Sorry to interrupt.. guys can you do me a favor and report this fan page on IG. She keeps on expressing hate *towards* our Rosié. I can message you our recent conversation in IG. page name: *jenlisas_.edits* I heart Rosié so much that she doesn't deserve any single hate.. and I appreciate all members.. Thank you!
tuyet ngan nguyen what? Her voice was always high pitched it’s just lower here. Blackpink have 3 high pitched voices and one mezzo soprano. They didn’t “need”a high voice. Rosé already had a high voice it just became higher.
로제 이거 불렀을 때 15살이라는데 데뷔할 때는 성인이었으니까 5년 사이에 창법이 바뀌었을 수도 있지 뭘 로제 목소리를 돌려달라느니.. 양현석이 강제로 목소리를 바꿨다느니하고 있음...로제가 인어공주냐 목소리 강제로 뺏기게; 3:09 이부분에서는 현재 창법도 보이는디...
Guys listen closely here at 3:09 she sounds the same as know at the beginning of the song it was low so rosé had to make her voice a little deeper plus there is a lot of audio tune in the song so no one could recognise her voice cuz she is the mysterious member in bp before she even debuted and also you could hear the audio tune in gd's voice second back then rosé didn't hit puberty yet so ofc it's gonna sound different again 3:09 here she sounds the same as know
I actaully agree on this, Rose was actually used another vocal technique...as in 3:09 indeed for me she sounds pretty similar to how she sings in bp songs, I never find Rose voice is weird, I would say it is unique, for me Rose's part in every bp songs is always great. I always attached to every Rose's line in bp songs... From the very beginning I started to love this girls group, for me Rose is deserved her title as main vocal, from their debut boombayah until their latest songs, Rose part is always been my favourite. But I wouldn't deny, Rose voice is soo beautiful in this song indeed, I just hope her solo music is "different" than what bp is used to be, maybe using this vocal technique again? I don't know, but I'd love it
Truly divine!!!! Her voice then and now are still the same, gd must've lowered her voice for the song. Alot of singers change their vocal range or their voice so that it can fit to the song. But not completely change it.
maybe she did it on purpose i mean she sang low to not be recognised from another people maybe her actually technique is the technique that she uses now
3:08 you can hear that the voice isn't changed it's only in a lower tone because the song is in a lower tone then Blackpink songs😅when people understand that she is not faking
She's not as faking as people make it but she still does. Look at Bom, they made her have a fake her voice when she was under yg and look now, her voice is damaged. Rosé's voicf is for sure being damaged too. I believe she can have a high pitched voice without forcing on her voice
Exactly plus this is edited😂why people make up things like she's destroying her voice and all😂😂if she ever sings in low scale her voice will sound deep again! She's good at singing at low scale like really good and that's why she can change scales while singing. But she didn't master the transition that's why it sounds bad sometimes and people say things like that about her!
I don't think it literally change, for me its more like rose's voice is adjusting to the song given to her. Whatever style she use is beautiful. In other words, rose's voice is versatile. Truly a queen 😍😘💗
IDK why YG would do this to rose her voice in this video is really good than now (i like it but i prefer this voice) YG is just turning rose’s voice nassal and hard to sing just like 2ne1’s Bom’s voice they made it unique idk why YG would want unique voices but rose’s vocal chords are suffering bc of rose’s singing technique i hope she can think of a good technique in singing soon or her voice will be much nassaly(idk if it’s a word) than here voice know but i hope YG will bring Rose’s old voice back
YG has nothing to do with the artists voices...its their own distinction...what yg responsibility is to develope..enhance and help them overcome the possible difficulties in terms of singing...its not impossible that during this song they used some technical tools to sound it this way....try to see the pre debut vids of rosé because that was her real singing voice and only in this song it sounds like not so much her voice...and i dont think why u find it hard for her to sing on that voice because as what all people reactions and not to mentions those highly recognized musicians during her guestings on king of mask singer and fantastic duo was all amazed and mesmerized on her voice and praises her for having a high quality tone...and its obvious that shes comfortable with her voice...much love and godbless
i heard from someone that expert vocalist i think, she said rose did not suffering her vocal chords, according to her. maybe she comfortable that way for now. she became used to become trendy.
