This Case blows my mind how this mother was brutally murdered by her daughter and everyone around her is coddling Sydney and What she did to her mother it is sick
Treating a murderer as a victim is insane. The murderer’s father was asked if his daughter ever sought treatment. He said no. The woman deceived her family and friends about major problems she was having, and lied to investigators, and tried to hide the crime scene. She beat her mother to death with a frying pan. That took malicious intent, to say the least! The attorney is using sleight of hand. Even if the defense gets a sur rebuttal, the jury will still find the defendant guilty.
A new trial will still have the same outcome. Guilty!! She was sane enough to pretend to be her mother on the phone, to set up the scene to look like a break in, and all the lies she told her family. She is not, and was NOT insane at the time of the murder. Just another selfish spoiled brat only daughter, who is the favorite of her father. He sees no wrong in her. I feel sorry for the dead mother, no one seems to care about her.
Right?... I actually have read about other kids young adults livi g a lie about college etc.. and murder their parents horrifically. So now it's called mental health. Disgusting spoiled kids .
@@rossi5839 Jennifer Pan as well. The Netflix doc is trash, but many true crime channels have covered it. All pathological liars. All unalived their parents when they were about to find out.
Allegedly she was mentally ill. But everyone with a brain contests that based on her behaviour before, during, and right after. She lied to her parents, friends, and university for months. When the parents found out she killed the mom, then tried to cover it up.
She is GUILTY! She MURDERED her Mother 😢😢😢. Why should money be wasted on another trial??? She's spoiled and entitled!! GIVE HER A LONGER SENTANCE!!! NO sympathy!!!
Because in America, people are afforded FAIR trials. She din't get one, so she gets a new one. You should be mad at the judge for violating the defendant's right to a fair trial.
This is a travesty of justice. It’s her FAMILY that wants her out of prison. They’re highly dysfunctional and justify her actions. They’re as sick as she is. Imo
Give her a new trial. It will be the same result. Defense lawyer is delusional about his client. It's one thing to provide a competent defense for your client. It's another thing to say you see your daughter in Sydney. There was more than enough evidence to show that she knew the wrongfulness of her actions. If she got away with this her father or grandmother would be next.
So what!?? They arent the first and only family who didn't want their family member to go to trial! The entitlement and feeling of privilege with this family and their darling sydney is over the top and ridiculous Why should she be treated any different than any other criminal or person that off'd their parent?? She is a danger to the community no different than carley gregg. Pretty sure carley has mental health issues too. Anyone that does something that diabolical has mental health issues Its not an excuse! Not even for the 'princess' this is sooo ..🤬
How Sydney was treated through out the whole thing made me sick. In the first trial the judge allowed her to leave the courtroom when pictures of what she did came up in case she had a breakdown. She also wanted a service dog to cope with the trauma that she herself inflicted. That is infuriating. She saw no issue with brutally killing her own mother but is too weak to look at the carnage of what she did? Disgusting. Thankfully the service dog request was denied as the company said we only provide dogs who were victims of crimes. Hope the second time around Sydney gets life without parole. Justice for Brenda.
it’s crazy that sydney only got 15 years, i don’t get why a judge would be so lenient on sydney who had malicious intent and was sober when she ended her mothers life. it makes no sense at all.
It wasn’t a fit of rage (I could maybe see that if it was just the frying pan) but she used a knife after that and then staged it as a break in? Like I’ve gotten mad and pushed my sisters when we were young but then got up and was like oh no and immediately felt bad this wasn’t that
Agreed! The knife & staging is another level. Obviously fry pan is unacceptable, but you could kind of see it as a snap (bad) reaction for a young girl in crisis. The screaming for Daddy out front, after police questioned the cuts on her hand, was also highly manipulative. She knew she had been caught out lying & setting the scene. This whole appeal is just her doubling down, absolutely nothing learnt & no responsibility taken.
Just because the victims (her dad and now deceased mother and other family) do not want to see her go to trial does not mean there wont be one. She would have to plead guilty. So ultimately....what does the defense even argue that this appeal would solve ? There will still be a trial and she will still be found guilty. How much of a mitigated sentence can you possibly ask for
This is outrages... the trial itself was weird with that short sentence... yet she is granted a new trial ? To me that is no justice to her mothers life she took so brutaly away... she faked to be her mither on the phone, she tamered with the scene etc... all these lies and so forth... She did what she did and she must face the consequences.... period.... she is only sorry for herself ... no true remorse imo... only selfsorry and playing the victim... how dare...
