PLEASE MARK MY COMMENT!!! I've never been a big fan of Stray Kids, but this is chilling 😢 Maybe some of you know that an unknown "fan" is sending hateful comments towards Felix and other SKZ members on social networks. He threatens to kill Felix and blind one other member with a laser on July 16, 2023, but it is unknown who. Spread the word and #protectfelix
no the person is a obesessed fan of hyunjin and said if hyunjin cries,loses a hair,gets hurt they will kill felix and said they will blind felix with a laser in their upcoming fanmeet in china
I think it’s been resolved and the person will no longer be going to the fan meet as her parents found out. But, there are still ppl threatening to throw eggs at them.
Sulli and Hara lost their lives, one for raising voice for womens rights and one for exposing a rapist. Just shows how evil disguised as good to destroy the true good.
that is true...but so sAd！if the Korean fans have more emphaty w their idols.understanding and giving them the chance to be heard...sad fact no one listens！ if tgey did they might still be here...
Yeah watching Jonghyun video still makes me cry & the facts he looks happy & it still hurt to hear him say “I will have a rest at the end year.” “I will take a rest at the end of December” 😭😭
@@jkworld33...I know I don't know you, but I know one thing... YOU ARE WORTH BEING HERE!... Whoever or whatever you believe created you found it important enough for you to be alive or you never would of been born in the first place...Think about it!... You are here because you are meant to be here...Being born to begin with means that the universe put allot of thought and effort into finding you specifically important enough to be created in the first place... If I could give you a hug and a Pat on the back for sticking around this far I would, but all I want to say is that I'm proud of you for sticking around up until this point and you should be proud of yourself as well... When you think life is shit, realize that you are still here surviving the shit despite it all... Realize that if you can get through all the shit you've been through so far, you're strong enough to get through the shit of another day, right?!... One day you can look back on your journey in life and smile and be proud that you can make it through anything...you made it this far and it's been hard, but you still went through life and you are here... Just being here when life is hard and living through the shit PROVES you are strong enough to keep going... Trust me! I know from experience! It's tough for me daily, but I've realized that if I have been going through things and making it through to this point, I'm strong enough to make it to the next day... Just tell yourself that each day!... It's not about trying to ignore that it's hard in life sometimes...that's where we go wrong, we think the answer is to come to a point where we act like we ignore we ever struggle... But the point of life is to be proud that when we struggle, we F ing made it through and that struggles exist for everyone in life... True happiness isn't trying to get to a "perfect" place in life, but to become OK with living life just as it is...feeling life, good, bad or otherwise... Once we learn to understand that rain exist and we exist despite the rain, we can also understand the cycle of rain is that the sun does come out as well AND after the rain, the smallest bit of sun will feel like a bright summer day because we lived through the rain and we let the sun do it's thing and we let the sun rise again. 🤗☔ ☀️ 🌈 😎
They all looked so tired and just... wanting to give up.. I feel so bad for them. I wish I could just go up to all of them and hug them. But it's too late now. Rest in peace Goo Hara, Sulli, Jonghyun... At least you found a better place..
I have a coworkernwuo have nerve to say that depress people dont go out for vacation. What a bullocks. Depression is so dangerous that u could be standing or sitting next to someone who is broken and u wouldnt even know it.
@@noexcuses5524that’s so ignorant of your coworker to say! People who are suicidal may actually be more likely to do something like blow money on a vacation because they aren’t worried about money or saving anymore because they don’t plan to be here. They’re more likely to plan a vacation with friends and family to have one last good experience with them and create a good last memory with them.
I will always miss these three. Sulli had such a beautiful soul inside and out. She was taken from us by the cruel hatred ppl have. Hara went thru so much too with the media, public, etc. Jonghyun was the unexpected for me. I feel like you just never know the struggles of people tbh. Some people think K-pop idols are just these machines. Forever will always miss them ❤️
I don't really stan shinee and barely listen to some songs every now and then but I always liked Jonghyun and loved his voice. One night I had a crazy dream about him in a apartment full of water and he was drowning, I woke up and thought it was weird that I dreamed about him even tho I haven't heard or seen anything about shinee in months and besides that it was my first time dreaming about him and I rarely dream about any Idols/Singers, but I didn't mind it too long I got up went to the restroom, went to the kitchen to make my breakfast and then sat down to eat and check my Phone and the first thing I saw was that "Shinee Jonghyun has passed away", I had goosebumps, was crying and started choking on my food. Until this day I can't believe that I had that dream about him the same night when he passed away. 😖😭
@@luvyuluvyu5266 that's actually so sad to wake up from a dream about someone just to find out they have passed at least he was in a safer place though
@@luvyuluvyu5266 what a crazy story.....it must have been so horrible for you.... I also have premonitions dreams and that was maybe what you experienced.. Thank you for sharing this story.. Rest in peace our sweet Jonghyun 💜
I saw that vlive and when he said these lines I was so confused and was getting negative vibes💔 I was feeling like something isn't right. At night, I had dream in which I was in a dark room filled with smoke I heard someone shouting ( I don't remember what the person was shouting) I woke up some moments later and I was so scared. Next day I saw "Jonghyun passed away from suicide by carbon monoxide poisoning" I was so freaked out. I don't really know if my dream is linked to it but I couldn't sleep for 4 nights properly. But I was so broken💔I often have these types of dreams. 70% things I see in dreams come true. But I am so sad and confused right now
@@blackblinkunofficial sorry I don't have much knowledge about this situation but can you tell me what made him take this extreme step😣? and is this vlive just the day before his passing?