Yes I agree with you and you are so right... I just live the way how rose sings a low pitch note in this song other than the extra auto tuning yg does this is actually how the singing should really fit in her in Blackpink but now the way she sings in Blackpink its more like a 12 yr old good vocal voice. Anyway she is still the main vocalist in Blackpink and her voice is just good...
너무 마음아프다 어쩌다 로제창법 바뀐거라는 댓글 봐서 전 창법은 어땠을까 찾아보던 중에 보는 영상인데 지금도 분명 잘부르는게 이게 훨씬더 듣기에도 편하고 로제라는 사람의 색이 확 표현되고 흔하지 않는 목소리 같음.. 지금 창법이 더 목에 무리가고 색을 잃은거 같아요 ㅠ 다른영상 찾아보니까 바뀐 창법때문에 예전 창법은 아예 잊은거 같던데 ㅜㅜㅜㅠ
ROSE'S VOICE IS SO AMAZING!! I LIKE HOW HARD AND DEEP HER VOICE HERE! I LOVE IT MORE THAN HER VOICE!!!! BEAUTIFUL SONG GD AND ROSE!! WHOOO!!! 😆😆😍😍😍😭😭💞💞💞
It’s not her old voice she can still use this voice but she now uses a different technique and she uses a pitch higher up in her vocal range to match blackpinks songs sounds.
I feel so happy for Rosé and I'm literally crying tears of joy for her to see how far she got through, becoming one of the most popular K-pop artists in the market now. Rosé hwaiting! BLACKPINK HWAITING!!
1:33 15y.o rosé singing 🥺🙌 Finally now rosé is already a soloist artist. And she's also record breaker, she break an 8y.o record by PSY, Her solo is now the most viewed mv in its 24hours by kpop soloist. So proud of her! 🙌
하 진짜 추측성 댓글 그만 좀 다세요 로제가 언제 양현석이 창법 바꾸라 해서 바꿨다고 했나요? 로제가 직접 바꿨다고 했어요 그리고 들어보시면 지금 창법이 예전 창법보다 더 확 들어와요 로제도 자기 창법 바꾸고 싶어하던데 왜 자꾸 지금의 로제 창법을 안 좋게 보세요? 지금은 그냥 로제가 하고 싶으면 따라가주는게 맞는거에요
When I heard Rose's voice in her part my tears flowed quickly. I felt so bad for her. Especially her voice. She's Absolutely a good singer. And I think if they hadn't just changed the way she sang. I believe that rose can sing higher than she does now. I Like rosè but i want Chaeyeong back. Everyone wants Chaeyeong back.
here... rosé's voice here sooo freaking good. hope her singing style stay this way..
Vini Sabhina ikr. i just hope she goes back the way she sings before. her voice here was insanely awsome.!!
@@katchie401 ㅐㅟㅣㅐㅣㅐㅏ
Because It's not Rosé
Sabhina Vini yess
@@misssarmy2.089 it's rose but here her voice is different I don't know why here her voice is different but it's her voice....
I'm addicted to rose's high note honestly 😍
same
Same
Sorry to interrupt.. guys can you do me a favor and report this fan page on IG. She keeps on expressing hate *towards* our Rosié. I can message you our recent conversation in IG. page name: *jenlisas_.edits*
I heart Rosié so much that she doesn't deserve any single hate.. and I appreciate all members..
Thank you!
hey delisya VIP
Me too
1:33 > 데뷔 전 창법
3:08 > 데뷔 후 창법
확연히 다르게 들려서 진짜 신기하다... 나중에라도 데뷔 전 창법으로 노래 해줬으면 좋겠다 진실된 울림? 그런게 너무 잘느껴짐
갑자기 이 노래에 빠져서 허우적대고 있음... 어휴... 아이유 내손을 잡아 급으로 돌려 듣는 중... 아무리 들어도 몇년전 노래가 아니라 걍 몇일 전에 낸 신곡같음...지디노래는 유명한 명품처럼 오래둬도 딱히 유행을 안타는 클레식 함이 있어서 좋음...ㅠ
전 갑자기 지금 그래요
@@miyaong-q4j 저도..!
