Everything Wrong With Planet of the Apes (1968)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 ก.ย. 2024
- With War for the Planet of the Apes upon us... we decided to go WAY back to the OG Apes movie, the original Charlton Heston Planet of the Apes. And you know what? We had TONS of fun finding these sins. It was truly a pleasure sinning this movie.
Thursday: 2017 sins.
Remember, no movie is without sin! Which movie's sins should we expose next?!
Podcast: / cinemasins
Sins Video Playlist: • Everything Wrong With ...
Tweet us: / cinemasins
Reddit with us: / cinemasins
Tumble us: / cinema-sins
Call us: 405-459-7466
Jeremy's book: theablesbook.com Merch: teespring.com/...
11:15 in a later interview, Charlton Heston said they did the "see no evil" bit as a gag and put it in the rough cut to amuse the producer. It was left in for the preview screening and the preview audience absolutely loved it, so they were stuck with it.
To this day I feel robbed: I went to the movie at 13 years old with my friend. While waiting outside the theater door I got impatient and decided to see if the showing before ours was done. I opened the door to peek in and saw the Statue of Liberty. Never got to enjoy the twist ending like everyone else.
When I watched endgame someone from an earlier screening opened the door halfway through and shouted 'Iron Man dies' to the whole cinema 😂😂
Read the book. It has a much different twist ending.
I dodged a bullet for the same reason. Someone walked out of Kingdom of the Crystal Skull shouting "there's aliens and it still sucks". I was not angry about that and saved myself $20
You definitely got robbed. It was quite an experience to see that they were actually on Earth far into the future and to realize that the world had undergone a massive disaster. Everyone in the theater was shocked.
By the way, did you see the 007 movie Moonraker in the theater in 1979? If so I have another question for you.
Ouch!
No matter how many times you watch it, the ending still has that, "oh shit!" effect on you. One of the best ever.
Oh, yeah, definitely. I know it's coming, but it still gets me every time. Not in a surprised way, but rather in a "Wow, this is still really effective and emotional" kind of way. I still really look forward to it. And they did a really nice job with the use of the matte painting. I will always prefer practical effects like this over CGI.
Correction: It is the best ever!
Seems stupid to me because they are obviously not on Staten Island.
Once you know who wrote the movie, the ending loses a bit of punch. 😉 But only a little...
ABSOLUTELY.
The ending of this movie makes perfect sense when you find out who wrote it. Rod Serling.
The whole movie looks like a colored episode of The Twilight Zone
Rod Serling the master of twist endings
ha.. didn't know
thank you random comment on the internet
Actually, the original novel was written by Pierre Boulle (hope I spelled that right). Serling just wrote the screenplay.
Actually there were four or five endings suggested by different people and they used Charlton Heston's in the movie.
No sin for them speaking the same English for 2000 years. I can barely read books that are a 100 years old.
There was a universal translator subplot in one of the deleted scenes. Honest.😂
It’s pretty scary watching the planet of the apes movies after the random chimp event.
A hundred or two isn't so bad, but 500-year old books are difficult, and 1000-year old books are practically in a foreign language. Two thousand years? Definitely a foreign language, like Latin compared to Spanish.
"Hwær cwom mearg? Hwær cwom mago? ... Hu seo þrag gewat, genap under nihthelm, swa heo no wære." [Eardstapa (The Earth-stepper/Wanderer) - 1000yr old ENGLISH poem]
@Tech4U ~ A Modern English time-traveller would struggle with Old English. As the poem says; "Where is the horse? Where the young man? .. How those days are gone, lost under darkness, as if they never were."
'It's a mad house! A maaaaad house!'
Oh Charlton, you predicted the TH-cam comments beautifully in 1968!
wish he was still around
Charlton Heston has never gotten the credit he deserves for his Sci-Fi work. Planet of the Apes, Omega Man and Soylent Green are all classics.
It turns out we just passed 2022, the year _Soylent Green_ was set.
I don't care how much you think you're picking this series apart, you'll never ruin one of the best movie series of all time. I have the box set and still watch all back to back from time to time. I was around when each of them came out and I ran to the movie theater to see each one. Were you around in the 60's and 70's to see these first hand?
Yes, I completely agree, minus any potential discrepancies (like mentioned in the video) it's the concept ITSELF that makes it so great. I'm in my late 50s, I was too young to remember it in the 60s when it first came out, although I was obviously around per se and I believe my older brother (no longer alive) probably saw it back then, even though I don't think he was a fan of it, I think it went over him, my older brother wasn't a very deep kind of a person if you know what I mean and it went to some deep, dark places that not everyone wants to go but, I can definitely remember it in the 70s and I thought back then and still do that it was a brilliant idea and not hard to believe.
Because let's face it, scary though it is to think about (one of those deep dark places that many don't want to go to), it's kind of inevitable that at some point in the distant future, we are going to lose our position, mankind's reign as the dominant species of the earth will come to an end, nothing lasts forever, and another species will be in our place and our nearest cousins, with whom we share a common ancestor with, namely the apes, would obviously be a top candidate for that position.
Although there are other species that have the potential too, dolphins, for example, have sufficient levels of intelligence to run the world but they lack the physical bodies that would give them the ability to live on land, so it seems unlikely that they could ever rule the earth in the same way humans do now.
Apes are so close to us physically though, they just fall way short when it comes to intelligence, although they are in themselves clever creatures but not enough, however, put a dolphins brain in an ape and watch them take over, and they would leave us, humans, for dead.
