It's always possible that Andrew attempted to lower his tone of voice or reduce any aggressive demeanor, once he saw or heard his daughter coming... if he thought that this disturbance was inadvertently inconveniencing her as well. Not to mention the father and daughter still needing to coexist with one another once Penelope is separated.
This is disgusting… an actual innocent woman! She had an argument with her husband… he falls to the floor and dies?!? She didn’t know that was gonna happen! WTF?
So if the husband had pushed and slapped his wife and she died of a heart attack would that change people's thoughts as many here think she shouldn't be in court.
No it wouldn’t change my mind. If two kids were fighting in the play ground, one pushes and slaps the other, and the other suffers, let’s say, a fatal asthma attack, I would certainly not charge the one who pushed,slapped and even if he had spit on him
What a shame.. The father collapsed while arguing with mom, now shes being charged with manslaughter??? This is unbelievable. What a disgrace of Massachusetts. Why didn't the daughter give cpr???; she's 18. Then the mom gave him CPR and this is her fault??? Ridiculous. 😢 free this lady!!
Ole Massachusetts where they give children to habitual criminals like Adam Montgomery that carry’s his own child crammed into a bag where he broke her bones to make her fit and throwed some Lyme on her is being allowed to appeal his conviction. All while the female who knew the baby was in a bag above her bunk with body fluids seeping through the tiles had sex and got pregnant again by the monster walked free!!
Daughter was 17. Her anxiety was thru the roof. The mother was trespassing. She was told to leave several times. She attacked the victim. Female or not, she is the aggressor. Never have children and never serve on a jury.
Who ever advised this woman to have a bench trial should be fired immediately, maybe even disbarred, especially knowing that Aunt Bev was the judge. What in the hell?????
This girl does not like her mother and I don’t believe it’s because of this. Cross examination may bring that out. This is a crazy trial. And, do I trust this judge? Hell no!
The whole justice system in this Commonwealth has to be overhauled, from police officers to DAs, and to the judge, some judges by county Bev, who in my opinion are not only inept in doing their jobs, but are biased to the degree that they will do anything to find somebody guilty!
This does seem ridiculous. People get into arguments all the time, even with sick people. I think the daughter is very angry about the loss of her beloved dad. I hope this woman is found not guilty and the family finds peace at some point.
I am a man, if I had a HEART CONDITION I would not continue to engage with my wife and would NOT be arguing period. I would leave the room and walk away. If my wife was not living in the home I would ask her to leave. If she continued all I have to do is call 911 and have the police remove her from the home. The FACT that this man CONTINUED to FIGHT and participate in the argument tells me he made that decision himself. He DIED becuase of a heart attack that HE ALONE could have prevented VERY EASY! It doesnt matter if somone is aware of your health condition as its the SOLE RESPONSABILITY of the person with that condition to take care of themselves. While I agree the wife was involved in the argument and contributed to the stress its was the MAN, the Father, the Husband, THAT CHOOSE to participate and CHOSE to engage even though he was fully aware that he had a heart condition and that tress was NOT healthy for his condition. Only the person with the condition can gauge how much stress they can take. This case SHOUDL NEVER be in court. The MA DA and the judge are BOTH CORRUPT and should be disbarred for wasting tax payer money on this case.
Mom went to her ex’s house after she received an email from his brother evicting her. Her ex kept telling her to leave. Daughter saw mom slapping, pushing & shoving dad…he experienced a stroke a few months prior to this! So the mom KNEW he had heart issues.
They should then charge little miss with the stress she put on her father by fighting with her own mother when her mother had to take care of her father.
Wait this woman had an argument with her husband that may or may not have caused him to go into cardiac arrest and she faces manslaughter? Please tell me i have this wrong. I swear only in MA would they charge a woman for arguing with her husband and claim the argument took his life. Unless I am missing crucial evidence not yet testified to then this is insane.
@@lisas8244Still doesnt mean she caused heart attack. I received a heart transplant and had advanced heart failure, implanted defibrillator, etc. When my heart stopped there was never any connection to physical stress, etc. People can die from heart attacks in their sleep and people like me with lethal heart arrhythmias often have them in sleep more than during exercise. No science behind this cause-effect argument in this case.