You cannot do tests after the event. You can only truly know for sure either way if you were present at the time of the alleged psychotic episode. Baseless defence, imo. Let's hope the new trial sentences her appropriately this time - LIFE, WOP!
Listening to this defense attorney is almost sickening in this case. What makes her so special, all the convicts probably need extra special mental health help. Why do some qualify and others don't??
This is ridiculous. She knew what she was doing. She deserves that murder sentence. She better remain in prison during the "new trial." Edit: The only VICTIM is Brenda. The family are concerned more about the killer than the victim because they feel bad. This brat's rights weren't trampled on. She was finally held accountable for her behaviour.
I am so glad about this. This is one of the cases in which the justice wasn’t served. Horrible to read comments from ignorant people who lack empathy and don’t understand mental health.
I can’t even believe she was out of bail living with her grandmother. 🤯 How is that even possible? She deserves life without parole. Idc. That’s your MOTHER!! I’ve been through horrific abuse and never killed my parents. Reminds me of Gypsy Rose. Two completely different cases with different circumstances but still! Absolutely horrific! Two wrongs doesn’t make a right!
I am sorry, but for a child to commit murder ‘out of the blue’, according to her Father (“No history of needing mental health intervention”), she absolutely deserves some form of punishment. No hall pass because SUDDENLY her mental health failed her. This Attorney sounds like the King of the Participation Trophy justice league. No rebuttal allowed? I understand that and agree with filing an appeal on this basis. I agree with the courts recognizing this error. But for her to get off Scott free? To come home like nothing happened? Absolutely not!
Wtf? If you are a murderer you don't belong free in public period! I don't care if she's nutts obviously you gotta be nutts to murderer a person for any reason other than self defense.
I am glad about this. State expert was incompetent and indeed defence was not able to question that at the end. Thanks Court TV for following up with this story.
She stabbed mother FCS she stabbed her Life should be her sentence We all know Carly Gregg shot her mother & stepdad the mom died she got Life in prison even tho they played the mental issue's thing
How terrible is this to give her a new trial. The lawyers need to run their business correctly the first time and stop trying to play new trial games where dead people are involved no respect for the victims. Shameful 😢
I'd like to know what Sydney's little brother thinks. She took his mom away from him. She was failing and her pride wasn't going let it be known. Maybe she'll get LWOP this time.
Had a bad feeling when Judge refused to let Defense have another rebuttal witness! Now appeals court says that should have been allowed. Yikes 😬she is still getting convicted as evidence proves she was just an entitled brat hiding secrets and when found out lashed out violently! Scary dangerous girl!
this wont go to trial this will become a mental health issue thats all is what will come out this expect maybe a mental health institution to get her help.
From all appearances, it doesn't look like Sydney was a calculated killer. To me, she looks like she was just spiraling. Nothing about what she was doing seems planned or devious, but rather desperate and improvised. She seemed confused about her own condition and unwilling to ask for help for whatever reason. Mental health might be a real factor here.
*So were Sydney’s family hoping for all charges to be dropped altogether? I don’t think it works that way even when the defendant has the full support of both families*
😮 WHAT!! I mean ru fkn kidding me! Absolutely not, this makes me sick 2 my stomach 😢😢 so sad this Ohio Court is obviously weak, but my opinion $$$ talks🤨🤔
She knew the difference between right and wrong that’s why she will be convicted. Unfortunately they still prosecute even if the family on the victim’s side is against the prosecution 🤷🏽♀️.
... but she wasn't insane when she committed the act and that's what matters. She knew what she did was wrong, then tried to cover it up. This is a waste of tax payer money. "Betrayed by the court system" my ass...
#CourtTV What do YOU think?
Catch up on the case against #SydneyPowell: www.courttv.com/tag/sydney-powell/?
It was torture for the mother who was killed, not for Sydney.
Exactly.
Yes she could have stopped at any time during the attack but didn't she tried to cover up the crime scene so no she knew what she was doing..
Horrible way to go..AND by your own baby girl..so sad
@@annebosworth7048exactly
This Case blows my mind how this mother was brutally murdered by her daughter and everyone around her is coddling Sydney and What she did to her mother it is sick
Her father supports her 🤷🏾♀️
You’re sick. She didn’t get a fair trial moron.
Completely agree with you, absolutely crazy that people are supporting murderers like Sydney and Luigi Mangione
It's mind blowing you'd think she'd take the 15 years do it quietly
@@Fayw2023very strange ....don't add up ....how could he !!!!
