Muslim philosopher clashes with Rabbi over condemnation of IDF’s Gaza casualties
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 พ.ย. 2023
- Muslim philosopher, scholar and TH-camr Mohammed Hijab says he is “consistent” with the manner he approaches conflict from both Islam and Judaism.
Mr Hijab joined Rabbi Shmuley Boteach to debate Israel’s conflict with Hamas in Gaza.
“If it is proven beyond reasonable doubt that these people have killed civilians in both of our faith traditions … I condemn them,” he told Sky News Australia host Piers Morgan.
“I condemn them. That’s what I do straight away whether it is Muslim, whether it is none Muslim, whether it is Christian or anybody else.
“I am not being inconsistent here.”
Muslim Philosopher? he is more like a clown that jumped a travelling circus.
A laughing pig who is growing big every day on british tax payers
Definitely a 🤡
Hijab got utterly embarrassed and exposed again 😳 😆
Go read the comments on some of his videos. His followers are brainwashed into trying to spread Islam to every corner of the world. Some real nutters on there.
Why does his religion matter? The world is an ugly place because of racist people like you.
Can you not call that man a philosopher? Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle must be turning in their graves.
Yup. He is cult head not philosopher. Philosophers are seekers and explorers of life, not fanatic religious figures.
Yeah, everyone's a philosopher these days. Ambassador of Islam vs Ambassador of Zionism.
Yessssss👌👌👌👌👌👌
Exactly, the man's a moron
@@susanna8612 he has a degree in philosophy though
Why are you stuttering?
that guy is not a muslim philosopher, he is only a shouting youtuber. 😂😂😂
😂😂
Oooohhh…your genocide caller rabbi became so crazy even piers failed to control 😂😂😂😂😂
@@nahinisrat1182😅 first of all, what rabbi shmuley saying about genovide is true coz your screaming youtuber hijab, is not a true muslim, but rather an extremist just like the terrorist hamas who are advocating genocide and wants to kills all the jews as what rabbi shmuley pointed out in the discussion, and hijab cannot even look straight. 😂 and lastly, in a way that hijab is arguing, his behaviour and the nonsensical words that he spits in the entire discussion, he only brought shame to the entire community of good muslims around the world. maybe that is the reason why the team of piers invited him.😂
@@nahinisrat1182 still better than the childish nonsense that Abdul was talking about 🤣😂🤣😂
@@disnigga9205 senseless cowards and genocide sympathizer like you can say this. What better people can expect from Israeli terrorist supporters like you. World hates Israel except few greedy people 😂😂😂😂😂
"It is condemnable to do things which are liable to kill civilians."
Ok so Hamas knows this and thus uses civilians to their advantage.
You cant choose to condemn one and support the other. Most western media and people in power completely worship Israel and are hesitant to critisize. Keep the same energy with the group that was literally created from the unjust and violent occupation of Israel.
And israel still has to pull the trigger
Where the civilians said they use by hamas?????
What @@adryanmuktiwicaksono6125
Its like two children fighting over toys.
So faarking true. 😆
Only the toy is an "Holy" land somewere lol
not about that they are geopolitics and middle east if one of the most important ones in world with massive oil and gas@@ori1676
This young man is really rude and violent and bully.
Your rabbi was too soft to handle….genocide caller
@@nahinisrat1182
An empty slogan from an empty mind 😂
@@kingomer9563 what’s the empty slogan?
😂😂😂. Philosopher Mohammed hijab
It is not wise to holler at the camera like that when debating.
You call Hijab Muslim philosopher 😂😂😂.....
seriously this is the era of digital charlatans tate, hijab, Shapiro 😅
Im guessing your a Shapiro fan boy
Care to tell us why hamas leader is sitting pretty in Doha, when there are 11thousand US troops there? Didn't mossad hunt down nazis until they brought them to justice?
And this is why there will never be peace.
SAHIH al-Bukhari :2925 “Slaughter the JEWS wherever you find them” = ISLAMIC SCRIPTURE.
@@luisammartinez5245Liar Liar. Is that your only way to defend your morality by spreading lies and then believing them?
