Came back here again because seeing some tweets about SBS bullying T-ara throughout the show. SHINee know what happened that’s why they kept standing and finding seats. Jonghyun was protecting the girls because the staffs keep telling them to sit again
Tara leader used to be SM trainee. So I beat jonghyun is close to Tara members. Our jonghyun really have awesome heart. He's the man of justice in K-pop.
Soyeon wasn't close with Jonghyun but he knew that T-ARA deserved better and stood up for them when they were being treated badly. Infinite respect for Jonghyun who chose love over hate.
Now that Jonghyun has passed away, a T-ara fan came out with a statement about Jonghyun being kind towards T ara and arguing with the staff because they didn't have enough seats for them. Hopefully you all feel bad for assuming that Jonghyun was a bad person. Jonghyun passing will be a lesson to all Kpop fans that spreading hate and rumours about an idol can really harm them WHY? ... because they are HUMANS!
the fact that some people have the audacity to make hateful comments for no reasonable explanation, really makes me fucking sick and disgusted. this is probably one of the common reasons why it causes idols to have deep dark thoughts and unhappy feelings to the point where they are just completely broken inside. And sometimes too be honest, i have an discomforted feeling that when I look at idols that I cherish, I am convinced that they are maybe really sad, and depressed because of receiving so much hateful bullshit from stupid people. Rest well in peace jjong, shinee will always forever be OT5.
Betsy Nguyen sorry but as just the video its pretty obvious may it be on the staff still i wont say he behave so well and btw that t-ara fan who spread her own assumption on this fancam was not even the fancamer and she just tweet it as assumption of her own also ..the truth no one knows what happened that day as even the fancamer is so far...only those were there knows what happened so lets pls stop spreading make up stories just to praised someone even its not actually what confirmed happened there
born to be a Queen's and what did he do to them? Do you have proof that he was actually yelling at them rather than at the staff which is what the whole t-ara staff has been saying for years now? Don’t you have anything better to do than bad mouth a man who has passed away and has no way to back himself up? Jesus Christ kpoppers are the worst
Apreciate Amber who naturally standing and try to arrange the seat. And I think Jonghyun not frustated over T-ara, but more angry to the crew, because when they try to give T-ara their seat, the crew keep telling them to go back to their seat and leave T-ara standing. And I'm in love with Taemin and Minho here, keep standing, such a gentlemen :D Poor T-ara, but God know they strong enough, my Queens, much love from me.
+Raey Hanah Yes. I think that's the situation. Shinee members are close to T-ara especially Soyeon. She was a trainee in SM that's why they knew each other.
Raey Hanah yeah! Exactly! At first i thought he was angry at T-ara but after thinking about it, i think he was pissed at the crew. I'd do the same too if i were in his position.
After so many years,just to clarify thing's up...this happen at the peak of T-ARA's scandal of allegation of bullying one of their own member.Back then,many people believe that it is true and so many have been angry to T-ARA to the extent that even an orginizer of an award event did'nt gave an assign seat for them (intentional or unintentional nobody know's) and so when they arrived there is no space so SHINee and FX tried to accomodate them because they just stand beside them.But there are so many members so they still woud'nt fit and so Jonghyun ask the staff why they did'nt assign seats for T-ARA and ask for extra chairs but when the staff just keep telling them to just compress with the girls, Jonghyun,Minho,and SHINee member's insist that they should have given T-ARA a proper seat because they feel sorry for the girls for having the trouble of not having seats and difficulty to find a place to sit.Jonghyun is actually asking the staff for more seats for the girls.He is more disappointed by the staff and not agry with the girls.They all just feel sorry for T-ARA for being treated that way...After a long time,truth came out that T-ARA's bullying scandal is not true and the group's got cleared.As of the member who said she is being bullied,as far as I know she was removed from the group after knowing that she lied.Hope everthing was cleared,SHINee and Jonghyun are not angry with T-ARA but disappointed by how the staff treat the girls. Peace everyone. ✌😊
Hello. I wanna ask something, i dont really know the members of t ara, so based on what you said, you meant the member who claimed to be bullied was here in the video and not yet leave the group until she was proven to be lying? Was she here in this video?
@@ginse4891 we know him and his body pattern. He tends to have sharp/abrupt movements, but that doesn't mean his being actually mean or aggressive towards anyone. And Jinki smiles at him too, he wouldn't if Jonghyun would've done or said something bad. Plus SHINee was close to T-ara since debut till then (I'm not sure about right now, that's why I use past tense), so knowing how Jonghyun is and the relationship between both groups, I don't think he was being mean towards the girls. They were talking with the staff too.
nope wrong. don't buy into their sympathy ploy. this is taemin's moment alone. to all those using this to make their shampoo papi look good, nahhhh! bull! This was The Gentleman Taemin's Moment ALONE! He gave up his seat for T-ara. He went up the stairs immediately beside T-ara Qri which shows staff clearly told them to move to their left and since there was no vacant seats anymore, the staff came back again to ask them to be gentlemen and give their seat to the ladies T-ara but instead your papi shampooed his hair in anger. Don't use this moment to prop up your jonghyun, THIS IS TAEMIN AND TAEMIN'S MOMENT ALONE!
