ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 พ.ย. 2024
- "Wenshan Dai" is a documentary film of the Dai ethnic group in Wenshan Prefecture of Yunnan Province, China. I suppose this group of Dai people to be of Central Tai group instead of the Southwestern Tai group, to which all other Dai groups in Yunnan Province belong. The evidence can be summarized from their language, culture, clothing, customs, and religious belief presented in the video. This group of Dai people may be identical with a specific western branch of the Tay people in Northern Vietnam, since both of them share similar ethnic features aforementioned. Moreover, they are both adjacently distributed crossing the Sino-Vietnamese border. I would like to carry a fieldwork research on this language in the future to test my hypothesis.
我剛看了由中國雲南文山壯族苗族自治州官方錄製的《文山傣族》的紀錄片，發現從語言、文化、服飾、習慣和宗教信仰等看，這一支傣族其實與越南的Tay（漢譯“岱族”）人的西部支系應為同一人群，語言上應該屬於台語支中部組，而不像其他傣族支系一樣屬於台語支西南組。我很有興趣未來實地調查文山傣族的語言，看看我這個初步印象是否可以得到證實。
![Black Tai Ethnic Group - Research Impact [by Mahidol]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ZhB8DLIve3A/mqdefault.jpg)
Lots of love from Tai phake north east india❤❤❤❤
Lots of love from Tai-Ahom,Assam to our ancestors🙂🙏🏼❤️
We're from Assam, India... We belong to the same Tai race from Mung Mao, China... Our ancestors migrated from China to India in 13 th century.... Hao Fan Tai.. Hao Hak Tai... Hao Fan Tai..Fan Tai Asak Ji Jao....
@Green Scenery Maximum indigenous tribes of NorthEast were migrated from China /Burma... So what's wrong in it? Even the brahmins were migrated from Middle East...
Huk khon tai 😀
Siam is also, but they don't like their origin they try to copy Khmer
@@luyormoneytalk5564 Siam is Tai mixed with local(mon , khmer )and chinese. and Khmer copied alot from Siam as well after Angkor period. Royal palace(built1866) in Phnompnh COPIED (Thai style architect/Khmer style is stone castle /indian hindu temple )from Grand palace (built1782 )in Bangkok.Ayuthaya kingdom was once the greatest kingdom in the world too while khmer kingdom died , learn more🙂
I am Thailand
Hao khon tai Yin lee lai lai. Hao pee nong tai huk kun lai lai
I m proud of our tai race and its culture and tradition. I'm tai from India,arunachal pradesh. Lots of love from India
Thank you for this valuable video. I am Tai-Ahom from Assam, India. Apparently this is the original home of all Tai communities and our ancestors. All Tai communities and tribes scattered around different countries are 'one' and United.
Thank you very much for your valuable video. I'm Tay in Vietnam and I agree with your comment.
That's song she sang like Thai poeple in Northern Thailand🎶🎼🎵 Lanna Chiang Mai
Not thais is tai Lanna 😂😂🤦🏼♂️🤦🏼♂️
You need a coffee ☕️😂😂
@@longsticyrice8151 they meant some of Thai ppl in the north are tai/Chinese dai and sing the same song.
ล้านนาเป็นจีนth-cam.com/video/F17PJyGeynk/w-d-xo.htmlsi=0mmnwHHK2_wO4XrJให้เข้าไปดู
At 3:20 when the man talks, it sounds like Laos/Thai, as a Laos person I am happy to know that my ancestors are Chinese, this is so fascinating and amazing ❤😮 all the more reason why I love Chinese people so much
Your ancestors aren't Chinese, the Chinese just took these people's land. Lao and Chinese people have nothing alike or in common
I am proud to be one of the Dai race. I am Thai from Thailand. We all are related.
Thai people are connected to the dong I think.
D YNG In general, I don’t think that the mainstream of Thai race is closely related with the Dong. Linguistically, Thais, Lao, Dai, Shan, and also Zhuang share the same vocabulary and structure of sentences. Culturally, they share many life aspects. Biologically, they are closely related by DNA and intermarriage.
@Kush Kunte Both Siamese and Khmers adopted Angkorian culture. ‘Adopt’ doesn’t mean ‘steal’. Thais are not pure Tai. Genetically, Siamese and Isan Thais have Mon-Khmer bloods. Southern Thais also has Malay and Dravidian bloods. Northern Thais are closer to Tai in China.
Khmers are originated in the Mekong lowland while Siam had been dominated by Dvaravati Mons since prehistory. So Mons are true ancestors of central Thai people mixed with Angkorians and Tai-Lao from the north. Stop claiming that all culture belong to Khmers. Your original culture is similar to Northern Khmer in Isan (Khmer Surin). Indians don’t claim that Khmers stole their culture.
