honestly anyone saying they wouldnt have snapped like Homura did is lying to themselves. No one could fail that many times and still stay sane. also her intentions were to "save" Madoka. Effectively being erased from existing isnt really being saved so I doubt this would be something Homura was satisfied with.
No the fact that she said that she want to save Madoka by redo their meeting is already insane. There's still a way for her to save her without do that.
@@966aAad "I wish that Madoka can't become a magical girl, and by that I want her to be alive right now" "I wish that I can replace Madoka as a magical girl in every timeline" "I want to resurect Madoka" "I wish that Madoka won't meet you (Kyubey) in the past" "I wish to go back to the past and Madoka doens't meet you, know about magical girl and all that shit" Something like that probably..
@@istaka1416 I don't think she knew about all the horrors of being a magical girl at that point. She couldn't unwish it, and plus I think Homura was lonely prior (I think it was confirmed that she was an orphan. It wasn't mentioned if she had any friends at the hospital either.) to meeting Madoka, and Homura meeting Madoka was one of the happiness moments of her life. So that's probably a reason why she wanted to redo their meeting, and protect her.
Fucking hate Madoka's va lmao. She's used in every anime ever. So tired of hearing her voice considering she never changes it for the character she's voicing.
@@inactive_ina Really? I heard her twice. In the show K-ON and then Madoka Magica. I hear Kyubey in Madoka Magica and K-On. Hitomi’s voice (Girl who also has a crush on Sayaka’s crush) on here and K-On and Homura’s voice on here, K-ON, Miraculous ladybug, Kakegurui and helluva boss. So I’m personally more annoyed with Cristina Vee being literally everywhere. Can you tell me what anime titles you headed Madoka’s voice? The fact I don’t watch that many anime’s might be the cause of it Edit:Just noticed this was from a year ago. But if your still willing to answer please enlighten me
@@Bubblegum_Bitter_Girlie I mean, she's in Violet Evergarden, Neptunia, Nanatsu no Taizai somewhere, she makes common cameos or voices smaller background characters in alot of anime; those examples are just a few She's in alot of other games too, like Stella Glow or Labyrinth of Refrain I just hate how little she changes her voice to fit her character, she just uses the same exact voice for like everything it never changes I do think Vee is used alot too, but she's actually capable of adjusting her voice to fit the character lol
@@inactive_ina Oh! I haven’t seen or heard of those. Also obviously Vee is always around. That’s why it’s pretty easy to notice her from me. But I can see the characters persona. As for Madoka’s voice actor. I think she’s slightly better in K-ON But compared to Cristina where I need to listen to her for 3 minutes to find out if it’s her when it’s a series I don’t know I instantly notice when she’s a character I’ve seen before. Though maybe it’s cause I watch both Madoka and K-ON a lot? They are my favorite out of the small group of anime’s I’ve watched
@@codingpikachu3333 And the world will always remember how interesting it is that the same crime can elicit admiration and repulsion. Such is the nature of Selfish Love.
Something I noticed that Touhou and PMMM have a lot of common fans. Another thing I noticed is that probably the reason behind this is the ridiculous amount of Yuri fanwork the both franchises have.
There are a lot of thematic similarities in Touhou project and Madoka Magica: Almost all girl cast Characters based in mythology and folklore (Japanese Mythology and European Fairy Tales) LGBTQ subtext Complex rules regarding magical use (Spell card rules for Touhou and Enthalpy/entropy for Madoka) Seems innocent on the surface, lots of underlying tragedy and sadness
@@johnmorrell3187 Evidence for? My evidence against is that Mami doesn't want to be alone and now has Nagisa, Kyoko and Sayaka are besties as Kyoko always intended but couldn't manage. Sayaka gets to hear Kyosuke play, all while not being heartbroken about it, she didn't erase her maturity. In addition to dealing with the Wraith issue herself, since other MGs have their powers suppressed to have a happy, normal lives (unless that's specifically the girls of Holy Quintet?) The only person that we know of where this gets sticky is with Madoka, who would've continued to hurt herself, literally forever, unless Homura helped her. It's like a mental patient that won't stop clawing his own skin off, the straight jacket is appropriate for him. Ironically, this makes Madoka the mental patient and Homura the Nurse. Now yes, what Madoka is doing is saving people, but is it really? When people are saved, they become part of the Law of Cycles, as evidenced by the Witch Card of Oktavia for Rebellion. Madoka is destined to have her soul split in half, causing her to not exist but for the Grief God and Hope Goddess to be born, with the latter being given Madoka's memories. Would this not erase everyone else as well? Thus not be helping?