Hara looked so tired, eye bags from just crying almost :( And it's like Sulli had like a depressive hysteria of laughing because she knows there's nothing left to lose
I remember, watching Hara on V live and she was crying talking about losing a close friend (sulli) and her manager I guess came in the room and told her she needed to stop crying and start interacting with the fans! it honestly didn’t surprise me when she passed shortly after!
before k!lling themselves, most people are surprisingly happy, maybe because they settled with the decision. sadly, to others they may seem fine, so no one will worry about them.
Sulli and Goo Hara went through a lot. Being harassed with sexist comments even though they were victims of their previous partners and the overly conservative society. I also feel for Jonghyun and Moonbin who felt the world's harshness. I hope that they are all at peace now 😔
Jonghyun gave us a hint that "I will take a rest in December" and he died in that month 😭😭 and also that "I have to getting closer to the bed time"....... He gave us a lots of hint but we can't save him 😭😭
@@riddhimawithsamridhi no one would have thought that time cuz fans will melt😍 watching their idol so no suspiscous mind will activate...if the fans normally watch they can find it but wat 2 do fans were always crazy....he changed the kpop industry when girls sulli go hara met suicide nothing changed but bcz of him many things changed...god took him to be a messenger to show this worls...let him rest in peace cuz he didnt live a peaceful life as an idol
Hara is such a brave woman. Hara helped in the investigation of Burning Sun, a night club run by her fellow friend Jung, where many assaults, rape and harassment took place. She took herself after that. It's really so sad, how much she went through in her life...RIP Hara. You will always be loved.
YOU DID WELL JONGHYUN❤ YOU DID WELL MOON BIN❤ YOU DID WELL GOO HARA❤ YOU DID WELL SULLI❤ MY 4 ANGELS 👼❤ #KIMJONGHYUN❤ #MOONBIN❤ #GOOHARA❤ #SULLI❤ #MYANGELS🕊
Even mine he even said good bye to us and we can clearly see that pain in his eyes he looked so tired from battling everything inside him and wanted to give up still he wanted to spend his last moments with his fans and we did not understand about which break he was talking about 💔watching his last live after his death and knowing the reason it breaks me soo hard and makes me cry for hours 🥺
They just all look like they can't do it anymore.😢 We hated them while they were alive and love them when they are dead. 😔 We lost three angels❤ Rest In Peace 🕊 We'll miss you...
I want to say this that if you're depressed please don't go to social media, instead talk to your friends, family or anyone you are close with because social media makes it worst. Social media is very toxic nowadays so please spend time on the things you like to do, have conversation with people that will motivate you to continue your life.
The knowledge that jonghyun said his plans outloud meant that he'd been thinking about it for a while and was so hopeless that it didn't matter if the fans knew why or when, it was really the only way for him.
He didn't say it out loud because no one is gonna think he means suicide when he says those words. Literally no one would guess it. I would just be like okay he will take a rest from his activities and that hes ending the live and going to sleep. That's not even saying it out loud
@@Ankku98 That is saying it out loud. Just because we interpreted his words differently didn’t mean that he never meant what he said in the way he did. Hermeneutics, my friend.
@@sriv2167 i mean of course he said it out loud, but not directly like "i'm gonna kill myself". But only he knew what he meant, not the fans. Or i don't know if some people suspected something? I dont know, i'm not that deep in the shinee fandom.
I remember the cctv show that he kinda going back and forth in supermarket (or his apartment parking, i don't really remember) and it shows sign that he wanted people to notice him and stop him
it's not just their passing that hurts, it's the facts that it's a constant reminder of how we as fans didn't protect our idols and treat them the way they deserved. look what happened.
she got so much hate online from a young age. if people weren’t always so cruel to her maybe she would still be here and whose to say she wasn’t in therapy.
I understand your feelings, but stuff like this is not on the fans. it's the industry's fault and the general stigma of mental health in south korea. there's only so much we can do, all we can is support and advocate
they all looked so sad and depressed, and then when I saw jonghyun I was heartbroken, him holding back tears made me feel so sorry for him, I just wish I was there to give him a hug, if just anyone, was there to give him some comfort and love,..
True. Being in the KPop Industry is tough especially in Korea where life is so hard. Young teens especially with talents and charms find this way to escape hardships and be able to help or give support to their parents. It's a life struggle for them competing to each other and no assurance whether they'll make it or not. And the fans are the ones who make them reach the height of their success. And some fans sometimes without knowing it are creating divisions among them. Of course, quite normal among fans they tend to have their own favourite and become very vocal about their idol/s. The Idol/Idols feel the atmosphere and deep inside them get the vibes. The rest is you know what will happen.
