Harry Potter Show BAD NEWS...

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 ม.ค. 2025

ความคิดเห็น • 276

  • @WesWorldYT
    @WesWorldYT  3 วันที่ผ่านมา +4

    Who is your ULTIMATE fan casting for Albus Dumbledore? Let me know, Like and SUBSCRIBE if you enjoyed this video!

    • @AdmiralBeethoven
      @AdmiralBeethoven 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

      Ian McKellen

    • @ladylizzie3
      @ladylizzie3 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Jude Law!

    • @maneldotalho
      @maneldotalho 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Ciarán Hinds, could a be solid choice.

    • @RaAaAwrsyourEye
      @RaAaAwrsyourEye 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      you cannot beat Ian Mckellen, but... he's 85 years old and I doubt it would be cheap to cast him, Patrick Stewart would be a close second, but its the same problem.

    • @andypartridge800
      @andypartridge800 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +3

      Stephen Fry would be awesome, after doing the audio books. Hell, the book even describes Dumbledore as having his nose broken at least twice.

  • @thecosmicaesthetic
    @thecosmicaesthetic 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +128

    That dude can act, cast him as Kingsley. Kingsley is the MF man

    • @acid0428
      @acid0428 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +16

      that's what I'm thinking. like I don't have a problem with him, give him Kingsley and that's great, I just don't want him as Snape to be honest

    • @oliviakrause3336
      @oliviakrause3336 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      ​@@acid0428Yeah, cause you're racist.

    • @coenfealy4731
      @coenfealy4731 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +6

      I love Kingsley!

    • @yakirchernin6015
      @yakirchernin6015 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Since they already change things around anyway, so could put more Kingsley. For example, Kingsley can replace Moddy and serve the same role as a super aurorer

    • @loganmiller6879
      @loganmiller6879 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@yakirchernin6015 Nah, just flesh out Kingsley more instead of cutting out Moody. More stuff can be added to enrich the storyline without completely changing the source material in a significant way

  • @justinwhorton8893
    @justinwhorton8893 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +50

    Please just stop! We don’t want a reboot we want the marauders, the founders, the first wizarding war there are so many more stories to tell

    • @Jay_Kiba
      @Jay_Kiba 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Honestly! What are they thinking aha

    • @Linkskyfyre
      @Linkskyfyre 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      That would require competent hollywood writers since there is no real source material to rip from. That's way too much work for them when they can just take the books again and utilize that.

    • @chrissnyder4439
      @chrissnyder4439 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      Why not all of it? Sure, I'd love to a series based on those as well, but I am happy to see a faithful adaptation of the books.

    • @brettbarton2370
      @brettbarton2370 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Agreed. How are people so stupid? Every reboot that comes out flops like hell. Why do they think anything else will happen with this terrible idea of a reboot? Plus, the way not to be racist is . . . not to be racist. Going out of their way to select a varying degree of races for the sake of their race. . . IS RACIST!

    • @ayiza8511
      @ayiza8511 วันที่ผ่านมา

      right?! besides prequels has less chance of flopping, we dont have anything to compare whit. while ever actor and actress in this reboot will be compared to the movies. they could have easily have done a show about the first wizening were, show us the marauders and characters like Voldemort, Lucius and bellatrix in their prime. the first war was darker than the second

  • @Garry-f4j
    @Garry-f4j 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +59

    If they race swap Snape, it will give his childhood disagreements with others in his year a distasteful overtone and detract from the original Dark Arts intention of it. I know its 'on trend' to bring race into everything, but this is a can of worms that really should be left alone.

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +4

      No, you can't ignore the fact that Snape was black in the original J.K.B. Rollin' manuscript, Harry Potlover and The Sorcerers Joint!
      Snape gon' enter the class saying:
      "Yo, yo, yo! Snapey Boy's in the hood! 🧙🏿‍♂️
      Sit you ass down or I'll whoop it real good! 🎾🍑
      Open page 364 of Advanced Potion Makin'! 📖
      We gon' cook some sleepin' draught, it's got the highest ratin'! 🧪⚗️
      Put Potter in a sleep from which he'll never be wakin'! ⚰️
      Yo! Yo! Uh! Light it up! 🚬
      Polyjuice Potion or a draught of peace,
      Veritaserum, if ya'll don't trust your neice,
      Fame in a bottle,
      Neville boy, he gon' get throttled ,
      Liquid luck to save you from a bloodthirsty hag,
      Hermione granger is a hoe bag!
      Skelegro or a cure for boils,
      I put Ron Weasely in a vat of hot oil!
      Now that ya'll know my evil plans, I'm signin' out,
      Snape Doggy dog, I'm yo' man!
      ×Peace×

    • @genohall2235
      @genohall2235 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Trying to be Racist.?

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @genohall2235 Interesting how the only terms that a tik-tok trained, reddit washed and instagram taught mind can produce are...
      -Racist
      -Body shame
      -"Cancel him/her!"
      -Rizz
      -Skibidi
      Not alot goin' on up there, huh?

    • @flugsven
      @flugsven 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      Ps. Could he play Hamlet, Prince of Denmark he can play Snape.

    • @genohall2235
      @genohall2235 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      @@flugsven
      At least this way he won’t be a carbon copy of Rickman…

  • @sf808yt
    @sf808yt 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +106

    A diverse cast for "modern audiences"? If that is their priority, then this will be yet another flop.

    • @oliviakrause3336
      @oliviakrause3336 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      Because you're racist.

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Snape gon' enter the class saying:
      "Yo, yo, yo! Snapey Boy's in the hood! 🧙🏿‍♂️
      Sit you ass down or I'll whoop it real good! 🎾🍑
      Open page 364 of Advanced Potion Makin'! 📖
      We gon' cook some sleepin' draught, it's got the highest ratin'! 🧪⚗️
      Put Potter in a sleep from which he'll never be wakin'! ⚰️
      Yo! Yo! Uh! Light it up! 🚬
      Polyjuice Potion or a draught of peace,
      Veritaserum, if ya'll don't trust your neice,
      Fame in a bottle,
      Neville boy, he gon' get throttled ,
      Liquid luck to save you from a bloodthirsty hag,
      Hermione granger is a hoe bag!
      Skelegro or a cure for boils,
      I put Ron Weasely in a vat of hot oil!
      Now that ya'll know my evil plans, I'm signin' out,
      Snape Doggy dog, I'm yo' man!
      ×Peace×

    • @carolynbrubaker1619
      @carolynbrubaker1619 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      The books were diverse.

    • @brettbarton2370
      @brettbarton2370 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

      Yeah. People are . . . Riddikulus!

    • @loganmiller6879
      @loganmiller6879 วันที่ผ่านมา +6

      @@carolynbrubaker1619 yeah, but snape was not black

  • @thoughtfulwatcher
    @thoughtfulwatcher 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +25

    If they cast Papa as Snape, they should get Peter Dinklage for Kingsley Shacklebolt.