I hope this time the judge hands down a sentence she deserves…. LIFE W/ Out parole
Where is justice for the true victim Brenda Powell whose life was brutally cut short?
I'm dumbfounded how anyone could have any sympathy for the murderer.
her justice is the trial. However, that doesnt mean the defendant doesnt get a FAIR trial. Welcome to America. Read the constitution.
Treating a murderer as a victim is insane. The murderer’s father was asked if his daughter ever sought treatment. He said no. The woman deceived her family and friends about major problems she was having, and lied to investigators, and tried to hide the crime scene. She beat her mother to death with a frying pan. That took malicious intent, to say the least! The attorney is using sleight of hand. Even if the defense gets a sur rebuttal, the jury will still find the defendant guilty.
A new trial will still have the same outcome. Guilty!! She was sane enough to pretend to be her mother on the phone, to set up the scene to look like a break in, and all the lies she told her family. She is not, and was NOT insane at the time of the murder. Just another selfish spoiled brat only daughter, who is the favorite of her father. He sees no wrong in her. I feel sorry for the dead mother, no one seems to care about her.
She ended her mother's life and she only has remorse for herself. I'm dumbfounded how anyone could have sympathy for the murderer.
try her again, convict her again, lock her back up.............again
A longer sentence perhaps
Hopefully she gets a longer sentence.
Agree
Exactly!
For real
Wow this is ridiculous, she is exactly where she should be. What next, Chandler Holderson gets out?
Could you imagine if Sydney and Chandler hooked up😮 both stories are so similar, it's unbelievable.
Right?... I actually have read about other kids young adults livi g a lie about college etc.. and murder their parents horrifically. So now it's called mental health. Disgusting spoiled kids .
@@rossi5839 Jennifer Pan as well. The Netflix doc is trash, but many true crime channels have covered it. All pathological liars. All unalived their parents when they were about to find out.
@@rossi5839 How about a love triangle with Sydney, Chandler, and Grant Amato? They can fight over her.
Blame the trial judge
She should be more than grateful that she even has a chance of parole after 15 years
Why only 15 years for her while others get life with no parole?? How old was she 23?? Her mother didn't abuse her Or anything why 15 years??
It's called Mental Health
Carly Gregg, a child, got a life sentence. Sydney Powell gets a slap on the wrist. That's messed up.
@mainecoon6514 yeah but why??
@mainecoon6514 if a younger male does This Is life With no parole
Allegedly she was mentally ill. But everyone with a brain contests that based on her behaviour before, during, and right after. She lied to her parents, friends, and university for months. When the parents found out she killed the mom, then tried to cover it up.
She is GUILTY! She MURDERED her Mother 😢😢😢. Why should money be wasted on another trial??? She's spoiled and entitled!! GIVE HER A LONGER SENTANCE!!! NO sympathy!!!
Because in America, people are afforded FAIR trials. She din't get one, so she gets a new one. You should be mad at the judge for violating the defendant's right to a fair trial.
@MicheleBorchewEsq I'm not mad at anyone
She is NOT the victim here - she should have gotten 25 to life in the first place 😡
Unbelievable. Entitled girl killed her mother. Period. 🙄
This mental health thing is going too far......
It sure is.
This is a travesty of justice. It’s her FAMILY that wants her out of prison. They’re highly dysfunctional and justify her actions. They’re as sick as she is. Imo
"Justice" = "Due process"
If the state can prove their case, they can also prove it the right way -- no shortcuts.
My advice to the family…if she gets out lock your bedroom door at night & sleep with one eye open.
They're all for her
Give her a new trial. It will be the same result. Defense lawyer is delusional about his client. It's one thing to provide a competent defense for your client. It's another thing to say you see your daughter in Sydney. There was more than enough evidence to show that she knew the wrongfulness of her actions.
If she got away with this her father or grandmother would be next.
Life without parole! Period!!
not happening!!
So what!?? They arent the first and only family who didn't want their family member to go to trial! The entitlement and feeling of privilege with this family and their darling sydney is over the top and ridiculous Why should she be treated any different than any other criminal or person that off'd their parent?? She is a danger to the community no different than carley gregg. Pretty sure carley has mental health issues too. Anyone that does something that diabolical has mental health issues Its not an excuse! Not even for the 'princess' this is sooo ..🤬
Or Joel guy or Chandler Halderson. You have to have a mental defect to M someone.
He is assuming the jurors found their decision on the experts , which BTW, they (the jurors) don't have to consider at all.
Good point!
I find it absolutely absurd she gets this and carly gregg gets nothing. Despicable.
