that was impossible because at such close range just a few hits from yamato's two 460mm main guns would be enough to seriously damage uss essex and render her inoperable.
@@samuelng9092 the air planes not are his weakness, yamato was defeat because he was attacked with a 3 strong ships and literally 300 airplanes not 1 weak ship and 30 Air planes lol
I think it's strange to get so serious about such a simple children's video, but the moment the Yamato-class shell hits the Essex-class, it becomes incapacitated, and at this range, the Yamato would have shot it before it could even take flight. That's it, why isn't the secondary gun working? Why isn't Yamato facing sideways? I've been thinking this for a while, but your video is to sloppy. Just because the historical facts are like that, please stop thinking that aircraft carriers are the absolute strongest aircraft carrier.
To be realistic, why hadn't Yamato been found by search planes while Essex was well out of gun range? (... And, yes, I do know about what happened with the Central Force during the Battle of Leyte. Please remember, though, that Halsey and the rest of the American high command thought that Kurita was retiring after the Central Force was mauled in the Sulu Sea; they had, after all, lost Musashi in that go-around.) You are right, though, with your observation that the first hit Essex took in this animation, the one on her front flight deck, would have rendered her incapable of launching aircraft.
Gee take a history lesson. The battle shown it only takes 11 torpedoes to sink Yamato. Essex’s attack aircraft have more than enough torpedoes to lay out that attack.
@@Bestplayer-mx6ybYou don't learn that kind of thing in school…Anyway, before we talk about aircraft, the Essex was within the range of the Yamato, and was hit by two or three shots, so the Yamato would have easily won. Probably, the poster just doesn't have the knowledge.
@@__kamikaze7471 Yamato would have won depending on the accuracy. It’s a 2D animation meaning the impacts on the flight deck on the Essex could have been anywhere within the 191ft width of the flight deck. If Yamato hit Essex with three 18in naval guns like in the video, it would matter where Yamato hits Essex to put her out of service. While yes, the Essex gets hit only twice in the first barrage, the single 18in shell wouldn’t be enough to collapse that forward part of the flight deck. And yea it is pretty dumb the battle is taking place within visual range
At such a range, Yamato should have won because only a few cannon hits and the Essex is basically dead and inoperable. However, ideally, the Essex wouldn’t have gotten that close to a battleship EVER. Essex should have started detected the Yamato and started launching their aircraft way WAY before the Yamato could fire their guns which is how the Yamato was actually taken down in real life.
Totally Historically Inaccurate 1: 11 torpedoes and 6 bombs were able to destroy the Yamato 2: Aircraft mainly used in the attack were F6F Hellcats, F4U Corsairs, SBC2 Helldivers, etc. 3. Yamato counterflooded multiple times from listing Heavily 4. The Casualties from the Carrier lost 27 aircraft, while in reality, Only 10 were destroyed in the attack Any Historical Inaccuracies I missed?
@@nationalfederationofcalradia the four yamato classes: Yamato, Musashi, Ginga (name came from SBY or Space Battleship Yamato) and Kaku (fanmade yamato class)
This is just glazing lol how tf can 1 carrier kill the yamato? Plus yamato could have 5-8 shoted the carrier and the planes cant take of in those conditions glazing a dam carrier
To those who are glazing the Yamato please pay attention. 1.Japanese AAguns we’re famously horrible in ww2 and the Yamatos is not an exception(out of roughly 300 aircraft that attacked her in her final battle she shot down only 10) 2. Why would a US aircraft carrier engage a battleship within its firing range instead of its aircrafts operational range? 3. In the circumstances of the video the Yamato would smoke the US carrier(Duh) 4. It’s a video for children (but I guess we like to nit-pick) In short, there’s a reason we don’t build battleships anymore.
*Battlecruisers Ahh Battle Start Scene* (Heckling Starts) Yamato: I will receive my first honor and you'll receive Dis-honor! Essex: Do you like Lemon Juice? I heard you have Your New Hotel open for Business
Hope this translates well: Above all that, aircraft carriers hold a lot of munitions and fuel for the aircraft; a 46cm shell has a good chance of igniting all of them as well
Realistically no battleship ever is winning against an Essex or any other fleet carrier, provided the latter is competent. The battleship won’t even get to open fire
It is inaccurate that it did not sink even though it was within the range of Yamato and was hit by many shells, and in the first place it is impossible to defeat Yamato with a carrier-based aircraft of one aircraft carrier can't sink the Yamato.