Khmers invaded Mon territories of Dvaravati in Chao Phraya valley much later and spred Khmer culture to Siamese. Many Khmer arts like dances, music, costumes and architecture were destroyed by Khmer Rouge. Cambodian royal family invited many Siamese artists to help revive their culture thereafter because we share the same culture. You can research the evidences in your country.
Mons are not Khmers! They are different race who speak Mon-Khmer language just like Vietnamese. Mons did not just disappear or migrated to Burma. They had been assimilated with Tai. You can prove from the genetic evidences.
Thai language has multiple layers of different roots: Native Tai, Old-Middle Chinese, Old Mon, Old Khmer, Old Malay, Pali-Sanskrit, Persian, etc. Old Mon words in Thai language are much older than Khmer so that Thais don’t realize those are Old Mon words because it’s monosyllabic and tonal unlike Old Khmer words which are unique and remarkable.
Past is past. We should support together to improve our well-being rather than blaim each other due to nationalism. I know both Thai and Khmer netizens always love to argue about this topic but they’d better stop this. We are brothers!
@Kush Kunte toxic comment. It's useless to protest about Thai Culture, cos we all share the same culture. It's better Living life in peace and make friends dude. No need to offend anyone else. I guess u r Ultra -Khmer nationalist. And maybe some ultra thai nationalist make u angry. Just ignore it and go to pray Lord Buddha.
@@sunduncan1151 Read Research more . There are some admixture but not All.
I'm Thai. When the groom's relatives come to ask for the bride, the bride's relatives say that my daughter is young. She can't cook rice yet. Guests come to the house. She doesn't know how to welcome guests. Haha. I'm sorry. I can translate a little. I think Thai people and them have been separated for thousands of years.
คนไทยคับ ฟังชาวบ้านพูดบางคำรู้เรื่องคับ ญาติพี่น้อง
คนไทยส่วนมากบรรพบรุษสายพ่อเป็นยีนแบบอินเดียใต้(yDNA ร่วมกับเขมรมอญ) อาจจะเรียกว่าเครือญาติสายแม่(ถ้ามี)ได้อยู่ แต่ส่วนมาคนไตจะไม่ค่อยนับคนทางญาติคนทางใต้ (เขมรมอญสยาม)เป็นญาติเท่าไหร่ เพราะนิสัยดุร้าย ป่าเถื่อน
I am Tai in Myanmar!!!
Very interesting. The whole culture- language, singing, clothes and food looks similar to my family's. According to my dna test, I'm 12% Chinese Dai... Doing some research but so far this seems right. I wish there were English subtitles so I could understand more what's going on. Thanks for sharing :)
Agreed! Very similar to Hmong culture
I'm 2.5 %
I'm 8.3
I am Thai and I can understand 0.01% haha!
@@gunjchowwiwat8357
สรุปใช่เผ่าเดียวกันไหม
Hi, I am Russell from Manipur ,India we have a tribe called Maring in Manipur whoes folk song is very similar to the song in this doc.
Wenshan Zhuang and Miao Autonomous Prefecture (文山壮族苗族自治州) in eastern Yunnan province (云南省), southwest China, borders Guangxi to the north, east, and southeast; and Vietnam's Hà Giang Province to the south.
Tai kao in Vietnames 🇻🇳🇻🇳🇻🇳
China is also have tai kao，most of them live in Jinping，yunnan province
They are Tai-Dam(black).Tai-khao(white), Tai-Deng(Red). and other Tai.
TAI IS ONE❤️🙏🏼
Love there clothes!
Just found out I am 75% Chinese Dai. lol
Wow. That’s a lot
Chinese Dai = Northern Thai
เฮ้ย...ฟังลุงพูดได้หลายคำอยู่นะ
3:20 He told about origin of PhuTai . He call himself PhuTai
泰族 有太多的地方 住在 myanmar thailand lao india vietnam
เมี่อสมัยก่อน5000กว่าปี ต้องเป็นญาติกับไทยแน่ๆ เหมีอนกันมาก
คนไทยมาที่หลัง
Why ,They Staying in China very well. Nepal, Burma ,Sikkim ,Bhutan are similar on rice paddy fields.
@@dhirendrabahadurbistaเนปาลไม่ปลูกข้าวแต่กินข้าวอินเดีย ชาวเนปาลไม่ได้ทำนาด้วยซ้ำ คุณทำอะไรกับฟาร์ม?
