History of the Armenian Language
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 เม.ย. 2021
- History of the Armenian Language, Hayasa-Azzi, Proto-Armenian, Armenian, Ancient Armenian, Medieval Armenian, Modern Armenian
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Support the channel with an ebook purchase or a donation. Thank you for your support. You help make the channel better
www.amazon.com/dp/B07QSC7BD1
www.amazon.com/dp/B07WS28WV7
www.paypal.com/paypalme/costa...
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Music:
Waking to Reality - Unicorn Heads
Elegy - Wayne Jones
Never ask a woman her age,
Never ask a man his salary,
Never ask the Turks where the Armenians went.
armenians migrated to east, the turks didn't do anything with them
never ask a brit about the indian famine
never ask a russian about holodomor
never ask a american about the stealing of native americans
never ask a belgian about the kongolese genocide
here u go western hypocrite
@@Engifarting456 never ask the France about what they did in Algeria
@@Engifarting456 it doesn't justify anything.
And saying turks didn't do anything to us, means that we don't know the story of our families..... and brothers and sisters of our great grandparents didn't die (they just disappeared or what? )...
So stop denying the facts...
The truth is one whether you like it or not.
@@AnginTsaturyan truth is nobody done anything to your grandfather. Because if he never existed, you wouldn't exist.
So stop trying to flame every Turkish for something 110 years ago.
Just blame the government
my heart sank at the end. but the souls of those martyrs will be reunited in heaven.
And Americans will say:
This was a real choice of arminians and we must accept their choice. This message was about: Cuba, Samoa(1898), Phillipeans(1899), Nikaragua(1912), Haiti(1915), Dominic Republic(1916), Russia (1918), Korea(1950), Guatemala(1954), Livan(1958), Laos1959), Vietnam(1964), Kambodia(1967), Salvador(1977), Iran(1980), Livan(1982), Grenada(1983), Libya(1986), Panama(1989), Somali(1992), Bosnia(1992)m Haiti(1994), Ugoslavia(1999), Afganistan(2001), Lyberia/Iraq(2003), Libya(2011), Syria(2014), Ukraine(2014), Jemen, Camerun,Libya(2015)
Where live come better? Yes! In USA.
Genocide of Armenians was not accepted by the world. United Nations say: mmmmm....this is usual situation... war... Not more
yeah it's sad, and turkey still denies it...
And God's revenge will come
I am proud to be half armenian!
@@muhan6831 so why didn’t they do the same thing to Georgians and why did they do the same to Alevists
@@muhan6831 the alavis???
@@muhan6831 and that not f in’ true Georgia had hold the line in 1918
The shift to melancholic music accurately represents how Armenians started truly struggling and forced to endure Turks after they arrived. Thank you
@@muhan6831 bot.
@@muhan6831 you're the one spamming the same exact message everywhere
Love and support to my Armenian brothers from Romania 🇷🇴🇦🇲
Artsakh is yours 💪
well you dont support armenia tho as i see so you lied with this comment
Karabakh is Azerbaijan!...
@@adnan_honest_jihadist5775 what
Why stop at Artsakh? Swallow the entire Anatolia, including Constantinople.
Better to be a gypsy than a Turk.
Greatly done, as always.
Thank you
Stay strong, Armenian people!
The scars of the Armenian genocide can still be seen but i hope you'll be able to reclaim your glory as bastion of European Civilisation in a hostile environment!
wasnt the bastion of european civilization greece
@@Engifarting456 armenian history was closely tied to greek history until a certain point i'd say
Armenians are as European as Arabs. Simply none.
@@sepulturaoftheforest2869 it being an indo european christian culture begs to differ
@@sepulturaoftheforest2869 Armenia speaks an Indo-European language and is a very old christian nation. Pretty european to me.
That genocide hurts...
what genocide
@@joacoolcipher eat your durgs
@@joacoolcipher ok T*rk
@@user-pz8op2bf8w proof i have drugs
@@decantabriaball938 ok Jew
6:06 if you’re wondering why this happened, in 1915 the Ottoman government organized a multi ethnic genocide of Armenians, Greeks and Assyrians which to this day hasn’t been recognized by the Republic of Turkey
And?
