as a chechen(Kist) it warms my heart to see that there are people like you that spreads our history to people who have never even heard about us. i wish you all god in this world and dont stop what you are doing, rather keep doing it and let the world see other parts of this world who many people dont know about
Bro I got one thing to tell you. You guys don't follow real islam. You have your own law adat law which is against shariah law . Now you tell me how is it possible that tagut ended up being acceptable in Islam.
You are an ethnographer of a very high level of skill. I am amazed someone so young as you is able to managed the complexity of political questions you ask. As polite as you are, you ask some hardball questions. You once told me that I overstate the importance of your work. I don't think so. This was so real and honest and it is documenting a world that is vanishing under the pressure of modernism. As for those pants, every cultural anthropologist has a story to tell about their missteps into cultural conformity and practice. Everything about this video is great!
Fantastic video Artem, the interview with the 80 year old gentleman was wonderful. You really are a great video producer. I have always said about the drone shots. No drone shots here, just brilliant production.
Это Человек нечего не понимает,Он как будто историкос но нечего не понимает болтает так как думает!Я тоже из Панкиси но я не читаю себе Кисти я Чечениц!Первый очеред верующий Мусульманин потом Чечениц!Я ещё раз говорю это Хасо как не Мусульманин так и не Чечениц как мне известно,Это Собака(Хасо)потаму говарить так чтобы разделить народ Чеченцов!
@@Amazon-7888 Вырожайся по аккуратнее, Хасо это один из наших уважаемых старейшин. И он имеет право на своё мнение! Я может тоже с ним в этом не согласен, но я готов жизнь отдать, чтобы наши старейшины могли выражать свою точку зрения)
@@karlteshenberk9702 Я знаю этого Собака и по этаму так говорю!Во первых Он сильнейший Мушрик потом нацист!Он ненавидит Истины Религия так как ненавидят Кадыровский Кафыри!Ишд Нах ч1ог1 зуламхуй бу Дин дуьхьалаъ ше Къоман дуьхьалаъ!Со уже аьл вела,х1инз хьайн лехь жизнь д1ало ради Мушрик Хасо!
I watched and "liked" this on my tv. I very much appreciate all the work you put into your videos. What a special feeling to interview a man who watched history happening. You are so fortunate! My father was in WWII and the Korean War, and he tells us very sad, happy and terrifying stories about the places he was sent to. He told us one story about Japanese daughters who were sent to wash their clothes and massage the men in return for protection from the Japanese soldiers who would rape them. Though I am quite certain in happened on both sides... 😒 They once saved them by warning them of an attack that came in the night. I owe those courageous women my heartfelt thanks for saving my father. I know you miss your drone, but this interview was amazing. Congratulations on a great video my friend.
Nice interview. He was very knowledgeable. The scenery was beautiful! I really like the way you film. You have the camera on a tripod, I'm guessing, then it's filming you walking down the road or you have it to the side or in front of you. Love it. Thanks Artem.
Great production, beautiful footage, excellent interview. It looks like a wonderful and peaceful place to be. That elderly gentleman Khaso is a treasure. When he was talking about Beria's urge to control the regions with or without the Chechen people's presence, I couldn't help but reflect on the same attitude prevailing in the current Ukraine war. It was also interesting that he made a distinction about people not agreeing with Russian influence as opposed to Soviet. Keep up the good work.
Great video! It’s amazing how diverse the culture in Caucasus Region is. I hope they preserve it over generations and live together with each other in peace.
This is very interesting. Khaso Khangoshvili is very very knowledgeable about the history of the area. You were lucky to find him. How did you manage to find him? (Also that he had Grape vines growing behind him). I liked that he said 'At the moment' he is an old man. It made me wonder if his real name might be Benjamin Button. :o)
Khaso Khagoshvili seems quite an amazing character. He tells lots of things we don't know here in the west. Funny anecdote, I never noticed that the Russian word for school is школа and that it is very much pronounced like in our local dialect "skoale". But then Russian has about 3000 Dutch loanwords...
I noticed that not too long ago too. Yeah, thanks Peter the great brought us КАРТОФЕЛЬ . It sounds more official, but stil in use, basically we say КАРТОШКА, more rusified. And how it’s rooted, I couldn’t imagine any Russian cuisine without that!
