I have light skin and generally prefer neutral/cooler undertones, but the High Temp palette is STUNNING. I actually don't think it's that warm, it's more of a dusky jewel tone palette. The amazing thing is that ALL the shades work well together. It's weird but they do, you don't need to even think when using it. I have had people literally stop me on the street when I wear it and all the shades just blend beautifully. I got it because I loved the color story and thought it might just work if I got a tan in the summer, but it has become my year round palette and go to when I just want to feel... royal.
GREAT video! I know it would be a ton of work, but it would be fun if you could put up a look you did with each palette from old footage! I love seeing your looks!
Unfortunately I did not have time to do that this time with so many palettes! I usually include it in my monthly rankings because there’s 10 and under palettes. I hope one day TH-cam can be my main gig so I can devote even more time to it but it’s just a side thing for me at this time!
Unearthly’s journey has been one of my favorites, I don’t have every single one but I have most of their palettes and I could never pick a single palette as a favorite lol the original Fall Magic haunts me to this day, I remember when it was still available.. I missed it and when it sold out it never restocked. I love the packaging too SO much! Fairy Frolic was my first palette from them. I’ll buy* literally anything they release like 💁🏻♀️💳
I didn’t watch Gargoyles but every time I hear about it I become more sure that if I had it would absolutely have become a key part of my personality / interests 🤣 I’ve been struggling with all kinds of motivation over the last week due to The Current Events, even for fun stuff like makeup - so thank you for getting me excited again
I have several, and if I had to choose, I think I'd choose Gargoyle and Dreamer as being tied for my favorites! But, yeah, I do agree about that original Fall Magic palette. It's a stunner! I wish I had that one in my collection!
100000% agree about putting looks together with multichromes! I've asked so many creators to help with that, and the majority just told me to put ur metallics down first..that's soo counterintuitive to me! I honestly end up avoiding most multichromes..😢
I had one Alien palette several years back and was unimpressed so I didn’t dive into unearthly until this year and more accurately until last month. I finally tried my Sorcerers Smoke which has been sitting around for months untouched. To say I’m in love would be an understatement!!! I now can’t wait to play with the other palettes I own. Fall Magic, Leather and Lace and Lore. I have a feeling if Leather and Lace had lighter shades like you mentioned, it might have turned into a fave. But I think I’m even more pale then you so it might be a struggle with all the mattes as deep as they are. But I will make it work. Sorcerers Smoke is mostly deep too and I have been enjoying it so much!!!
I was a phlebotomist you can take your bandage off after 10 mins. It's mainly covered since it's an open puncture to keep air bacteria off while it seals closed but it stops bleeding within seconds after pressure otherwise your arm be covered in blood and you would know there's a problem just a tip cause I know uncomfortable it is to bend your arm with that thing on.❤😊 as long as u arent downing a bunch of alcohol and asprin and running a marathon youll be okay 😂
I absolutely love Unearthly cosmetics. Leather and lace was my first palette from them and i still love it to this day. Other i love are Lore, fairly frolic, sorceress smoke, dreamer, Devour, spring magic, night terror. My order with Not normal remastered and Gargoyle has just shipped today so I'm excited to get my hands on them 😊
I kinda want their all shimmer palette the 'all i ever wanted'? It is a rerelease as far as i know and the shimmers ...oh. my. god the SHIMMERS are beautiful on the swatch video ❤❤❤so i kinda on the fence with this one. Also spring magic looks very beautiful❤ I already have pastel palettes but i am still interested in it
Great video Rachel - I would have no idea how to rank my Unearthly palettes but I can say there would be a tie for first place between Frolic, Learher and Lace, Sleepover, The Grind, Spring Magic, Gargoyle and High Temp. However, being an obviously indecisive person I can say with 100% certainty that Unearthly Cosmetics is my #1 FAVORITE Indy Brand! I love watching Hayden's Haunts and I think Amanda Hayden is one of the coolest people on the planet. 💜💚🩵
i don’t have any unearthly palettes yet but i ordered sorcerous smoke and fall magic during the halloween sale! still waiting on those since sorcerous smoke was on preorder but i cannot wait to try them
Unearthly is my favorite indie brand since their most recent formula upgrade (the old one creased on me). My fav is Sorcerous Smoke followed by Dreamer and Resurgence. I think the new Not Normal is the only newer formula palette I don't have. I also love their Satin Liquid Lipsticks. 🤩💗
I have the Sleepover palette. It's really cute. I think it's a pretty nice palette for people that like pink and w the size it's so easy to use them as blushes and there's blushes for different skin tones too. I actually used the shimmers as highlighter too and thought it worked really well. They looked good as highlighter 😊the Charmer palette is stunning. So many pretty shades
My fav is So Strange, Sorcerous Smoke, and Not Normal.... the older version. I don't have the new one but will get it sometime. Holiday shopping has got me tapped out right now!
