Nothing like that, in our IIT Madras, this year (2022-2023) 5 assistant professor got recruited, all did PhD from India. But post doc, it is mandatory to do from abroad.
@@maharanagguj6191 Kishor is right ...Not applicable for IITs (science/engineering dept), Top 2 IIMs have strong preference for foreign desi PhD students irrespective of zero publications...Indian PhD in all IIMs and other Indian universities for social science (Economics and allied subjects) get negligible resources and exposures compared to western peers...... The western ones have edge especially in terms of networking and resources which lead to their significant superior research output ...... Although the good Desis do not return back to India ......Majority of the ones returning back are not able to publish in desired journals and are not able to convert their tenure (generally they are given 3 to 6 years' time to publish at least one to two papers in desired set of journals.) ........
@@Philoshoper-OOO Pros and cons you can discuss for hours, but the truth is PhD means PhD... Cons of foreign universities 1] An Indian student studying in India has at least 2 years to find a job & convert his/ her PhD to part-time, abroad there are no such options because the student does not have work authorisation and is not allowed to convert visa due to immigration laws. 2] If they are not from the top 500 (even the best newly established uni), they need to clear NET for teaching positions. 3] PhD disqualifies (mostly PhDs become 30+) them from all non-teaching/research govt job exams, 4] My friends have joined govt professor jobs with just a master's after passing exams, but foreign students don't get such opportunity. 5] ABVP and AISA goons have more relevant networks in Indian uni when compared to the Nobel Lectorate. 6] The stipend offered is mostly lower than minimum wages (Postdoc salary could be compared with construction workers and PhD with delivery man). If a person matches his/ her lifestyle with the poor working class then they might get enough savings to fund their post-study work visa. 7] For a middle-class Indian, it is difficult to survive even 1 year of extension (many of them submit MPhil). In India, I know many students who take 1.5-2 yrs of extension. 8] Finding a job and survival is not difficult for a PhD (anywhere on the planet), Postdoc and publications are the worst career choices one can make. Smart students never look at academia as a career. Everyone's life is different, they make their own choices due to personal circumstances. Some go back to India due to loneliness, parents, responsibilities, and service of the country, and many of them do not go because they do not think they can sell their achievements in the world's most populous and competitive job market, get comfortable, or get tenured jobs. Many of them start dating locals & family commitments stop them from going back. 5-6 years is a long time and many things change. It's life, if you choose a PhD you get paused in life but not everything.
No. I've seen most of professors in physics department from India's top research institutes like tifr,iisc,hri,rri,imsc,barc,etc but have 1-2 postdocs in foreign
Yeh har line ke saath problem hai India may. Indians are first-class citizens ruled by third-class politicians. Yeh, baat toh hai ki pay grade aacha hona chahiye. Private sector companies ke saath collaboration might be one option.
Foreign ka PhD scholarship waha ke expenses ke hisaab se koi khaas high nahi hoti. PhD karne se koi dher saara paise nahi kamaata. Par uske balboote par expertise, patience aur ethics sikhna zaruri hai. IIT se PhD karne ke baad maine foreign se postdoc ki.. ab main foreign mein faculty hoon. Isliye, India ki PhD behtareeen hai, aisa mera maanna hai.
Hi, I completely agree with your opinion. What is other opportunity who has already completed their PhD in India. Any suggestions for those. Where are you these days. Have you finished your PhD.
25000 PhD me kharcha ho raha hai. I guess IISc charges around 60 65k per year for tuition and hostels fee. Where are you sending 25k. I have seen people saving 20k per month from the stipend itself (they are getting HRA).
@@agobletoflove5035 Me saving some amount is restricted to myself and it is hugely affected by the fee structure of tye IIT where i study. I am in IIT delhi and it's reasonably expensive compared to old 7 iits. Still I can save 15k pm which is Ok for me.
@@SanjeevKumar-xg1ty yeah you can't possibly ask people where their is money is going. Some people pursue good phds from major cities, hence a lot of expenses come into the play, and that could easily be NOT okay for a lot of people.
@@agobletoflove5035 If you go for a PhD in 'major cities' and are not able to figure out the approximate expenses you are going to have, I don't know where you'll end up. When you think about phd, after the vision, second thought is of money. You should enroll in phd in major cities after making all this analysis. If it doesn't fit, it's too hard to manage and you'll end up making such videos.
@@SanjeevKumar-xg1ty I am not even thinking of getting a phd so, spare me on that. Also, while you have a different approach to your phd experience, others have a different approach too. You can't possibly shame them for sharing their perspective. There's no winning in this argument
Not agree with your personal views. In India institutes like IISER IIT CSIR DRDO DAE has cutting age instruments. For doing research their is no restrictions you can do excellent work. However most of the time you are talking about money, in that case you have to compare expenses abroad including flight, accomodation and all. In India getting fellowship is much easier than getting outside. Amount of fellowship is much better than expenses occurred. Do not misguide students based on your own views. For earning lot of money industry is best option than PhD. Main issue in India is our old mindset and it's slowly changing it will take time. However for quality of research we are far ahead.
