A lot of people only care about views and awards these days but this songs is BEAUTIFUL. VIEWS DOESNT MATTER, I hope CNBlue knows how much we appreciate them coming back!!
I really miss those times when I like Kpop whatever they are from, i listen almost all of them because I like them, those played in replay, still now, like memories.. i dont know about now.. this CNBLUE song finally awaken those memories huhu
@@flowersandpeach i think its more of streaming because we genuinely like the song, not because of awards and views. Cause creating a lot of accounts, just for views is not the way to do it cause its not authentic, its pathetic.
Nowadays is all about competition. And I just realize that when I'm being Treasure fans. Actually I just want to enjoy their music but suddenly my competition spirit got rise because of views. I know it's funny. I don't get it why. I miss my 2nd gen of Kpop, when we can appreciate and respect with each other music and artists more than now. Suju, bigbang, snsd, 2ne1, 4minutes, beast, ft island, cnblue, 2am, 2pm, wonder girls, ah ...I miss them.
CN Blue: Then, Now, Forever FT Island: Quit N.Flying: Stand By Me Those three songs are telling about members leaving the group implicitly. Those three songs make me feel sad and happy at the same time. Tears are falling but there is something refreshing in my heart and mind. At the end of the day, people come and go, but we can still have slightly good memories of them.
Aah made me cry that the inspiration for Yonghwa to write Then, Now and Forever was cause of those Fans who left and came back. Aah I’m guilty of this cause i did laylow and almost lost track of them but then I found my way back when I keep seeing him on my ig. Gladly i came back and will be here now and forever.
Every BOICE has their own stories how we fall in love with CNBLUE, from being single now married, from employed now a mother of boicelette, as I promised no matter what happen I will continue to support my forever CNBLUE, my only kpop band, I will never say goodbye, then, now and forever, congrats CNBLUE, congrats BOICE,
처음 외톨이야로 데뷔했을 때 초등학생이었던 내가 벌써 20살이 됐다,, 갑자기 보게 된 외톨이야 무대가 첫사랑에 빠진 듯한 기분을 들게 했다. 그때부터 지금까지 씨엔블루를 사랑하고 있는 나는 미래에도 영원히 사랑할거란 확신이 든다. 고마워요 내 빛나던 10대 시절에 함께 빛나줘서. 그리구 앞으로도 영원히 빛날거에요 잊지 않을거에요.
"A song that honestly describes the complex feelings of a person left behind living a daily life in the absence of a person who left" Tears are falling but nothing to regret. People come and go but the memories will remained. Yh Js Mh are sad. Boice are sad. But wrong is still wrong, no matter who you are. We should stop dwelling on the past and start moving forward.. TOGETHER! We're 'Then, Now and Forever'. Thank you for holding on! You've work hard! 씨엔블루 사랑합니다!!!!
You have said what i wanna said.... i feel really sad for the "one" i feel there is empty space around them... but yeaahh.. we must move on... its hard indeed but we must go trough... 😭
lyrics. 오늘 날씨 맑음 오후에는 먹구름 내 마음은 계속 비가 내릴 예정 친구들아 미안해 오늘도 난 빠질게 너희 맘은 아는데 시간 조금만 줄래 계속 맘이 쓰릴 예정 하루의 시작과 끝에 이젠 이별의 끈에 서로 묶여 있어 엉켜 있어 매듭처럼 말이야 어떤 날은 괜찮고 어떤 날은 미치도록 그리워 어떤 날은 또 정말 미워 언젠가는 이러다가 말겠지 잊혀지긴 하겠지 어떤 날은 다 무뎌지겠지 우린 과거 현재 미래에 있어 차마 버리지는 못할 너와 손가락 걸고 했던 약속 혼자서라도 지킬 예정 쉽게 헤어진 이별 어려운 문제를 주고 전혀 알 수 없게 날 시험해 바보처럼 말이야 어떤 날은 괜찮고 어떤 날은 미치도록 그리워 어떤 날은 또 정말 미워 언젠가는 이러다가 말겠지 잊혀지긴 하겠지 어떤 날은 다 무뎌지겠지 우린 과거 현재 미래에 있어 추억이 또 뚝뚝뚝 여전히 Nobody Nobody but you I can’t say Goodbye Baby You You 어떤 날은 괜찮고 어떤 날은 미치도록 그리워 어떤 날은 또 정말 미워 이젠 우리 행복했으면 좋겠다 그러면 참 좋겠다 보통날이 날 찾아오겠지 우린 과거 현재 미래에 있어 우린 과거 현재 미래에 있어
Goosebumps Yonghwa ssi... Brings back a lot of memorable moments. You won't understand us 'old fans' Still present even all these years. Re-code mini album is very Special to us. Not about fame, number of views, BUT for those fans who choose to STaY supporting re-make of CNBLUE Yonghwa, MinHyuk & JungShin. Then, Now and Forever.
I love Yong Hwa and CNBlue since 2019 and 2010 respectively . I have been watching how they faced with many difficulties and struggled hardly. Especially in the first two years, Yong Hwa ran around different variety shows, practised songs and created own songs every day. He could only sleep for one or two hours a day, but he never complained, and always smiled warmly, shared joy and sorrow with the members. He gradually led CNBlue step to the world. They have broken many records, received numerous awards and recognitions. Every time I attend their concerts, it is supreme enjoyment! In the past four years, Yong Hwa has faced many difficulties and suffered a lot of injuries and solved many problems by himself. He cried in front of us for the last concert in Hong Kong before he enlisted in the army. I cried with him and promised to meet each other again. I wait because it is worthy! I am very grateful to Yong Hwa for fulfilling his promise. I understood that it is a very difficult decision for you and CNBlue to renew contract with FNC and return to the music world under the name of CNBlue. I will support all your decisions. I have never left, no matter what happens, the past, present and future, I will always be with all of you as a strong backing. 🙌🏻🙌🏻👍👍👏🏻👏🏻💙❤️💙❤️😍😍
I understand why people say that views aren't important, but nearly it's been a year since after released and views are roughly the same as end of the first month :/ Doesn't this masterpiece deserve at least 10 million?
