This was Pau choosing to unload a burden she had been carrying for some time. No one knows just what she was hefting, but she obviously felt the time was right to let it go…..with people who care for her all around. I am so glad she was able to lighten her load and move on. This song is one of my favorites that she has written. 🤘🏻🥹🤘🏻
Yes, mine too. Another one of her songs that doesn't get much attention at all is Escape The Mind. She performed it live at Liceo de Monterrey show for their classmates. Those girls were singing with her there too!
Very sweet reaction. Vulnerable Pau just tears your heart up. She's incredible. You have to go to one of their shows, if you haven't already. They are just on another level.
A lot of people will tell you this is about her dealing with the loss of a friend. I believe it is about Pau' dealing with anxiety and panic attacks. So, your analysis is probably right on target. Having had panic attacks driven by anxiety in the past, the lyrics accurately describe the smothering (drowning) feelings.
@@NM-tr6kq That has been brought up many times but I can't find a single person who can show the source of that quote. It also wouldn't mean that the song was about panic attacks, it could mean that it felt like a panic attack dealing with it and writing the song.
I thought it was written from the perspective of a friend who was suicidal, similar to the way in which Black Holes was written from the perspective of a distant relative struggling with addiction.
First of all, thank YOU for your own vulnerability as evoked by Pau's performance. What really struck deeply for me was, once the crowd realized Pau was struggling to continue, they added their voices to help her along. The audience got it. Inside - are too many times for far too many of us - we feel like we are all alone with no support, so that, in Pau's song lyrics, we just disappear. The audience was assuring her she was NOT alone. They were with her and they understood. Pau ends by saying "I love you all." Then, despite having the flu and only able to perform because the doctor administered steroids to allow the performance to go on, she went back to her kit to play the next song on the set list: Enter Sandman. What a brave, strong, self-aware tower of strength Pau is.
“As an artist…” So true. We put pieces of ourselves into every creation. Dany, Ale, and Pau do this with everything they create and they’ve said this over and over. “We can create something, put it out in the world, and people react to it.” - Pau. Can you imagine putting a song like Breathe out there, with every vulnerability exposed, and the first time you share it live the crowd knows every word and sings it back to you? In English! This was Mexico City. I don’t know how she even made it through the performance only that she faces fear and pushes through it on a mission to share her self with those who love her…and that is equally as beautiful as the dark and haunting lyrics of Breathe. Great reaction.
This perfromace was shared by audiance memebrs with their recorders versions months ago and the first time I saw this perfroamce I Wept lol the only other song that had me with such emotions was Johny Cash version of Hurt. I saw them last week for the first time in Brooklyn as I became a fan a month ago and they are soooo much better live .
Great song, a beautiful and at the same time very, very sad moment. Brought tears to my eyes. I really didn't expect that and I wasn't ready for that. Thank you for the reaction. 🌹 Feel hugged.
These young ladies are just incredible... I am a 68 year old Rock and Roll Fanatic. I am so proud to know them, support them, and enjoy the art they create. It is such a pleasure to see that this fame and and talent hasn't corrupted these three women. A loud shoutout to mom and dad , and the rest of their team for guiding and protecting Dany, Pau, and Ale. You all have done well!! I have laughed hysterically watching their Vlogs, and interviews. I have been made stronger by their lyrics. I have cried, teared up, and been torn apart by The Warning. They are so "Goosebump Worthy" as well. I love them as I love my own adult kids. Thank you The Warning for these 11+ years of the pleasure of your music. I am and will always be a fan till my last breath. 😍🤩☺
💔 Thanks for your insightful comments. Don't know what other platforms this was on, but her Instagram post is still there, where she says "nothing more humbling than crying in front of 8,000 people - thank you for singing with me through the tears 🫶🏼🥹".
I feel very fortunate 1) to have been in the room to hear this performance, and 2) to have a copy of the lyrics to this song hand-written by Pau. Like many others, this song has had a big impact on my. More than just about any in the last 25 years. Feels like a panic/anxiety attack in a song. "Is it so wrong, wrong to want to be alright" is indeed the line that got me. Simple. Illustrative. Impactful.