Quality of research is 💩 in India. PhD in India is infamous for its corruption, data manipulation, politics and toxic work culture. In case it's a troll account, in foreign countries you have better infrastructure, work life balance, exposure and JRFs are allowed to have a life outside work
It seems like you more interested towards money than doing proper research. If someone's interest is earning then he should go for job or start his/her own business. Btw people from India even from central universities also doing preety good in research. This video is only putting negative impact towards student.
Brother.. When your friends are earning in lakhs doing job in IT sector. And you are doing a novel work doing research at such a minimum stipend. Money always crosses your mind now and then... If govt cannot pay more atleast they should keep the flow of fellowship regular.. Research don't receive their scholarships for many consecutive months.. And majority of researchers are in their late 20's So saying if money is your concern then do job not research is a bit rude.
Institutes like IIMs and IITs also give preference to these Foreign (USA/Europe etc. ) PhD holders in faculty recruitment.
Nothing like that, in our IIT Madras, this year (2022-2023) 5 assistant professor got recruited, all did PhD from India.
But post doc, it is mandatory to do from abroad.
I think only publications matter in academia., if u r diamond u r diamond.; whether it's India or America😂!!
@@maharanagguj6191 Kishor is right ...Not applicable for IITs (science/engineering dept), Top 2 IIMs have strong preference for foreign desi PhD students irrespective of zero publications...Indian PhD in all IIMs and other Indian universities for social science (Economics and allied subjects) get negligible resources and exposures compared to western peers...... The western ones have edge especially in terms of networking and resources which lead to their significant superior research output ...... Although the good Desis do not return back to India ......Majority of the ones returning back are not able to publish in desired journals and are not able to convert their tenure (generally they are given 3 to 6 years' time to publish at least one to two papers in desired set of journals.) ........
@@Philoshoper-OOO Pros and cons you can discuss for hours, but the truth is PhD means PhD... Cons of foreign universities
1] An Indian student studying in India has at least 2 years to find a job & convert his/ her PhD to part-time, abroad there are no such options because the student does not have work authorisation and is not allowed to convert visa due to immigration laws.
2] If they are not from the top 500 (even the best newly established uni), they need to clear NET for teaching positions.
3] PhD disqualifies (mostly PhDs become 30+) them from all non-teaching/research govt job exams,
4] My friends have joined govt professor jobs with just a master's after passing exams, but foreign students don't get such opportunity.
5] ABVP and AISA goons have more relevant networks in Indian uni when compared to the Nobel Lectorate.
6] The stipend offered is mostly lower than minimum wages (Postdoc salary could be compared with construction workers and PhD with delivery man). If a person matches his/ her lifestyle with the poor working class then they might get enough savings to fund their post-study work visa. 7] For a middle-class Indian, it is difficult to survive even 1 year of extension (many of them submit MPhil). In India, I know many students who take 1.5-2 yrs of extension.
8] Finding a job and survival is not difficult for a PhD (anywhere on the planet), Postdoc and publications are the worst career choices one can make. Smart students never look at academia as a career. Everyone's life is different, they make their own choices due to personal circumstances. Some go back to India due to loneliness, parents, responsibilities, and service of the country, and many of them do not go because they do not think they can sell their achievements in the world's most populous and competitive job market, get comfortable, or get tenured jobs. Many of them start dating locals & family commitments stop them from going back. 5-6 years is a long time and many things change. It's life, if you choose a PhD you get paused in life but not everything.
No. I've seen most of professors in physics department from India's top research institutes like tifr,iisc,hri,rri,imsc,barc,etc but have 1-2 postdocs in foreign
Akdam to the point answer dia apne. Thanks!
Yeh har line ke saath problem hai India may.
Indians are first-class citizens ruled by third-class politicians.
Yeh, baat toh hai ki pay grade aacha hona chahiye.
Private sector companies ke saath collaboration might be one option.
phd from USA is much more rigorous so the depth of knowledge you gain is much more.
You are Absolutely right Bro...
True brother 👍
I'm totally agree Your Information
Foreign ka PhD scholarship waha ke expenses ke hisaab se koi khaas high nahi hoti. PhD karne se koi dher saara paise nahi kamaata. Par uske balboote par expertise, patience aur ethics sikhna zaruri hai.
IIT se PhD karne ke baad maine foreign se postdoc ki.. ab main foreign mein faculty hoon. Isliye, India ki PhD behtareeen hai, aisa mera maanna hai.
Foreign mei faculty hote toh English mein likhte, gawar 😂
I like your confidence 👌👌👌
Hi, I completely agree with your opinion.
