Is America right to fear Huawei?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 11 พ.ย. 2019
- America worries that Huawei, China's telecoms giant, spies on behalf of its government and threatens Western interests. Such concerns are not just about America's security, but also its insecurity. Read more here: econ.st/2O9kgyc
Click here to subscribe to The Economist on TH-cam: econ.st/2xvTKdy
Rarely does a country go to war with a private company. But America has done just that. But is this really about Huawei or is it something bigger than that? And what is the threat?
What is this war really about and why is Huawei in the middle of it?
Founded in China in 1987 Huawei is now the world’s largest maker of telecoms equipment with revenues exceeding $103bn. When you think about Huawei you might think about the handset. That makes sense, since it sold 200m of them in 2018 alone. But close to half of its revenue comes from selling network equipment. In fact, since 2014 it’s outgrown all its competitors reaching over 3bn people.
This is how networks function - Your phone sends a signal to a nearby tower using radio waves, voice and data are passed over an internal network run by your phone company, which connects your handset to other phone users and the wider internet. In other words, these antennas connect us all. But now, there’s a new kind of network. Although 5G is massively overhyped, it is coming and Huawei is a leading force in this innovation. But though this computerised, smart future opens up new possibilities it comes with a health warning. Because if entire networks are vulnerable this opens the door to countries spying on one another.
In a rare interview with The Economist Ren Zhengfei, Huawei’s founder and CEO, talked about the political storm surrounding his company. As the argument rages over the security of Huawei’s products the effects can be seen in some unexpected places. Joe Franell runs Eastern Oregon Telecom, a small network serving the people of this rural area. The problem is that the network here relies on Huawei technology.
It’s a similar story around the world Mobile-phone users in developing countries have benefited from Huawei’s attractive deals. But how is Huawei undercutting its competitors?
Whether or how Huawei is connected to and subsidised by the Chinese government is unclear. But what is clear is this - China is the kind of country where if the party says jump all you can say is, well how high? Loyalty to the state is actually enshrined in China’s intelligence law
Article 7, a 2017 addition, states that “Any organisation or citizen shall support, assist and co-operate with the state intelligence work.” Critics say this law means that when you buy Huawei equipment you may be exposing yourself to surveillance by the Chinese intelligence services. And this makes governments very uncomfortable.
The fear is that Huawei will leave backdoor vulnerabilities in its networks that would provide China with an opportunity to spy on its competitors and enemies. To counter this mistrust, Huawei has shared its code and allowed the likes of Britain’s National Cyber Security Centre
to scan it for backdoors. So, if there’s no solid security threat why is America making an enemy out of Huawei?
It seems as though the concern over Huawei is not only about America’s security but also its insecurity. And it’s causing collateral damage at home as well as abroad. In May 2019 the Trump administration issued an executive order which not only forbade American companies from supplying Huawei with components, but restricted domestic networks from using its equipment. It’s a move that feels like an own goal to Americans like Joe Franell.
And there’s another uncomfortable truth that America can’t ignore. Smartphone technology relies on a truly global supply chain. Take an average smartphone. Some contain components from more than 200 international suppliers. Screens might be made by Samsung in South Korea. The camera lens engineered in Germany. The chip could be designed by a California-based company and manufactured in Taiwan. The battery could come from Japan and the audio chip from China. But increasingly, hostility and lack of trust threaten to fracture these supply chains.
America's concerns about Huawei are understandable. But the risks can be managed by limiting the use of Huawei equipment to less sensitive parts of 5G networks. That way it is possible to benefit from the low cost of Huawei’s equipment while minimising security concerns.
Billions of people around the world have benefited from increased connectivity made possible by global standards and global supply chains. But if political mistrust divides the telecoms industry into rival camps
everybody stands to lose
For more from Economist Films visit: films.economist.com/
Like The Economist on Facebook: / theeconomist
Follow The Economist on Twitter: / theeconomist
Follow us on Instagram: / theeconomist
People need to read history... it's not "rarely", it's very common that the United States go to war with a company with superior technology:
-- Toshiba in Japan
-- Alstom in France
👍
so true
truth
yep
nailled it
"Rarely does a country go to war with a private company"
Dutch East India Company: hold my beer
English East India company: hold my tea
This is all very touching. But do people really believe that Google or Amazon wouldn`t have to supply personal data to an American intelligence agency when asked?
Even Facebook is US spy
We atleast know for a fact that Apple does not. They are notorious about not sharing info with any govt, let alone the US govt
so would you use alibaba, baidu, wechat instead of amazon google whatsapp?
it's a matter of choice. 1 more option, you could have just disconnect.
@@shreenathjraman3619 Check the news. Apple has already admitted it.