Thank you f(x) Exo and Shinee! 3 groups who are respectful and caring and dear Shawols just ignore them they're not t-ara fans i want to thank you too for not bashing t-ara in this video even if trolls keep saying stupid stuff about shinee sorry again
The way the groups handled it was nice, as I saw in a statement, jonghyun was arguing with the crew as they didn't gave t ara a seat and he was livid and disappointed, amber wanted to squeeze t ara in but as there're too many of them, it was impossible to do so. They try to give their seats to t ara but the crew wanted them to go and sit down instead. I think they all should be credited and not only taemin since they too were trying to give seats to t ara. I did hoped that they gave them enough seats even with the "rumors" going around even as a sign of respect to them as an idol.
@@ocenavictorialuisap.6272 one thing is clear minho do the talking with the staff and as a leader is really look up to minho always and taemin being that nice boy acted normally what a good would do and thats to give way directly
I dont know clearly about this but I see that f(x) and Minho are very polite. When T-ara just comes, f(x) hurry to find seat for T-ara and Minho looks around to find too.
I always feel thankful for Jonghyun, as T-ARA fans, i knew my girls could never brave enough to talk anything with staffs during that fake scandals era so atleasr this man swore to the staff for me for mismanaged the artist's seats.
nope, point your gratitude to the right MAN, Taemin. to all those using this to make their shampoo papi look good, nahhhh! bull! This was The Gentleman Taemin's Moment ALONE! He gave up his seat for T-ara. He went up the stairs immediately beside T-ara Qri which shows staff clearly told them to move to their left and since there was no vacant seats anymore, the staff came back again to ask them to be gentlemen and give their seat to the ladies T-ara but instead your papi shampooed his hair in anger. Don't use this moment to prop up your jonghyun, THIS IS TAEMIN AND TAEMIN'S MOMENT ALONE!
Jonghyun was angry with the staff cos they screwed up and he was joking .. Watch other fancams .. He was smiling .. He even comforted key who was a little pissed as well. Pls comment after getting ur facts right .
IMO Jonghyun doesnt even looked as being rude or mad. His face is more like he's teasing & saying "are you kidding me? there's not enough seat how can we squeeze in??" Plus the staff keep asking them all to squeeze into the seats. While one chair is for one person I believed. U can see Onew is smile after Jonghyun acts. If Jonghyun is mad then surely Onew, who is next to him will try to calm him down. Stop make a bad accusations. And I'm not even a shawol. Just know how to read a situation. For t-ara member who closed her mouth probably bcs the staff have said "if there's no seat, then all of u need to stand throughout the show"
I think you saw it wrong the staff didnt asked them ti squeeze into the seat but the opposite the staff keep asking them to just sit and ignore them u can saw the staff hand gesture when they were moving the staff hand asking them to move back
I can’t understand anything, I know this is years ago but all keeping blaming SHINee and not another groups, Gosh, Jonghyun was yelling to a staff for their rude behaviour toward t-ara...you guys made bad comments on him just because you thought he was yelling to T-ara when the true is he wasn’t
Soyeon was an SM trainee who also trained with SHINee, so they knew her and friends with her. I watched Hello Baby and SHINee seems friends with other members like Eunjung too. And Taemin and Jiyeon are same age friends too, when they debuted around the same time they exchanged phone numbers and took pics together. So the "bullying" rumor (proven false eventually) didn't seem to affect their friendships. SHINee ofc being gentlemen, don't feel it's right to see their friends (and women at that) standing there without seats and tried to offer them their seats.
and T-ara so humble don´t ask anyone to stand up, weren´t angry with SBS staff, they were just waiting and surprised by this stupid situation. This girls have gold hearts, i hope they weren´t sad because of this. But i think all the bad moments this year will only have it´s pay back next year + T-ara and queen´s are stronger.
I cannot imagine how ppl could have thought Jonghyun was being rude to T-ara or the crew from this video when 1) he has no history of being rude to anyone 2) nobody was reacting as shocked or concerned (which is a logical reaction to someone being rude) 3) ppl were still smiling (I assume they were smiling from the frustration of the crap they have to deal with sometines) 4) T-ara may have been in the middle of a scandal BUT idols would know better what to believe (they'd have first and secondhand info, being from the industry) and would also know better to sympathize (coz they've all been victims of malicious gossip)
have you seen boram,soyeon and specially hyomin so shocked when your papi started shampooing his hair in anger? lol don't use T-ara to prop up your papi for this is TAEMIN'S MOMENT ALONE! to all those using this to make their shampoo papi look good, nahhhh! bull! This was The Gentleman Taemin's Moment ALONE! He gave up his seat for T-ara. He went up the stairs immediately beside T-ara Qri which shows staff clearly told them to move to their left and since there was no vacant seats anymore, the staff came back again to ask them to be gentlemen and give their seat to the ladies T-ara but instead your papi shampooed his hair in anger. Don't use this moment to prop up your jonghyun, THIS IS TAEMIN AND TAEMIN'S MOMENT ALONE!
i guess i need to clear this up bc i saw many bashing jonghyun for being mad with t-ara. he's not. i guess i can say that he's 'acting' like he's mad with the sbs workers bc of the awful seating plans. and idk if you can see it from this fancams, but a few people actually smile and laughs at jjong's 'rage' acting. he's just joking.