@@wilderbeast9368 Here is the thing, even if Homura is right, she isnt doing it for the right reasons, Madoka made the ultimate selfless action, Homura the ultimate selfish one. Homuras wish was to save Madoka, which Madokas wish directly went against by basically erasing her own existence for the sake of others. Both sacrifice themselves for others, yes. But Madoka takes in the weight of the world while the only thing Homura cares about is Madoka, at least in the original series, she was ready to kill Madokas best friend there if it prevented Madoka from being sad and becoming a Magical girl. She created a "perfect" world in the end mostly for Madoka, not for any of the others. The others are only there for Madoka. Yes maybe she "likes" the others, she at least doesn't hate them, but I have no doubt Homura would sacrifice everyone else for Madoka if she had to.
Wilderbeast I think Homura, in theory, did nothing right. But the things she do aren’t morally white either. She’s just selfish, and all of her actiona focus around Madoka. Yes she tries to save Madoka from her cycle of pain (which IS a good thing, and is morally right). And the amount of suffering she had to endure might be an excuse to what she did at the end of Rebellion. But, that does not change the fact that she created a rather broken world. Also she accepts that she’s a demon. Even Homura doesn’t think Homura is right.
it might be because I'm missing something since it's been a while since I've watched Rebellion, but from what I can recall Kyubey says (in the anime) that the soul gems are their "real bodies", so to speak and their "bodies" are merely vessels and cannot feel pain. So why does Mami (unsuccessfully might I add) try to stop Homura from gunning herself? Do their bodies still cease to function if they die under normal circumstances? (Like shooting through the brain or being pierced through the heart)
@@mimo__.- ah that is what I thought. Which of course begs the question of why Mami tried to stop Homura, since feasibly speaking that should not have had an effect. Though, she was already gone by the time the rest of the Holy Quintet discovered the truth about the soul gems, so maybe she simply didn't know?
@@lilypyrope4620 oh yeah sorry I didn't answer your question, it's because mami didn't know (I believe) about the truth of their soul gems so she thought homura was truly trying to gun herself
Homura uses actual guns but has an inventory Mami can straight up create rifles but they’re single shot Fun fact- Homura stole those guns from the Mafia
I see. Hm.. I just thought about the subs cause the lyrics conveys a good amount of the feelings (Homura's pain and etc). However, on the other side, you're right about spoiling the visual of the video.
![[Madoka Magica AMV] Homura Akemi - Echo](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pKWGHLLpm28/mqdefault.jpg)
it's funny how homura's English voice actor is the same person who sings the English version of bad apple
which eng dub
Ikr!
Really? I didn't know about the dub version, but I know the singer.
Which English version? Cristina Vee?
Didn't Cristina voice kyoko?
"A hero would sacrifice you to save the world but a villain will sacrifice the world to save you."
honestly anyone saying they wouldnt have snapped like Homura did is lying to themselves. No one could fail that many times and still stay sane. also her intentions were to "save" Madoka. Effectively being erased from existing isnt really being saved so I doubt this would be something Homura was satisfied with.
No the fact that she said that she want to save Madoka by redo their meeting is already insane. There's still a way for her to save her without do that.
@@istaka1416 and this way is?
