most of the comments here are about other artists singing this song.. seriously? can we just appreciate the ones in the video tho., these ladies sing it just as beautiful as others
4:10 omg this is so amazing Number 4 has a really strong voice, Number 3 has a great and beautiful voice and Numbers 1 and 2 have a beautiful voice too 💗💫
they all have amazing voices but i am super glad i chose number 2 because i have been listening to this song on loop to the point i was able to figure out who it was. Amazing voice!
People keep mentioning their idol biases but let me tell you something obvious: these four ladies are on another freaking level. This stage is theirs and those voices are the bomb!
these four just simply on another level,, just gather all kpop idols, from the great girl generation or some other recent kpop girls; among them, you can count by fingers just how many can barely reach those 4 voice level 🔥🔥
I knew she was 2 because no matter how similar all of them sound, you can still tell it’s her because there’s a tone in her voice that none of the others had :)
All 4 of these ladies should form a group. 1,3 & 4 did the honour for this song. Chan-Whee must be proud of them. Other fandoms try to say that their idols slayed this song are bullshit. Unlike of these 3, other idols were screaming, not slaying. Otherwise, you should check your hearing
I've only heard the original singer once and it was in a duet with Sunyoul so I don't really know how she sounds like but I was thinking 4. Boy, was I wrong. Very good, all of them though.
Eunkwang has an amazing voice and hit the notes well but Sunyoul hit the notes far more cleanly and in tune. And I'm not being biased - I've been a BTOB fan for years and I've only even known about Up10tion for about a week, haha. I just think that Sunyoul did a better job with it, but that's not to say Eunkwang didn't do well!!
People are too caught up in 'my-'idol'-can-sing-better' races. Just appreciate the singers in the video no one will die if you didnt mention your 'idol'.
jimin's serendipity for me, No. 1 is the most similar when it comes to the voice and haa the most relaxed and smooth voice. Number 3 has a more defined vibrato and Number 4 has the most powerful voice, she's a power belter but not having obvious vibrato.
Song Ji Hyo's favorite song
Yep!
+SugarPebbles28 Hot issue's choreography is Ji Hyo's favorite dance step.
I love song ji hyo😍😍
how do you know? did she say that in a RM ep? :)
+BTSoul Bingu She sang this song in ep 28
their voices were so in sync it sounded just like one voice.
That is purpose this program.
Audience choice who is the real singer.
Very famous in Korea
@@USER-ec9tjnah they meant like in the end where all of them sang together
와.... 소찬휘님도 컨디션 좋아야 부른다는 이곡을 4번분 진짜 잘 하신다
올해 7월 1일 인천에 저희 콘서트에도 모시게 되었습니다 :)
2023 타임캡슐 슈퍼콘서트 인천
라인업 : 코요태, 이재훈, 디바, 소찬휘, 태사자, 스페이스A, 채연, K2 김성면, 이하늘(DJDOC)
4번 진짜 음처리 핵깔끔함 당연히 이분인줄ㅋㅋㅋ이분이 음역대가 더 높다기 보단 소찬휘님 전성기가 지나서 그러신게 아닐지ㅜㅜ
너무 깔끔한데 ㄷㄷ
@@밥보온 ㅇㅈ
1번은 조금 무딘 목소리였고... 4번 노래소리는 가장 아마추어 스러웠다 억지로 쥐어짜는 목소리... 3번의 성량은 소찬휘보다 좋았지만... 소찬휘 특유의 음색을 표현하지는 못했다....
님들 마트에서 이노래나와서 필 받아서 따라부르다가 직원이 발 작이르키는줄 알고 달려옴ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
너를 알아 마음이 아파 듣고 2번 소찬휘 확신함 ㅋㅋ
the 4th woman had such a powerful voice though...?
Kwon Jiheun yup I thought she's the real one
yeah, me too. i think too be honest that the 4th woman had power in her voice.
Yes..she is.
ikr
Too much power
내 주변에 저게 올라가는 사람 찾기도 힘든데 목소리 빼다 박은 사람 5명 어케 모았냐
이재훈편 예심 신청해봤는데 노래 파일단계에서 컷당할정도로 ㅎㄷㄷ한 싱크로 많더라고요.
44ㅏㅌ애
most of the comments here are about other artists singing this song.. seriously? can we just appreciate the ones in the video tho., these ladies sing it just as beautiful as others
Exo forever Ot9 and you’re just here for fan wars so shoo
Thats what im talking about! This video is not about their biases . But they keep on talking and talking about it 😂
Plus the second singer was the original singer. Of coarse she sings it best
No. 1, what's the name?
