ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 มี.ค. 2023
- Prolific anti-war activist Noam Chomsky delivers his verdict on the “most elementary truth” American leaders still refuse to acknowledge about the Iraq War 20 years later: “It was the supreme international crime of aggression.” Watch his wide ranging discussion with Mehdi on the lessons the U.S. has still failed to learn from the 2003 Iraq War.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: on.msnbc.com/SubscribeTomsnbc
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/maddowblog
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/reidoutblog
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: on.msnbc.com/Readmsnbc
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: MSNBC.com/NewslettersTH-cam
Find MSNBC on Facebook: on.msnbc.com/Likemsnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: on.msnbc.com/Followmsnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: on.msnbc.com/Instamsnbc
#msnbc #noamchomsky #iraq
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA GF D1 | Summer | แข่งที่ไทย ต้องใส่ให้สุด](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Jkuf7nCS7jI/mqdefault.jpg)
![เปิดบ้าน เปิด Supercar อั๋นโอกิ เคยเอา rolls Royce เเลกพระ องค์ละ 100 ล้าน l [Nickynachat]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/FeGwJwXauZ0/mqdefault.jpg)
Wow Noam Chomsky on the mainstream corporate media. Thanks Mehdi!
I too am shocked lol, this would have been impossible even ten years ago
Second appearance I believe
@@kidmaciek2 Totally false. You're probably just a denier of the Indoneasian genocide of east timor which the US supported.
But TH-cam is all about censorship. Noticed all the extra ads lately?
You better not DARE say anything about them. The google is so EVIL these days.
Wow Chomsky the eternal democrat gets invited to a democratic platform WOAAAAH
"The Military Industrial Complex acts as a transfer mechanism, it transfers Public Funds to the Private Sector" - Noam Chomsky
And come back from where it started.
@Int’l Voice of Reason: Such a brilliant and truthful quote.
This man is a living hero.
Dude made his money leeching of these wars his Jewish people promoted
Gets to look like a hero making shekels and looking like a good Jew
What a time to be alive
Bush has to pay
@ناصر such as?
Putin Bush and Biden are all the same
I cherish Noam Chomsky, and every moment he's shared with us all.
You cherish the guy who hides behind leftist rhetoric to deny genocides? Wow....
Nothing has been learned 20 years later.
Not a thing.
We did Iraq 30-40 years after Vietnam so we have a few years before we make a mess somewhere else.
Well, at least with Iraq again on the news, more people will finally learn the proper pronounciation of the name of this country ;) (no, it's not "eye-rak")
@@robertchmielecki2580 I Ran home and I Rack the balls.
I do not condone the Iraq invasion but just now I find Putin Trump, and Brexit, more of an issue I find Trump a greater menace to the USA than Stalin ever was, and I am no Stalinist but the massive ignorance of the Republican Party and Fox are really more of a menace than Communism.
As an Iraqi who majors in linguistics, I truly thank you for your words.
السلام عليكم.
شنو قصد چومسكي ب USS Fallujah ؟
انكليزيتي ضعيفة.
شكرا.
@@gr3ndizer97 وعليكم السلام ورحمة الله، بيكول البحرية الاميريكية عملت سفينة حربية جديدة وسمتها يوسس فلوجة على اسم مدينة الفلوجة العراقية، فبيكول كيف يسموها مثل هذا الاسم اللي يخلد ذكرى مدمرة لأهل العراق
Im shocked you actually had such an anti imperalist voice on a pro imperialism corporate network. This would have been impossible even ten years ago, but you need to keep it up much longer.
Well said and well REASONED.
Only thing you that can be said is that the topics they discuss even the title of what he is know for is different
Dude, stop. It's not pro-imperialist and Chomsky isn't anti-imperialist unless it's about the USA. With Russian imperialism, he's perfectly fine with that.