It’s hard nowadays to compete views. BOICE or CNBLUE long time fans are 10 years older now. Busy with their own life, works, family or kids. And some of them probably have a change of heart which I did not blame them cause it’s their choice. Me too sometimes late in realizing they release album. If go to any reaction videos, please do ask them to watch for CNBLUE. I do go and dm on their SNS or youtube sometimes but probably not many ask for it so they skip to react for this marvelous band. Reaction video do helps other people to learn who is the best band in 2nd generation that achieved so many awards. Even Love Cut are hardly reaching 1m in a month now.
5 years later...things have changed but no one can deny that CNBLUE still makes the best music...we have these three back and for good.. they are shinning 🥺 this song is so good...as someone who have waited for them to comeback...it stil feels surreal that they are actually back...!!!!! welcome back CNBLUE 💙
This is a song that can be conveyed only by a band that have gone through so much in 10 years. What a deep and wrenching feeling. I love you CNBLUE. We’ll see better days in the future
what happened to them? (i mean aside from their friend leaving the group after some scandal) :/ and did they part on bad terms ? sorry i don't know much details but i'm curious to know more
@@wafamokni5492 the scandal was pretty big, and as a group that had been together for 10yrs, him leaving the group bcz of the scandal and not because they are in bad terms is much worst in my opinion.
이분들 노래 진짜 좋아했었는데… 크면서 자연스럽게 잊었었다… 틱톡 구경하다가 외톨이야 듣고 진짜 눈물이 찔끔 나왔네요 초딩때 막 부르면서 친구들이랑 딱지 치고 했던 시절 생각나고 오랜만에 기억나서 찾아보니까 컴백했다 그래서 너무 좋네요 그건 그렇고 왜 11년 전이나 외모가 달라진게 없죠??? ㄷ ㄷ
Wow, truly a masterpiece. 10 years later and CNBLUE is still producing quality music. I am not surprised considering Jung Yong Hwa basically = quality assurance.
CNBLUE has opened weverse, Yong Hwa has responded to fans' messages for three consecutive days. He said that he has a strong mind and will continue to make music.
i can't help but cry. being a fan for a long time, losing a member and have to accept it is not as easy as said. "sometimes I'm fine, sometimes I miss it madly, sometimes I want to forget it." really hits me hard. "we're here then, now and forever" really reassured me that everything will be fine and that cnblue will always be cnblue. really happy and proud of our cnblue
Jungshin said comeback should be end of October so hope everyone is ready for new music from CNBLUE. MV is already filmed getting excited for the comeback.
It's not debut it a true re-code in a true meaning, what a meaningful song they are so deligent and smart "coming back" with such a song... Welcome back CNBlue...👏👏👏👍👍👍
CNBLUE were the one who brought me into kmusic 8yrs ago, it feels so nostalgic to be hearing again to their new songs but now for just 3 members. Maybe some goodbyes means new beginning, past is past and the future will be just made, we don't know the future but still hopeful for good things. Cheers to us boice for always supporting CN BLUE no matter what happen.
Who's with crying upon hearing the song? Hit like if you did. This song is telling us how they felt in the past year. It's so meaningful that it hurts yet make me happy.
I was trying to pay attention to the lyrics and couldn't help but feel they were about JH and moving past that situation and moving forward as CNBLUE. I only cried when I saw Yonghwa standing in his spot.... It really solidifies that he's gone. No I don't condone what he did, but I will miss the CNBLUE that was. :/
CNBLUE doesn't need to dance!!!! Jung Yong Hwa and Lee Jung Shin's Guitar and Kang Min Hyuk's drum is enough!!!! To create such a wonderful piece. A legendary group indeed!!! It's been a decade since I started stan this group. And it feels nostalgic!! BOICE: We're always here for you!! Then, Now and Forever!!
Oh, I totally agree. Love watching them play musical instruments and it's amazing to see what they can create. Maybe that's why I'm more partial towards bands.
“I can’t say goodbye” -CNBLUE . Mee tooo can’t say goodbye to youuu my first love since 2011.. YongHwa oppa Then, Now and Forever CNBLUE Always in My Heart i’m sooo pround of yoouu. This song mean soo much for BOICE and CNBLUE and this song is soooo great nice beautiful can’t help my tears keep falling.. Fighting YongHwa oppa, MinHyukkie and JungShinnie we’ll always support you -BOICE Indonesia .
I know BTS is super popular right now and they are cool...but....I still love CN Blue... for some reason CN Blue music touches my heart at like a deeper level ❤️
CNBLUE my first band, my first babies, I know we have been through a lot but together we'll overcome all of this, I'm thankful for all those memories we had together and yet even if it hurts we know better days will come and we can't turn a blind eye on him. I'm proud to be a Boice and I'm so happy you took your time to release new music, we are healing together and I'll always love you. Thank you CNBLUE for everything.
Yonghwa is a genius songwriter. He always exceeds our expectations. This one deserves recognition. The song is soul-piercing. It reaches the bottom of our hearts and be able to penetrate the very deep recesses of our hearts. CNBLUE never fails to deliver a masterpiece.
Welcome to the rabbit hole. ^^. Watch CNBLUE live concerts on TH-cam for a completely different side to Yong Hwa (and his musical talent), Between Us and Puzzle would be a great start. Enjoy!
OMG. same here.. I am so in love with their music and can't get enough of CN BLUE.. I just finished WGM with Seohyun and now binge watching their concerts..
Same here. However mine was his 2009 series You're Beautiful, then found out he is a singer and not just any singer but a real musician. 11yrs later, and I'm still fangirling over him.:)
CNBLUE has opened weverse, Yong Hwa has responded to fans' messages for three consecutive days. He said that he has a strong mind and will continue to make music.
They pour the unspoken words into this song and it hits different. Seeing just 3 of them, it must be hard. Then, Now and Forever CNBLUE Read the description guys :( "The title track ‘Then, Now and Forever’ is a song that honestly describes the complex feelings of a person left behind living a daily life in the absence of a person who has left. CNBLUE's emotional melody and alternative rock arrangements have increased the level of perfection, like the various rock songs it has shown so far''
CNBLUE has opened weverse, Yong Hwa has responded to fans' messages for three consecutive days. He said that he has a strong mind and will continue to make music.