If apes had the SAME IQ as an average human being, or even nearly the same (like they did in the movies), they could do everything that humans can do and MORE because they are by far physically stronger and greater than any human. Their lack of sufficient mental ability is the only thing that stymies them from taking over......for now. Many thanks.
Yea, and watched Star Trek on original air dates
The point of these is not to ruin things. It's just to find ridiculous shit for entertainment.
@@Oakshield2 sure, but the entertainment is cheap
Even with “outdated” stuffs, the movie is far more meaningful than all the videos this stupid channel has ever done.
The movie can be so good at some point that making fun of it no longer is funny, but annoying
The original story had the apes in a fully industrialized society. They made it "caveman" due to the budget. So I like to assume that this is more of an out-land village, and there are cities out there somewhere.
you are correct about 65 to 70 of the budget went to the ground breaking make up...fox hired every available make up artist in holllywood to work on this production.This was the first time rubber foam appliances were used the ape hair was real human hair from Korea and were the teeth..i read about this in a TV guide when this movie made its first TV premier.
Yes, there was a Saturday morning cartoon back in 1975 called, "Return to the Planet of the Apes," where they apes lived in a fully industrialized society. I believe you can watch some of the episodes on TH-cam.
Well said, and well researched. 'THIS' version of the original book was a temperate version intended to satiate movie audiences of-the-day on a budget-conscious story line to pack audiences into theatres. It worked well and provided a foundation for the next four installments.
Yeah I hate the original series never explored beyond the forbidden zone. I would have liked to seen potential other ape colonies.
Originally, co-writer Rod Serling (Yes, of The Twilight Zone,) pitched this version to 20th Fox in about 66. Executives realized putting suits and ties on the apes would be too costly. Not wanting to waste money, Fox hired the other writer (I forgot his name, I’ll edit it when I find out,) to write them as what I call ‘getting there’, because I’m possible when the apes took over, they simply started over, so this could be their version of the 1300-1800s or whatever century you would see that clothing in.
"Take your stinking paws off me, you damn dirty ape!" I wonder if they realised at the time that this would become as iconic a line as "Frankly my dear, I don't give a damn" or "Toto, I've got a feeling we're not in Kansas any more!"
How about " What we've got here is a failure to communicate " !
I say that sort of thing all the time
Or "I'll be back "
I remember a radio ad using all Charlton Heston quotes to sell something, with him being at Woodstock and some shirtless guy grabbing him.
"Take you stinking paws off me, you damn dirty ape!"
Finally there's a problem with the green acid people are taking:
"[Soylent] Green is people!"
I don't remember the rest.
It’s bizarre how many iconic lines and scenes this movie produced.
No sin for that human girl having shaved legs and under arms while wearing a perfectly contoured and highlighted face in a society where humans aren't meant to even know how to speak?
Nova is in no way a sin!
First Name way to bring in feminism on a movie from '68 👍
No it's bringing up a point on where did she get the makeup or have time/need to shave her legs when being chased by apes
Her legs are just naturally hairless and the "make up" is just sweat and the worlds prettiest face. Convenient isn't it?
It was 1968, so she probably had a jungle going on down under. Minus 10 sins for being smoking hot.
Sorry, this movie is without sin; still one of my favorite movies.
When you ignore the fact that they should know they are on earth from the very first moment
@@ReinersBlauerHoden Let's start with the fact that it's a fictional movie... Also, without seeing the moon, they would have no reason to believe they were on Earth. The film is brilliant since it imagines a future that has, in many ways, regressed but, in some ways, is wiser due to the humans blowing themselves up. Given the path humans are on now, it seems plausible that we could be replaced by a more primitive but less violent species. Or at least replaced by a species incapable of blowing up the planet. Get it?
_"Damn you all to Hell!"_
Still the greatest reveal in cinema history. _"I am your Father"_ was good, but this was better.
I am you father? ffs
The "I am your father" plot twist was better. It was obvious from the scenary to the creatures that "It was Earth all along". But that doesn't mean the "I am your father" plot twist was totally unpredictable. The whole franchise was built upon that twist. The themes of family in Return of the Jedi were because of that single twist. Plus, imagine if a person you idolized suddendly said "btw Hitler's my dad".
Debatable
Except the audience knew Taylor could talk the whole movie; Darth Vader was not revealed to the audience before he told Luke.
I really disagree. Even without the years of pop culture references, it’s not the hardest twist to figure out. The reveal just confirms what a lot of viewers had already figured out.
Two sins off.
The Apes are not cutting down the corn, they are beating it to flush any hiding humans. It's an old hunting technique.
The "crutch" was a broom
CinemaSins are retarded. They simply say that it's a joke and they get off free.
"Imma beat your ass with a broom"
@@easybakeovens309 These videos are not to be taken too seriously, relax.
@@easybakeovens309 You do realize these vids are not serious
What's with the GD word????
No. He didn't "wake up" from cryosleep. He was just the last one to go INTO cryosleep having "tucked in" everyone else and set the ship for its long journey.What he's recording is a log entry, not a radio transmission, so the "everyone listening is dead" still applies.
@edmond Daentez is exactly correct.
Edmond Dantez Agreed 👍🏼
In the book it was someone who was reading those logs. I don't remember how those logs were acquired.