@@jenniferamyx78 Ok, so your opinion is it is just a random coincidence that at the exact time she's pushing on his chest he drops dead of a heart attack? Good to know.
This poor daughter! 💔 She calls her mother by her first name and wasn’t living with her at the time of this incident. Very telling. 😢 12:31 OMG, if someone fell, I would immediately render aid and whatever the issue was would be irrelevant. Sad to read all of the harsh comments about their daughter. She was a CHILD!!! Her reaction was appropriate based on the circumstance. Stop being so quick to judge and demonstrate some compassion. The world would be a safer place if more of us would lead with grace. 🙏✨
Something bad has been happening in this family ,the husbands brother told her she had to leave the house she was living in as the husband had told him too, she goes round Maybee arguing against this , the daughter is calling the mum by her first name in the trial , is this a case of parental alienation by the father and that’s why the daughter is so against her mother or Maybee she wasn’t a good mother to them after and or before separation , something very wrong with this family
The daughter was 18 why didnt she giver her dad cpr. She complained her mom wouldnt, at first so why didnt she do it. So she must be as guilty as her mom.
What??? How has this natural death become manslaughter by reason of medical negligence by a non-medical person ??? Apologies if i missed the intention is this trial
@@Lez_awakeBev is not a fair and ethical judge at all. I also believe she will rule against any defendant better looking than her OR if it involves protecting her police friends !!! Both conditions apply to the Karen Read case!!!! This lady doesn’t stand a chance with Bev in control 😤
how on earth do you know the daughter was lying? Where do you get off speculating on an issue that is so hard for these people and that you're so far removed from??
If that were my dad and I witnessed my mom yelling, pushing, shoving and SMACKING my dad?! 😡😡 No way would I EVER forgive my mom for that!! What kind of immature woman does that in front of her kids anyway?!!! She precipitated this event. Had she not gone over there, he might not have had the heart attack.
Very fact that you said in your comment that he may not have had a heart attack had she gone not gone over, proves there is reasonable doubt, and it shouldn’t be a trial!
I really don't like this case at all. We are supposed to believe a daughter who before hand did not get along with her mother in so much that she was not allowed to be in her presence. Seems very toxic from the get go. I think it's tragic but it was just as much he's fault as hers. Overcharged
Or Maybee she was a crap mother and didn’t bother with the children or Maybee the dad turned her against her mother ( parental alienation) 🤷🏼♀️ who knows what’s gone on here in this family , something has that’s for sure.
Ridiculous trial again. You should have gone with a jury. This judge should not be a judge Your dad had a heart condition. Get over yourself little girl
The worst thing you can do when someone is injured or in a 911 medical emergency is to scream or shout.I have seen people at shootings and car accudents standing over a victim SCREAMING...as they die.
There is a difference in sentences in cases of just a regular fight when the victim is an elderly vs a young person So by the same token,pushing and slapping a healthy person is not the same as doing it to a person with heart condition.
EX wife comes into the house. Physically attacks her ex husband. He tells her to leave several times. She does not and continues to attack him. She is the aggressor. She is the abuser. The 17 year old daughter went into high anxiety mode. Glad she called the police. Ex wife not the victim. It's that simple.
I agree with Philip, saying that the state went too far with charging the wife. Instead of charging her for manslaughter, she should have gotten charged with something one level down, involving a domestic dispute resulting in death without consent to kill. Other charges, such as abuse and physical assault I can see her being charged for.
Does the father not have some culpability? He knows he has a cardiac issue and yet he let her in & participated in the screaming match. He could have not let her in, he could have walked away, he could have called police and had her removed. He definitely bears some responsibility; but we now live in a society where nothing is ever our own fault.
So you're blaming the victim who had health issues and just had a stroke? Would you say the same if it was a man coming in to argue with a sick woman or even an elderly woman? And that man pushed the woman and slapped her?
I'm no fan of Political figures but to charge this woman for her husbands death is overkill and unjust! She's not a physician and she did at some point administor CPR. I understand the daughters upset but to charge her for his death after he collapsed is going to far. Surely there's plenty of Defendants waiting in jail for their day in Court! Ontario, 🇨🇦 🐾
Come on dude, she knew of her Husbands condition and its pretty obvious that someone faling to the ground and your own daughter telling you what needs to be done under the circumstances, its a no brainer.
