Thanks for watching! Here's a link to the short video on Euler and the Self-Buckling Problem on Nebula - nebula.tv/videos/the-efficient-engineer-euler-and-the-selfbuckling-problem!
@@TheEfficientEngineer Thank you for your comment and taking the time. You're right that E indicates material stiffness, not strength. However, in column buckling, E is crucial for determining buckling load, albeit not directly indicating the material's strength. While it doesn't predict strength beyond its elastic limit, E is essential for understanding material behavior up to that point. Thank you so much for the Video it is very insightful and thank you for the promotion as well really Fantastic work.
Honestly, I feel very grateful to be able to see this videos. I just want to remind you that, whenever you feel down, please remind yourself that you helped thousands of students understand the physics behind the theoretical stuff! You are awesome!
I wouldn’t have understood a lot of engineering subjects as i do without your videos. Keep doing what you do brother. We appreciate every single effort spent. ❤️.
Just look at Timoshenko's "Theory of elastic stability"...This video, while very good, does not bring anything new and everything is covered in any half-decent engineering course.
@@les8489 its not about bringing anything new or just memorising formulas or knowing how to derive them, its about bringing out the beauty of it and making it conceptual and easy to understand. This channel does that for us.
Agree. By watching this video one does not gain any knowledge related to the subject. To understand it you have to review course in Theory of Elasticity. Timoshenko is good, but N.Muskhelishvili book offers much rigorous approach.
As a civil engineer, I've been looking for a really in-depth engineering channel on TH-cam for many years, but have always been disappointed until now. It seems I've finally found something reputable. Thank you very much and greetings from Germany!
This is pure gold - 15 minutes, free and with way more digestable information that during part of the course of Mechanics of Solids nearly a decade ago, for which I unfortunately paid a fortune!
there are people in this world who are meant to be the best. whoever makes these videos is one of the greatest teachers i have ever know and yet english is my second language
You are the only person who is saving me from the difficulty of understanding any topics regarding Mechanical Subject. I want to connect with this channel throughout my life.
I love your videos, thank you! It's so much more understandable than the theory in my books. My favorite thing about watching your channel is understanding the "whys" and the context of the formulas + the visual examples of what the formula means! Your videos are amazing!
This channel deserves more......... Sensational efforts from the creators...... Thank you guys, for making this knowledge available to everyone for free ❤️
I wish I had access to this kind explanation and education during my college days. As a structural engineer, you explained it on a level that even a student will find it understandable and how those formulas were derived from. Thanks so much.
Thank you YT for recommending me this channel. Thank you TEE for your great work. Haven't seen a subject like this presented in a way like yours before and I really enjoyed it. Plus, I'm not only refreshing my knowledge, it also calms me down. Great work.
Another great video, thanks so much. As a practicing engineer it's always interesting to go back to fundamentals and the history of how the design and analysis techniques developed. A particularly pleasant surprise was seeing the offshore pipeline lateral buckling example in this video as that's the field I work in and didn't expect it to see it illustrated to beautifully. I'm very impressed with the attention to detail with the animation of the mode 3 buckle shape and the formation of the soil berm at the buckle crown.
Brilliant tutorial......very much appreciated you for easy to understand.This tutorial is better explain than a college classroom lecture......! lots of love from JADAVPUR UNIVERSITY.
I keep being amazed by how simple and pleasant you make your videos to watch and learn from. I literally aced my first technical interview for my first mechanical design position thanks to your videos.
In less than 15 minutes you provide more insight than my professors did across several two hour lectures. The education system needs a complete overhaul. Universities need to purchase lessons like this from creators such as yourself and Real Engineering.
Great video about buckling. Euler was a genius, buckling was a tinny amount of his work but with great effect. Been able to predict buckling failure can save work, money and mostly save lives. Sadly most scientist that mention Euler never mention his development of the buckling equation. In my career as a structural analyst I always dealt with buckling. A thin-walled open cross-section (11:34) beam, or column, can also fail at the flanges and at the center member. In aircraft structural analysis it is known as "crippling". Crippling can occur in longitudinal member between frames. Also another way that a slim member can fail in buckling is called "longitudinal buckling". It can be loaded in a concentrated moment at the ends or as a distributed load as in floor beam.
These videos helped me a lot in studying for the mechanical engineering board exam. Now i am a registered ME. To the creators behind this channel, GOD Bless you.
Literally just stumbled onto your channel. Halfway througg this 1st video...great presentation. Thank you for the refresher. Need to watch ALL the others!
Music playing in the background immerses me in engineering depth, it seems like an imagination of depth concept. U r the king of explanation and best tutor in the world.
