The funniest part was a solder asked an oriental looking reporter "where you from ?" The guy was trembling and replied "Hong Kong". The solder said that doesn't sound American, and shot him dead. I think HK was carefully chosen by the producer, or director, because they could not use Korea or Japan, it would cause a lot of resentment when showing the movie in these US ally countries. They probably didn't want to use China because that may cause diplomatic tension. So they choose Hong Kong, a place most people can relate to but too insignificant that it didn't matter if they got offended or not ! I wonder what reactions they got from Hong Kong audiences, lol.
I don't think so, it simply means that the producers think HK is no different than any other parts of China. Even the soldier repeated the word "China" after he shot the guy. The film is not afraid to utter the word "China". They just thought HK is China. Nothing more, nothing less.
I am from Hong Kong too... Perhaps the director want to express white supremacy still exists in US society nowadays. The soilder (with red sun glasses) killed two guys without hesitation based on the nationality and race (one guy look like red Indian and other confirmed he was from Hong Kong)
Good Cantonese commentary about the film. Really discussing the details and values of the film. The director purposely vague how the civil war was broken and open for audience discussion. I am not understanding > the scene of the soldier (wearing red glasses) treatment with the corpse. He spreaded some white powder (lime) on the corpse > what is the purpose. Also why so many civilian was killed and scretely buried the corpse? It is one of the most shocking war film I even seen. I watched "the killing field", "the full metal jacket". But only "civil war" able to put audience situated at real battle engage scenes between two troops.
![[Part 1] ทารกน้อยถูกทิ้ง👶 หญิงชราเก็บขวดขายเลี้ยงดูเขาจนโต #โลกการละคร](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nPTDvFCExks/mqdefault.jpg)
😂😂俾Fox 給愛國之心鼓動過後， 又真係覺得港譯片名出色。 嗱嗱嗱， 愛中國者要睇夠十次㗎！
其中一段好如笑，有香港記者在途中，俾反叛軍問佢地係乜人，答，香港人🤣，反叛軍話香港？？即係中國啦。。。。。。反叛軍即時開槍殺死😮😮
我哋都可拍番套！問你來自那裡, 那人答加州, 之後士兵說, 即係美國啦！即 kill
@@kkho575你所指嘅我哋係邊個國家先，唔係人哋拍你又拍，要有自知之明。
@@guysmart7028 梗係中國啦！我哋的祖國！
嗰段大快人心😂👍
唔好打咁多飛機！壞腦㗎！
好耐冇開台😂❤
前晚開完🤣🤣
TH-cam冇通知 錯過咗😂 @@jermany2023
我覺得個對望笑同Lee 死係因為佢地享受作為戰地記者同覺悟
係個尾，女主角中槍果幕係比較硬造作出來。
美國可以拍美國崩潰，但中國可否拍中國崩潰？
民主國與獨裁國的分別！
小熊維尼都唔上得，你話呢😂
大陸十年前拍過一套電影叫大明劫，Fall of Ming，現在網上都有得睇，故事背景人物都寫實反映明帝國崩潰前夕。
美国真系会内战，20年之内。中国崩溃，讲好耐啦，咪一样90万人去送中。
历朝历代有个规律叫300年怪圈。你数一数现在中国有没有到300年？没到就不会崩溃。
分裂後會更強大呀? 咁佢哋就快分裂囉
來到我最後一代，地球上只有尾帝，沒有米國😅
*Thank you Jermany for this episode, wish you a nice holiday !*
Fox 狼， 會唔會講下個套鐵人狗狗呀 都好睇喎， 想聽下你嘅影評😂❤
未睇，近排睇左幾套戲同追緊劇，前日先睇左無限制軍團，劇就睇緊幕府將軍同fallout😂😂
我都聽你同阿j呀講嗰套莫副將軍 都諗住睇不過未有時間 😂@@jermany2023
由頭好睇到尾，係Lee死得太求其，結局完得太急。
Hong Kong？China 砰😂
中國人就愛
聯合國《世界移民報告2022》(World Migration Report 2022)，1970年至2020年中國在向美國移民的國家中居第三位。移民美國最多的是墨西哥人，其次是印度人 。
2020年之後中國升做第一位！
@@edwardyiuming咁咁多年霉遠程畜牧業唔係白做，如果唔係國內就冇咁多殖畜。而三哥，首選一定是大麻國呀、北歐這種高福利國家。而南美，乜他們在你眼中是人嗎？
@@lautommy9498 所謂走線去美國近三年急升！
中国人口常年世界第一。
@lainfonet 那又怎樣，別人沒像你整天吹捧自己國家卻連移民都叫不回來。
Where you from? Hong Kong..."Ping "....China. 真係忍唔住...！
眾議院剛剛似乎將《聖經》新約定為非法…猶太人殺死基督的說法定義為反猶…有乜辦法吾分裂…
你篇影評好似讀稿咁？喺記者角度出發令套戲好睇咗？好睇在邊到？你冇講，同埋你講德州加州聯盟 套戲冇交代 因為喺記者角度出發小人物未必知道，唔通呢個係令套戲好睇咗嘅原因嗎？😂
The funniest part was a solder asked an oriental looking reporter "where you from ?" The guy was trembling and replied "Hong Kong". The solder said that doesn't sound American, and shot him dead.