Rest in peace moonbin,we will never forget u❤️ -19th april 2023 edit 1: thanks for the sweet comments,it shows a lot of people cared about him. we will miss him❤ edit 2: i still think of moonbin every day,we all miss him very much,but he is in great hands and is probably somewhere beautiful. well thats what he deserves.. The time has flies,its been 109 days ago in half an hour since april 19th...💔
Jonghyun's word just broke my soul please protect our idols🙏 all idols are same please atleast dont hate them by words 🙏🙏 they also humans too please u dont need to love them atleast dont hurt them🙏😢
Goo Hara live is days after Sulli... she's crying so hard since when Sulli died, she's not in Korea... she was facing really hard time after her problem with her ex boyfriend, then also Sulli, she feels sorry cause she can't be there for Sulli... Also I remember how Sulli keep saying that she wants to be a mother and taking care of her kid well... she also choose to not sue any hate comment cause some of them are kid and she didn't want to ruin any kid future... I really love both Sulli and Hara, they are my favorite member in their group... not far from their death, cvd come... and I lost my grandpa too after that... I feel like, this world maybe too harsh to good people, that's why God trying to protect them and hold them close. I miss them so much... rest in peace for them...
You know what i feel same.. All good people leave early as if god us sayung child you have dealt with that ugly world enough, its time for real rest. ☮️
Sometimes the people that smile the brightest are those who suffer alone on the inside, and they don't tell anyone because they don't want to be a burden.
I agree they all look very very tired and Goo Hara just downright looked like she wanted to cry as well, I feel so bad for them The kpop industry definitely needs to change and give these idols more rest and more freedom and try to not put so much pressure on them
Same I just happened to come across a TikTok on him and I just thought of how much hate you must've been receiving to do that. He was beautiful, and he never showed he was hurting. If you watched the funeral you'll probably cry more, all the SHINee members had their heads down and were comforting each other
Oh my god... It can even be seen in their eyes... Their eyes scream pain, they are just blank and too tired to do anything. Imagine how much they would have gone through to the point they had to choose this. It must have been so tough for them.
was in Hara's last live. i kept telling her we loved her and thanked her for being born. But when someone is that far gone, nothing you can do to stop them unless you literally have hands on them.
Jonghyun got me into kpop back in 2010 and when I woke up that day on December 17/2017 I was numb ngl… My instagram and musically(tiktok) were filled with the news about him, I couldn’t even go to school or move from my bed. Jonghyun mattered so much to me even tho I didn’t physically know him it felt like he was an older brother, I was 15 when he passed I’m 20 now and each day I think about how much do all idols truly suffer in silence.
Yo cuando me enteré de eso no lo podía creer....decía y pensaba esto es una pesadillla...quería llorar ....y me preguntaba porque pasaba esto a un ser tan hermoso como el😢😢😢.....en fin paso años.....aún no lo superó.....si tan solo pudiera retroceder el tiempo..me duele 😭😖😖😖😖😰😥😢😔💔😖
People who saw Sulilies comment that said that wasn’t really her comment, though somebody else commented but on her live stream it said "I don't listen to you"
when jonghyun said I will go to rest at the end of December. this line really broke my heart. I wish that on that time I was able to understand the hidden meaning beside those words but now it's gonna be 5 years when he left us. 죄송합니다 종현 🥺 My hands really stop working when I wrote the above passage. I wish wherever they are, always be happy and rest peacefully 😢
Its so shocking that these idols are prominent figures of the area of Kpop i grew up with. It seems so surreal that these angels arent here anymore. R.I.P to them ♥️
Hey guys I just want anybody to know if your hurting or feeling depression “don’t commit suicide it won’t bring the pain away it’ll just give it to others “.there’s always someone who cares 💓 even if u think that no one does there is.” I care !”so if ur hurting or feeling sad always talk to someone there’s gunna be someone who cares 😊 hope u have a wonderful day whoever reads this fighting~!❣️
I never knew about these people until now.. and I feel so deeply sad for what they went through in this lifetime. I wish they were treated like humans, because I'm sure they were overworked and underappreciated. 💔🫶🏻 May they rest in peace
jonghyun made me want to cry. he knew what he wanted to do. i wish i we've would've checked up on him. i wish we could bring him back. just one day to tell him everything's okay.
If hurts so much knowing the effect people can easily have over someone’s life… People who hate, bully and push people to the point of their death, in my eyes are considered murderers. :(
They all look sad and tired, I feel so bad, Goo-hara and sulli were so beautiful it hurts how much hate they’ve gotten..And jonghyun is so handsome and he looked a little happy but you can tell from his eyes something is wrong I loved him so much he was so caring and adorable, it’s so sad I miss them so much❤.
Sometime you just have to look for that small sign when they are depressed. They are the type of people who like to lie to themselves from others. So that's why you can't label people by their actions. When J said "I will take a rest by the end of the year." We thought he'll be doing something else beside media but his intention was something we are not ready or expecting to see. We can clearly see from those videos that they are all scared to take the path they choose. Just remember they are human with emotions. So don't judge them because you don't like them. They didn't do you wrong. Just respect anyone you come across. It's not worth to judge someone for fun. Rest In Peace for those who lost their way to the living. God will always love you.
The day I read Jonghyun died it broke me I believe it was very early in the morning for me back in 2017 and I just remembered crying my eyes out I didn't leave my room that day I just kept crying wishing it wasn't true and then I saw people saying that they saw a greenish dot in the sky like the colour of shinee and that they felt like that was jonghyun watching over us and when I looked out side I saw it and cried even more but happy to know that he was like I will watch over you that gave me some comfort he was such a amazing person a bright beautiful smile that made you feel safe a kind personality, people forget idols are humans too . Edit : this made me look on his insta someone literally said , how did the carbon monoxide taste.... wtf is wrong with people at someone who took their own life I am just disappointed
goo hara and sulli's death was one of the saddest deaths. goo hara lost everything she loved, her bestfriend sulli,her mother,her boyfriend. sulli was hated for no good reason,i miss them so so much i still cant deal with it.