@@Joelmonterrey Chomsky is at best adjacent to Glenn Greenwald but no more than that, which is one of Noams *only* failures as a media critic and public intellectual. And to be frank, he's factually correct about America and its genocidal imperialism and the disinformation used to support that imperialism which has been platformed by the MSM since before we were born and continues to this day. I know this because I'm a media criticism-focused academic journalist and I started down this road because I was raised on Rush Limbaugh. If your only argument against Chomsky is Russia Bad you're fundamentally arguing that our imperialsm isn't as bad and thats...that's not the vibe my man. Read the room, few folks under 35 that are on the left are into your whole "we say we're liberal but really we're neoliberal democrats who uphold the status quo and ensure progressive values are tantamount to communism" mccarthyism nonsense anymore, that way of life is dying the death it deserves before our eyes. Just think! If the ICC finally has any guts they will use the Afghanistan Papers as evidence to haul Obama and Biden in for the many war crimes they committed...and if your answer to those factual realities is that I'm a far left extremist, I hate to break it to you my friend but on a global political spectrum you're a conservative, and an imperialist warmonger. Some of us realized we have blood on our hands and are willing to actually dedicate ourselves to dismantling white supremacy, the rest of yall are the white moderate that MLK wrote about in Letter From Birmingham Jail. Have a nice life tho.
It's an exception that proves the rule, in this case the propaganda model.
Thank you for having Mr. Chomsky on your program! He's educated me so much! I read 'How the World Works', and I was never the same. 🕊️💕
The biggest industry on earth is War. War creates money, so the defence industry is working overtime.
Thank you. You rarely see Chomsky on US media at all these days. It's good to hear his voice once again on US media.
Thank you, Mehdi, for allowing Chomsky full time to answer your questions. He’s a truth teller !!!
As an American expat who left in 2006, primarily due to the atrocious and illegal actions being carried out in my name at the time- THANK YOU MEHDI, THANK YOU NOAM!!
You left in 2006. Thank you. Please do not come back.
@@adk46er5203 Why would he want to come back???
@@adk46er5203 and it's 2023 now. What makes you think the person is coming back?. People like you and Bush and Blair should be tried for crimes against humanity
Why Americans called themselves "Expats" but refer to other as "immigrants"??? I'm just curious...WHY? 🤨🤔
@@MidnightSunshine27 all yanks are immigrants.
Even NPR is scared of Noam so it's shocking to see him get coverage on MSNBC.
NPR is scared of Noam because Noam isn’t afraid to tell the truth about Israel
Shocking? Not on Medhi's show I'm not shocked
NPR is center-left so it's not really so shocking...
Their official ban started with Jeff Greenfield, before he moved on to corporate media. You can look up Noam discussing this to learn more if interested.....
@@intlvoiceofreason9239 NPR started banning Chomsky under Jeff Greenfield.
Dr Noam chomsky ,we ❤️ you for speaking in favor of truth .
Absolutely CORRECT and true.
*What I like about Mehdi the most is that he listens to people and gives them their fair chance to speak, rather than coming with questions and forcing people to get the answers he wants to.*
Cheers from Somalia.
20 Years after Iraq… Msnbc finally let’s him on TV
If Mehdi didn’t invite him, he would have never made it on the show
@@stevebergman4587 Yea Mehdi is the best thing on MSNBC, but that’s not saying much.
@@notbadnotbad True. Only thing I didn’t like about Mehdi is how he played the entire Trump Russia commentary .
Bush even said Iraq when speaking about Ukraine.😂
Because he lives with guilty!
Freudian slip
Chomsky was right then and he is still right now
Chomsky was not, ' right ', about anything, then or now:
Chomsky NEVER produced proof that the US Government of, ' Lying ', about the Iraq Intel until AFTER the War started!
And Chomsky NEVER explained how Saddam could be compelled to allow proper inspections WITHOUT the threat of Military Force!
SMH
Noam Chomsky: Producer of formal language theory books that were the standard in the early days of my computer science degree.
But TH-cam is all about censorship. Noticed all the extra ads lately?
