Absolut! Sie hat eine schöne Stimme, das lässt sich nicht abstreiten. Aber verdammt! Klingt wie eine Mischung aus Rasmus und Within Temptation! Das waren noch geile Zeiten, als Dorian, Alicia und BJ dabei waren...
Alter wie geil is dat denn? Hätt ich ja nich gedacht das der Song so burnt ey. Ich find die neue Bestzung recht gelungen, mal was anderes als dieses langweilige gestöhne von Dorian. Manja du bis ne geile Sau :-) Dino du bist eh der Beste, Chai hat den längsten und Chris, fedden Headlessbass alter:-)
i remember them playing at a little festival in my hometown, nobody knew they had a new singer, almost everybody left instantanously :D this just isn't JoE anymore, glad there was nothing after this piece of junk
@pancakerepairman That comparison fits the most...don't know how so many here can think it sounds like Nightwish. Why is Nightwish such a big measuring tool anyways - they may have been the first with this kind of sound, but there are many better comparable bands meanwhile i think...
*Alte-Menschen-Brille aufsetz* Früher war alles besser! ^^ Aber gut. Gegen die neu Besetzung kann ich jetzt nicht viel sagen. Es hört sich gut an. Auch wenn ich es an sich schade finde das Dorian weg ist. Aber so ist es nun mal gekommen und es ist zwar anders aber nicht unbedingt schlechter geworden. :) Wünschen wir ihnen Erfolg. ;)
@MsEvangelice i agree on the part where dorians voice was better but the band has been through alot but this is not a copy of any other band besides old JOE its still there
@Jinelle0212 it does sound just like another goth nightwish rip off, not that she isn't good but i really like this dorian guy kinda sounds like marlyin manson lol
Ich würde nie sagen die Musik ist schlecht, halt anders als gewohnt von JoE und mehr richtung The Birthday Massacre - aber die hört man (ich) schliesslich auch gern. Aber n iPhone rockt mal so überhaupt nich. :P
ganz ehrlich... klingt sehr nach Evanescence, also find ich jetzt... der Song an sich is ja ganz ok aber es is halt nicht Dorian´s einzigartige Stimme : /
They should change their name. This is not Jesus On Extasy at all! another female fronted "gothic metal" bleh! Does anyone know what Dorian is doing now?
JOE mit Frauenstimme.... neee das ist nicht wirklich mein Geschmack. Mit Dorian klang es viel besser, vor allem weil Manja so eine ziemlich normale Stimme hat... Im großen und ganzen ist es ja nicht schlecht, aber ich mag es echt nicht! :(
I'm not a fan of this song in the slightest. Sounds like a more industrial version of pretty much EVERY female fronted "Goth Metal" band I have ever heard. That being said, I'm sure there are people out there that will enjoy this. I'm still not 100% sure if I like the new sound, guess the new album will tell. The is something the other albums had that this song does not, be it Dorian, or something else. Either way, what does my opinion matter?
I am beginning to think that the "gothic metal" fanbase is unbearable. Tarja leaves nightwish and everyone is suddenly cutting themselves and crying that Baaaw it iwll not be the same, despite the band sound better now. Now yet another case with this band and the so called "fans" crying their lungs out and crying blood tears that their "god" has left the building. Oh well. Band moved on. they grew up. They evolved. They sound better. Deal with it. Don't like it - move on, stop btiching.
Awesome band, awesome song, a big influence!
Stumbled across this video on accident. Not sure what's up with the comments but I quite like this song. Very catchy lyrics :)
2nd
Nicely done! Can't wait to hear the rest of the album.
Omg i knew this band from vampire freaks when i was a teen🥹🖤
Sehr geil.....:)
i love JOE new music new sound cant get much better than this :D
Sehr geil! Der Song, das Video...bin begeistert!
Dorian leaves + Chai takes full control = all new JoE ^^
Suenan como Leaves Eyes
I don't care about what everybody else say I really like this song I think it's one f their bst
Einfach nur geil ^^
das ist neu oda ?! wie genial =) ich liebe diese Band
Mit der neuen Besetzung ist die Band gestorben ..nun kann man sich nurnoch an den alten Liedern erfreuen -.-
Sehr geiles Lied! Auf jeden Fall. Und das Video harmoniert perfekt dazu. :)
Weiter so Leute !!!!!
Exelente me gusta.....zero emo....yeah......i like it
Dorian!!! Come back!
cooles Video :) und gutes Lied ! freu mich schon euch live zu sehen
Hatse jut gemacht, die Jazz ^^
Now they sound like late Crematory with female vocals ))
DORIAN
where are u babe? :'(
😆😆👍👍👍
This reminds me of the Birthday Massacre
Absolut! Sie hat eine schöne Stimme, das lässt sich nicht abstreiten. Aber verdammt! Klingt wie eine Mischung aus Rasmus und Within Temptation! Das waren noch geile Zeiten, als Dorian, Alicia und BJ dabei waren...
Dorian left after 2010 to start a new band. JoE was dissolved, then came back in 2011 with some new members and a new vocalist.
I miss the old stuff, I love the rhythm but I prefer Dorian's voice
I was thinking, why the band is still called JOE if only the original alignment is chai?