I find it amazing that most of the comments are saying they regret they couldn't save their idols. Some here may be innocent but I'm sure that there are some here who threw hate at other idols and never thought of the consequences. It's ok to protect their favs but also at the same time they throw hate at other idols. Some here may be hypocrites.
PLEASE MARK MY COMMENT!!!
I've never been a big fan of Stray Kids, but this is chilling 😢
Maybe some of you know that an unknown "fan" is sending hateful comments towards Felix and other SKZ members on social networks. He threatens to kill Felix and blind one other member with a laser on July 16, 2023, but it is unknown who.
Spread the word and #protectfelix
Sure dear and it’s really important too🥺
Thank you so much for spreading even though you aren't a Stay❤
@@Laura-uw8mp I am stay…….!!!!❤️❤️❤️
no the person is a obesessed fan of hyunjin and said if hyunjin cries,loses a hair,gets hurt they will kill felix and said they will blind felix with a laser in their upcoming fanmeet in china
I think it’s been resolved and the person will no longer be going to the fan meet as her parents found out. But, there are still ppl threatening to throw eggs at them.
"i want to become a mother before i die."
-𝘀𝘂𝗹𝗹𝗶
I’m sobbing 😭 I would like to think positively and believe all her true fans are her children :(
😭😭😭😭😭
@@thecov3nAwwww 😭
oop
Sulli can make me cry 😢
Sulli and Hara lost their lives, one for raising voice for womens rights and one for exposing a rapist. Just shows how evil disguised as good to destroy the true good.
that is true...but so sAd！if the Korean fans have more emphaty w their idols.understanding and giving them the chance to be heard...sad fact no one listens！
if tgey did they might still be here...
The way Jonghyun was acting normally in that vid made me cry. He is always smiley but actually dying inside 😭
Yeah watching Jonghyun video still makes me cry & the facts he looks happy & it still hurt to hear him say “I will have a rest at the end year.” “I will take a rest at the end of December” 😭😭
Yes
You never know what someone's going through
This is so sad they look as tired
And Sulli & Jonghyun dropped hints but no one knew what they meant 😭
May they R.I.P 😔🕊️
Even goo hara posted plain black photo on Instagram before she take her life
And the caption was goodbye
@@jinnieatswhats her ig??
you can see it in their eyes.
they stopped trying. they're too tired. to go on.
it breaks my heart.
😭😢
@@lindyt3942 The people in this world can be so demonic😢 Why would you bully or harass a literal stranger??
@@lindyt3942even if sulli was staying out late who tf cares she was an adult and can date anyone have sex and stay out late
I don't know but i'm also going in that way😢I am getting tired too.hope to meet them. Jonghyun&Moonbin ❤😢
@@jkworld33...I know I don't know you, but I know one thing...
YOU ARE WORTH BEING HERE!...
Whoever or whatever you believe created you found it important enough for you to be alive or you never would of been born in the first place...Think about it!...
You are here because you are meant to be here...Being born to begin with means that the universe put allot of thought and effort into finding you specifically important enough to be created in the first place...
If I could give you a hug and a Pat on the back for sticking around this far I would, but all I want to say is that I'm proud of you for sticking around up until this point and you should be proud of yourself as well...
When you think life is shit, realize that you are still here surviving the shit despite it all...
Realize that if you can get through all the shit you've been through so far, you're strong enough to get through the shit of another day, right?!...
One day you can look back on your journey in life and smile and be proud that you can make it through anything...you made it this far and it's been hard, but you still went through life and you are here...
Just being here when life is hard and living through the shit PROVES you are strong enough to keep going...
Trust me! I know from experience! It's tough for me daily, but I've realized that if I have been going through things and making it through to this point, I'm strong enough to make it to the next day...
Just tell yourself that each day!...
It's not about trying to ignore that it's hard in life sometimes...that's where we go wrong, we think the answer is to come to a point where we act like we ignore we ever struggle...
But the point of life is to be proud that when we struggle, we F ing made it through and that struggles exist for everyone in life...
True happiness isn't trying to get to a "perfect" place in life, but to become OK with living life just as it is...feeling life, good, bad or otherwise...
Once we learn to understand that rain exist and we exist despite the rain, we can also understand the cycle of rain is that the sun does come out as well AND after the rain, the smallest bit of sun will feel like a bright summer day because we lived through the rain and we let the sun do it's thing and we let the sun rise again. 🤗☔ ☀️ 🌈 😎
They all looked so tired and just... wanting to give up.. I feel so bad for them. I wish I could just go up to all of them and hug them. But it's too late now. Rest in peace Goo Hara, Sulli, Jonghyun... At least you found a better place..
yeah same I would like to hug them from my phone :((
I dont really think they in a better place rn ngl
@@AAA-rd4dl Wdym bro they are in heaven don't say sh*t
@@Soroosh.S83 oh yeah totally everyone who kills themselves are in “heaven”😂. Why don’t we both kill ourselves rn so we can instantly be in heaven? 🤣
Ty uraraka this is why your my favorite
Moonbin not here but always in our hearts rest in peace 🕊️🕊️
Did he also commited s word?
