@@browniescout25 Yes please!! I hope they will all debut. But I have a feeling tho that the guiders doesn't really root for Yinghao. I mean knowing Korean industry, they don't really pick those who are kind of in the feminine side. If you understand what I mean. But I am rooting for the three of them!!! Xingxing is my bias but Guanyou deserves to be the center.
Guanyou and Sun Yihao withdrew from the competition. They left, they were not eliminated. They are even in 2nd and 4th place. Only Xing Xing left 😭 Let's at least help Xing Xing debut.
China goes all out with survival shows, but what's with these songs after debut?! These song will never go big in the world stage. I'm happy xing xing, gwanwoo & sun yinghao are in kpop survival show now.
With how big the Chinese entertainment industry is there's really no need to spread internationally if you have a stable fanbase inside of China. Artists make bankkkkk there I'd they are semi popular.
China has a talent for doing great survival shows and then letting their groups crash down with a mid song, mid dance and an unbelievably weak marketing just to disband them a year and a half later, what a waste of trainees every time
so real bruh 😭 the thing is these companies have so much money too but they always give them these corny ass songs. the main point of the survival shows in china is to make the idols super successful individually, and the group usually comes second. That's why most CPOP idols become actors, bc actors are more popular and make more money than groups. Nine Percent made a tonnnnn of money - similar to top Kpop groups, but individual members like cai xukun and Zhu zhengting were able to surpass those profits just from acting, endorsements, and more.
You have to understand by now that CPOP is different from KPOP. China is actually focused on individual artists than groups unlike in Korea wherein they get that group as long as they can. Which is actually sad bc you'll love those C-trainees then they'll disband and later on you'll happy seeing them successful. LOL.
You wouldnt know xingxing is a main dancer with great vocals based on this clip bcos he keeps getting shoved to the back. Guys pls support xingxing, guanyou and yinghao on starlight boys. They deserve to shine on stage once more, hopefully with better conditions than when they were in ixform
still cant believe jojo and jerome debuted bro. i found out yesterday. like i found out that ywy3 finale did end up happening and i saw the lineup and i was happy with 6/9. jojo, jerome and someone else but i dont remember his name....they were a major shock to me. like i had 3 other people in mind who deserved to debut but whatever.
He practically said in each and every speech in the show how reluctant he was to debut the voters were idk 🙂 they found it charming that he didn't want to debut.
Because of one person( the guy in brown jacket) the whole performance looks not perfect. That’s why vote for talent you guys. That’s Xinche and Xu Shi Huan a big no no
😢😢 I'm not gonna be surprised at the finals if the lineup is fucked up 😢 idk I can't put my faith in the finals anymore, I'm just tired of the system they are making us vote by money, I can vote only 1 trainee then without my vip acc I won't be able to vote multiple times...man Idk anymore....
xin che is more like jojo, cuz he has chemistry to other people which it can help him though. yet his dance aren't that bad too, he still put some effort on it.
I love the song but Jerome is stressing me out so much 😩During and even after YWY, it seems he's still not passionate about this at all. He just seems like a corporate slave forced to do his job out of money. I hope he works harder for the sake of his fans who voted for him to be in this group.
liek after the show, i rarely got updates from IXFORM since i was so busy in school and just get back with them this year (and they alr disbanded) but recently some clip of IXFORM passed on my feed here in yt and i remember everyone except for one coz i rlly did not rmbr him on the show and being part of the debut member, so i searched it on google and i realized it was jerome, the reason back then why i was so frustrated and sad about the results bec someone was more deserving of his spot. TT i rlly thought he’ll improve thru out the months of being the group but when i saw this performance of them, he still did not change and got worse than before TT i feel so bad for saying this but he really lack skills of an idol TT
I'm so distracted with the guy in brown.. 😁 I still can't believe they actually voted for him in top 10. There arw so much better talented trainees than him.
seriously though :( when he got to debut, everyone (intl fans) was really so shookt when he was part of the debut member, i mean honestly speaking, he isn’t good in dancing and singing, people even say idol is not for him. the fact that he got to debut despite his lacking skills, we already know it was because of his looks (he is so popular bec of his visual esp. in china) and he also comes from a wealthy family - some c-idols got to debut bec of that :( it is just so sad that there are more talented that deserves his spot.