@@yousifalneamy7833 SAHIH al-Bukhari: 2926: YOU don’t know what the hell Islam teaches= google it,and read your Quran!
Ireland is with Palestine, but also wants no more deaths on either side,
This is like when am the Brit’s took over our land an still has a part.
Move out to who you love and free the land you occupy.
Long live israel
long live palestine
@@ASSASIN7-sd5srgo home
@@ASSASIN7-sd5srlong live Palpatine
@@ASSASIN7-sd5srfree palastine from islam
Mo Hijab identified as a "Muslim philosopher" - Is this a joke or something?
islamic philosophy is very good you do need to be Muslim
A philosopher with the last name Hijabi. That’s funny.
History of the imaginary Palestinian state:
1. Before Israel there was a British mandate, not a Palestinian state
2. Before the British Mandate, it was the Ottoman Empire, not a Palestinian state.
3. Before the Ottoman Empire, it was the Islamic state of Egypt’s Mamluks, not a Palestinian state.
4. Before the establishment of the Islamic Mamluk state from Egypt, the Arab-Kurdish Empire was the Ayyubid state, not a Palestinian state.
5. Before the Ayyubid Empire, it was the Frankish and Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem, not a Palestinian state.
6. Before the Kingdom of Jerusalem, it was the Umayyad and Fatimid states, not a Palestinian state.
7. Before the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, the Byzantine Empire was not a Palestinian state.
8. Before the Byzantine Empire, there were the Sassanids, not a Palestinian state. 9. Before the Sasanian Empire, it was the Byzantine Empire, not a Palestinian state.
10. Before the Byzantine Empire, it was the Roman Empire, not a Palestinian state.
11. Before the Roman Empire, it was a Hasmonean state, not a Palestinian state.
12. Before the Hasmonean state, it was the Seleucid state, not a Palestinian state.
13. Before the Seleucid Empire, it was Alexander’s empire, not a Palestinian state.
14. Before Alexander’s empire, it was the Persian Empire, not a Palestinian state.
15. Before the Persian Empire was the Babylonian Empire, not a Palestinian state.
16. Before the Babylonian Empire, there were the kingdoms of Israel and Judah, and it was not a Palestinian state.
17. Before the kingdoms of Israel and Judah, there was no Kingdom of Israel in the Kingdom of Israel, nor a Palestinian state.
18. Before the Kingdom of Israel, the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel was not a Palestinian state.
19. Before the theocracy of the Twelve Tribes of Israel, there was an accumulation of independent Canaanite city-kingdoms, not a Palestinian state.
20. The truth is that in this land kingdoms fell and fell... but there was never a state or a Palestinian people.
Palestinians are Arabs and Arabs came from the Arabian Peninsula, and they are the original inhabitants of the Arabian Peninsula.
It is pure propaganda to claim that the Arabs are the inhabitants of Palestine or that the Palestinians are not Arabs.
Cut and paste nonsense. Palestinians, Jews, Bedouins, Jordanians and Lebanese are all descendants of the Canaanites. Finklestein - Canaanite DNA - Cell. Israel illegally occupies the West Bank and East Jerusalem.
palestinian have cannite dna, which are indiginous.
The british mandate was unlawful, handling the state to other people.
No one is denying jewish heritage to the holy land but why expel the palestinians ?
palestinians are descended from canaanites
"Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas … This is part of our strategy - to isolate the Palestinians in Gaza from the Palestinians in the West Bank.”
March 2019, Netanyahu told his Likud colleagues the above.
Likud Party: Original Party Platform (1977)
a. The right of the Jewish people to the land of Israel is eternal and indisputable and is linked with the right to security and peace; therefore, Judea and Samaria will not be handed to any foreign administration; BETWEEN THE SEA AND THE JORDAN THERE WILL ONLY ISRAELI SOVEREIGNTY
b. A plan which relinquishes parts of western Eretz Israel, undermines our right to the country, unavoidably leads to the establishment of a "Palestinian State," jeopardizes the security of the Jewish population, endangers the existence of the State of Israel. and frustrates any prospect of peace
Brig. Gen. Yitzhak Segev, who was the Israeli military governor in Gaza in the early 1980s. Segev later told a New York Times reporter that he had helped finance the Palestinian Islamist movement as a “counterweight” to the secularists and leftists of the Palestine Liberation Organization and the Fatah party, led by Yasser Arafat (who himself referred to Hamas as “a creature of Israel.”)