I think HK was carefully chosen by the producer, or director, because they could not use Korea or Japan, it would cause a lot of resentment when showing the movie in these US ally countries. They probably didn't want to use China because that may cause diplomatic tension. So they choose Hong Kong, a place most people can relate to but too insignificant that it didn't matter if they got offended or not !
I wonder what reactions they got from Hong Kong audiences, lol.
I don't think so, it simply means that the producers think HK is no different than any other parts of China. Even the soldier repeated the word "China" after he shot the guy. The film is not afraid to utter the word "China". They just thought HK is China. Nothing more, nothing less.
I am from Hong Kong too...
Perhaps the director want to express white supremacy still exists in US society nowadays.
The soilder (with red sun glasses) killed two guys without hesitation based on the nationality and race (one guy look like red Indian and other confirmed he was from Hong Kong)
Good Cantonese commentary about the film. Really discussing the details and values of the film.
The director purposely vague how the civil war was broken and open for audience discussion.
I am not understanding > the scene of the soldier (wearing red glasses) treatment with the corpse. He spreaded some white powder (lime) on the corpse > what is the purpose. Also why so many civilian was killed and scretely buried the corpse?
It is one of the most shocking war film I even seen. I watched "the killing field", "the full metal jacket". But only "civil war" able to put audience situated at real battle engage scenes between two troops.
辛苦波波既影評～就咁聽，好似覺得係...同顏色有關，不過只係係美國？
睇套戲內容就知道咩叫言論自由只係電影講話唔畀咩,對比某啲地方
因為，美國有國安法，所以，加州德州獨立唔到，所以拍出片出黎打飛機。
蜘蛛女老很快
佢後生20幾歲果時我都已經覺得佢好老相
真正民族自信，不是得把口講😂
因為，美國有國安法，所以，加州德州獨立唔到，所以拍出片出黎打飛機。
@@catladderhk 大陸及香港都有法，又唔見得可以拍中共崩裂，港共末日😝
@@helloma5788联邦国家，政体不同，两党恨不得把这片禁了 除了美国欧洲也不敢拍 你不会因为某个片头破防了吧港仔😂
認同說法🤩👍👍@@helloma5788
@@helloma5788 「強國支爆」?