Omg, GARGOYLES!! 😂 I haven't thought about that show since the 90's! My younger brother and I used to LOVE watching that show. We'd watch it together all the time. Aww...! I really didn't think I'd get such a big nostalgia hit from an Unearthly ranking video right at the start of my day 😂 I'm pretty sure I'm a handful of yrs older than you, Rachel, so I was already in high school when it was running, and I remember believing that I had to keep the fact that I liked/watched the show be this BIG secret bc I didn't want people to make fun of me. Gargoyles and anime (which I've watched since the 80's), so happy that public perception has changed in that area. Of course, now I'm too old to care what other people think about it, but back then? I'm pretty sure I threatened my brother with swift retaliation once or twice when he tried to joke about telling people 😂😂 Anyway, memories aside, great video! I have yet to make my first purchase from Unearthly, but I promised myself that I would get the Sorcerous Smoke palette this Black Friday. Oh and one last thing..! I just checked, and the Leather and Lace palette is still both on their site, AND it's actually in stock for $36! (Just thought some of your viewers would want to know!) I had to double check bc I was pretty sure I had seen it on there last week when I was deciding which one I wanted to get. Gargoyles and Spring Magic are another 2 kinda on the list, but I'm not sure bc they both have more than 1 shade I wouldn't use. While it looks like I could use all of Sorcerous Smoke and Leather and Lace. Hope everyone has a fantastic weekend!
I picked up the new not normal during the first pre-order. They were supposed to ship Halloween then pushed it back to Nov 6th and( after hearing nothing till I reached out) I emailed them again when Nov 6th came and went and never heard back..I just got my shipping confirmation this morning tho..never had this happen before especially with unearthly very frustrating. I'm just done with fronting companies my money 😂
The whole rating, I was thinking, I wonder if she has the original Fall Magic?! 😂 Great ranking! Blues are not my 1st choice (or 2nd or 3rd lol!) but something about Gargoyle, I just LOVE the blues in it. Same with Spring Magic. So those would be my #1 and 2. And then original Fall Magic and the new Fall Magic would be 3 and 4. Then the rest would be similar. I really love the newer formula.
Thank you so much for mentioning which old ones are the newer formula I just had them in my cart and pulled back specifically because I thought they were the old formula specifically the daily grind lore and leather and lace so you are saying lore and leather n lace are the new formula do you know about the daily grind? Would be super helpful cause I want devour also more money for Amanda if you let me know...😊 I guess I can ask on Hayden haunts she usually always replies which is awesome I love that..❤🥰
@rachelapalmieri THANK YOU SO SO MUCH Rachel, that is so so helpful!! I loved seeing fairy frolic ranked so high because I love it too!! In fact it was my throwback Thursday winner just yesterday and I created the best look yet with it to date. I love mystical moss and frolic shade. I also like how unearthly gives us bigger pans than most other brands, I don't hear people mention that much, but it's a huge selling point for me that their prices are on the lower end, bigger pans, and in my eyes the most unique matte tones on the market..and magnetic for my byop, I byop if I want before I can afford. I don't get pr so I buy everything on my channel I showcase. I'm a nano, nano channel..😂🫶🖤
I enjoyed the video because I just love unearthly especially some of the older palettes. I have a good amount but wish for the old fall magic and the leather and lace. But my favorite is not normal and the low lights highlighter palette.
Unfortunately I don't have the same appreciation for some of the cover art. The ones that have hypersexualized covers have actually been a deterrent from purchasing. And YES--their shimmers of late are completely gasp-worthy! ❤❤❤❤ (And how has there not been a live-action Gargoyles movie yet??!! LOVED that show!!!)