이 노래를 왜 이제야 알았을까..ㅠㅜ
이노래 듣고 ㄹㅇ 감탄함.. 지디 노래 진짜 잘만들어
i wish she would sing like this again.her deep soothing voice gave me goosebumps LITERALLY
채국 she's still use her deep voice in Blackpink songs, but to ad-libs because Jisoo's voice is already low so BP need a high voice
채국 YAS
채국 I love her unique voice now’!
tuyet ngan nguyen what? Her voice was always high pitched it’s just lower here. Blackpink have 3 high pitched voices and one mezzo soprano. They didn’t “need”a high voice. Rosé already had a high voice it just became higher.
채국 VIP
Rose's high note is so freakin' gooooood 😍
eung an ni ya gd ga the moksori jo eum byeongsin ㅋ
와 근데 로제 이 창법도 매력있다
이런게 진짜 좋다니까. 멜로디는 희망적인데 가사는 슬픈 그런곡.
요즘에 이노래에 중독됨ㅋㅋ
4년전 노래가 왤케 좋냐
이 노래가 수록된 앨범 발매일 2012.09.15
10년
이제 11년 됐네요~ 지디 빨리 보고싶다~ 올해는 컴백하기를..
*Fun fact : Rosé was just 15 years old when she sang Without You*
and only a month old trainee
@@sarmar626 That's Rosé's power
Oh my God ...Such a brilliant singer
*that emotion in her voice* I can hear it
Bruh im 15 and still being a pathetic bitch
*Rose's highnote sent me chills*
eung an ni ya gd ga the moksori jo eum byeongsin ㅋ
@@user-yx9ly1ye4b ne da um banggusuck jjindda
이 노래 진짜 띵곡..
로제 창법 안바꾼게 더 탄탄하고 바꾼건 개성 짙음
Everyone talking about rose ... im just like ... G dragon 😍😍😍😍😍😭💜💜💜💜💜
me tooo
Same LoL
Norma Santiago VIP
Bi ;6 5🛍️🎒🎒👍👏👏👐💔❤️💛💚💙💜💟💌
ⁿ¹⅓¹¹#@>8‰6¿⁴6\8 ©®🤘🤘🤘🤘
전 채영이가 이때 태연이 처럼 OST를 몇곡 불렀으면 얼마나 좋았을까 하는 아쉬움이 남아요.명곡으로 남았을텐데... 이젠 되돌릴수도 없고, GD 덕분에 로제 오리지널 목소리나마 듣을수 있어서 그나마 다행....
@스누피스냅핑 로제님이 본인 의지로 바꾼건데 원래 목소리 돌려달라 하면 로제님은 뭐가 되는 거죠?;;;
로제 이거 불렀을 때 15살이라는데 데뷔할 때는 성인이었으니까 5년 사이에 창법이 바뀌었을 수도 있지 뭘 로제 목소리를 돌려달라느니.. 양현석이 강제로 목소리를 바꿨다느니하고 있음...로제가 인어공주냐 목소리 강제로 뺏기게; 3:09 이부분에서는 현재 창법도 보이는디...
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ말하는거 속시원해서 웃기다
박봄 ㅈㄴ 치켜세우려는 거 알겠는데 박봄 음색이 무슨 얼마나 대단한거라고 그렇게 로제한테 이상한 루머 씌우는지 모르겠음
@@밍밍큥 박봄 음색이 존나 지리긴함 블핑 상위호환 느낌인거같은디
@@밍밍큥 전성기 박봄 음색은 얼마나 대단하냐거고 무시할만큼 만만하지 않음;;,
@@밍밍큥 박봄은 갑자기 왜나오는데?.. 너야말로 로제가 더 대단하다는말투야
진짜 이 곡 로제 목소리가 더 편안해 보인다 ㅠㅠ
이 목소리도 좋지만 지금 목소리가 내공 쌓인 목소리라 매력 철철~
근데 와지가 바꾸라 한건 절대 아님 그냥 자연스레 바뀐듯
로제가 원해서 바꾼 거니까..오해는 no...
