It's not just a California issue, if we can overturn the Assault Weapons ban here, it will eliminate it across the entire country. Text, history, and tradition.
True if every circuit would acknowledge it, here in Tenn they have no problems with any weapons. We are Cc state this mostly has to fall for the blue states that want to Outlaw and abolish our 2nd right.
Hopefully the Supreme Court can give the 9th circus a whoopin for playing games as political activists instead of judges on behalf of the constitution.
The biggest issue I have with The People's Republic Of California is the legislature can push a law through in a matter of weeks and we have to pay both sides for years to get rid of it.
@@scottman6969 Then stay and fight for your rights but I'll be enjoying them elsewhere. Honestly I think the northeast and far west are lost causes regarding high taxes and overregulation. High taxes and overregulation may ultimately be the fate of all states, but I intend to enjoy my life for as long as I can :)
❤❤❤ Kudos to judge Benita's and his assisting clerks or attorneys that helped him our hats go off. To you guys, we thank you so much for all the hard work. And late countless hours you put in. Thank you so much, God bless you all.😊
Thank you for these posts. They are so important on so many levels. Kudos to Joel and everyone who speaks with Joel on these posts, especially Chuck M., Sam P., and Rick T.
Why is it so easy for them to pass these unconstitutional laws. Yet they make it so hard to take them off. It sure sounds like a kangaroo court system.
Bruen made things worse in NY. The relalitory laws they passed were far worse than what we had before. Multiple suits have been filed but the circuit Court has denied staying the laws using interest balancing in violation of Bruen and the SCOTUS has declined emergency review of every case so far. It makes zero sense for them to have sent the cases that were already before them back down to have to work their way back up. They could have settled the matter narion wide. Instead of stalling. A right delayed is a right denied.
The Bruen case has already made a MAJOR change, every state is now SHALL issue not MAY issue for CCW.. that is a major major change for CA and many other states using may issue to deny people on their whim
I’ve asked countless people this question…Will this be making its way to New York? I’m in Ticonderoga (Upstate) and we are being restricted to Death here. Kathy Hochul should be impeached.
If this thing is struck down in the 9th circuit court I think this will only apply to states under the 9th circuit jurisdiction. You guys in New York would still be sol.
As frustrated as I am, I have to stay the course and agree with Mr. Michel and to keep fighting through the courts, and it will ultimately win this for us peacefully. I can kick in another $100 this month to CRPA. Thanks for fighting for us.
We need a better system. The current system incentives the gun lobby by getting more money the more 2A challenge laws that are enacted. There is a financial incentive that incentives the lobbyists. It's a mes
Thank you so much for the video and update. This is not a sprint, it is a marathon, just like our independence from the crown, and our Bill of Rights was. I am supporting this effort for me, me fellow citizen, and for all our posterity to come.
OK----ask chuck why his group has never fought for open carry or offered any help to Charles Nichols who has been fighting for Ca open carry since 2012!
Chuck Michel, the 9th District did NOT listen to the SCOTUS, and sent back the same verdict they did before Bruen. I wish Judge Benitez had at least given us another “freedom week.”
When the Miller decision came out I yawned and went about my day and didn't give it a second thought. I know I'm still looking at years before my AR's can be normal.
Anyone doing a background check should be sued and felony charges brought against them in a federal court in violation of Title 18 U.S.C. section 241 conspiracy against rights, Title 18 U.S.C. section 242 deprivation of rights under color of law, Title 5 U.S.C. section 7311 Ex. ORD. No. 10450 subsection (5).
Mr. Persinger, as we've seen around the country some judges just defy the supreme court. This happens not only in 2A cases but other cases as well. Unfortunately, the political winds sway some judges. How are these types of judges delt with? The 9th does this often without accountability. This is the ongoing problem with cases that never seem to be resolved. Can the supreme court disbar a judge in defiance? Pick a topic, there are defying judges out there.
Man I can’t wait till you put up a video telling us to unCuck out rifles and get all the standard/high capacity magazines we want. We’re free!!! One day 🤙🏾. Thanks for what you do.
A right delayed is a right denied. Granting a stay is direct defiance and should be a mandatory prison sentence for any judge who defies the supreme court and refuses to uphold the laws of the land.