They also showed the credits BEFORE they happen, the first shot of the film is taylor making the log entry THEN going into cryosleep and the opening credits roll
And yet ANSA launches another ship to find out what happened to this one only a few months later in 1972 as per the second film!
"Is it going to be difficult for them to get out of the net?"
"No, it'll be Super Easy, Barely an Inconvenience!"
At 6:02, the Apes are NOT 'cutting down the corn", they are are obviously whacking the corn stalks to flush out the hiding humans like wild animals or birds.
That's not corn it's Maize! Corn is a cereal like wheat. Corn is yellow waxy knobbles full of Sorbitol
LOL!! You're right! What was I thinking!!??
No they're not the same. You eat the CORN and aliens make crop circles that look like MAIZEs.
Amaiseing I know.
MAIZE is the ANCESTOR of "corn". What we call corn has been engineered over the centuries to give greater yields and resist diseases like corn blight. Modern people would probably have found true maize rather unappetizing. The stuff called "indian corn", that you often see as Thanksgiving DECORATIONS is closer to maize
Mike Grossberg Indian corn looks like Jonny Depp's teeth more than maize
Cutting the corn? They were beating the grass driving the humans towards the nets, an old hunters trick. Love you cinemasins but you really stretch sometimes.
Kurtis Deakin Yes they do!
Its click bait but GOOD click bait.
Cinemasins don't strike me as the type to go hunting through the brush for sustenance for their Paleolithic tribe. Just a hunch, though.
Kurtis Deakin I really don't feel this is common knowledge, but all right.
Maggie G you never heard the phrase "beat the bushes"? Same thing.
The horse shoe shape is the correct shape for brain surgery, the skin is cut into the horse shoe shape then folded back to give access to the skull
dpowerful1 It's just like those female wallet thingies that clip together. Easy to close. Optimal shape.
change purses?
dpowerful1 NERRRRD! Just kidding.
CinemaSins should've been sinned for not knowing the lobotomy scar...he sounded real ignorant right there
speaking as someone who has one yes they do that for brain surgery
When your seeing this in a theater at 7 years, you neither see nor care about the flaws in this movie. It totally blew my my young mind.
He can talk! He can talk! He can talk!
I CAN SIIIIIIINNNNNGGGG!!!
Matt Stone and Trey Parker should make Planet of The Apes The Musical
soulassassin0g *I CAN FIGHT*
if this is a reference to the simpsons episode, you have made my day
Dr Zaius Dr Zaius. Ohh Dr Zaius
Lol.
Do Everything Wrong With Eragon. One of the worst book adaptations ever! You'll love tearing it apart.
bladersmosh I'd also love to see that made
God that movie... committed suicide AND killed any potential sequels in the first 20 minutes
That's the only movie I have ever walked out on......
one of the worst books*
CinemaSins doesn't take the book into account when sinning a movie. If he did, every book adaptation would have a few hundred sins. Eragon, as a movie without considering the books, wasn't actually all that bad of a movie. It's just unfortunate enough to suffer from Percy Jackson syndrome, where everyone has read the book, and the movie is so different from the book that you could change the name of the movie and the characters and it would bear no similarity to the book whatsoever, which is something nobody likes.
I saw this movie when it first came out. It is still one of my all time favorite movies.
I watched this and 2001 Space Odyssey with my Family at the drive in when I was a kid, 68/69 was a great period for movies. from Bullit, Rosemary's baby, Once upon a time in the west. Hang them high, easy rider, Midnight Cowboy, and so on. good times for cinema
Same here. One of my all time faves!! I've watched it more times than i can count and will m any more before i die
Gorlox Me too. Infact the publicity told us what was going to happen but it didn't matter as it was still shocking to see it in the film when it came out.
The backgrounds weren't fake during the shore scene. It was a beach-head at Lake Powell, Utah.
Wait it was filmed IN Utah?! Sweet I am in a state where it was filmed!
Yes
Yeah it looks like Utah
The beach scene with the Statue of Liberty was filmed in Zuma Beach California (I believe it's called "Point Dumas"). As a matter of fact that beach is located very nearby the Fox Ranch (today its know as Malibu Canyon State Park and open to the public) where the Ape City set was. The opening scenes when Taylor and the others land in the lake was filmed at Lake Powell in Utah.
@@JOECANDELA22 We're talking about the landing scene at the top of the movie where the ship crashed.
sins video of original planet of the apes movie does not contain a Simpson's Troy McClure reference in the end scenes: *ding*
Madagascar as well. Plus, being a bit picky as well, but McClure references POTA, not the other way around.
i love you, dr zaius!
Or even Homer screaming "Wait a minute - that was our planet! YOU BLEW IT UP! YOU MANIACS!"
dr zaius dr zaius, dr zaius dr zaius, dr zaius dr zaius, oooh dr zaius
he can talk!
I CAN SIIIIIIIIIIIING!
Total classic film. Great story. Great music. Always enjoy watching it. The sense of journey is fabulous.
2:46
If I didn't know better, I'd say that fellow was a villain. He's got that ending-where-the-bad-guy-wins laugh. hahaha
Swell Character what was he laughing at? the flag??
Danielle Vaughn Taylor was rather fatalistic and negative about human nature and existence and was laughing at the futility of Landon's planting the American flag on a planet 4.6 light years distant and 2000 years in the future.
You cant possibly lose if Charlton Heston is the lead,,gimme a break,,friggn Moses was in your movie. He gave everything I ever saw with him in it 1000%,,a real legend.
