any other way.
The plaintiff was a stuck up old scammer,who was just after extra cash.