Omg I never focused on him but now that I saw your comment, omg. He's not even putting in any effort. I was so mad when it was announced of Tony's departure. This group could have been perfect.
@@Prix_fai each member is doing their own activities, some as singers, some as actors, some as both. there are still some interactions between some members, whether it is sns, meeting up, or guesting for shows
idk but every person who knows jerome, or even do not knows him and saw him dancing with the group, that phrase you commented always come 😭 i mean, it’s true though TT
Sorry saya lambat tahu group Ixform ni, tetapi saya mendengar juga ada member dari Malaysia Jun liu, semenjak starlight boy saya hanya tahu syh, duan xing xing, donghwa, sebenarnya apa yang terjadi pada group Ixform sebelum ni😢
@@luna740AND he is supposed to train hard for the group and his so called fans since he got to debut, but he did not. he still act like a princess and doesnt care about it. i just feel bad for the group and i think it was a good thing that their contract is just short, tho i rlly love some of them.
Checking this group after watching starlight boys. Why is there 1 member that seemed like not ready to debut? I watch YWY before and I remember many trainees who can do better
Idk who the guy in brown is but it’s better if I don’t bcoz he’s pissing me off. I discovered not long ago that ywy3 final group debuted so I was like “are we sure this guy is in top 9?” Bcoz no offence but he’s not made for the stage. I’d have accepted a bit if at least he tried but no, seeing him makes me not enjoy their performance. He literally just dgaf like he’s there coz he had to.. I’m not happy at all but what can I do lol they already disbanded
stop sugarcoating guys! we know fr that one guy here is lacking and that's constructive critism stop being delusional that your faves can be in a group just because of visuals the purpose of survival show is to showcase who's the one that's ready to debut but because ya'll prioritize visuals with your money to vote lacking trainees you're only making it worst for them. Even there's a bunch of fans would support them the level or quality of the performance won't look as good! IQIYI STOP BEING SO CORRUPT AND LET PEOPLE VOTE NOT FOR MONEY!! ❗❗❗ I HATE YA'LL
If anything XinChe visuals will make the group more successful. You don't need to worry and SYH already quit the show anyway. I saw one K netizen comment last month(forget where) with his visual XinChe need to debut even if he is tone deaf. If anything it's international fans that is having problem with XinChe not the K netizens and some homophobic Chinese stans of other boys.
@@shineecrystal sal de acá mina, no he estado esperando meses desde que comenzó el programa a que debute mi pick para que en el video oficial salgan con este weon
im sorry but jerome d. did not deserve to debut. he doesn't have the talent. he doesn't even have the passion. obviously people only voted him for his looks. the voters should be ashamed. if only tony didn't leave. this group would be better. i'd replace jojo and jerome with tony and yang hoaming.
Duan Xingxing, Yoo Gwan Yoo and Sun Ying Hao are in Starlight now. Let's debut them again!
❤❤❤ Liu Guanyou Must Be Center
@@browniescout25 Yes please!! I hope they will all debut. But I have a feeling tho that the guiders doesn't really root for Yinghao. I mean knowing Korean industry, they don't really pick those who are kind of in the feminine side. If you understand what I mean. But I am rooting for the three of them!!!
Xingxing is my bias but Guanyou deserves to be the center.
Yesss...been voting for them!
We must put them in group together again❤
Guanyou and Sun Yihao withdrew from the competition. They left, they were not eliminated. They are even in 2nd and 4th place. Only Xing Xing left 😭 Let's at least help Xing Xing debut.
China goes all out with survival shows, but what's with these songs after debut?! These song will never go big in the world stage. I'm happy xing xing, gwanwoo & sun yinghao are in kpop survival show now.