I got the VHS for _El Cid_ which says on the box "The role he was born to play."
he did not want to do the sequel so he has a look alike in James Franciscus. They needed a big name actor to kick it off.
I don't care what you say! This is one of the best movies ever.
I'm still absolutely pissed off at the crappy remake they made a few years back with Mark Wahlberg.
I agree
only funny thing the guy said was 'all my life i dreaded you coming'
'that's what my girlfriend said regarding sex'
I concur
@@dx1450 wasn't that just the pits
wait, no "Dr Zaius"-song from the Simpsons?
I was looking for that, too! ;_;
RIGHT?!
Michael Vogt I was really hoping for it
EXACTLY
This is what I was waiting for!
They were NOT cutting down all of the corn...
they were bush beating.. or in this situation corn beating,
to drive the humans toward the waiting nets.
Exactly.
Would have loved getting tangled in those nets.
Thank god I'm not the only man watching this that wasn't raised on soymilk. I'm concerned for future generations when a majority of people dont understand how to gather their own food, of course, in a post apocalyptic world I'll be a warlord.
point is, they are doing it too slowly to ba able to catch up to the humans!
The only sin is you claiming that there's anything wrong with this movie. Utter classic
agree 44, this is one of the best science fiction movies ever, with an ending that rocks me still to this day. incredible.
but this guy does a very funny job all the same, and i loved it.
peace and love to you all,
xxxxxx
What happened to the moon, and did the Astronauts never once look into the night sky and see the Big Dipper or Orion's Belt? Worst Astronauts ever.
Rick Johnson Thank you, I thought I was the only one to notice, what I though to be the strongest movie spoiler, that astronauts who memorize constellations did not notice the same ones in their “new” night sky.
@@conrad4667 stars near ours see similar constellations
There was a line when they were crossing the desert that the nights were overcast. Rather curious as the daytime skies were very clear.
Good point about the Moon. Remember the pilot for "Space: 1999" ? The Moon being launched out of orbit had serious affects on the planet. It is possible that they did NOT recognize the stars because their positions had changed over 2000 years. Actually, THAT would of been a nice touch if they would of had a scene where Cornelius and Zira had mentioned the names of some of the stars and constellations.
It could simply have been a New Moon (not visible that night), and it's been a couple of thousand years. The stars may have shifted enough to make the constellations only familiar-ish.
Little known fact, the twist scene at the end where Heston see the Statue of Liberty and realizes he's back on Earth, was written by Rod Serling.
I think you mean Serling.
Makes sense... he was a genius. And he was famous for HOLY SHIT reveals with the Twilight Zone, so... yeah that makes total sense.
He actually wrote the original screenplay adaption. Then dropped out when new writer brought in for rewrite.
@@mickobrien3156 Richard Matheson was the better TZ writer, not as ham handed as Serling, and stylistically they both ripped off Chekov.
Matheson and Serling were genius writers. Planet of the apes was taken from the book but written story was humans crash on another world. All the twilight zone writers were fantastic. That is why the show hold up over half a century later. Serling also did night gallery later on and undersea documentary’s for. Cousteau. His early work was requiem for a heavyweight and playhouse 90. He and paddy Chayefsky wrote teleplays.
Side note, my cousin went to school with rod and his brother from K- 12. She was good friends with them both. Too bad rod was a heavy smoker and stress if tv censors drove him crazy. That is why after every season he returned to upstate NY to relax and teach. I believe Ithaca college school of communications is named after him. He is buried in Binghamton and NY METS AA farm team two years ago had a Rod Serling twilight zone day..
Richard matheson wrote “ I am legend” at 19 while living in NYC. He wished someone would make an actual adaptation of that book as written.
A coworker of mine lived in Page AZ when the movie was filmed. He said he went to the area where the movie was filmed. The movie crew left the scare crows so he set the scare crows on fire. He almost had a heart attack when I told him that he should of saved the scare crows because they would be worth a fortune now.
He set them on fire? What an asshole.
Dr. Scott Giles exactly what I thought. Fucking juvenile delinquent.
Burning the scarecrows was stupid, but I think even the movie producers didn't imagine it would become such an iconic blockbuster film.
Tom Quimby actually movie crews leave shit all the time. I live in New Orleans and they shot a movie at 6 flags and left everything they built to make the park look active
Tom Quimby , left-over movie sh!t expert.
Charlton Heston, in his autobiography discussed the issue of how the producers and director grappled with the issue of the apes speaking perfectly fluent English. According to Heston, they simply decided to leave it alone and wing it.
You left off the big one: Charlton Heston would have easily seen that it's the Statue of Liberty on the beach from way further back, but he waited until he got closer to get all dramatic about it. **DING**
also how did the statue of liberty end up near the grand canyon-ish
lol
The end reveal is movie legend,but the problem in "real life" is now we know its NY and no buildings left? when we have buildings from 4k yrs ago in Egypt lol *DING*
Adrian, stone versus steel? DING for you. Stone lasts longer
There are no buildings left because people blew the planet up. It's a badass ending, but I'm curious how the Statue of Liberty is still standing upright even after a bomb destroyed everything.
I "sin" shows, movies and people all the time now. I'm on the bus like "teen mom yelling at her deadbeat baby daddy on the phone cliche".