EXO's seat is crowd so they don't need to move f(x) and Jonghyung move and sit down already but SBS worker call them to comeback Taemin stand up and go to behind lately I make sure Jonghyung is not shout to T-ara maybe he is singing with MBLAQ's music or shout to SBS worker
@@dllhyyunjae572 the girls standing up in red costumes. Because of a big scandal they were heavily mistreated and in the video Jonghyun is seen yelling at the staff for not assigning them seats.
he was joking around , like being sarcastic lol He's obviously not upset at anyone but frustrated at the seating confustion~ SHINee are respectful boys
it's SBS fault. They didnt organized the seats well. you shouldn't be angry to SHINee too you shouldn't blame the idols who were sitting there. you can see Amber asking EXO to move down which they did and Jonghyun 1:38 trying to find seats down there and also Minho keeps searching for available seats 2:31 you should watch the video attentively :)
I know it's too late to say this but i think Jong was pissed at the crew. 2012 Gayo Daejun was a mess, they didn't have enough seats for everyone and this is the example. Jong and Shinee was trying to give their seats for T-ara but the crew told them to sit back, and after a while the crew asked them to move for T-ara which made Jong frustated. But i believe he didn't actually mean it.
Telling myself not to be moved by others' bad mouthing towards him, but srsly this is way cruel to just scrolling thru this comment section. I bet he would've seen things that is much more cruel than this. Jonghyun ah I will always love you
Isn't it crazy how ppl could make lots of assumptions based on a video?? I read back all the comments and damn some ppl do act like a know-it-all just by watching one video
And it will always be a video u would juat keep assuming whats happening there because no story resurface about this from the idol themselves except t-ara shared during the scandal they were thankful to their snsd...kara...iu and other idols friends of them who never leave them and stayed on their side
no because in another fancam, Jonghyun laughed after his "outburst" and we couldn't judge from a fancam since we don't know what he really said, also, u must know that Jonghyun talk like this all the time, in shows, reality shows, lives, everybody in SBS who used to work with him, know him. they all said that Jonghyun is like this and he ended being called the brave idol. Also, I don't think that it's the first time SBS have this seat poor management, so they had to get used to it. no?
jonghyun from shinee. lol he didnt yell actually. he was just frustrated with sbs workers bc of the seating plan. they and a some other artists had moved quite a lot before this so he was angry.
Omg the fact that they survive this without harming themselves is Incredible ,they were so strong,I used to really fear for jiyeon wellbeing in that time she was always the most sensitive,thank God her unnies took care of her
Its clearly visible that the staff screwed the sitting arrangement.. they were asking the idols to squeeze when it was obvious that there was no space for doing that. Jonghyun indeed seemed frustrated but he has a comical face while doing so.. its possible that he was singing the song being hyper as he is known to be...he is definitely not screaming at t-ara... the t-ara member was not covering her face bcos she was shocked..if you notice clearly she had her hands on her face even before Jonghyun started shouting... I may be wrong but its a situation that happened due to mismanagement which was blown out of proportions by the fans of both sides..
So for context: T-ara was at the height of their bullying scandal during this time. Because of this, they were ignored by SBS and weren’t provided a seat during the 2012 SBS Gayo Daejeun. During that time, other idol groups were told by their agencies not to communicate with T-ara members due to the bullying scandal. However, SHINee and f(x) ( who were really supportive of the group ) decided to move and squeeze seats for the members. However, staff members forbade them to sit in the seats provided by the two SM groups. This caused the main vocalist of SHINee, the late Jonghyun to get mad at the staff and proceeded to scream at them for mistreating the girl group.
yes he wasnt being mad for had to let their seats to the girls. he's totally normal and fine. PEOPLE have to stop misunderstanding him LOL. btw im not a fan of shinee. just being neutral :)
All I can that event was a mess, not giving t-ara specific seats to them, bad organization and even staff rude behaviour towards all groups yelling at them to sit down when they were Seeing T-ara didn’t have a seat, I can see jonghyung was so angry toward that boy who was angrily telling them to sit
Các Queen's nghe này, tình huống này các bạn đã hiểu lầm Jonghyun rồi, BTC đang bảo anh ấy về chỗ ngồi yên đó và đừng làm lọan. Chứ không phải Jonghyun tức giận vì bị cướp chổ đâu nhé ! Anh ấy đang tức giận vì BTC ko sắp xếp chỗ ngồi chu đáo cho mấy gái nhà mình đấy :)))) Ngày hôm nay mình nhận đc tin sốc, đối vs SHINee và Shawols nói riêng, vs Kpop nói chung là anh ấy đã ra đi vĩnh viễn :((((( Vậy cho nên...hãy để anh ấy yên nghỉ. Hành động của các bạn vô tình xác muối vào vết thương của anh ấy đấy :((((
Minho seems to be scolding someone. Jonghyun is definitely frustrated.. And the song really suits that atmosphere.. sbs seating is really unorganise.....
if we want to blame somebody in this, we should blame sbs.you shouldnt blame other idols.. if you see other fancams, shinee and exo, (and even f(x) i guess. im not entirely sure) actually moved their seats when t-ara came but the workers called them back and asked them to stay. key & jonghyun actually tried to stand up and give his place to t-ara but the workers wont let him. this does not happen to t-ara only, other idols like exo-m had to go back to their own van bc there's no seats for them
the fact that ppl thought jjong was screaming at t-ara shows how stupid are they. jjong is known fr being a rly nice person. EVEN IF he was just faking to be a nice person; would he scream at t-ara in public where the entire crowd and fans can see it?