@@ginandromeda1618 don't know if he actually did but may his soul rest in peace 🕊️
I have a coworkernwuo have nerve to say that depress people dont go out for vacation. What a bullocks. Depression is so dangerous that u could be standing or sitting next to someone who is broken and u wouldnt even know it.
@@noexcuses5524that’s so ignorant of your coworker to say! People who are suicidal may actually be more likely to do something like blow money on a vacation because they aren’t worried about money or saving anymore because they don’t plan to be here. They’re more likely to plan a vacation with friends and family to have one last good experience with them and create a good last memory with them.
I MISS MOONBIN 💗💗😭😭
I will always miss these three. Sulli had such a beautiful soul inside and out. She was taken from us by the cruel hatred ppl have. Hara went thru so much too with the media, public, etc. Jonghyun was the unexpected for me. I feel like you just never know the struggles of people tbh. Some people think K-pop idols are just these machines. Forever will always miss them ❤️
Jonghyuns last words to fans have always stuck with I wish we understood what he ment before it was too late
I don't really stan shinee and barely listen to some songs every now and then but I always liked Jonghyun and loved his voice. One night I had a crazy dream about him in a apartment full of water and he was drowning, I woke up and thought it was weird that I dreamed about him even tho I haven't heard or seen anything about shinee in months and besides that it was my first time dreaming about him and I rarely dream about any Idols/Singers, but I didn't mind it too long I got up went to the restroom, went to the kitchen to make my breakfast and then sat down to eat and check my Phone and the first thing I saw was that "Shinee Jonghyun has passed away", I had goosebumps, was crying and started choking on my food. Until this day I can't believe that I had that dream about him the same night when he passed away. 😖😭
@@luvyuluvyu5266 that's actually so sad to wake up from a dream about someone just to find out they have passed at least he was in a safer place though
@@luvyuluvyu5266 what a crazy story.....it must have been so horrible for you.... I also have premonitions dreams and that was maybe what you experienced.. Thank you for sharing this story.. Rest in peace our sweet Jonghyun 💜
I saw that vlive and when he said these lines I was so confused and was getting negative vibes💔 I was feeling like something isn't right. At night, I had dream in which I was in a dark room filled with smoke I heard someone shouting ( I don't remember what the person was shouting) I woke up some moments later and I was so scared. Next day I saw "Jonghyun passed away from suicide by carbon monoxide poisoning" I was so freaked out. I don't really know if my dream is linked to it but I couldn't sleep for 4 nights properly. But I was so broken💔I often have these types of dreams. 70% things I see in dreams come true. But I am so sad and confused right now
@@blackblinkunofficial sorry I don't have much knowledge about this situation but can you tell me what made him take this extreme step😣? and is this vlive just the day before his passing?
Hara looked so tired, eye bags from just crying almost :(
And it's like Sulli had like a depressive hysteria of laughing because she knows there's nothing left to lose
I remember, watching Hara on V live and she was crying talking about losing a close friend (sulli) and her manager I guess came in the room and told her she needed to stop crying and start interacting with the fans! it honestly didn’t surprise me when she passed shortly after!
before k!lling themselves, most people are surprisingly happy, maybe because they settled with the decision. sadly, to others they may seem fine, so no one will worry about them.
hey can I pls copy this idea for a vid?
Sulli and Goo Hara went through a lot. Being harassed with sexist comments even though they were victims of their previous partners and the overly conservative society. I also feel for Jonghyun and Moonbin who felt the world's harshness. I hope that they are all at peace now 😔
"I want to be a mum before i die"
-sulli 🥺
💔
She D because of k pooopers fan
i love her, fly high angel 🕊️❤
Jonghyun gave us a hint that "I will take a rest in December" and he died in that month 😭😭 and also that "I have to getting closer to the bed time"....... He gave us a lots of hint but we can't save him 😭😭
Even his close team members can't find it how can we find it???
@@keerthikitty1394 right but still..... The bed time one was the MAIN hint
@@riddhimawithsamridhi no one would have thought that time cuz fans will melt😍 watching their idol so no suspiscous mind will activate...if the fans normally watch they can find it but wat 2 do fans were always crazy....he changed the kpop industry when girls sulli go hara met suicide nothing changed but bcz of him many things changed...god took him to be a messenger to show this worls...let him rest in peace cuz he didnt live a peaceful life as an idol
The fact that I was born in December makes it all more sad 😢😭
I also think he gave us a hint
Jonghyun said his last good bye l can't even complete this coment it is so heartbreaking 🥺😭💔💔
Gurlllllllllllllllllllllllll I used to have the same profile pic as u, BTW hi army 💜 👋
@@Castformsupremacy oh sorry, it is very heartbreaking 😢 💔 😞
@@Ducks_are_cool25 come on for God sake pls stop comment is about jonghyun show some respect I don't mean hate but this is kinda rude
@@totallyawkwardrandomstream3948 did u read my other comment, ? Read it then come argue with me
😭
Hara is such a brave woman. Hara helped in the investigation of Burning Sun, a night club run by her fellow friend Jung, where many assaults, rape and harassment took place. She took herself after that. It's really so sad, how much she went through in her life...RIP Hara. You will always be loved.