What is other opportunity who has already completed their PhD in India. Any suggestions for those.
Where are you these days. Have you finished your PhD.
Sir Jo csir net se jo stipend milta hai to vo regular per month time par ata hai y phir kabhi kabhi 2 -3 month ka sath mai ata hai ?
25000 PhD me kharcha ho raha hai. I guess IISc charges around 60 65k per year for tuition and hostels fee. Where are you sending 25k. I have seen people saving 20k per month from the stipend itself (they are getting HRA).
Are you saving it yourself? Seen people. Don't see people
@@agobletoflove5035 Me saving some amount is restricted to myself and it is hugely affected by the fee structure of tye IIT where i study. I am in IIT delhi and it's reasonably expensive compared to old 7 iits. Still I can save 15k pm which is Ok for me.
@@SanjeevKumar-xg1ty yeah you can't possibly ask people where their is money is going. Some people pursue good phds from major cities, hence a lot of expenses come into the play, and that could easily be NOT okay for a lot of people.
@@agobletoflove5035 If you go for a PhD in 'major cities' and are not able to figure out the approximate expenses you are going to have, I don't know where you'll end up. When you think about phd, after the vision, second thought is of money. You should enroll in phd in major cities after making all this analysis. If it doesn't fit, it's too hard to manage and you'll end up making such videos.
@@SanjeevKumar-xg1ty I am not even thinking of getting a phd so, spare me on that. Also, while you have a different approach to your phd experience, others have a different approach too. You can't possibly shame them for sharing their perspective. There's no winning in this argument
Love you sir.
But i will complete 💯💯💯 agree
What is the procedure to take the addmission in Abroad
Why did you stop making videos??
Good points. 👍
thanks♥️👍
Esa nhi Hota hai foreign expensive a international student ke lye .
India isliye piche hai qiuki yha pe researchers ko jada importance nehi date murkh government....
DDFS walo ko 75000 per month milta he including HRA!
DDFS kya hai?
agar hmare pas masters me thesis nhi tha to iska alternative kya ho skta h after completion of msc physics
What will be d job opportunity in EU for Indians after postdoc ?
sSir how is IIT BHU for Phd in Biomedical Engineering?
Not agree with your personal views. In India institutes like IISER IIT CSIR DRDO DAE has cutting age instruments. For doing research their is no restrictions you can do excellent work. However most of the time you are talking about money, in that case you have to compare expenses abroad including flight, accomodation and all. In India getting fellowship is much easier than getting outside. Amount of fellowship is much better than expenses occurred. Do not misguide students based on your own views. For earning lot of money industry is best option than PhD.
Main issue in India is our old mindset and it's slowly changing it will take time. However for quality of research we are far ahead.
how?
Quality of research is 💩 in India. PhD in India is infamous for its corruption, data manipulation, politics and toxic work culture. In case it's a troll account, in foreign countries you have better infrastructure, work life balance, exposure and JRFs are allowed to have a life outside work
Dr.dineshsawant8872 Is mechanical engineering stream is good for doing PhD in india 😢
Btech ke baad 15-25 thousands hi mil pate hai ek average insan ko.....apko sahi se jankari nahi hai.
Subscribed
Opportunity after phd + post doc abroad?
It seems like you more interested towards money than doing proper research. If someone's interest is earning then he should go for job or start his/her own business. Btw people from India even from central universities also doing preety good in research. This video is only putting negative impact towards student.
Brother.. When your friends are earning in lakhs doing job in IT sector. And you are doing a novel work doing research at such a minimum stipend. Money always crosses your mind now and then... If govt cannot pay more atleast they should keep the flow of fellowship regular.. Research don't receive their scholarships for many consecutive months.. And majority of researchers are in their late 20's
So saying if money is your concern then do job not research is a bit rude.
Be passionate and don't go for money
@@vivekpal368preach 💯
please sir contact kaise krey apko please..
state university main phd karne ka bahut nuksan hai bhai India main wo bhi bina fellowship ke bahut dikkat hogi yaar
Kyn?
Tumhara phd nahi huwa, you don't have any right to speak about that.
Bhai tune abroad se flight se aane jaane ka kharcha nhi likha
Kuch information leni abroad mai phd karne ke liye
Bhaiya... I have many doubts about research
.. How can i contact you.. Kindly reply ✌❤
Kindly reply bhaiya✌❤
Don't do PhD, you will suffer
@@rakshithm1257why
pagal insaan 2000 dollars per month usa mai bahut kaam hai approx poor person so never do phd with this low stipend
Bhai PMR UTHAlo
India does,t have work and study culture...
bhrata shri 1800 euros vahan ka tees hazar hi hai, vaise hi bhikhari jaise jeena padega
Ab to kar leee.......
Bhai mughe phd karni hai bhai tumhara number chahiye
Mat karo! Run for your life