@@966aAad "I wish that Madoka can't become a magical girl, and by that I want her to be alive right now"
"I wish that I can replace Madoka as a magical girl in every timeline"
"I want to resurect Madoka"
"I wish that Madoka won't meet you (Kyubey) in the past"
"I wish to go back to the past and Madoka doens't meet you, know about magical girl and all that shit"
Something like that probably..
@@istaka1416 I don't think she knew about all the horrors of being a magical girl at that point. She couldn't unwish it, and plus I think Homura was lonely prior (I think it was confirmed that she was an orphan. It wasn't mentioned if she had any friends at the hospital either.) to meeting Madoka, and Homura meeting Madoka was one of the happiness moments of her life. So that's probably a reason why she wanted to redo their meeting, and protect her.
@@mydog4289 not to mention she just watched Madoka die, so surely she couldn’t have been in the right mindset to make a proper wish
This song is perfect for Madoka Magica-- happy and ditzy on the outside, depressing af on the inside
I never felt that it was happy or ditzy, not even sonically. Like I always got such pained/angry vibes from the instrumental and vocals.
It's amazing how the lyrics fit so well with Homura's history
ほむVSマミのシーンがカッコよすぎる
あと映画作画神
i love madoka magica
Same
Sophie chan 92 94 so do I.
Dito! Sorry I mean me too
Me as well
지수영 오늘 날씨 진짜 내가 좋아하는 사람들은
Currently listening to this on full blast. I may be busting my eardrums but it's honestly the True Homura Experience
😂😂😂
I love Madoka's English voice actor she sounds so gentle and warm. And she voice acts Hotaru Tomoe or Sailor Saturn in Sailor Moon the Viz Media dub!
And Homura's English VA voices Sailor Mars in the VIZ Dub too 🤣
Fucking hate Madoka's va lmao. She's used in every anime ever. So tired of hearing her voice considering she never changes it for the character she's voicing.
@@inactive_ina Really? I heard her twice. In the show K-ON and then Madoka Magica. I hear Kyubey in Madoka Magica and K-On. Hitomi’s voice (Girl who also has a crush on Sayaka’s crush) on here and K-On and Homura’s voice on here, K-ON, Miraculous ladybug, Kakegurui and helluva boss. So I’m personally more annoyed with Cristina Vee being literally everywhere. Can you tell me what anime titles you headed Madoka’s voice? The fact I don’t watch that many anime’s might be the cause of it
Edit:Just noticed this was from a year ago. But if your still willing to answer please enlighten me
@@Bubblegum_Bitter_Girlie I mean, she's in Violet Evergarden, Neptunia, Nanatsu no Taizai somewhere, she makes common cameos or voices smaller background characters in alot of anime; those examples are just a few
She's in alot of other games too, like Stella Glow or Labyrinth of Refrain
I just hate how little she changes her voice to fit her character, she just uses the same exact voice for like everything it never changes
I do think Vee is used alot too, but she's actually capable of adjusting her voice to fit the character lol
@@inactive_ina Oh! I haven’t seen or heard of those. Also obviously Vee is always around. That’s why it’s pretty easy to notice her from me. But I can see the characters persona. As for Madoka’s voice actor. I think she’s slightly better in K-ON But compared to Cristina where I need to listen to her for 3 minutes to find out if it’s her when it’s a series I don’t know I instantly notice when she’s a character I’ve seen before. Though maybe it’s cause I watch both Madoka and K-ON a lot? They are my favorite out of the small group of anime’s I’ve watched
When I got to the end of rebellion:
No... No no ... NO ... I will not let this happen
NO NO NO NO NO NO! No!
I was like YES YES YES YES YES YES! This is divine retribution, this will show Kyubey, WELL DONE HOMURA! xD
@@codingpikachu3333 And the world will always remember how interesting it is that the same crime can elicit admiration and repulsion. Such is the nature of Selfish Love.