蘇聯分裂後俄羅斯是否更強大？ 有分裂的基石會令國家更強大的說法是攞黎講的廢話。
譯名要倒扣10分，應該譯為美麗風景線😊
名字真係改得好好
霍士说得好，有兴趣入场见证美帝灭亡了
要統一才強大，這是美國歷史追求的強大，歐洲尋求的強大，你要讀多點歷史書。唔好好似小學雞咁
電影以戰地記者嘅角度去睇戰爭係好好👍🏻
不過我覺得某啲場面有啲到喉唔到肺，如果可以再鑽deep D，令觀眾感受到戰地記者嘅兩難、無奈同危險，咁會更好😊
另外，我都同意最後無人理”李”係好唔合理，我覺得”當”女主角被爆頭明顯無得救，Jessie 就最後都幫佢影一張相去紀錄佢嘅犧牲，咁我會覺得好震撼人心❤
幾時開反隻講金像獎😃
前晚開左直播講😂😂
其實德州好快都會變藍州，大量加州人為咗避稅走咗落德州，已經令德州越來越藍。
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
直頭係崩壞
真係得美帝拍得出，仲要xx埋自己總統。試吓搵人拍套中共xx，即日畀國安拉咗啦。一個國家強大，在於佢嘅自信，唔需要成日自卑心作崇，話人哋亡我之心不死。
刚在洛杉矶看完。观后感：对香港人的民族性做了准确的表现。
因為，中國無可能分裂，裂唔到，美國係可以裂到，讀多書個人就唔咁柒。
因為 尾角 人民有 自知之明！
自卑心因為共產黨實行資本主義，覺得自己七
戰狼國經常話自己好強大！佢有條靚叫「疣痔及㷫」！一樣咁X👈🤭❗❗😂😂😂
完全唔交代點解會內占！
完全唔交代點解煞果2個香港人！
實在太多嘢唔交代，呢部電影只值５分！
這套電影導演刻意模事情發展 > 給觀眾思考+討論空間
不交代
1. 內戰怎樣發生 (其實細節可以找到 > 總統違反憲法 > 部份美國人不滿意)
2. 為何隨意殺兩個非美裔人 > 導演嘗試表達一部份美國人仍然存白人至上觀念 > 非我種類即死...
Remarks:-
這套是思考電影 >
一般受傳統訓練思維
大佬話怎樣就怎樣的人
很難接受電影不交代細節😅
所以不喜歡這套電影...
但部份人正正喜歡這樣的思考電影😅
刚在洛杉矶看完。观后感：对香港人的民族性做了准确的表现。
是, 中國人！ 大家都是同胞！
@@kkho575 不是同胞！不喜欢香港人，互相尊重
@@kkho575只针对黄丝，最近英国的海外税收，美国的亚裔细分，加上这电影，黄丝估计内心已经快崩溃了。😂
不不不，你们高端一点，你们是睁眼看世界的第一人。😂我们可跟你们不一样，我们是顽固的，愚昧的。@@kkho575
@@michaellee1191但是真正的中国人谁会在意呢？😂这棒子又打不到我们身上。😂
真係好奇怪，啲音樂明明應該緊張就播啲輕輕鬆鬆的文歌
中國自古以來內戰都當飯食，美帝嗰啲算乜春啊
并不一样，中国内战总有人出来统一中国。罗马灭亡就再也没有罗马，欧洲的历史规律就是刚开始强大就在一起，国家衰落就分裂了。
@@何应钦-c2q你嘅所謂強大，有什么標準？
@@guysmart7028当你问出这种问题的时候，你也就失去了被回答的资格
强大就系今时今日你都用紧中文。@@guysmart7028
女配角好靚 期待佢套異形
呀Lee好突然喺最大戰場變咗傻仔
德克薩斯共和國
孤星共和國先係正式名😂😂😂😂
改能錯晒,遅D美帝隊長4呀,擦晒大陸鞋,一個國家冇民主先可以叫帝,大陸應該叫陸帝!
錯！ 蝦蝦霸霸先叫帝！
女配角個屎忽好正
尾 角 有自知之明！
你做人心地唔好!d中國人偷渡都要去美國呀!崩裂!
14亿人出几只曱甴很正常吧
我响美国，而家我都想返大陆了，呢度D治安真好差，种族歧视严重，税又重，同我26年前黎美国差太太太远。20年内，美国内战不是梦。
@@慕晓辉現在最多十二億。
@@Kitlam-G那你回國了嗎？😂😂😂
@@dhvdbsadjksb3686 6/10的机票。危邦不居。
狗up👎👎👎👎👎👎👎
垃圾第4權
妖言
87😢悶到抽筋
幾時有中國崩裂…
刚在洛杉矶看完。观后感：对香港人的民族性做了准确的表现。
@@lainfonet 中國人應該成日想中X崩壞🤣😂😅🥴
@@yukin1990 讲就无敌，做就不但无能为力，仲最怕橪死。
@@lainfonet 愛中國嘅你為甚麼在美國？做間諜？
@@lainfonetd人唔识死。落后就挨打的道理，距地理解唔到，好似d生活不如意噶人，成日想世界末日。其实都几可怜
遲早來變真實！
无论怎么说，hk人在美国白人眼里就是如此
大爛片
非常難看