@@Artem_Mukhametgaliev Картофель comes from German "Kartoffel". We mostly use "aardappel" which literally means "earth apple". IN local dialecty we use "tuffel" and has to do with the strange Low-Saxon habit of dropping the first syllable when abbreviating a word 🤣
very cool and interesting documentary! - As allways of your videos! 🙂 The only question I want to ask: what language do they speek? Is it russian too? (aka: how many different languages are you able to speek?)
They speak 4 languages maximum: Chechen and Georgian is a must have, Russian ~ 60% knows somehow, English ~ 30% knows. I used to speak in Russian with them. I can speak only Russian and English with very small knowledge of Tatar, which similar to others Turkic languages
Чеченский Народ образуется Отдельными Обществами/Мохками(Союзами Тайпов). Кистой-мохк, находящийся сегодня на территории Грузии и есть Один из Отдельных Чеченских Обществ/Мохков(Союзов Тайпов), наряду с другим Отдельным Обществом/Мохком(Союзом Тайпов) - Бацбийцы(Бацой-мохк).
Kogda gavarit chelovek tokogo vozrasta, budu ochen astarojnim i skaju emu s uvajeniem, Gruzini vsegdo bili vaiuiushi narod, i gruzia vsegdo bilo bolshe chem ves kavkaz i esli bi ne bili kem mi bili, mi bi bili sechas musulmanami.
эт кто пукнул гляньт?)))) чувак вы 15 тысяч детей невинных угробили за пять месяцев и продолжаете. звери. хорошо что вы сказали так про грузин я теперь их вообще люблю
Ты наверное один из тех кто после смерти своего Отца женятся на бывшую Жену своего Отца и Меняют своих Дочерей на Компас да? Всё на что вы способны это насиловать четырёх летних Девочек и то своих! Какого хрена ты вмешиваешь Чеченские дела? Эрмлой. Компас Курхарс и Фал ваша сила... пидофилы способны только насиловать своих четырёх летних Девочек!
as a chechen(Kist) it warms my heart to see that there are people like you that spreads our history to people who have never even heard about us. i wish you all god in this world and dont stop what you are doing, rather keep doing it and let the world see other parts of this world who many people dont know about
You guys are terrorists
Bro I got one thing to tell you. You guys don't follow real islam. You have your own law adat law which is against shariah law . Now you tell me how is it possible that tagut ended up being acceptable in Islam.
Very interesting interview. He must have been a great teacher.
Sure, he did!
Fantastic interview, so many different groups in such a relatively small part of the world. Really good that it’s documented and understood by people.
Yes, that's a small part of diversity shown. What's a diversity inside one republic of Dagestan...OMG, uncountable
Фантастика ты он лутче знаеть что как
You are an ethnographer of a very high level of skill. I am amazed someone so young as you is able to managed the complexity of political questions you ask. As polite as you are, you ask some hardball questions. You once told me that I overstate the importance of your work. I don't think so. This was so real and honest and it is documenting a world that is vanishing under the pressure of modernism. As for those pants, every cultural anthropologist has a story to tell about their missteps into cultural conformity and practice. Everything about this video is great!
Thank you, William, I value your appreciation! Thank you!
Fantastic video Artem, the interview with the 80 year old gentleman was wonderful. You really are a great video producer. I have always said about the drone shots. No drone shots here, just brilliant production.
Soon drones will return 🙏🙏🙏
Обиделься цигани из индии😅😅он все кисти панкиси знают кто они сто раз лутче вас
Very interesting to learn about histories that we in the west know very little about. The lush green mountain scenery is quite beautiful too!
Thank you Bill, hopefully once to visit this place again!
So very beautiful! Great cinematography!
Thanks, love it, of course love to get such noticing about the way of filming!
Wonderful video !!! You are doing Great !!!!
These are so informative. We live in such a complex world, these videos are important. Thanks
Thanks much you, Bruce, as always!
Another fantastic vidio
You-re welcome Muriel!
Правда глаза колять ингуси не плачь
Amazing job. Fantastic interview.
🙏☺️
Обиженый ингус история есть вы соченяете сказки это бесполезно есть российский грузинский архивах вся истори начиная манголов на русских на кавказ
Ингус обиженый
Your videos are amazing, in my opinion, on the level of BBC, NatGEO, Discovery and so on...