Guys listen closely here at 3:09 she sounds the same as know at the beginning of the song it was low so rosé had to make her voice a little deeper plus there is a lot of audio tune in the song so no one could recognise her voice cuz she is the mysterious member in bp before she even debuted and also you could hear the audio tune in gd's voice second back then rosé didn't hit puberty yet so ofc it's gonna sound different again 3:09 here she sounds the same as know
I actaully agree on this, Rose was actually used another vocal technique...as in 3:09 indeed for me she sounds pretty similar to how she sings in bp songs, I never find Rose voice is weird, I would say it is unique, for me Rose's part in every bp songs is always great. I always attached to every Rose's line in bp songs... From the very beginning I started to love this girls group, for me Rose is deserved her title as main vocal, from their debut boombayah until their latest songs, Rose part is always been my favourite. But I wouldn't deny, Rose voice is soo beautiful in this song indeed, I just hope her solo music is "different" than what bp is used to be, maybe using this vocal technique again? I don't know, but I'd love it
Truly divine!!!! Her voice then and now are still the same, gd must've lowered her voice for the song. Alot of singers change their vocal range or their voice so that it can fit to the song. But not completely change it.
Rosé is my drugs VIP
maybe she did it on purpose i mean she sang low to not be recognised from another people maybe her actually technique is the technique that she uses now
eung an ni ya gd ga the moksori jo eum byeongsin ㅋ
이노래 처음듣는 귀사고싶다..10년째 듣는중인데 처음들었을때 그 감동을 다시느끼고싶다ㄹㅇ
와 지금 음색도 좋지만 이때 음색 개 지린다....
I love rose's voice here! It gives me goosebumps all the time!
Linkin Genetia PPPpp
eung an ni ya gd ga the moksori jo eum byeongsin ㅋ
로제 창법을 바꿔서 목소리도 바뀐거구나 근데 예나 지금이나 목소리 너무 좋음
블핑으로 부를때랑 그냥 부를때는 다른듯. 로제 너였다면 들어보면 이때랑 똑같음.
@@user-lu9nl3yt7h 근데 로제는 그렇다쳐도 왜 리사는 목소리를 몇개로 변형시켜서 내는거임? 곡마다 적응이안됌 노래마다 목소리달라서 다른사람이 대신부르나 생각하게 만들던데..라이브보면 리사목소리긴 한데 리사도 그냥 음색한개로 가지..YG일을 왜 이런식으로함?
@@요미지킴이맥스 난 로제 지금창법이 좋고 리사도 바뀐 목소리가 더 좋음 ㅠㅠ
3:08 you can hear that the voice isn't changed it's only in a lower tone because the song is in a lower tone then Blackpink songs😅when people understand that she is not faking
Carly TV yeaah they always she change her voice its really funny when im always read that comment
@@Black-gl1lk yes always l say no this not change but them stupid or not hear
this so funny all comment say the voice change l think they not hear very clear the voice same naw but the song is low layer
She's not as faking as people make it but she still does. Look at Bom, they made her have a fake her voice when she was under yg and look now, her voice is damaged. Rosé's voicf is for sure being damaged too. I believe she can have a high pitched voice without forcing on her voice
but her original voice is deep even when she reaches high notes
1:33 로제야 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅜㅠㅜㅜ온니 넘조아
2:08 Wow Rose😍. High note is so good😭😍
Thinking the same.
yall im so in love with rosie and i honestly the most perfect human being no one can tell me otherwise
😂😂😂 yeah girl
❤️❤️
I think Rosé sounds the same as now at 3:09 she probably sounds different in the beginning because it was low?
i have the same thoughts..
Astron 82 I agree its just she sings higher pitch now because of the songs of BP, you know to match it.
@@RAlNARCH Finally, someone who I can agree with. I thought I was the only one who thought that her voice didn't change.