You better not DARE say anything about them. The google is so EVIL these days.
Then Chomsky should limit his comments to those fields that he actually knows what he is talking about: Linguistics-And its relationship to Computer Science.
But he has ZERO Credibility to talk about anything else-Especially Foreign Policy!
Boo
@@khdmhd2947
Don't Shoot the Messenger if you can't face the reality of the message.
Hater?
It really is a step forward that MSNBC are willing to give a platform to a voice like this. Whether you agree or disagree with him (I agree largely with him by the way), these are important voices and they should be heard. Not silenced by ignoring.
A waste of money and millions of Iraqi lives, all so we could test new weapons and strategies, along with making billions for defense contractors. Nothing more
Frank, That sounds about right,,,.
oil contracts
Thank you for giving Noam a platform
Ty very much for platforming Noam Chomsky. Pls have more Progressives on. I would watch more
One of the great, honest thinkers of our time. A privilege to see him here.
Yes sir, it was and stands as a crime of aggression.
Aggression against who? I dare you to answer, Eduardo.
The Australian minister of Defense in 2007, Brendan Nelson MP said that the real reason for the invasion was the Iraqi oil, sure ... the man was sacked later that year.
Keep shining light on the truth!
Right on
Many times I disagree with Mehdi Hasan, but he is undoubtedly a hero for bringing Noam Chomsky to his show. Most News shows don't invite Nome Chomsky because he needs time to explain his views which are often different from others.
@@FC-vp9ej huh?
"The goal is to use Afghanistan to wash money out of the tax bases of the US and Europe through Afghanistan and back into the hands of a transnational security elite. The goal is an endless war, not a successful war." - Julian Assange (2011)
Not many will understand it though
"The Military Industrial Complex acts as a transfer mechanism, it transfers Public Funds to the Private Sector" - Noam Chomsky
"The war is waged by each ruling group against its own subjects, and the object of the war is not to make or prevent conquests of territory, but to keep the structure of society intact."
- Emmanuel Goldstein, "The Theory and Practice of Oligarchical Collectivism," from George Orwell's "Nineteen Eighty-Four"
And less than year after the Afghan retreat, the Ukraine war begins, with the same goal.
The only way to maintain their order is by creating chaos in others destruction.
George Jr's war for his daddy, based on a lie.
This is a gem of an exchange.
Let us not forget this Freudian slip;
“It was the decision of one man to launch a wholly unjustified and brutal invasion of Iraq,” former president George W. Bush said before quickly correcting himself, saying he meant to describe Russian President Vladimir Putin’s war on Ukraine. He then openly admitted with his iconic chuckle, “Iraq, too, anyway,”
Thank you for interviewing Noam Chomsky, and decades of thanks to Noam Chomsky for offering informed and reasonable responses to a world that lacks both.
I love Mehdi .America is so lucky to have him constantly speaking truth to power.Thankyou.
Who'd'a thunk a USA mainstream news outlet would air a truthful, fact-based, interview! Now I can have hope!
Lets not go too far... this wasn't THE MEDIA... it was one show... so credit should go to Mehdi Hasan not the media
It's Mehdi Hasan not the complete media
Hasan can be fired for this.
I wasn't aware of what happened in Fallujah until now when I heard Noam Chomsky mention it and did some research about it.
I found a documentary named: Fallujah, The Hidden Massacre
I thought I have seen a lot of terrible things... but seeing this and knowing this is real and not scenes from a horror film... can't find any word bad enough to describe this crime. How could human beings do something like that!?
The least the US could do is apologize for it... but instead they simply ignore it!
I saw it years ago.. Was honestly NOT surprised about Americas hypocrisy.
I recently saw there were video games being made specifically about Fallujah and glorifying american soldiers evil. its disgusting
@@aliceinwonder8978 yes, it's disgusting. That's the Military-entertainment complex. There is an article about it on Wikipedia.