First of all, do not insult people if you don't not them nor the situation they we're in (especially if they are idols, you're just gonna be hated by everyone). Second, if you knew just a little bit who you're talking about you would know he (Jonghyun) was trying to make it look like a funny little accident and the people who should be blamed are sbs staff. Third, if you're gonna insult at least do it grammatically correct so we would know what you're saying. :)
IKR? its so obvious some his facial expression that he was just messing around, but frustrated too because its ridiculous that the staff continued to make them get up and move over.... when there was no where to move over too meanwhile poor T-ara is just standing there awkwardly poor organization by the staff
We T-ara Queens are educated, we don’t turn our back to abuse any idols or groups, and we wouldn’t be pointing fingers to any groups cos we have brain to think and eye to see, because all this happen to T-ara, and we don’t want the same thing happen to other,we believe they are trying hard to get more space for T-ara,thanks for all your kindness. I don’t blame and groups or idols, I blame the organization for no proper arranging sit and let T-ara standing for more than 1 hr.
it seems to me that the places are originally SHINees, because they were sitting near other SM groups, and the staff decided at the last moment to ive the places to T-ara, which leads to a messy and awkward situation
bc of sbs. they didnt provide enough seats for the artist so some of them had to change seats quite a number of time and some resorts to go back at their own van and wait there
Flag all the unnecessary hater comments as spam! Some other fancams of what happened /watch?v=19F6IlrdMjw /watch?v=jILntBrP-P4&feature=youtu.be&t=1m15s you can see in this fancam that onew was smiling at jjong's "fit", and onew isn't the kind to stand by or laugh it off if any of the SHINee members do something unacceptable so it was obviously joking. :) And don't scold $B$ too, they created a fantastic gayo daejun for us :D
You can tell that he heard them say to move back but he pretends as he didn’t and also how frustrated he got in min 1:52 I really can’t believe that I can fall more in love with this man
No one still knows what went on with this? Fans way back knows that this isn't Jonghyun being a dick. And a Tara fan (and even Queen Jiyeon herself) came out with the truth when Jonghyun passed away. This is him being angry over the SBS staff not preparing seats for T-ara because they are jackasses who kept on mistreating these ladies for the bullying scandal that turned out to be not true at all. Jonghyun was angry because he knew the situation and SBS is known to mistreat idols and he was standing up to it. They also offered their seats to Tara but the SBS staff said they should sit back down as they can't produce more seat but as not seen in this video, they still gave their seats. Miraculously, SBS was able to provide more seats for Shinee
LOL WATCH YOUR MOUTH. JJONG WAS SINGING . HE DIDN'T YELLED AT T-ARA. Look at Onew's face at that moment. If he was yelling could our leader smile like that??
![[HD fancam] 121231 MBC 가요대제전 - ending (SHINee focus)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/9sApuF4TTuA/mqdefault.jpg)
![[HD fancam] 121231 MBC 가요대제전 - ending (SHINee focus)](/img/tr.png)
![[HOT] Hyomin didn't give up thanks to Sunny and Yu-ri ,라디오스타 20190807](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/o3hhFNZUdBk/mqdefault.jpg)
Came back here again because seeing some tweets about SBS bullying T-ara throughout the show. SHINee know what happened that’s why they kept standing and finding seats. Jonghyun was protecting the girls because the staffs keep telling them to sit again
Reading it made me cry. He was such a good person 🥺
me too
I can see Minho pointing his finger to his left and say "Ka" to those boys beside F'x
That's not true, he wasn't protecting them. He was pissed off because he was asked to stand up a move a little.
@saulfernandez5666 t-ara fan confirmed he was helping out the girls, get help.
Tara leader used to be SM trainee. So I beat jonghyun is close to Tara members. Our jonghyun really have awesome heart. He's the man of justice in K-pop.
Hmmm soyeon ain't close to him ...i guess soyeon way more closer to suju boys and to tvxq boys as she was a trainee along with them
Yes,,but The best Leader king Taeyeon 💗💗💗 legend and queen indeed
@@jmaejinks1138Minho used to train with Super Junior 2gen idols knew each other and where scared to express it back then
@@muhfajfir8613and what about it? I know I'm a year late but Taeyeon was not even mention anywhere in this thread 🤦
Soyeon wasn't close with Jonghyun but he knew that T-ARA deserved better and stood up for them when they were being treated badly.
Infinite respect for Jonghyun who chose love over hate.
Now that Jonghyun has passed away, a T-ara fan came out with a statement about Jonghyun being kind towards T ara and arguing with the staff because they didn't have enough seats for them.
Hopefully you all feel bad for assuming that Jonghyun was a bad person.
Jonghyun passing will be a lesson to all Kpop fans that spreading hate and rumours about an idol can really harm them WHY? ... because they are HUMANS!
the fact that some people have the audacity to make hateful comments for no reasonable explanation, really makes me fucking sick and disgusted. this is probably one of the common reasons why it causes idols to have deep dark thoughts and unhappy feelings to the point where they are just completely broken inside. And sometimes too be honest, i have an discomforted feeling that when I look at idols that I cherish, I am convinced that they are maybe really sad, and depressed because of receiving so much hateful bullshit from stupid people. Rest well in peace jjong, shinee will always forever be OT5.
That’s true and pls don’t comment any rude things first about people when you don’t know about the full story behind it
As a fan I still think he was rude...people feeling bad for him does not justify what he did to them.