PROOF?
@@turkishmapping2587, Turkish propaganda isn't that great to foolish the whole world.
@@kebabseverim3364?
kurds parcipitate but they got away with it because of women soldiers
The sudden and dramatic disappearing of the language in 1916-17 from large regions, all at once (because of the genocide, of course), is something never seen in other cases, by those who are accustomed to Costas Melas's maps, and it is really impressive! Chilling!
Previously, only Westerners wrote history books. Fortunately, we now know that these are not true. This was just the West misleading the whole world with their perception. How can so many people disappear in a few years? So the Turks must have slaughtered all the Armenians. However, the reality is not like that. Those who first lived there as Armenians did not disappear and continued their lives as citizens of the Republic of Turkey. Because there is no racial discrimination in the Republic of Turkey. Everyone is a Turkish citizen and there is no discrimination against anyone. However, the narrator has presented such a narrative to make you believe that "the Turks destroyed the Armenians en masse". Westerners do this all the time. I suggest you look at it from other perspectives to avoid falling into Western perception games.
Hello, greetings from Colombia, your videos are great and informative 🙂
Thank you very much
Reuploaded based on Hayasa-Azzi hypothesis which seems more likely than the Phrygo-Armenian case of the older video.
Cool video 👍
@@Joaco3406 Thank you
Why you don't include armenian into your video about iranian languages?
Armenian language has so much similarities with İranian languages!..
@@ratcastle0679 Surely the armenian language had many and heavy influences from the iranian languages due to their proximity and numerous interactions, but many scholars classify this language as closer to greek and maybe phrigian as well, even if there are still more things to research figure out about it
I was thinking about that video when this video popped up. I was wondering why you created another video but shows Armenian only when you already have that video.
Turistas en Turquía: ¿Cómo se formó este hermoso país?
Turcos: Si bueno, ¿Quién tiene hambre?
Μπράβο Κώστα πολύ ωραίο βίντεο δεν ήξερα ότι οι Αρμένιοι υπήρχαν τόσο πίσω στο χρόνο
Ευχαριστώ πολύ
black people language
@@joacoolcipher that’s Greek...
@@retrosrobloxreviews9564 exactly
@@trantorcapitalofthegalacti3173 they are ancestors of swahilis dumb
Excellent work as always! And may you make history of Sino-Tibetan please? Or if too difficult, Sinitic first?
Thank you
-5000 social credit
Done. Its interesting how the sino-tibetan ppl diversify. I never knew more ppl groups would come out of that family tree
After reading your answers to comments, you seem to research a lot to gain info for þe videos. Anyone else want a special video, where we can see how much effort you put into þis?
how we miss thorn
Thank you
Nice thorn
rojava is terrorism
communist
Noice !
please, can you make a video on Occitan languages, and Catalan why not.
He already made a video about romance languages
@@zro0480 yes i know
I can't explain my feelings(((😢
Im Azeri ,but I love Armenians and want them get back they’re historic land!
Im so sad that my country(🇦🇿)is only 104 years old and so artificial!
I will support all Armenians against my corrupt and falsification country!
🇦🇲💖
#QarabağErnənidem
@@heyellada-ball3929 I hope you can be free from the tyrant Aliyev soon!
@@heyellada-ball3929 such a stupid trolling.
@@heyellada-ball3929Haven't seen a more troll and loser guy than you
I think Armenian roots started near Lake van. Other than that awesome video. 👍
It's amazing how far Armenians used to populated both east and west until the late 20th century. And how it all got reduced to a small country and the diaspora, which out numbers it.
Unfurtunately, As far as Azerbaijan text books are concerned none of this would be true, just as every other damage Turks and Azeribaijanies incurred on Armenians before, during, and after the genocide.
But, Armenians aren't going anywhere. United, they will survive. 🇦🇲
As a Turkish person, I am sorry for your losses. I hope our peoples finds peace.
@@gomicgamer1245 🙏
Could you put timestamps for key dates in your videos?
For example, here you could put Urartu's fall, Manazkert, the Crusades, etc.
god save Armenia and its beautiful people
Nice video!, can you also make a history of the Finnish language?