AGREEEEEE
I tried to sing this one, my neighbor thought my house got robbed.
Made my day
😂😂😂
Hahahahaha
Ahhhhhhhaaaaaaa 🤣
omg you made me laugh so much haha! thank you!! lol
찬휘씨 얼마나 행복하실까요 본인의 노래를 이렇게나 잘하는 팬들이 코앞에서 열창 함께하는 자리 ㅡ 오래도록 함께해요🌻
친구들이랑 노래방 가면 못 불러도 필수로 불러야하는,,
항상 찐막곡이죠
막타로 워후가자! 하면서 목상할때까지 진성으로 내뱉는 그곡..ㅋㅋㅋ
ㅇㅈㅇㅈ
막곡으로부르다가 100점떠서 한곡더불러야하면 갑분싸됨...
@@---fh7ej마지막에 5번씩은 불러줘야!!!!노래방 갔다고 할수있죸ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
분명 목소리가 비슷하긴 한데 소찬휘 목소리는 알겟다 소찬휘 특유의 느낌??
ㅇㅈ
그 뽕삘? 그런느낌
허스키에 쇠를 긁는소리
뭔가 그 올릴 때 부욱 부욱 하는 느낌이 있죠 ㅋㅋ
근데 막상 현장가면 스튜디오 특유의 울리는 소리때문에 되게 헷갈린다 하더라구요 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
4:10 omg this is so amazing Number 4 has a really strong voice, Number 3 has a great and beautiful voice and Numbers 1 and 2 have a beautiful voice too 💗💫
Number two is real singer
아니 외국인들은 이 노래를 도대체 어떻게 아는건데..ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
위국인입니당! 우린 런닝맨땜에 알죠ㅎㅎ 송지효가 부른 노래~
제목이 영어라서 암
@@ohhimark6864 한국 놀러와 맛있는거 사줄께
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ저두사줘용
@엔몬Ěņģēł_Đêmøń 공짜 좋아하면 대머리됨.
I dont know this song or who own this song but this 4 girls should do collaboration. They give me goosebumb
the second owns the song, you even see their reaction by her appearance
+xMortalBlade cos she was the original singer. Ofcourse there would be a reaction. XD
HAHAHA love how u reply. I misread it HAHAHA but ur reaction really made my day :)
the real singer is number 2 😊
ikr
1:52 찾지마 할 때 ' 찾지 ' 떨림 와 진짜 비슷하다
@여름나비 다른댓글에는 2번 4번이라면서요
@@김민재-x5z1v 왜그래욬ㅋㅌㅌㅋㅋㅋㅋ
That last lady gave me goosebumps.. omfg T.T she's badass.
Rivianca Sanchez yes so she had a wards but original singer is second girl
She sang the full version too. She's amazing tbh
can't find her full version...
what is her name
what's her name
omg number 4 😢 its amzing ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
3번 너무 편하게 부르셔서 무조건 3번이라고 생각했는데 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 속았어...
3번은 왜나왔나 싶을정도로 너무 안똑같은데??
@@hdudgkh 나만 그렇게 생각한게 아니구나
SING IT NUMBER FOUR YAASSS
4번분이 소찬휘보다 음역대가 높은듯.. 이영상말고 왕중왕전 영상보면 소름끼침..
조금 더 높으심
지금은 그럴수 있긴한데, 소찬휘 신인 시절보면 춤추면서 눈깜짝 안하고 녹음본처럼 부르죠.
@@jinsong3890 신인시절까지 거슬러 올라갈 것도 없이 몇년전 나가수 무대만 봐두 4옥도 스크래치.....
전성기 시절 소찬휘 라이브를 못들어봤으니 이런 소리가 나오지 ㅉ
@@flakesnow4234 응 황인숙보다 더 힘있고 더 길어~~그리고 더 높아~#
속이 뻥 뚫리네요! 야식 먹고 배가 더부룩했는데, 노래 듣고나니 소화제 안먹어도 될것같군요. 간만에 영상 잘 보고갑니다.
진짜 말이 안나왔던 무대..마지막 원조 가수 소찬휘의 환호성에 놀라움,기쁨,감동등이 묻어 나오는 것이 느껴진다..자신의 노래를 저토록 완성도 있게 열창해 주는 팬이 있다는게 얼마나 감동일지..