I can't even watch old episodes of _Batman: The Animated Series_ anymore without counting up the sins as I go along.
thegreatbutterfly I'm worried I'll start Honest Trailering life soon 😂😂😂
Yup. It's fun with the Russian dash cams. "He survives this. Ding!"
"Ding".
Ah, a movie that isn't 50% pitch black, 25% too quiet, and 25% too loud
And no Brad Pitt. Yay!
You said it! Ten trillion sins off for not being a crap movie! And eighty eight zillion sins off for a minimum of lens flairs!!!!!
Omg yes. It's so fucking bad that I can barely watch any movies at night anymore without worrying about waking up my parents. If I want to actually hear the dialog in the quiet moments I have to turn it up and a split second later it's blasting loud af and I have to rush to lower it again. Either wake up the household or not be able to hear anything, fucking thanks whatever assholes are responsible for this retarded trend.
@@Jenacide - That really bugs me, spend millions and screw up the audio... They must make something to fix that by now. I have an old Audio Boss made for that problem, never tried it on the TV. It is annoying all alone. Seems like good acting and directing is bent on mumbling too. One would think enunciating and quality audio would be important. If I got a job fixing their mistakes I'd get fired and they would start over and screw it up. I stopped going to theaters around 1990, because the audiences cheer over dialogue and other annoying things, must be the general demographics.
omg...I just watched 2001 a space odyssey and...uuuhhh
not only is it 50% pitch black but it also contains like half an hour of breathing
I was lucky to have seen this movie when I was young, and I saw it without knowing anything about it. That ending actually got me.
At least it had a STORY LINE That's more then can be said for ALOT of today's SO called blockbuster movies.
You must be new here...
Even with their pathetic stuff ups, I still like watching it.
My favourite part in these movies, the part when he finds the statue of liberty.
Yeah all they got is sex and violence and nobody likes that.
@@auntymoo8372 Yeah he acts holier than thou and goes ape when he sees that statue a hurricane knocked down.
@@bubbalong7646 not true
That laugh at 2:45 and when Jeremy is laughing back I LOST IT
yup
Coraline Parmentier - Pianist for Peace what was Charlton Heston laughing about??
This is exactly what I want to know XD
1968 is a better version than over produced new versions.
stop
No
some kind of universal law there: "the original is always better than the remake of a movie"
@@ronschlorff7089 Except in this case, it was not only better, but FAR better!
I 100% agree
I don't care how much you think you're picking this series apart, you'll never ruin one of the best movie series of all time
Everything Wrong With - Fifty Shades Darker!
The whole movie
That's too cruel even for him. He'd have to watch it at least four or five times and that's a punishment worse than death.
Everything Wrong With Fifty Shades Darker in 5 seconds or less!
Hahahaha you're right
Gig Pig I think he'll probably do in February when fifty shades freed comes out.
that horseshoe surgery incision is correct, my Aunt had a brain tumor removed and that is what it looked like post op.
David Hecht brain cowering. Hahahaha!
This was a wonderful movie. I forgive ALL the sins.
Is that the Spaghetti Monster in your logo? Pasta be with you! :-)
Still, to this day, a God Damned Masterpiece
Am I the only one who starts sinning myself and my own life after I watched too many sin's videos ?
me too, but more of the things in my life, as opposed to my actual life
deadass
You're watching another mediocre youtuber exploit stupid people? TINGx3
I went through a phase about 2 years ago where I would sin real life (actual incident: *opens fridge door* "We are out of milk" DING!")
Speak no evil, hear no evil, see no evil, is an iconic scene
scene was TOO comical to me ... but it fits
Loved this film as a kid. And it's still pretty good. More entertaining than most films made in the last 50 years.
One of the best movies EVER made.
Lol its more entertaining than mcu films. Especially overrated actors in it
That film is the perfect example of where a willing suspension of disbelief is justified
1968 I was 10 years old when I saw this movie with my Dad ( Bronx New York ) , I thought that it was an awesome movie ! 😀
Michael Schmid - yes me too and I thought it was a Great movie = plot/actors/cinematography /film quality !
Michael Schmid so cool that it was set in your home town, 3,000 years later!!
I agree. I first saw it in the early 70's & I loved it, I was immediately fascinated with everything about it. My father was an Air Force engineer/physicis at the time. I started asking him all kinds of questions about how earth could age without them getting old. I am sure I asked all kinds of questions but I recall being fascinated that time isn't a constant. lol I was probably the only 3rd grader on the planet trying to understand spacetime. No doubt, I didn't really understand but it sparked my interest in science.
I also liked the TV series that ran in 74 or 75ish. I don't think it ran very long but we watched it. I also recall some late night reruns in the 80's.
Anyways, awesome movie, I grew up with Apes, I still watch it every few years.
Double up-vote for @michael schmid !! My dad took me (and my brother) to see this in the theater too!
@Frank Winkhorst Wow, all the negativity; must be a man of the left-you guys are always so unhappy-it's a real glass-half-empty mentality. @michael Schmidt is trying to tell us about a happy memory as a kid with his dad, and you jump on his punctuation-style, and his _possible_ support (we don't know) for the current president?
Does it ever occur to you lefties that we on the right hated all 8 years of Obummer? We just didn't act out like your side does.
Hmmm... 2:35 "If there's no life here we've got just 72 hours to find it" isn't a sin.
When they say 'here', they mean the area that they're in, not the planet which they haven't explored yet so couldn't possibly know for sure so they are going to look for life elsewhere on the land they've found, within 72 hours.