Thank you. I have made a video about the Uralic Languages
@Antonio Ferrara Hungarian IS a uralic language
@Antonio Ferrara It's Uralic
@@CostasMelas I mean specifically only Finnish and not all uralic languages, if its not a big hassle for you :)
@@jesperperttunen6269 that’s not how things work on this channel
Interesting video bro
Thank you
Nice one!
6:07 Goooodbyyeeeeee 😭
😢
😂😂😂😂👍
🤢🤢🤢🤢🤢🤢🤢🤢🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️
@@ratcastle0679 😡
@@AlexIsoyan😂😂😂
🇹🇷👉👌🇦🇲👌👈🇦🇿
Next you should do Albanian and it’s likely ancestor Illyrian
Or may be all paleo Balkan languages like Thracian, Dacian, Illyrian and of course Albanian. Love u Brother.
He made it and it has like 21k views but over 3.5k comments lmfaoooo
@@bletrick3352 Yes,the truth hurts so much😂
Эээ... Скорее наоборот)
Μπραβο για το βίντεο, επίσης είσαι τυχερός που έχεις το όνομα του θρυλικού Παύλου Μελά, συνέχισε έτσι
Ευχαριστώ πολύ
black people language
Ok , gonna watch again . Thanks !
The Armenian (Hayotz lezu)language is a synthesis of the PIE language and Hurri language.By the way the Hurrit language is a sister language to the PIE and the word Hurri in Armenian means -with the quality of fire,firy man.These two nations were almost the same,from the same race and cradle.
You could show Eastern Armenian language and Western Armenian language separatly because they differed/differ considerably. And many Armenians lived/live in Crimea and Eastern coast of Black Sea.
You re right. I could have shown the presence in Abkhazia and Krasnodar
@@CostasMelas There are Armenian presence in Blacksea region of Turkey nowadays too. Homshetsi people.
Do Armenians still live in Abkhazia? (Georgians have been erased from there by Abkhazians).
@@maciejkulczycki3882 yes, because the are enemies of Georgians and servants of Russkies.
thank you !
This needs to be updated.
Indeed, more Armenians were massacrated .
I think that one day the Turks will face the evil of their deeds@@arcaniteplays-blackdeath-5218
Good video! Idea: History of English
Artksah Is Armenia 🇨🇱♥️🇦🇲
Excellent job. I like your videos; keep doing it! However, you can add the line in Istanbul because still today, the Armenian language is spoken in Istanbul they are Armenian schools.
6:07 and it matches the history book pictures, and *sigh* it's 1916 A.D *sigh* the real pain starts now
Hmm, you think so The Master of Genociders, ok.
@@joseph4226 and Germany has admitted to the Holocaust, and had apogized for it, and yet Turkey still denies it
@@decantabriaball938 because there is not
@@omerturunc4594 that's bull my guy
Armenians still live in Anatolia today. Rize, Artvin, Kars, Ardahan, Bursa, Istanbul, Adana, Izmir etc...There is no genocide.The reason for the decrease in the population of Armenians in the east today is the settlement of Muslims who came from the Balkans and the Crimea with the migration of Christian Armenians to Russia after the Russian-Turkish War.
In Basra south of Iraq we have some armenian speakers who escaped from genocide
@@user-ge2st5rt3p حسنًا ، كانت سوريا آرامية وسريانية قبل الإسلام ومعظم السوريين مختلطون وراثيًا. إذا كان السوريون عربًا وراثيًا بنسبة 100٪ ، فلماذا يبدو معظم السوريين مختلفين عن اليمنيين والخليجيين؟ معظم السوريين هم من مواليد سوريا وراثيًا ، لكنهم قاموا للتو بتغيير الهوية والدين بعد أن احتل العرب بلدهم.