와 4번분 진짜 미쳤다 ;;;
겁나 잘하셔,,, ㄷㄷ
진짜 헷갈려요
소찬휘랑 저 모창자가 헷갈린다고?ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
노래 잘하는건 인정하지만
음색이 너무 다름
2번이 소찬휘 모창 진짜 정석대로 잘한다고 생각했고 4번이 ㄹㅇ소찬휘인줄
@@Yeah22_tv ?
@@Yeah22_tv 잘 할 만큼 비슷하니까 헷갈린다고 했겠지 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
3:45 why this high note looks so effortless but I know I'm gonna burst my vocal cord if I try to sing this ???
Same thoo my voice always cracks 😭
lol it’s bc it’s the actual singer of the original song
두번째 소절 "나 너를 알아 마음이 아파" 부분 들으니깐 바로 알겠네 ㅋㅋ
ㅇㅈ
ㄹㅇㅋㅋ 2번 음 이러면서 봤는데 딱 나오니까 알음 ㅋㅋ
ㅇㄱㄹㅇ
목관리을 어떻게 하기에 아직도 저 소리가 나온담 대단 ㄷㄷㄷㄷ
Wow...#4 got me crying on how deep the emotions are in this song, and how she sang 사랑해....got me lol amazing singing!!!!
2번인거알고있었는데 모창능력자 중에는 4번분이 가장잘하는듯....
ㅇㅈ
ㅇㅈ
ㅇㅈ
ㅇㅈ
ㄴㅇㅈ
마지막 소찬휘의 함성이 인상적이다..난이도가 최고레벨인 자신의 곡을 완벽에 가까이 열창하는 팬과 함께 하는 것이 얼마나 가슴 벅찰까..
I watched it in December 2024, and I instantly fell in love with this song and playing this video hundreds of times ❤.
2 was the original singer but..number 4 has a powerful voice that fit for this.. awesome song
I was so stumped, I listened to this song so much and I still do! I seriously thought 4 was So Chan Whee I was confused when she came out from 2.
Have you seen Kim Yeonji or Son Seungyeons covers??? They’re way better than number 4
zhu shin I literally thought it was number 4
@@JakeReeves001 They are really great singers, too.
4번 너무 대단해서 말이 안나와...오마이갓오마이갓
+HexYang Leggo 역시 파워는 몸집이 좀 있어야..
+Fakl Fa ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
솔찍히 4번이 진짜인줄 ㅜㅜㅜㅜ
다시봐도 명장면 다들 정말 잘하시네요
2번인건 알았는데. 1번은 진짜 비슷하고 4번님이 노래를 걍 잘하네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
4번 마지막 클라이막스 입이 하마인줄 ㅋㅋ
3번이 제일못불럿는데 3번이 제일 유명해지지 않앗나 ㅋㅋ
4번이 소찬휘인줄
근데 탈락은 1번이 오히려...
1번은딱봐도아닌데 ㅋㅋ
it would be hilarious if Sunyoul appeared behind one of those doors >.
jackie yan trueeees!!
😶😶😶😶😶😶😶😶😶😶😶😶😶😑😶😶😶😶😶😶😶😶😶😶😶
이 노래는 듣기보다 부르길 많이 해서 모르겠다ㅋㅌㅋㅋㅋ
Hfnbtt o seu trabalho com as pessoas mais importantes que eu possa ter certeza que você foi
@여름의 나비 오오 그렇군요!ㅎㅎㅎ
와 4번이 소찬휘님인줄.... 진짜 똑같다..
소찬휘랑 목소리는 대부분 비슷하긴한데 소찬휘 특유의 성량같은걸로 알 수 있는듯..다들 비슷하게 따라해도 소찬휘 성량까진 못따라한다..역시 갓찬휘
아냐...완도 소찬휘가 음역대 더 높은듯^^
왕중왕전보면알겠지만 완도소찬휘 성량안꿀림..
그건 아닌듯
4번 음이 더높음
소찬휘 특유의 쉰소리가 있어서 금방알아차림
저는 소찬휘는 어렵지 않게 맞췄는데 1번이나 4번분이 소찬휘보다 떨어진다는 생각은 절대 안들었음. 갠적으로 소찬휘 목소리를 별로 안좋아해서.. 음악은 내귀에 좋은게 장땡임.
I think I'm the only one who loved the voice of the first singer. It's so great listening to her
Listening to this i know wendy sang it really well
all i can remember is eunkwang slaying this song as if it was nothing at weekly idol
Yeah I agree.
agree eunkwang and his effortless amazing high note
yasss
very well agree😂😂
I'm RIGHT Change My MIND
and on knowing brothers tho!! he literally did it like he just drinking water
4번 넘 잘한다.