Betsy Nguyen sorry but as just the video its pretty obvious may it be on the staff still i wont say he behave so well and btw that t-ara fan who spread her own assumption on this fancam was not even the fancamer and she just tweet it as assumption of her own also ..the truth no one knows what happened that day as even the fancamer is so far...only those were there knows what happened so lets pls stop spreading make up stories just to praised someone even its not actually what confirmed happened there
born to be a Queen's and what did he do to them? Do you have proof that he was actually yelling at them rather than at the staff which is what the whole t-ara staff has been saying for years now? Don’t you have anything better to do than bad mouth a man who has passed away and has no way to back himself up? Jesus Christ kpoppers are the worst
Apreciate Amber who naturally standing and try to arrange the seat. And I think Jonghyun not frustated over T-ara, but more angry to the crew, because when they try to give T-ara their seat, the crew keep telling them to go back to their seat and leave T-ara standing. And I'm in love with Taemin and Minho here, keep standing, such a gentlemen :D Poor T-ara, but God know they strong enough, my Queens, much love from me.
+Raey Hanah Yes. I think that's the situation. Shinee members are close to T-ara especially Soyeon. She was a trainee in SM that's why they knew each other.
Raey Hanah yeah! Exactly! At first i thought he was angry at T-ara but after thinking about it, i think he was pissed at the crew. I'd do the same too if i were in his position.
Terima kasih untuk SHINee dan F(x) telah menghargai dan peduli pada T-ara kami,,kami QUEEN'S khususnya saya sngat berterim kasih...
P
After so many years,just to clarify thing's up...this happen at the peak of T-ARA's scandal of allegation of bullying one of their own member.Back then,many people believe that it is true and so many have been angry to T-ARA to the extent that even an orginizer of an award event did'nt gave an assign seat for them (intentional or unintentional nobody know's) and so when they arrived there is no space so SHINee and FX tried to accomodate them because they just stand beside them.But there are so many members so they still woud'nt fit and so Jonghyun ask the staff why they did'nt assign seats for T-ARA and ask for extra chairs but when the staff just keep telling them to just compress with the girls, Jonghyun,Minho,and SHINee member's insist that they should have given T-ARA a proper seat because they feel sorry for the girls for having the trouble of not having seats and difficulty to find a place to sit.Jonghyun is actually asking the staff for more seats for the girls.He is more disappointed by the staff and not agry with the girls.They all just feel sorry for T-ARA for being treated that way...After a long time,truth came out that T-ARA's bullying scandal is not true and the group's got cleared.As of the member who said she is being bullied,as far as I know she was removed from the group after knowing that she lied.Hope everthing was cleared,SHINee and Jonghyun are not angry with T-ARA but disappointed by how the staff treat the girls. Peace everyone. ✌😊
Hello. I wanna ask something, i dont really know the members of t ara, so based on what you said, you meant the member who claimed to be bullied was here in the video and not yet leave the group until she was proven to be lying? Was she here in this video?
@@freepalestineforhumanityjo5993 she who bullied exit from t-ara (sorry my bad eng)
Jonghyun was really an angel. And he still is
How could you know he was arguing with the staff and insisted to give his seat to T-ara? It doesn't seem like that to me.
@@ginse4891 we know him and his body pattern. He tends to have sharp/abrupt movements, but that doesn't mean his being actually mean or aggressive towards anyone. And Jinki smiles at him too, he wouldn't if Jonghyun would've done or said something bad. Plus SHINee was close to T-ara since debut till then (I'm not sure about right now, that's why I use past tense), so knowing how Jonghyun is and the relationship between both groups, I don't think he was being mean towards the girls. They were talking with the staff too.
Thank You Shinee especially Jonghyun, for caring uri T-ara 💕
Nn Park say sorry NOW. He was singing
nope wrong. don't buy into their sympathy ploy. this is taemin's moment alone.
to all those using this to make their shampoo papi look good, nahhhh! bull! This was The Gentleman Taemin's Moment ALONE! He gave up his seat for T-ara. He went up the stairs immediately beside T-ara Qri which shows staff clearly told them to move to their left and since there was no vacant seats anymore, the staff came back again to ask them to be gentlemen and give their seat to the ladies T-ara but instead your papi shampooed his hair in anger. Don't use this moment to prop up your jonghyun, THIS IS TAEMIN AND TAEMIN'S MOMENT ALONE!
Thank you f(x) Exo and Shinee! 3 groups who are respectful and caring and dear Shawols just ignore them they're not t-ara fans i want to thank you too for not bashing t-ara in this video even if trolls keep saying stupid stuff about shinee sorry again
Taemin wanna give way for T-ara. A good man
Le Alice jonghuynk
agree! the way he got up and immediately moved to the back giving his seat up to T-ara is heart warming
The way the groups handled it was nice, as I saw in a statement, jonghyun was arguing with the crew as they didn't gave t ara a seat and he was livid and disappointed, amber wanted to squeeze t ara in but as there're too many of them, it was impossible to do so. They try to give their seats to t ara but the crew wanted them to go and sit down instead. I think they all should be credited and not only taemin since they too were trying to give seats to t ara. I did hoped that they gave them enough seats even with the "rumors" going around even as a sign of respect to them as an idol.
@@ocenavictorialuisap.6272 no one heard there if his arguing with the staff only those idols there tho lol
@@ocenavictorialuisap.6272 one thing is clear minho do the talking with the staff and as a leader is really look up to minho always and taemin being that nice boy acted normally what a good would do and thats to give way directly
I dont know clearly about this but I see that f(x) and Minho are very polite. When T-ara just comes, f(x) hurry to find seat for T-ara and Minho looks around to find too.