Been stanning them for years but I would say this is the best song they've ever released! You did well Yonghwa! You did well Minhyuk! You did well Jungshin! We did well Boice for waiting them for almost 4 years and still being here, loving and supporting them!
While listening to this song, I remember not only the hardships they surpassed for 10 years, but also the memories I have as a fan for 10 years. I remember my memories with my co-Boices. Laughing with them, having fan gatherings, kiddie parties for their birthdays, falling in line to buy concert tickets. I just feel so sad and comforted at the same time because they kept their promise that they'll stick with us until they become a grandpa band. Thank you my co-Boices who never turned their backs. Thank you Yonghwa for your sacrifices as a leader, thank you CNBLUE for being with us. Your presence is enough to let us feel that we are not alone. 너무 고맙고 사랑합니다 💙 다죽자! #보이스영원히 #씨엔블루오래가자
People don't understand how influential music is in life. Good people, make good music. Even with the language barrier Cnblue brings people together and helps people get in touch with their own feelings. In times we are currently living we need this. We need to go back to being humans. Blessings to all.
I am so overwhelmed reading all the comments. Didn't knew how many people/fans/Boice feel the same way, that I do. I am really, really happy, that we have CNBlue and CNBlue has us.
@@graces1878 i would love that! I want cnblue back in my life. Also the other old idols and groups! Most of them are done with their military service - i hope that most of them will continue their music career. :) like shinee, bigbang, ftisland, suju and more
Hi dear. Could you kindly edit the comment to remove the emoji? According to yt guideline the number of views will be frozen/decreased when emoji is used. Thanks !
This is such a meaningful song for us Boice and Cnblue, after literally losing a part us, here we are standing strong for each other! We really can never say goodbye. Then, now and forever CNBLUE.
Don't care about winning awards, sales etc. Shout our y'all cnblue is far beyond greater than imagination. They are truly musicians, that's why their music surrounds our soul with a warm hug. Their musical characteristics and art never disappoint!
Back here again.... CNBLUE's Then Now and Forever is like a healing piece for me. Now, waiting for the next masterpiece from Yonghwa, Minhyuk and Jungshin.
This Song is so great but Still so sad. Shows Yong hwa and his sadness as a leader. How hard was to take the decision of going on just the three of them with all heavy feelings they went through. But The promise was an everlasting CNBLUE and that choise was the only way to keep it and protect the band and the rest of the members
@@blueslsl I think is more for minhyuk and jungshin...how yong hwa felt because it was his dutty as a leader to stand for them but, at that time all happened pretty quick, he wasn't out of the army. He must felt really sad and endured it all alone, he couldn't give any explanation until he got out. And it was like one day everything around them just fell apart
CNBLUE never disappoint us with their music. This song is so beautiful and heartbreaking. You can feel the emotion in Yonghwa's voice, along with the beautiful melody.
*The title track ‘Then, Now and Forever’ is a song that honestly describes the complex feelings of a person left behind living a daily life in the absence of a person who has left* Hits me hard. I have watched the MV over and over again but just read the description now. Here you will realize how they are trying to bounce back after all that they have been through. Stay Strong and Rocking My Boys! We will always be with you 💕
The lyrics hits me so hard. I dont know why i cry over this song. Whatever happened boice will keep support and love cnblue. I feel like they tryna say something to the boice, i think i know what it means but i can't accept my thought! I still feel so sad right now. I hope this comeback will be successful. Everyone who read this let's keep support them till the end 💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙
I agree with you. This song is for us. They needed time to move on after what happened. CnBlue will still be CNBlue even with three members. They are here because they deserve it! Let's just be there for them
I’ve read a lot of comment that audiences of Sell Your Haunted House came here to listen to Yonghwa’s and CNBlue’ songs. For viewers who haven’t known Yonghwa or CNBlue before, I recommend watching their live performance, both CNBlue’s concerts and Yonghwa’s solo concerts. Then you guys might become a BOICE since then. Please don’t just watch the MVs.
I don't why my tears fall down while hearing this song. Then, now and forever I will be one of Boices in the world. CNBLUE will never be forgotten. (Thanks for the likes)
I know how you deeply want to express your support to our favorite band, please edit your comment and remove the emoji coz yt standard will not count the views. Thank you so much. Let's continue to cheer CNBlue.
Am I the only one who noticed that every stuff that is broken in this MV is color BLUE? There might be no meaning on it but I just realized that maybe it is CNBLUE itself. We all know that every letter on BLUE describes every member, but knowing that there's only 3 members left makes the CodeNameBLUE broken also. AND THAT'S REALLY REALLY SAD. I'm legit crying. 😭 But I'm happy that CNBLUE is back after years of waiting. You never break your promise to us, Boice! 💙
Because one messed up doesn’t mean all of the other members are same like him so please educate yourself about putting the dislike button. They worked hard for this not for a ex member to pull them down.
This song is so emotional. The lyrics, the vibes. I'm crying..literally crying. Remember all the stories and memories with CNBLUE. I love you guys. I will always support you. But still...I can't hide my feelings now.
@@Sandra-um2qnLee JongHyun got canned cause he got wrapped up in the Burning Sun Scandal.....I miss him! His role in the scandal wasn't even close to what the other guys did...
Just like Big Bang, these guys got nothing to prove anymore. They've reached the heights others can only dream of. Awards, sensational music, you name it. Now, its just good seeing them continue making music for themselves, and for everyone else especially their fans... Its quite heart-warming really to see them again.. After everything that has happened, they're still here with us. *bring back the long hair Jung-shin*
I’m literally crying right now. I miss them so much and the song’s somehow sad yet beautiful and nostalgic :( I also hope we’ll become happier. CNBLUE FIGHTING!!!
The feels is a bit different than what I'm used to, probably because this one sounds so sad. I still love it! Honestly, CNBLUE does not disappoint when it comes to their music. I think I understand where they are coming from in this song. So glad that they still decided to make new music. I missed you so much! I'll always support you!
we talk don't talk about k-bands as much as we should, and even when we do cnblue isn't always brought up. but I really did grow up on their albums. their music just heals me. I hope they know they will always have an audience.