@@tsobenny2051 I would. Never used Amazon but can't live without alibaba. Use more wechat than whatsapp
So Huawei is open to the west "here's our code". Has any other US tech company done this?
No....Huawei is setting the highest standard, no other tech companies can match it.
@@bonbonhon76 Ever seen what the US does do whistleblowers?
@@bonbonhon76 Like the NSA having access to Facebook, Google and Apple servers? Government even spying on allied heads of state in order to win some major commercial deals?
Microsoft did that when Chinese government wanted to by Windows
@@jerrychen3832 Non sense comment from person has not brain.
UK searched Huawei’s code for backdoor application, they found nothing. However like Iraq, the US found nothing after overthrown Iraq government.
You do know you don't need a "backdoor" to see "intercept" personal data.??
But Weapons of Mass Destruction were very real, we just haven't found them yet.
Trump and his puppet administration only best at finger-pointing others. The truth is too much for them to handle. So why is it ok that the U.S. implemented the Patriot Act, where FBI, CIA, and ICE to spy and search arrest their own American citizens. What about the hunting down of Eric Snowden by U.S. authorities. And when China is doing the same to protect its sovereignty and citizens by implementing the National Security laws or develop and improve their own technology in mobile, etc.. it's not okay, it's labeled as a threat. So U.S. is not a threat at all??? Obviously, the U.S. is fear-mongering toward the rest of the world.
@@Theguyin915 Ofcouse you don't need backdoor to do this,but you need one to do it secretly.Use your brain.
@@ShowLoTime While they point finger to others, they have rest 4 fingers point them back for the same as they claim.
USA:Huawei stole our technology.
Huawei:But you don't even have it.
USA: that's why exactly
Sadaqat Ali they never said that? They are saying it’s a security threat. USA already has 5G
@@Timothee_Chalamet_CMBYN the European and the Korean have 5G, not the US
yang hu are you dumb? Us does have 5G
@@Timothee_Chalamet_CMBYN Name one US company that manufactures 5G network equipment?
bb d All of the big four wireless carriers in the US-Verizon, AT&T, T-Mobile, and Sprint-have launched 5G. Dish network and Qualcomm as well
6:56 there is the main reason: "we cannot allow any chinase company to outcompete the united states in this powerfull industry of the future". Donald Trump
Out of jealousy and all fricking BS
@@sonnywolf383 Not jealousy my friend. Its the need to stay on top. Remember that guy that create the engine that runs on water and just disappeared over night?
Truth is America isn't even in race!
it's an fair fight. china has banned many US companies like google, facebook... Now they got paid back for that
@@DucPham-nb7xm not exactly true. Companies operating in China needs to follow Chinese laws. Companies choosing not to follow Chinese laws can't operate on China.
Trump is banning Chinese companies operating successful businesses that follow US laws. Ban is imposed because American companies can't compete.
America is like a competitor who is losing badly to its opponent and its strategy is to accuse the opponents of cheating and then band them in the game even though there is no evidence.
They are born loser country..history can tell..so add in in history book.
Losing badly when they cant make their own software and chip?
@@dracoii1147 look at this comment from the lens of the date of the ban. Huawei was making their own Kirin chips at the time.
A thief thinks everyone else a thief.
Mr Miyagi USA has nothing to spy. Spy what?
Mr Miyagi that was denied and clarified further as not true check the news again.
Huawei even shared the code
Why judges in Australia are lenient on pedophiles I guess?
wow...what a comment...i am happy to see wow what a comment ....100 likes from me
Mr. Pompeo is a right man for a US Secretary job, brutal, there is not a shred of finesse, a full scale brute with a cannon...the problem with such and "go ahead" is that other side has a cannon to and listens to Mr. Pompeo carefully to find out how much of his palabra is true.
And why should world trust Apple US Govt. ??
@General Luise Martinbanger you have no idea about american companies. do you ever hear about "PRISM"? all american companies of course must be loyal to US gov.
@General Luise Martinbanger cause this cunts companies already providing us govt with the info so there is no law needed what a cunt country it is
General Luise Martinbanger Snowden say the difference
At least China admits they have control over companies, the U.S. on the other hand, controlling and spying without admission. Hypocrisy at its finest!
@General Luise Martinbanger US government ask apple to hack in an iPhone before but Apple refuse to do that because of security reason. But they did it anyway. That doesn't seam so secure.
"World strongest country" scared from a company
Its like a joke right..
Peace
USA afraid of his allies too
Haha Thank you
@@nelsongeada4930 a lot of people are very anti america and actially serious.