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Snape gon' enter the class saying:
      "Yo, yo, yo! Snapey Boy's in the hood! 🧙🏿‍♂️
      Sit you ass down or I'll whoop it real good! 🎾🍑
      Open page 364 of Advanced Potion Makin'! 📖
      We gon' cook some sleepin' draught, it's got the highest ratin'! 🧪⚗️
      Put Potter in a sleep from which he'll never be wakin'! ⚰️
      Yo! Yo! Uh! Light it up! 🚬
      Polyjuice Potion or a draught of peace,
      Veritaserum, if ya'll don't trust your neice,
      Fame in a bottle,
      Neville boy, he gon' get throttled ,
      Liquid luck to save you from a bloodthirsty hag,
      Hermione granger is a hoe bag!
      Skelegro or a cure for boils,
      I put Ron Weasely in a vat of hot oil!
      Now that ya'll know my evil plans, I'm signin' out,
      Snape Doggy dog, I'm yo' man!
      ×Peace×

    • @thedrunkweddingphotographer
      @thedrunkweddingphotographer 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      for real

  • @maneldotalho
    @maneldotalho 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +53

    They need to be carefull, because IN CANON Snape is bullied by the Maraudes, he is ,IN CANON, racist towards Lilly and he is not the most friendly to Petunia.
    And that can leave a a bad taste in many people mouths.
    For me, I am fine with any choice they make as long they can bring book Snape to the screen.

    • @thomasskywalker8893
      @thomasskywalker8893 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Don’t forget that Lilly doesn’t want to date a black guy… and James goes from bully to racist!

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Snape gon' enter the class saying:
      "Yo, yo, yo! Snapey Boy's in the hood! 🧙🏿‍♂️
      Sit you ass down or I'll whoop it real good! 🎾🍑
      Open page 364 of Advanced Potion Makin'! 📖
      We gon' cook some sleepin' draught, it's got the highest ratin'! 🧪⚗️
      Put Potter in a sleep from which he'll never be wakin'! ⚰️
      Yo! Yo! Uh! Light it up! 🚬
      Polyjuice Potion or a draught of peace,
      Veritaserum, if ya'll don't trust your neice,
      Fame in a bottle,
      Neville boy, he gon' get throttled ,
      Liquid luck to save you from a bloodthirsty hag,
      Hermione granger is a hoe bag!
      Skelegro or a cure for boils,
      I put Ron Weasely in a vat of hot oil!
      Now that ya'll know my evil plans, I'm signin' out,
      Snape Doggy dog, I'm yo' man!
      ×Peace×

    • @alephnulI
      @alephnulI วันที่ผ่านมา +3

      Yeah, I was thinking that. The way Snape is treated in the books by everyone in general, even students. It would reframe everything, and potentially make everyone on Gryffindor suddenly look extremely racist.

  • @chasebishop309
    @chasebishop309 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +46

    (for context i am not a white guy)
    i am tried of studios pushing race changes. i grew up with many characters who have been race swapped and just because they might look like me doesn’t mean im gonna go watch it. i dont care if someone looks like me, i just want them to be as accurate as possible
    i personally think the whole diversity movement in entertainment is the reason for many new film failures

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      No way!
      I love Black Snape!
      Snape Dogg gon' enter the class saying:
      "Yo, yo, yo! Snapey Boy's in the hood! 🧙🏿‍♂️
      Sit you ass down or I'll whoop it real good! 🎾🍑
      Open page 364 of Advanced Potion Makin'! 📖
      We gon' cook some sleepin' draught, it's got the highest ratin'! 🧪⚗️
      Put Potter in a sleep from which he'll never be wakin'! ⚰️
      Yo! Yo! Uh! Light it up! 🚬
      Polyjuice Potion or a draught of peace,
      Veritaserum, if ya'll don't trust your neice,
      Fame in a bottle,
      Neville boy, he gon' get throttled ,
      Liquid luck to save you from a bloodthirsty hag,
      Hermione granger is a hoe bag!
      Skelegro or a cure for boils,
      I put Ron Weasely in a vat of hot oil!
      Now that ya'll know my evil plans, I'm signin' out,
      Snape Doggy dog, I'm yo' man!
      ×Peace×

    • @coenfealy4731
      @coenfealy4731 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +4

      Yeah you sound exactly like me (I’m white but strongly agree)

    • @Pantierina
      @Pantierina 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      ​@midnightrealmbooks You do know that the majority of black people don't talk like that, right?

    • @genohall2235
      @genohall2235 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Black people invented rock and roll why don’t you remake a Beatles song they stole from black artists anyway…

    • @Cissy.M4LFOY
      @Cissy.M4LFOY วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@midnightrealmbookswhat the hell is wrong with you?

  • @kimrowlinson4406
    @kimrowlinson4406 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +25

    Snape is described as having skin the colour of sour milk and also the colour of white marble the one character that’s colour is stated is him. Have Papa in the series as Kingsley

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      No, no, no.
      Black Snape all da way, yo!
      Snape gon' enter the class saying:
      "Yo, yo, yo! Snapey Boy's in the hood! 🧙🏿‍♂️
      Sit you ass down or I'll whoop it real good! 🎾🍑
      Open page 364 of Advanced Potion Makin'! 📖
      We gon' cook some sleepin' draught, it's got the highest ratin'! 🧪⚗️
      Put Potter in a sleep from which he'll never be wakin'! ⚰️
      Yo! Yo! Uh! Light it up! 🚬
      Polyjuice Potion or a draught of peace,
      Veritaserum, if ya'll don't trust your neice,
      Fame in a bottle,
      Neville boy, he gon' get throttled ,
      Liquid luck to save you from a bloodthirsty hag,
      Hermione granger is a hoe bag!
      Skelegro or a cure for boils,
      I put Ron Weasely in a vat of hot oil!
      Now that ya'll know my evil plans, I'm signin' out,
      Snape Doggy dog, I'm yo' man!
      ×Peace×

    • @CaptnJack
      @CaptnJack 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      If you must be race oriented, then look at the books and see what they say, and match as you can, rather than enforce your racism. If Snape is palid then he should be. if Lila Brown has darker skin in the book, then she should in movie/tv. Just do it.

    • @armak7774
      @armak7774 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@midnightrealmbooks sit down 🤡

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@armak7774 Wut?

  • @elizabethshinault4867
    @elizabethshinault4867 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +84

    The actor who may play Snape should not make the mistake of emulating Alan Rickmans’ performance, but make the role his own.

    • @BeastBoyTitan28
      @BeastBoyTitan28 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +5

      If we're going thru all this... I actually agree. That will make us dislike the newly casted character even more.

    • @Nitroh-
      @Nitroh- 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

      Of course, as should be the case for every cast member. They will never top or beat the performance of the actor who came before them, but if we have to deal with this reboot, making the role their own version of it as long as the actor keeps it in line with the source material is fine. If the actor tries to replicate the previous it might end up being a mess cause no matter how it turns out people are going to compare anyway, but as long as the casting isn't woke, and the director and script writers stay to the source material I'm willing to watch.

    • @rach5516
      @rach5516 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

      The problem is, Alan was completely true to the character.

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

      I totally agree with you, he should enter the class saying:
      "Yo, yo, yo! Snapey Boy's in the hood! 🧙🏿‍♂️
      Sit you ass down or I'll whoop it real good! 🎾🍑
      Open page 364 of Advanced Potion Makin'! 📖
      We gon' cook some sleepin' draught, it's got the highest ratin'! 🧪⚗️
      Put Potter in a sleep from which he'll never be wakin'!
      Yo! Yo! Uh! Light it up! 🚬
      Polyjuice Potion or a draught of peace,
      Veritaserum, if ya'll don't trust your neice,
      Fame in a bottle,
      Neville boy, he gon' get throttled ,
      Liquid luck to save you from a bloodthirsty hag,
      Hermione granger is a hoe bag!
      Skelegro or a cure for boils,
      I put Ron Weasely in a vat of hot oil!
      Now that ya'll know my evil plans, I'm signin' out,
      Snape Doggy dog, I'm yo' man!