CNBLUE has opened weverse, Yong Hwa has responded to fans' messages for three consecutive days. He said that he has a strong mind and will continue to make music.
![[MV] CNBLUE(씨엔블루) _ Between Us(헷갈리게)](/img/n.gif)
"I can't say goodbye"
"There will be better days for you"
"We're here then, now and forever"
These words feels so warm!!!
please delete the emoji
@@sariniabdlatif9072 thanks for the info!! I almost forgot :))))))
@@kristinnevizcarra540 ppp
I feel bad for those people who didn't know cnblue
I just came to know them😭
They missing a diamond
No worries, these guys are popular in korea
Sell your haunted house brought me here
@@racjae8137 same
CNBLUE 💙
What is he doing here? :0
Where is jonghyun
@@candacenuts5791 don't wait him...!
Tan bellos 😭🤧
정용화가 노래에 있어서는 진짜 솔직한 듯. 있는 그대로 다 말해주네. 지금쯤은 다 아물었겠지...
A lot of people only care about views and awards these days but this songs is BEAUTIFUL. VIEWS DOESNT MATTER, I hope CNBlue knows how much we appreciate them coming back!!
I really miss those times when I like Kpop whatever they are from, i listen almost all of them because I like them, those played in replay, still now, like memories.. i dont know about now.. this CNBLUE song finally awaken those memories huhu
So true!! It's always the views nowadays. Miss the old way..
I love your comment 💙💙💙
@@flowersandpeach i think its more of streaming because we genuinely like the song, not because of awards and views. Cause creating a lot of accounts, just for views is not the way to do it cause its not authentic, its pathetic.
Nowadays is all about competition.
And I just realize that when I'm being Treasure fans. Actually I just want to enjoy their music but suddenly my competition spirit got rise because of views. I know it's funny. I don't get it why.
I miss my 2nd gen of Kpop, when we can appreciate and respect with each other music and artists more than now.
Suju, bigbang, snsd, 2ne1, 4minutes, beast, ft island, cnblue, 2am, 2pm, wonder girls, ah ...I miss them.
띵곡인데 ㅠㅠ 더 많은 사람들한테 알려져야한다
heres another album
th-cam.com/video/Hx4fG2Y4TWk/w-d-xo.html
💙💙
Please listen to the Japanese album Let it shine th-cam.com/video/b0qMefc2RdY/w-d-xo.html
CN Blue: Then, Now, Forever
FT Island: Quit
N.Flying: Stand By Me
Those three songs are telling about members leaving the group implicitly.
Those three songs make me feel sad and happy at the same time.
Tears are falling but there is something refreshing in my heart and mind.
At the end of the day, people come and go, but we can still have slightly good memories of them.
Would as well add "Letting Go'' by DAY6 😢
🤧🤧😭😭😭
Now I just remember that these three songs were sung / released after they all lost a member 😭
I desperate want a song like this for AOA.. 😭😭😭
@@MatchaLatte520 yes 🤧🤧🤧😭😭😭😭
Aah made me cry that the inspiration for Yonghwa to write Then, Now and Forever was cause of those Fans who left and came back. Aah I’m guilty of this cause i did laylow and almost lost track of them but then I found my way back when I keep seeing him on my ig. Gladly i came back and will be here now and forever.
No matter what, CNBlue is still CNBlue
No one can replace .
어떻게.. 매일 지날수록 노래가 좋아질까. 이번 노래 내 최애곡이 될 듯.
Yonghwa, Jungshin and Minhyuk worked hard on this album. Let's support them all the way
Yes 💗💗💗
I wish them to get comeback of theirs 4-th guy and be happy all together
Came after Suga's show. This song is a masterpiece
I think you will also like "note to self" from Yong-Hwa's new album do check it out!
Every BOICE has their own stories how we fall in love with CNBLUE, from being single now married, from employed now a mother of boicelette, as I promised no matter what happen I will continue to support my forever CNBLUE, my only kpop band, I will never say goodbye, then, now and forever, congrats CNBLUE, congrats BOICE,
Thats so sweet... :) Let's continue supporting them to infinity and beyond!
Boice always miss CNBLUE
Hey same here. 😁
Let’s continue supporting cnblue till forever
Yes!! BOICE THEN, NOW AND FOREVER!!
처음 외톨이야로 데뷔했을 때 초등학생이었던 내가 벌써 20살이 됐다,, 갑자기 보게 된 외톨이야 무대가 첫사랑에 빠진 듯한 기분을 들게 했다. 그때부터 지금까지 씨엔블루를 사랑하고 있는 나는 미래에도 영원히 사랑할거란 확신이 든다. 고마워요
내 빛나던 10대 시절에 함께 빛나줘서.
그리구 앞으로도 영원히 빛날거에요 잊지 않을거에요.
나랑 비슷한친구가 여기잇구만
CNBLUE will be in our hearts
Then
Now and
FOREVER
Jung yong hwa...perfect.
"A song that honestly describes the complex feelings of a person left behind living a daily life in the absence of a person who left" Tears are falling but nothing to regret. People come and go but the memories will remained. Yh Js Mh are sad. Boice are sad. But wrong is still wrong, no matter who you are. We should stop dwelling on the past and start moving forward.. TOGETHER! We're 'Then, Now and Forever'. Thank you for holding on! You've work hard! 씨엔블루 사랑합니다!!!!
Beautifully said
Support the king of blue rock CNBLUE 🖐🖐👀
in in kim ỉm ko mà là mà
You have said what i wanna said.... i feel really sad for the "one" i feel there is empty space around them... but yeaahh.. we must move on... its hard indeed but we must go trough... 😭
lyrics.