The Warning are advocates for mental health. Pau's writing is from the heart whether it's from personal experience such as this song or an incident that she or the girls have been privy too. She is a bundle of emotions that she often seems to wear on her sleeve. Just lovely and human.
Rachel, this is probably my favorite reaction of yours to date. You “get it”. Pau is a treasure, and I really hope the 3 of them get all the flowers they so richly deserve. Thanks for sharing your heart. Keep doing this, you never know who you’re touching with your words.
This song is personal to Pau and no matter what you hear, no one really knows what it is about or why Pau wrote it. I don't think she will ever play this again live for a long time if at all. It is one of those magical moments that you will never see again, so enjoy this video. You can tell the emotion qand apin in this song and if you do not have a tear by the end of the song something is wrong. It is so sad to see Pau, one of the best and fiercest drummers tear up at the end.
Pau is a genius, so she struggles like a genius. Anxiety, depression, how do you say "incomprendido". We feel that we don't belong, we don't fit, the "majority rejection". The world said they "love artist, love genius for what they receive from them" that's a f* lie, the world is a hell for us.
The Warning just deleted Breathe video from all their social media. I'm really puzzled to be honest. Probably Pau didn't feel right about the video being published and asked to remove it. I don't think it was a mistake since it was pulled out from all their platforms, not only from TH-cam. I hope Pau allows it to be re-uploaded because it's a gorgeous song and touching performance.
Pau is my favorite cuz she's always putting EVERYTHING into her peformance and always connects with the fans from the heart. I wanna be like her when I grow up.
Hola amiga. Paulina incluyó "Breathe" en el bonus track del tercer álbum llamado "Error". En su momento dijo que no la iba a interpretar en vivo porque era una canción muy personal y muy sentida para ella. Cuando The Warning presentó su álbum "Error" en el Teatro Metropolitan de Ciudad de México en el 2022, se escuchó la pista de la canción "Breathe" en el interludio del concierto. Paulina en ese momento se negó a interpretar la canción en vivo. Finalmente, en octubre del 2023, en el concierto del Pepsi Center, creo que Paulina encontró la oportunidad ante 8 mil personas de exorcizar la canción y de alguna manera sacar la pesada carga emocional que llevaba dentro de sí. Saludos desde la Patagonia Argentina. The Warning nos une.
Nice Reaction! To think in about 2 1/2 weeks, The Warning will be in Vancouver to play 9 shows in Canada opening for Halestorm and Evanescence. Maybe Pau and Amy will hit it off and maybe try writing a few songs together after their tours?
Pau did have to fight through this one, but that's the beauty of it being probably the only time we will see this track performed live. Not just emotionally either, but that's part of her strength. I've always felt that she tries to drop too low out of her range. She is natural and in her stride in mid to mid highs. There's a lot of noticeable effort and a drop in power when she goes low. That said, this is probably the best live performance that we have been privileged to get from Pau to date.
As of right now, Breathe is no longer viewable. I’m not sure why but, I’m just glad I got to listen and see the video. I hope it gets put back up. Such an incredible performance. I love Pau.
@@GreatOutdoors1 I haven't heard anything from any of them regarding why it was taken down. Who knows. I hope they put it back up. I honestly think it's one of the most moving and powerful performances I've ever seen. It's even gone for people on Patreon. Which makes me wonder if Pau had a change of heart. (Understandable considering...)
@@TylerLL2112 If it was done on Pau's behalf I wouldn't blame her, it is her creation and that concert was her moment with the fans. I hope it is a technical issue or maybe they want to add a hardcoded translation of the Spanish at the start of the song.
She said "No! I need to sing this well" Meaning she got surprised when the crowd started singing with her and she wanted to cry, that's why she said "I need to sing this well".
PAULINA PAULINA PAULINA... What a feeling it must be to hear 8000 people chant your name. The crowd showed her their love, and she used her soul as a mirror, to reflect it right back. That voice... The bug running roughshod through her body that night didn't stand a chance.
*Breathe* a deeply felt panic/anxiety attack set to music... when Pau plays *Breathe* i can't because i'm 😿😿😿 idk how she gained possession of my soul in addition to my heart... i think we all know that when looking at a keyboard, any keyboard, through tear filled eyes, it is impossible to see the keys properly... (that's why this is a pre-written comment in a text file 😉) 🧅🥷🧅🥷🧅🥷 TWA ⚡🤘😸🤘⚡ TWA
Exorscism of pain over a difficult loss is excruciating. It looks like she let go of some major weight baggage with that performance! Vulnerability is special. Pau is an emotive empath, a rare bird. That was incredible.