My only Unearthly palette is the Resurgence by Heather Austin and it has been my GO TO for bright pops of color since I got it! The formula is top tier for sure!
I picked up the new not normal on launch day, just haven’t received it yet! Super excited though because I agree- I love the mattes in the original but never reach for it because of the shimmers
I have decluttered all but 3 of my Unearthly palettes, so my top 3 are Lore, Leather and Lace, and Sleepover. I haven't bought from them since their palette prices have almost doubled and their shipping costs are ridiculous.
I prefer the old shimmer formula from Unearthly. I don't know if I'm alone in this (maybe so!), but I don't like sparkly high-shine shimmers. I like more a more subtle finish. I know a lot of brands have moved to high shimmer/shine. It makes sense and they are very pretty and super high impact, but I don't find them as wearable for day-to-day use.
I never owned the Not Normal but I just ordered the Remastered and I’m so excited to try it! I’ve been eyeing this color story for ages! I think both of the Fall Magic palettes are at the top of my list as well. I love them both so much! 💖
😢💔 I'm so sad right now, and I didn't hear anything either. The Dreamer palette is already discontinued and gone. Does anyone know why and when this happened? That was my top choice to purchase as a gift to myself for Christmas.
I have three or four palettes. I like their formulas, but to me all of them are required to have a companion palette. I just don't wear the full crazy all day at work, I need neutrals. I have old Not Normal, Dreamer, Sleepover reboot (sold the original, but missed it. I miss the large size, but feel less guilty with a small one), and I have Smells Like Holiday Spirit. so I am set, but did get the Spring Magic on their Halloween sale, which was a score, as the palette is really gorgeous. I didn't get Leather and Lace as I really hate the background on the palette and have far too many red/pink palettes, or red and pink in palettes, so it's not attractive to me.
The color stories I'm drawn to (Sorcerer's Smoke and Not Normal) I already have in my collection. I would have probably grabbed Not Normal, but I don't like the cover art. Maybe just not the brand for me right now
I have light skin and generally prefer neutral/cooler undertones, but the High Temp palette is STUNNING. I actually don't think it's that warm, it's more of a dusky jewel tone palette. The amazing thing is that ALL the shades work well together. It's weird but they do, you don't need to even think when using it. I have had people literally stop me on the street when I wear it and all the shades just blend beautifully. I got it because I loved the color story and thought it might just work if I got a tan in the summer, but it has become my year round palette and go to when I just want to feel... royal.
GREAT video! I know it would be a ton of work, but it would be fun if you could put up a look you did with each palette from old footage! I love seeing your looks!
Unfortunately I did not have time to do that this time with so many palettes! I usually include it in my monthly rankings because there’s 10 and under palettes. I hope one day TH-cam can be my main gig so I can devote even more time to it but it’s just a side thing for me at this time!
This is a giant Sophie's Choice of a video. I love all of my Unearthly pallettes
Unearthly’s journey has been one of my favorites, I don’t have every single one but I have most of their palettes and I could never pick a single palette as a favorite lol the original Fall Magic haunts me to this day, I remember when it was still available.. I missed it and when it sold out it never restocked. I love the packaging too SO much! Fairy Frolic was my first palette from them. I’ll buy* literally anything they release like 💁🏻♀️💳
lol saaaaame!!
I didn’t watch Gargoyles but every time I hear about it I become more sure that if I had it would absolutely have become a key part of my personality / interests 🤣
I’ve been struggling with all kinds of motivation over the last week due to The Current Events, even for fun stuff like makeup - so thank you for getting me excited again
🫶
Hands down, favorite indie brand! ❤I love Unearthly and I can't wait for her Holiday releases!!❤
They’re so good!!
Leather & Lace hands Down Love it!! I heard that the one lunar beauty is sort of like this but love Unearthly 😂😂❤😂❤
I just got that during the sale and I have used it all but 1 day since it showed up lol
I absolutely loved the Gargoyle tv show & was the reason I bought this palette 😂
Yessss 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
I have several, and if I had to choose, I think I'd choose Gargoyle and Dreamer as being tied for my favorites!