@@johnmalik2631 خطا السريان مذهب مسيحي مثل السنة والشيعة اول دولة تكلمت السريانية كانت دولة عربية اسمها مملكة الرها وكل النقوش كانت تذكر العرب ك سكان المملكة والملك كان يسمي نفسه ملك العرب ( سلطان العرب ) وكل الدول الي تكلمت بالارامية لم يطلقو على انفسهم اراميين والملوك اطلقوا على انفسهم ملوك العرب ( الحضر تدمر الانباط ميسان ) عطني اسم سرياني للملوك كل الأسماء عربية هل فيه سرياني اسمه منصور او خلف او معن او بكر ؟ السريانية مذهب ديني تحول لقومية واول من اعتنق المسيحية السريانية هم العرب اما الارامية مصطلح لغني اطلقه علماء اللغويات الغربيين وكل دولة وشعب تكلمو ارامي لم يعبرون عن هويتهم بالارامية بل قالو انهم عرب وملوكهم اطلقو على انفسهم ملوك العرب … السريان هوية دينية للعرب بعد ظهور المسيحية والارامية هوية عربية وثنية للوثنيين العرب
@@johnmalik2631 يا عزيزي الشام و العراق و شمال افريقيا امم مستعربة
Thanks, but our history starts around 2500 bc with the tribal kingdom of Teg-Arme from which came the sacred name of our nation Torgomyan Tun, sich translates as the hom of the sons of Torgom. The kindom stads around the region of Commagene and Armenia minor.
Artksah is Armenia.🇧🇬❤️🇦🇲
Also Eastern Anatolia
So take than . As if you do
Make a new video about the history of the scythians
Armenian is still spoken in North-East Turkey as a majority first language in some villages especially near Hopa.
hopa is pure laz/colchian
@@davexorus9836 Go away. We don't need racists here.
@@i.k.8868 I am not rascist i dont hate nor armenians nor others. You are just claiming what isnt yours and I dont like it.
@@davexorus9836 It was Armenian until you murdered all of them
@@davexorus9836 It's like to murder or expell all the inhabitants of Istanbul, resettle it with Greeks, rename it to the Constantinopole and rebuild the mosques to churches and then claim that It's not Turkish at all.
It's very interesting the fact that after the seljuk invasions, armenian was more spread in eastern anatolia.
yes, it seems they were driven out of their lands in central Anatolia, and moved to Cilicia in the south, and eastern Anatolia
Armenians were compatible and loyal to Turkic empires in Anatolia. if they were stay loyal to Ottoman Empire and did not rebel with Russia’s provacations they were still living in Anatolia as Kurdish people in Modern Turkey. Still 100.000 Armenians living in İstanbul which is not a low number. Anatolian Greek population is 1.500 in İstanbul.
@@magnuslh84 no
@@mukan9 αντε χασου ρε
@@magnuslh84 Actually it was a treaty concluded by Basil II. I can't recall the name right now, but some governor or Vaspurkan, an Armenain principality, was granted land in Cappadocia in exchange for leaving Vaspurkan to the (eastern) Romans, which he did, together with a good portion of Armenian settlers. Later this became the kingdom of little Armenia in Cilicia, which is reflected here.
"Oh look! The armenians are doing great! I feel like nothing could stop them now... wait, turks, what are you doing? Wait, wait, wait turks noooo"
Wait, what do you mean, everyone know that "tHe aRmEnIaN GenOcIdE nEvEr hApPeNed!" 🙈🙉🙊
genocide is lie . but you cant understand
@@tigin11 oh no, I understand well. History isn't hard to grasp, as no credible historian or archeologist would ever deny the Armenian Genocide. However, when authoritarian regimes falsify history for their own gain and ambitions, it blinds and dumbs down their people as a result, and we end up getting responses like yours with no substance to them. I can't blame you. I hope one day you reclaim your true history and topple your tyrannical regimes. ✌
@@tigin11 Yeah like we would believe Turkish nationalists and Pan-Turks who claim everything from Scythian and Parthians to Sumerians and Hungarians as "TURKS".
such wit
There’s still Armenians living in Salmas and Urmia regions of Iran
How many armenians live there? There used to be plenty of armenian in the Khoy-Salmast-Urmia regions who spoke their own dialects. Now only the region of Arasbaran retains its historical armenian inhabitants.
One of the old nation in the world
Victim of ottoman empire
Nice
Many armenians migrated to Poland-Lithuania too
Next video When???
bruh this video was released 15 minutes ago and you're asking when is the next video?