I thought i was the only one who notice it you can really hear her voice at that time
Exactly plus this is edited😂why people make up things like she's destroying her voice and all😂😂if she ever sings in low scale her voice will sound deep again! She's good at singing at low scale like really good and that's why she can change scales while singing. But she didn't master the transition that's why it sounds bad sometimes and people say things like that about her!
Now that GD is out of Military,want him to collab with Rose again😩
울 채영이 목 안 상하게 이렇게 노래해줬으면 좋겠다ㅠㅠ 물론 난 채영이의 모든 모습을 사랑해
Rose had a more control voice here it’s so good
It’s the same voice she has now she’s using more of her higher vocal range now instead of low to match blackpink songs themes and style
eung an ni ya gd ga the moksori jo eum byeongsin ㅋ
또다시남이되나 이쪽 ㅈㄴ소름돋게 목소리좋네 로제ㅠㅠ
her voice doesn’t even sound like her voice now, it’s really beautiful I wish she could show this voice more often.
eung an ni ya gd ga the moksori jo eum byeongsin ㅋ
Gd, songwriter singer and producers this masterpiece 👏🏻🔥
Rose voice is so beautiful.....
I like Rosé high note
I’m shocked that this’s Rosé voice I cannot believe it such a beautiful voice 😍❤️
IKR how can a 14 year old sound like that
eung an ni ya gd ga the moksori jo eum byeongsin ㅋ
요즘 이 노래에 다시 빠졌는데 아니 여기에 있는 권지용 사진 왤케 이쁘지 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 오빠 컴백 언제해 ㅠㅠ
미씽유,블랙과 함께 결국 이노래도 진짜 너무 좋음 지디 목소리는 너무 좋아서 말할것도 없고 같이 부르는 윤아제니로제 목소리도 진짜 미침ㅠㅜ
진짜 나랑 똑같네 세 곡 특유의 매력 ㅇㅈ
Ive listened to this 1000 times and honestly thought it was just GD with autotune lol
This was a slight shock to find its another singer l
Raie-Louise W IM CRYING SHSHDDHH I CANT EVEN GD WITHOUT AUTOTUNE
Raie-Louise W ajsjajahajaa lmao
I don't understand what you mean?
FUNNIEST THING IVE READ TODAY OMFG
both nasal
I don't think it literally change, for me its more like rose's voice is adjusting to the song given to her. Whatever style she use is beautiful. In other words, rose's voice is versatile. Truly a queen 😍😘💗
Why is no one talking about the softness of Gd's voice ? Godd my ears were blessed!!!! I 🎶🎶🎵🎶🎶
IDK why YG would do this to rose her voice in this video is really good than now (i like it but i prefer this voice) YG is just turning rose’s voice nassal and hard to sing just like 2ne1’s Bom’s voice they made it unique idk why YG would want unique voices but rose’s vocal chords are suffering bc of rose’s singing technique i hope she can think of a good technique in singing soon or her voice will be much nassaly(idk if it’s a word) than here voice know but i hope YG will bring Rose’s old voice back
not always yg .. its rose who is having different styles of singng
YG has nothing to do with the artists voices...its their own distinction...what yg responsibility is to develope..enhance and help them overcome the possible difficulties in terms of singing...its not impossible that during this song they used some technical tools to sound it this way....try to see the pre debut vids of rosé because that was her real singing voice and only in this song it sounds like not so much her voice...and i dont think why u find it hard for her to sing on that voice because as what all people reactions and not to mentions those highly recognized musicians during her guestings on king of mask singer and fantastic duo was all amazed and mesmerized on her voice and praises her for having a high quality tone...and its obvious that shes comfortable with her voice...much love and godbless
i heard from someone that expert vocalist i think, she said rose did not suffering her vocal chords, according to her. maybe she comfortable that way for now. she became used to become trendy.
She was 14 dis time...
Yes I agree with you and you are so right...
I just live the way how rose sings a low pitch note in this song other than the extra auto tuning yg does this is actually how the singing should really fit in her in Blackpink but now the way she sings in Blackpink its more like a 12 yr old good vocal voice. Anyway she is still the main vocalist in Blackpink and her voice is just good...