I always feel thankful for Jonghyun, as T-ARA fans, i knew my girls could never brave enough to talk anything with staffs during that fake scandals era so atleasr this man swore to the staff for me for mismanaged the artist's seats.
nope, point your gratitude to the right MAN, Taemin.
to all those using this to make their shampoo papi look good, nahhhh! bull! This was The Gentleman Taemin's Moment ALONE! He gave up his seat for T-ara. He went up the stairs immediately beside T-ara Qri which shows staff clearly told them to move to their left and since there was no vacant seats anymore, the staff came back again to ask them to be gentlemen and give their seat to the ladies T-ara but instead your papi shampooed his hair in anger. Don't use this moment to prop up your jonghyun, THIS IS TAEMIN AND TAEMIN'S MOMENT ALONE!
This makes me love SHINee more, f(x) too :)
Which one is t-ara
@@dllhyyunjae572 girls wear red costumes
Jonghyun was angry with the staff cos they screwed up and he was joking .. Watch other fancams .. He was smiling .. He even comforted key who was a little pissed as well. Pls comment after getting ur facts right .
IMO Jonghyun doesnt even looked as being rude or mad. His face is more like he's teasing & saying "are you kidding me? there's not enough seat how can we squeeze in??" Plus the staff keep asking them all to squeeze into the seats. While one chair is for one person I believed. U can see Onew is smile after Jonghyun acts. If Jonghyun is mad then surely Onew, who is next to him will try to calm him down. Stop make a bad accusations. And I'm not even a shawol. Just know how to read a situation.
For t-ara member who closed her mouth probably bcs the staff have said "if there's no seat, then all of u need to stand throughout the show"
Thats what I think too. He is neither yelling at the girls nor the staff.. Onew and Jonghyun's expressions and body language says it all.
I think you saw it wrong the staff didnt asked them ti squeeze into the seat but the opposite the staff keep asking them to just sit and ignore them u can saw the staff hand gesture when they were moving the staff hand asking them to move back
I can’t understand anything, I know this is years ago but all keeping blaming SHINee and not another groups, Gosh, Jonghyun was yelling to a staff for their rude behaviour toward t-ara...you guys made bad comments on him just because you thought he was yelling to T-ara when the true is he wasn’t
They are still smiling even though there is no seats for them. :)) ♥
T-ara fighting! Boram.
Saw this on Shawol tlist again.. what a shame to the program really.. for doing this to Tara..
Man..I just realized that Jonghyun was the one who’s mad at the staff..lemme crying rn
Soyeon was an SM trainee who also trained with SHINee, so they knew her and friends with her. I watched Hello Baby and SHINee seems friends with other members like Eunjung too. And Taemin and Jiyeon are same age friends too, when they debuted around the same time they exchanged phone numbers and took pics together. So the "bullying" rumor (proven false eventually) didn't seem to affect their friendships. SHINee ofc being gentlemen, don't feel it's right to see their friends (and women at that) standing there without seats and tried to offer them their seats.
and T-ara so humble don´t ask anyone to stand up, weren´t angry with SBS staff, they were just waiting and surprised by this stupid situation. This girls have gold hearts, i hope they weren´t sad because of this.
But i think all the bad moments this year will only have it´s pay back next year + T-ara and queen´s are stronger.
Good work Jonghyung. May you rest in peace.
I cannot imagine how ppl could have thought Jonghyun was being rude to T-ara or the crew from this video when
1) he has no history of being rude to anyone
2) nobody was reacting as shocked or concerned (which is a logical reaction to someone being rude)
3) ppl were still smiling (I assume they were smiling from the frustration of the crap they have to deal with sometines)
4) T-ara may have been in the middle of a scandal BUT idols would know better what to believe (they'd have first and secondhand info, being from the industry) and would also know better to sympathize (coz they've all been victims of malicious gossip)
have you seen boram,soyeon and specially hyomin so shocked when your papi started shampooing his hair in anger? lol don't use T-ara to prop up your papi for this is TAEMIN'S MOMENT ALONE!
to all those using this to make their shampoo papi look good, nahhhh! bull! This was The Gentleman Taemin's Moment ALONE! He gave up his seat for T-ara. He went up the stairs immediately beside T-ara Qri which shows staff clearly told them to move to their left and since there was no vacant seats anymore, the staff came back again to ask them to be gentlemen and give their seat to the ladies T-ara but instead your papi shampooed his hair in anger. Don't use this moment to prop up your jonghyun, THIS IS TAEMIN AND TAEMIN'S MOMENT ALONE!
i guess i need to clear this up bc i saw many bashing jonghyun for being mad with t-ara. he's not. i guess i can say that he's 'acting' like he's mad with the sbs workers bc of the awful seating plans. and idk if you can see it from this fancams, but a few people actually smile and laughs at jjong's 'rage' acting. he's just joking.
Came this D-1 before T-ARA comeback, proud to be SM Stan.
They are so kind to Other Idol like T-ARA.
SHINee best boys indeed
I just want to cry seing this , if i were them i just could not hold back my tears see how others neglect what happend
EXO's seat is crowd so they don't need to move
f(x) and Jonghyung move and sit down already
but SBS worker call them to comeback
Taemin stand up and go to behind lately
I make sure Jonghyung is not shout to T-ara
maybe he is singing with MBLAQ's music
or shout to SBS worker
STUPID SBS !!!!! SBS has hurt T-ara a lot in 2012. I do not want SBS to repeat it again in 2013. Be strong, T-ara !
Can i know which one is t ara
@@dllhyyunjae572 the girls standing up in red costumes. Because of a big scandal they were heavily mistreated and in the video Jonghyun is seen yelling at the staff for not assigning them seats.