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@rach5516 Not as true as Papa gon' be! Snape was and will always be black! No one can take that away from him!

  • @artursandwich1974
    @artursandwich1974 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    I am sure Daniel Radcliffe would make a wonderful Snape. Having seen him in a few adult roles I am in awe for his range and thespian skills (there's no point talking about his talent because now he's already holding a well-honed skill set)

  • @kimrowlinson4406
    @kimrowlinson4406 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +12

    There are millions of Harry Potter fans around the world that want to see the series true to the book and forget what the films

  • @AlexanderLongacre182
    @AlexanderLongacre182 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +45

    I am not an absolute purist, but I think if the premise and promise is to “be faithful to the books” , be faithful to the books down to how a character is described.

    • @amberbanuelos7053
      @amberbanuelos7053 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +7

      Exactly. The new Snape does not have a hooked nose. He can have a wig for the hair, but the fact is Snape’s large, hooked nose is a very defining physical feature and the actor just doesn’t have one. I’m sure he’s a great actor, but he’s just not a book-accurate depiction of Snape, and we were told the whole point of doing the series was to be more accurate to the books.

    • @matejmatuska6700
      @matejmatuska6700 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@amberbanuelos7053 we are in modern age they can add the nose in post editing since its not that hard in my opinion dumbledore has broken nose and they will have to make it too so it will make sense to make characters be played by actors that can act for mainly a double agent character and another thing is that they can change actor of snape anytime since they didnt start shooting and even if they do there is always a chance they will have to recast faitfull to the books isnt always best in terms of aperance of characters some things will look better as cgi effect than having actors that cant act mainly as proffesors

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      I disagree, yo!
      Snape gon' enter the class saying:
      "Yo, yo, yo! Snapey Boy's in the hood! 🧙🏿‍♂️
      Sit you ass down or I'll whoop it real good! 🎾🍑
      Open page 364 of Advanced Potion Makin'! 📖
      We gon' cook some sleepin' draught, it's got the highest ratin'! 🧪⚗️
      Put Potter in a sleep from which he'll never be wakin'! ⚰️
      Yo! Yo! Uh! Light it up! 🚬
      Polyjuice Potion or a draught of peace,
      Veritaserum, if ya'll don't trust your neice,
      Fame in a bottle,
      Neville boy, he gon' get throttled ,
      Liquid luck to save you from a bloodthirsty hag,
      Hermione granger is a hoe bag!
      Skelegro or a cure for boils,
      I put Ron Weasely in a vat of hot oil!
      Now that ya'll know my evil plans, I'm signin' out,
      Snape Doggy dog, I'm yo' man!
      ×Peace×

    • @coenfealy4731
      @coenfealy4731 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@amberbanuelos7053neither did rickman also prosthetics

    • @amberbanuelos7053
      @amberbanuelos7053 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      @@coenfealy4731 no, that was Rickman’s nose. Give him a Google, you’ll see his nose looked the same in his other films as it did in the HP films.

  • @martynamaczyszyn
    @martynamaczyszyn 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    To be honest, I will be among those who're gonna have a problem reconciling the casting of Paapa Essiedu as Snape, should he end up taking the role. And it's solely due to the fact his appearance doesn't fit the bill, when compared to the book description. But like you said, it's not the actor himself I'll be having the beef with, but the show's casting department instead. Also, as someone has already proposed in the comments, Essiedu would be a perfect casting for Kingsley, ngl... because damn, the guy can, indeed, act.

  • @Nitroh-
    @Nitroh- 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +28

    With casting, they can not and should not race swap or gender swap characters under any circumstances! Woke is killing media franchises and needs to stay tf away from Harry Potter, especially with main cast! This reboot should not exist in the first place, but it needs to remain faithful to the books, that is essential, no iffs buts or maybes, either that or just cancel it now cause the HP fandom isn't gonna let it slide.

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Snape gon' enter the class saying:
      "Yo, yo, yo! Snapey Boy's in the hood! 🧙🏿‍♂️
      Sit you ass down or I'll whoop it real good! 🎾🍑
      Open page 364 of Advanced Potion Makin'! 📖
      We gon' cook some sleepin' draught, it's got the highest ratin'! 🧪⚗️
      Put Potter in a sleep from which he'll never be wakin'! ⚰️
      Yo! Yo! Uh! Light it up! 🚬
      Polyjuice Potion or a draught of peace,
      Veritaserum, if ya'll don't trust your neice,
      Fame in a bottle,
      Neville boy, he gon' get throttled ,
      Liquid luck to save you from a bloodthirsty hag,
      Hermione granger is a hoe bag!
      Skelegro or a cure for boils,
      I put Ron Weasely in a vat of hot oil!
      Now that ya'll know my evil plans, I'm signin' out,
      Snape Doggy dog, I'm yo' man!
      ×Peace×

  • @layneathebutterfly4959
    @layneathebutterfly4959 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +9

    I personally want Peter Capaldi as Dumbledore. He can absolutely be that calm wise grandfather figure and he can definitely switch to a fierce Firey man. Where you can have this line from the book.
    -For the first time Harry understood why Dumbledore was the only one Voldemort ever feared.
    If you doubt me watch Doctor who
    I specifically enjoy hist softer moments like his last episode.

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Snape gon' enter the class saying:
      "Yo, yo, yo! Snapey Boy's in the hood! 🧙🏿‍♂️
      Sit you ass down or I'll whoop it real good! 🎾🍑
      Open page 364 of Advanced Potion Makin'! 📖
      We gon' cook some sleepin' draught, it's got the highest ratin'! 🧪⚗️
      Put Potter in a sleep from which he'll never be wakin'! ⚰️
      Yo! Yo! Uh! Light it up! 🚬
      Polyjuice Potion or a draught of peace,
      Veritaserum, if ya'll don't trust your neice,
      Fame in a bottle,
      Neville boy, he gon' get throttled ,
      Liquid luck to save you from a bloodthirsty hag,
      Hermione granger is a hoe bag!
      Skelegro or a cure for boils,
      I put Ron Weasely in a vat of hot oil!
      Now that ya'll know my evil plans, I'm signin' out,
      Snape Doggy dog, I'm yo' man!
      ×Peace×

    • @gegamst7323
      @gegamst7323 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

      Good choice. If not him, maybe Hugh Laurie? He can do both the stern and whimsical part of Dumbledor, and he's a great actor.

  • @alexandraboaru
    @alexandraboaru วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    Unlike other stories where they could excuse the race swap because there were no characters of a different races, that’s not the case in the Harry Potter universe, since there are other races in that universe, so the race swapping makes no sense for me for some characters if you have other roles to fill for that race that would be accurate with the character descriptions. I would like them to be faithful to the books and the descriptions.