But, yeah, I do agree about that original Fall Magic palette. It's a stunner! I wish I had that one in my collection!
Both of those are so good ! Great picks
100000% agree about putting looks together with multichromes! I've asked so many creators to help with that, and the majority just told me to put ur metallics down first..that's soo counterintuitive to me! I honestly end up avoiding most multichromes..😢
Love rankings. I’ve only used lore, devour, and sorcerer smoke.
I had one Alien palette several years back and was unimpressed so I didn’t dive into unearthly until this year and more accurately until last month. I finally tried my Sorcerers Smoke which has been sitting around for months untouched. To say I’m in love would be an understatement!!! I now can’t wait to play with the other palettes I own. Fall Magic, Leather and Lace and Lore.
I have a feeling if Leather and Lace had lighter shades like you mentioned, it might have turned into a fave. But I think I’m even more pale then you so it might be a struggle with all the mattes as deep as they are. But I will make it work. Sorcerers Smoke is mostly deep too and I have been enjoying it so much!!!
Yes, their formulas have changed A LOT since Alien days!! I’m glad you’re living Sorcerous Smoke!!
Haha, getting that workout in for the thumbnail! 😂
🤣🤣🤣
I was a phlebotomist you can take your bandage off after 10 mins. It's mainly covered since it's an open puncture to keep air bacteria off while it seals closed but it stops bleeding within seconds after pressure otherwise your arm be covered in blood and you would know there's a problem just a tip cause I know uncomfortable it is to bend your arm with that thing on.❤😊 as long as u arent downing a bunch of alcohol and asprin and running a marathon youll be okay 😂
Thank you!!!
I absolutely love Unearthly cosmetics. Leather and lace was my first palette from them and i still love it to this day. Other i love are Lore, fairly frolic, sorceress smoke, dreamer, Devour, spring magic, night terror. My order with Not normal remastered and Gargoyle has just shipped today so I'm excited to get my hands on them 😊
Ohhh yay!! I hope you love them
I kinda want their all shimmer palette the 'all i ever wanted'? It is a rerelease as far as i know and the shimmers ...oh. my. god the SHIMMERS are beautiful on the swatch video ❤❤❤so i kinda on the fence with this one. Also spring magic looks very beautiful❤ I already have pastel palettes but i am still interested in it
Yesss the all shimmer palette looks stunning ✨✨
Great video Rachel - I would have no idea how to rank my Unearthly palettes but I can say there would be a tie for first place between Frolic, Learher and Lace, Sleepover, The Grind, Spring Magic, Gargoyle and High Temp. However, being an obviously indecisive person I can say with 100% certainty that Unearthly Cosmetics is my #1 FAVORITE Indy Brand! I love watching Hayden's Haunts and I think Amanda Hayden is one of the coolest people on the planet. 💜💚🩵
Amanda is very very cool & incredibly sweet
I haven't tried Unearthly... yet. I like the Gargoyle palette. Yey for the drum roll moment every time we reach number one in your rankings 😊
😂🤣
i don’t have any unearthly palettes yet but i ordered sorcerous smoke and fall magic during the halloween sale! still waiting on those since sorcerous smoke was on preorder but i cannot wait to try them
Ooooh I hope you love them!!
Unearthly is my favorite indie brand since their most recent formula upgrade (the old one creased on me). My fav is Sorcerous Smoke followed by Dreamer and Resurgence. I think the new Not Normal is the only newer formula palette I don't have. I also love their Satin Liquid Lipsticks. 🤩💗
All so good!!
I have the Sleepover palette. It's really cute. I think it's a pretty nice palette for people that like pink and w the size it's so easy to use them as blushes and there's blushes for different skin tones too. I actually used the shimmers as highlighter too and thought it worked really well. They looked good as highlighter 😊the Charmer palette is stunning. So many pretty shades
Def can see using the shimmers as highlights!
I was very fortunate to own both Fall magic as well 🙏 ❤❤❤🎉❤❤❤ blessed to have them 4 sure!!!
Both are so beautiful
My fav is So Strange, Sorcerous Smoke, and Not Normal.... the older version. I don't have the new one but will get it sometime. Holiday shopping has got me tapped out right now!