Joel is right, nothing ever changes, but the bottom line is we have to stay in the fight and support the organization who are fighting for our rights, whether county, state and federal, it is frustrating but we have to stay in it!!!🤔👊👊👊
So when can good Californians purchase AR15s again, without restrictions on sCaRy FeAtUrEs or magazine capacity? And when will the rest of the tyrannical states remove their bans 🤷♂️? Prayers from the UN-Constitution State of Connecticut 🙏🇺🇸!!
This is Kommiefornia(I know that is what we are called).For us here time moves slowly .Wins for us are slow and long comming.But when they happen they affect the whole country.Which turns out to help alot of other states.I would suggest helping the the gun groups when you can.The people in the free states are helping us.The sad part is that it takes time.I truely believe we will WIN.
Actually both parties are in violation of the second Amendment. GRUSOM for continuing violating Constitution and his oath which is treason and Benitez for doing the same. there is no debate on the 2nd Amendment.
If judge Benitez was really a saint, he wouldn't have put a stay on it. At least give us a freedom week, because that's the only opportunity you'll get for years, if ever, while the case bounces back and forth.
These judges can be removed from their benches under title 5 U.S.C. section 7311 Ex. ORD. No. 10450 subsection (5), Title 18 U.S.C. section 1918, Title 18 U.S.C. section 241,242. And article 2 section 4,article 3 shall hold their offices during good behavior (violating, waring against the constitution is bad behavior, grounds for a judges immediate removal from their bench).
The lifetime appointments are a horrible idea for the inferior courts. ONE 15 year Elected term with no chance for further fed. Employment should be the standard.
Questions for Chuck: The last interview I saw with him (can’t remember if it was on Gun Guy TV or somewhere else) he was talking about taking Duncan to SCOTUS. Any further updates on that? I didn’t hear Boland/Renna cases mentioned here. Are they in a similar boat as all the others as far as how the 9th will approach them? The state put off micro stamping for a few years. Does he expect this to have any effect on Boland/Renna cases?
Can someone file a lawsuit against these corrupt judges? They are effecting every one of these pending cases and personally effecting everyone that lives in California and supports the 2A.
Joel...the idea that we the people will not have to fight for our rights is the false proposition...tyranny exists in and outside this country and will forever strive to undermine human rights. The founders of the Greatest Country, knew this and did their best to give a perpetual structure for citizens to fight back....stay strong, stay vigilant, stay free...there is no silver bullet for this, just getting up everyday and standing our ground.❤
How can these judges be so misaligned , why do they need to find a Method to interpet the Bruen Case? Do they not understand Plain English "Shall not Be Infringed" Scotus needs to do their Job snd Rule accordingly.........
I’m not featureless. I have the cross armor break down rear pin release to remove mag. I thought this new ruling negates the features determining fixed or removable mag? Do we wait to see if the ruling sticks to see if my AR with a pistol grip can have a normal mag release?
Bruen Didn't change the Safety Claws. (the safety claws is part of the foundation of being "well Regulated") regulations can be implemented to address very specific problems that pose a danger to public safety.
What does it matter, after this week with a Czech corp. Purchasing our ammo producing companys, big ones .ike CCI, Speer, Remington and Winchester saying no more civilian sales 70% of our ammo is gone. Yesterday the was an exllosion at thd Hornady ammo plant, gee, what a convienent accjdent?!?!?!. Looks ,ike we could win everh case and still be scfewed !!!
All background checks are unconstitutional therefore illegal in violation of article 4 section 2 paragraph 1, second amendment,9th amendment,14th amendment section 1. And illegal felonies in violation of Title 18 U.S.C. section 241 conspiracy against rights, Title 18 U.S.C. section 242, Title 5 U.S.C. section 7311 Ex. ORD. No. 10450 subsection (5).
It’s all BS and none of this ever goes anywhere. We all get excited and get our hopes up for nothing and all these donations are becoming a waste of time of money and nothing ever changes. People are getting to their point where they don’t care anymore. I asked myself last night being a California native. Will I ever see any of these changes in my lifetime and I am now 50yrs old.