오늘 날씨 맑음
오후에는 먹구름
내 마음은
계속 비가 내릴 예정
친구들아 미안해
오늘도 난 빠질게
너희 맘은 아는데
시간 조금만 줄래
계속 맘이 쓰릴 예정
하루의 시작과 끝에
이젠 이별의 끈에
서로 묶여 있어 엉켜 있어
매듭처럼 말이야
어떤 날은 괜찮고
어떤 날은 미치도록 그리워
어떤 날은 또 정말 미워
언젠가는 이러다가 말겠지
잊혀지긴 하겠지
어떤 날은 다 무뎌지겠지
우린 과거 현재 미래에 있어
차마 버리지는 못할
너와 손가락 걸고 했던 약속
혼자서라도 지킬 예정
쉽게 헤어진 이별
어려운 문제를 주고
전혀 알 수 없게 날 시험해
바보처럼 말이야
어떤 날은 괜찮고
어떤 날은 미치도록 그리워
어떤 날은 또 정말 미워
언젠가는 이러다가 말겠지
잊혀지긴 하겠지
어떤 날은 다 무뎌지겠지
우린 과거 현재 미래에 있어
추억이 또 뚝뚝뚝
여전히 Nobody Nobody but you
I can’t say Goodbye
Baby You You
어떤 날은 괜찮고
어떤 날은 미치도록 그리워
어떤 날은 또 정말 미워
이젠 우리 행복했으면 좋겠다
그러면 참 좋겠다
보통날이 날 찾아오겠지
우린 과거 현재 미래에 있어
우린 과거 현재 미래에 있어
정말 노래 좋은데 모두가 이 노래 알았으면 좋겠다😭❤️❤️❤️
2pm 준호 영상에도 댓글 안달던 내가 용화에 빠져, 노래에 더 빠져 댓까지 달고 있다 ㅠ 노래가 너무 좋아ㅠㅠ
Goosebumps Yonghwa ssi... Brings back a lot of memorable moments. You won't understand us 'old fans' Still present even all these years. Re-code mini album is very Special to us. Not about fame, number of views, BUT for those fans who choose to STaY supporting re-make of CNBLUE Yonghwa, MinHyuk & JungShin. Then, Now and Forever.
Exactly! As what they promise before, they will stay together forever. 🥺
I'm a new BOICE here to support them. My very first comeback with them
@@nomonwndrr yeah. Yonghwa himself assured us that they will be more mature comeback and appear as new ones, putting their dark side aside
This ❤️
@@aleezahaleem1114 welcome to the family 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
I love Yong Hwa and CNBlue since 2019 and 2010 respectively . I have been watching how they faced with many difficulties and struggled hardly. Especially in the first two years, Yong Hwa ran around different variety shows, practised songs and created own songs every day. He could only sleep for one or two hours a day, but he never complained, and always smiled warmly, shared joy and sorrow with the members. He gradually led CNBlue step to the world. They have broken many records, received numerous awards and recognitions. Every time I attend their concerts, it is supreme enjoyment!
In the past four years, Yong Hwa has faced many difficulties and suffered a lot of injuries and solved many problems by himself. He cried in front of us for the last concert in Hong Kong before he enlisted in the army. I cried with him and promised to meet each other again. I wait because it is worthy! I am very grateful to Yong Hwa for fulfilling his promise. I understood that it is a very difficult decision for you and CNBlue to renew contract with FNC and return to the music world under the name of CNBlue. I will support all your decisions. I have never left, no matter what happens, the past, present and future, I will always be with all of you as a strong backing. 🙌🏻🙌🏻👍👍👏🏻👏🏻💙❤️💙❤️😍😍
Support the king of blue rock CNBLUE 🖐🖐👀
This
Well said.
this song is criminally underrated
I understand why people say that views aren't important, but nearly it's been a year since after released and views are roughly the same as end of the first month :/ Doesn't this masterpiece deserve at least 10 million?
cnblue is back!!! new album released #wanted #lovecut
Yeah they deserve that's stream because they need us now for the award
yeah they deserve a lot
It’s hard nowadays to compete views. BOICE or CNBLUE long time fans are 10 years older now. Busy with their own life, works, family or kids. And some of them probably have a change of heart which I did not blame them cause it’s their choice. Me too sometimes late in realizing they release album. If go to any reaction videos, please do ask them to watch for CNBLUE. I do go and dm on their SNS or youtube sometimes but probably not many ask for it so they skip to react for this marvelous band. Reaction video do helps other people to learn who is the best band in 2nd generation that achieved so many awards. Even Love Cut are hardly reaching 1m in a month now.
It hits differently, they are only three now. Then, now and forever... Still with CN BLUE
Yes exactly were here them now and forever the cnblue even though there's only tree I am happy to see cnblue is back saranghe cnblue finghting ❤❤❤❤❤
where is jonghyun?
@@MelDharmawan he left
Support the king of blue rock CNBLUE 🖐🖐👀
@@juvyjosol7508 âjwj
better days will come, let's stay together then, now, and forever
노래 진짜 핵좋음,,,,,,,,,,,오늘 출근길 내내 들으면서 왔네 진짜,,,,,,,,
한때 미친듯이 반복해서 들었었는데... 나의 이별송. 고마워 이런 노래 만들어줘서.
5 years later...things have changed but no one can deny that CNBLUE still makes the best music...we have these three back and for good.. they are shinning 🥺 this song is so good...as someone who have waited for them to comeback...it stil feels surreal that they are actually back...!!!!! welcome back CNBLUE 💙
This is a song that can be conveyed only by a band that have gone through so much in 10 years. What a deep and wrenching feeling. I love you CNBLUE. We’ll see better days in the future
Absplutely agree
yesss better days 🙏🏻♥️
I agree.
what happened to them? (i mean aside from their friend leaving the group after some scandal) :/ and did they part on bad terms ? sorry i don't know much details but i'm curious to know more
@@wafamokni5492 the scandal was pretty big, and as a group that had been together for 10yrs, him leaving the group bcz of the scandal and not because they are in bad terms is much worst in my opinion.