Another video with superb quality, condensing in a very easy and understandable way a topic that can take an entire course of mechanic of mayerials to understand.
In Eurocode 3, EN 1993, there are classified into 4 categories according to buckling curve. In many cases, buckling and fatigue govern structural design rather than material yield strength. There is no better way to understand it than your video! Superb! I've got a lot of details on how to derive the buckling curves from their origin. Excellent video on engineering!
Great way of explaining various factors that influence buckling. Reminds me of my projects the buckling of the thin shell due to geometric imperfections
Your video series are highly informative and conceptual for civil Engineers . kindly start Engineering mechanics too . your knowledge and concepts are divine gift sir. ♥️Love and respect from Pakistan🙏
There's something interesting about learning where you need to hear a poor explanation many times before you understand, and a great one once. This is one of those channels with a great explanation, thank you so so much for these videos!!
You are an amazing creator. It is really Mind blowing how we live nowadays : Acessing such clear and well structured information for free. Thanks a lot!
Wow! Mind blowing! All this stuff I was unable to understand in college and suddenly it makes complete sense! Wonderful work. All architecture students much watch ur videos in college.
Concise and easy to follow. That's another quality video worth to watch. I especially love how you pronounce Euler the right way :-) Something that's probably not very intuitive: A pipe can even buckle when under tension while supporting a compressive load. We did experiments at the university showing that, but I kinda forgot the exact reason for it.
Wow wow wow super dooper amazing channel! What a channel for learning!!! Honestly the way you teach in a very simple way is mind blowing, what a conceptual you are!!! Highly admire your efforts and your teaching skills! You are the best tutor ever i have seen! I learned a lot from this channel. Thank you so much for sharing your high standard knowledge with us... Just keep going like this, honestly very soon your's channel will cross million subscribers! Your mad fan🤣🤣🤣 From Pakistan. Lots of love and respect🙏🙏🙏
Hello Efficient Engineer Team, You are doing great things in shaping the future of engineering student and consequently the future of engineers of the Nation. ❤️ 💜 Heartily Salute to you 💜❤️
A good teacher is worth his/her weight in gold. You exemplify this. Sadly at Uni, there are tons of bullshitters out there making a good living because even they do not understand the subject very well, let alone teach it. I have seen lots of them.
No way... I'm finishing my mechanics of materials FE review book, and the last topic is buckling. I must have said the word out loud because there was no way this video was going to get recommended to me. I never looked this topic up in school so I wasn't going to get this particular topic. I do watch a lot of your videos so to study for the FE exam. Man is the algorithm crazy... You day a word once...
Sir you are just awesome.. in jst one all the concept get clear.. thanks sir.. sir one request pls make more vedio on Mechanical engineering topic like Tom
Your videos are top-notch! I love your design approach to explaining Engineering with 3D Models and great graphical support. Your videos remind me of 3b1b ones, but you found your unique own way to animate and display these concepts! I would actually love to know how you're doing it, I'm a Mechatronics student and would love to be able to help myself sometimes by bringing these concepts to life
@@TheEfficientEngineer wow, this is Blender? I used to tinker with that when I was still very young 😂 Anyways, thanks for making these videos, they're a ton of help, looking forward to watching the next!
Just in time! Tomorrow i have the end test in “strength of material” course. for sure there will be question about buckling . Following you here and also in nebula, Watched all your videos and I really appreciate the work that you do to create them .👏🏻👏🏻 waiting for the next one already 🤞🏻 be safe 😷 Ori from Israel 🇮🇱.
So if I wanted to find the force needed to a crush an aluminium can for example against a fixed surface, would the Euler's formula presented at 3:06 be useful to find the buckling force? and using le as 2L in the formula
![[Live สด] การออกรางวัลสลากกินแบ่งรัฐบาล งวดวันที่ 16 ธันวาคม 2567](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dNTiBBthKgQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Thanks for watching! Here's a link to the short video on Euler and the Self-Buckling Problem on Nebula - nebula.tv/videos/the-efficient-engineer-euler-and-the-selfbuckling-problem!
You are saying “ Pcr doesn’t depend on the strength of the material at all” but it is a factor of E and E is the indicator of the material strength
E represents the stiffness of the material, it doesn’t tell you anything about the strength of the material.
@@TheEfficientEngineer Thank you for your comment and taking the time. You're right that E indicates material stiffness, not strength. However, in column buckling, E is crucial for determining buckling load, albeit not directly indicating the material's strength. While it doesn't predict strength beyond its elastic limit, E is essential for understanding material behavior up to that point. Thank you so much for the Video it is very insightful and thank you for the promotion as well really Fantastic work.