  • @christopherhansson5854
    @christopherhansson5854 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +26

    Personally I think they make a huge mistake in filming this at all. It would make so much sense in animating the series. Here are my reasons:
    1. This will be a longwinded series in serveral ways, both that they need to secure actors that can remain for at least seven years. That includes both child actors that will age rapidly and elderly actors that sadly might pass during production (eg dumbledore, macgonagal, ollivander, hagridetc) . Then we also must consider that there are certain rules when it comes to child actors concerning allowed time on set.
    2. Effects, such as spells and creatures, will be hard to keep to consistent and timeless quality over the span of the series. Consider that there will be developments in both formats, but by animating the series, it will be easier to lock down a certain style that will not feel dated if you were to rewatch the entire series later on
    3. You are free to do as described in the books. This one is related to point 2, where animation will allow for a certain wimsy in characters, style, design etc.
    4. By animating, the series will become its own thing instead of being compared to the amazing job that was done in the movies. Let's face the facts, no matter who is cast, there will be controversy and the actor will have a pair of humongous shoes to fill.
    5. Might be easier to adjust for the international crowd. Eg is it the Sorcerer's stone or the Philosopher's stone? Also what would be the anagram for voldemort? Etc
    This is just my thoughts on this

    • @Lamarbear616
      @Lamarbear616 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +3

      It would be amazing to see a Harry Potter series animated in a style similar to the arcane series.

    • @birichinaxox9937
      @birichinaxox9937 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

      Yer in the style of the last airbender would be great and compelling

    • @kiriyubel
      @kiriyubel 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      I agree with this SO MUCH.

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Snape gon' enter the class saying:
      "Yo, yo, yo! Snapey Boy's in the hood! 🧙🏿‍♂️
      Sit you ass down or I'll whoop it real good! 🎾🍑
      Open page 364 of Advanced Potion Makin'! 📖
      We gon' cook some sleepin' draught, it's got the highest ratin'! 🧪⚗️
      Put Potter in a sleep from which he'll never be wakin'! ⚰️
      Yo! Yo! Uh! Light it up! 🚬
      Polyjuice Potion or a draught of peace,
      Veritaserum, if ya'll don't trust your neice,
      Fame in a bottle,
      Neville boy, he gon' get throttled ,
      Liquid luck to save you from a bloodthirsty hag,
      Hermione granger is a hoe bag!
      Skelegro or a cure for boils,
      I put Ron Weasely in a vat of hot oil!
      Now that ya'll know my evil plans, I'm signin' out,
      Snape Doggy dog, I'm yo' man!
      ×Peace×

    • @kprenesti
      @kprenesti 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      100% agree!

  • @johnclark8359
    @johnclark8359 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    A live action interpretation of the Harry Potter books has already been done and done very well, so rather than just repeat themselves they should nake an animated Harry Potter series. This makes even more sense when you consider the enormous progress in artificial intelligence and text to video generation that has occurred in just the last year. This would also eliminate the problem of the kid actors growing up too fast

  • @Kesedrith
    @Kesedrith 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    I'm most concerned about whether or not they're going to actually adapt the source material or just tell their own story with a nod of names and places mentioned in the book. So many "adaptations" these days are that in name only with the show runners and writers deciding to tell their own stories instead and, frankly, I'm done with that to the point that I don't trust any statement that they're adapting anything. They're just doing their own thing and riding on the coattails of a fandom, hoping we won't notice or care.

  • @snedler
    @snedler 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +3

    We all have seen how it worked out for the Lord of the Rings tv series.
    I don't wanna see that happen for Harry Potter, too...
    I hope they know what they are doing and doesn't ruin it..
    That's all i have to say for now

  • @arctan2010
    @arctan2010 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    They should just make it an animated series so they don’t have to worry about kids aging out and they can remain true to the books without worrying about the budget.

  • @betelgeuseredstone9082
    @betelgeuseredstone9082 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +16

    I preferred him as Kingsley Shocklebolt instead, not Severus Snape. I preferred Adam Driver. Or this is going to be Woke. That means I won’t watch the series. This needs to be book accurate, or it’s going to be a flop.

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      You read the wrong book, man. Snape was and will always be BLACK.
      Snape gon' enter the class saying:
      "Yo, yo, yo! Snapey Boy's in the hood! 🧙🏿‍♂️
      Sit you ass down or I'll whoop it real good! 🎾🍑
      Open page 364 of Advanced Potion Makin'! 📖
      We gon' cook some sleepin' draught, it's got the highest ratin'! 🧪⚗️
      Put Potter in a sleep from which he'll never be wakin'! ⚰️
      Yo! Yo! Uh! Light it up! 🚬
      Polyjuice Potion or a draught of peace,
      Veritaserum, if ya'll don't trust your neice,
      Fame in a bottle,
      Neville boy, he gon' get throttled ,
      Liquid luck to save you from a bloodthirsty hag,
      Hermione granger is a hoe bag!
      Skelegro or a cure for boils,
      I put Ron Weasely in a vat of hot oil!
      Now that ya'll know my evil plans, I'm signin' out,
      Snape Doggy dog, I'm yo' man!
      ×Peace×

    • @gegamst7323
      @gegamst7323 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

      Adam Driver looks the part, but can he do a british accent? JK Rowling has always been clear on having a british cast

    • @vitokorunic3761
      @vitokorunic3761 19 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

      Preferred? Are you from the future? You 've already seen the show?

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 19 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

      @@vitokorunic3761 Caution ⚠️: KAREN alert.

    • @vitokorunic3761
      @vitokorunic3761 16 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

      @@midnightrealmbooks Huh?

  • @mathieu2492
    @mathieu2492 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    if disney can have a budget for andor season1 and 2 being 600 something million and the dumpster fest of the acolyte being 300 million i bet hbo could do the same for harry potter

  • @Zorzu-df5mm5wb6t
    @Zorzu-df5mm5wb6t 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +15

    Snape has a hooked nose and is pale sooooo this guy is no way close of being Snape

    • @larryroberts3598
      @larryroberts3598 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Yeah....sallow skin, hooked nose and long greasy hair...dude isn't even bloody well close

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      You read the wrong book. Snape was totally black. Remember when Snape enter the class saying:
      "Yo, yo, yo! Snapey Boy's in the hood! 🧙🏿‍♂️
      Sit you ass down or I'll whoop it real good! 🎾🍑
      Open page 364 of Advanced Potion Makin'! 📖
      We gon' cook some sleepin' draught, it's got the highest ratin'! 🧪⚗️
      Put Potter in a sleep from which he'll never be wakin'! ⚰️
      Yo! Yo! Uh! Light it up! 🚬
      Polyjuice Potion or a draught of peace,
      Veritaserum, if ya'll don't trust your neice,
      Fame in a bottle,
      Neville boy, he gon' get throttled ,
      Liquid luck to save you from a bloodthirsty hag,
      Hermione granger is a hoe bag!
      Skelegro or a cure for boils,
      I put Ron Weasely in a vat of hot oil!
      Now that ya'll know my evil plans, I'm signin' out,
      Snape Doggy dog, I'm yo' man!
      ×Peace×

    • @saxoncrow2500
      @saxoncrow2500 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Its called latex mate.

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@saxoncrow2500 huh?

    • @saxoncrow2500
      @saxoncrow2500 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @midnightrealmbooks its called make up mate. Latex nose, bit o lippy, a wig. Jobs a good un

  • @ManavYadav-w5s
    @ManavYadav-w5s วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    Exactly....and don't know why ppl are not realising that harry potter as story is already diverse and inclusive there are character which are not british (or WHITE) already...

  • @Zero_Reaper13
    @Zero_Reaper13 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    Unfortunately some of the film actors are now iconic as those characters, like Alan Rickman, Robbie Coltrane, brendan gleeson

  • @oliviakrause3336
    @oliviakrause3336 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +9

    It's so funny how people cancel JK Rowling for not being woke enough and when they choose black actors, they're suddenly too woke. Wtf is wrong with y'all?

