Love what you said in the outro. Many people tends to reject the truth especially when they hear something that doesn't fit their narrative. Denialism is an irrational action that withholds the validation of history.
Agree, we tend to see only what we already believe in, when opposing view somehow leaks in, we rush to demonizing rather than acknowledging it. Acknowledgement is the way to bulletproofing our case for the future, not denialism.
I'm your big fan Mingzai! Thanks for your hard work seriously. tbh I'm more excited on your edits than any other movies and shows out there. i know it's a bit harsh to say but please don't drag too long for your next edit😂😂😂I need more to cure my boredom at home😂 love you😂
😮surprised beginning history of UK. Well said 👍 it's not about what happened in the past; it's about how you overcome dark days and keep standing strong! 👏
Excellent video! The only issue I have relates to the unification of England & Scotland, which needs clarification. In 1603, Queen Elizabeth I of England (the Virgin Queen) died in London without any heir (male or female). Her closest male relative was James Stuart, King James VI of Scotland, who was the son of Mary, Queen of Scots, and Henry Stuart. Mary was the grand-daughter of Margaret Tudor, sister of King Henry VIII of England. Henry Stuart, aka Lord Darnley, was himself a relative of the Tudors. So, by default, James VI of Scotland was crowned King James I of England after QE I. The two kingdoms maintained their separate parliaments under the same monarch(s), except the Republican years of 1649-1660, until 1707 when Queen Anne, the last Stuart queen, signed the Act of Union joining the two as one country with a single Parliament at Westminster. So, looking from a different angle, one can say that England was taken over by Scotland, instead of the other way 'round!
![[TH] FS vs BME - VCT Ascension Pacific - Lower Bracket Final](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wnygqsR2Fig/mqdefault.jpg)
思考題：你是如何看待一個國家的黑歷史呢？
這是快鏡睇英國千年歷史，當中很多枝節，有的只輕輕帶過，有的略過、如對任何專題有興趣，歡迎提出！
想繼續支持不正常人類系列既，老規矩：Like、comment、subscribe👍
另外，不正常研究所正在招聘中！想加入的話，請查詢Description box📧
枝節呀，人家大佬！😂🤣🤣
我覺得黑歷史係冇乜所謂，我最緊要係肯面對，同埋將來唔會再繼續就可以
民族主義只係上層統戰下層嘅思想
Ok la 無意見
@@rositaradicallyobjective 😂
NICE，期待
快更下一集👍
Vikings唔係講笑，好睇到爆炸，如果我係條村到見到維京人Ragnar嗰對眼，我實驚到瀨尿
我最欣赏英国统治马来西亚的历史里都是以买卖得到而不是打战。如果回到过去，我认真觉得马来西亚没必要独立。虽然我没有经过英国统治时期，不过也可以感觉到英国统治下的华人过得比较好。
那是因為大馬的人口大多數，70%是大馬人，在大馬獨立前，大馬不是行民主，英國人是大佬賺最多的錢及擁有絕對的統治權，然後才是大馬人及華人，他們看大馬人跟華人是一樣的，都是他小弟。但大馬人怎會甘心做英國人的小弟，這是人性，獨立後，以西方民主制，人的多數會佔優勢，大馬人佔多數，華人是少數，才會有現在的不公平對待。
👍👍👍
Support
我第一次咁快黎睇！ 你真係好強！ 咁深咁長既歷史，你居然可以深入簡出咁剪出13分鐘唔夠！但我感覺到你為左呢條片已經無訓好多晚啦。 我真係有學到野。支持你！
本人已經練成不眠不休大法🙏🏻
@@mingjai14 你太厲害啦🙏😅
@@mingjai14 大師何時授徒 🤣
@@mingjai14大師請收我為徒，我仲可以被人折騰😂
自細都唔鍾意歷史 但係好鍾意ming仔呢個系列👍
人愈大愈對歷史有興趣，歷史係人類文明智慧結晶，其實歷史永無過時既一日，大大小小歷史每日都不斷重演緊，只係時代背景不同，讀歷史可以令人行少好多冤枉路，要追尋答案讀歷史係好方法
以前讀書唔明背後道理，只會覺得歷史好悶同死記硬背，明白歷史背後動機同意義係會明白箇中樂趣的。
好中意睇你講國家既歷史，講得深入淺出，不過可唔可以出多啲片，等成兩三個星期唔係辦法🤣
lol
唔係辦法 可以自己又試下出片 試下細細地講所羅門群島 🙂🙂
@@Monitor2023 咁要排期參加Ming 仔剪片班先得😅
同意, 每個國家都有自己的黑歷史, 最重要此刻是否黑現代
記得你講過, 道德應該有通脹, 咁歷史都要自我增值, 走回頭路等如自殺
香港永遠隸屬於英國🇬🇧!香港人葛家!