Disgusting. She faked craziness. And murdered her mother in brutal fashion.
How Sydney was treated through out the whole thing made me sick. In the first trial the judge allowed her to leave the courtroom when pictures of what she did came up in case she had a breakdown. She also wanted a service dog to cope with the trauma that she herself inflicted. That is infuriating. She saw no issue with brutally killing her own mother but is too weak to look at the carnage of what she did? Disgusting. Thankfully the service dog request was denied as the company said we only provide dogs who were victims of crimes.
Hope the second time around Sydney gets life without parole. Justice for Brenda.
it’s crazy that sydney only got 15 years, i don’t get why a judge would be so lenient on sydney who had malicious intent and was sober when she ended her mothers life. it makes no sense at all.
Is the defense attorney ok? Comparing this cold blooded murder to
His daughter?
This defense attorney is delusional.
naww hes smart not delusional! thats why ur not lawyer and he is
15 years was a gift.
This is not about what the family want but justice for the mother she murdered in cold blood.
This is ridiculous! No crisis other than she didn’t want her parents to find out her secrets. She knew EXACTLY what she was doing 😡
It wasn’t a fit of rage (I could maybe see that if it was just the frying pan) but she used a knife after that and then staged it as a break in? Like I’ve gotten mad and pushed my sisters when we were young but then got up and was like oh no and immediately felt bad this wasn’t that
Agreed! The knife & staging is another level. Obviously fry pan is unacceptable, but you could kind of see it as a snap (bad) reaction for a young girl in crisis. The screaming for Daddy out front, after police questioned the cuts on her hand, was also highly manipulative. She knew she had been caught out lying & setting the scene. This whole appeal is just her doubling down, absolutely nothing learnt & no responsibility taken.
If I was the judge I would give her more time! She deserves to be in prison wasting time on appeals…WTF
Next, she'll be convicted again
This guy is gross. I don’t know why they let him on here
You’re gross.
He likes to sniff just like old Joe.
@@VampirusXGo take a hike, troll.
Get it right at the 1st trial and then we dont have to spend thousands on another trial
She will be found guilty again, period
Just because the victims (her dad and now deceased mother and other family) do not want to see her go to trial does not mean there wont be one. She would have to plead guilty. So ultimately....what does the defense even argue that this appeal would solve ? There will still be a trial and she will still be found guilty. How much of a mitigated sentence can you possibly ask for
So I’m hoping that she will get Life w/out parole in the end of this new trial because her mom won’t get another life to live again 😢
This is outrages... the trial itself was weird with that short sentence... yet she is granted a new trial ? To me that is no justice to her mothers life she took so brutaly away... she faked to be her mither on the phone, she tamered with the scene etc... all these lies and so forth... She did what she did and she must face the consequences.... period.... she is only sorry for herself ... no true remorse imo... only selfsorry and playing the victim... how dare...
You cannot do tests after the event. You can only truly know for sure either way if you were present at the time of the alleged psychotic episode. Baseless defence, imo. Let's hope the new trial sentences her appropriately this time - LIFE, WOP!
From the get go this murderer has been treated like the victim, while her poor mother’s life was cut short by her hands . Just disturbing
Parents love and raise their kids and this is how they repay them for every sacrifice they made for them.
LIFE. She was deliberate in the murder of her dear mother. Unforgivable.
Where is Brenda’s rights? it all becomes about Sydney! The behaviour of the adults in her life is why things like this happen.. called enabling 🤯
Its another Chandler Halderson case. Live a life of lies and when they come crashing down, they do the horrible.
Listening to this defense attorney is almost sickening in this case. What makes her so special, all the convicts probably need extra special mental health help. Why do some qualify and others don't??
These wastes of lives languishing and wasting taxpayer dollars .. they away with it which is outrageous!
All a waste of money
This is ridiculous. She knew what she was doing. She deserves that murder sentence. She better remain in prison during the "new trial."
Edit: The only VICTIM is Brenda. The family are concerned more about the killer than the victim because they feel bad. This brat's rights weren't trampled on. She was finally held accountable for her behaviour.
I am so glad about this. This is one of the cases in which the justice wasn’t served. Horrible to read comments from ignorant people who lack empathy and don’t understand mental health.
I can’t even believe she was out of bail living with her grandmother. 🤯 How is that even possible? She deserves life without parole. Idc. That’s your MOTHER!! I’ve been through horrific abuse and never killed my parents. Reminds me of Gypsy Rose. Two completely different cases with different circumstances but still! Absolutely horrific! Two wrongs doesn’t make a right!