@@ganjubas667 but it is not really new, just a fixed video
@@diegoragot655 The next will be possibly about Caucasus or Anatolians
Artksah is Armenia.🇨🇿❤️🇦🇲
@Ռուդոլֆ Մելքոնյան Do you speak Czech?
Pridaj k tomu ešte 2x väčšie územia o ktoré ich Turci odrbali a kde ich vyvraždili ;)
@@jiri7778 bohemia is germany
@@matusmotlo3854 Přesně tak, celý severovýchod dnešního Hitlerdoganovo islamofašistického sultanátu.
@@leviathan4846 Istanbul is Konstantinopol, Konstantinopol is Greece. Izmyr is Smyrna. Smyrna is Greece. 🇨🇿❤️🇦🇲🇬🇷🇨🇾⛪✝️🔪🇹🇷🇦🇿
You should've put a small tick on Istanbul. It still has a sizable Armenian community. In Central and Northern Anatolia as well as a few regions like Malatya, faint stripes should've been seen up to the 60's or thereabouts as the survivors still remained for a while until they either migrated to Istanbul or left the country. In a few southeastern regions, descendants of survivors have resurfaced and there are a couple church attenders.
God bless the Armenians.
There's a large ethnic armenian enclave in Beirut lebanon.
100 000 peoples
Спасибо автору.
great video, efxaristo para poli
we did, we do, and will surive, no matter what you , bishes, come up with (you know who you are)
This comment section will be spicy
XD
6:06 😭😭
aahahah
6:06 Ahahahaha😂
@@volkanaydemir1440 Comments like yours are why people hate turkey.
why are you crying
im not Armenian but im sorry for what happened to your people turks always prove that they are fascist
Have a nice day 👋
I think you should include the west coast of Asia minor like the city of Smyrna. Till its catastrophe by young turks, 40-60.000 armenians lived there.
6:06 To 6:08 hits hard
Tocharian when?
I should return to central Asia soon
@@CostasMelas
What about another caucasian launguages?
İ mean Kartvelian, Nakho-Dagestani and Circasian launguage families...
Sorry for my terryble english...
@@CostasMelas The Turks should too lmao
@@matusmotlo3854 Turks don't even belong in central asia. It's a common misconception that turks originated from central asia. Actually, they came from northeast siberia, and Central Asia was a pure Indo-European homeland of the Aryan Scythians before the turks came and invaded
4:21 Map of distribution of Armenian language look like Shark :)))
Forgot the Abkhaz Armenians
What happened to the Armenians in Abkhazia and southern Russia???
People from some part of Northeast Blacksea coast of Turker speaks Hemshin. Hemshin is a pretty much closer language Armenian
Hemshin is a armenian dialect not a seperat language
@@varg3952 it already seperate languages west east and khoy dialect armenian are dialects
i can still understand an hamshin but as much as an spaniard can understand a portuguese
@@nicoleiadammegherdichans1474 its an old armenian dialect its normal that you dont understand maybe
@@varg3952 it probably comes from old armenian but it definitely not a diealect of it probably a descent of a dialect that was an dialect of church armenian
1915
Remember and demand!
Preach
Circassia genocide and Siberia genocide happened. Free Circassia free dagestan free yakutia free Chechenistan Free Tuva Free Chukchis Free Kazan Tataria Free Crimea Free Udmurtia Free Chuvashia Free Nenetia Free Evenkia Free Ural! All Asian lands of Russia should be given back to it's natives!! Russia is a terrorist invader country. Russia proper is only Moscow and St. Petersburg. Every other land is stolen!!!
Неужели Турция никогда не ответит за свои злодеяния ?
I thought the Armenian language migrated into the Caucasus from the Balkans (like the Phrygians, who the Armenians were related to?)
It based on a mention of Herodotus and the identification of Mushki with the Armenians but remains a weak theory
Les armeniens sont venus de Balkans a Kavkase du sud
time for a nice, civil comments section!