Didn’t the US used Huawei’s 4G to tap the worlds Leader. Just ask the PM of Germany Angela Merkel and Snowden
If you look at how USA prints money like its free and how it maintain its currency as global reserve with petrodollar and sanctions on countries that tries to setup its own trade outside of USD, you then know why America is so afraid of China's rise. Because if one day the world move away from USD as global reserve fund and trade, America can no longer print money and make the world pay. More so, given that trillions of dollars of debt, USD would overnight becomes worthless. When it was Japan that was on the rise, they started a trade war against Japan and they won. Now its China, except that China is far bigger and stronger than Japan is. America is now very desperate.
They use cold war against the former Soviet Union as well and eventually made the whole country collapse
So on point!!
@peter williams Hey look, the world police, the person that knows it all! :D
There are also many things you don't know about the US, Britain, France, OR Germany. And before you talk about human right issues in China, maybe you need to talk about your own American rights that seems to get shorter and shorter every year.
peter williams black lives matter!!!
US is a dying power trying to stop a raising power with it's last breath. Corona crisis has exposed US as dying power.
I’m more concerned with the extensive spying by the accuser..
How many times has the NSA or enforcement agencies using their data been at your door? How many times do you think the Chinese security services punish its citizenry for things they said or did privately online?
Huawei is more than about spying. If they start building your infrastructure, they OWN you.
@@nutsackmania Are you Chinese?
Can the Chinese government punish you for what you say in your country?
Be that China or the NSA there is nothing you can do to stop it but to go off-grid.
Wolf Edmunds exactly
Nah Hawaii seems like a pretty nice place to live
LOL, I love Hawaii too, I am talking about nice bitches. I mean beaches.
shouldn't they change the flag of Hawaii from the union jack to something more american and patriotic?
I beat the sh** out when someone copied my answers in highschool. Huaweii copying and stealing all intellectual properties of US high tech companies who spent billions $$ to invent new tech. I feel like slapping the crap out of Huaweii
Huaweii installed BACKDOOR in all HUAWII PHONES stealing all info on your phone!!!! Images, conversations, documents!!!! CREEEEEPY!!!!!!
Agreed
It’s refreshing to see economist stays honest and truthful when it comes to China related stories
It’s refreshing to see CIA bot in top comment
Bahaha, actually made me lol, great joke, thanks 👌
Thanks to Snowden, we know who the real enemy is.
Chump
@@sonnywolf383 trump
@@sonnywolf383 trump is a liar
@@user-he5cj2tj2s the CCP is a king liar and thief-truly evil:
India sending its navy to the SCS, Vietnam buying sophisticated weapons from Russia to give China something to think about, Indonesia sending its ships through CCP's absurd 9-dot line that nobody regards, Japan deploying new stealth anti-ship missiles to counter China... ALL ALL ALL China's neighbours hate China, feel threatened by China, are taking action against China.
China's friends are N.Korea (who cares about a crazy lap-dog) and impoverished countries in Africa who change their loyalties like the changing wind depending on who is sending aid or paying off their corrupt leaders.
Soo true.. USA is the best nation to make enemies.. They must be very proud to destroy earth and human race.. We should work all for one side as human race.. No we split, we arrange some issues to split people and cultures, create anger..
"We lie .We cheat. And we steal."-----Pompeo
Michael Chen "We lie. We cheat. And we steal." ------ Xi
@@ParmMohan-us6rn Pompeo really said the words in a prideful sounds. Xi never do that.
Chinagate - Bill
@@ParmMohan-us6rn Could you give me the recording of this quote or are you just shittalking? I certainly can give you the recording of pompeos quote if you want.
@@Weisswurstesser No statesman stand for justice, they just fight for benefits, and they will use any kinds of methods to win.
6:55
" We cannot allow any other country to out compete the US " . It just so happens to be China in this case .
All countries, that are climbing. Watch out !
Americans do not really care about capitalism, they crave global dominance which is fast fading away.
A H That is what all leaders of a country will say to their country so that isn’t a big deal. Is it not right to accuse Huawei as a threat. It is very close to a party that massacre its own citizens with live bullets.
Boo to The US clown!
Come on, USA, you just need to develop 6G, problem solved
That is How you stay on the top of the world, NEVER NEVER NEVER NEVER NEVER LET ONE SINGLE COMPANY out-compete USA.
by sabotaging your competitor and spread lies, don't provide the necessary tool for China to enable them to work , using the Uighurs to attack China.. CIA white hat team
"In a rare interview with the Economist" ..... - ..... This guy has literally been interviewed everywhere!
