Playing "Act Naturally" without breaking rhythm is difficult in itself. Playing it while singing is remarkable. Playing it while singing on The Ed Sullivan Show before 73 million people is amazing.
Yeah, had that feeling he would be overlooked. He could bring it !! When I play the long extended version of "Get Ready", I allow my neighbors to enjoy it with me ! Great Detroit Rock and Soul !!!
He's not a great singer but the fact that his voice loses nothing single while playing that drum part is truly impressive. That rhythm is a bitch even when you're not singing.
That dude in Electric Light Orchestra is pretty good too. He was really getting into the singing in their performance of "Blinded by the Light" on "The Midnight Special" show.
Nick DiVirgilio of Spock's Beard and Big Big Train. Christian Vander of Magma. Bonus points for writing all his own lyrics in a language of his own construction.
@@gmoney1592 Paul only played a few songs and he had said that he can keep the beat and spread some energy but can not do more than that, besides he would not enjoy playing drums in a concert for more than a few songs
brilliant list! but i'd like to nominate Fyfe Ewing from Therapy?, as he was able to create such harsh, angry vocals whilst cooking up some of the absolute best drum beats at the same time!
If anyone’s a big fan of the stone roses they’d know there drummer was a very talented man who did the backing vocals for every song, Reni you bloody legend
I honestly would’ve thought Ringo would’ve been at least Top 3, he’s always the first person I think of but for some heavier representation I’d also include Jimmy “The Rev” Sullivan from Avenged Sevenfold’s (RIP) and Brann Dailor from Mastodon, those guys have killer voices as well
Missing Deen Castronovo, current drummer for Journey. During the early 2000s while they were struggling to find a new permanent vocalist he would sing a few songs and still does in their later sets. He has an absolutely insane range, almost as good as Steve Perry’s.
![Dave Grohl - Play [Isolated Drums]](/img/n.gif)
Not even a minute passed and they blocked the "Eagles" part.
Oh, man, one of my favorite songs, too: 'Cease and Desist' by Our Lawyers Will Be In Touch
Don Henley hated when his music is represented in modern technology like cameras and internet, he's petty asf.
Don is old man scrooge
Why was that done
@@marygordon9352 Don Henley hits TH-camrs with copyright strikes if they use Eagles music because he's a douche.
Karen Carpenter’s drumming skills are sadly hidden by her another talent, her beautiful voice
Bruh i know Karen Carpenter from her drumming
I grew up with the Carpenters on the radio, no one knew she was a drummer until she was finally on TV.
It’s 100% her voice she was known for.
Not to mention her perfect figure!!! She might have put on a few too many pounds near the end though.
@@charlesdarwin7253that’s wild 😂
I'm playing the drums again...Don't be sad, the band doesn't sound half bad!
Damn! Don Henley’s voice is deafening! I swear I didn’t hear a thing!
Someone forgot to start the tape.
I think maybe this was God's way of having Mercy on us😅
Probably copyright issues gonna be honest
Yup. Henley is notorious for blocking, threatening to sue etc. That's why you'll never see a reaction video of, hearing the eagles, video.
Playing "Act Naturally" without breaking rhythm is difficult in itself. Playing it while singing is remarkable. Playing it while singing on The Ed Sullivan Show before 73 million people is amazing.
Roger taylor's voice is seriously underrated, freddie deservedly in the spotlight but tiger has some amazing solo albums and parts in queen
Freddie asked Roger to do the "Galilleos" on Bohemian Rapsody
Tiger is his son
How can every single musician on TH-cam be overrated? This comment didn’t age well
Best singer in queen
I would have never put Phil at #1....but that's just me
The Rev (Jimmy Sullivan) (avenged Sevenfold drummer 1999 to 2009)
Fr but this channel hates any kind of new metal so they wouldn’t put him in
Forget that ... Keith Moon wasn't here
@@aarongarcia4381don’t forget that man the rev was a legend
Literally my favorite musician ever i was lowkey upset when i didn’t see him here
The Rev not being here is a crime
Maybe Don Henley didn’t like being put at #2 so much he blocked the audio
Wmg’s an a-hole so they worldwide block his music for some reason
@@LWsquidward UMG be like “it’s OUR ip to sit on and do nothing with!”
@@absurdcheesecake umg sme and wmg are heartless
No he didn't!
Roger Taylor is awesome
I prefer his singing then drumming tbh
@@jumper44he is a good drummer . You can see it in the Queen concert live Montreal or in their live album Killers .
@@miguelrubiorincon3904 I wasn't saying he's a bad drummer his drumming is amazing I just meant I loved his voice more
Dave Grohl?
I think a lot of the time when he sings he plays guitar. I might be slow though
@@MCBIGlilRonDogs he sang backup in nirvana
@@fabio_sbar yeah that's right
Matt Cameron is better
He doesn’t sing and play together, not lead singing anyway.