With how big the Chinese entertainment industry is there's really no need to spread internationally if you have a stable fanbase inside of China. Artists make bankkkkk there I'd they are semi popular.
China has a talent for doing great survival shows and then letting their groups crash down with a mid song, mid dance and an unbelievably weak marketing just to disband them a year and a half later, what a waste of trainees every time
so real bruh 😭 the thing is these companies have so much money too but they always give them these corny ass songs.
the main point of the survival shows in china is to make the idols super successful individually, and the group usually comes second. That's why most CPOP idols become actors, bc actors are more popular and make more money than groups. Nine Percent made a tonnnnn of money - similar to top Kpop groups, but individual members like cai xukun and Zhu zhengting were able to surpass those profits just from acting, endorsements, and more.
You have to understand by now that CPOP is different from KPOP. China is actually focused on individual artists than groups unlike in Korea wherein they get that group as long as they can. Which is actually sad bc you'll love those C-trainees then they'll disband and later on you'll happy seeing them successful. LOL.
@veeelaine7011 i do know that but then why make groups (except for the money ofc) this is literally so bad for these boys mental health lol
@ i don't know either and it's sad. But C survival shows are better than Korean ones tho.
I love them but the song is terrible
I miss them 😭 Luo Yizhou is sooo finneee 😩💗💗💗
You wouldnt know xingxing is a main dancer with great vocals based on this clip bcos he keeps getting shoved to the back. Guys pls support xingxing, guanyou and yinghao on starlight boys. They deserve to shine on stage once more, hopefully with better conditions than when they were in ixform
xiaoci doesnt give a fuck he does NOT wanna be there lmaooo
also u can see that they have absolutely no chemistry as a group lmaoo, still love them tho
omg help its so obvious
still cant believe jojo and jerome debuted bro. i found out yesterday. like i found out that ywy3 finale did end up happening and i saw the lineup and i was happy with 6/9. jojo, jerome and someone else but i dont remember his name....they were a major shock to me. like i had 3 other people in mind who deserved to debut but whatever.
The group disbanded so you don’t have to worry anymore
@@luna740 breaking hearts LOL
@@kklynlyn7384 I don’t like people who hate/criticize anything that’s in the past so yea
i need you to shut up sorry
for added context i am defending jojo not jerome
*每一个都比另一个好.🙌🏻 我对你们的声音很着迷😩✨ You shouldn't have to disbanded😢🤍*
i’m back here again because im sad xingxing didn’t get to debut :(((((((( he deserved the spot so much!
Luo Yizhou, Tang Jiuzhou, Lian Huaiwei, Liu Guanyou, Deng Xiaoci, Sun Yinghao, Liu Jun, Duan Xingxing, and Sun Yihang. Love you so much.
相信有一天九人都能走更大花路❤
他們應該要紅起來的❤，每位都是
Neil dance and vocal is amazing❤❤
Wtf jerome is dragging down the group🙊
2:32 Neil dance break 😍😍 just Wow!💖💖
omg liu guanyou 😮 slayy
Deng Xiaoci what are you doingn
The one in brown lmao in the middle just gave up and moved to his designated place, he barely danced the right moves. How did he get in?
What's up with the guy wearing brown jacket doing?!
1:58~ the way yizhou move his body is insane🔥
BLUE HAIR ATE
That's yizhou :)
the one in the brown is stressing me the fuck out bro like what 😭
I DON'T KNOW WHY THEY VOTED HIM TOP TEN... two years later and I'm still upset lol. omg.