I'm in awe. You are the 3Blue1Brown of engineering!
That certainly sets the bar!
Perfectly pointed!
extremely true
SIMPLY YES
Indeed
Honestly, I feel very grateful to be able to see this videos. I just want to remind you that, whenever you feel down, please remind yourself that you helped thousands of students understand the physics behind the theoretical stuff! You are awesome!
I wouldn’t have understood a lot of engineering subjects as i do without your videos. Keep doing what you do brother. We appreciate every single effort spent. ❤️.
Just look at Timoshenko's "Theory of elastic stability"...This video, while very good, does not bring anything new and everything is covered in any half-decent engineering course.
@@les8489 its not about bringing anything new or just memorising formulas or knowing how to derive them, its about bringing out the beauty of it and making it conceptual and easy to understand. This channel does that for us.
me too, Thank you
Agree. By watching this video one does not gain any knowledge related to the subject. To understand it you have to review course in Theory of Elasticity. Timoshenko is good, but N.Muskhelishvili book offers much rigorous approach.
Agree, as a layperson, being able to engage in any engineering conversation because of this video has improved the conversation. Thank you.
As a civil engineer, I've been looking for a really in-depth engineering channel on TH-cam for many years, but have always been disappointed until now. It seems I've finally found something reputable. Thank you very much and greetings from Germany!
This is pure gold - 15 minutes, free and with way more digestable information that during part of the course of Mechanics of Solids nearly a decade ago, for which I unfortunately paid a fortune!
Isn't it so bittersweet?
@@anthonys5542 I am glad future has come - and I am also glad not to be a zoomer stuck at home, studying without partying. ;-)
@@Renvoxan :(
@@XxteardamagexX why sad? Forwards and upwards!
😂 it all depends on who is teaching the concept
there are people in this world who are meant to be the best. whoever makes these videos is one of the greatest teachers i have ever know and yet english is my second language
Your animations are billion times more EFFICIENT than college professor's lectures to make me THE EFFICIENT ENGINEER.
You must be rewarded with an unparalleled prize for creating this type of engineering videos .
I feel like I was born to benefit from these videos at the right time! I'm just about to cover this in class next month!
You are the only person who is saving me from the difficulty of understanding any topics regarding Mechanical Subject. I want to connect with this channel throughout my life.
I love your videos, thank you! It's so much more understandable than the theory in my books. My favorite thing about watching your channel is understanding the "whys" and the context of the formulas + the visual examples of what the formula means! Your videos are amazing!
This channel deserves more.........
Sensational efforts from the creators......
Thank you guys, for making this knowledge available to everyone for free ❤️
Please don't stop making such videos they are really helping us out .
I wish I had access to this kind explanation and education during my college days. As a structural engineer, you explained it on a level that even a student will find it understandable and how those formulas were derived from. Thanks so much.
Whoever is reading this comment, I wish you success, health, love and happiness
Thankyou mam😊
who needs health when you can have 12 cold ones and car keys
😊
Thank you😊
I don't
These type of videos are what we need during the online classes.
This channel does a better job to understand on a conceptual level than any class ive taken in 4 years of mech eng
Thank you YT for recommending me this channel.
Thank you TEE for your great work.
Haven't seen a subject like this presented in a way like yours before and I really enjoyed it.
Plus, I'm not only refreshing my knowledge, it also calms me down.
Great work.
This channel has gotten me so hype on engineering. What a beast
Yessss!
Another great video, thanks so much. As a practicing engineer it's always interesting to go back to fundamentals and the history of how the design and analysis techniques developed. A particularly pleasant surprise was seeing the offshore pipeline lateral buckling example in this video as that's the field I work in and didn't expect it to see it illustrated to beautifully. I'm very impressed with the attention to detail with the animation of the mode 3 buckle shape and the formation of the soil berm at the buckle crown.
Thanks Paul - glad someone spotted the berm!
Exactly, i always spot these minor details in this channel's videos. And these extra efforts really make a difference.
@@TheEfficientEngineer please can you give your email i want to offer you one deal and ask something?
always able to take concepts taught in class in which i always am lost in and clarify them so gracefully! hero
Brilliant tutorial......very much appreciated you for easy to understand.This tutorial is better explain than a college classroom lecture......!
lots of love from JADAVPUR UNIVERSITY.
I was looking on your channel for a buckling video a month ago, and now you have uploaded one! YOU ROCK SIR!
The scientific growth of a country is directly proportional to the subscription count of that country to this channel .
These types of videos deserve tons of appreciation!
I keep being amazed by how simple and pleasant you make your videos to watch and learn from.