Goo Hara and Sulli were two of my fav actresses. It hurts the day i heard the news and it even hurts today
NOW MOONBIN ASTRO...ITS JUST HEARTBREAKING THIS NEVER STOPS
Moonbin died I’d cardiac arrest… no suicide… He was sick Manager didn’t find foul play. He found it like he was sleeping….
🤍🕊🇰🇷moonbin 😭
he still died@@DolceMar56 we still lose a idol due death.
@@DolceMar56it wasn’t confirmed how he died
Moonbin died in 2022 right? I’m not a fan but jeez it hurts when they pushed over the edge like this
Goo hara's eye shows her intense, painful grief
YOU DID WELL JONGHYUN❤
YOU DID WELL MOON BIN❤
YOU DID WELL GOO HARA❤
YOU DID WELL SULLI❤
MY 4 ANGELS 👼❤
#KIMJONGHYUN❤
#MOONBIN❤
#GOOHARA❤
#SULLI❤
#MYANGELS🕊
i was a big big fan of goo hara.... i went to every concert and fanmeet when she died i wouldnot stop crying
When Jonghyun said it's getting closer to bedtime good night all it make my heart broken into million pieces 💔🥺
Even mine he even said good bye to us and we can clearly see that pain in his eyes he looked so tired from battling everything inside him and wanted to give up still he wanted to spend his last moments with his fans and we did not understand about which break he was talking about 💔watching his last live after his death and knowing the reason it breaks me soo hard and makes me cry for hours 🥺
You can see in her eyes she looks sad, depressed & all alone...😢😢😢
Srx video release his she fear
@RBTSHellboy
The old saying "They eyes are the windows to the soul." Is so true.
They just all look like they can't do it anymore.😢
We hated them while they were alive and love them when they are dead. 😔
We lost three angels❤
Rest In Peace 🕊
We'll miss you...
I want to say this that if you're depressed please don't go to social media, instead talk to your friends, family or anyone you are close with because social media makes it worst. Social media is very toxic nowadays so please spend time on the things you like to do, have conversation with people that will motivate you to continue your life.
The knowledge that jonghyun said his plans outloud meant that he'd been thinking about it for a while and was so hopeless that it didn't matter if the fans knew why or when, it was really the only way for him.
He didn't say it out loud because no one is gonna think he means suicide when he says those words. Literally no one would guess it. I would just be like okay he will take a rest from his activities and that hes ending the live and going to sleep. That's not even saying it out loud
@@Ankku98 That is saying it out loud. Just because we interpreted his words differently didn’t mean that he never meant what he said in the way he did. Hermeneutics, my friend.
@@sriv2167 i mean of course he said it out loud, but not directly like "i'm gonna kill myself". But only he knew what he meant, not the fans. Or i don't know if some people suspected something? I dont know, i'm not that deep in the shinee fandom.
I remember the cctv show that he kinda going back and forth in supermarket (or his apartment parking, i don't really remember) and it shows sign that he wanted people to notice him and stop him
@@yeppoheerawhen was this and how do u know?
Rest in peace Moonbin 😭
We lost an another angel 🕊️
That was the last good bye from Jonghyun🥺🥺🥺😭😭
Rest in peace 🙏🏻 🪦 🥺🥺
The fact that l cried as soon as I saw Jonghyuns face, he was my favourite kpop idol and l stanned Shinee for years on no ends because of him.
it's not just their passing that hurts, it's the facts that it's a constant reminder of how we as fans didn't protect our idols and treat them the way they deserved. look what happened.
It seemed like nobody could do anything about Sulli. She had to work on herself. Seemed like she was bipolar.
I mean u really can’t protect them it’s the truth
she got so much hate online from a young age. if people weren’t always so cruel to her maybe she would still be here and whose to say she wasn’t in therapy.
I understand your feelings, but stuff like this is not on the fans. it's the industry's fault and the general stigma of mental health in south korea. there's only so much we can do, all we can is support and advocate
Rest in peace sulli, goo Hara, jonghyun, moonbin, heasoo🕊️❤
they all looked so sad and depressed, and then when I saw jonghyun I was heartbroken, him holding back tears made me feel so sorry for him, I just wish I was there to give him a hug, if just anyone, was there to give him some comfort and love,..
"Goodbye all" 💔 breaks my heart every time
"All of them didn't die by themselves, society did "
True. Being in the KPop Industry is tough especially in Korea where life is so hard. Young teens especially with talents and charms find this way to escape hardships and be able to help or give support to their parents. It's a life struggle for them competing to each other and no assurance whether they'll make it or not. And the fans are the ones who make them reach the height of their success. And some fans sometimes without knowing it are creating divisions among them. Of course, quite normal among fans they tend to have their own favourite and become very vocal about their idol/s. The Idol/Idols feel the atmosphere and deep inside them get the vibes. The rest is you know what will happen.
Rest in peace moonbin,we will never forget u❤️ -19th april 2023
edit 1: thanks for the sweet comments,it shows a lot of people cared about him. we will miss him❤
edit 2: i still think of moonbin every day,we all miss him very much,but he is in great hands and is probably somewhere beautiful. well thats what he deserves.. The time has flies,its been 109 days ago in half an hour since april 19th...💔
I miss u already… rest in peace sleepyhead binnie ❤️❤️❤️ We’ll always remember u so be happier now 😇
I've been crying for like 30 minutes or more now... he may rest in peace...