8000 fans finish the song for her out of love what a magical moment great performance especially after doing Black Holes. This was stunning thanks Rachel great reaction. 🔥⚡
I think, more importantly, all those people showed Pau that _she_ was not alone. And when she started to break down, the audience were very glad to sing the ending for her, showing they love and support her, and appreciate that she went above and beyond singing a song she said she'd never sing live. And while she is well known to cry at the drop of a hat over the silliest of things, _this_ was vastly more heartfelt than most of the time, and we all feel it. A truly impressive and honest performance that we may never see again.
Reading the lyrics, I thought it is about someone drowning. Possibly a suicide. But you also may be right, especially about the refrain which could be a separate narrator (more or less Pau).
When the audience knows the lyrics to a song that is not their native language, that is not regularly performed at your shows, and wants to join in, to be part of what you are doing, you know you are doing a lot of things right.
Goddess factor 11. My oldest has written songs to keep his sanity since he was a teen and there are many that he has just filed away and not shared with anyone because the pain is too deep.
That is one of the most beautiful moments I've ever seen from an artist who had written a song about a loss that was deep and personal and then sing it to fans; Because of her appreciation of the Love the fans have given in support of their success, Pau wanted to give something back and was willing to give it in the most vulnerable way....That's a total trust in the fans. Thank you Pau! How the fans there responded was phenomenal. The Villareal sisters Rock! 🤘
I'm sure that's only temporary, Money was also taken to private (Patreon access), they're probably just fixing or adjusting some things, perhaps official subtitles for Breathe.
Protect these girls at all cost
A very precious family....all of them. Simply stunning and incredible what these girls are doing. 😥😥
These.
Amen.
This was Pau choosing to unload a burden she had been carrying for some time. No one knows just what she was hefting, but she obviously felt the time was right to let it go…..with people who care for her all around. I am so glad she was able to lighten her load and move on. This song is one of my favorites that she has written. 🤘🏻🥹🤘🏻
Yes, mine too. Another one of her songs that doesn't get much attention at all is Escape The Mind. She performed it live at Liceo de Monterrey show for their classmates. Those girls were singing with her there too!
Very sweet reaction. Vulnerable Pau just tears your heart up. She's incredible. You have to go to one of their shows, if you haven't already. They are just on another level.
A lot of people will tell you this is about her dealing with the loss of a friend. I believe it is about Pau' dealing with anxiety and panic attacks. So, your analysis is probably right on target. Having had panic attacks driven by anxiety in the past, the lyrics accurately describe the smothering (drowning) feelings.
Pau said it was about her panic attacks ,
But, the true is, nobody else really knows the true meaning, but, Pau.
@@hardknox1917 I believe Pau has described this song as “a panic attack set to music”.
@@NM-tr6kq That has been brought up many times but I can't find a single person who can show the source of that quote. It also wouldn't mean that the song was about panic attacks, it could mean that it felt like a panic attack dealing with it and writing the song.
I thought it was written from the perspective of a friend who was suicidal, similar to the way in which Black Holes was written from the perspective of a distant relative struggling with addiction.
Unforgettable performance
Pau bled on stage for us…she was in pain and chose this time when she knew all the TW fans would catch her when she fell…
First of all, thank YOU for your own vulnerability as evoked by Pau's performance. What really struck deeply for me was, once the crowd realized Pau was struggling to continue, they added their voices to help her along. The audience got it. Inside - are too many times for far too many of us - we feel like we are all alone with no support, so that, in Pau's song lyrics, we just disappear. The audience was assuring her she was NOT alone. They were with her and they understood. Pau ends by saying "I love you all." Then, despite having the flu and only able to perform because the doctor administered steroids to allow the performance to go on, she went back to her kit to play the next song on the set list: Enter Sandman. What a brave, strong, self-aware tower of strength Pau is.