Thank you, Atosh!
Я тоже из тайпа Дишни, только я из Чечни!
Всегда приятно видеть наших братьев Кистин!!!😊
Это Человек нечего не понимает,Он как будто историкос но нечего не понимает болтает так как думает!Я тоже из Панкиси но я не читаю себе Кисти я Чечениц!Первый очеред верующий Мусульманин потом Чечениц!Я ещё раз говорю это Хасо как не Мусульманин так и не Чечениц как мне известно,Это Собака(Хасо)потаму говарить так чтобы разделить народ Чеченцов!
@@Amazon-7888 Вырожайся по аккуратнее, Хасо это один из наших уважаемых старейшин. И он имеет право на своё мнение!
Я может тоже с ним в этом не согласен, но я готов жизнь отдать, чтобы наши старейшины могли выражать свою точку зрения)
@@Amazon-7888ПНХ ИНЧУШ КУРХАРСНАЯ СОБАКА ОБОСРАНАЯ...НОЛЬ ШЕСТЕРКА.
и нохчи к1енти ма хаз бу 🥰☺️
@@karlteshenberk9702 Я знаю этого Собака и по этаму так говорю!Во первых Он сильнейший Мушрик потом нацист!Он ненавидит Истины Религия так как ненавидят Кадыровский Кафыри!Ишд Нах ч1ог1 зуламхуй бу Дин дуьхьалаъ ше Къоман дуьхьалаъ!Со уже аьл вела,х1инз хьайн лехь жизнь д1ало ради Мушрик Хасо!
This video was fantastic first rate!! Absolutely beautiful and well done. ❤️
Thank you, Roy!
Ингус обиженый 😅😅кисти Нохчи плачь ингус
I watched and "liked" this on my tv. I very much appreciate all the work you put into your videos. What a special feeling to interview a man who watched history happening. You are so fortunate! My father was in WWII and the Korean War, and he tells us very sad, happy and terrifying stories about the places he was sent to. He told us one story about Japanese daughters who were sent to wash their clothes and massage the men in return for protection from the Japanese soldiers who would rape them. Though I am quite certain in happened on both sides... 😒 They once saved them by warning them of an attack that came in the night. I owe those courageous women my heartfelt thanks for saving my father. I know you miss your drone, but this interview was amazing. Congratulations on a great video my friend.
Thank you, Karina. Heartbreaking story, especially knowing context of Koreas resistance
Ассаламу1алайкум братья ЧЕЧЕНЦЫ-КИСТИНЦЫ ! Я НАХЧО из тайпа Дишни. Проживаю в ЧЕЧНЕ, село ДИШНИ-Ведено.
Nice interview. He was very knowledgeable. The scenery was beautiful! I really like the way you film. You have the camera on a tripod, I'm guessing, then it's filming you walking down the road or you have it to the side or in front of you. Love it. Thanks Artem.
Seeking wide-angle lens for my GH5 to refuse using iPhone for logging and unify camera shoots . I put sometimes iPhone or GH5 itself on a tripod
Great production, beautiful footage, excellent interview. It looks like a wonderful and peaceful place to be. That elderly gentleman Khaso is a treasure. When he was talking about Beria's urge to control the regions with or without the Chechen people's presence, I couldn't help but reflect on the same attitude prevailing in the current Ukraine war. It was also interesting that he made a distinction about people not agreeing with Russian influence as opposed to Soviet. Keep up the good work.
Thank you! Hopefully, I do!
This is a great video! Greetings from Turkey!
Great video! It’s amazing how diverse the culture in Caucasus Region is. I hope they preserve it over generations and live together with each other in peace.
Amazing vid very interesting, thank you for your work.
Самое прекрасное место на планете это Панкиский ущелье)) очень скучаю по тебе ❤
Kists fought for Georgia in every war respect.
This is very interesting. Khaso Khangoshvili is very very knowledgeable about the history of the area. You were lucky to find him. How did you manage to find him?
(Also that he had Grape vines growing behind him).
I liked that he said 'At the moment' he is an old man. It made me wonder if his real name might be Benjamin Button. :o)
🤣🤣🤣
As all I do - just come and find)))) Thank you much!