“The Israeli government gave me a budget,” the retired brigadier general confessed, “and the military government gives to the mosques.”
“Hamas, to my great regret, is Israel’s creation,” Avner Cohen, a former Israeli religious affairs official who worked in Gaza for more than two decades, told the Wall Street Journal in 2009. Back in the mid-1980s, Cohen even wrote an official report to his superiors warning them not to play divide-and-rule in the Occupied Territories, by backing Palestinian Islamists against Palestinian secularists. “I … suggest focusing our efforts on finding ways to break up this monster before this reality jumps in our face,” he wrote.
Sources:
Hansard Israel/Gaza
Volume 833: debated on Tuesday 24 October 2023
For years, Netanyahu propped up Hamas. Now it’s blown up in our faces - The premier’s policy of treating the terror group as a partner, at the expense of Abbas and Palestinian statehood, has resulted in wounds that will take Israel years to heal from
By TAL SCHNEIDER Times of Israel
8 October 2023, 3:58 pm
Netanyahu: Money to Hamas part of strategy to keep Palestinians divided
Jerusalem Post 12 March 2019
Also: The Guardian 20 Oct 2023
@@jamesmorrow1646Philistines are NEVER the same of this FAKE ARAB MADE Palestine state put there by Britain.
Yeah good one. A talk between a rabbi and a muslim philospher about gaza is always going to end well isn't it😁
I watched this earlier. Comedy Gold. Definitely not a debate lol
why?
@@user-cm3cd2gk2kbecuase the man in the blue suit is a terrorist supporter
He even looooks like a terrorist… I’d never trust some one who looks like Him to fly in a plane.
He looks like a 9/11 terrorist
God gave us two ears and one mouth. Muhammed should learn to listen a little bit instead of talking so much... keeps inturupting.
He thinks he is god. Typical fanatic.
People don't care about the 2 state solution. Is it possible for both sides to just stop being so cruel?
"Philosopher."
🤡
He has 3 masters, one in philosophy, one in theology, and a PhD in Islamic philosophy so... Lol
😂😂 his mother hated him fancy calling him hijab 😂😂😂
Hijab is his last name you twat, his mother didn’t give him that
His name is Mohamed .. hijab is his surname
This guy punk muhammad is so maddingly annoying. You can see he learned his debate skills like a street chess hustler - on the streets. And his manners show it.
Read the comments on his channel and you'll see what type of people follow him.
There is only 2 group of people with who you cant have real conversation because they think they are above anyone else and only serves their own agenda and its "liberal" leftists and Islamists.
Both enemies of the free world.
The rabbi was even worse
@@SMSSAKSKPHONIEX umm no he wasn't I didn't even like this rabbis oratory style but hijab makes him look really good.
Hamas has a right to defend itself too as it was doing on Oct. 7th. By carrying out the attack it was attempting to minimize civilian casualties. You think that my logic is absurd??? I’m only applying the same standard to Hamas that you guys apply to the IDF.
I don’t have a dog in this fight but how can that muso defend 7 Oct….
Piers is just happy not to be the dumbest one at the desk, for once.
That’s how you know you’re the dumbest if you think piers was a smart man
Though aggressive, Hijab was the intellectual superior here, with the rabbi being the dumbest and relying almost purely on ad hominems
Free Israel
From the river to the sea, Israel will be free only by God's hand.
Fuck the Zionist state
Free israel from what??😂😂😂 from this world?😂😂
Rabbi: *starts raising his voice
Hijab: "Stop pointing at me."
Rabbi: Stops pointing and lowers voice.
😄
and these people continue to breed GOD HELP US ALL THAT ARE NORMAL
Rabbi wins, in all senses!!!
The confidence 💀
Hijab should not have left Speakers Corner.
Never wise to argue with the GOD of Abraham wise rabbi's. Almighty does not like it .