How can you not love Pau. Such a sweet soul
“As an artist…” So true. We put pieces of ourselves into every creation. Dany, Ale, and Pau do this with everything they create and they’ve said this over and over. “We can create something, put it out in the world, and people react to it.” - Pau. Can you imagine putting a song like Breathe out there, with every vulnerability exposed, and the first time you share it live the crowd knows every word and sings it back to you? In English! This was Mexico City. I don’t know how she even made it through the performance only that she faces fear and pushes through it on a mission to share her self with those who love her…and that is equally as beautiful as the dark and haunting lyrics of Breathe. Great reaction.
This perfromace was shared by audiance memebrs with their recorders versions months ago and the first time I saw this perfroamce I Wept lol the only other song that had me with such emotions was Johny Cash version of Hurt. I saw them last week for the first time in Brooklyn as I became a fan a month ago and they are soooo much better live .
Great song and preformance. Must have been a Great show for those who where there and this might be the only time she does this song live.
Then Pau's sweet smile just makes it even more emotional. SIGH
The Warning has made it onto my list of favorites.
Great song, a beautiful and at the same time very, very sad moment. Brought tears to my eyes. I really didn't expect that and I wasn't ready for that.
Thank you for the reaction. 🌹 Feel hugged.
These young ladies are just incredible... I am a 68 year old Rock and Roll Fanatic. I am so proud to know them, support them, and enjoy the art they create. It is such a pleasure to see that this fame and and talent hasn't corrupted these three women. A loud shoutout to mom and dad , and the rest of their team for guiding and protecting Dany, Pau, and Ale. You all have done well!! I have laughed hysterically watching their Vlogs, and interviews. I have been made stronger by their lyrics. I have cried, teared up, and been torn apart by The Warning. They are so "Goosebump Worthy" as well. I love them as I love my own adult kids. Thank you The Warning for these 11+ years of the pleasure of your music. I am and will always be a fan till my last breath. 😍🤩☺
Ahem brother ❤
💔 Thanks for your insightful comments.
Don't know what other platforms this was on, but her Instagram post is still there, where she says "nothing more humbling than crying in front of 8,000 people - thank you for singing with me through the tears 🫶🏼🥹".
Such a brave and honest performance! Thanks for your reaction. 👍
Absolutely wonderful live performance!!
Paulina is a treasure for all humanity!
Viva The Warning!! ⚡⚡⚡
I feel very fortunate 1) to have been in the room to hear this performance, and 2) to have a copy of the lyrics to this song hand-written by Pau.
Like many others, this song has had a big impact on my. More than just about any in the last 25 years. Feels like a panic/anxiety attack in a song. "Is it so wrong, wrong to want to be alright" is indeed the line that got me. Simple. Illustrative. Impactful.
Pau is truly something special.
This one broke me...the amount of raw emotion on full display here is insane...just so powerful.
gets me every time 😭😭
57 yrs old male here and crying for the 20th time watching Pau pouring her amazing heart out 😍😍
nice reaction 👍👍
She has touched my soul every time...😢❤
The Warning are advocates for mental health. Pau's writing is from the heart whether it's from personal experience such as this song or an incident that she or the girls have been privy too. She is a bundle of emotions that she often seems to wear on her sleeve. Just lovely and human.
Rachel, this is probably my favorite reaction of yours to date. You “get it”. Pau is a treasure, and I really hope the 3 of them get all the flowers they so richly deserve. Thanks for sharing your heart. Keep doing this, you never know who you’re touching with your words.
Gotta do Black Holes next if you want more Pau
It should have been Black holes and Breathe together in the same video, has more impact.
FYI she didn't tell the crowd to not sing as a joke, but because she knew that if the crowd sang along, she would have immediately lost it.
Don't read to much into it, it was a joke
@@brunokingz Considering how emotional she was during the song I believe it was not a joke.
She is special. Scary that she is going to get even better. Thank you for the reaction.
This song is personal to Pau and no matter what you hear, no one really knows what it is about or why Pau wrote it. I don't think she will ever play this again live for a long time if at all. It is one of those magical moments that you will never see again, so enjoy this video. You can tell the emotion qand apin in this song and if you do not have a tear by the end of the song something is wrong. It is so sad to see Pau, one of the best and fiercest drummers tear up at the end.
Pau once again making grown men cry! Amazing performance!