소찬휘 목소리 찾으라 하니까 2번 찾는거지 누가 잘하냐 번호 누른다면 4번 누를듯
I remember Song Ji Hyo singing this hahahahaha~
same hahahahaha
what episode of RM anyway ?
It's ep 28
So?
me too hahaha
4번 언니 너무 잔인해
Feel like they are all Soo Chan Whee. 👍🏼👍🏼
I can't help but always remember Sunyoul when I hear this song.>_
so glad im not the only one hahah hiiiiiiii!!
I dont think i'll ever forget the moment uhwadong reveal herself..
same hahaha. it was so shocking.
Hahahaha can't erase him in my thoughts tho.
I even thought that he's inside one of those booths 😂
3:32 Seeing Kim Kyoung Ho celebrating like a Kid who won a prize
들을 때 마다 왜이리 신나노〜😎👍💕💕💕💕💕💕
This video keeps getting recommended to me atleast once a year
And I never regret watching it every single time it appears
I remember Solji sing this song with high notes..and the other member gone crazy on exid showtime. LoL
YAS HAHAHAH
Yeees😂
hahahahahha
Aww i remember that too xD
XD
Watched this again and again😂 for so many times right now and I still love it!
Chen keeps flashing back in my mind when I hear this
4 Years and I'm still here listening to this, I can't get over...
Edit - To those 15 likes, I would like to thank you for being here with me.
they all have amazing voices but i am super glad i chose number 2 because i have been listening to this song on loop to the point i was able to figure out who it was. Amazing voice!
When I listen too this song I always remember jihyo Running man 😂😂😂😂❤️ she's crazyyyy.
me too
lol same
You should watch Son Seungyeon and Kim Yeonji’s covers they slay with effortless and supported high notes
.Antwort
When trying to hit those high notes but I just can't. Salute to those who really did.
I knew this song before any idol cover this song💕 and I also love how Seulgi & Irene also Solji cover this song🎉
the song Solji sang on EXID Showtime! wow... mad high notes
can you give a link ?
난 너를 알아 마음이 아파 이부분은 소찬휘 딱 바로 알겠네
연새가 좀. ? 있으시나봐요 단번에 아시는걸보면? 전 데뒤때부터 팬 ㅎㅎ경희씨 넘이뻐요
ㄹㅇ 너를알아 이부분할때 특유의 하마같아짐 존멋
히든싱어 특: 하이라이트, 고음구간은 절때 원조가수 아님 ㅇㅇ
+누구 공개되기 전에 맨날 충격! 대환호! 깜짝! 소름! 이딴 자막나옴 개오글
원조가수 나올 때 연예인패널들 난리남ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
순서 제비뽑기로 합니다 제작진 설정 아니에요ㅎㅎ
I remember watching G-Dragon‘s excited reaction over this song in Gaon Chart Awards back then😂👍🏻
아니 여기 왜 외국인 댓글이 더 많아 ???? 한국어 댓글 볼려고 왔는데
유튜브가 잘른걸수도
송지효가 런닝맨에서 불러서 퍼진듯..런닝맨이 해외팬들이 어마어마함
I agree too
ㅇㅈ
Because this song is so popular among idols and also from korean variety show and yes for international fans too this song is so hard for singing😅
모창을 잘하고 못하고를 떠나 진짜 다들 가창력들이 대단하시네요.부럽습니다.
People keep mentioning their idol biases but let me tell you something obvious: these four ladies are on another freaking level. This stage is theirs and those voices are the bomb!
Ikr
these four just simply on another level,, just gather all kpop idols, from the great girl generation or some other recent kpop girls; among them, you can count by fingers just how many can barely reach those 4 voice level 🔥🔥
와 진짜 다들 노래 내공 쩌는 거 같음
I knew she was 2 because no matter how similar all of them sound, you can still tell it’s her because there’s a tone in her voice that none of the others had :)
Ouff So chan whee is such an amazing vocalist, her highnotes are just getting better each year & she's still as beautiful as ever.
4 is amazing omg
很難相信！*^O^* 기가막힙니다 소름끼치는 고음! 오늘 귀호강 했어요 ^^
감사합니다 ~ 홍콩에서 Kim Joanna
THIS GAVE ME GOOSEBUMPS ESPECIALLY WHEN THEY ALL CAME OUT AT THE SAME TIME WOOOOOW ITS AMAZING
They should have put sunyoul as one of the choices 😂
ikr he sounds like he could be the singer😂
too bad dis was be4 he was on king of masked singer
😀
but the point of the show is to have people who sound like the original. sunyoul sounds very different to the original singer
omg yes !!!