The Rabbi owned this fool. 😆
@@jacobl.s.9467 You and I clearly didn't watch the same debate. The Rabbi was obliterated. He openly supports oppression and genocide of Palestinians. He's no Rabbi. He's a charlatan. The oppressive and genocide sympathising God of the Rabbi is not my God.
I’m 5 minutes into the video. So far I see Mohammed Hijab not answering the questions and constantly interrupting and yelling over the other guest and Pierce while they are speaking. I think the only way to have a fair debate is to do it virtually and mute everyone else while one person gets their minute to speak.
Ahha u finally experience short flash entertainment at its finest. Watch the whole debate and then say what u say. The Rabbi was even worse 💀
"Why are you so anti-Hamas?” “I mean, isn't pita bread the real enemy here?” - Bruno.
Jews Rock and Cohen made a mockery of the islamic aspect of the middle east time and time again 😆
Found IDF’s news network
Good grief..no wonder God flooded the planet.
No Zionism = Peace
Not to forget Netanyahu showing the fully Palestinian land including the occupied as Israel map in a UN conference this year 2023 without being SHAMEFUL.
Who is the real terrorist Hamas or Israel? the answer: Hamas attack had israeli civilian death ratio to israeli military death as 3:1(Israels own name list of 1200 death of which 30/40 are IDF). Israels killing rate of civilian in gazan vs killed hamas fighters is 180:1 , even a retired person can figure/calculate out the answer to the question.
Weird how people are ok with killing children . Really weird
The Lord says to love your neighbour, this shouldn't have happened.
The Lord is wise above all Amen 🙏😌
Exactly. It's a real shame Israel is oppressing the Palestinians the way it is. Stealing their lands, occupying them, etc. Israel is embarrassing to Judaism, and the West is embarrassing to Christianity, who support such an apartheid regime.
Hijab trolled unholy Shmuley big time, he used this zionist's tactics against them. This is what stuck with me, “justice is a prerequisite for peace”, the whole truth in a nutshell. Hijab on this episode with Piers and unholy Shmuley was a comedy gold, props to Hijab, he had me in stitches.
Everything hamas is blamed for, Israel did worse.
🇮🇱👍🏼🇮🇱👍🏼🇮🇱
philosopher ? what r u talking about ? this man physically threatens people in speaker's corner in london and other locations
he is very good
this debate was messy but Hijab was right in his conclusion. In conclusion, JUSTICE IS REQUIRED FOR PEACE. Thats so truee. u cant expect peace if theres no just. Unless you want a FAKE PEACE
justice for what ?? Israel backed to his land after 2000 years of exile, the Arab exploit the fact the Arab nation invaded Israel a few times over the history and took over those lands, they should say thank you for giving them a place and offering them to build their own country after ignoring over and over again the existence of Israel.
If let them hey speak one over the other is imposible to follow
Hijab is already medium rare in the first 10 min 😂
These two academics have strongly supported Margaret Thatcher's assertion that debates tend to generate more hot air than light.
I kind of like Shumley, he is nowhere near as evil as say, Alan Dershowitz 🎉
A real text book example of how to have impossible conversations. Just calmly arguing for your own point without for example bringing up the sex life of your opponent. Thank you, sirs!
The Rabbi is a disgrace to humanity. Openly supporting genocide and oppression.
Yk the Rabbi started calling him personal and discusting things first and continously. Glad that Hijab called him out for his Hipocracy.
As the Rabbi was so professional 😂😂
He made Unholy Shmuley a trend .
You can't expect that average to stick
Boteach ripped him a new one :)
Proper debate 😂😂😂.
Rabbi Shmuley is a joke, this man consistently uses an Ad Hominem as a starting point in his debate in other debates that I’ve seen, one off the top of my head is the one with Cenk Ugur. Mohammed puts up a great argument but should’ve held the moral high ground by refraining from biting back at him.
After reading some of the comments you can tell people don't care about what's right or wrong. Telling a lie to support your argument/side? Will that give you some satisfaction?
BRAVO TO THE RABBI!!!!
Piers Morgan is a hopeless moderator. You need someone disciplined like Jeremy Paxman.