Why didn't she just leave and not get into it with him pushing and slapping him..there is some culpability here. To say it's ridiculous is messed up. This is DV at least. We have to have control and not use hands for God's' sakes.
#CourtTV What do YOU think?
Catch up on the case against Penelope McGee here: www.courttv.com/tag/penelope-mcgee/?
@CourtTV are you going to stream this live?
It's always possible that Andrew attempted to lower his tone of voice or reduce any aggressive demeanor, once he saw or heard his daughter coming... if he thought that this disturbance was inadvertently inconveniencing her as well. Not to mention the father and daughter still needing to coexist with one another once Penelope is separated.
I am an attorney, this is insane to charge this.
This is outrageous of the state of MA to ever bring these charges against this woman. When does it end. Norfolk County is shameful.
This is absolutely ridiculous!! How can she be charged with anything?! What a waste of money!!!!
She might not be of highest regard but she actually didn’t kill him
I agree. His weak ass heart killed him.
Or even attempt to!
I'm confused..they had a massive quarrel..he had a heart attack ...and she's guilty of this horrible consequence?..I'm surprised by this charge
she didnt do crap all to help however - her daughter's testimony is interesting
Crazy charge for a verbal argument. How is a shove manslaughter?
She was shoving him and would not leave...I do not think mom lived there...mom did not try to help him
She attacked him. Attacked. It's a crime.
How is this even a case ? How did this even make it thru court to this point? Wow
This is disgusting… an actual innocent woman! She had an argument with her husband… he falls to the floor and dies?!? She didn’t know that was gonna happen! WTF?
So if the husband had pushed and slapped his wife and she died of a heart attack would that change people's thoughts as many here think she shouldn't be in court.
Many die from heart attacks
behind the wheel when Driving ...
Does that mean the Car Manufacturer should be. SUED !?! 🤔 🤡
Not at all. If he weak heart couldn’t handle a push and a shove then she would’ve been a walking time bomb herself
No it wouldn’t change my mind. If two kids were fighting in the play ground, one pushes and slaps the other, and the other suffers, let’s say, a fatal asthma attack, I would certainly not charge the one who pushed,slapped and even if he had spit on him
Exactly. The comments on here are ridiculous, except yours.
If the car pushed you around and slapped you yes sue the car company
What a shame..
The father collapsed while arguing with mom, now shes being charged with manslaughter??? This is unbelievable.
What a disgrace of Massachusetts.
Why didn't the daughter give cpr???; she's 18.
Then the mom gave him CPR and this is her fault???
Ridiculous. 😢 free this lady!!
Ole Massachusetts where they give children to habitual criminals like Adam Montgomery that carry’s his own child crammed into a bag where he broke her bones to make her fit and throwed some Lyme on her is being allowed to appeal his conviction. All while the female who knew the baby was in a bag above her bunk with body fluids seeping through the tiles had sex and got pregnant again by the monster walked free!!
Daughter was 17. Her anxiety was thru the roof. The mother was trespassing. She was told to leave several times. She attacked the victim. Female or not, she is the aggressor. Never have children and never serve on a jury.
Who ever advised this woman to have a bench trial should be fired immediately, maybe even disbarred, especially knowing that Aunt Bev was the judge. What in the hell?????
That part!! I'm from Massachusetts lots and lots of corruption and racism.
This girl does not like her mother and I don’t believe it’s because of this. Cross examination may bring that out. This is a crazy trial. And, do I trust this judge? Hell no!
The whole justice system in this Commonwealth has to be overhauled, from police officers to DAs, and to the judge, some judges by county Bev, who in my opinion are not only inept in doing their jobs, but are biased to the degree that they will do anything to find somebody guilty!
Seems like she would be a hostile witness
True dat... WTH bench trial is crazy move....
I am a former prosecutor from California, this woman being charged is madness. I can't believe she was charged with this and it is gotten to a trial!
This does seem ridiculous. People get into arguments all the time, even with sick people. I think the daughter is very angry about the loss of her beloved dad. I hope this woman is found not guilty and the family finds peace at some point.
Doesn’t shock me they charged her. I can’t stand this judge or prosecutor!!!
You’re in good company because most people feel the same way
@@Lez_awakelol she’s a killer plain and simple
@@Beckster8811 corrupt as hell!!!