Artem, utterly fascinating! But how did you get back home?
With locals by taxi, thanks they promoted me how do it cheaper. Thank you, Nyckolaus!
Chechen georgian beotherhood❤
"Bent not broken."
Khaso Khagoshvili seems quite an amazing character. He tells lots of things we don't know here in the west. Funny anecdote, I never noticed that the Russian word for school is школа and that it is very much pronounced like in our local dialect "skoale".
But then Russian has about 3000 Dutch loanwords...
I noticed that not too long ago too. Yeah, thanks Peter the great brought us КАРТОФЕЛЬ . It sounds more official, but stil in use, basically we say КАРТОШКА, more rusified. And how it’s rooted, I couldn’t imagine any Russian cuisine without that!
@@Artem_Mukhametgaliev Картофель comes from German "Kartoffel". We mostly use "aardappel" which literally means "earth apple". IN local dialecty we use "tuffel" and has to do with the strange Low-Saxon habit of dropping the first syllable when abbreviating a word 🤣
very cool and interesting documentary! - As allways of your videos! 🙂
The only question I want to ask: what language do they speek? Is it russian too?
(aka: how many different languages are you able to speek?)
They speak 4 languages maximum: Chechen and Georgian is a must have, Russian ~ 60% knows somehow, English ~ 30% knows. I used to speak in Russian with them.
I can speak only Russian and English with very small knowledge of Tatar, which similar to others Turkic languages
@@Artem_Mukhametgaliev I see, thx very much for the answer and information - or let`s say SPASIBA ;-)
What's the rent or hotel daily price?
I paid 25$ per night in guest house
First comment 😄
And last 😅🤣😅🤣😂😂
Чеченский Народ образуется Отдельными Обществами/Мохками(Союзами Тайпов). Кистой-мохк, находящийся сегодня на территории Грузии и есть Один из Отдельных Чеченских Обществ/Мохков(Союзов Тайпов), наряду с другим Отдельным Обществом/Мохком(Союзом Тайпов) - Бацбийцы(Бацой-мохк).
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👈
Kogda gavarit chelovek tokogo vozrasta, budu ochen astarojnim i skaju emu s uvajeniem, Gruzini vsegdo bili vaiuiushi narod, i gruzia vsegdo bilo bolshe chem ves kavkaz i esli bi ne bili kem mi bili, mi bi bili sechas musulmanami.
Уай ю спик нотрашн)? Спик рашн , ер экцент из фанни)))
ну и ладно, че стесняться акцента)
Грузины - самая нацистская нация из всех, что я видел!
эт кто пукнул гляньт?)))) чувак вы 15 тысяч детей невинных угробили за пять месяцев и продолжаете. звери. хорошо что вы сказали так про грузин я теперь их вообще люблю
?
Интересно 👍
Хасо бох Ж1ал Аллах1у х1алак йоал хьо нацист!Хьай Наркоман,Алкаш Кант мух валар нисделир из дицахь Гуьржи 1едал лей хьо!Оц Панкиси мел вог1уш вол Кафир хьун те х1унд вог1?Вог1 дер хьо шой Ж1ал дол ден!
Даял ингуш хьай куйх цабойаш.
Бузуртанов яхш кагдойти хюрск я хьо...курхарс чу бид тел хьайн джал.
Ты наверное один из тех кто после смерти своего Отца женятся на бывшую Жену своего Отца и Меняют своих Дочерей на Компас да? Всё на что вы способны это насиловать четырёх летних Девочек и то своих! Какого хрена ты вмешиваешь Чеченские дела? Эрмлой. Компас Курхарс и Фал ваша сила... пидофилы способны только насиловать своих четырёх летних Девочек!
Смотреть долго,времени нет... А что вы так набросились на какого то Хасо,что так резко реагируете на него..?
Ма ледар къамял дяш ву хьо, цхьа джим бьорш хил, хьо мил ву и диц? Хьо мил ву, хьена ву ала? Вэй хьовсар ду, хьа чур нах мух бу, хьо а ту лелош ву? Стаг вац хьо ца алахь!
Не знал что Хасо так хорошо говорит на русском
К сожалению, он скончался. И грузинский у него был идеальный, так говорить в Грузии мог только Илья Чавчавадзе и еще немногие.