@@PaCoL-l8i sohai
上下扫一眼评论区的评论，就还真是那个一言难尽。
@@kunkunhuang8022 什么一言难尽，一句不行你可以写一句以上
@@PaCoL-l8i你呢句呀令我覺得有D難以評價😂
非常感興趣一個系列，亦見到ming仔愈做愈好，前幾集都還有一些吐槽，今集真係比叻叻，又中立又有介紹電影，真係有聽觀眾的意見👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
向Ming仔學到ge愛就係激進地客觀，各個方面都要睇，都學習，自己的觀點可以輸出，但唔一定要人地同你一樣觀點或要佢地接受，有時候做一個聆聽者去學習都好重要ge！期待下一集呀！！！😎
我仍未夠客觀，大家一齊進步😜
每一次「不正常人類」系列出新片
都要好認真咁坐低飲住杯茶睇
好多時要睇兩次三次
反覆咀嚼 思想
多謝明仔👻
接受缺點都係愛的一種，好多人都搞唔清楚，因為書本上面無教吧
黑歷史國家唔恐怖, 最恐怖係比黑歷史更恐怖既現有國家. 俄同佢既契弟
想睇英國篇好耐😍，覺得黑歷史其實都係國家既一部部分，認識下並唔係壞事
明仔好多謝你認真製作這些歷史教學影片，這是一個好好起點，引起年輕人的興趣去從不同角度思考這個世界。而且又有提及課後閱讀。小小提議，配埋英文解說，咁可以reach 到世界各地觀眾（增加收入）。
點樣我成日覺得好似有把周星馳既聲線喺度講歷史咁嘅😂
期待更多新片 真係好有心機同好好睇 5會悶 。精而簡得黎好想拿拿林睇下一集
非常享受呢13分鐘～ 多謝Ming 仔，如果唔識欣賞都冇辦法，歴史老師可以好似你咁就好難肥佬～
有少少意見 (擺明雞蛋挑骨頭.呵呵):
1. 1707年前用英格蘭人會準確D. 我睇BBC 紀錄片, 1707年前會用English, 1707年後係用British
2. 1707年只係英蘇合拼, 地圖好似畫多左愛爾蘭. 愛爾蘭係到1801 年先join 埋一齊.
3. 如果講埋英格蘭蘇格蘭由1603年開始, 係同一個王室不同國會黎管治. 成件事會再Full D.
BTW, 做得好好睇~! 加油!
片長關係，細節唯有靠大家提供喇，感謝補充資料參考👍👏🏻
@@mingjai14 哈哈~ 加油吧~😄😄
終於等到英國篇🇬🇧！三部曲都唔夠喉，希望有多幾集😍
10幾分鐘嘅片感覺只係睇左2分鐘，好enjoy聽你講故仔! D片又剪得好! I don’t like it.. I love it 😉Thanks Mingjai!
時間長度剛好, 講解生動, 又提供參考材料俾有興趣的人,
Ming 仔呢個系列做得好, 係香港 TH-camr 中依然俾人走前了一步 ~
結尾講得好好, 一個有心去認識世界歷史既人, 一定要有呢種心態先可以睇到更多, 知道更多
一味盲撐同玻璃心既只會令自己視野變得狹隘, 永遠活喺自己所謂既"烏托邦"之中
Love thisssssss!!!🔥 CANT WAIT FOR THE NEXT EPISODE 😆
正！期待下2集，你TH-cam 有時都能夠令人深思，獲益良多。 下2集 如果可以帶出點解要殖民？經濟或地理利益等，同埋 英國的政治手腕 管理手法和架構 思想影響 等等是如何統治這些殖民地那就更透澈。 非常期待。
講得好👍🏻
黑歷史定係黑現在！
呢個系列真係無得頂，令我追番曬你呢半年D片，如果出片可以快少少就完美!