38:45 Since we (arguably) only have 1 generation before SCOTUS swings left, any thoughts on the Court revisiting the holding of Miller '38, in light of Minneapolis Star '83, and Bruen to finally strike down the NFA? Or am I just wishing too hard?
How un-American how are these people even considered for America? Aren’t they supposed to uphold our laws not tear them down!!! I’m just a dumb floor layer and infringement is infringement. Do they not know how to read the definition of a word?
Ok, let's just be honest...the reason nobody believe it will happen is that it seems the 9th is looking for a way to eliminate Bruen. If they can't come up with a legal reason, I'll really be shocked with these pukes that have violated our rights for my entire life. I'm similar age and just as skeptic as Joel. Voter ID ASAP!🗽(so we have better odds at the ballots)
Question what effect will the Benitez strike down have on the assault weapon registry that. The state imposed on it’s citizens when do we get to loss the fin grip?
Mark from four boxes diner is saying Benitez is wrong in the way that he is putting the "common use" test in a way that the state in future cases might use to try and manipulate the pro 2A side into carrying the burden. Does Chuck have any concerns of that happening?
It's not just a California issue, if we can overturn the Assault Weapons ban here, it will eliminate it across the entire country. Text, history, and tradition.
True if every circuit would acknowledge it, here in Tenn they have no problems with any weapons. We are Cc state this mostly has to fall for the blue states that want to Outlaw and abolish our 2nd right.
Hopefully the Supreme Court can give the 9th circus a whoopin for playing games as political activists instead of judges on behalf of the constitution.
I seriously doubt that is possible
The METHODOLOGY is IGNORANCE is NOT a DEFENSE
@@texture6 exactly
@@damanyocum149 It will happen
@@scottp7587I seriously doubt it
The biggest issue I have with The People's Republic Of California is the legislature can push a law through in a matter of weeks and we have to pay both sides for years to get rid of it.
Legislatures which pass and Governors who sign unconstitutional laws need to be penalized.
@@philipdepalma4672 and incarcerated
That's why I would recommend avoid living in the northeast and far west.
@@andnorr7738why would we run away like cowards???. Real men stay and fight for their rights.
@@scottman6969 Then stay and fight for your rights but I'll be enjoying them elsewhere. Honestly I think the northeast and far west are lost causes regarding high taxes and overregulation. High taxes and overregulation may ultimately be the fate of all states, but I intend to enjoy my life for as long as I can :)
Newsom crying like a beach is a real good sign. IMO.
It wont last they will rule against it.....sadly
These tyrannical crooks need to be jailed
How many times do we have to do this? Cause we r way past insanity
This ends when enough people feel that the pain of inaction is more than the pain of action.
Over and over again as long as politicians don't uphold the constitution and the people are in support of laws that violate the 2A
The assault weapon ban being struck down is great news and thank you for the 2a News brother.
❤❤❤ Kudos to judge Benita's and his assisting clerks or attorneys that helped him our hats go off. To you guys, we thank you so much for all the hard work. And late countless hours you put in. Thank you so much, God bless you all.😊
This all means nothing until it's finalized.
disband the 9th they know this is wrong!
Thank you for these posts. They are so important on so many levels. Kudos to Joel and everyone who speaks with Joel on these posts, especially Chuck M., Sam P., and Rick T.
Outstanding video and presentation
Remember too- the word “Assault” is a Noun and a Verb but but it is not a adjective.
There literally cant be “an assault rifle”
So I wonder if Illinois watching California and it’s outcome
The icing on the cake will be challenging the need for a CCW permit.
The icing would be elimination of all illegal unconstitutional background checks.
Why is it so easy for them to pass these unconstitutional laws. Yet they make it so hard to take them off. It sure sounds like a kangaroo court system.
Cost lots of money to fight the laws that corrupt inept politicians try to tyrannically force in it's minion's uhm I mean people
Well done!
Brady and Giffords are also doing this.
Your right! So many times we win, then ………..😮 nothing! Time to load up some more popcorn and watch the rerun!
Thanks for your show. 🙌🙏❤️
The long term problem is that law schools are teaching future lawyers and judges badly. They Progressive movement is in charge of the law school.