I hear you on that one! 😅
Good morning Rachel! Happy Thursday! I'm so excited to watch this! 😊🩷💜🩵💚💛🧡
Hello!! I hope you enjoy :)
😊Love your lip colour and blush! Of course the eyelook is great too. Wonder if Unearthly will have a black Friday sale too 👀
Thank you!
Omg, GARGOYLES!! 😂 I haven't thought about that show since the 90's! My younger brother and I used to LOVE watching that show. We'd watch it together all the time. Aww...! I really didn't think I'd get such a big nostalgia hit from an Unearthly ranking video right at the start of my day 😂 I'm pretty sure I'm a handful of yrs older than you, Rachel, so I was already in high school when it was running, and I remember believing that I had to keep the fact that I liked/watched the show be this BIG secret bc I didn't want people to make fun of me. Gargoyles and anime (which I've watched since the 80's), so happy that public perception has changed in that area. Of course, now I'm too old to care what other people think about it, but back then? I'm pretty sure I threatened my brother with swift retaliation once or twice when he tried to joke about telling people 😂😂
Anyway, memories aside, great video! I have yet to make my first purchase from Unearthly, but I promised myself that I would get the Sorcerous Smoke palette this Black Friday. Oh and one last thing..! I just checked, and the Leather and Lace palette is still both on their site, AND it's actually in stock for $36! (Just thought some of your viewers would want to know!) I had to double check bc I was pretty sure I had seen it on there last week when I was deciding which one I wanted to get. Gargoyles and Spring Magic are another 2 kinda on the list, but I'm not sure bc they both have more than 1 shade I wouldn't use. While it looks like I could use all of Sorcerous Smoke and Leather and Lace. Hope everyone has a fantastic weekend!
I'm so glad Leather & Lace is available. Yes, it's at a great price point!! Totally worth it :)
I loved the show gargoyles, it was so fun.
Yesss!
Yeahhhh❤🎉❤🎉😂😂❤🎉😂🙏 👍🏻 💯 🎉 HAPPY THURSDAY GOD LOVE YOU YESZzzzz!!! 🎉❤🎉😂 🤗 🙏 U ROCK RACHEL hahahaha
1. Old Bunnies Palette
2. Gargoyle
3. Spring palette
P. S. 🙏 don't keep that on your arm a long time 😘
I knew you were waiting for this video!! Good picks. I never tried Bunnies but wanted it so bad
Yes!! I’ve been waiting for this ranking!
I’m so in love with this brand!
Yayyy!!
@ ❤️❤️❤️
I picked up the new not normal during the first pre-order. They were supposed to ship Halloween then pushed it back to Nov 6th and( after hearing nothing till I reached out) I emailed them again when Nov 6th came and went and never heard back..I just got my shipping confirmation this morning tho..never had this happen before especially with unearthly very frustrating. I'm just done with fronting companies my money 😂
I'm sorry you had that experience 😥
The whole rating, I was thinking, I wonder if she has the original Fall Magic?! 😂 Great ranking! Blues are not my 1st choice (or 2nd or 3rd lol!) but something about Gargoyle, I just LOVE the blues in it. Same with Spring Magic. So those would be my #1 and 2. And then original Fall Magic and the new Fall Magic would be 3 and 4. Then the rest would be similar. I really love the newer formula.
Thanks for sharing your faves! I agree, the new formula is SO good
I loved this video! I love ranking videos!!!
I'm so glad!
I haven't tried Unearthly, but I want to! I will go there now and see what they have.
They’re great 😊
Thank you so much for mentioning which old ones are the newer formula I just had them in my cart and pulled back specifically because I thought they were the old formula specifically the daily grind lore and leather and lace so you are saying lore and leather n lace are the new formula do you know about the daily grind? Would be super helpful cause I want devour also more money for Amanda if you let me know...😊 I guess I can ask on Hayden haunts she usually always replies which is awesome I love that..❤🥰
Yes Daily Grind is the new formula too!