I am a man, if I had a HEART CONDITION I would not continue to engage with my wife and would NOT be arguing period. I would leave the room and walk away. If my wife was not living in the home I would ask her to leave. If she continued all I have to do is call 911 and have the police remove her from the home.
The FACT that this man CONTINUED to FIGHT and participate in the argument tells me he made that decision himself. He DIED becuase of a heart attack that HE ALONE could have prevented VERY EASY! It doesnt matter if somone is aware of your health condition as its the SOLE RESPONSABILITY of the person with that condition to take care of themselves.
While I agree the wife was involved in the argument and contributed to the stress its was the MAN, the Father, the Husband, THAT CHOOSE to participate and CHOSE to engage even though he was fully aware that he had a heart condition and that tress was NOT healthy for his condition. Only the person with the condition can gauge how much stress they can take.
This case SHOUDL NEVER be in court. The MA DA and the judge are BOTH CORRUPT and should be disbarred for wasting tax payer money on this case.
Mom went to her ex’s house after she received an email from his brother evicting her. Her ex kept telling her to leave. Daughter saw mom slapping, pushing & shoving dad…he experienced a stroke a few months prior to this! So the mom KNEW he had heart issues.
Not murder, did you ever argue with a family member or stranger? What if they had a heart attack? Did you kill them?
Yep
And?? So what!
@@margaretmary1139 exactly! Being guilty of physical assault is not the same as murder
@@Lez_awakeif it leads to death sounds like murder to me. Involuntary manslaughter possibly.
This is the most ridiculous trial I’ve ever seen. An argument cannot cause the death of somebody when will it end?
They should then charge little miss with the stress she put on her father by fighting with her own mother when her mother had to take care of her father.
Oh no, not Auntie Bev!!!! She is screwed. I’m so sick of these ridiculous cases and charges against innocent people 😡
I’m so sick of you clowns who think murder is ok
How would u possibly know if she’s guilty or not lady lol
@@averyshenandoah1637oh hush!!! You don't need to be rude! You don't like the comment? Then keep scrolling by them!
How is this even a criminal matter!? What a waste of taxpayers money!!
That judge is questionable.
Haven’t watched this yet but that’s an understatement.
@JusticeSeeker-u7s it sure is, the other trial exposed her.
She did assault him. I don’t think it’s entirely baseless to charge her.
So charge her for assault
Wait this woman had an argument with her husband that may or may not have caused him to go into cardiac arrest and she faces manslaughter? Please tell me i have this wrong. I swear only in MA would they charge a woman for arguing with her husband and claim the argument took his life. Unless I am missing crucial evidence not yet testified to then this is insane.
She knew he had heart problems and an pushed him
Oh puhleese!! It is murder to argue with someone who had stroke and heart issues! Grow up!!
@@kirstenwright1974so what??
It sounds like she physically assaulted her ex-husband during the argument.
@daniellealexander7392 He DIED while she was physically assaulting him. There IS a difference.
This is absolutely wrong, plain and simple. Because someone has medical conditions, you can not argue against them? 😜
Nobody better try me then lol im set 😂
@sunshinepatriot1846 She was not just arguing. She went batshit crazy and assaulted him. He died AS she was assaulting him.
@@lisas8244Still doesnt mean she caused heart attack. I received a heart transplant and had advanced heart failure, implanted defibrillator, etc. When my heart stopped there was never any connection to physical stress, etc. People can die from heart attacks in their sleep and people like me with lethal heart arrhythmias often have them in sleep more than during exercise. No science behind this cause-effect argument in this case.
Why didn’t the daughter do CPR? Wasn’t she on the phone with 911?
@@jenniferamyx78 Ok, so your opinion is it is just a random coincidence that at the exact time she's pushing on his chest he drops dead of a heart attack? Good to know.
This poor daughter! 💔 She calls her mother by her first name and wasn’t living with her at the time of this incident. Very telling. 😢 12:31 OMG, if someone fell, I would immediately render aid and whatever the issue was would be irrelevant. Sad to read all of the harsh comments about their daughter. She was a CHILD!!! Her reaction was appropriate based on the circumstance. Stop being so quick to judge and demonstrate some compassion. The world would be a safer place if more of us would lead with grace. 🙏✨
She’s 18
The 911 call sounded like two tea kettles called 911.