I am DiLue
Apparently these are my ancestors
You must be Vietnamese
same
@@dyaaong6030 How come Vietnamese? They speak ancient Thai in the video. I can understand like 60% (I couldn't catch the rest due to their accent and used some ancient Thai words.). Only Tai Dam people in Northen Vietnam are Dai.
They are the ancestors of all southeast asians, Chinese people are the original ones who came before us all, we are all connected in this way
Love you..Hug khon Tai .Thai
make english subtitle too
แปลออกตรงที่พ่อแม่เจ้าบ่าวมาขอเจ้าสาว พ่อแม่ฝ่ายเจ้าสาวร้องว่า ลูกยิงของข่อยหนอ ยังเด็กยังน้อยหนอ.....ยังหุงข้าวบ่เป็นหนอ 555
Ai tai Lao kingdom nanchao yunnun
In Vietnam, they are known as Pa Dí. I think is have something to do with Baiyi.
so beautiful
Their language same as people in Thailand😗 Dai-Zhuang similar Thai
with the help of 23andme DNA test, I found out that I am about 4% Chinese Dai. I am 91% Vietnamese. I would like to travel and learn about Dai people in Yunnan. Should I learn Tai or Cantonese or Mandarin to communicate with them?
Possibly Southern Zhuang (or Tay-Nung).
What do you think? The common language in China is mandarin why would you learn Cantonese? It isn’t even spoken in yunnan
@@NoCareBearsGiven the person properly didn’t know that’s why they asked. Don’t be rude.
@@vegandemon3259 they shouldn’t ask stupid questions then
@@NoCareBearsGiven Very extremist and discriminative person. Is it that people have no freedom and human rights to learn Cantonese? Is it people cannot ask questions that they don't know? Stupid?
u r not stupid but u r
no upbringing, uncivilised, uncultured,
gravely impertinent. 沒教養 沒文明 沒文化 沒禮貌. 讀屎片啦汝
พี่น้องคนไทยไตย ลาว
คนผู้ไท อยู่ที่จีน
ที่จีนไม่มีภูไทภูไทยอยู่ที่ประเทศไทยและประเทศลาว
เจ้าลองฟังนาทีที่3.20เด้อ ฟังเด้อข่อยสิเเปลให้ฟัง พี่น้องทั้งหลาย อำเภอเหวินซานนี่มีผู้ไท16000คน อยู่กัน3เมืองคือเมืองเหวินซาน หม่าก๊วน หม่าลีโพ เมืองเหวินซานเมืองหม่าก๊วน เป็นผู้ไทมาเเต่12 ปันนา เมืองมาลีโพนี้ เป็นผู้ไทมาเเต่เมืองไท ขึ้นมาทางเมืองเเกว ตอนหลังจังขึ้นมาถึงเมืองนี้ ผู้ไทตั้งเเต่เก่ามา กะฮักบ้านเมืองฮักพี้น้อง เคารพกฏหมายมีมารยาท ใจดีขยันฮู้จักต้อนฮับฮู้จังร้องจักลำ
เจ้าลองฟังเบิงกอน จังมาว่าข่อย ข่อยคนผู้ไทข่อยฟังออกข่อยศึกษาภาษาตระกูลไตกะไดมา ข่อยฟังออก มันกะภาษาผู้ไทนั้นละเเต่เป็นสำเนียงจีน คือไตลื้ออยู่สิบสองปันนาหั่นละ
ฟังแล้วจร้าท่านก็ไม่เห็นจะเหมือนภาษาภูไทเลยประเพณีก็ไม่เหมือนกันการแต่งกายดนตรีเพลงไม่เห็นจะเหมือนภูไทเลยภูไทยจะเหมือนอิสานมากกว่าเช่นรำภูไทยก็ใช้ดนตรีอิสานทั่งนั่น
ถ้าถูไทอยู่จีนทำไหมลาวตอนบนติดจีนเวียดนามไม่มีภูไทยเลย
บอเห็นเเปลกเลย วัฒนธรรมมันมีการปรับเปลียน ไปตามสภาพเเวดล้อมอยู่เเล้ว สิเอาหยังมาคือกัน ขนาด ผู้ไทยุสกล ยังบอคือผู้ไทอยู่มุกดาหาร ขนาดผู้ไทอยู่กาฬสินธุ์ยังบอคือผู้ไทอยู่นครพนม ผู้ไทอยู่ไทย ยังบอคือผู้ไทอยู่ลาวเลย อัญญาเอ้ย
Rice cook in bamboo like in Malay lembang
In Assam, India we have a similar dish called sunga pitha where sticky rice is cooked in bamboo.
Another Kradai speaking people in china.
Phu Noong mưng chiu
跟越南传统跳大神的巫婆装束很相似。