와...이걸 이제야 봐버렸네...아니ㅠㅜㅜ 요즘 씨엔블루 완전체 보고싶었는데ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 진짜ㅠㅠㅠ 씨엔블루 노래 들으면 뭔가 옛날 생각 나면서 뭉클해지는 느낌이라 좋은데ㅜㅠㅜ
이거 계속 들으러 올께요ㅠ 너무 좋아요ㅠㅠㅠ
이분들 노래 진짜 좋아했었는데… 크면서 자연스럽게 잊었었다… 틱톡 구경하다가 외톨이야 듣고 진짜 눈물이 찔끔 나왔네요 초딩때 막 부르면서 친구들이랑 딱지 치고 했던 시절 생각나고 오랜만에 기억나서 찾아보니까 컴백했다 그래서 너무 좋네요
그건 그렇고 왜 11년 전이나 외모가 달라진게 없죠??? ㄷ ㄷ
After almost 4 years, we're finally here. Bittersweet but we'll carry on. We always have your back, CNBLUE. Welcome back!
Wow, truly a masterpiece. 10 years later and CNBLUE is still producing quality music. I am not surprised considering Jung Yong Hwa basically = quality assurance.
KMH AND LJS !!!
CNBLUE has opened weverse,
Yong Hwa has responded to fans' messages for three consecutive days. He said that he has a strong mind and will continue to make music.
Cnblue cameback with sad songs for couple of times, but this one hits me on another level.
어떤 종류의 이별이든 어떤 날은 괜찮고 어떤 날은 미치도록 그리운 것 같다 이 노래 명곡인 줄은 알았지만 오랜만에 들으니까 또 새삼 명곡이라고 느끼는 중입니다 가사도 곡도 멤버까지도 완벽..!
i can't help but cry. being a fan for a long time, losing a member and have to accept it is not as easy as said.
"sometimes I'm fine,
sometimes I miss it madly,
sometimes I want to forget it."
really hits me hard.
"we're here then, now and forever"
really reassured me that everything will be fine and that cnblue will always be cnblue.
really happy and proud of our cnblue
😭😭😭😭Same thoughts
Jungshin changed so much after military.. I find him a leading role material in a drama. His eyes speaks a lot..
Ikr!?
Yes, there's just something about Jungshin, even before his military service. He's always been my other favourite.
As a guy who grew up watching cnblue, its hard to get used to only 3 members but i will always support them
yes. i'm used to that smile and how goofy they're together... it's okay...
been miss their voice n sound..tq for coming back
we got used to his soulful voice
Jungshin said comeback should be end of October so hope everyone is ready for new music from CNBLUE. MV is already filmed getting excited for the comeback.
Wow ! This song is a masterpiece. Who else here is a stan since their debuts ?
It's not debut it a true re-code in a true meaning, what a meaningful song they are so deligent and smart "coming back" with such a song... Welcome back CNBlue...👏👏👏👍👍👍
CNBLUE were the one who brought me into kmusic 8yrs ago, it feels so nostalgic to be hearing again to their new songs but now for just 3 members. Maybe some goodbyes means new beginning, past is past and the future will be just made, we don't know the future but still hopeful for good things. Cheers to us boice for always supporting CN BLUE no matter what happen.
진짜 목소리 보물이야.,.이렇게 좋은음악 들고나와줘서 너무 고맙고 사랑해ㅜㅜ
앞으로 할아버지 밴드될때까지 씨엔블루하자~
듣자마자 그냥 무한반복
그냥 모두 안아주고 싶어지네요
너무 그 마음을 알 것 같은데.....
용화님 진짜 마음을 글로 표현하는게 너무 진정성이 느껴져요. 존경하고 사랑합니다.
Who's with crying upon hearing the song? Hit like if you did.
This song is telling us how they felt in the past year. It's so meaningful that it hurts yet make me happy.
I was trying to pay attention to the lyrics and couldn't help but feel they were about JH and moving past that situation and moving forward as CNBLUE. I only cried when I saw Yonghwa standing in his spot.... It really solidifies that he's gone. No I don't condone what he did, but I will miss the CNBLUE that was. :/
CNBLUE is definition of "Men age like fine wine". Their visual and their talents always make me suprise, as time goes by.
CNBLUE doesn't need to dance!!!! Jung Yong Hwa and Lee Jung Shin's Guitar and Kang Min Hyuk's drum is enough!!!! To create such a wonderful piece. A legendary group indeed!!! It's been a decade since I started stan this group. And it feels nostalgic!!
BOICE: We're always here for you!! Then, Now and Forever!!
Support the king of blue rock CNBLUE 🖐🖐👀
👏👏👏💙💙💙
But Jungshin play the bass, dosn´t he? However, I think just enough this three for play beautiful music
@@ariali2204 Yesss it's a bass guitar. Sorry if I didn't specify it. HAHAHAHHA
Oh, I totally agree. Love watching them play musical instruments and it's amazing to see what they can create. Maybe that's why I'm more partial towards bands.
we're then, now, and forever...
“I can’t say goodbye” -CNBLUE .
Mee tooo can’t say goodbye to youuu my first love since 2011..
YongHwa oppa Then, Now and Forever CNBLUE Always in My Heart i’m sooo pround of yoouu. This song mean soo much for BOICE and CNBLUE and this song is soooo great nice beautiful can’t help my tears keep falling.. Fighting YongHwa oppa, MinHyukkie and JungShinnie we’ll always support you -BOICE Indonesia .
Yonghwa: "I can't say goodbye"
Me: NEITHER DO I T-T
They are soooooo totally worth the wait. Fighting!
I know BTS is super popular right now and they are cool...but....I still love CN Blue... for some reason CN Blue music touches my heart at like a deeper level ❤️
🥰
I totally agree with you! 💖
And nobody can’t stop you know
Actually this song is better then any other world known K-Pop song
I agree with u ...Cnblue only kband tjat i really like it...Best composer ,singer ,etc.
We're here then, now and forever
"We're here then, now and forever"
Yesss me to!! Yess Boice always support CNBLUE !!! Thanks for comeback, i'm really happy for you all!!
CNBLUE my first band, my first babies, I know we have been through a lot but together we'll overcome all of this, I'm thankful for all those memories we had together and yet even if it hurts we know better days will come and we can't turn a blind eye on him. I'm proud to be a Boice and I'm so happy you took your time to release new music, we are healing together and I'll always love you. Thank you CNBLUE for everything.