ming仔d片, 係我唯一正常速睇既片, 其他唔係1.5就2倍速🤣🤣
恭喜你搵到一條好適合你嘅拍片路向！
叫afternoon tea好啲
用low tea圖配high tea旁白
令真正只能夠食high tea嘅人感到。。。。
見到Ming仔出片，即睇👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻點解你講歷史可以講到一啲都唔悶既呢，唔夠喉呀，快啲出埋下條片呀😂😂😂
謝謝你的客觀分析歷史，感謝你整理出一個歷史龐大的資料庫，至於如何判断，每個人都有自己的一套標準，人格，人生觀。及，與生俱來的天賦人類的良知， 包括不忍人之心 道德等……。
但首先要對歷史有正確的認識才能作出判斷！
感謝您！👍👍👍
想知英倫四國本身係同樣民族，定係唔同嘅民族? 如果唔係一樣民族，這四國是如何誕生的?
语言文化背景和宗教背景区分了这四个地区
最後講得非常好！
適合某啲人聽🙊
睇歷史係唔應該抱有啲私人民族情感
最後部份實在太發人深省👍🏻加油，期待下兩集！
救命⋯可唔可以出片快少少⋯少少都好呀！條頸長左好多，我終於明白長頸鹿🦒喺點誕生⋯⋯
當每一個人去到佢嘅大英博物館， 就會感受到佢係一個不折不扣嘅海盜扮紳士嘅國家
Ming仔，真係好厲害，我真係有排學，演繹得超好
oh my god!!! it's KO阿佬!!! 野生搏獲!!!
好生鬼 , 好好睇 , 又入脳 👍 如果以前教歴史科嘅老師 係咁 , 學生就無痛苦。
我系大陆观众，好中意你讲历史，真系好撚搞笑幽默😂 加油！粤语千古！
Ming仔
我想問唔係丹麥人唔係首先打贏咗撒克遜人同埋維京人咩？
當中仲出咗個好有名嘅人 叫做克努特大帝
Love what you said in the outro. Many people tends to reject the truth especially when they hear something that doesn't fit their narrative. Denialism is an irrational action that withholds the validation of history.
Agree, we tend to see only what we already believe in, when opposing view somehow leaks in, we rush to demonizing rather than acknowledging it. Acknowledgement is the way to bulletproofing our case for the future, not denialism.
好同意你最好噶观点 一个国家肯定有好有唔好
聆聽ming仔講歷史真係-種享受😍💪
I'm your big fan Mingzai! Thanks for your hard work seriously. tbh I'm more excited on your edits than any other movies and shows out there. i know it's a bit harsh to say but please don't drag too long for your next edit😂😂😂I need more to cure my boredom at home😂 love you😂
移民左過去，係咪應該要支持蘇格蘭獨立好呢？
Free Scotland and Wales 😊
😮surprised beginning history of UK. Well said 👍 it's not about what happened in the past; it's about how you overcome dark days and keep standing strong! 👏
You got it😄
@@mingjai14 …
@@mingjai14 〉
surprised beginning history of UK. Well said it's not about what happened in the past; it's about how you overcome dark days and keep standing strong!
我好中意你嘅不正常人类嘅内容，好烧脑，学到很多嘢！🥃
🇲🇾
再一次只用眼睛+腦，去旅行✈✈~~手動👍~冇得去旅行的不正常人類打卡路過~牙~
Great work and so happy to see my sis working with u! Eager to watch the next episodes!
最尾嗰幾分鐘有意義有意思
英國就係一個經歷幾百次清朝的國家。
呢個講法幾有趣，值得深思
喂😂十幾分鐘完全唔夠喉呀
快啲出下集🙏🏻🙏🏻😆
我而家成日都 search 睇你有無新片出
你啲animation technique 愈來愈進步 support!
When the roman's first came to Britain, Colchester (Camulodunum) was the ancient capital not London！
Yea the video merely said they founded London, it didn’t become capital until the normans🤗
aming真係香港優質youtuber真係學到好多嘢，辛苦曬你
Ming哥：非常鍾意聽你講歷史，感激多謝🙏
Very nice summary. I like watching your works. Thanks.