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Yeah, they're all racist!
      Me personally, I love me a Black Snape, baby!
      In my dreams, Snape gon' enter the class saying:
      "Yo, yo, yo! Snapey Boy's in the hood! 🧙🏿‍♂️
      Sit you ass down or I'll whoop it real good! 🎾🍑
      Open page 364 of Advanced Potion Makin'! 📖
      We gon' cook some sleepin' draught, it's got the highest ratin'! 🧪⚗️
      Put Potter in a sleep from which he'll never be wakin'! ⚰️
      Yo! Yo! Uh! Light it up! 🚬
      Polyjuice Potion or a draught of peace,
      Veritaserum, if ya'll don't trust your neice,
      Fame in a bottle,
      Neville boy, he gon' get throttled ,
      Liquid luck to save you from a bloodthirsty hag,
      Hermione granger is a hoe bag!
      Skelegro or a cure for boils,
      I put Ron Weasely in a vat of hot oil!
      Now that ya'll know my evil plans, I'm signin' out,
      Snape Doggy dog, I'm yo' man!
      ×Peace×

    • @ManavYadav-w5s
      @ManavYadav-w5s วันที่ผ่านมา +3

      Exactly....and don't know why ppl are not realising that harry potter as story is already diverse and inclusive there are character which are not british (or WHITE) already...

    • @johnlovatsis7861
      @johnlovatsis7861 10 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

      There are a LOT of conservatives who love Harry Potter and support JK Rowling and hate seeing their favorite series be torn to shreds by DEI and wokeness. Believe it or not, Harry Potter didn't just appeal to liberals. The people who want to cancel JK (the radical left) will not watch the show no matter what, and conservatives along with those who simply want an accurate adaption of the series will also not watch the show if its super woke. They will be left with a small sliver of people who LOVE woke TV shows and who aren't boycotting JK for her political views.

  • @Sleepyfye
    @Sleepyfye 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    okay bro got snape vibes 😂 ill give him a chance

  • @thomasbaron5367
    @thomasbaron5367 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +8

    If Snape is black, the show is DOA
    If they were smart, they would pick Adam Driver

    • @margisama
      @margisama 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

      ohh Adam Driver would be a great choice!

    • @saxoncrow2500
      @saxoncrow2500 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      But he cant act! Ben whishaw would strangely work.

    • @nicknoble9693
      @nicknoble9693 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      And besides, Adam Driver is American!!

  • @marysp1440
    @marysp1440 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +8

    There are a lot of characters i could picture beeing black. I personally could see Lupin, Tonks, maybe Cedric.. it could be all three of them and I wouldn't mind ...idk it wouldn't be 100% how it is in the books, but u know i could see that, it would kinda fit. But snape. I can't see it. In my mind he looks like an oldschool vampire that never saw any daylight. Maybe they'll prove me wrong but it seems to be an odd choice

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      Nah man, Snape gotta be black. It's the only thing can save this series, ya feel me?
      Snape gon' enter the class saying:
      "Yo, yo, yo! Snapey Boy's in the hood! 🧙🏿‍♂️
      Sit you ass down or I'll whoop it real good! 🎾🍑
      Open page 364 of Advanced Potion Makin'! 📖
      We gon' cook some sleepin' draught, it's got the highest ratin'! 🧪⚗️
      Put Potter in a sleep from which he'll never be wakin'! ⚰️
      Yo! Yo! Uh! Light it up! 🚬
      Polyjuice Potion or a draught of peace,
      Veritaserum, if ya'll don't trust your neice,
      Fame in a bottle,
      Neville boy, he gon' get throttled ,
      Liquid luck to save you from a bloodthirsty hag,
      Hermione granger is a hoe bag!
      Skelegro or a cure for boils,
      I put Ron Weasely in a vat of hot oil!
      Now that ya'll know my evil plans, I'm signin' out,
      Snape Doggy dog, I'm yo' man!
      ×Peace×

  • @Gigglestheclown1983
    @Gigglestheclown1983 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +5

    I'd like to see an actor that actually looks like the character from the book I'm sure they could find some

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      You ain't read the books proper, boy!
      Remember the first chapter in The Sorcerer's Joint when Snape entered the class saying:
      "Yo, yo, yo! Snapey Boy's in the hood! 🧙🏿‍♂️
      Sit you ass down or I'll whoop it real good! 🎾🍑
      Open page 364 of Advanced Potion Makin'! 📖
      We gon' cook some sleepin' draught, it's got the highest ratin'! 🧪⚗️
      Put Potter in a sleep from which he'll never be wakin'! ⚰️
      Yo! Yo! Uh! Light it up! 🚬
      Polyjuice Potion or a draught of peace,
      Veritaserum, if ya'll don't trust your neice,
      Fame in a bottle,
      Neville boy, he gon' get throttled ,
      Liquid luck to save you from a bloodthirsty hag,
      Hermione granger is a hoe bag!
      Skelegro or a cure for boils,
      I put Ron Weasely in a vat of hot oil!
      Now that ya'll know my evil plans, I'm signin' out,
      Snape Doggy dog, I'm yo' man!
      ×Peace×

  • @davidfarinella129
    @davidfarinella129 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    I agree cast him as Kingsley. The dude can act. He's really good. I think Adam Driver would make a better snape.

  • @kandipiatkowski8589
    @kandipiatkowski8589 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    I watched the movies before I read the series, so when I was reading the books, I could hear the original actors voice in my head....even if the lines weren't in the movie. That being said, I'm going to always be partial to Alan Rickman's and Maggie Smith's portrayals over anyone else. It will just be a case of seeing who they cast. Honestly, anyone who has done Shakespeare could play many of the characters...especially Snape.

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Snape gon' enter the class saying:
      "Yo, yo, yo! Snapey Boy's in the hood! 🧙🏿‍♂️
      Sit you ass down or I'll whoop it real good! 🎾🍑
      Open page 364 of Advanced Potion Makin'! 📖
      We gon' cook some sleepin' draught, it's got the highest ratin'! 🧪⚗️
      Put Potter in a sleep from which he'll never be wakin'! ⚰️
      Yo! Yo! Uh! Light it up! 🚬
      Polyjuice Potion or a draught of peace,
      Veritaserum, if ya'll don't trust your neice,
      Fame in a bottle,
      Neville boy, he gon' get throttled ,
      Liquid luck to save you from a bloodthirsty hag,
      Hermione granger is a hoe bag!
      Skelegro or a cure for boils,
      I put Ron Weasely in a vat of hot oil!
      Now that ya'll know my evil plans, I'm signin' out,
      Snape Doggy dog, I'm yo' man!
      ×Peace×

  • @artursandwich1974
    @artursandwich1974 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Having no doubts about Pappa Sidou's acting skills, if he is being seriously considered for the role of Snape, I think he would even be better in the role of Bellatrix Lestrange.

  • @EmilioBarby
    @EmilioBarby วันที่ผ่านมา

    Mark Strong with long hairs would actually be a terrific Snape 🤩

  • @pawesomianski1241
    @pawesomianski1241 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    In my opinion, setting Joaquin Phoenix’s Joker as an example that some roles can’t be outdone is wrong, because that’s exactly the concept he undermined - he played Arthur Fleck superbly, gave a performance that left the other Jokers not unparalleled.