He didn’t need to debit
He practically said in each and every speech in the show how reluctant he was to debut the voters were idk 🙂 they found it charming that he didn't want to debut.
he literally told viewers to not vote him and people did…
I don't he is a dancer
kachine, neil, and xingxing wishing there would be no xiaoci that will debut in starlight boys future group…
There's Xin Che in it 😂...quite good ranking that I am not sure to laugh or cry 😅
@ RIGHT????? he reminds me of xiaoci, actually 😭 but at least we can see xin che MOVES, he may be awkward to watch but not this awkward 😭
At least xin che shows some effort lmaooo
Imagine dude just pop-up and sit next to them on the Airplane or Spawn in front of them at the Korea Airport. 💀
That’s Traumatizing af. 😭
Even worse, XSH 😢😢😢
Lou yizhou he kill my eye😭😭😭😭
Because of one person( the guy in brown jacket) the whole performance looks not perfect. That’s why vote for talent you guys. That’s Xinche and Xu Shi Huan a big no no
😢😢 I'm not gonna be surprised at the finals if the lineup is fucked up 😢 idk I can't put my faith in the finals anymore, I'm just tired of the system they are making us vote by money, I can vote only 1 trainee then without my vip acc I won't be able to vote multiple times...man Idk anymore....
xin che is more like jojo, cuz he has chemistry to other people which it can help him though. yet his dance aren't that bad too, he still put some effort on it.
@ idk he look stiff to me and his expression remind me of hyewon izone n wonhee
I love the song but Jerome is stressing me out so much 😩During and even after YWY, it seems he's still not passionate about this at all. He just seems like a corporate slave forced to do his job out of money. I hope he works harder for the sake of his fans who voted for him to be in this group.
liek after the show, i rarely got updates from IXFORM since i was so busy in school and just get back with them this year (and they alr disbanded) but recently some clip of IXFORM passed on my feed here in yt and i remember everyone except for one coz i rlly did not rmbr him on the show and being part of the debut member, so i searched it on google and i realized it was jerome, the reason back then why i was so frustrated and sad about the results bec someone was more deserving of his spot. TT i rlly thought he’ll improve thru out the months of being the group but when i saw this performance of them, he still did not change and got worse than before TT i feel so bad for saying this but he really lack skills of an idol TT
I am here for #duanxingxing, what a performer!
I'm so distracted with the guy in brown.. 😁 I still can't believe they actually voted for him in top 10. There arw so much better talented trainees than him.
only because either he's rich and had lots of followers or his looks... same with JoJo.
seriously though :( when he got to debut, everyone (intl fans) was really so shookt when he was part of the debut member, i mean honestly speaking, he isn’t good in dancing and singing, people even say idol is not for him. the fact that he got to debut despite his lacking skills, we already know it was because of his looks (he is so popular bec of his visual esp. in china) and he also comes from a wealthy family - some c-idols got to debut bec of that :( it is just so sad that there are more talented that deserves his spot.
@@SESEnpaiiiafter iQiyi canceling the final night, how they decide the final line up?
@@virgantaraaa i forgot already :(( but i think still thru votes??? they still continue the voting i think
Omg I never focused on him but now that I saw your comment, omg. He's not even putting in any effort. I was so mad when it was announced of Tony's departure. This group could have been perfect.
Rambut biru itu liu jun dari Malaysia, ixform❤
Pls teach brown jacket how to dance😩😩
This song so damn good, they bring different style of cpop.... May I know how they're now, i mean their contract.....
disbanded as of November 2022
Why
@@edaxxx9955 They were a temporary group with a 1.5 year contract (group debuted from idol survival show Youth With You 3)
@@liujuncams what are they doing right now like any new news ???
@@Prix_fai each member is doing their own activities, some as singers, some as actors, some as both. there are still some interactions between some members, whether it is sns, meeting up, or guesting for shows
2:10 sounds like drama music
Xiaoci what are u doing lmaoo
Which one is heM
The right man at the end, use brown suit?
idk but every person who knows jerome, or even do not knows him and saw him dancing with the group, that phrase you commented always come 😭 i mean, it’s true though TT
Sorry saya lambat tahu group Ixform ni, tetapi saya mendengar juga ada member dari Malaysia Jun liu, semenjak starlight boy saya hanya tahu syh, duan xing xing, donghwa, sebenarnya apa yang terjadi pada group Ixform sebelum ni😢
since when donghwa in ixform or am i trippin
Luo Yizhou = Sung hanbin
Zhang hao = Sun yi hang
Gunwook = Duan xing xing
they could've been the greatest group 😢
Not with Jerome with the group. T_T
The one in the brown is not a very good dancer he look like he is not caring
That's Jerome. 😩
Yeah that's Jerome, his dancing kinda has always been like that... back when IXFORM debuted i was super confused on how he made the lineup-
It’s not that he doesn’t care it’s just that he literally trained for 3-6 months before debuting..