Credit to Medhi for having the great Noam Chomsky on. Not many mainstream media outlets will have him on, both the left and right. Great stuff.
4:35 "The rest thought what the rest of the world thinks..." Mehdi, you didn't seem interested in the end of that sentence (not unlike the general attitude of the rest of the country). The motivation behind the invasion seems like kind of an important point to not notice. Thank you, Mr. Chomsky, for shining a light on the long-term, horrific American hypocrisy, and the completely unnecessary suffering it has caused. I'm surprised you were "allowed" to.
The United States has spent a few trillions fighting in Iraq and Afghanistan. Just imagine if that money could've been poured into handling domestic problems...
So many of us value you tremendously
We have to be grateful for Chomsky. Thank you Noam!
Noam Shitheadsky
The Vietnam War and the Iraq War are the two major wars in American history that were unjustified.
There’s more than two
Korean War? and let's not even begin to talk about all the proxy wars the U.S. has funded
Invasion of Afghanistan n many other nations justified? Brutally killing of MILLIONS of innocent civilians justified?
And add Afghanistan and Libya too.
Yes, the extermination of native tribes was perfectly justified. As was the genocidal invasion of the Philippines. As was our involvement in the Balkans. Etc. Etc.
Imagine if Noam was a frequent guest on the Sunday talk shows instead of the military types. Thank you, Mehdi, for giving him a voice. 👆 ♥
Give the man a break. He's 94 yrs old. He should be cuddling up with a cat and taking catnaps in the sunlight.
I'll do you one better:
Imagine IF academic egghead Chomsky ever did more with his life than merely complain from the sidelines about fields that he has never had the guts to actually work in himself-Which is everything outside Linguistics-Like the worthless armchair critic that he is! :-D
If Mehdi Hassan isn't thrown out of MSNBC, it would be a real miracle.
I am so grateful to Noam. I’ve been following him for some years and he’s truly a legendary thinker. I wish I could meet or at least extent my gratitude to him.
Noam....you have been RIGHT.....ON EVERY LEVEL...BLESSINGS
cant believe I’m seeing this on mainstream media
THANK YOU Noam Chomsky for YOUR LEGACY of knowledge and better understanding of our language guiding Society for good or bad.
You and Bernie got it right, it was for oil.
NOAM SAID 👈😳
"strageitiblunderbummer"..
NOAM SAID 👈😳
"truminplazriondeadcatsnblunder"...
Some unintelligent people will not understand what Noam Chomsky said... because they lack brain power to decipher the meaning of his words.
NOAM SAID 👈😳
"Nazihanginoblunderbummer"...
And Ukraine is for laundering our taxes right into the pockets of corrupt politicians and the war machine.
When are they going to arrest all those war criminals.
I am always dismayed by how American parents tollerate the loss of their children in senseless wars..If it was my son or grandson, I would have a lifetime goal of getting revenge! The war mongers would not live.
His still alive cause his a man with integrity
What a argumentative voice: the great Noam Chomosky. Very much thanks Mehdi for recaping & unveling the truth of US atrocities.
This man is still young ❤
Such an amazing, sharp intellect. Professor Chomsky, may the Almighty God keep you in excellent health.
I love norm Chomsky. He is a man of integrity and probity.
sounds so reasonable. why kept off media?
because he names names, and corporate media hates that.
Mehdi, I don't comment on TH-cam videos at all but I just have to say THANK YOU for bringing Noam Chomsky on mainstream media. This is moving in itself since these type of independent thinkers aren't highlighted at all.
Noam Chomsky was right all the time
Truth and wisdom from age
I just heard that this was the first time that Noam Chomsky was invited on MSNBC.
I also heard that Mehdi Hasan now has his own news platform.
I hope msnbc doesn’t fire you for this interview.
Professor Chomsky is a MIT linguistic. He designed and develop theories for Context Free Grammar. CFG used for computer programming language design and compiler parser design. It is an important building block of all modern programming language.