Terima kasih untuk jonghyun shinee, F(X) dan EXO sudah peduli dengan T-ARA. 👍🏻🙏🏻
As expected of SHINee and how they respect the others too. I'm proud to know them really.
he was joking around , like being sarcastic lol He's obviously not upset at anyone but frustrated at the seating confustion~ SHINee are respectful boys
it's SBS fault. They didnt organized the seats well.
you shouldn't be angry to SHINee too
you shouldn't blame the idols who were sitting there. you can see Amber asking EXO to move down which they did and Jonghyun 1:38 trying to find seats down there and also Minho keeps searching for available seats 2:31
you should watch the video attentively :)
I know it's too late to say this but i think Jong was pissed at the crew. 2012 Gayo Daejun was a mess, they didn't have enough seats for everyone and this is the example. Jong and Shinee was trying to give their seats for T-ara but the crew told them to sit back, and after a while the crew asked them to move for T-ara which made Jong frustated. But i believe he didn't actually mean it.
Telling myself not to be moved by others' bad mouthing towards him, but srsly this is way cruel to just scrolling thru this comment section. I bet he would've seen things that is much more cruel than this. Jonghyun ah I will always love you
Hwayoung destroyed T Ara...but nowdays people can see the fact by themself
Isn't it crazy how ppl could make lots of assumptions based on a video?? I read back all the comments and damn some ppl do act like a know-it-all just by watching one video
And it will always be a video u would juat keep assuming whats happening there because no story resurface about this from the idol themselves except t-ara shared during the scandal they were thankful to their snsd...kara...iu and other idols friends of them who never leave them and stayed on their side
no because in another fancam, Jonghyun laughed after his "outburst" and we couldn't judge from a fancam since we don't know what he really said, also, u must know that Jonghyun talk like this all the time, in shows, reality shows, lives, everybody in SBS who used to work with him, know him. they all said that Jonghyun is like this and he ended being called the brave idol. Also, I don't think that it's the first time SBS have this seat poor management, so they had to get used to it. no?
jonghyun from shinee. lol he didnt yell actually. he was just frustrated with sbs workers bc of the seating plan. they and a some other artists had moved quite a lot before this so he was angry.
Jonghyun are ANGEL ❤️
I feel hurt when watching this video
Be strong, T-ara and Queen's~
I do not blame anyone, but I do admire her T-ARA has a strong heart.
Can you guys imagine how T-Ara member feeling in that time? 😭😭
Omg the fact that they survive this without harming themselves is Incredible ,they were so strong,I used to really fear for jiyeon wellbeing in that time she was always the most sensitive,thank God her unnies took care of her
My mental health could never be same level as T-ARA. They faced a lot of bad things. They're so strong.
I will always look up and adore taemin and minho
T-ara my babies... fighting ! Who needs seats anyway, beautiful just standing up, always showing your charms .
Its clearly visible that the staff screwed the sitting arrangement.. they were asking the idols to squeeze when it was obvious that there was no space for doing that.
Jonghyun indeed seemed frustrated but he has a comical face while doing so.. its possible that he was singing the song being hyper as he is known to be...he is definitely not screaming at t-ara... the t-ara member was not covering her face bcos she was shocked..if you notice clearly she had her hands on her face even before Jonghyun started shouting... I may be wrong but its a situation that happened due to mismanagement which was blown out of proportions by the fans of both sides..
f(x) and SHINee are let their seat to T-ara
jonghyun is angry with SBS worker
Jonghyun a good person
i came here bcs i saw a tweet regarding the issue way back then
So for context: T-ara was at the height of their bullying scandal during this time. Because of this, they were ignored by SBS and weren’t provided a seat during the 2012 SBS Gayo Daejeun. During that time, other idol groups were told by their agencies not to communicate with T-ara members due to the bullying scandal. However, SHINee and f(x) ( who were really supportive of the group ) decided to move and squeeze seats for the members. However, staff members forbade them to sit in the seats provided by the two SM groups. This caused the main vocalist of SHINee, the late Jonghyun to get mad at the staff and proceeded to scream at them for mistreating the girl group.
He always act angry even on TV shows , but then he smiled ;D Why so serious , he's smiling after that yeaaa
They are so kind. Proud to be fan.
T-ara is making comeback around october pls support them!
yes he wasnt being mad for had to let their seats to the girls. he's totally normal and fine. PEOPLE have to stop misunderstanding him LOL. btw im not a fan of shinee. just being neutral :)
Thank you shinee
unbelievable,my T-ARA :(
I'm still watching 😔
he's being funny. he's not mad and looking at him he is trying to surpass a smile in he's face ^_^
All I can that event was a mess, not giving t-ara specific seats to them, bad organization and even staff rude behaviour towards all groups yelling at them to sit down when they were Seeing T-ara didn’t have a seat, I can see jonghyung was so angry toward that boy who was angrily telling them to sit
Miss jonghuyn thank you for support T-ara
Các Queen's nghe này, tình huống này các bạn đã hiểu lầm Jonghyun rồi, BTC đang bảo anh ấy về chỗ ngồi yên đó và đừng làm lọan. Chứ không phải Jonghyun tức giận vì bị cướp chổ đâu nhé ! Anh ấy đang tức giận vì BTC ko sắp xếp chỗ ngồi chu đáo cho mấy gái nhà mình đấy :)))) Ngày hôm nay mình nhận đc tin sốc, đối vs SHINee và Shawols nói riêng, vs Kpop nói chung là anh ấy đã ra đi vĩnh viễn :((((( Vậy cho nên...hãy để anh ấy yên nghỉ. Hành động của các bạn vô tình xác muối vào vết thương của anh ấy đấy :((((
I think Jonghyun was joking cause you can see Onew smiled
hyomin had her hands over her mouth before Jong. even yelled tho
Minho seems to be scolding someone. Jonghyun is definitely frustrated.. And the song really suits that atmosphere.. sbs seating is really unorganise.....