With Autie Bev at the helm its anyones guess😮
This young woman in time will regret her perception, emotional trauma can trigger false memories
the daughter is a brat!
Something is definitely “off” with that girl …lMO
the “daughter” lost her father at the age of 17 and has to recall and go thru this horrific experience and repeat it. get a life.
@pokeyb2229 really, what a stupid comment! She was a young girl who see her father collapse, what makes her brat?
I must be missing something. I don't understand why charges were brought here.
It’s the same county as the Karen Read case, if that tells you anything
@@Lez_awakethat tells me EVERYTHING!!! Lady YOU ARE COOKED with Bev in charge… UNLESS that political family has some pull over Bev
The sound in Beverly’s courtroom is AWFUL! 😢
This judge I trust as much as a kid in a sweet store.
Massachusetts AGAIN! ANOTHER ridiculous charge.
It’s amazing how different she treats this defense her Bias shines thru in katennread trial 😮
Leaving it up to Aunt Bev???? That’s risky.
Didn’t understand a damn thing, not one damn thing on that 911 call…..
Is this a real trial? I mean, honestly does one or can one prove that another caused a cardiac event leading to manslaughter? I don’t think so.
lol
I don't find the daughter believable sadly
Something bad has been happening in this family ,the husbands brother told her she had to leave the house she was living in as the husband had told him too, she goes round Maybee arguing against this , the daughter is calling the mum by her first name in the trial , is this a case of parental alienation by the father and that’s why the daughter is so against her mother or Maybee she wasn’t a good mother to them after and or before separation , something very wrong with this family
Where is Common sense, folks?? And of course auntie Bev is involved.
The daughter was 18 why didnt she giver her dad cpr. She complained her mom wouldnt, at first so why didnt she do it. So she must be as guilty as her mom.
Yip and her hysterical yelling wouldn't have calmed his heart.
What???
How has this natural death become manslaughter by reason of medical negligence by a non-medical person ??? Apologies if i missed the intention is this trial
She will be acquitted.
Idk , this judge is horrible
@@Lez_awakeBev is not a fair and ethical judge at all. I also believe she will rule against any defendant better looking than her OR if it involves protecting her police friends !!! Both conditions apply to the Karen Read case!!!! This lady doesn’t stand a chance with Bev in control 😤
@ you called it, anyone she is jealous of or can’t slip her a favor
Bev still employed. Startling
Why is she calling her mom ‘Penelope’ ? Is it the Father's second wife? Or are they calling her that out of spite & protest..? I am confused..
Show the whole trial and not just clips!
HOW IS THIS THE MOTHER FAULT . THE DAUGHTER PUSHED THE ISSUE AND MADE UP LIES. WHY DIDN'T YOU HELP YOUR DAD THEN?
I wondered why she didn't perform CPR. Her hysterics heard on the 911 call would have inflamed the situation.
how on earth do you know the daughter was lying? Where do you get off speculating on an issue that is so hard for these people and that you're so far removed from??
If that were my dad and I witnessed my mom yelling, pushing, shoving and SMACKING my dad?! 😡😡 No way would I EVER forgive my mom for that!! What kind of immature woman does that in front of her kids anyway?!!! She precipitated this event. Had she not gone over there, he might not have had the heart attack.
Very fact that you said in your comment that he may not have had a heart attack had she gone not gone over, proves there is reasonable doubt, and it shouldn’t be a trial!
Well well well Aunti Bev… you won’t see any rulings going the way of defense- she’s the most corrupt judge I’ve seen in a while.
I couldn't understand a word anyone was saying on that 911 call. 😢. Sounded like they were in a dog shelter place.
I really don't like this case at all. We are supposed to believe a daughter who before hand did not get along with her mother in so much that she was not allowed to be in her presence. Seems very toxic from the get go. I think it's tragic but it was just as much he's fault as hers. Overcharged
Another case showing the Commonwealth players at their finest! Auntie Bev, and the prosecutor, what a surprise😂
Does this county not have any real crimes?
Why would you stop the video there it doesn’t make any sense
Therefore, even if someone collapses in public, you could blame all the people standing around for the death...