You're right. It would have been clearer if they had added the word 'elsewhere' to the end of the sentence, but then they couldn't have imagined that one day pedants would pull the film apart over the most miniscule aspects of grammar and plot. I just hope the people who make these videos never go to the theatre. Having someone shout 'that's not a real building, someone's just painted a picture!' would really ruin it for everyone else.
Then the inflection is a sin.
Seen this movie dozens of times,a true classic..
I saw this movie when I was twelve, a friend and I got in when a good samaritan vouched for us, said he was our uncle. Never saw anything like this movie.It sparked a lifelong love of film. At the time it was really groundbreaking. To a twelve year kid it was quite an experience
For THAT ending? I'd take off 80 sins!
I was thinking similar...That ending, when you weren't expecting it and watching it for the first time (specially back then as an 10 year old like I was) was just brilliant. Still one of the best twists to any film out there....
The author of the book said that Serling's ending was better than the one he came up with.
Tighelanderll
Tim Burton's version ended like the book. If that's the case I gotta agree with the author!
To be fair, this wasn't the first time that the Statue of Liberty had been used this way. At least a couple of Sci-fi magazine covers during the Fifties had similar scenes.
I agree, only five sins off for that ending is a travesty. It's a twist that M. Night Shyamalan would give half his limbs for.
I’m removing 104 sins because this movies is awesome
zamp6969 same
@@chufengfang2314 same
Yes
zamp6969 That's why I didn't subscribe
See what I wrote
It's so easy to trash something and yet no one can create something Better.
@@stardude2006 who's trashing anything?
When every 'Sins' video starts being annoyed at logos, maybe that's a sign you shouldn't take what follows so seriously.
This is a classic movie. I saw all 5 movies at my local cinema when I was a kid.
In the decades I’ve been watching the film, I’ve often wondered why they were no night scenes revealing the night sky to the astronauts, the Moon and the constellations would’ve made them realize they were indeed on Earth. All cloudy nights and perfectly clear days simply don’t make any sense.
Maybe they were in the U.K.?
11:00 that shape is actually very common in brain surgery, craniotomy, etc. gonna have to give cinema sins a sin here.
Yeah. My brother has a horseshoe shaped scar on his head under his hair from a brain surgery he had when he was a kid. Its almost impossible to see but you can still feel it.
southernstyleman Yeah, my cousin has one. Ans if you look up brain surgery scar, many of the top results include horseshoe shaped scars. As much research as cinema sins does, I, surprised they let that detail slip up. It's a VERY common shape. Hope your brother is doing well.
@@BMarie774 I think you over-estimate the amount of research CS do. P{retty sure by now it's whatever comes to their mind when they're watching a movie with beers, and then their errors are handwaved away by 'it's just comedy'. Which is, you know, fair, but it's annoying when they flat out state things that should be so should not be so when you know they totes be so. They have demonstrated repeatedly, for example, that they actually know so little about technology esp. firearms that their channel is a net drain on the quantity of knowledge in the universe.
Admiral Belzediel they will continue their format just to piss ppl off like you and I’m here for it tbh. It’s a joke jeez, not like this is affecting the overall review of the movie 🙄
Oop
Can someone actually tell me how they landed on earth? They left earth but somehow came back? Is this explained in the later movies?.
good question
I think they were supposed to come back to earth. Like specific coordinates were programmed into the ship or whatever. It's mentioned in the very beginning of this movie - I believe. It's been a long time since I've seen it though, so can't remember for sure.
uhh.... space is round? Worm hole? Magnetic fields? Cigar ashes fucked up the computers? Who knows
Henrique Lazarini Worm Hole? More like Plot Hole, am I right?
Its relatively possible, in a way that Im not qualified to try to explain.
How did he land on a planet where everybody who can talk speaks English and NOT think he was on Earth?
because its a movie, did u think all the movies set in ancient times or space also spoke English too like alexander, 300,guardians of galaxy etc, nobody wants to read subtitles.
@@tomato7955 - That is understandable. But then again, some people see FOREIGN movies with subtitles from time to time.
I have the same question. The "reveal" at the end was hardly a reveal for me.
@@robertpolanco1973 true but those are also made in the language in the country they are from, but there are movies with subtitles that are made in USA too. So we both have our points
@@tomato7955 But subtitled films are not mass market money makers
There’s NOTHING wrong with this masterpiece!
@Anjali 😂😂😂
Actually this is the beat 'planet of the apes' movie still and none of the others especially the most recent CGI crap ones even compare. It's pretty deep stuff and a classic
There was nothing wrong with the original Planet of the Apes . It spawned plenty of sequels and remakes that still can't compare to it .
Andy Serkis says otherwise
@J Dial I did read the book when I was kid . Actually it was called "Monkey Planet " by Pierre Boule .Tim Burton's version was a little more like the book , especially at the end . I saw "Planet of the Apes "when it was originally released making me pretty old . I only remember so much about the book , but I liked the way Rod Serling took over writing the screenplay and and turned it one big episode of the "Twilight Zone " Michael Wilson I heard had made the screenplay a little to modern with apes wearing normal clothes and cities .
@@lxlcaesarlxl Obviously the digital effects are more realistic but the story isn't nearly as good . Maybe people don't care about stories anymore being these Disney remakes are horrible .