@@codingpikachu3333 nicely said
Clap
Clap
C
L
A
P
C
Cl
Ap
Clap
Clap
Clap
Clap
Clap..
@@Asehpe Yes, indeed. Homura is the best! :D
Homura wish to go back to save madoka makes her basically immortal right? She cursed herself in a sort of groundhog day predicament with no end.
Bad Apple!!とまどマギを掛け合わせるっていう考えによく至れたな…
製作者さん軽く神ですね
ろくでなしって所で神への叛逆するの好き（語彙力）
Everyone who says homura a bad person hasn't understood the anime go watch it again
You are DAMN RIGHT pal
「ろくでなし」のところでmadも急展開するの好き（語彙力）
Something I noticed that Touhou and PMMM have a lot of common fans.
Another thing I noticed is that probably the reason behind this is the ridiculous amount of Yuri fanwork the both franchises have.
the more i dive into comments
the more i know about anime culture/memes
without watching the anime beforehand
well homura is obviously gay for madoka
@@eyekandi rebellion proved that canonically so it's legit
Song: bad apple
Kyoko: i am a joke to you?
Homura (after being hit by apple): i am?
not tomatoes?
LMFAOOO
TOMATOES
I thought they were tomatoes
さやかちゃん、かっこいいなぁ。
Great video! I like the focus on Homura -- you portray her really well
ほむらちゃん大好き
Homura did no thing wrong !!
She's just want protect her first freind , she is love......madoka 💔💔
방금 집에 왔어 카페
Oooohhhh one of my fav animes with my fav song yaaaaayyy i luv Touhou and madoka magicia.
Thanks, now there's another anime i wanna watch
2:17 Here I go replaying this scene repeatedly till I break the play button.
Wow english homura sings this
SakuranChibin n yup.
What's the name of her voice actor again?
@@roseorchids2248 Cristina Valenzuela (A.K.A. Cristina Vee)
反逆のさやかちゃんがかっこよすぎて...
We are going to be in a meeting in July to
We are not going to be there but I am
대전 중구 신당동 나 이제 집 도착했어요
homura is dope af
3:42 - 4:25 just epic. Very nice montage.
There are a lot of thematic similarities in Touhou project and Madoka Magica:
Almost all girl cast
Characters based in mythology and folklore (Japanese Mythology and European Fairy Tales)
LGBTQ subtext
Complex rules regarding magical use (Spell card rules for Touhou and Enthalpy/entropy for Madoka)
Seems innocent on the surface, lots of underlying tragedy and sadness
Homura is right. Someone, anyone, try to bring up at least one solid, inarguable point that she isn't.
she cares more about what she wants for others than what they want for themselves
@@johnmorrell3187 Evidence for? My evidence against is that Mami doesn't want to be alone and now has Nagisa, Kyoko and Sayaka are besties as Kyoko always intended but couldn't manage. Sayaka gets to hear Kyosuke play, all while not being heartbroken about it, she didn't erase her maturity. In addition to dealing with the Wraith issue herself, since other MGs have their powers suppressed to have a happy, normal lives (unless that's specifically the girls of Holy Quintet?) The only person that we know of where this gets sticky is with Madoka, who would've continued to hurt herself, literally forever, unless Homura helped her. It's like a mental patient that won't stop clawing his own skin off, the straight jacket is appropriate for him. Ironically, this makes Madoka the mental patient and Homura the Nurse. Now yes, what Madoka is doing is saving people, but is it really? When people are saved, they become part of the Law of Cycles, as evidenced by the Witch Card of Oktavia for Rebellion. Madoka is destined to have her soul split in half, causing her to not exist but for the Grief God and Hope Goddess to be born, with the latter being given Madoka's memories. Would this not erase everyone else as well? Thus not be helping?
@@wilderbeast9368 Here is the thing, even if Homura is right, she isnt doing it for the right reasons, Madoka made the ultimate selfless action, Homura the ultimate selfish one.