전에도 평범한음색은 아닌데
너무 마음아프다 어쩌다 로제창법 바뀐거라는 댓글 봐서 전 창법은 어땠을까 찾아보던 중에 보는 영상인데 지금도 분명 잘부르는게 이게 훨씬더 듣기에도 편하고 로제라는 사람의 색이 확 표현되고 흔하지 않는 목소리 같음.. 지금 창법이 더 목에 무리가고 색을 잃은거 같아요 ㅠ 다른영상 찾아보니까 바뀐 창법때문에 예전 창법은 아예 잊은거 같던데 ㅜㅜㅜㅠ
로제가 스스로 창법 바꾼거구요 지금도 예전 창법 종종 나옵니다
@@우하하-o9n yg 양현석이 바꾼거라던데
@@인간-r4q 그런 말이 어디서 나오냐구요 로제는 스스로 바꿧다고 얘기했어요 본인도 잘 모르면서 추측성 댓글 그만 좀 작성해 주세요.
@@dongwonfish123 네 그거 데뷔초부터 많이 나오던 루머구요. 양씨 없었으면 블핑도 없었습니다 물론 양씨가 잘못을 많이하긴 했지만 블핑을 만든건 사실이니까요
어떤 외부 압력이 있었다 해도 지금 창법으로 바꾼건 어찌보면 로제가 선택한 일이고 독특한 음색이 데뷔하는데 메리트가 아예 없었을 거라곤 말할 수 없죠 시장성과 그룹의 색깔을 고려하면 흔한 목소리보단 지금 로제처럼 유니크한 음색의 가수가 더 데뷔 가능성이 높아지니까요
Rosé's voice + GDRAGON's voice = A DRAMATIC NIGHT.
로제 예전 창법이 더 좋다는 사람들도 있는데 난 오히려 지금 창법이 더 특별(?)해서 좋은고가틈
어/절수 없음 지수 목소리 낮은 성량때문에 노래 잘부르는 로제가 그냥 맞춰준거임
@@asdccfasdad3029 개소리쩌네
권지용 목소리 넘 좋아😊
진짜 노래 너무 좋다
Rosé ❤
Bellaa Sim yes me too
ROSE'S VOICE IS SO AMAZING!! I LIKE HOW HARD AND DEEP HER VOICE HERE! I LOVE IT MORE THAN HER VOICE!!!! BEAUTIFUL SONG GD AND ROSE!! WHOOO!!! 😆😆😍😍😍😭😭💞💞💞
eung an ni ya gd ga the moksori jo eum byeongsin ㅋ
Rosé voice 💕💕❤❤❤😍😍😍
I miss rose's old voice
It’s not her old voice she can still use this voice but she now uses a different technique and she uses a pitch higher up in her vocal range to match blackpinks songs sounds.
3:09 she still having the same voice lmao
진짜 띵곡이야...
I feel so happy for Rosé and I'm literally crying tears of joy for her to see how far she got through, becoming one of the most popular K-pop artists in the market now. Rosé hwaiting! BLACKPINK HWAITING!!
I fell in love w this song when I first hear it at One Of A Kind concert. GD was just standing there singing but it's so mesmerizing
what's good about Rose is that she can go back and forth to her original and unique voice techniques. Some people just dont see it.
Rose's voice omg so perfect ❤️
Rosie and G-dragon are always amazing 😍😍
"it's so hard to go around each other so I gave parting to you as a gift and turned my back, I'm falling without you...
I really like when she say "heah!" in 2:10 so much.
빅뱅노래 정주행중 찾은 또다른 명곡….
Im the comment here about g dragon that youre looking for. Everyone is talking about rose but im here for my g dragon 👑
I'm in love with rose's old voice, I can't help it😆😆
Bro I was shooked when Rosè sing her voice really changed 😭😭
I am in tears!!
Rose Beautiful Voice in her Teen!!
but Past is Past!!
Love Her Voice No matter what!!!
Past or even Now
I’m still having goosebumps at rosé part,
It’s feels good to be back here ,,,, the old days.