@@wilson6717 I disagree with that one. The reboot trilogy is one of the best trilogies ever. The story is fantastic it takes you on an emotional journey throughout the three movies.
@@lxlcaesarlxl They are pretty much remakes of "Conquest of the Planet of Apes" and" Battle for the Planet of the Apes" but whatever you like . I would like to know why in the first movie when Caesar finally spoke it was in plain English and the next two movies they had grunting caveman voices .
One of the best movies I've ever watched
Killer_ Street_Machines fucking right
Every movie I've ever watched is literally "ONE OF THE BEST MOVIES I'VE EVER WATCHED". Also ONE OF THE WORST MOVIES I'VE EVER WATCHED. If you want to praise something, give it some real praise instead of using a stupid cliche pseudo-expert claims that says nothing if you look past the fake intellectualism.
I remember my first three movies, too.
Take two sins off and add three.
Soylent Green is Another
Sorry, but in my opinion, and by the look of it, many others, Planet of the Apes remains a classic. I will never forget the moment in the cinema, in 1968, when the Apes first emerge out of the corn crop. That was such a brilliant reveal but the end of the film has to be one of the greatest ever. Sheer brilliance and it still stands up today, in spite of the anomalies.
Personally, I am somewhat impressed with CinemaSins' analysis of the original "Planet of the Apes" from 1968. In spite of the sins presented in this video of the movie, I still LOVE the movie. It is a classic forever.
Robert Polanco Agreed! But I always remind myself when they sin a movie I like : Their tagline is "no movie is without sin", ie, even film's like the Godfather aren't perfect. No such thing as the perfect, sinless film😁
@munstrumridcully - I understand. I remembered making a similar comment about CinemaSins' analysis of "Citizen Kane" not too long ago. Another great classic movie. Thanks anyway.
Funny how that line is just alteration of a line from the bible. see nothing oringal
@Raptorian - I guess you made a good point on this one.
Do you ever see a comment and say, "Man...I wish I commented that."
Do you ever see a comment and say, "Man...I wish I people would *STOP* commenting that."
Brian Antoine No
Do you ever see a comment that said, "Do you ever see a comment and say, "Man...I wish I commented that"" and say, "Man I wish people would *STOP* commenting that"
Because apparently Brian did.
Do you ever see a comment that says "Do you ever see a comment and say, "Man...I wish I commented that." and say "Man...I wish I commented that."
if no movie is without sin, then do schindlers list.
Increeeeedibly long runtime...main character is far too altruistic to be real...
Just a couple.
Connor Bonelli Excellent idea!
But Cinemsins are stooges of PC and they would not have the guts to slam into Spielberg's numero uno propaganda film - - - - - it would be like secular blasphemy
Chad Castagana it aint propaganda. im a jew. i think itd be cool to see them have the balls to do it.
Connor Bonelli I don't really think them sinning that's racist every ten seconded would be that fun
Connor Bonelli sadly, white people get more triggered than the race actually is. i mean did you see what happened with the ghost in the shell? even though the japanese didn't care what race the main character was, all the white people did was talk about white washing instead of enjoying the film
The basic premise for the movie never did make sense to me--Why would the US fund a mission that had no purpose but sending people into the far future? 4 people isn't enough to start a colony, and any data they collected would never been seen by anyone that could use it. And why would anyone volunteer for such a trip? You'd essentially be committing suicide--everyone and everything you knew would be gone even if you survived whatever waited on the other side. Humans are risk takers, but that's not just a risk--that's nuts.
Jesus don’t slag this classic, slag the Tim Burton remake. That movie can put an insomniac to sleep
not a damn thing wrong with this film.
Right. It's perfect. The music alone is pure genius, and the ending still gives me the creeps.
@@bigswingface5847 music got Oscar nominated for "best original score", don't know if it won
emma Duncan yup, and the key word, "film" in sci fi genre; and not a documentary based on a true story, …..but maybe.....just maybe!
it was funny to see the great film under a new perspective after having seen it a dozen times. Refreshing. Some sense of humor may be helpful.
Hey Cinemasins, do everything wrong with Chicken Little
His asshole father, that's what's wrong. What a piece of shit. Everyone in that movie is a fucking prick. What an weird, sad movie they've made. Poor Chicken Little got shitted on way too much.
that would be dope
God that movie is messed up.
i always wondered how they got from the grand canyon to NY by walking with 3 days rations
No, the Statue of Liberty must have been moved to California before civilization fell. I think the show _Life After People_ said the arm would fall off and the collapsed statue would be underwater.
Plate tectonics. After a couple thousand years NY and AZ could be right next to each other.
Atomic bomb magic!!!
I love Cinema Sins, but I take exception: I don't think Taylor came out of cryosleep to leave a message. I think they had been working in the ship for a few days or weeks at hyperspeed and were only now going to sleep, the others had already gone down, and Taylor was signing off. Also, there WAS a shot of the actress sleeping before we saw the mummified version, so they DID cast an actress. Last thing - that was a real background behind Taylor. The lighting was just odd and it was out of focus, but real.
"By the way, have I talked about inbreeding yet? Well let me te-" -CinemaSins(2017)
My favorite film of all time not because it’s perfect but because this story always fascinated me and the sense of journey it has I was obsessed with it as a kid
I am old enough to have seen it in the theater when I was a kid and it blew my mind. Much later I read the Pierre Boulle's book "La planète des singes "on which the movie is losely based and it is vastly different from the movie.