Homuras wish was to save Madoka, which Madokas wish directly went against by basically erasing her own existence for the sake of others. Both sacrifice themselves for others, yes. But Madoka takes in the weight of the world while the only thing Homura cares about is Madoka, at least in the original series, she was ready to kill Madokas best friend there if it prevented Madoka from being sad and becoming a Magical girl.
She created a "perfect" world in the end mostly for Madoka, not for any of the others. The others are only there for Madoka.
Yes maybe she "likes" the others, she at least doesn't hate them, but I have no doubt Homura would sacrifice everyone else for Madoka if she had to.
Wilderbeast I think Homura, in theory, did nothing right. But the things she do aren’t morally white either. She’s just selfish, and all of her actiona focus around Madoka. Yes she tries to save Madoka from her cycle of pain (which IS a good thing, and is morally right). And the amount of suffering she had to endure might be an excuse to what she did at the end of Rebellion. But, that does not change the fact that she created a rather broken world.
Also she accepts that she’s a demon. Even Homura doesn’t think Homura is right.
センス良すぎ…!
This AMV is still so great ! I came back to watch it again.
Wooow amazing AMV!!! Really like it ~ nice work!
Thank you!!!
Lesbian love is one hell of a drug
神曲＆神アニメ
Poor poor Homura : (
Ita criminal that they didnt use the Cristina Vee version.
SENTENCE: The Law of Cycles is forever lost to the creator of this video
Monsicorn to be fair, she hadn’t done the full length version of the song yet.
Lies but ok
The best anime Ever,, 👍👍
She is a stand user. Her stand is The Word.
When you realize Touhou was a Mahou Shoujo franchise since the beginning
I like it very much nos they are 33 likes :D I was thinking , this is AMAZING!!!
+Aditi Neko Kuroha Thank you so much!!! Please subscribe! :D
So beautiful
And thus the cycle of dystopia shall begin again...
Everything is fine until a wild Undertale fan appears from nowhere
3:53
Bro, why I'm imaging scene from Underverse when I see this...
To summarize this whole vid:
Homura is the biggest simp in history
juuuuuuuuuuust kidding.
or am I?
Este AMV me ayuda a concentrarme a mil!!! excelente AMV!
BEST CROSSOVER
omg homura é incrível!
Concordo
well done for the apple at end of the video :D
really nice work!
used it windows live movie maker :D?
+F 22Raptor (coolglock19) Thank you!! And no, I used Final Cut Pro X
AlexLopezMusic
is that easy use it? :D
if that was some kind of vegas pro..
soo frekin hard. i cant use that xD
No, it's very easy and works great
+AlexLopezMusic thanks man!
！！！すごい
love it!
+brendaly salas Thank you!
Your welcome😀 AlexLopezMusic
I want babymetal to make a version of this song
最高…
I love madoka magica and 2hu
it might be because I'm missing something since it's been a while since I've watched Rebellion, but from what I can recall Kyubey says (in the anime) that the soul gems are their "real bodies", so to speak and their "bodies" are merely vessels and cannot feel pain. So why does Mami (unsuccessfully might I add) try to stop Homura from gunning herself? Do their bodies still cease to function if they die under normal circumstances? (Like shooting through the brain or being pierced through the heart)
It's more like the gems are their actual souls, it makes their bodies kinda immortal as long as their soul gem isn't damaged
@@mimo__.- ah that is what I thought. Which of course begs the question of why Mami tried to stop Homura, since feasibly speaking that should not have had an effect. Though, she was already gone by the time the rest of the Holy Quintet discovered the truth about the soul gems, so maybe she simply didn't know?
@@lilypyrope4620 oh yeah sorry I didn't answer your question, it's because mami didn't know (I believe) about the truth of their soul gems so she thought homura was truly trying to gun herself
*the sync.*
Cool amv :3
19 likes?
Make tha now 20 :D
+Isaac :3 Thank you!!! Please subscribe!!!