Caetano - All Bearable Arms Are Protected. It really is that simple.
Good job Joel!
Bruen made things worse in NY. The relalitory laws they passed were far worse than what we had before. Multiple suits have been filed but the circuit Court has denied staying the laws using interest balancing in violation of Bruen and the SCOTUS has declined emergency review of every case so far. It makes zero sense for them to have sent the cases that were already before them back down to have to work their way back up. They could have settled the matter narion wide. Instead of stalling. A right delayed is a right denied.
For a minute then back to the 9th full panel and then rejected and we start all over again
That can't happen.
@@jimklemens5018 why not? They did it with the magazine ban. Is there something I don't know
@@jeffreymorgan4381 How would the case get kicked back to Benitez again?
@@jimklemens5018 it wouldn't. it would go to 11 panel in the 9th circuit just like the magazine ban.
@@jeffreymorgan4381 The Miller case will go to a three judge panel first.
Thank you for your channel. Appreciate good men like you.
So nice of you to say.
Thanks great information 🦅🇺🇸
The only thing that actually changed was the sunset on the AW ban. Nothing else.
The Bruen case has already made a MAJOR change, every state is now SHALL issue not MAY issue for CCW.. that is a major major change for CA and many other states using may issue to deny people on their whim
Thank you, gentlemen
The SCOTUS has to clean The 9Th Sewer.
I’ve asked countless people this question…Will this be making its way to New York? I’m in Ticonderoga (Upstate) and we are being restricted to Death here. Kathy Hochul should be impeached.
If this thing is struck down in the 9th circuit court I think this will only apply to states under the 9th circuit jurisdiction. You guys in New York would still be sol.
As frustrated as I am, I have to stay the course and agree with Mr. Michel and to keep fighting through the courts, and it will ultimately win this for us peacefully. I can kick in another $100 this month to CRPA. Thanks for fighting for us.
We need a better system. The current system incentives the gun lobby by getting more money the more 2A challenge laws that are enacted. There is a financial incentive that incentives the lobbyists. It's a mes
The METHODOLOGY is IGNORANCE is NOT a DEFENSE
Thank you so much for the video and update. This is not a sprint, it is a marathon, just like our independence from the crown, and our Bill of Rights was. I am supporting this effort for me, me fellow citizen, and for all our posterity to come.
OK----ask chuck why his group has never fought for open carry or offered any help to Charles Nichols who has been fighting for Ca open carry since 2012!
I have been wondering about that also. He was the OG constitutional open carry advocate ❤
Chuck Michel, the 9th District did NOT listen to the SCOTUS, and sent back the same verdict they did before Bruen. I wish Judge Benitez had at least given us another “freedom week.”
will wait another 5 decades before we get and answer by all these courts. I'm 61 yrs of age and it's been like this for the last 40 yrs.
Question: What could the Bruen case say about the constitutionality of the National Firearms Act?
This almost certainly will go to the Supreme Court for final resolution, so the question is how long will we have to wait?
Does this affect the first roberti-roos law!!!!!!!!!
When the Miller decision came out I yawned and went about my day and didn't give it a second thought. I know I'm still looking at years before my AR's can be normal.
Anyone doing a background check should be sued and felony charges brought against them in a federal court in violation of Title 18 U.S.C. section 241 conspiracy against rights, Title 18 U.S.C. section 242 deprivation of rights under color of law, Title 5 U.S.C. section 7311 Ex. ORD. No. 10450 subsection (5).
Its a great day when i see a Mr. Persinger upload!
Mr. Persinger, as we've seen around the country some judges just defy the supreme court. This happens not only in 2A cases but other cases as well. Unfortunately, the political winds sway some judges. How are these types of judges delt with?
The 9th does this often without accountability. This is the ongoing problem with cases that never seem to be resolved.
Can the supreme court disbar a judge in defiance? Pick a topic, there are defying judges out there.
The 9th circuit Court a Appeal there not for the people of the 2 Amendment it sad when people don't trust the courts
Man I can’t wait till you put up a video telling us to unCuck out rifles and get all the standard/high capacity magazines we want. We’re free!!!
One day 🤙🏾.
Thanks for what you do.