Yonghwa is a genius songwriter. He always exceeds our expectations. This one deserves recognition. The song is soul-piercing. It reaches the bottom of our hearts and be able to penetrate the very deep recesses of our hearts. CNBLUE never fails to deliver a masterpiece.
I was watching "Sell Your Haunted House," and I found Jung Yong Hwa and found out that he is a singer and now I'm obsessed with his songs-
Welcome to the rabbit hole. ^^. Watch CNBLUE live concerts on TH-cam for a completely different side to Yong Hwa (and his musical talent), Between Us and Puzzle would be a great start. Enjoy!
OMG. same here.. I am so in love with their music and can't get enough of CN BLUE.. I just finished WGM with Seohyun and now binge watching their concerts..
Same here. However mine was his 2009 series You're Beautiful, then found out he is a singer and not just any singer but a real musician. 11yrs later, and I'm still fangirling over him.:)
I am too 9 years ago. Like I'm so obsessed to Heartstrings, eventually got curious about Yong Hwa. and Boom, I am a Boice for almost 10 years now.
CNBLUE has opened weverse,
Yong Hwa has responded to fans' messages for three consecutive days. He said that he has a strong mind and will continue to make music.
Tell me, I'm not the only one who's crying. My Boice heart is overflowing with Joyfulness.
You're not the only one..
overflowing with Joyfulness
Let's k33p str3aming,until it reach 1M in 24hrs.💙💙💙
Same here. Same here.
Im crying too! So emotional
Never fade cnblue, then now & forever.
They pour the unspoken words into this song and it hits different. Seeing just 3 of them, it must be hard. Then, Now and Forever CNBLUE
Read the description guys :(
"The title track ‘Then, Now and Forever’ is a song that honestly describes the complex feelings of a person left behind living a daily life in the absence of a person who has left. CNBLUE's emotional melody and alternative rock arrangements have increased the level of perfection, like the various rock songs it has shown so far''
CNBLUE has opened weverse, Yong Hwa has responded to fans' messages for three consecutive days. He said that he has a strong mind and will continue to make music.
Fighting for MAMA
This line "we're here then now and forever" made me cry. This song is a masterpiece. So much emotion 😭
I will always support you. Fighting!
Been stanning them for years but I would say this is the best song they've ever released! You did well Yonghwa! You did well Minhyuk! You did well Jungshin! We did well Boice for waiting them for almost 4 years and still being here, loving and supporting them!
I wish them to get comeback of theirs 4-th guy. And be happy all together
why am I crying reading the lyrics, the meaning is very deep. lets be together forever
I like real musicians like these guys, they're awesome.
In 2010-2013 everyday i listening many songs of CNBLUE, and now i grow up and i'm crying to know that they're still not disbanded. I love u guys
We are on the same area.
IKR! 🥺 they have gone through so much through the years
They are not disband but only 3 of them is left, 1 of them is gone 😏
@@toto4834 i did'nt say they're disbanded
와 30대인데도 목소리 진짜 소년 같다 몽글하달까
While listening to this song, I remember not only the hardships they surpassed for 10 years, but also the memories I have as a fan for 10 years. I remember my memories with my co-Boices. Laughing with them, having fan gatherings, kiddie parties for their birthdays, falling in line to buy concert tickets. I just feel so sad and comforted at the same time because they kept their promise that they'll stick with us until they become a grandpa band.
Thank you my co-Boices who never turned their backs. Thank you Yonghwa for your sacrifices as a leader, thank you CNBLUE for being with us. Your presence is enough to let us feel that we are not alone.
너무 고맙고 사랑합니다 💙
다죽자!
#보이스영원히
#씨엔블루오래가자
CNBLUE still *wanted* by everyone *then,now and forever*
This song just made me cry. But I'm still replaying it. Proud to be a Boice.
me too，already more 10times
Me too
Proud here BOICE since 2010
Me too 💙
I got so emotional too, cnblue really touch my heart
People don't understand how influential music is in life. Good people, make good music. Even with the language barrier Cnblue brings people together and helps people get in touch with their own feelings. In times we are currently living we need this.
We need to go back to being humans. Blessings to all.
I am so overwhelmed reading all the comments. Didn't knew how many people/fans/Boice feel the same way, that I do. I am really, really happy, that we have CNBlue and CNBlue has us.
Mee tooo, i think Not many people know cnblue now, but i think truely fans still know them and support them
I am not BOICE, but I always adored CN Blue ever since their debut :)
I am so happy that many old kpop group are having comeback these days
❤❤
@@graces1878 i would love that! I want cnblue back in my life. Also the other old idols and groups! Most of them are done with their military service - i hope that most of them will continue their music career. :) like shinee, bigbang, ftisland, suju and more
Hi dear. Could you kindly edit the comment to remove the emoji? According to yt guideline the number of views will be frozen/decreased when emoji is used. Thanks !
We're here then, now and forever 💙
이번 앨범은 그 어느때보다 많은 생각과 감동을 느끼게 만드는 노래들인거같음. 이전보다 훨씬 깊고 짙어진 감성이 울컥하게 만드네
This is such a meaningful song for us Boice and Cnblue, after literally losing a part us, here we are standing strong for each other!
We really can never say goodbye.
Then, now and forever CNBLUE.
Don't care about winning awards, sales etc. Shout our y'all cnblue is far beyond greater than imagination. They are truly musicians, that's why their music surrounds our soul with a warm hug. Their musical characteristics and art never disappoint!
Yes, absolutely right!!
Yesssss
Back here again.... CNBLUE's Then Now and Forever is like a healing piece for me. Now, waiting for the next masterpiece from Yonghwa, Minhyuk and Jungshin.
과거에 겪었던 어려움을 잘 이겨내서 지금과 같은 성공적인 현재가 있는거고..! 이러한 현재를 뜨겁게 살아가면서 노력하다 보면 씨엔블루가 예상했던 미래의 모습보다 더 멋진 시대가 열릴거에요!! 항상 응원하겠습니다:-) 돌아와줘서 고마워요 정말..