Still love JOE was kind of disappointed of the new singer but JOE still sound like them so its all good
Alter wie geil is dat denn? Hätt ich ja nich gedacht das der Song so burnt ey. Ich find die neue Bestzung recht gelungen, mal was anderes als dieses langweilige gestöhne von Dorian. Manja du bis ne geile Sau :-) Dino du bist eh der Beste, Chai hat den längsten und Chris, fedden Headlessbass alter:-)
hu cool ;) und in der stadt essen gedreht ;)
pretty good birthday massacre imitation
Hölkeskampring \m/ yay
.....WHAT HAPPENED TO DORIAN?
i remember them playing at a little festival in my hometown, nobody knew they had a new singer, almost everybody left instantanously :D
this just isn't JoE anymore, glad there was nothing after this piece of junk
wirklich ein gutes lied obgleich ich sagen muss das zb. assassinate me irgentwie besser ist;kann auch sein,das ich mich hierran nicht gewöhnt hab´.
They still have the same members...I think.
What ever happen to the lead singer Dorian?
Klingt wie die holländische band "autumn"
@pancakerepairman
That comparison fits the most...don't know how so many here can think it sounds like Nightwish. Why is Nightwish such a big measuring tool anyways - they may have been the first with this kind of sound, but there are many better comparable bands meanwhile i think...
3++
where can i find the lyrics?
@MsEvangelice I AGREE...!!! Manja's voice I did not like at all ... the song sounds good ... but only for a moment expect to hear Dorian :(
*Alte-Menschen-Brille aufsetz* Früher war alles besser! ^^
Aber gut. Gegen die neu Besetzung kann ich jetzt nicht viel sagen. Es hört sich gut an. Auch wenn ich es an sich schade finde das Dorian weg ist. Aber so ist es nun mal gekommen und es ist zwar anders aber nicht unbedingt schlechter geworden. :)
Wünschen wir ihnen Erfolg. ;)
@MsEvangelice i agree on the part where dorians voice was better but the band has been through alot but this is not a copy of any other band besides old JOE its still there
what the hell man, a female singer, seriously, we want the old joe back, we want dorian back
Girl singing in JoE? wtf!
one more female vocal band same to all others
Someone tell what happened to the band? Why did they change singers?
Hm, at first I expected them to sound heavier or darker, judging from the video... It's still a very nice song though
in dem video kommt manjas stimme zumindest besser zu geltung als live... da konnte sie mich leider nicht ganz so überzeugen :(
ansonsten super song :)
@Jinelle0212 whats wrong with nightwish
didn't they have a Singer???
@trylayser66616 Yah i liked better the old vocalist better too. But the new one isin't that bad
though Dorian wasn't the best singer, they sounded unique. this...sounds like Nightwish or something =.=
this is a completely different fucking band xD
The old band was much better
not my taste... old songs were better
@Jinelle0212 it does sound just like another goth nightwish rip off, not that she isn't good but i really like this dorian guy kinda sounds like marlyin manson lol
Dorian Deveraux will always be missed. He was so much better than this!
Ich würde nie sagen die Musik ist schlecht, halt anders als gewohnt von JoE und mehr richtung The Birthday Massacre - aber die hört man (ich) schliesslich auch gern.
Aber n iPhone rockt mal so überhaupt nich. :P
ganz ehrlich... klingt sehr nach Evanescence, also find ich jetzt...
der Song an sich is ja ganz ok aber es is halt nicht Dorian´s einzigartige Stimme : /
They should change their name. This is not Jesus On Extasy at all! another female fronted "gothic metal" bleh!
Does anyone know what Dorian is doing now?
I don't know, if I'm the only one, but I think, with Dorian's Voice, JOE was much better. This soundz like some Nightwish- or Evanescance-Copy. Sry.
Короче группа сдохла...
JOE mit Frauenstimme.... neee das ist nicht wirklich mein Geschmack. Mit Dorian klang es viel besser, vor allem weil Manja so eine ziemlich normale Stimme hat...
Im großen und ganzen ist es ja nicht schlecht, aber ich mag es echt nicht! :(
It's ok, but not the unique stuff they were offering before. When I want to hear this kind of music I would just tune some Birthday Massacre :/
SHIT...
What shit is it ?
J-O-E is complete crap without dorian!
I'm not a fan of this song in the slightest.
Sounds like a more industrial version of pretty much EVERY female fronted "Goth Metal" band I have ever heard.
That being said, I'm sure there are people out there that will enjoy this.
I'm still not 100% sure if I like the new sound, guess the new album will tell.
The is something the other albums had that this song does not, be it Dorian, or something else. Either way, what does my opinion matter?
This wasn't what I expected... Not bad, but I don't like it.
This is disappointing. There are plenty of bands that sound like this now. I prefer the old stuff. This sounds like an attempt at mainstream success.
I am beginning to think that the "gothic metal" fanbase is unbearable.
Tarja leaves nightwish and everyone is suddenly cutting themselves and crying that Baaaw it iwll not be the same, despite the band sound better now.
Now yet another case with this band and the so called "fans" crying their lungs out and crying blood tears that their "god" has left the building.
Oh well. Band moved on. they grew up. They evolved. They sound better. Deal with it. Don't like it - move on, stop btiching.
This is shockingly bad.