@rachelapalmieri THANK YOU SO SO MUCH Rachel, that is so so helpful!! I loved seeing fairy frolic ranked so high because I love it too!! In fact it was my throwback Thursday winner just yesterday and I created the best look yet with it to date. I love mystical moss and frolic shade. I also like how unearthly gives us bigger pans than most other brands, I don't hear people mention that much, but it's a huge selling point for me that their prices are on the lower end, bigger pans, and in my eyes the most unique matte tones on the market..and magnetic for my byop, I byop if I want before I can afford. I don't get pr so I buy everything on my channel I showcase. I'm a nano, nano channel..😂🫶🖤
I enjoyed the video because I just love unearthly especially some of the older palettes. I have a good amount but wish for the old fall magic and the leather and lace. But my favorite is not normal and the low lights highlighter palette.
Ooooh I loooove the lowlight highlighter formula! It’s so good!
Unfortunately I don't have the same appreciation for some of the cover art. The ones that have hypersexualized covers have actually been a deterrent from purchasing.
And YES--their shimmers of late are completely gasp-worthy! ❤❤❤❤
(And how has there not been a live-action Gargoyles movie yet??!! LOVED that show!!!)
They totally should have made a live action version!
I only own Resurgence and Devour from Unearthly, I love them both! 😍 And I love their Satin liquid lipstick formula.
Oooh yes the satin liquid lip is great!!
You're adorable❤❤❤
And unearthly palettes too😂
🤣🤣 thanks!!
I only have the Gargoyle pallet and I love it. I used your code on my order. 😊
Yay! Thank you! 🙏 🥰
My only Unearthly palette is the Resurgence by Heather Austin and it has been my GO TO for bright pops of color since I got it! The formula is top tier for sure!
Love it!!
Rachel, you just made me buy 4 palettes!!!! Haha. ❤❤❤
lol I hope you enjoy them!!
I picked up the new not normal on launch day, just haven’t received it yet! Super excited though because I agree- I love the mattes in the original but never reach for it because of the shimmers
I'm so jealous!! I hope you love the new version.
Love your look here! Can you do a tutorial on this look?
i got the older fall magic but i actually never used it! i will have to break it out to try it!!
You DEF should!!
I have decluttered all but 3 of my Unearthly palettes, so my top 3 are Lore, Leather and Lace, and Sleepover. I haven't bought from them since their palette prices have almost doubled and their shipping costs are ridiculous.
I prefer the old shimmer formula from Unearthly. I don't know if I'm alone in this (maybe so!), but I don't like sparkly high-shine shimmers. I like more a more subtle finish. I know a lot of brands have moved to high shimmer/shine. It makes sense and they are very pretty and super high impact, but I don't find them as wearable for day-to-day use.
I can totally understand that! I’m sure you’re not alone. I also like a more subtle shimmer sometimes 🙂
PSA: Unearthly is having an amazing sale RN - 50%! I snagged the Leather and Lace palette which I’ve been eying for weeks!
I never owned the Not Normal but I just ordered the Remastered and I’m so excited to try it! I’ve been eyeing this color story for ages!
I think both of the Fall Magic palettes are at the top of my list as well. I love them both so much! 💖
All so pretty!!
I did buy the new Not Normal, but haven’t received yet.
I hope you love it :)
😢💔 I'm so sad right now, and I didn't hear anything either. The Dreamer palette is already discontinued and gone. Does anyone know why and when this happened? That was my top choice to purchase as a gift to myself for Christmas.
Oh no! 😟 I’m sorry
I have three or four palettes. I like their formulas, but to me all of them are required to have a companion palette. I just don't wear the full crazy all day at work, I need neutrals.
I have old Not Normal, Dreamer, Sleepover reboot (sold the original, but missed it. I miss the large size, but feel less guilty with a small one), and I have Smells Like Holiday Spirit.
so I am set, but did get the Spring Magic on their Halloween sale, which was a score, as the palette is really gorgeous.
I didn't get Leather and Lace as I really hate the background on the palette and have far too many red/pink palettes, or red and pink in palettes, so it's not attractive to me.
😊👍
🥰🥰🥰
The color stories I'm drawn to (Sorcerer's Smoke and Not Normal) I already have in my collection. I would have probably grabbed Not Normal, but I don't like the cover art. Maybe just not the brand for me right now
Always good to compare & use what you already have!!
Had a bad customer service experience with unearthly so i stopped buying there products.
This video was excellent! Loved it and probably my most favorite! I actually purchased Fall Magic as soon as it dropped 🍂🍁😊🤎