+AlexLopezMusic I have :)
日本人いますか？👍
※いません
…… 居ます！！
※……居ません!!(^ω^)
※いません
…いませんといっている人は外国人なのかな？(笑)
日本人 又は さやか推し
又は 東方ファン
居ますか？
私は
日本人&東方ファン&さやか推しです!!
さやか可愛い～!!
(^ω^)(^ω^)
東方曲はいいよね!!
黒になれ!!(サビ)
へ？私もさやか推しの東方好きの日本人です！
おぉ～!!日本人居た～!!嬉しいです!!
@@milksakura9933 いぇーい
モノクレームproject イエーイ😃✌️!!
そうなんですか!?
奇遇ですね‼️
Homura did nothing wrong
Meencanta esta cancion laamo😘
lmao, people who haven't watched madoka magica must be getting the biggest wtf ever.
nostalgia
Dark
東方とまどマギなんてすげぇ
The FBI and the local police department of Japan has confiscated their guns because of owning one without license.
(Joking)
Homura uses actual guns but has an inventory
Mami can straight up create rifles but they’re single shot
Fun fact- Homura stole those guns from the Mafia
Hello there, nice AMV S2
Is it possible to sub it with English lyrics?
I'd prefer not to, I feel it ruins the video to have subtitles there
I see.
Hm.. I just thought about the subs cause the lyrics conveys a good amount of the feelings (Homura's pain and etc). However, on the other side, you're right about spoiling the visual of the video.
SpaceCadetAlex we can put yt subs... that u can turn on and off
호무라쨩...
What movie Is? Of mágica Madoka?
Madoka Magica: Rebellion
Wow thanks you >:3
Touhou's music!!
호무라❤
例え、世界中が敵に周っても
私は、ほむらちゃんが大好きよ
Hermoso
Badasssssss
Homura thank you 🙏🧞♀️🌌
Thanks? She turned evil and now they gonna half to defeat her or find how to turn her back.
Madoka
Does anyone know what the pink yarn resembles?
Which pink yarn? The one that ties up Homura? That's just how Mami's Magic power to ty things up looks.
@@andreavolker840 the thimble that falls bit I think it has to do with Madoka
@@FallenHalfWingedWolf I think it's Madokas old bow which she weared in her Hair.
すき
We are not sure if
Warning: Watch this at your own risk. If you get nausea easily, go out and rest.
Xian Baldelovar nope but thanks for the warning ⚠️
@@krystalkaname5941 be blessed.
Xian Baldelovar I hope I will.
호무라는 간지입니다♡
OKTAVIAAAAAAA
I loooooooooveeeeeeeeee iiiiiiiiit!!!!!!!❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
It's Mahou Shoujo not Mashou
Tabbender- I know, and just that I was wrong and now I can not change it
You can change it from your google+ page
Tabbender tanks😝
La frujaa negra aceptó protectora de los límites dimenciones y ayudarme contra el creador si nos pone límites a mi y a mi amor
쩐다
東方プロジェクトだー！
😭😭😭
지수영 오늘 하루도 잘 마무리 하시길 기원합니다 기원합니다 나 진짜 좋네요 난 왜 자꾸 나한테 너무 좋네요 난 오늘 날씨 오늘 하루도 화이팅 입니다 당신이 생각하는 태어난 이유 때문에 때문에 더
지수영 오늘 하루도 잘 보내고 있어 좋다 좋아 너무 좋아요 좋아요 누르고 싶은 생각이 들었다 오늘 날씨 정말 좋아요
supraise maza faka sopra baba
El faraón cronos existe en el otro planeta
Esta canción la tengo en osu uwu jzjzjz ♡
Movie??
Madoka Magica: Rebellion
호무호무
東方の曲じゃん…
what song?
Touhou Bad Apple
คนไทย
Alguem aqui br???
Assistimos a mesma droga desgraçada e agora somos irmãos