Pau + piano = 😪
I'm not crying, you are crying!😭
Love the glasses, better to wipe the tears... Doogie
Pau is a genius, so she struggles like a genius. Anxiety, depression, how do you say "incomprendido". We feel that we don't belong, we don't fit, the "majority rejection". The world said they "love artist, love genius for what they receive from them" that's a f* lie, the world is a hell for us.
incomprendido = misunderstood
I love your honest reactions,girl...❤
⚠️ ⚡ 💖 ⚡ ⚠️
I wont cry. I wont cry I my god iam criying 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
Resistance is futile
The Warning just deleted Breathe video from all their social media. I'm really puzzled to be honest.
Probably Pau didn't feel right about the video being published and asked to remove it. I don't think it was a mistake since it was pulled out from all their platforms, not only from TH-cam.
I hope Pau allows it to be re-uploaded because it's a gorgeous song and touching performance.
It is back on their page.
@@GreatOutdoors1 Yes, it is. Just saw it once again. I didn't notice any change. It's back, that's what really matters.
...ya...brings tears evrytime 2 this badASS...losing a brother 2 suicide n not understanding it.......... emotional song...kudos 2 Pau...
Pau is my favorite cuz she's always putting EVERYTHING into her peformance and always connects with the fans from the heart. I wanna be like her when I grow up.
wow
Tears. Every. Time.
🤘
🫶
Fucking HATE the ''twitch'' BullShit, but I guess it's the only way we'll get reactions now...................sigh
Hola amiga.
Paulina incluyó "Breathe" en el bonus track del tercer álbum llamado "Error".
En su momento dijo que no la iba a interpretar en vivo porque era una canción muy personal y muy sentida para ella.
Cuando The Warning presentó su álbum "Error" en el Teatro Metropolitan de Ciudad de México en el 2022, se escuchó la pista de la canción "Breathe" en el interludio del concierto. Paulina en ese momento se negó a interpretar la canción en vivo.
Finalmente, en octubre del 2023, en el concierto del Pepsi Center, creo que Paulina encontró la oportunidad ante 8 mil personas de exorcizar la canción y de alguna manera sacar la pesada carga emocional que llevaba dentro de sí.
Saludos desde la Patagonia Argentina.
The Warning nos une.
Take that A.I.!!!!
React avenged sevenfold so far away rock @m ring 2014 pls
Nice Reaction! To think in about 2 1/2 weeks, The Warning will be in Vancouver to play 9 shows in Canada opening for Halestorm and Evanescence. Maybe Pau and Amy will hit it off and maybe try writing a few songs together after their tours?
Pau did have to fight through this one, but that's the beauty of it being probably the only time we will see this track performed live. Not just emotionally either, but that's part of her strength. I've always felt that she tries to drop too low out of her range. She is natural and in her stride in mid to mid highs. There's a lot of noticeable effort and a drop in power when she goes low. That said, this is probably the best live performance that we have been privileged to get from Pau to date.
You must have got in just under the wire. Breathe is set to private on their channel now.
Glad you did this reaction-BREATHE has been taken down from The Warning’s channel…
It's on Reddit now
It is back on their page.
As of right now, Breathe is no longer viewable. I’m not sure why but, I’m just glad I got to listen and see the video. I hope it gets put back up. Such an incredible performance. I love Pau.
I noticed that and have posted on multiple reactors videos to see if anyone knows why they took it down.
@@GreatOutdoors1 I haven't heard anything from any of them regarding why it was taken down. Who knows. I hope they put it back up. I honestly think it's one of the most moving and powerful performances I've ever seen. It's even gone for people on Patreon. Which makes me wonder if Pau had a change of heart. (Understandable considering...)
@@TylerLL2112 If it was done on Pau's behalf I wouldn't blame her, it is her creation and that concert was her moment with the fans. I hope it is a technical issue or maybe they want to add a hardcoded translation of the Spanish at the start of the song.
It looks like it is back on their page.
@@GreatOutdoors1 It is!!! I'm glad to see that. Take care!
Yes, I love Pau darker voice!
She said "No! I need to sing this well" Meaning she got surprised when the crowd started singing with her and she wanted to cry, that's why she said "I need to sing this well".