He used to be very media shy, until recently, in an attempt to defend his companies' reputation
*Typical - want to make Huawei sounds secretive.*
Make america run again
Paranoia is a inferior trait due to genetics
agreed, they make it sound like he is some North Korean official who has secretly been allowed to speak on camera come on give me a break
US caught Huawei CEO’s daughter, and they called for human rights
Pub Comrad well who arrest first，brainless
@Pub Comrad
Fair hearing in america? LOL
@Pub Comrad 🖕🖕🖕🖕
Pub Comrad American wants to find a reason to fight with China because of China will hurt his profit. China is safe and beautiful also can make you rich
@Pub Comrad Satanic dog.
If Huawei is US company, I'm not able to leave this comment.
What
@Vincent Boies china 😂
Best product type of country, make sure you're don't fighting:
Smartphone: China 50% & Korean 50%
Car: Japanese 50% & USA 50%
Sometime using China product, sometime using Korean product, sometime using Japanese product, sometime using USA product. Perfect balance, no going war technology
Huawei's products do not have backdoors. That's the problem.
sure, why not
All software is one update away from having a backdoor.
That’s not what the UK found in Huawei’s security lab they themselves fund.
K. Deese they also stole Canadian tech
Jack Mcg who stole Canadian tech and what Canadian tech?
Before I'm iPhone user
And now I'm huawei user.
@robert dawson better than funding world bomber that invading other countries lol.
my whole family all become Huawei user now!
🤮🤮
Jay Faelrca my kids were huawei users now we all are iPhone users!!
@robert dawson I don't know why they say Huawai is a "private company". There is NOT any "private company" in China. The government controls everything in this country.
I love huawei products and their services
And i trust Huawei too
First it was Toshiba. Next, Alstrom. Now Huawei.
Amercia has given free advertisement for Huawei & directly admit Huawei technology is superior
Allegations are purely lied.
J what sort of an idiot make a pathetic statement like that
It worked in their favor tho...
Generally when someone is accusing others for doing something wrong, its because he is doing that as 1st :-D
sergeendrix....yeh mate, the truth hurts Trump claims it's pure envy . the spying business it's like child tantrums , as he said~ no company in the world can overcome America's supremacy
u mean new chine blame foreign intervention in HK matters? you are not loyal to party and your country in this case! bad bad boy!
@@meijibig are they wrong? USA interfere with other nations for breakfast
But is the accusation true?
Dasd Da for lunch they invade them
Bla, bla, bla , bottom line you don't except any body ahead of you , stop lying to the nation and working together make the world a better place rather then just saying this is bad and that is bad , and you are the bad guy , stop the war make peace in the world .
It is true that our human race should cooperate with each other and make the world a better place and peace. But you can’t deny, our world is still politically connected and some dictatorships are still existed. They are not willing to share and they are not willing to open because it will affect their control of people. That’s how they do. We all want things to be simpler but it’s just not the case right now. Look around you, do you judge people just by their ethnicity and color? Rely on your first reaction, that says a lot. If you are not judgemental, what about others? So technology is no longer technology anymore. We human have great potential but we created barriers to cut off the connection between great talents and therefore created allies and enemies. Only when we realized we are one, our great gift will show. For now, just let them play.
You are being naive, there is industry espionage and innovations were stolen.
Some people just going to believe in whatever is throwing at them , with a set Mind and prejudged , something you don't yet have it , it must been stolen by someone who had on their hands already, right ! Stop living in the well , come out see a bigger picture .
@@shadowlessbeam8124 what people believe that is thrown at them is that you can chose your own gender, and that protecting your borders is racist while other countries are selfish to the rotten core and do everything to undermine the US and I am not saying US is a saint, it has started too many wars.
@@ringrageboxing5870 there is three kind of people in any situations , one will agree , one will dis agree and the 3rd one will not agree or disagree however there is a forth one who will go and investigate analyze find the real true to the matter .
Can you trust Chinese government? Says The US government.
LOL 🤣🤣🤣Did you forget the prism program?
pu zhao why should Americans risk giving their data to communist China?
@@amitcarbyne3635 To stop the US from spying the whole world?
@@amitcarbyne3635 And what data does the average truck driver have that the Chinese government wants so much? Are you forgetting that facebook is ripping data off of you right this moment?
China don't care about you. Thats why its actually safer...
@@puzhao1639 tell us about uighars.
US: you can't use Huawei equipment because I can't spy you anymore.
agree
the reason why the us restrict huawei is that uncle sam need to spy on people's piracy for his benefit but he can't do it with huawei
well, before the US notice Huawei, maybe only Chinese people know the company, but after america, everybody knows Huawei. I think we should say thank you to america🤔
@@kenwang2258 in this part, I can't agree with you more. president Trump and secretary of State Pompeo's word is the best advertisement to Huawei😂😂. although huawei had already entered the Western market before it was districted, what American politics do really make huawei gained a lot of popularity. the lighthouse has been dim
In the first place why would China have anything to do with the civilians of us
If a country has everything in order, it has no reason to fear anybody.