I literally aced my first technical interview for my first mechanical design position thanks to your videos.
please donate if possible from ur first salary,he deserves our support
The amount of detail and effort in your videos is outstanding. Thank you for your inspiring work
I wish I had these videos as my engineering courses
So much more interesting and better explained than the books 😅
I learned more in 15 minutes than I did in two lectures, thank you!
What you explained in 16 minutes took my professor like 3 days. Thank you!!
In less than 15 minutes you provide more insight than my professors did across several two hour lectures. The education system needs a complete overhaul. Universities need to purchase lessons like this from creators such as yourself and Real Engineering.
I am so happy that you posted a video three days before an exam I have on this exact subject!
I've been watching these for a long time. Retired engineer that did little structural design.
These are great for this old timer
Great video about buckling. Euler was a genius, buckling was a tinny amount of his work but with great effect. Been able to predict buckling failure can save work, money and mostly save lives. Sadly most scientist that mention Euler never mention his development of the buckling equation.
In my career as a structural analyst I always dealt with buckling.
A thin-walled open cross-section (11:34) beam, or column, can also fail at the flanges and at the center member. In aircraft structural analysis it is known as "crippling". Crippling can occur in longitudinal member between frames.
Also another way that a slim member can fail in buckling is called "longitudinal buckling". It can be loaded in a concentrated moment at the ends or as a distributed load as in floor beam.
These videos helped me a lot in studying for the mechanical engineering board exam. Now i am a registered ME. To the creators behind this channel, GOD Bless you.
Cant find much words to explain, very descriptive, simplified, neat...... appreciate you!!!
Brilliant demonstration with top notch quality illustrations really nice work.
I can't believe this channel has only 380 000 subscribers
Literally just stumbled onto your channel. Halfway througg this 1st video...great presentation. Thank you for the refresher. Need to watch ALL the others!
Music playing in the background immerses me in engineering depth, it seems like an imagination of depth concept. U r the king of explanation and best tutor in the world.
Everytime I start to get frustrated by all the highly theoretical stuff like Tensors etc. , your Videos keep up my spirit.
Another video with superb quality, condensing in a very easy and understandable way a topic that can take an entire course of mechanic of mayerials to understand.
In Eurocode 3, EN 1993, there are classified into 4 categories according to buckling curve. In many cases, buckling and fatigue govern structural design rather than material yield strength. There is no better way to understand it than your video! Superb! I've got a lot of details on how to derive the buckling curves from their origin. Excellent video on engineering!
I wouldn't survive without your videos.
Thank you very much.. you are a hero. ❤
you make engineering easy,interesting and so pleasing to listen
Great way of explaining various factors that influence buckling. Reminds me of my projects the buckling of the thin shell due to geometric imperfections
Your video series are highly informative and conceptual for civil Engineers . kindly start Engineering mechanics too . your knowledge and concepts are divine gift sir.
♥️Love and respect from Pakistan🙏
Imma just say thank you for doing these videos with such high production quality
🎯 Key points for quick navigation:
00:01 *Compression causes buckling*
00:29 *Buckling is destabilization*
01:22 *Thermal expansion risks*
02:20 *Euler's formula introduced*
02:48 *Critical load parameters*
04:09 *Effective length calculation*
05:31 *Slender columns vulnerability*
06:26 *Slenderness ratio explained*
08:38 *Inelastic buckling complexity*
09:08 *Load eccentricity effect*
10:27 *Structural analysis limitations*
11:22 *Different buckling types*
11:51 *Plates and shells sensitivity*
12:48 *Gravity-induced buckling*
13:40 *Nebula streaming offer*
Made with HARPA AI
Concepts are clearly explained best TH-cam channel
I was literally searching for this type of video since last 1 month every where on TH-cam
topic suggestion: Torsional Buckling
thanks for this video👍
it is clear and understandable
I love these videos, it is like a recap of my degree. Thanks.
I am feeling blessed for getting this channel . Kudos to ur work sir🙏 thanks to u
Simple and efficient. The best channel the engineer
I love how thorough and clear your videos are!
wow, what an amazing and high quality video, even university professors couldnt do a beautiful work like this.
Excellently visualized and explained. That's why I love this channel.
There's something interesting about learning where you need to hear a poor explanation many times before you understand, and a great one once. This is one of those channels with a great explanation, thank you so so much for these videos!!
If only you made this video before last year. What an amazing video.
You are such a genius,never seen that type of video ever,pls upload more videos
Amazing video! All engineering students should be grateful for the existence of this channel. Please keep posting, your content has immense value! 🙌🏽
I love the Music behind these efficient engineering videos as much as videos itself.