🤘🤘🤘🔥🔥🔥
❤🩹🖤❤🩹🤘
Is it so wrong, so wrong to feel alright? So many ask that question, every day. Thank you for the beautiful reaction.
Great that Paulina felt comfortable enough to share this in public.Gotta love Pau!!Great reaction!!
PAULINA PAULINA PAULINA... What a feeling it must be to hear 8000 people chant your name. The crowd showed her their love, and she used her soul as a mirror, to reflect it right back. That voice... The bug running roughshod through her body that night didn't stand a chance.
*Breathe*
a deeply felt panic/anxiety attack set to music...
when Pau plays *Breathe* i can't because i'm 😿😿😿
idk how she gained possession of my soul in addition to my heart...
i think we all know that when looking at a keyboard, any keyboard, through tear filled eyes, it is impossible to see the keys properly... (that's why this is a pre-written comment in a text file 😉)
🧅🥷🧅🥷🧅🥷
TWA ⚡🤘😸🤘⚡ TWA
Exorscism of pain over a difficult loss is excruciating. It looks like she let go of some major weight baggage with that performance! Vulnerability is special. Pau is an emotive empath, a rare bird. That was incredible.
8000 fans finish the song for her out of love what a magical moment great performance especially after doing Black Holes. This was stunning thanks Rachel great reaction. 🔥⚡
I think, more importantly, all those people showed Pau that _she_ was not alone. And when she started to break down, the audience were very glad to sing the ending for her, showing they love and support her, and appreciate that she went above and beyond singing a song she said she'd never sing live. And while she is well known to cry at the drop of a hat over the silliest of things, _this_ was vastly more heartfelt than most of the time, and we all feel it. A truly impressive and honest performance that we may never see again.
Reading the lyrics, I thought it is about someone drowning. Possibly a suicide. But you also may be right, especially about the refrain which could be a separate narrator (more or less Pau).
Slash ft Myles Kennedy n the Conspirator "Anastasia"❤
Beautiful song by a beautiful soul. Pau is not from this world!
(HUGS) to you as well.
It is an amazing song, and a heartfelt performance.
When the audience knows the lyrics to a song that is not their native language, that is not regularly performed at your shows, and wants to join in, to be part of what you are doing, you know you are doing a lot of things right.
Wonderland Indonesia by Alfy Reff❤
thank you for giving Pau the props, i think its bad azz that you do that on the platform you're on ❤
Goddess factor 11. My oldest has written songs to keep his sanity since he was a teen and there are many that he has just filed away and not shared with anyone because the pain is too deep.
She send some kisses to somebody at the end, I wondering who? her sisters? her family. I want see some behind the scenes or something.
This original video is gone !!!?? 😢 they removed it! ☹️
It is back now.
@@GreatOutdoors1 is it?
@@SBC1113 I just checked, and yes it is.
Can you react to Villain of the Story - Losing Control ?
Can you react on Editors - No Sound but the Wind?
Do avenged sevenfold againnnnn
Pau is a beautiful soul ❤
pau! dany! ale! ❤🤘🏼🔥
I love Pau
That is one of the most beautiful moments I've ever seen from an artist who had written a song about a loss that was deep and personal and then sing it to fans; Because of her appreciation of the Love the fans have given in support of their success, Pau wanted to give something back and was willing to give it in the most vulnerable way....That's a total trust in the fans. Thank you Pau! How the fans there responded was phenomenal. The Villareal sisters Rock! 🤘
It is not known what the song is about. Pau said that it is a panic attack set to music.
❤️⚡😭
🤘
You're lucky to have done this review... the original video has been taken offline, sadly.
If anyone has the video, please upload it somewhere and give us the link
I didn't know it was taken down until your comment. When did they remove it?
I'm sure that's only temporary, Money was also taken to private (Patreon access), they're probably just fixing or adjusting some things, perhaps official subtitles for Breathe.
@@FrankyPiI really hope so. It'd be so sad if people could not experience such a beautiful song and rendition anymore.
@@mexicanopolis9390 It would also be weird when they drop the full concert video that those two are missing lol
Great reaction😊 You should definitely chech out "From dusk till dawn"- Baby metal Budokan 2021😊
Day 12 of asking for Unknown soldier by breaking Benjamin
No llores hermosa, yo te amo❤️😘