I was unsubscribed, apparently by Facebook. I re subscribed this a.m.
Extremely important for everyone in Comifornia that enjoys the second Amendment and would like to the desendants to actually also enjoy our rights 😮
Not really. It's going to get appealed and a stay is going to get placed. It'll be dragged for at least 5 more years through the courts.
So what happens to the 80% builds if they are no longer considered assault rifle any more under this decision?
A right delayed is a right denied. Granting a stay is direct defiance and should be a mandatory prison sentence for any judge who defies the supreme court and refuses to uphold the laws of the land.
Benitez stayed his own ruling.
@jimklemens5018 in the i was referring to the 11 judge panel when it gets there
Joel is right, nothing ever changes, but the bottom line is we have to stay in the fight and support the organization who are fighting for our rights, whether county, state and federal, it is frustrating but we have to stay in it!!!🤔👊👊👊
GOOD !!!
Yeah, I’m 63 and I won’t live long enough to see my freedoms restored…..
I love CRPA tweet to Gavin.. awesome
So when can good Californians purchase AR15s again, without restrictions on sCaRy FeAtUrEs or magazine capacity? And when will the rest of the tyrannical states remove their bans 🤷♂️? Prayers from the UN-Constitution State of Connecticut 🙏🇺🇸!!
Get out of my house Dude 😂
This is Kommiefornia(I know that is what we are called).For us here time moves slowly .Wins for us are slow and long comming.But when they happen they affect the whole country.Which turns out to help alot of other states.I would suggest helping the the gun groups when you can.The people in the free states are helping us.The sad part is that it takes time.I truely believe we will WIN.
Actually both parties are in violation of the second Amendment. GRUSOM for continuing violating Constitution and his oath which is treason and Benitez for doing the same. there is no debate on the 2nd Amendment.
If judge Benitez was really a saint, he wouldn't have put a stay on it. At least give us a freedom week, because that's the only opportunity you'll get for years, if ever, while the case bounces back and forth.
Drive to Nevada (wink, wink).
Freedom week for the assault weapon ban?
Due to politics freedom week is a no no in California now
@@hokanut Both the mag ban and the scary rifle ban.
These judges can be removed from their benches under title 5 U.S.C. section 7311 Ex. ORD. No. 10450 subsection (5), Title 18 U.S.C. section 1918, Title 18 U.S.C. section 241,242. And article 2 section 4,article 3 shall hold their offices during good behavior (violating, waring against the constitution is bad behavior, grounds for a judges immediate removal from their bench).
The lifetime appointments are a horrible idea for the inferior courts. ONE 15 year Elected term with no chance for further fed. Employment should be the standard.
Questions for Chuck:
The last interview I saw with him (can’t remember if it was on Gun Guy TV or somewhere else) he was talking about taking Duncan to SCOTUS. Any further updates on that?
I didn’t hear Boland/Renna cases mentioned here. Are they in a similar boat as all the others as far as how the 9th will approach them?
The state put off micro stamping for a few years. Does he expect this to have any effect on Boland/Renna cases?
Can someone file a lawsuit against these corrupt judges? They are effecting every one of these pending cases and personally effecting everyone that lives in California and supports the 2A.
No. Under longstanding Supreme Court precedent, judges have absolute immunity from
suit (for better or worse)
No.
Joel...the idea that we the people will not have to fight for our rights is the false proposition...tyranny exists in and outside this country and will forever strive to undermine human rights. The founders of the Greatest Country, knew this and did their best to give a perpetual structure for citizens to fight back....stay strong, stay vigilant, stay free...there is no silver bullet for this, just getting up everyday and standing our ground.❤
I'm going to miss breaking that law.
How can these judges be so misaligned , why do they need to find a Method to interpet the Bruen Case? Do they not understand Plain English "Shall not Be Infringed" Scotus needs to do their Job snd Rule accordingly.........
So can we put regular mag releases back on and pistol grips or not?
No you can't.
Not yet. Soon sounds like.
I’m not featureless. I have the cross armor break down rear pin release to remove mag. I thought this new ruling negates the features determining fixed or removable mag? Do we wait to see if the ruling sticks to see if my AR with a pistol grip can have a normal mag release?