Not true at all
then why does China fear about Hong Kong, Taiwan , the Muslims in their North West????
Blue Sky There’s more brainwash in America if you ask me
Yukon Joe They don’t.... it’s the US who got HK to make riots in name of “democracy” even tho they already had the right to vote and all the stuff they asked in the first place were given
I didn't even know the Huawei brand 2 years ago. Now I have replaced iphone with my Huawei and Huawei CEO Mr. Ren is my hero.
哈哈
华为牛逼!
HUAWEI is great!
Can you trust the US government...!
I'm one of Huawei employees, let's see what will happen in the future. It seems that Huawei would less and less dependent on US firm or even foreign company. And Huawei actually have started prepare for this challenge more than 10 years.
Stand strong Huawei. And gave me a sneak peak at the new Huawei P90 Pro Plus Ultra+ PS28 thanks!!!!
Can't agree more. As the video said, the major consideration of the U.S is motivated by a desire to slow down China's rise and keep a dominant position in this powerful future industry.
One day huawei will have it’s own supply chain and get rid of other restrictions
Honor, Oppo, Xiomie should be ban and never used US made tech, China cannot produce own tech just copycat and made money by used US tech. unlike small south korea, taiwan and japan are more advance.
THANK YOU AND HUAWEI FOR KEEPING THE PROMISE.
" its not about the America's security, but also its INSECURITY" 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
This was our favourite line in this film too, glad you liked it!
The person who's doing the same... suspects others also do the same for them..FEAR..😂🤣😜🤔
Absolutely 😂😂
This is one of the few videos I have ever seen that has no prejudice against China. I think as a developed country most Americans are more aware of the truth than Chinese.
？自大
It’s not only about America’s security, but also it’s insecurity. 💥there you have it
张Sebastian if China bans google Facebook twitter. Netflix. Instagram snap. why can’t America ban hua wei ?
Ruoyu Li There’s a big big difference between China’s ban on Twitter, Facebook, etc. and America’s ban on HUAWEI.
@@levelazn You can't simply look at things in a dichotomy; and the situations for bans on Facebook, Google are rather for CCP's political stability and protection for Chinese domestic enterprises so that they could have grown in a faster pace (not trying to justify, simply the way it was).
@@Sebastian-on1ci they are literally the same reasons, us bans huawei to protect political stability, and to protect apple.
@Joe china 1.4 billion people don't use facebook, twitter, instagram etc.. USA ask europe to not use huawei, the entire european union together is no bigger than china population wise. the impact is equal
Huawei is not a listed company, hence they can invest in research
The USA itself is the biggest security concern.
Chinese brainwashing has worked well I see.
@@100KGNatty CIA bot identified
@@Kai-xw6ut fair enough! they got 5g wires in their masks,lol.
@@alybhatemi5086 True. I think that blm should be a class war but not a race war. The American should know that when 1% people grasp 99% wealth.
@@alybhatemi5086 True. I think that blm should be a class war but not a race war. The American should know that when 1% people grasp 99% wealth.
huawei : hello we are back ! 😘🇨🇳
Why is America saying huawei will do exactly what Snowden already proved America has done? 🤷♂️
I don't know mandarin but I really admired the elegant way Huawei CEO spoke mandarin.
Do you really think he is the CEO? He is a puppet. The real CEO is the brains with ip.
wow cool, you even know mandarin is different from contonese etc
SA DU it's easy all you do is wait for the "Sh" sound.
Me:watching this
Also me:watching this with Huawei =/
Remember when China saw itself at the top of the world but was brought down by technological advancements it missed out on due to refusing to open up?
Watching this video from a huawei phone.... 😂😂😂
me? too😂
Bruh i know right?
watching on my old p10.... waiting for my mate 30 pro 5G version
Me to hihi mate 20 x 😁
watching from my mate30
it is not about security, it is about money. and everybody knows this.
Wrong goobus. Its about the ccp controlling our telicommunications infrastructure. Like they control the meds you need, like they control the electronics you need, like they control a majority of the ports you obviously know anything about, Wake the freak up.
But, Trump is about to make some changes.
TRUMP2020
Can you let the communist using 5G to spy on your country? Can you???
@@yeahyeahnatnat If you don't trust huawei, not one can force you to use it.
路边蜗牛 this is a national security problem, china gets nth even if they spy on me
@@yeahyeahnatnatIf your government even the whole country didn't use Huawei there will not be nation security problem. However, what American government did is prevent Huawei from doing business with other countries, what kind of national security problem like this?