@@aikim609 we all miss him...lets hope he is in a better place looking down on us❤🕊
Rest in peace dear moonbin ❤
Yes
Jonghyun's word just broke my soul please protect our idols🙏 all idols are same please atleast dont hate them by words 🙏🙏 they also humans too please u dont need to love them atleast dont hurt them🙏😢
Goo Hara looked tired and also holding back tears 😭
I watched jonghyuns last Instagram live.. and I wish I had understood before it was too late.. rest in peace shawols beloved bling bling 🥹😭
🩵🩵🩵
Goo Hara live is days after Sulli... she's crying so hard since when Sulli died, she's not in Korea... she was facing really hard time after her problem with her ex boyfriend, then also Sulli, she feels sorry cause she can't be there for Sulli...
Also I remember how Sulli keep saying that she wants to be a mother and taking care of her kid well... she also choose to not sue any hate comment cause some of them are kid and she didn't want to ruin any kid future...
I really love both Sulli and Hara, they are my favorite member in their group... not far from their death, cvd come... and I lost my grandpa too after that... I feel like, this world maybe too harsh to good people, that's why God trying to protect them and hold them close. I miss them so much... rest in peace for them...
You know what i feel same..
All good people leave early as if god us sayung child you have dealt with that ugly world enough, its time for real rest. ☮️
@@live_smilingyeah................
Sometimes the people that smile the brightest are those who suffer alone on the inside, and they don't tell anyone because they don't want to be a burden.
@@SkzStay25 That's true. Very well said. It hurts so much when we find that out late. 😭 😭 😭
Goo hara was a month after sulli i believe
Does anybody else genuinely feel cold when they watch these videos, I always get a chill all over me and start to cry
Just seeing Sulli smile has me in tears, I miss her so much. You mattered to me princess
I agree they all look very very tired and Goo Hara just downright looked like she wanted to cry as well, I feel so bad for them The kpop industry definitely needs to change and give these idols more rest and more freedom and try to not put so much pressure on them
Why do I cry so hard on jonghung i dont even Stan them 🥺
The only thing I am thinking he must be in soo pain his rest is more painful 😖
Same I just happened to come across a TikTok on him and I just thought of how much hate you must've been receiving to do that. He was beautiful, and he never showed he was hurting. If you watched the funeral you'll probably cry more, all the SHINee members had their heads down and were comforting each other
@@lyphrx even after years or just how happy I am when I see him I always cry
@@Bulletproofxarmy same, I don't know what it is, but he has such a friendly angel like energy. His smile is everything ♥️
Same bro same 😭😭
@@lyphrxthats not jonghyuns case he was loved by public it was probably success related
My poor favorite Kpop Idols rest in peace.
"I want to become a mother before i die."
-*sulli*
Oh my god... It can even be seen in their eyes... Their eyes scream pain, they are just blank and too tired to do anything. Imagine how much they would have gone through to the point they had to choose this. It must have been so tough for them.
was in Hara's last live. i kept telling her we loved her and thanked her for being born. But when someone is that far gone, nothing you can do to stop them unless you literally have hands on them.
Moonbin’s death really hit me in the heart 😢
Astro isn’t the same without him 😢
Even today I can't believe he's gone ❤💔
Rest in peace moonbin🤍 We again lost a beautiful star... Sorry Moonbin, we failed to protect you. You will be missed alot🤍🥀
Goo hara, sulli, jonghyun.......... I miss you so much 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭rest in peace my... Bro /sis
😭😭😭
Jonghyun's one hurts me the most...
You can see the sadness on there 😔 faces.
Can’t believe moonbin was going to be a part of this list
Yeah we failed to protect him too💔and it was also a suicide we lost another angel🥺
Jonghyun got me into kpop back in 2010 and when I woke up that day on December 17/2017 I was numb ngl…
My instagram and musically(tiktok) were filled with the news about him, I couldn’t even go to school or move from my bed.
Jonghyun mattered so much to me even tho I didn’t physically know him it felt like he was an older brother, I was 15 when he passed I’m 20 now and each day I think about how much do all idols truly suffer in silence.
Yo cuando me enteré de eso no lo podía creer....decía y pensaba esto es una pesadillla...quería llorar ....y me preguntaba porque pasaba esto a un ser tan hermoso como el😢😢😢.....en fin paso años.....aún no lo superó.....si tan solo pudiera retroceder el tiempo..me duele 😭😖😖😖😖😰😥😢😔💔😖
My god, I feel sorry for you.
I feel sorry, he in an angel, in any aspect of this word
Theres this girl who is friend to the kpop idols when the her friends die she always atend❤❤❤😢😢😢
People who saw Sulilies comment that said that wasn’t really her comment, though somebody else commented but on her live stream it said "I don't listen to you"
Now it’s moonbin…
Now it's moonbin again we .....failed to protect......
knowing that all of these idols died from hate makes me sick. Those cruel people.