Just wow 4th contests voice was unreal. JUST WOW LIKE HOWWWWW !!! Literally perfect 🤩
🇰🇷한쿡인 찾습니다😃
진짜 한국인이 없네요
@@신희연-g7m 댁이 한국인인데요
@@이영석-m2r 1시간전 ㅎㄷㄷ
한국인!
영훈 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ한국인 찾는데 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
there are many good covers (and these ladies are all great) but no one does it like so chan whee
확실히 가수는 가수다 대단하다 마지막 모창능력자랑 소찬휘씨랑 같이 고음올리는부분에서 그냥 모창능력자분 목소리가 묻히네
아니 외국인들이고 뭐고 다 외케 잘하냐 귀호강하는중
My favorite old song❤I love
this is quite literally the best video in the world
2번이 소찬휘라고 맞췄는데 다행히 저음파트에서 불러 맞춘거고 고음파트였으면 절대 못 맞출 것 같음 ㅜㅜ
다들 장난아니심
ㅇㅈ
All 4 of these ladies should form a group. 1,3 & 4 did the honour for this song. Chan-Whee must be proud of them. Other fandoms try to say that their idols slayed this song are bullshit. Unlike of these 3, other idols were screaming, not slaying. Otherwise, you should check your hearing
I keep coming back to this video every now and again and every time I get complete goosebumps 🤯4 incredible singers 😍
I've only heard the original singer once and it was in a duet with Sunyoul so I don't really know how she sounds like but I was thinking 4. Boy, was I wrong. Very good, all of them though.
- ❤
the best cover for boy group is up10tion sungyeol..
eunkwang btob is better
I've listen to it, but eunkwang using falsetto... so sunyeol gets more credits in covering it
Eunkwang didn't use falsetto; he deadass pulled a head voice.
Eunkwang has an amazing voice and hit the notes well but Sunyoul hit the notes far more cleanly and in tune. And I'm not being biased - I've been a BTOB fan for years and I've only even known about Up10tion for about a week, haha. I just think that Sunyoul did a better job with it, but that's not to say Eunkwang didn't do well!!
ForeverCellist chen is better
I love this song so much. Thousand of times I listen, sing it like a pro singer 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 but failed to pronounce
So Chan Whee is a wonderful singer and musician i love his voice and this song
Where's Sunyoul when you need him!!
도데체 어떻게 이 노래를 따라 할수 있는거지!
기적의 목소리! 대박이다!
wow!!!!! I didn't understand them but their voices are incredible...😎
Exo Chen bring me here. I love this song too :)
vandy winata haha we are same. i m found this song because i see chen at knowing brother
Gabriel Calvin Rumondor haha but I think this is a nice song :)
Same. And now I really appreciate chen even more because this song has so many highnotes.
same!
Same. Me too
I got goosebumps everytime I listened to this song. Even though you already listened to this song a hundred times, the chills' seems so new to me.
Chen high notes made me like this song so much.
4 of them have powerfull voice... love this song
The amount of power these ladies are radiating seriously gives me chills😳😳
Eunkwang(Btob) and Wendy(Redvelvet) has slayed this song. Thumbs up!
kato yuki dont forget Solji (EXID)
Ivan Montilla and Sunyoul (UP10TION)
flavoured X and Chen (EXO)
chen has a version too :)
Seulgi and irene (red velvet) also sang this song on Singderella 😘
People are too caught up in 'my-'idol'-can-sing-better' races. Just appreciate the singers in the video no one will die if you didnt mention your 'idol'.
Omg these ladies are so freaking amazinggg...their voices are so stable mahn🔥🔥🔥
exo Chen sang this song in knowing brothers ....with ease
somebody give me the analysis of their notes please, like, those were hella lots of exceptional belting in the span of four minutes whoa
jimin's serendipity for me, No. 1 is the most similar when it comes to the voice and haa the most relaxed and smooth voice. Number 3 has a more defined vibrato and Number 4 has the most powerful voice, she's a power belter but not having obvious vibrato.
와 대박 미쳤다.. 다 너무 잘 부르시는데..
저는 3번인줄 알았어요..ㅜ 근데 외모까지 비슷하시다 대박..
It's like hearing 4 so chan whee
4 times FUGGIN HARDER 😢
Bless my ears