2:01 로제 목소리...짱이다
채연의 목소리인지 의심스러울 목소리
매우 깨끗하다😍
YG really change rose voice alot 😢
I wish yg would let Rosé sing in this voice... not only is it her actual voice, it would make all their ( Blackpink) songs sound amazing!
모든파트 로제 목소리와, 마지막 한문장 '시간이 지나면..' 로제목소리가 달라서, 다른 가수인줄 알았는데..
한 사람 목소리라니.. rose♡
1:33 15y.o rosé singing 🥺🙌
Finally now rosé is already a soloist artist. And she's also record breaker, she break an 8y.o record by PSY, Her solo is now the most viewed mv in its 24hours by kpop soloist. So proud of her! 🙌
i love this with the powerful voice of gd and rose like them
That's why I admire her so much. Her voice is just so beautiful
How could someone's voice can be so perfect like my baby. I'm addicted.
와 이거 진짜 8년전에 이 노래만 계속 듣고 피쳐링한 여자 누군가 계속 쳐봤는데 자꾸 아이돌 연습생이라고만 나와서 궁금했는데 블랙핑크 로제 였구나 개 소름돋네
이 음색으로 로제 발라드나 이런장르 내줬으면..
이 노래 친오빠가 꽤 틀어서 많이 들었는데 로제였구나...창법이 너무 달라서 몰랐네 지금 창법이 더 좋지만 이때 창법도 좋다💖
❤Rose❤.........💙g-Dragon💙.........💚I LOVE YOU💚..😍😘
تايهيونغ تايهيونغ عرب☺☺
Who miss this rose old voice
I miss so much 😭😭💜💜💜
2019
사랑해 지드래곤 이 케미 너무 좋다고 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
damn her voice is *everything* in this song. like her high note, damnnn chaeyoung
원래 로제가 이랬구나...
okay gdragon is on another level as an artist
2:00 until 2:10 . never heard something better than this.
Rosés high note has me SHOOKETH
Rosé's voice is Gold 💖
이 노래에 나오는 로제 음색이 지금보다 훨 나음 지금은 왠지 목소리가 흔들림 옛날로제 목소리는 진짜 한국 스타일임
I didn't even recognised her voice first !!!!!!
I couldn't believe that rose was singing it
Why is it so beautiful ?!?!?!?!?!?!?!
Chaeyoung unnie high notes always get me 🥺😭🥰 I can replaying it over and over again.....
Idk why im so addicted to this 2:01
me too.. i love at this part
Wow.G dragon voice soamazing.😘
ROSE voice here so lovely. im crying.....
노래 개좋은데 시바 .. ꖶዞ 이걸 이제 알았지 나란년 바보다 진짜 너무 좋다 우연히 들었는데 너무 좋아서 찾ටㅏ 봤는데 미쳤다 지디 /로제 라니 너무 좋다
하 진짜 추측성 댓글 그만 좀 다세요 로제가 언제 양현석이 창법 바꾸라 해서 바꿨다고 했나요? 로제가 직접 바꿨다고 했어요 그리고 들어보시면 지금 창법이 예전 창법보다 더 확 들어와요 로제도 자기 창법 바꾸고 싶어하던데 왜 자꾸 지금의 로제 창법을 안 좋게 보세요? 지금은 그냥 로제가 하고 싶으면 따라가주는게 맞는거에요
진짜 인정 한국인들 종특임
그러는 애들 걍 팬코임 ㅋㅋㅋ 목에 안 좋다고 창법 바꾸라는데 그게 더 목 상하게 할 수 있음
its just her deep voice/ lower register guys, rosé’s voice didn’t change.
When I heard Rose's voice in her part my tears flowed quickly. I felt so bad for her. Especially her voice. She's Absolutely a good singer. And I think if they hadn't just changed the way she sang. I believe that rose can sing higher than she does now. I Like rosè but i want Chaeyeong back. Everyone wants Chaeyeong back.
They didn’t she uses a higher pitch which is in her vocal range to match the style and theme of BlackPinks songs
I love how before rose voice was more soft and less nasually. It sounds more like her natural voice.
Rosé's voice is so different!! I mean in a good way, ofcourse