@@luna740AND he is supposed to train hard for the group and his so called fans since he got to debut, but he did not. he still act like a princess and doesnt care about it. i just feel bad for the group and i think it was a good thing that their contract is just short, tho i rlly love some of them.
@@SESEnpaiii I mean... he did not want to debute in the first place. He even said to his fans, to not vote for him.
Why is jojo and jerome here😅
Why is there a member who doesn't dance like the others? He can not??
穿西裝外套扣子沒扣起來的那個傢伙，是怎麼進團的？？？🤔🤔🤔
That one could not even dancing, OMG, what a mess. 😂
There’s one amateur dancing with professionals..😅
🥺
What is Jerome fucking doing omg…
Checking this group after watching starlight boys.
Why is there 1 member that seemed like not ready to debut?
I watch YWY before and I remember many trainees who can do better
Idk who the guy in brown is but it’s better if I don’t bcoz he’s pissing me off. I discovered not long ago that ywy3 final group debuted so I was like “are we sure this guy is in top 9?” Bcoz no offence but he’s not made for the stage. I’d have accepted a bit if at least he tried but no, seeing him makes me not enjoy their performance. He literally just dgaf like he’s there coz he had to.. I’m not happy at all but what can I do lol they already disbanded
blue hair name?
luo yizhou
xiaoci seriously ruined the already nothingburger vibe of this song
stop sugarcoating guys! we know fr that one guy here is lacking and that's constructive critism stop being delusional that your faves can be in a group just because of visuals the purpose of survival show is to showcase who's the one that's ready to debut but because ya'll prioritize visuals with your money to vote lacking trainees you're only making it worst for them. Even there's a bunch of fans would support them the level or quality of the performance won't look as good! IQIYI STOP BEING SO CORRUPT AND LET PEOPLE VOTE NOT FOR MONEY!! ❗❗❗ I HATE YA'LL
pooor starlightboys hope the debut lineup would still be successful 😢😢😢
If anything XinChe visuals will make the group more successful. You don't need to worry and SYH already quit the show anyway. I saw one K netizen comment last month(forget where) with his visual XinChe need to debut even if he is tone deaf. If anything it's international fans that is having problem with XinChe not the K netizens and some homophobic Chinese stans of other boys.
@@voteyinghao i dont know about it now since xingxing did not make it to the debut lineup 😭😭😭😭
Wtf is up with the guy in the brown jacket? Is he drunk?
cada vez que veo a jerome me da un ataque de estrés, tipo sáquenlo de ahí, el tipo ni siquiera se está esforzando por bailar bien
atte: la que ni siquiera conoce a los chicos
@@shineecrystal sal de acá mina, no he estado esperando meses desde que comenzó el programa a que debute mi pick para que en el video oficial salgan con este weon
@@sofiabravo9781 sí amiga, casi te creo
@@shineecrystal dude 💀
前九 沒十七跟余 我不追
Red hair guy make this group go down not good enough
This is one of the emptiest and most generic songs I have ever heard. Stop making groups if you don't have the budget to make actual good music ...
Too many people
Ixform is such a flop..if tony was the face , they would have made it big
oh my shut up and leave if you dont like ixform
im sorry but jerome d. did not deserve to debut. he doesn't have the talent. he doesn't even have the passion. obviously people only voted him for his looks. the voters should be ashamed.
if only tony didn't leave. this group would be better. i'd replace jojo and jerome with tony and yang hoaming.
Exactly...i feel like , even if RIMIKO was there he would have put in 100% effort into it .. there were more deserving ones but ...