Why the hell are some of you pissed that the guys did not give up their seats for T-ara? Please don't blame other idols for SBS' lousy planning.
I looks at t-ara's face, they seem upset... :( t-ara hwattig
if we want to blame somebody in this, we should blame sbs.you shouldnt blame other idols.. if you see other fancams, shinee and exo, (and even f(x) i guess. im not entirely sure) actually moved their seats when t-ara came but the workers called them back and asked them to stay. key & jonghyun actually tried to stand up and give his place to t-ara but the workers wont let him. this does not happen to t-ara only, other idols like exo-m had to go back to their own van bc there's no seats for them
the fact that ppl thought jjong was screaming at t-ara shows how stupid are they. jjong is known fr being a rly nice person. EVEN IF he was just faking to be a nice person; would he scream at t-ara in public where the entire crowd and fans can see it?
Lol he can yell they were so far from the fans fyi haha this is an area just for the idols
First of all, do not insult people if you don't not them nor the situation they we're in (especially if they are idols, you're just gonna be hated by everyone). Second, if you knew just a little bit who you're talking about you would know he (Jonghyun) was trying to make it look like a funny little accident and the people who should be blamed are sbs staff. Third, if you're gonna insult at least do it grammatically correct so we would know what you're saying. :)
IKR? its so obvious some his facial expression that he was just messing around, but frustrated too because its ridiculous that the staff continued to make them get up and move over.... when there was no where to move over too meanwhile poor T-ara is just standing there awkwardly poor organization by the staff
I stan a Gentleman..
Were they able to sit?
Precious Jonghyun 💙
@boojiyong2 I know you're a fan of T-ara... what happened next after this fancam???
We T-ara Queens are educated, we don’t turn our back to abuse any idols or groups, and we wouldn’t be pointing fingers to any groups cos we have brain to think and eye to see, because all this happen to T-ara, and we don’t want the same thing happen to other,we believe they are trying hard to get more space for
T-ara,thanks for all your kindness. I don’t blame and groups or idols, I blame the organization for no proper arranging sit and let T-ara standing for more than 1 hr.
Love T-ARA
Still broken my heart 😭😭
Keep it up with this guys and u will get firm abs.
it's garanted.
What happen after this?
The way jonghyun angry(?) make me...
Makes you what ?
@@muggle4835 make me miss him more
@@nurhafizah3976 😭💖
@@muggle4835 😢
it seems to me that the places are originally SHINees, because they were sitting near other SM groups, and the staff decided at the last moment to ive the places to T-ara, which leads to a messy and awkward situation
FX Miss them . Kind idol
Jonghyun ahhh
Where's the continue of this video?
T-ara no need to attend sbs already la !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I'm really hurt when watch this TT
I don't know why I'm here 6/2021😍
bc of sbs. they didnt provide enough seats for the artist so some of them had to change seats quite a number of time and some resorts to go back at their own van and wait there
EXO's hoobae and they should'd stood insteđ of T-ara
Flag all the unnecessary hater comments as spam!
Some other fancams of what happened
/watch?v=19F6IlrdMjw
/watch?v=jILntBrP-P4&feature=youtu.be&t=1m15s you can see in this fancam that onew was smiling at jjong's "fit", and onew isn't the kind to stand by or laugh it off if any of the SHINee members do something unacceptable so it was obviously joking. :)
And don't scold $B$ too, they created a fantastic gayo daejun for us :D
You can tell that he heard them say to move back but he pretends as he didn’t and also how frustrated he got in min 1:52
I really can’t believe that I can fall more in love with this man
what happened after this? Did t-ara get a seat?
and there is taemin away from all chaos!!!! he knew it back then and now... his hyungs will handle!
No one still knows what went on with this? Fans way back knows that this isn't Jonghyun being a dick. And a Tara fan (and even Queen Jiyeon herself) came out with the truth when Jonghyun passed away. This is him being angry over the SBS staff not preparing seats for T-ara because they are jackasses who kept on mistreating these ladies for the bullying scandal that turned out to be not true at all. Jonghyun was angry because he knew the situation and SBS is known to mistreat idols and he was standing up to it. They also offered their seats to Tara but the SBS staff said they should sit back down as they can't produce more seat but as not seen in this video, they still gave their seats. Miraculously, SBS was able to provide more seats for Shinee
my fx girls so kind to looking for more seat can let tara get too
please continue the video again becaus
Poor Shinee, THEY COULDN'T ENJOY MBLAQ's perf ugh SBS please put MORE seats!!!!!!
Y ahora todos sabemos que la culpa fue de la Hwayoung. T-ara es muy fuerte y sigue activa en 2021!
LOL WATCH YOUR MOUTH. JJONG WAS SINGING . HE DIDN'T YELLED AT T-ARA. Look at Onew's face at that moment. If he was yelling could our leader smile like that??
Everyone calm. :O It's not just 'T-ARA', the other idol don't have seats too!
Anyone know the song playing in the background
Run by MBLAQ!! One of the best bg during that era.
Where Eunjung and Jiyeon?