8:20 wont be dismantling iPhone 11 😂
Huawei mobile phone has the strongest signal according my experience, when we are in countryside to book flight, only Huawei can finish, while Iphone and Sumsung failed, i think it because Huawei is professional on communication device.
true, when trading stocks in America, my uncle use Huawei's P10 Pro , P30 Pro, his iPhone is too slow, lagging.
When the most powerful country in the world is afraid of a phone company.
Huawei is suspected of doing what The USA is known to do routinely.
Shut up.
You're right
@@mommyanne30 USA dicktasters are known to get triggered easily.
tarjei99 so true! Actually not only the us....
The problem US still use 4G.
Sour. Sour
I would love to see what the economist has to say now when UK government shares the concern. The Economist is such a big hypocrite.
UK's biggest concern is its big brother. UK and US have a common concern about Huawei, if other countries use Huawei, Five eyes will not be able to wiretap other countries. Madam Merkel knows clearly!
India number 1
A country which has not fired even a single shot outside of its border for about 40 years is being accused of one crime after another and viewed with fear and distrust is quite abnormal.
"We cannot let any other countries to outcompete the United States in this powerful industry of the future."
Serena Zheng that says it all, does’nt it ? “Any other country”. Think about that, dear “allies”.
The United States is pissed the Huawei is leading 5G.
@Anthony Lopez maybe you miss understood what I meant. They own most of the patents and they have better tech than their competitors. Maybe you are the troglodyte, you can't ignore the obvious. Please be objective
Think about this:
1. No one can hack a computer (or a cellphone) unless it's connected with net.
2. Nets are running by local net company who operate the equipments
, not the company made the equipment.
3. The only way that the maker of the equipment spy on the net user, is bypass the runner of the net, and that operation need a backdoor to carry out.
4. Now, Huawei, and only Huawei opened its code for check.
So, pls you tell me, which net equipment maker hasn't been caught as a backdoor maker? And which one you trust most?
From what material is the smartphone battery made
The loss of technology! The tool of politics! Love Huawei
America is scared because America now for the first time has a competition for the world... and if America lose this fight will be because of America's arrogance.. it's blinding them..
Ain't the first time America has had competition. We were playing second fiddle to Europe until WW1 and WW2 weakened them and allowed America to overtake them far sooner than would have been possible if those two wars had not happened.
We then competed with the USSR from the 40's till they collapsed at the beginning of the 90s.
This conflict between China and America is a lot like the old cold war. The only difference is that I do not see America or China falling apart in 50 or 60 years.
Right now, China will probably overtake America in economic power sometime soon. However, barring consecutive presidents like Trump or Hollywood collapsing, I see American political and cultural influence in the world being stronger than China's. Then of course there is the expected rise of India sometime this century. I would not be surprised if in the next 30 to 50 years India overtakes China's economy just like China is overtaking America's.
It will be an interesting century.
We're not going to lose to China is a dictatorship lol Japan products is ,100 times better lol
Isaac Harvison ever been there or...?
US: UK, be careful. China may monitor you.
UK: How do you know that?
US: because that's what I am doing!
We should be clear internet security is shared responsibility. strongly condemn US high tech hegemony.
Is Asia right to fear the US and CIA and NSA? Lol ...
And so is China
i trust the US more than i trust bing bongs
We don't fear it, we combat them.
also NGO and NED
Asia fears the CCP
Toshiba yesterday, Huawei today!
Author: Tan KW | Publish date: Wed, 13 Feb 2019, 5:30 PM
Thirty years ago, Toshiba exported precision instruments to Russia. The United States has imposed the following penalties on Toshiba Group.
1: The Japanese Police Department was ordered to arrest Erhe Lin, President of Toshiba Machinery Foundry, and Hiroshima Tanamura, President of Machine Tool Business, and sentenced to 10 years'imprisonment.
2: Closing Toshiba's factory in the United States
3: A 100% tariff on Toshiba products sold to the United States
4: As an alternative punishment to the previous one, Toshiba's exports to the United States were banned for five years.
5: A huge fine of 1 trillion yen was imposed on Toshiba, equivalent to $16 billion today.
In order to calm the anger of the United States, Japan has imposed severe penalties on Toshiba Group:
First, Japan's semiconductor industry will unconditionally share technology with American companies.
Second, Toshiba spent 100 million yen to publish a full-page apology advertisement in all major newspapers in the United States.
Thirdly, Japan Semiconductor Association invested 9 million US dollars to launch various relations lobbying in the US Congress, and this lobbying has become the most costly lobbying war in history.
Fourthly, the chairman and general manager of Toshiba Group resigned.
Fifthly, by an administrative order issued by the Ministry of Communications, Toshiba is prohibited from exporting any products to 14 countries for a period of one year.