It seems brrenda,s mother or husband cared much about brenda the actual victim, Rip Brenda.
Never heard of a surrerebuttal by the defense in a criminal case. If it's allowed/acceptable, why would the judge deny that???
will be found guilty again
She and Chandler Halderson would be a great couple
I am sorry, but for a child to commit murder ‘out of the blue’, according to her Father (“No history of needing mental health intervention”), she absolutely deserves some form of punishment. No hall pass because SUDDENLY her mental health failed her. This Attorney sounds like the King of the Participation Trophy justice league. No rebuttal allowed? I understand that and agree with filing an appeal on this basis. I agree with the courts recognizing this error. But for her to get off Scott free? To come home like nothing happened? Absolutely not!
Life in prison period, appeal all you want.
Privileged 😢
Privilege!
She is a mother killer that should have got life without any chance of parole. What has American law came too
Geezs waste of money
The friends of Sydney are not in charge of the law.
Wtf? If you are a murderer you don't belong free in public period! I don't care if she's nutts obviously you gotta be nutts to murderer a person for any reason other than self defense.
She will be convicted again. I feel like Brenda is overlooked in all of this. It’s all about Sydney and that doesn’t sit right with me. 😕
I had never heard of a surrebuttal until the sarah boone trial.
Just retry her...guilty again...the lawyers earn money...win/win...how good is our legal system?
Exactly 💯!!!
I am glad about this. State expert was incompetent and indeed defence was not able to question that at the end. Thanks Court TV for following up with this story.
Can they give her the death penalty?
What's with people and the last name powell being horrible people
she should never be allowed to roam free. such a waste of money and time. GUILTY as charged
How nice the murderer ,her rights were violated, but what about the rights the mother had to live? She didn't have any rights not be killed?
She stabbed mother FCS she stabbed her Life should be her sentence We all know Carly Gregg shot her mother & stepdad the mom died she got Life in prison even tho they played the mental issue's thing
How terrible is this to give her a new trial. The lawyers need to run their business correctly the first time and stop trying to play new trial games where dead people are involved no respect for the victims. Shameful 😢
She killed 2:39 her best friend in life. 😢 She will be found guilty again.
Sickening.
This i insane. She need prison for life PERIOD
I'd like to know what Sydney's little brother thinks. She took his mom away from him. She was failing and her pride wasn't going let it be known. Maybe she'll get LWOP this time.
Had a bad feeling when Judge refused to let Defense have another rebuttal witness! Now appeals court says that should have been allowed. Yikes 😬she is still getting convicted as evidence proves she was just an entitled brat hiding secrets and when found out lashed out violently! Scary dangerous girl!
this wont go to trial this will become a mental health issue thats all is what will come out this expect maybe a mental health institution to get her help.
This serves as a crucial example for individuals to seek mental health support before engaging in criminal behavior.
If mentally ill is asylum next? What rights if you murder someone?
Nah you can be treated
Actions have consequences.
From all appearances, it doesn't look like Sydney was a calculated killer. To me, she looks like she was just spiraling. Nothing about what she was doing seems planned or devious, but rather desperate and improvised. She seemed confused about her own condition and unwilling to ask for help for whatever reason. Mental health might be a real factor here.
Wow. That was quick.
If the appellate court says it is erroneous then it is flawed!
Now how long do we think it will be to get a new trial??
Wow I’m really surprised!
She'll be convicted again.
Ridiculous
*So were Sydney’s family hoping for all charges to be dropped altogether? I don’t think it works that way even when the defendant has the full support of both families*
Justice/the victim is usually the deceased person.
😮 WHAT!! I mean ru fkn kidding me! Absolutely not, this makes me sick 2 my stomach 😢😢 so sad this Ohio Court is obviously weak, but my opinion $$$ talks🤨🤔
earth to the people in the comments: affording a defendant a FAIR trial is NOT sympathy. It is what our justice system promises (and fails too often)
Actually this is GREAT she got only 15 years I hope the new trial she gets life without parole
What?????? She killed her mother
She still needs to spend time in jail.
? She IS in prison.
She just didn't want get caught flunking school. Didn't want her parents to find out
She knew the difference between right and wrong that’s why she will be convicted. Unfortunately they still prosecute even if the family on the victim’s side is against the prosecution 🤷🏽♀️.
... but she wasn't insane when she committed the act and that's what matters. She knew what she did was wrong, then tried to cover it up. This is a waste of tax payer money. "Betrayed by the court system" my ass...