Paulina Villarreal from The Warning
you said what i was gonna say.... it aint even close that pau batters the shit out of phill collins
damn right she smashes all
List is automatically invalid if they didn’t add Brann Dailor from Mastodon
You beat me to it!
Totally agree, most of these lists seem to forget that metal exists
@@theconman3468 it's for people over 80.
Mike Portnoy is missing too
Literally my first thought
I totally agree, maybe in the future we will add Paulina Villarreal from the Warning, she's very good already.
YESSSSSS
Levon Helm should be #1, such a legendary voice. Brought The Band their biggest and best songs.
Not in anyway, shape or form as talented as Phil Collins. Of course, you are entitled to your own opinion but it’s wrong.
Yup!@@genesisfan029
@@genesisfan029 no need to get so pressed about it lol
this is drummers not vocalists lol
@@genesisfan029when the best shit you got is a disney song, you aint shit.
Gil Moore from Triumph and Kelly Keagy from Night Ranger .
Damn straight!!
Definitely take either of those gents over Mickey Dolenz
GILL MOORE !
When the lights go down time to light time to light the fuse. 🤘🤘
I said the exact same thing when I watched the video.
Paulina Villarreal of THE WARNING on #2: batterist, pianist, singer and composer (a new Phil Collins).
If you do a modern list of this Paulina from the Warning is defo one of the best out there right now
I missed her on this list, too ...
Paulina Villareal from The Warning coming up right NOW.
Deen Castronovo from Journey should be here
h
Yep and should be top 5
Absolutely! He should be the lead singer for Journey too as long as Steve Perry is not in the Band!
Brann Dailor of mastodon needs to be on here
And Dan Beehler of Exciter
Paulina Villarreal Vélez - The Warning
You forgot Gil Moore of Triumph
Paulina Villarreal, drummer of the rock band called The Warning. She truly deserves being on this list.
Great band and she should be better known #2 Phil #1
Finally some respect for grand funk
WTH? No Gil Moore of Triumph??
Where is Pau from THE WARNING???
You forgot Kevin Malone from Scrantonicity and Scrantonicity 2
And from kevin and the zits
was literally about to comment this
I’ll only guess they forgot Peter Rivera of Rare Earth?
Yeah, had that feeling he would be overlooked. He could bring it !! When I play the long extended version of "Get Ready", I allow my neighbors to enjoy it with me !
Great Detroit Rock and Soul !!!
Ringo Starr at number 4 is an absolute crime
He's not a great singer but the fact that his voice loses nothing single while playing that drum part is truly impressive. That rhythm is a bitch even when you're not singing.
Roger should’ve been higher. Mans falsettos are insane.
I miss Paulina Villarreal on this list.
Kelly Keagy - Sister Christian
Singer-pianists next?
Billy Joel better be #1!
@@yelljal2764 I completely agree!
Freddy Mercury better be #1
elton john better be #1
stevie wonder?
Might be too heavy but any list like this is incomplete without Brann Dailor.
I was thinking the same.
Im impressed that you included Micky Dolenz.
what does Paulina Villarreal still need to do to make it onto this list?
Levon #1
Fr
You're right, Levon #1 for sure !
No one did it better
Great list. Don't forget about mastodon
Happy to see Levon on here
The guy from Night Ranger deserves some love too.
Kelly Keagy! And he should be on this list he sang 90% of their greatest hits😊😊😊
Thank you, Levon Helm..
Gil Moore of Triumph and Grant Hart of Husker Du are both up there as well, imo
Collins definitely no 1 but love Triumph and Gil Moore definitely up there
@@robertwalkey1443 oh yeah no question about #1. Phil’s a slam dunk there.
Gil Moore is soooo overlooked.
Remarkable talent.
🇨🇦
Great list but honorable mention: Brann Dailor from Mastodon.
I don't think Dennis Wilson of The Beach Boys sing many songs but he did sing and wrote the song "Forever"
He had an album
@@camioso I didn't know that. Thanks for letting me know.
@@rickyallen7176 No worries bro. It's a pretty great record after a few listens. You And I is my favourite
Levon Helm is underrated and underappreciated!!!
The most agreeable list!!!
Great list! Just if I made it I think I would have also included Georgia Hubley from Yo La Tengo cause she’s also a great singer.
Not having Brann Dailor on here is just insane
Robert Wyatt from early Soft Machine
ANDERSON PAAK?!
I KNOW IT'S ROCK BANDS BUT COME ON!
PUT HIM ON THE LIST! HE SHOULD BE #1
tbf yea
Who?
@@fabrizio4190 no, Keith Moon was awful singer
@@cosmonatty4614duh😮😅
Why?