One of my favorite films. Forbidden Planet being another. The crap coming out today is unbearable.
"Forbidden Planet" AKA "Star Trek Before Star Trek"
@Russ Gallagher I know that from Rocky Horror XD
There are some good ones today, if you know where to look.
The Leslie Nielsen Forbidden Planet??? Always worth a watch.
@@davidprice5563 No-one called him Shirley.
"Keeping us from seeing Charlton's Heston."
- Cinemasins 2017
You forgot to add the famous line at the end " GOD Dam you ! GOD DAM you all to hell ! " Then the movie fades to black and you keep hearing the surf . (28 July 2018 1523 hours)
Susan we may have the Mandela effect here, because I remember the final line as "You blew it all to hell."
"damn".
@@donaldgrant9067 nah it was god damn you all to hell, you tried tho... you tried
He didn't blaspheme God. He just said "damn".
I have the first DVD in the computer right now 12/31/18. "You maniacs! You blew it up! Ah, damn you! God, damn you all to hell!" And I ran it three times to make sure the first one was "Ah, damn you", not "God, damn you."
And yes, the fade to black with the sound of the surf is sheer movie brilliance.
Charlton Heston is a legend
He was john Charles Carter in real life.
Linda Harrison, Nova, was EXQUISITE!
Anaris10 you gotta be kidding me.
@@chuckfriebe843 Chuck is fine if you're gay. No one is judging you.
Trulysarcastic44 lol! So I’m gay if I think she’s ugly. You must be really old. You dig those hippy chicks. Lol
@@chuckfriebe843 Yeah ok boomer
RJ Villacampa not a boomer, asshole. Nice try though.
Haha CinemaSins managed to piss off so many people LOL. I come for the videos but the comments section is where the entertainment is.
Get your filthy Videos off my feed. you damn dirty CinemaCins. haha jk love these!
CinemaSins is being a moron at sin #47 & #48. Tons of fruit around, hungry, obviously would grab one. Isn't that special. Doesn't need to be filmed. And he DOES share, because that's where the other guy gets his fruit from. Look close. Same fruit, just the other half of it. Really stupid mistake from CinemaSins. Really expect better.
Johannes but the fruits just appear out of no where and into their hands... yet they casually take it out and eat it lol
You know what kind of ammunition feeding devices the apes' rifles use?
Banana clips.
You missed the perfect opportunity, while they were in the life raft on the water, to play the "Land of the Lost" theme.
I remember that show i watched it every Saturday!! That would have been awesome. You need to edit this one Jeremy!!
Or Gilligan’s Island...
Everything wrong with Power Rangers (2017)
True
This movie truly is a classic, which makes this video hell of a lot of fun.
I remember seeing this movie sometime in the 70s on TV (most likely after 1975 when we got colour TV in Australia) and was absolutely gobsmacked by it. The plot-holes to be stepped around came later when I was old enough to recognise them. The final reveal though was awesome but in hindsight, all the signs it was Earth all along were dotted throughout the movie and you just had to be savvy enough to see them. I, being a small child at the time, was oblivious and just enjoyed a great movie.
The Lincoln Memorial was derivative in that _Apes_ movie, but what was the point? Probably after 1000 years, only the pyramids would be recognizable. Everything else would be overgrown rubble.
So how did the Statue of Liberty get from New York, to the Grand Canyon?
Or even the Cali coast line for that matter.
Because that was not the Grand Canyon. They were in...New Jersey!
by the "magic of stagecraft"
From a modern POV, it could also be that that is the LAS VEGAS Statue of Liberty, and that one of the explosions was enough to tear a hold in the area to the sea at California (according to google it's just about 276 miles, a bomb induced crack could do it)
The statue in LV is really small though so that doesn't work.
This video has the biggest sin removal I've seen in this channel so far.
This is a pretty iconic movie so it's kinda deserved :)
Please explain
Anshul Kaushik well it's the biggest he have SEEN dumbass
V for Vendetta, Nathalie Portman posing as an underage pleasure doll... Find it, NOW!
Are we counting EWW Trolls 2 for the record of 'Highest Sin Removal count'?
In the Parallel Solar System "Simian Sins: Everything Wrong With Planet of the Homo Sapiens" on ZooTube.
I loved this movie as a kid, but 40 years later my nephew took one look at it and said...they are riding horses and speaking english! Of course it is Earth
the Jerry Goldsmith score is an epic classic. Cheap shot playing one second to mock it.
You mean at 5:55?
Where a sin got taken off?
The ending of this movie makes perfect sense when you see who wrote the screenplay. Rod Serling!
Actually, that ending was not Serling's idea (surprisingly enough). In fact, comparatively little of Serling's work made it into the final movie. (He wrote an early version of the screenplay, set in a "contemporary" Ape city with cars and helicopters and glass skyscrapers.) I just got "The Making of Planet of the Apes" for Christmas. Great big coffee table book, full of great photos and interesting details and facts. Highly recommended.
holy shit
Did they not recognize the Grand Canyon as they were rowing through it? Also, please do "The Princess Bride."
+Poverty Gaming When they blew it up it blasted into the air and flew across the country.
That's 'cause it's not Grand Canyon. It's Glen Canyon, a.k.a. Lake Powell.
Yesssssssss The Princess Bride!!!
When I was 12 years old in 1968 and I saw the first Planet of the Apes movie, I wondered what would those apes be singing if Planet of the Apes was a musical?