對英國噶歷史停留係亞瑟王時期，同日不落帝國，其他你唔講我可能連大概都講唔出來，主要以前上課都覺得悶
下次講德國🤣🤣
個人認為有強烈立場既人唔適合睇明仔頻道，好易上火
😂
唔緊要，可能藥到病除呢！試一試，分享俾朋友啦！
咁快睇完既..13分鐘吾夠喉…
ming仔講得十分之生動.令我一口氣追哂成個不正常系列.十卜你加油!!!
如果share 俾屋企人同朋友，就perfect池喇。
資料詳盡，客觀分析，street fighter 卡通圖案好特別，短片制作吸引，一啲都吾悶，大人學心都啱睇，支持你咁比心機咁有質素既片👍👍👍
越睇越識多咗 幾拾年被殖民統治 今日先知老闆娘的祖先歷史
過兩集樹頭婆出場🙉
一定要like，好正啊！
Well said at the end!!! support MingGor
等你既片幾耐都值得! 如果可以既講下多D歐洲小國呀 Ming 哥🙂
本身好怕睇歷史 覺得好悶 原來歷史都好有趣 好高質嘅系列！Well done!!
認同黑歷史同黑現代ge概念👍🏻
你的片的呈现方式好有趣，聲畫及內容，好好睇😎
非常期待之後的2集！
nice sharing! I am very appreciate your effort to this video, thx
一講起蘇格蘭即時諗起Mel Gilbson 套Braveheart, 結局非常悲壯，未睇過的話，可以諗下
Britain before🦁, Britain now🐈, Britain in the future🐛
想溫故知新，幾時講下中國歷史？
講吓中國歷史搞吓笑都好😁
好buy最後既觀點。respect
好Jeng😍
Love this series. can't wait to see the next eposidoe
帶英地理純屬外掛 打過機應該可以明白 地理造就文明 文明亦影響地理….
Btw 下次可以講下東南亞華人政權 如蘭芳共和國
未聽夠 期待第二集
Really love this series so so so much!!!!
啲音效好funny，搞到我笑咗幾次XD 期待下一集～
個timeline做得幾好。好有興趣睇埋點解英國會衰落
好一個黑現在，咁我想問下就呢二三十年內，用最漂亮的理由人為地抺去最多生命是那個國家？如你所謂的愛，純是敬畏強者不問真正是與非，那我無言
去玩刺客信條吧，對維京和英格蘭歷史都會有好大幫助
正呀，多謝Ming仔，講得好好，學到嘢！
咁中国究竟是黑历史还是黑现代？中国现在承认了毛时代文革等是错误，但又坚持六四系动乱，镇压无错……
以前唔知道明哥你係咁有深度嘅TH-camr, 失覺晒，我會追返哂你D片…….睇下有冇黑歷史🤣
Waiting for your next epic, thanks.
I’m getting addicted to this series and I like your sense of humour! Keep up the great work Mingjai, looking forward to the next episode :)
Excellent video! The only issue I have relates to the unification of England & Scotland, which needs clarification. In 1603, Queen Elizabeth I of England (the Virgin Queen) died in London without any heir (male or female). Her closest male relative was James Stuart, King James VI of Scotland, who was the son of Mary, Queen of Scots, and Henry Stuart. Mary was the grand-daughter of Margaret Tudor, sister of King Henry VIII of England. Henry Stuart, aka Lord Darnley, was himself a relative of the Tudors. So, by default, James VI of Scotland was crowned King James I of England after QE I. The two kingdoms maintained their separate parliaments under the same monarch(s), except the Republican years of 1649-1660, until 1707 when Queen Anne, the last Stuart queen, signed the Act of Union joining the two as one country with a single Parliament at Westminster. So, looking from a different angle, one can say that England was taken over by Scotland, instead of the other way 'round!
呢一集絕對係巔峰之作。繼續努力，期待更新。
在以巴開戰才看到 ming 仔頻道。簡短精稅流暢地將世界歷史一一講述。講得好有條理又輕鬆。
Excellent presentation!
I have learnt a lot. Thank you so much!