Well, apparantely this is about top classic rock dummers. But I'm glad more people acknowledge Paulina Villareal. Keep on singing, Pau!
Love for levon helm and the band ❤❤❤
That dude in Electric Light Orchestra is pretty good too. He was really getting into the singing in their performance of "Blinded by the Light" on "The Midnight Special" show.
Bev Bevan. Also played for Black Sabbath.
Anderson paak not being on here is criminal
Nick DiVirgilio of Spock's Beard and Big Big Train.
Christian Vander of Magma. Bonus points for writing all his own lyrics in a language of his own construction.
Don Henley is #1 for me, and Roger Taylor is #2.
This.!
taylor is alright, only his falsetto stand out
Glad to see Buddy Miles getting some love ❤
Taylor Hawkins - Cold Day In The Sun
Personally Levon helm is the best drummer/singer there is
Aaron Gillespie from Underoath and Brandon Saller from Atreyu are two of my favorite singing drummers.
Albert Bouchard from Blue Oyster Cult?
Glad I can see I’ve seen one of these live
Mickey Dolenz has one of the best rock voices.
Rock? Do you mean pop? There was no rock n roll soul in that band.
Id like to add Aaron Gillespie of Underoath on here, hes amazing!❤
Come on..!Ringo all the way! Impressive, he never lost the beat despite the screams of hysteria that surrounded him
Even more impressive that they also played before monitors, so he could probably barely hear the rest of the band
@@gmoney1592elaborate
@@gmoney1592 You didn't listen to Rain and She Said She Said...
@@gmoney1592 Paul only played a few songs and he had said that he can keep the beat and spread some energy but can not do more than that, besides he would not enjoy playing drums in a concert for more than a few songs
@@joseemilianobonilla4737Ringo wasn’t even the best Drummer in the Beatles .
Gil Moore from Triumph is no slouch. He's pretty darn good.
Ringo has such an elegant/warm voice
Ringo should have sung more Beatles songs. His singing is very underrated
But not better than Karen Carpenter.
brilliant list! but i'd like to nominate Fyfe Ewing from Therapy?, as he was able to create such harsh, angry vocals whilst cooking up some of the absolute best drum beats at the same time!
Phil number one easy...The GOAT ! But you forget Mastodon 😉
If anyone’s a big fan of the stone roses they’d know there drummer was a very talented man who did the backing vocals for every song, Reni you bloody legend
robert wyatt???
Paulina Villarreal is No. 1 for me
I honestly would’ve thought Ringo would’ve been at least Top 3, he’s always the first person I think of but for some heavier representation I’d also include Jimmy “The Rev” Sullivan from Avenged Sevenfold’s (RIP) and Brann Dailor from Mastodon, those guys have killer voices as well
Gil Moore from Triumph
LEVON HELM THE VERY VERY BEST ¡¡¡¡¡
Glad to see Peter on this list 🤘
Karen should be first!!
In Brazil, there is a singer/drummer from Roupa Nova band named Serginho.
Shouldn't count people who also sing on a song or two
The only acceptable #1 is Neil Peart!
Roger Taylor was invited to Genesis.Roger did not agree.They took Phil Collins👑❤️
Gil Moore of Triumph should be on this list
As Roger Taylor is my favorite vocalist in Queen, I would've liked to see him higher on this list
Brann Dailor of Mastodon should have been in that list.
Ringo Starr should be in #1
He sung like 7 songs
?????????
Ringo is a very good drummer, but just an average singer. Levon Helm was a GREAT singer and an UNIQUE drummer ❤
@@ishgaet he has an entire solo career
Phil is the number one here, way better drummer and way better singer than Ringo.
Don Henley, has written, sung,performed for nearly,55 years and is by far the most successful EVER.
That's funny, because Taylor Swift is very successful too but I still don't enjoy her music. I hate the Eagles.
Honorable Mention: Brann Dailor (Mastodon)
Of course the notorious blocker himself Don Henley
Might not be top ten for folks but Brann Dailor from Mastodon is great.
Levon is God
Buddy Miles sang his ass off bigtime
Ringo should be 1
😂😂😂😂
Dogs loved the Don Henley clip.
No Brann Dailor is CRIMINAL
The list is missing Brann Dailor from Mastodon
Levon is 1 but pretty solid list.
Solid list. Usually there's one or two you look at and say, "WTF?" 👍
Missing Deen Castronovo, current drummer for Journey. During the early 2000s while they were struggling to find a new permanent vocalist he would sing a few songs and still does in their later sets. He has an absolutely insane range, almost as good as Steve Perry’s.
You left off the best. Dennis Wilson.
Donovan Melero from Hail the Sun, the most complex stuff I’ve seen played on drums whilst singing
I never heard much of Grand Funk Railroad, but what little I heard was good.