6:07 Bruh Moment
that moment when nothing happened
The armenian genocide
@@armenbabikian94 the armenian what? never heard of it probably didnt happen
@@irgendwer3610 ok, search and you will see what actually happened
@@armenbabikian94 I hate to explain a joke, but I am making fun of the turkish government denial
As a Turkish, I can say, Armenians are still here. They are in our veins, in our heritage, in our memory. Languages changes but blood never.
Also remember: Armenia once Urartu land that native to Anatolia. Languages changes and no one can blame the superior.
Urartu is Armenia. Urartu literally translates to Armenia in Old Persian "In the 6th century BC, with the emergence of Armenia in the region, the Urartu and Urartians were synonymously referred to as Armenia and Armenians, in two of the three languages used in the Behistun inscription". We know for a fact that Armenians had been in Armenian Highlands for at least 7811 years from carbon dating of Neolithic burials who's maternal DNA was identical to modern Armenians
@@armennazarian7097 Everybody knows Urartu is more ancient and native to Caucasus. Armenians came from north and they are indo-european. We don't need nationalistic lies. In genetics, absolutely Urartu still lives in Armenia but this not means Urartu were Armenians.
@@dizifilmvesaire Let me ask you this. What came before Urartu? Hayasa-Azzi confederation. That's were the prefix Hay comes from. Ask any Armenian what they are and they will say Yes hay em. The court language of Urartu was Hurro-Urartian but the common language of everybody living in the Highlands of the time was Proto-Armenian as demonstrated by this video. The fact of the matter is that we are Indigenous in every sense of the word. Turks and Azerbaijanis are incredibly inconsistent when they have their own tellings of where Armenians come from (Oh they came from India, Oh they came from Balkans, Oh they came from the Steppes, Oh they came from Iraq) literally every explanation in the book to deny the possibility of us being on Indigenous land. Classic settler-colonial tactic.
@@armennazarian7097 Do not make history with vocabulary. Old and useless method. Words can be learned by newcomers. Modern Chechen people are the inheriters of Urartu (by language of course).
@@armennazarian7097 Another issue: if you want to make history with old methods, you can say bulgarians are turkic also greeks too. Even some of the blind historians said Etruscans were Turkic because of the similar symbols. But this is not gonna true. Half of the modern Turkish city names came from Greek and most of our dna is greco-anatolian. But this not make the language of turkish is anatolian or something. I just try to explain this.
Very good video!
Thank you
@@CostasMelas thanks for replying :-)
it's fictional, he made that up
@@joacoolcipher you cry :)
@@blackphoenix3220 you
What happened ? İn first video you show frigian and armenian languages came from balkans. Now you show it in anatolia 🤔🤔
Studying the Caucasus more, Hayasa-Azzi seems more probable hypothesis than Phrygo-Armenian. I have left a relevant comment in the comment section
@@CostasMelas yeah I guess so
@@CostasMelas You’ve mentioned the Hayasa-Azzi theory a few times in the comments, but what exactly is that theory? Thanks. Excellent videos, btw. I’ve been binge watching watching all of the language ones.
I would like you to have put the changes of the new war in Karabach on 2020, but other than that, great!
The language remained armenian
Why did you delete the old video that included the armenian language? Was the theory wrong? I am very curious
See the previous comments
Please make roms and Doms lamguage
Three years ago I visited the Holy Land. I was quite surprised when I learned old Jerusalem has an Armenian Quarter.
nice
It also amazes me that the Armenians are the only group of people in the indo European family tree that never diversify.
Boom!!! But how did it get there? Through the caucuses or through the Balkans and then Anatolia? Positive feedback welcome.
nice i want to see my second native language japanese
I must ask where you got your information for the Bronze Age portion of the video, because it does not match what I know of the origins of Armenian. Armenian is closely related to Greek and the extinct language Phygian (spoken in western Anatolia in the late Bronze Age) and must have been directly adjacent to them in its early history, perhaps as far east as central Anatolia, but more likely in the southern Balkans, before crossing into Anatolia during the Bronze Age Collapse.
yes there are more scholar reasonable relationship between ancient armenian language and phrygian. but it also its a so speculative problematic. one of them from balkans and other one is from caucasus region/east anatolia.... i mean there is a some evidences yes but not so much and relative. but if i would think more closely... there are some interesting etymologic similarities between bronze age eastern anatolian region called ''azzi hayaja'' and armenians. as far as i know armenians called themselves as ''hay'' and there is an unique word ''hayaja'' i dont know may br this is too speculative too... need more reading research and of course objective perspective...but armenian historians are soo speculative and peculiar in some issues...