The United States is the master of Japan, Japan can only apologize, which has led to Toshiba gradually losing its past glory.
Toshiba was the hope of Japan's science and technology industry, and also the hope and pillar of Japan's manufacturing. After suffering a heavy blow from the United States, Toshiba went downhill thoroughly.
The U.S. attacked Toshiba not because it sold equipment to the Soviet Union, but because it affected U.S. interests. The United States believes that the Japanese semiconductor industry represented by Toshiba Group seriously threatens the economic interests of the United States, while the Japanese high-end manufacturing plan threatens the United States and challenges the technological hegemony of the United States.
Looking back more than 30 years ago, the experience of Toshiba, Japan, and looking at what the United States is doing today, there are indeed many similarities.
The United States does not allow its high-end manufacturing industry to be challenged at all, nor does it allow its technological hegemony to be challenged. The United States hopes that other countries will all be American workers and will never allow other countries to become shareholders of American interests.
Only proves one thing: Japan was weak (relies so much on import) and it could not fight back, but China/its economy isn't. Only a superpower could fight against another superpower
The last magazine I would look to for an opinion is the “Economist.”
Economist is the racist , 12 out of 10 articles from Economist is to spread misinformation and hate towards China
Well given how badly the extradition of Meng Wanzhou is going for them, I would say yes. It's going to be a substantial loss for them
The US can sanction or even launch a war to another country base on solely their ungrounded hypothesis.
@@24emerald corrected now thanks
Yes of course... any country "can" go to war for what ever reason they choose. Any country including China can do that.
Of course it also means they will have to deal with the consequences of their actions afterwards.
Any person can jump off a bridge as well.
Yeah we seen what happened with their "i found wmd in iraq" and how it turned out. America is a know pathalogical liar.
@Cary Andrae ... The CCP is "presently" at war with many countries. They have been for more than 20 years.
Nobody realized it though. It's a different kind of warfare.
@@24emerald yes at war with the west's constant communist rhetoric which for over 20 years, china has never exported their communism but instead brought investment to other countries. But west still insist not to trust china but they want their money🤷♂️
"It's mistake to politisize 5G" - since when were technologies ever not politisized? Technology is power, and who controls power is politics.
I think the debate is that, they way the US politisize it is hurting everyone but a small interest group
Communist transvestite detected!
It should be an embarrassment to even include him. He spews utter nonsense and is a mouthpiece for the CCP.
This is the general characteristics of the technology. With your saying, every country should close the border and only use their own productions. Say goodbye to globalization. This is a developing problem, dude, which should be solved technically not politically especially this way.
Edward Liu I have no idea how you extrapolated me saying that a technology is inherently political into me thinking that countries should adopt isolationist policies.
And thats ok. Cause Samsung will fill that spot. They signed a deal with U.S./Verizon 5G Networking worth $6.6 Billion dollars
CINE DETINE ACESTI BANI ?
using and paying Huawei IP license fees.. yes, Qualcomm have to pay Huawei IP license fees .. 5G is Huawei's. Not Samsung, Not Nokia. Not Verizon
this is the best report I have seen on youtube. Unbiased, full of facts, and objective. And it presents both sides.
The Economists main point seemed to be that US should trust China because mistrust is a bad thing. There was no real attempt to explore how such a network could be used by China in wartime. There was some reference to intercepting data but no mention of being able to completely shutdown an enemy's communications. Such networks would be the first thing to be shutdown before a major attack.
Lets ignore how they never brought up that the actual reason was how they couldn't spy on citizens as easily and they didn't want china to have enough power to eo anything major to them
6:55, "We cannot allow to outcompete USA...." But do you Mr. President expect your competitors to wait till you're smart enough?
US: you can't buy 5G from China
UK: okay, I buy from US then,
US: ......I have not yet got it
Honestly, do you really believe 4G is safe? no one spy on us? Joking.
China: steal all their tech and sell it cheaper
@@leonesperanza3672 How can other steal something that you don't have? Look up who owns most patents on 5G.
USA does have 5G cities, I saw few TH-camrs trying out 5g too.
@@Cindy-gb1io According to Forbes patents number doesn't reflect their quality ,based on quality ranking they ranked Qualcomm #1 and Huawei #9
Forbes or social media are not ideal places for serious tech info. I suggest you to visit real technology platforms and you will see Huawei owns more patents than other firms.
all the us fears is competition especially when the competition is better
2:53 answer of the question coming right after
1g 2g 3g 4g all developed by American，but china never say “national security”，lol
clot art China wasn’t a competitor at the time so they didn’t care.