Fly high all u beautiful souls. I’m sorry u had to go through that terrible time in ur life and I hope u are in a better place now❤️✝️🪦
And now moonbin and haesoo…
when jonghyun said I will go to rest at the end of December. this line really broke my heart. I wish that on that time I was able to understand the hidden meaning beside those words but now it's gonna be 5 years when he left us. 죄송합니다 종현 🥺
My hands really stop working when I wrote the above passage. I wish wherever they are, always be happy and rest peacefully 😢
You know whats the scariest part
Is that your seeing a past away person right in your eyes A REAL DEAD PERSON its scary but sad at the same time.
They are all truly missed and I hope they are resting peacefully
Never thought another one would be added
And now moonbin 😢😢 rip my loves
Its so shocking that these idols are prominent figures of the area of Kpop i grew up with. It seems so surreal that these angels arent here anymore. R.I.P to them ♥️
Hey guys I just want anybody to know if your hurting or feeling depression “don’t commit suicide it won’t bring the pain away it’ll just give it to others “.there’s always someone who cares 💓 even if u think that no one does there is.” I care !”so if ur hurting or feeling sad always talk to someone there’s gunna be someone who cares 😊 hope u have a wonderful day whoever reads this fighting~!❣️
Thank you for not forgetting Goo Hara ! It always makes me sad when I see videos of Sulli, Jonghyun... but they always seem to forget Goo Hara
And now, Moonbin is added to the list...
I really love also others k-pop idols please don't hit k- pop idols please 🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
So sad that these young people choose death over life. Wish someone could have helped them. We lose to many rest in peace sweet souls 💜🌹
I never knew about these people until now.. and I feel so deeply sad for what they went through in this lifetime. I wish they were treated like humans, because I'm sure they were overworked and underappreciated. 💔🫶🏻 May they rest in peace
its 2022 and i still cry for jonghyun
The pain the feelings and the thoughts just to give up…it’s so relatable
Are you okay?
@@DJBoise no lol but thank you for asking
@@esraatanoglu9021 okay if you want anyone to talk to I'll be around
Moonbin we will never forget about you. Rest in peace little angel❤️
jonghyun made me want to cry. he knew what he wanted to do. i wish i we've would've checked up on him. i wish we could bring him back. just one day to tell him everything's okay.
If hurts so much knowing the effect people can easily have over someone’s life… People who hate, bully and push people to the point of their death, in my eyes are considered murderers. :(
They are, but what's even more sad is fact that they will never face responsibility for what they did.
If I were a kpop idol, I would have asked Sulli to show people that Sulli was never gone and was always there 🥺💔🕊️
We can't save them because of haters 😭😞 this was our mistake 😭😭
I cannot believe Moonbin will soon be joining these videos
Rest in peace hara, sulli, Jonghyun, moonbin✨
Deep inside they're crying for help, always remember to be kind always we don't know what people are going through.
F %cking kills me seeing Jonghyun talk like it’s ok when it wasn’t😔
We failed to protect one more idol 😭
Rest in peace Moonbin 🕊️
Rest in peace JongHyun, Sulli and Go Hara. 😭
They deserved a long live😢🥺
They all look sad and tired, I feel so bad, Goo-hara and sulli were so beautiful it hurts how much hate they’ve gotten..And jonghyun is so handsome and he looked a little happy but you can tell from his eyes something is wrong I loved him so much he was so caring and adorable, it’s so sad I miss them so much❤.
Who are here after Moonbin's death😭😭😭😭💔💔💔
Sometime you just have to look for that small sign when they are depressed. They are the type of people who like to lie to themselves from others. So that's why you can't label people by their actions.
When J said "I will take a rest by the end of the year." We thought he'll be doing something else beside media but his intention was something we are not ready or expecting to see.
We can clearly see from those videos that they are all scared to take the path they choose. Just remember they are human with emotions. So don't judge them because you don't like them. They didn't do you wrong.
Just respect anyone you come across. It's not worth to judge someone for fun.
Rest In Peace for those who lost their way to the living. God will always love you.
All of them hurt me but the last one hurt me the most he tries giving signs yet we were too blind 😔😞😣
I feel like being alive is a miracle out of those who died and those who died today 😔. To those who died Rest In Peace
The day I read Jonghyun died it broke me I believe it was very early in the morning for me back in 2017 and I just remembered crying my eyes out I didn't leave my room that day I just kept crying wishing it wasn't true and then I saw people saying that they saw a greenish dot in the sky like the colour of shinee and that they felt like that was jonghyun watching over us and when I looked out side I saw it and cried even more but happy to know that he was like I will watch over you that gave me some comfort he was such a amazing person a bright beautiful smile that made you feel safe a kind personality, people forget idols are humans too
.
Edit : this made me look on his insta someone literally said , how did the carbon monoxide taste.... wtf is wrong with people at someone who took their own life I am just disappointed
it's heartbreaking coz there is one more to add now 😭😭
goo hara and sulli's death was one of the saddest deaths.
goo hara lost everything she loved, her bestfriend sulli,her mother,her boyfriend.
sulli was hated for no good reason,i miss them so so much i still cant deal with it.
I find it amazing that most of the comments are saying they regret they couldn't save their idols. Some here may be innocent but I'm sure that there are some here who threw hate at other idols and never thought of the consequences. It's ok to protect their favs but also at the same time they throw hate at other idols. Some here may be hypocrites.
And now moonbin 💔
i still cant believe moonbin from astro has passed away 19 of april 2023 rest in peace😭💔
I enjoyed all there music and it’s getting close to when sulli died😭😭😭😭😭