  • @Sebandthegoat99
    @Sebandthegoat99 6 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

    Rumours of Chilian Murphy as Voldemort, that would be epic

  • @johnwoods6539
    @johnwoods6539 6 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

    Correction..... The gentleman that you speak about, he can act very well...... I want the characters that are in the book their descriptions to come out and walk out of the book and it be like " that's the guy or the lady...".. I see with the description in the book

  • @theodorescott653
    @theodorescott653 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    I still would have loved to see Tim Curry as Snape.

  • @chris730
    @chris730 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    It feels so sad there rebooting the series, especially now that the three main teachers (mcgonnagal, dumbledore and Snape) are gone

  • @PolorX25
    @PolorX25 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    If they are going to be faithful to any version (Books or Movies), then there should be no nonsense from today’s political opinions.

  • @path1400
    @path1400 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    I know HBO will do their best. Fans will get uses to any actor they see playing the parts as long as they don't deviate to much from the original script. For instance turning Dumbledore into a clown or Hagrid into a midget, etc.

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Snape gon' enter the class saying:
      "Yo, yo, yo! Snapey Boy's in the hood! 🧙🏿‍♂️
      Sit you ass down or I'll whoop it real good! 🎾🍑
      Open page 364 of Advanced Potion Makin'! 📖
      We gon' cook some sleepin' draught, it's got the highest ratin'! 🧪⚗️
      Put Potter in a sleep from which he'll never be wakin'! ⚰️
      Yo! Yo! Uh! Light it up! 🚬
      Polyjuice Potion or a draught of peace,
      Veritaserum, if ya'll don't trust your neice,
      Fame in a bottle,
      Neville boy, he gon' get throttled ,
      Liquid luck to save you from a bloodthirsty hag,
      Hermione granger is a hoe bag!
      Skelegro or a cure for boils,
      I put Ron Weasely in a vat of hot oil!
      Now that ya'll know my evil plans, I'm signin' out,
      Snape Doggy dog, I'm yo' man!
      ×Peace×

  • @AndyJacksonSoftware
    @AndyJacksonSoftware 8 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

    Diversity means showing the stories of all people, not coopting someone else's story.

  • @MiserableSpice
    @MiserableSpice 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    The mobile game handles diversity well with a few new characters. Really wish they had the courage and creativity to come up with a new story plot and not remake stuff. I believe people would be all over a new story set in the Hogwarts universe. Hire writers...!

  • @rikmetz4720
    @rikmetz4720 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Honestly they should use a lot of makeup to make the actor look more like snape. Just like they did with voldemort in the movies.

  • @pepitouwu17
    @pepitouwu17 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    2:10 this convinced me. he can play snape

    • @MaximusWolfe
      @MaximusWolfe 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      He’s black though.

    • @pepitouwu17
      @pepitouwu17 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @ ok yea ik but just something abt this clip made me see snape in him

    • @MaximusWolfe
      @MaximusWolfe 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@pepitouwu17
      Wishful

  • @javierdeharo7715
    @javierdeharo7715 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    Serious doubts this will make it past 4 seasons. Actors will quit, get more famous and leave. They are gen a/z so they have no work ethic and will complain. The tough shooting schedule will be a big issue. Plus kids like their own stuff. They don't want a hand me down franchise

  • @bigbadjoe2823
    @bigbadjoe2823 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    CGI should be kept at a minimum,to me CGI takes away the character, charm, depth and authenticity.

    • @WesWorldYT
      @WesWorldYT  3 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Agreed!

    • @mmhmmmyearight7183
      @mmhmmmyearight7183 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      I love CGI if done right

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Snape gon' enter the class saying:
      "Yo, yo, yo! Snapey Boy's in the hood! 🧙🏿‍♂️
      Sit you ass down or I'll whoop it real good! 🎾🍑
      Open page 364 of Advanced Potion Makin'! 📖
      We gon' cook some sleepin' draught, it's got the highest ratin'! 🧪⚗️
      Put Potter in a sleep from which he'll never be wakin'! ⚰️
      Yo! Yo! Uh! Light it up! 🚬
      Polyjuice Potion or a draught of peace,
      Veritaserum, if ya'll don't trust your neice,
      Fame in a bottle,
      Neville boy, he gon' get throttled ,
      Liquid luck to save you from a bloodthirsty hag,
      Hermione granger is a hoe bag!
      Skelegro or a cure for boils,
      I put Ron Weasely in a vat of hot oil!
      Now that ya'll know my evil plans, I'm signin' out,
      Snape Doggy dog, I'm yo' man!
      ×Peace×

  • @LapisAndroid17ParkRanger
    @LapisAndroid17ParkRanger 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +3

    If they want to tank the show before its even out, sure go for it....

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      It ain't gon' tank if Snape gon' enter the class saying:
      "Yo, yo, yo! Snapey Boy's in the hood! 🧙🏿‍♂️
      Sit you ass down or I'll whoop it real good! 🎾🍑
      Open page 364 of Advanced Potion Makin'! 📖
      We gon' cook some sleepin' draught, it's got the highest ratin'! 🧪⚗️
      Put Potter in a sleep from which he'll never be wakin'! ⚰️
      Yo! Yo! Uh! Light it up! 🚬
      Polyjuice Potion or a draught of peace,
      Veritaserum, if ya'll don't trust your neice,
      Fame in a bottle,
      Neville boy, he gon' get throttled ,
      Liquid luck to save you from a bloodthirsty hag,
      Hermione granger is a hoe bag!
      Skelegro or a cure for boils,
      I put Ron Weasely in a vat of hot oil!
      Now that ya'll know my evil plans, I'm signin' out,
      Snape Doggy dog, I'm yo' man!
      ×Peace×

    • @LapisAndroid17ParkRanger
      @LapisAndroid17ParkRanger วันที่ผ่านมา

      @midnightrealmbooks How high were you when you wrote that?

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks วันที่ผ่านมา

      @LapisAndroid17ParkRanger I wasn't high man 😂
      Just in a funny mood.

  • @ayiza8511
    @ayiza8511 วันที่ผ่านมา

    i am black and think this is utterly ridiculous ive never been a fan of whitewashing or race bending. If they want this actor in the show cast him as Kingsley. dont race bend a British pale skinned character into a dark skinned actor

  • @rudycaiazza6867
    @rudycaiazza6867 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    book snape and movie snape are different and movie snape is def written to be more likeable in terms of not content but literally just personality. so there is hope if its to be a book accurate adaptation that any other actor who is talented could create their own version of snape that is good.

  • @wendymalik6784
    @wendymalik6784 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    I think Snape will be the hardest roll to cast. No matter who they cast there will be strong comments from true Potterheads. I personally am not sure it’s been long enough to allow fans to accept it. We will see.