It's not all American. Many technologies have been found by the European counties, especially the Nordic countries like Sweden or Finland. 2G was found by Finland. 3G and 4G/LTE are pretty much the same.
Since the time of 2G, there were 2 different technology standards: CDMA which is made in America and GSM which is made in Europe. By the time of 3G, CDMA lost out and Nortel went bankrupt first, followed by Lucent being acquired by Alcatel. Eventually, during the time of 4G, Alcatel-Lucent got acquired by Nokia - so the are no telecoms equipment manufacturers left in America.
@@stang8913 show that you only look on the surface. Nokia is indeed founded by finland but american own most of the company share. When a company profit it goes to the share holder, that is why U.S choose Nokia (U.S owned)
clot art that’s because Communist China steals all its technologies.
Yeah go to check out the US “patriot act. “, the US law to ask companies to disclose data.
Dragging others down doesn't make you go any higher.
Apparently, it's a full scale competition.
The ban is never caused by Huawei's security issue but by American's self-insecurity that their economy is outpaced by Chinese.
The U.S. debt is 70% gdp. Chinese debt is 300%. China s economy is a ticking bomb.
We also don't like, want an authoritarian government building our telecom systems. Or something.
@@mr.mystery9338 no USA debt to GDP is 105%. In China it's 49.7%
@@nightprowler6336 not government debt. Corporate debt.
I Love my Huawei Y9 2019.
America ：huawei is spying us !
PRISM: HOLD MY BEER
I think that it is more likely that Huawei will not provide a backdoor for the 5 eyes surveillance network.
We need a third world country that have the ability to provide these technologies.
it's called mexico
It's called central america and South America
@@russianbadass5052 yeap they too
russian badass not Africa or South Asia or Middle East?
Manufacturing economy is the sign a country ascended to the first world. As soon the the third world country gets able to provide this kind of technology, this country is no longer part of the third world
Americans apparently can't pronounce: nuclear and Huawei.
Add "router" to that :)
You realize that there are like 330 million Americans right
@@crustindanglade6036 Nah really?
What if 5G runs the autopilot then CCP via Huawei make the car to crash?
Anyway, cheap means unreliable.
Indonesia makes one step ahead, any cellular phones even Apple must made in Indonesia and certified by the government before selling to Indonesia market.
Because Indonesia can do that, why USA cannot?
Crazy
US “We are not afraid to compete with China.”
Right. Competition for the best smear campaign.
Backdoors? ... according to the researchers mentioned in this video, they found nothing after thorough checks
UK has a lab, all of Huawei's code is thoroughly inspected , no backdoor
.......... Divided the western alliance?
Lol.
Aren't you who aggressively strain your own relationship with those allies?
Prism Prism, Is Huawei trustworthy? America must have that answer.
HK Pest Terminator why America didn't provide evidence？another question, does American government enforce their enterprise to spy other country?
Will this be the end, or the beginning of the end of Internet, growing security concerns!?...
It's going to need more laws in the future. 20 odd years of BS on the markets as people still don't understand IT very well
@@philiposborne982, Tim Berners Lee would blush with Mikko Hypponen!
Is it The Economist advertising Huawei on purpose? You have to Show the Ad official website somewhere at least when you doing it...
America’s one to talk about spying? Snowden anyone? 🤣
They (u.s.) lied as usual.
So we (all other countries) shouldn't protect ourselves from Chinese spying, or what's your logic?
@@adoatero5129 logic here is china's spying exists only in rumors but the us is proved the biggist spying regime. Yeah, i get it. People just keep saying we have information from intel people saying china is on spying, but no conspicuous, public prove. Just look at this case. People keep saying Huawei is on spying, even if Huawei is asked to open the source code, and they did, all these haven't come to an end. But us has been proved to do all those. Therefore, this made the us the last country who has the position to accuse other countries for spying.
Fark I reckon there one's to talk, USA are the worse for farkin spying! They want to be the only ones to have that power. Power and control fark them both!
One Day Three Plates America its a continent
That was helpful to get a general idea of the whole situation, thankyou
They don't need a back door if they get access through the front door
Bunker boy is a coward..scare to competes with Huawei because their far behind
Every country has the right to fear of anything but no government must interfere in international trade. Fear is no excuse when the country cannot produce a convincing evidence. May be the fear of Huawei is not security but of Huawei's technology.
This comment aged well. Turns out Huawei was using cell towers on property near US military institutions to interfere with strategic nuclear comms.
When it comes to national security. Not only fear is paramount, but USA must be wary of companies like China's state run Huawei. It could make a difference between invasion of China's communication into the USA military.
NOTHING TO DO WITH FEAR ITS JEALOUSY
You can't say they have shared everything. That's why.
wish Edward Snowden can tell the world more about usa