The Armenian prehistory is quite obscure but there are evidence for early Bronze Age indo-european settlement in upper Kura river, linguistic studies shows formation of Armenian with elements from Caucasian and Hittite loans at least 1300/1200 BC, much before the arrival of Phrygians, and the mysterious Azzi-Hayasa suits with the period and the area as long as linguistically with the endonym of Armenia.
There is a case of phrygoarmenian deriving from the steppes and passing through greece in central anatolia. Phrygian was spoken from usak to sivastia, from ankara to knoya.
The Greek-Phrygian-Armenian hypothesis is invalid, and has been so for some 50 years. It was originally derived from Herodotus and Strabo, which believed the Armenians were Thracian/Phrygian colonists of Urartu. None of those claims have been supported by any genetic evidence or linguistic. Armenian is as close to Greek as it is to Persian... Phonetically, it is nothing like either. Just look at the word for commander for each. Dioikitis-Sparapet-Spahbod, thats Greek, Armenian and Persian. Genetic evidence shows no relationship with Armenians and Balkan groups, Armenians have mostly J2 and R1b haplogroup, giving zero credibility to the Greco-Armenian language theory.
@@ArthaxtaDaVince777 You CANNOT judge the relationship of two languages by looking at a single word pair. Greek and Armenian are almost universally accepted as being closely related. See the following paper:
A comparison of phylogenetic reconstruction methods on an Indo‐European dataset
d1wqtxts1xzle7.cloudfront.net/49935673/TPS05.pdf?1477654337=&response-content-disposition=inline%3B+filename%3DA_comparison_of_phylogenetic_reconstruct.pdf&Expires=1621865092&Signature=ZKN-2jhX3IqgjDVDwIRCyK6DHfHG2LVpX0Bp~mIhavrrL2OE3XGIDDjNR-l5nMsxhIzN9ZLojUCfpJatWVrwdeFN0qfpTHq9cBRTWR-QLGExHPfo0hWNibd4pyoU4q8S2O9asFsD-Qfi4PAHeap8lZSbtAyxPk1QCeLRJdiPzb96grkRv2l8ZyPrOEGeMMtKkJnLqqDf2G34JVIJ3OWeoLl~anWCWZxJCAk4Jxzf8AOxCcQOvQbTlzt~swQTydRyWiWkgVaGgpdO2zVnWIugUaBFnllWOl2zj2WD1u4leYP9wRDB~WUj1-QAcx9I4SxVgbKaDwF-8hxpUPDyTykRGA__&Key-Pair-Id=APKAJLOHF5GGSLRBV4ZA
In a 2005 publication, a group of linguists and statisticians, comprising Luay Nakhleh, Tandy Warnow, Donald Ringe and Steven N. Evans, compared quantitative phylogenetic linguistic methods and found that a Graeco-Armenian subgroup was supported by that five procedures - maximum parsimony, weighted and unweighted maximum compatibility, neighbor-joining, and the binary lexical coding technique.
MUSH,VAN,ERZRUM,ANI,ARARAT LER,ARTCAX,NAXICHEVAN,GANCAK,SHUSHI IS ARMENIA☝🏻🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲❤️💙🧡✊🏻
Wow_mao brings me here
🇦🇱 Αλβανική Γλώσσα ?
Αυτή μπορεί να με παιδέψει περισσότερο από την Αρμένικη. Θα ήθελα να το κάνω στο άμεσο μέλλον
Απ'ότι ξέρω χωρίζεται σε Τοσκικές και Γκεγκικές (Τουρκαλβανικές) διαλέκτους. Ίσως όμως να είναι δύσκολο να βρει για την αλβανική επειδή δεν είμαστε βέβαιοι από ποια κατάγεται. Μπορεί να είναι από την Ιλλυρική ή από την Παλαιοβαλκανική ομάδα γλωσσών. Άλλοι πάλι έχουν υποθέσει πως σχετίζεται με τα Ελληνικά. Το πρόβλημα είναι ότι ούτε η Ιλλυρική ούτε οι Παλαιοβαλκανικές γλώσσες έχουν γραφεί (πλην της Ελληνικής). Και τα γραπτά αρχεία της Αλβανικής ξεκινούν από τον 16ο αιώνα, οπότε δεν ξέρουμε τι είχαν να πουν οι ίδιοι οι Αλβανοί για την γλώσσα τους πριν από αυτό το σημείο.