The daughter's hysterics on the 911 call were more likely to set off a heart attack than the mother's actions.
Understand this court she should be charged as an accessory
Hate hate auntie Bev….
The question is would he still be alive today if she hadn’t assaulted him?
I think this is more of a civil matter than criminal
Daughter has some history with her mother. Calling her by her real name Penelope and not mum shows her distance from her
Maybe she doesn’t because she’s abusive or just maybe she holds her responsible for her fathers death
Or Maybee she was a crap mother and didn’t bother with the children or Maybee the dad turned her against her mother ( parental alienation) 🤷🏼♀️ who knows what’s gone on here in this family , something has that’s for sure.
She calls her mom Penelope. Pretty bias little girl
Ooohf momma has very angry eyes!
Freaky.
Would t you, I mean look at the accusations
Oh my gosh turn that noise off
I can't listen to this. Someone is screaming. AAArrgghh
This is insane
Ridiculous trial again. You should have gone with a jury. This judge should not be a judge Your dad had a heart condition. Get over yourself little girl
What?! Seriously?! 😮
The worst thing you can do when someone is injured or in a 911 medical emergency is to scream or shout.I have seen people at shootings and car accudents standing over a victim SCREAMING...as they die.
There is a difference in sentences in cases of just a regular fight when the victim is an elderly vs a young person So by the same token,pushing and slapping a healthy person is not the same as doing it to a person with heart condition.
She assaulted him. She sounds erratic and unhinged. Let the Judge decide.
What day of the trial was the daughter on the witness stand?
Thank You Ted.
Daughter has an oddly low/ short forehead...hmmm
Ridiculous trial again. You should have gone with a jury. This judge should not be a judge
Unbelievable! With all the real murders and horrific criminals in our country This is what courts are actually spending time on?
EX wife comes into the house. Physically attacks her ex husband. He tells her to leave several times. She does not and continues to attack him. She is the aggressor. She is the abuser. The 17 year old daughter went into high anxiety mode. Glad she called the police. Ex wife not the victim. It's that simple.
I agree with Philip, saying that the state went too far with charging the wife. Instead of charging her for manslaughter, she should have gotten charged with something one level down, involving a domestic dispute resulting in death without consent to kill. Other charges, such as abuse and physical assault I can see her being charged for.
Defense attorney Philip Dube always sides with the defense in every case 🤯
They didn’t even have the for-site to put tissues on the stand
I'm sorry i don't believe this woman should be charged.Maybe i missed something?
Well we already know how this is going to turn out. We know Bev.
Where is the cross testimony of this witness????? Anyone know where to find the full trial vs clips?
What did the autopsy show
WTF is going on in Massachusetts?!?! Seriously!
O. M. G. !!! Aunt Bev!
Massachusetts is a weird state
She did slap him. Throw her in prison!!
The look mom is giving her daughter is scary. I get a bad feeling about her.
Insanity. This entire thing.
Does the father not have some culpability? He knows he has a cardiac issue and yet he let her in & participated in the screaming match. He could have not let her in, he could have walked away, he could have called police and had her removed. He definitely bears some responsibility; but we now live in a society where nothing is ever our own fault.
So you're blaming the victim who had health issues and just had a stroke? Would you say the same if it was a man coming in to argue with a sick woman or even an elderly woman? And that man pushed the woman and slapped her?
This is absurd.
Heartbreaking
Depends on the elements of the charge if it's valid or not. Just depends on the state law codes.
I'm no fan of Political figures but to charge this woman for her husbands death is overkill and unjust! She's not a physician and she did at some point administor CPR. I understand the daughters upset but to charge her for his death after he collapsed is going to far. Surely there's plenty of Defendants waiting in jail for their day in Court! Ontario, 🇨🇦 🐾
Come on dude, she knew of her Husbands condition and its pretty obvious that someone faling to the ground and your own daughter telling you what needs to be done under the circumstances, its a no brainer.
Hmmm. Same district that charged Karen Reed. Same judge. Nonsense.
Why didn't she just leave and not get into it with him pushing and slapping him..there is some culpability here. To say it's ridiculous is messed up. This is DV at least. We have to have control and not use hands for God's' sakes.
Suzie? No, Zuzzie.
Ridiculous . RIP 🙏
Zuzzie? oy vey.