They also need to find how much these cases have cost from day one.
Will I get my California assault weapon registration fee returned with interest?
When will the CA gun roster be challenged?
By making it out of wood
That is one of the cases we are still waiting for.
The 9th Never goes in favor of gun owners!
Glad I moved to Nevada and don't have deal with the Bravo Sierra that is going on in occupied Kalifornistan.
I think he is way to optimistic. The courts understand how the ruling is supposed to be applied. They’re just not doing it and they won’t anytime soon
Bruen Didn't change the Safety Claws. (the safety claws is part of the foundation of being "well Regulated")
regulations can be implemented to address very specific problems that pose a danger to public safety.
Well regulated has nothing to do with government regulation.
Claws?
Still behind bars waiting for relief, you can’t depend on McDonald, Heller or Bruen.
Time marches on….standby 3-5 years
Soooo can I have a pistol grip now?
no, you'll have to wait ten years to find out you can't
What does it matter, after this week with a Czech corp. Purchasing our ammo producing companys, big ones .ike CCI, Speer, Remington and Winchester saying no more civilian sales 70% of our ammo is gone. Yesterday the was an exllosion at thd Hornady ammo plant, gee, what a convienent accjdent?!?!?!. Looks ,ike we could win everh case and still be scfewed !!!
All background checks are unconstitutional therefore illegal in violation of article 4 section 2 paragraph 1, second amendment,9th amendment,14th amendment section 1. And illegal felonies in violation of Title 18 U.S.C. section 241 conspiracy against rights, Title 18 U.S.C. section 242, Title 5 U.S.C. section 7311 Ex. ORD. No. 10450 subsection (5).
It’s all BS and none of this ever goes anywhere. We all get excited and get our hopes up for nothing and all these donations are becoming a waste of time of money and nothing ever changes.
People are getting to their point where they don’t care anymore. I asked myself last night being a California native. Will I ever see any of these changes in my lifetime and I am now 50yrs old.
38:45 Since we (arguably) only have 1 generation before SCOTUS swings left, any thoughts on the Court revisiting the holding of Miller '38, in light of Minneapolis Star '83, and Bruen to finally strike down the NFA? Or am I just wishing too hard?
Hi, Joel 😁
How un-American how are these people even considered for America? Aren’t they supposed to uphold our laws not tear them down!!!
I’m just a dumb floor layer and infringement is infringement. Do they not know how to read the definition of a word?
Groundhog Day
Hopefully soon Mr desperado 😂
No State or Federal Government can make a Law telling Gun Owner there guns are illeagal or take our Guns
They are all committing maladministration against our rights. That is a felony crime.
Forget about it
So can we now remove the fin grips & maglocks?!?!
No. It's on appeal to the 9th Circuit.
What are they going to do about background checks for ammunition
Ok, let's just be honest...the reason nobody believe it will happen is that it seems the 9th is looking for a way to eliminate Bruen. If they can't come up with a legal reason, I'll really be shocked with these pukes that have violated our rights for my entire life. I'm similar age and just as skeptic as Joel. Voter ID ASAP!🗽(so we have better odds at the ballots)
FEED THE GTMO
thank you gentlemen for your explanation but as a layman I'm overwhelm but I do understand bologna
So with this decision, does this mean that we can take the wing off of our ARs?
No. It's on appeal to the 9th Circuit.
Question what effect will the Benitez strike down have on the assault weapon registry that. The state imposed on it’s citizens when do we get to loss the fin grip?
The law will go away when the Supreme Court rules against it.
Awesome
Don't forget about Staples decision
The justice department (courts) and law enforcement have been operating illegally unconstitutionally for the past 100 years.
Each and every American citizen is the militia (THE RIGHT of THE PEOPLE). Including felons.
Is: Year's
S/B: Days
Mark from four boxes diner is saying Benitez is wrong in the way that he is putting the "common use" test in a way that the state in future cases might use to try and manipulate the pro 2A side into carrying the burden. Does Chuck have any concerns of that happening?
Hmm... there's nothing specific in your question for me to ask Chuck. What is the gent's specific issue with common use?
The Supreme Court, already decided