Noam and Mehdi are the conscience of humanity. Bravo! Thanks!
Sad to see him get older. I have become fond of him in last year and have already read two of his books.
*CHOMSKY ON MSNBC??*
Who put mushrooms in my water?
When enough of us want The World to be better it is, slowly but surely.
Optimistic but a good thought nonetheless
The premise was to ensure Iraq not invade Kuwait the first time, and push them back to Baghdad the second time - George Jr. finished off what his George Sr. started. Saddam was a brutal dictator, who also happened to furnish his nation with good roads, education, advanced health care and rights for women and minorities. What's left? Maybe a burgeoning democracy 20 yrs on? May be.
NOAM Responded 👈😳
"Saddamngreatfriendumukraineum"...
Saddam was a brutal dictator that the U.S. train supported and funded for many a year. You can almost say the U.S made Saddam
Words of bitter truth. Thank you, Noam.
I did not know about them calling a war vessel the USS Fallujah. Absolutely unforgivable
A true American hero!
NOAM SAID 👈😳
"strageitiblunderbummer"..
NOAM Responded 👈😳
"Saddamngreatfriendumukraineum"...
LOL... a true “anti American”... American hero... (I can hear the South Park 🎼intro theme as I read your comment).
Yea he got Iraq right, but he did want to lock up the unvaccinated so 🤷🏻♂️
@@debbie5728 of course you can....that shows your level of thinking ability...sad. 🤡
Why didn’t MSNBS have Chomsky on immediately before the invasion of Iraq?
It doesn’t mean anything for the American establishment to realise that Iraq was a bad move, because they don’t actually learn their lessons when it comes to the next issue. That’s not learning your lesson, that’s being sheepish because you didn’t get what you wanted.
I knew they had no weapons of mass destruction and I was hanging banners with peace slogans along Highway 1
Iraqi General Sada wrote a book detailing how Iraq's WMD were moved to Syria. Look up his name he's very convincing. The weapons were later used by Syria.
@@vitocorleone8323what were these so called weapons of mass destruction, 99% of sources say there were none.
@@vitocorleone8323Iraq and Syria were not friends. Still you cannot invade a country for that. Any country has a right to have strong military. You don’t talk about zionist Israel.
Charges should have came after this war… wmds????
Very good news coverage. Aggravating outro music gets on my nerves, tho
That's the price I pay I suppose
God Bless Noam
One of my heroes. We ignore him at our peril!!!
This guy is absolute gold! thank you gentlemen!
NOAM Responded 👈😳
"Saddamngreatfriendumukraineum"...
If you're a far leftist
@@marklasky3555 if you like your truth unfiltered
Great to see Noam on the show. Clear and correct analysis as always.
Noam is the Voltaire of our generation... enjoy him while he is here... a sage's voice will go unheard...
Chomsky has dedicated his life earnestly mining for the truth and showing it to the public
Thanks Mehdi
How about having on Chris Hedges, next?
My dear professor, I miss you! ❤
How are you???
So WONDERFUL to see this guy looking so old. Soon he'll be gone and forgotten
Surreal, Chomsky on MSNBC, finally a change?
It sounds like this two people don’t like the us.
Nobody with an ounce of morality will like international drone attacking terrorist
Another country destroyed 😮
Who controls Iraq's oil? Nobody talks about that.
Having Mehdi Hassan on a mainstream network might actually break the mold in what kind of political discourse is allowed.
“When you win a war you celebrate by mourning” Lao Tse
Excellent *
Love Chomsky ❤
Appreciate you giving Mr Chomsky some mainstream air time very much. Thank you.
Chomsky somehow looks younger than he did a couple years ago
Should’ve asked him about Ukraine too
He is a living legend!
Wow, can't believe MSNBC allowed Chomsky on
surprised they gave Noam a little airtime on the Mainstream Media.
I remember MSNBC firing Phil for opposing the Iraq War.
94 years young is a way to be polite with age towards someone