Philosopher? I thought Averroes, Ibn Arabi and Suhrawardhi were Muslim philosophers...the bar has fallen low.
Here are his full accreditations:
PhD - University of Birmingham (Completing)
MTH in Applied Theology - University of Oxford
MA in Islamic Studies - SOAS University London
MA in History - Queen Mary University of London
BA in Politics - - Queen Mary University of London 2010 - 2013
BA in Islamic Sciences - Al-Azhar (Completing)
But sure hes just a “Muslim philosopher”
You forgot to list:
Pervert who endorses child marriage
Islamist who endorses violence against none Muslims
Golden shower endorser
Wife beater
Anti Semitic
Brawler
Sexual deviant who offers to suck the breasts of other mens wives
Egotistical moron
The only man who suffers from penis envy
The only Muslim who thinks his god al lah prays to his prophet....
But sure, he's a scholar, "student of religion"
Bullshit.
Islamic studies. Really, do they have Harry Potter studies too?
arab islamic civilization is one of the most influential in human history @@mithrasrevisited4873
@@mithrasrevisited4873 A degree in Islamic studies typically involves the academic study of Islam, its beliefs, history, culture, and practices. Students may explore topics such as theology, Quranic studies, Islamic law, and the history of Muslim civilizations. It provides a comprehensive understanding of Islam from both religious and cultural perspectives. I don’t understand your comment..
I agree . Rabbi Boteach did an excellent job of getting a word in with Mr. Hijab as the opponent.
There shouldn’t have been shouting from both sides, and people on the comments sections are racist. Not trying to see the whole picture. As always people currently believes the IDF who has a history of lying. Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Good Muslims should say no to Hamas.
Unholy Shmoly😂😂😂😂
That rabbi was an embarrassment….was busy with screaming and shouting without any logical points to backup. What else this genocide caller can do who don’t even recognize state of Palestine. Hijab was in another level. MashaAllah
True
They were both aggressive, but if you watch the whole interview, Hijab was very clearly the intellectual superior. The rabbi consistently relied on personal arguements and ad hominems FROM THE START, piers even aknowledged this
U are insane, hijab is a absolute clown, talking about sex acts and vibrators. A total LOSER.
Richard Falk, American international law scholar and former UN Special Rapporteur for Palestine: "Israel's occupation of Palestinian land, use of excessive force, and policies like settlement expansion and the blockade of Gaza classify it as a terrorist state."
Never argue with a fool. Onlookers might not be able to tell the difference (Mark Twain).
Why its... like they Missed the Compassion Teacher..
Ahem.
philosopher, this word is thrown out just like that these days, how sad that the word meant something in the past.
Lol the Rabbi is nuts. And his followers are just mad he’s debating someone out of his league, so they resort to belittling his title. May Allah make the Muslims victorious!
Omg he is a sex guru plus rabbi ? How does that work ?
Will there be peace?Has the world tired of the pointless rationalisations & the taking of sides?All I see are bodies on both sides, trails of blood, relatively young men trying to do their best to get the wounded to a hospital that might be able to treat them while the pointless arguments rage.
He debated piers morgan and the
Rabbi together next debate mohamed must bring Daniel
So it will be 2 vs 2
@RafikKhan-ol4zk Is Daniel the guy who said that a 5 year old can get married if she's physically and mentally mature provided her parents grant consent?
Mohamed did very well in the debate
Hijab definitely had the best argument. He would have won the debate if it was on based on debating.
Definitely a very compelling statement you have made here. You would have won the statement contest if it was based on stating.
Talking about the bedroom was an amazing debate 😂😂
@@sholoy480 Ha ha. Yes I made a statement and so have you.
@@disnigga9205 You missed his actual argument obviously.
@@msbramble176 nope 😂
Rabbi Boteach did an excellent job of getting a word in with Mr. Hijab as the opponent.
I watched the whole uncensored 1 hour. Shmuley was absolutely belligerent.
He only shouting even piers have to tell him dont shout let him answer hehehe unholly rabbis daughter has a kosher sexshop
@@msbramble176 I found Mr. Hijab to be belligerent overbearing rude and repetitive repeatedly gunfiring the same phrase as if he had turrets. Does he have turrets or does he just consider that a valid style of arguing?