Long and time killing lessons explained within minutes. 😘
You are an amazing creator. It is really Mind blowing how we live nowadays : Acessing such clear and well structured information for free. Thanks a lot!
I don't know if you realize how good your video's are... for real
dude your crazy talented way you explain its freaking wow, keep making videos.
You are far better than most professors
All these concepts explained and information in some minutes. Amazing ❤
One more time you made the impossible! You made an amazing, short and astonish video with an important content. Thank you once again! You're the best"
Wow! Mind blowing! All this stuff I was unable to understand in college and suddenly it makes complete sense! Wonderful work. All architecture students much watch ur videos in college.
Bar none simply the best engineering videos out there
Perfect explanation and summary for Buckling.
Concise and easy to follow. That's another quality video worth to watch.
I especially love how you pronounce Euler the right way :-)
Something that's probably not very intuitive: A pipe can even buckle when under tension while supporting a compressive load. We did experiments at the university showing that, but I kinda forgot the exact reason for it.
Wow. I really love the way you present and explain concepts. I also loved your all earlier videos. Keep it up.
so precious a video for 15 minutes
You have done too much for us engineers..
Lot of Love all the way from Afghanistan...
Wow wow wow super dooper amazing channel! What a channel for learning!!! Honestly the way you teach in a very simple way is mind blowing, what a conceptual you are!!! Highly admire your efforts and your teaching skills! You are the best tutor ever i have seen! I learned a lot from this channel. Thank you so much for sharing your high standard knowledge with us... Just keep going like this, honestly very soon your's channel will cross million subscribers! Your mad fan🤣🤣🤣 From Pakistan. Lots of love and respect🙏🙏🙏
Great as always
Hello Efficient Engineer Team,
You are doing great things in shaping the future of engineering student and consequently the future of engineers of the Nation.
❤️ 💜 Heartily Salute to you 💜❤️
Fantastic explanation
Wish your videos were available when I was studying this, very clear easy to follow.
A good teacher is worth his/her weight in gold. You exemplify this. Sadly at Uni, there are tons of bullshitters out there making a good living because even they do not understand the subject very well, let alone teach it. I have seen lots of them.
Awesome, this is the topic I’ve been waiting for the most 😃
Amazing work as always. This is the topic I've been waiting for.
No way... I'm finishing my mechanics of materials FE review book, and the last topic is buckling. I must have said the word out loud because there was no way this video was going to get recommended to me. I never looked this topic up in school so I wasn't going to get this particular topic. I do watch a lot of your videos so to study for the FE exam. Man is the algorithm crazy... You day a word once...
If I wouldn't be struggling to pay rent and buy food your channel would be one of those where I would be spending money on patreon.
Really enjoyed studying this topic, specially thin plate buckling. Great video!!
such an amazing channel, the best place I've ever seen mechanical engineering.
I wonder who did this research.
Euler. Of. Course.
Great stuff man! 💯
Sir you are just awesome.. in jst one all the concept get clear.. thanks sir.. sir one request pls make more vedio on Mechanical engineering topic like Tom
Your videos are top-notch! I love your design approach to explaining Engineering with 3D Models and great graphical support. Your videos remind me of 3b1b ones, but you found your unique own way to animate and display these concepts! I would actually love to know how you're doing it, I'm a Mechatronics student and would love to be able to help myself sometimes by bringing these concepts to life
Appreciate the kind words, thank you! I use Blender to create the animations, if that helps.
@@TheEfficientEngineer wow, this is Blender? I used to tinker with that when I was still very young 😂 Anyways, thanks for making these videos, they're a ton of help, looking forward to watching the next!
Brilliant video. Wished I had come across this during my days as an undergraduate student.
Love you work man, please do a video on material science phase diagram or virtual work it would be awesome
The Efficen Engineer At its very Best
I wish u posted this 6 months ago where i was struggling with mechanics of material II ..lol ..great explaination and top quality animation as always
incredible animations and great explanations, thank you
Thanks a lot , I find only one this which clear my concept just before the exam
Just in time!
Tomorrow i have the end test in “strength of material” course. for sure there will be question about buckling .
Following you here and also in nebula,
Watched all your videos and I really appreciate the work that you do to create them .👏🏻👏🏻
waiting for the next one already 🤞🏻
be safe 😷
Ori from Israel 🇮🇱.
Thank you! Hope it goes well!
So if I wanted to find the force needed to a crush an aluminium can for example against a fixed surface, would the Euler's formula presented at 3:06 be useful to find the buckling force? and using le as 2L in the formula
If I could like this video several times, I Definitely would!