  • @ImDefNotFamous
    @ImDefNotFamous 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    On first thought I said "well that's not Alan Rickman" but on second thought nothing's really going to be the same so I'm hyped to see it. He doesn't need to be white if that's the issue

  • @digvijaysinghnegi301
    @digvijaysinghnegi301 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +3

    Faithful and inclusive do not go hand in hand. It's one or the other. I just want something close to the books but I know they are going to make some characters different which is fine if it doesn't break the story. We know that they are going to make someone gay I just hope it doesn't break the story because I am not able to think of a character that can be gay without changing the story

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Snape gon' enter the class saying:
      "Yo, yo, yo! Snapey Boy's in the hood! 🧙🏿‍♂️
      Sit you ass down or I'll whoop it real good! 🎾🍑
      Open page 364 of Advanced Potion Makin'! 📖
      We gon' cook some sleepin' draught, it's got the highest ratin'! 🧪⚗️
      Put Potter in a sleep from which he'll never be wakin'! ⚰️
      Yo! Yo! Uh! Light it up! 🚬
      Polyjuice Potion or a draught of peace,
      Veritaserum, if ya'll don't trust your neice,
      Fame in a bottle,
      Neville boy, he gon' get throttled ,
      Liquid luck to save you from a bloodthirsty hag,
      Hermione granger is a hoe bag!
      Skelegro or a cure for boils,
      I put Ron Weasely in a vat of hot oil!
      Now that ya'll know my evil plans, I'm signin' out,
      Snape Doggy dog, I'm yo' man!
      ×Peace×

  • @kendalynx
    @kendalynx วันที่ผ่านมา

    I could care less if Alan Rickman is held up as Snape.
    I'd rather have the actors and storyline live up to the books.

  • @coenfealy4731
    @coenfealy4731 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Robbie Coltrane is actually Scottish btw

  • @JacobRobison-c6d
    @JacobRobison-c6d วันที่ผ่านมา

    I think people need to chill and remember that's it's just tv chill out your childhoods are not being attacked good acting is what gets jobs

  • @UkePingu_the_rizzler
    @UkePingu_the_rizzler 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    No way we get a footballer as hagrid

  • @michelleweintraub945
    @michelleweintraub945 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Is there still the stipulation that the actors need to be English actors?

  • @baileybland4497
    @baileybland4497 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    I mean. It's the uk. In the 90s. Population is vastly white. But Rowling did include diverse characters. Why cant they cast a black person to a character that is already black?? (Kingsley??)

  • @ManavYadav-w5s
    @ManavYadav-w5s วันที่ผ่านมา

    Can Cillian for snape instead of voldemort as we would not notice person appearance without nose 😂

  • @flugsven
    @flugsven 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    Could he play Hamlet, Prince of Denmark, he sure can play Severus Snape. Could they make old grey Rickman look emo, this will be a cake walk.

  • @dawnferrettjesusfreak
    @dawnferrettjesusfreak 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    I think my reservations with the casting of a black man as Snape is that, while they were at school, Snape was relentlessly tormented by James and the other marauders, which is uncomfortable enough with Snape being white!

  • @AnantaNow
    @AnantaNow 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    They should make it like the books as far as possible with Rowling

  • @fandombuilds6701
    @fandombuilds6701 วันที่ผ่านมา

    How is it difficult to live up to.
    That’s just a cop out
    Adam driver is still the perfect choice

  • @Shaylovespopeye
    @Shaylovespopeye 22 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

    I don’t think that guy playing sniper

  • @andrewweber9930
    @andrewweber9930 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    I think Murphey Mcallen was fo Voldamort would work

  • @Luthandondumisosithole
    @Luthandondumisosithole 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    I was 11 years old when I read the first Harry Potter in 1997. I am 38 now and I am still just as much of a fan as I was when I was a kid. I will be 40 when the series debuts and I am looking forward to seeing a cast that reflects the ethnicity of fans like me.

    • @chesterdamolester6990
      @chesterdamolester6990 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

      Then cast Denzel Washington as Dumbledore

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      Me too, I can't wait for Snape to be Black!
      In my dreams, Snape gon' enter the class saying:
      "Yo, yo, yo! Snapey Boy's in the hood! 🧙🏿‍♂️
      Sit you ass down or I'll whoop it real good! 🎾🍑
      Open page 364 of Advanced Potion Makin'! 📖
      We gon' cook some sleepin' draught, it's got the highest ratin'! 🧪⚗️
      Put Potter in a sleep from which he'll never be wakin'! ⚰️
      Yo! Yo! Uh! Light it up! 🚬
      Polyjuice Potion or a draught of peace,
      Veritaserum, if ya'll don't trust your neice,
      Fame in a bottle,
      Neville boy, he gon' get throttled ,
      Liquid luck to save you from a bloodthirsty hag,
      Hermione granger is a hoe bag!
      Skelegro or a cure for boils,
      I put Ron Weasely in a vat of hot oil!
      Now that ya'll know my evil plans, I'm signin' out,
      Snape Doggy dog, I'm yo' man!
      ×Peace×

    • @chesterdamolester6990
      @chesterdamolester6990 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @midnightrealmbooks lol your racism is inspiring!

  • @Thanatosofos
    @Thanatosofos 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    What ever they do I think they can hardly do worse than the original films. The acting on those was simply atrocious. 🙄

    • @amithajay9275
      @amithajay9275 9 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

      A year back, i would argue with you for this comment. Because I loved the movies soo much. But then completed reading the book then I am like the movies are shit🤣

  • @05Coala
    @05Coala 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    No one complained when the movies selected a white girl to play Lila Brown...

    • @CaptnJack
      @CaptnJack 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      is lila Brown not white in the book or movie? It didnt matter because I done see race before all else...

    • @MaximusWolfe
      @MaximusWolfe 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

      They should if the original creator saw her as black.

    • @anthonyfisher9413
      @anthonyfisher9413 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      ​@@CaptnJackhahaha

    • @anthonyfisher9413
      @anthonyfisher9413 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      It was remarked upon at the time actually

    • @nicknoble9693
      @nicknoble9693 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Who tf is Lila Brown?!... I think you mean 'Lavender', right??

  • @manuelzeller1175
    @manuelzeller1175 15 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

    if it was not important that Snape was in his 30s, why is the pale skin important now? just wondering how are the marauders not depicted as racist bullying him?

  • @johnwoods6539
    @johnwoods6539 6 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

    The gentleman can't act very Well. But if you cast him as snape, . Then you run the risk of making James Potter look like a racist... Cause James picked on snape a lot... And then you're gonna get the people you're gonna say oh you made the black guy an evil guy... I just think it opened up kind of worms.. The guy that played as Han Solo's son-in star was I think he would make a great snape...

  • @saxoncrow2500
    @saxoncrow2500 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Strangely I 5hink Ben Whishaw would make a good snape.

  • @hardy3089
    @hardy3089 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    Race overall really isn’t important. I won’t like it cause it’s not how snape looks in my mind as I imagined the character growing due to the books description.Alan Rickman was believable in my mind and helped immerse me in the movies but is race essential to the character absolutely not. the guy could put on an amazing performance. I didn’t like the dumbledore recast in third movie but he grew on me. Casting this guy isn’t gonna be enough to make me not watch the show. I wish they would cast people that at least fit the description of the character as the book describes them but so long as they stay true to the story that’s all that matters to me. I personally don’t think this show should even be made I mean movies one and two are pretty darn close to the book. midnight duel in sorcerers stone and the death day party in chamber would be some cool additions but really seasons three and four are where the show will really shine. What we really need to look out for is them adding crap not in the books to pad the show. They start messing with the story by adding in stuff I’m out.