@@charwest9449 Yep belligerent for sure but his arguments were sound, and Piers always repeats the same question over and over and over and Shmuley usually screams "blood liable" over and over. It was a meeting of 3 belligerents, but Hijab had the soundest argument if you actually listen. If you can stand it the whole hour version shows Shmuley to be very belligerent and petty.
@@msbramble176 Hijab's arguments were not sound, they were immaterial -- that 100 to 1 ratio he kept repeating ad nauseum is not a critical factor, INTENT is. Hamas tries its best to harm civilians, hides behind them, puts and keeps them in harm's way to protect itself. Israel tries its best to protect civilians even putting itself in harm's way. Hijab made very little sense.
The muslims guy has no manners .Just likes the sound of his own voice. Horrible ignorance and bullying.
Two weirdos. 😆
Religion is a cult, any religion
Religion is the cause of all suffering
I gotta grow a bearrd.
Beard gives vibes of confidence and manhood
They will defend there wrong with
Anger
Go Rabbi. We are on your and in Jewish people side. We are not stupid or blind and see what has happened even to Europe too in past 15 years.
This how Israel feels. They also like Churchill do not admit that a great wrong has been done to Palestinians as settler colonisers move in their land.
In 1937, Churchill stated that:
I do not admit ... for instance, that a great wrong has been done to the Red Indians of America or the black people of Australia. I do not admit that a wrong has been done to these people by the fact that a stronger race, a higher-grade race, a more worldly wise race to put it that way, has come in and taken their place.
Islam fare treatment of prisonors? Rabbi doesn't know islam.
Why only blame hamas also blame
America
How is this Americas fault? Abdul 😂😂
Hijab even doesn’t let his opponent voice to be heard. Ex Muslim here, this dirty tactic is not new.
arab islamic civilization is one of the most influential in human history
@@user-cm3cd2gk2k Yes very influential, down graded any civilization they conquered.
Ah, an "ex-muslim". As biased as can be. The Rabbi is the one who didn't let any voices be heard.
@@shahram6869 Hijab has always used fallacies. And you as well.
Attacking the messenger is a fallacy. But I don’t expect Muslims to finish any argument without using fallacy.
@@shahram6869 And your country was downgraded after conquered by Islam. Ask any patriotic Iranian they tell you so.
Free palestiaians
Hijab 🦁
Muslims behave badly on every occasion x
Mohamed did an exellent job
At embarrassing himself
Think hijab finger got numb by pointing pathetic.
Why is it challenging for muslim to engage an articulate speaker for debates? I've noticed that Hijab's recent debates have been characterized by aggressiveness, nonsensical arguments, and a lack of professionalism. Muslim, please consider the impact this debater is having on your image; it's reflecting poorly on islam.
Hahahah Mimi Hijab wantsnface-to-face confrontation! 😂 No sane person will sacrifice their soldiers so Mimi can play 620 AD
Muslim philosopher🙄
Sorry, where is the philosopher? I did not get it
Mohamed debated piers morgan and the Rabbi together next debate
Mohamed must bring daniel then
It will be 2 vs 2
Piers was unbiased, Abdul 😂😂
All I care about are the innocent people especially the children, I could not care less about who owns what. What a sick a twisted world that people are justifying this bloodshed
That’s what Islam does to human beings ! I hope this dude be free from that ideology and seek treatment
😂 rabbi got so personal and was interrupting Mohammed so much that it just funny. It's so pathetic
It's amazing how Muslim Arabs gave a knack for inverting facts and making themselves the victims.
The Abdul talking about the rabbis bedroom, wasn’t personal?🤣🤣🤣
@@disnigga9205 there's a difference between roasting someone and getting seriously personal or offended personally
@@xzil2167 Maybe you are blind, the Jew won the debate
@@ori1676 😂 sure buddy. All he did was shout.
Send this philosopher to Gaza to defend Gazans.
He’s defining them on media.
that rabbi is clearly older than the other guy and im quite worried for how the rabbi gets upset on tv. he got to protect his health, he's kinda losing it. now calm down🤣