P
) Pl lop momongan Lloyd %o0
ELF here supporting CNBLUE and Boice, they are finally back and with such a masterpiece.. Fighting :D
Yes 2GEN stan here
thank you
Me too!!! Baby ELF is supporting CNBLUE 💙💙💙💙💙💙💙
Thank u
Thank you💙💙💙
This Song is so great but Still so sad. Shows Yong hwa and his sadness as a leader. How hard was to take the decision of going on just the three of them with all heavy feelings they went through. But The promise was an everlasting CNBLUE and that choise was the only way to keep it and protect the band and the rest of the members
วันละ
I think, this song is for Jong Hyun ):
@@blueslsl I think is more for minhyuk and jungshin...how yong hwa felt because it was his dutty as a leader to stand for them but, at that time all happened pretty quick, he wasn't out of the army. He must felt really sad and endured it all alone, he couldn't give any explanation until he got out. And it was like one day everything around them just fell apart
i miss them on the stage🙁
CNBLUE never disappoint us with their music. This song is so beautiful and heartbreaking. You can feel the emotion in Yonghwa's voice, along with the beautiful melody.
Kpop was so dry without CNBLUE
*The title track ‘Then, Now and Forever’ is a song that honestly describes the complex feelings of a person left behind living a daily life in the absence of a person who has left*
Hits me hard.
I have watched the MV over and over again but just read the description now. Here you will realize how they are trying to bounce back after all that they have been through.
Stay Strong and Rocking My Boys!
We will always be with you 💕
처음 들을 때보다 들으면 들을수록 더 좋아지고 깊이감 있는 노래
The lyrics hits me so hard. I dont know why i cry over this song. Whatever happened boice will keep support and love cnblue. I feel like they tryna say something to the boice, i think i know what it means but i can't accept my thought! I still feel so sad right now. I hope this comeback will be successful. Everyone who read this let's keep support them till the end 💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙
I agree with you. This song is for us. They needed time to move on after what happened. CnBlue will still be CNBlue even with three members. They are here because they deserve it! Let's just be there for them
@@joleya0710 Yesss, lets support this king!! :)
mmrd
How can a song be this sad and comforting at the same time? :(
I’ve read a lot of comment that audiences of Sell Your Haunted House came here to listen to Yonghwa’s and CNBlue’ songs. For viewers who haven’t known Yonghwa or CNBlue before, I recommend watching their live performance, both CNBlue’s concerts and Yonghwa’s solo concerts. Then you guys might become a BOICE since then. Please don’t just watch the MVs.
"I can't say goodbye" that hurts a little every time
I don't why my tears fall down while hearing this song.
Then, now and forever I will be one of Boices in the world. CNBLUE will never be forgotten.
(Thanks for the likes)
Absolutely not to be forgotten. Will forever love them.
I know how you deeply want to express your support to our favorite band, please edit your comment and remove the emoji coz yt standard will not count the views. Thank you so much. Let's continue to cheer CNBlue.
Support the king of blue rock CNBLUE ⭕🖐🖐👀
@@chuchubiaroha8823 Thanks
Who's crying :"""( freaking love the song!
Am I the only one who noticed that every stuff that is broken in this MV is color BLUE? There might be no meaning on it but I just realized that maybe it is CNBLUE itself. We all know that every letter on BLUE describes every member, but knowing that there's only 3 members left makes the CodeNameBLUE broken also. AND THAT'S REALLY REALLY SAD. I'm legit crying. 😭
But I'm happy that CNBLUE is back after years of waiting. You never break your promise to us, Boice! 💙
same think
Really sad when know the meaning of the song
same here
씨엔블루의 노래는 언제나 깊은 울림이 있어
Because one messed up doesn’t mean all of the other members are same like him so please educate yourself about putting the dislike button. They worked hard for this not for a ex member to pull them down.
A1akks$owo
That's right
Yeah, i sad look the dislike :( how's dare them give our boys dislike -_-
Yeah(*´﹀`*)
Support the king of blue rock CNBLUE ⭕🖐🖐👀
This song is so emotional. The lyrics, the vibes. I'm crying..literally crying. Remember all the stories and memories with CNBLUE. I love you guys. I will always support you. But still...I can't hide my feelings now.
It’s already a month. And I’m still here everyday. CNBLUE fighting! Yonghwa fighting! Jungshin fighting! Minhyuk fighting!
Na dul
There was another one tooo where is he??
@@Sandra-um2qnLee JongHyun got canned cause he got wrapped up in the Burning Sun Scandal.....I miss him! His role in the scandal wasn't even close to what the other guys did...
@@JPWChannel2-j3w He wasn´t involved in burning sun scandal, he got involved on JJY sex scandal and his participation wasn´t forgivable either.
Nope, according to police he Is not involved in JJY scandal, he can be a witness himself.... Missed him💓💓💓
Just like Big Bang, these guys got nothing to prove anymore. They've reached the heights others can only dream of. Awards, sensational music, you name it.
Now, its just good seeing them continue making music for themselves, and for everyone else especially their fans... Its quite heart-warming really to see them again..
After everything that has happened, they're still here with us.
*bring back the long hair Jung-shin*
Well said👏🏼🔥🤙🏼
Ikr😭😭😭
I miss the long hair Jungshin too💙💙💙💙🥺
I’m literally crying right now. I miss them so much and the song’s somehow sad yet beautiful and nostalgic :( I also hope we’ll become happier. CNBLUE FIGHTING!!!
The feels is a bit different than what I'm used to, probably because this one sounds so sad. I still love it! Honestly, CNBLUE does not disappoint when it comes to their music. I think I understand where they are coming from in this song. So glad that they still decided to make new music. I missed you so much! I'll always support you!
Support the king of blue rock CNBLUE 🖐🖐👀
we talk don't talk about k-bands as much as we should, and even when we do cnblue isn't always brought up. but I really did grow up on their albums. their music just heals me. I hope they know they will always have an audience.
Yes
CNBLUE has opened weverse,
Yong Hwa has responded to fans' messages for three consecutive days. He said that he has a strong mind and will continue to make music.
now then and forever BOICE.. CNBLUE forever.. i miss the old days..