@@DionysiosPhryx thank you for your educational comment. I didn't say that Albanian needs a script to prove its existence, of course not. I only said that because we don't have older texts written in Albanian, we don't know what the Albanians themselves had to say about their language and their people.
@@georgios_5342 They are Illyrians native to the Mountains of the Albanian Alps and Sharr Mountains.
@@DionysiosPhryx even so, the Illyrian language is not surely the ancestor of Albanian, as it is not even clear what it was. Many suspect that Illyrian died out during the high Roman Empire due to latinization for example, and that Albanian became widespread in the region after the Germanic conquests
Coca cola is older than azerbaijan
coca cola is more valuable than armenia and georgia
@@volkanaydemir1440 Armenia is 3,500 years old and Azerbaijan is 30 years old 💀💀💀😂
@@Toniko2029 you should remember the Seljuks, kid.
Armenian language are indo aryan language
Not sure what the shadings signify in terms of density but I think the presence of Armenians - even during the middle Byzantine period - is a rather too extensive as far as Anatolia and the Pontus is concerned. Again - this is dependent on what the shadings signify.
Присутствие было очень сильным, особенно с 11 века
The original area of proto-Armenian was located south-westwards and was much larger than presented in the video.
Incidentally I am not sure that such an early date for 'Proto-Armenian' is supported (but I am willing to see/hear the evidence).
The Armenian prehistory is quite obscure but there are evidence for early Bronze Age indo-european settlement in upper Kura river (after 2300 BC), linguistic studies shows formation of Armenian with elements from Caucasian and Hittite loans at least 1200 BC, much before the arrival of Phrygians, and the mysterious Azzi-Hayasa suits with the period and the area as long as linguistically with the endonym of Armenia.
What? Should I also remake it?
Both theories are possible. Armenian prehistory remains quite difficult and obscure. Studying the Caucasus better, I tend more towards the Hayasa-Azzi hypothesis. Congratulations on your latest videos, you have done a very good job
Yes i think so, this hypothesis is more logical.
@Antonio Ferrara Altaic is not a language family dude
6:06 😨😨
😀😀😀😀🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😏
@@umutcandemir4119 You think this will go unanswered? The average Armenian would gladly nuke your country.
First Of All, The Turks Did not commit Genocide Against the ermenians And if Anything Happens To Turkey We will capture The whole World
@@kebabseverim3364 Good luck with that, as your cities turn to ash.
@@ArthaxtaDaVince777 Tell me who lost Karabakh war?
Who had riots over president signing peace?
Who had assault in parliament?
Who had coup attempt after losing a war?
Who is in economic turmoil?
Who is the one can't trade and depend on Iran?
3 million people can't defeat 84 million
If I were you, I'd start friendship instead of being hostile
Good lord this really showcases just how extensive the Armenian Genocide was.
6:05 Enver pasha effect: -300k. armenian separatists😶
Armenians have sizeable population in Lebanon in western Caucasus lowlands.
6:06 like if u cry Everytime
Anyway Nice video
@Atbing 24 Thank you
What is this? A crossover episode?
I didnt cry
I laughed
cry what
@Turkish Mapper
Name checks out
It was all fun and games until ww1
Need to show the Armenians that fledbto cyprus ❤
Happy Easter day. #Rosalina
Hello
Artksah is Armenia
People here talk about how much that changed at 1915, but does anyone consider the fact most areas are only mixed for the entirety of the Middle Ages and up to 1915?
Always stand with minorities and especially with those that suffered and still suffer genocide. I stand with Armenia because I understand that Russia was the only one willing to help you. You sometimes must deal with the devil when lack of allies.