  • @bluntslt8023
    @bluntslt8023 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    Hwyyy Brotherrr

  • @marci841
    @marci841 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    IMAGINE if they race swapped Cho, Dean, or Kingsley…

  • @toniomalley5661
    @toniomalley5661 2 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

    They made these mistakes in Terry prattchett as well oh let’s go opposite just cause we can and didn’t get a second chance be careful guys

  • @mahmoudtamimi6018
    @mahmoudtamimi6018 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    If they go woke they will go broke. That's how I see it. Changing Snape's race or any character for that matter, to appease the DEI crowd, will make this a complete failure. Keep the orthodoxy of the material and don't try to piss off all the people who made this story an international phenomenon. It is perfect the way it was written, don't let a showrunner inject their stupidity into it. The story is there! Complete and finished, unlike Game of Thrones, incomplete. We all know what happened when D & D had to actually start writing for the show once the source material ran out, disaster! I hope JK doesn't fall prey to the woke mind virus and stays true to her vision. Don't mess this up!

  • @BobVahn
    @BobVahn 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    james potter bully snape, how they gonna create that scene? suddenly its not just about pure blood anymore.
    I doubt they gonna be faithful to the book.

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Snape gon' enter the class saying:
      "Yo, yo, yo! Snapey Boy's in the hood! 🧙🏿‍♂️
      Sit you ass down or I'll whoop it real good! 🎾🍑
      Open page 364 of Advanced Potion Makin'! 📖
      We gon' cook some sleepin' draught, it's got the highest ratin'! 🧪⚗️
      Put Potter in a sleep from which he'll never be wakin'! ⚰️
      Yo! Yo! Uh! Light it up! 🚬
      Polyjuice Potion or a draught of peace,
      Veritaserum, if ya'll don't trust your neice,
      Fame in a bottle,
      Neville boy, he gon' get throttled ,
      Liquid luck to save you from a bloodthirsty hag,
      Hermione granger is a hoe bag!
      Skelegro or a cure for boils,
      I put Ron Weasely in a vat of hot oil!
      Now that ya'll know my evil plans, I'm signin' out,
      Snape Doggy dog, I'm yo' man!
      ×Peace×

  • @robertbarger6439
    @robertbarger6439 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Harry Potter for the modern day audience

  • @CrackTheo
    @CrackTheo 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Some of my own personal fan cast's for Harry Potter
    Dumbledore Ralph Ineson
    Voldemort Cillian Murphy
    Professor McGonagall Michelle Fairley
    Aunt Petunia Kate Dickie
    Hugh Grant as Mad Eye Moody
    Tom Hiddleston Severus Snape or
    Adam Levy as Severus Snape or
    Benedict Cumberbatch as Severus Snape
    Michael Sheen as Peeves
    Kelly MacDonald as Rita Skeeter
    Sirius Black Aidan Gillen
    The Sorting Hat Charles Dance
    Iain Glenn Lucius Malfoy
    Florence Pugh as Trelawny or Nymphadora
    Matt Lucas as Professor Quirell
    Simon Pegg Nearly Headless Nick
    Paul Bettany Dobby
    Hugh Laurie as Gilderoy Lockheart

  • @TheBranchez
    @TheBranchez วันที่ผ่านมา

    Anyone saying this is a perfect choice for Snape is a racist idiot. And if he accepts this role he should know what to expect in terms of criticism. Don't cry later.

  • @TomRiddle-2
    @TomRiddle-2 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    Not watching then..

  • @annacarlsson1280
    @annacarlsson1280 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Snape needs to have a presence not many posess im afraid..... Race aside! Papa Looks to nice and he dosnt give me that kind of heavyness Snape needs :/ If he lost a bunsh of weight and looked older than his age it would kinda fit more into my picture of snape (im not saying he should, that can be dangerous.....)
    Both Rickman and Smith had the presence to make anyone listen and THAT is so important!!! He looks and feels like a teddy bear in comparison

  • @daniellarsson3699
    @daniellarsson3699 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    What is the point off him taking the role of an iconic character when it will tank the whole series and noone will watch it.

  • @ConMan-mb3vm
    @ConMan-mb3vm 3 วันที่ผ่านมา +2

    Definitely will not be watching this rubbish

  • @ManavYadav-w5s
    @ManavYadav-w5s วันที่ผ่านมา

    Cast ian mckellen as Dumbledore and cate blanchett as minerva then i am done 👍

  • @Thiantrus
    @Thiantrus 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    All i know if they cast Snape wrong and the golden trio then the show will not see season 2

  • @armak7774
    @armak7774 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Just write new stories with black characters, you don't need to ruin a good thing.

  • @michaelsaunders1064
    @michaelsaunders1064 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Just stay true to the book not hard. Y we all love it fix Ravenclaw smh wtf. Mascot eagle colors blue and bronze not hard.

  • @SquareGhost-bz2nw
    @SquareGhost-bz2nw 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    At the end of the day for me it is Plain and Simple. As far as I am aware this series will run alongside that of the books. Thus saying you MUST be faithful to the characters wrote in these books. It has nothing to do with Race or Acting ability. Yes it all comes down to opinions but if in the books Snape is a White Male then surely the makers have to stand by this! Let me put this another way, is it ok to cast a white male in either the role of Martin Luther King or the guy from Roots? I have no hang ups with Diversity, I champion Choice but when does taking on these view-points just to please some of the masses have to do with a faithful transition of a book series? Enough said.

  • @FlagOnFire
    @FlagOnFire 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    The girls are fighting

  • @m33st3rdanny
    @m33st3rdanny วันที่ผ่านมา

    Kylo Ren for Snape!!

  • @alias_8_9
    @alias_8_9 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    So the show won't be like the book...great

  • @MsAddams06
    @MsAddams06 วันที่ผ่านมา

    The books were already pretty diverse. They just race swapping again

  • @brettbarton2370
    @brettbarton2370 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Are people actually expecting this to be anything but a piece of crap show?

  • @LooneyClubMafia
    @LooneyClubMafia 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Wow 20 hours ago and you have how many likes 267? Cool I guess

  • @darajeeling
    @darajeeling 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    there is no need to make an Akan Rickman Snape remake
    because book Snape is different from Alan Rickman Snape (film Snape)
    And I am still on the side that IF they cast a black Snape I am NOT watching that, because then the seies is going to be crap.
    It's just not book accurate. Sorry.
    There are good british actors out there, that could do this,
    that are age appropriate and look the part - Harry Melling for one...

  • @fastneuro9829
    @fastneuro9829 2 วันที่ผ่านมา +1

    What if Kingsley would become white. He is black in the books

    • @midnightrealmbooks
      @midnightrealmbooks 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Kingsley is white in the books, Snape is black. You have not read the books right.
      Remember when Snape enter the class saying:
      "Yo, yo, yo! Snapey Boy's in the hood! 🧙🏿‍♂️
      Sit you ass down or I'll whoop it real good! 🎾🍑
      Open page 364 of Advanced Potion Makin'! 📖
      We gon' cook some sleepin' draught, it's got the highest ratin'! 🧪⚗️
      Put Potter in a sleep from which he'll never be wakin'! ⚰️
      Yo! Yo! Uh! Light it up! 🚬
      Polyjuice Potion or a draught of peace,
      Veritaserum, if ya'll don't trust your neice,
      Fame in a bottle,
      Neville boy, he gon' get throttled ,
      Liquid luck to save you from a bloodthirsty hag,
      Hermione granger is a hoe bag!
      Skelegro or a cure for boils,
      I put Ron Weasely in a vat of hot oil!
      Now that ya'll know my evil plans, I'm signin' out,
      Snape Doggy dog, I'm yo' man!
      ×Peace×