i have a few questions, wouldn't yamato just list while torpedos hit in broadsides? plus battleships are better than aircraft carriers, there were some essex class carriers that were sunk and i thought yamato would just hit from the broadsides, please fix this
Hope this translates well, I'll try to keep it simple for google: I do not think planes could land from the front of the deck. Essex would not survive 46cm shells, her best hope is that they punch all the way through before detonating in the ship. I'd say any ship is weak to torpedoes as it's only a matter of time until the hull buckles. Not sure what you mean by special attack, probably google translate acting up
At a long range. An Aircraft carrier could possibly take out the Yamato with its Aircraft but at a short range when time is essential for victory, Yamato could take out the Essex with a couple of shots
Honestly in this case, Yamato will keep moving ahead or show her broadside and fire at Essex with all her guns in the 4 - 5 - 4 - 5 series. The accuracy will be better and of course, just a few shells of Yamato can sink Essex or makes her inoperable, and how the hell can Essex lets her aircraft take off especially when her flying deck is damaged that much? Is this world of warships' physics with U.S. bias 🙃
No, at any range that a Yamato can shoot at an aircraft carrier, any aircraft carrier? Well, said aircraft carrier is dead. There is no way that ship will survive. If it is stupid enough to stumble into Yamato or Musashi, it’s dead. I will also point out. It took 6, 7, or 8 Essex class ships, including a bunch of secondary carriers to sink a single Yamato. The same for the Musashi.
that was impossible because at such close range just a few hits from yamato's two 460mm main guns would be enough to seriously damage uss essex and render her inoperable.
Besides, the Yamato wouldn't wait for an entire Essex air mission before firing again and again...
USS Johnston a small destroyer survived 6 direct hit from Yamato and continue to fight 😂😂😂
@@ahtong1014 True, the Yamato's armor-piercing rounds simply passed through the American ship, without exploding inside it.
@@ahtong1014Overpens tho
When you see the Yamato through your binoculars,you are already 100% inside the range of Yamato’s main battery
Yamato armor: 650mm
Yamato weapons: 460 mm
Us essex armor: 30-100 mm
Us essex weapons: only Air planes.
Yamato could win very easy lol
But air planes is actually yamatos weakness
@@samuelng9092戦艦大和を倒すには10隻は航空母艦が必要だと思うよ
@@samuelng9092 the air planes not are his weakness, yamato was defeat because he was attacked with a 3 strong ships and literally 300 airplanes not 1 weak ship and 30 Air planes lol
@@samuelng9092そんなん言ったら全員弱点だわw
I think only need one
だから何で陸軍の曲なんだよw
普通は軍艦行進曲だろうがw
I think it's strange to get so serious about such a simple children's video, but the moment the Yamato-class shell hits the Essex-class, it becomes incapacitated, and at this range, the Yamato would have shot it before it could even take flight. That's it, why isn't the secondary gun working? Why isn't Yamato facing sideways? I've been thinking this for a while, but your video is to sloppy. Just because the historical facts are like that, please stop thinking that aircraft carriers are the absolute strongest aircraft carrier.
I also sympathize with it I also thought that his video had a growing extension But I was betrayed by the idea
Yes I agree with you this video doesn't make sense
"Please stop thinking aircraft carriers are the absolute strongest aircraft carriers"
r/godzillahadastroketryingtoreadthisandfuckingdied
I agree with you
To be realistic, why hadn't Yamato been found by search planes while Essex was well out of gun range?
(... And, yes, I do know about what happened with the Central Force during the Battle of Leyte. Please remember, though, that Halsey and the rest of the American high command thought that Kurita was retiring after the Central Force was mauled in the Sulu Sea; they had, after all, lost Musashi in that go-around.)
You are right, though, with your observation that the first hit Essex took in this animation, the one on her front flight deck, would have rendered her incapable of launching aircraft.
まず空母が大和の射程に入るなよ。
あと集弾率悪すぎるし副砲を
飾りにするな。
大和の水雷防御こんなに低いもんなん?
@@ニキニキニキ威力はわからんが魚雷1本で船底に穴が空くほど大和の装甲は薄くない
動画の作者は返信してこないしな..
The bombers were too fast to shoot down
エンタメエンタメ、許したりな
史実の戦艦大和は400機以上の航空機、10隻以上の航空母艦の猛攻を受けてやっと沈んだのだからこんな結果はありえない
ポンチ絵に本気で反論してるアホ。
坊ノ岬沖海戦での大和の戦果は敵航空機12機だけだけどね
戦艦が空母に勝てるわけがない
Gee take a history lesson. The battle shown it only takes 11 torpedoes to sink Yamato. Essex’s attack aircraft have more than enough torpedoes to lay out that attack.
@@Bestplayer-mx6ybYou don't learn that kind of thing in school…Anyway, before we talk about aircraft, the Essex was within the range of the Yamato, and was hit by two or three shots, so the Yamato would have easily won. Probably, the poster just doesn't have the knowledge.
@@__kamikaze7471 Yamato would have won depending on the accuracy. It’s a 2D animation meaning the impacts on the flight deck on the Essex could have been anywhere within the 191ft width of the flight deck. If Yamato hit Essex with three 18in naval guns like in the video, it would matter where Yamato hits Essex to put her out of service. While yes, the Essex gets hit only twice in the first barrage, the single 18in shell wouldn’t be enough to collapse that forward part of the flight deck. And yea it is pretty dumb the battle is taking place within visual range
そもそも何であの状態で発艦したり着艦できるんですかねぇ
At such a range, Yamato should have won because only a few cannon hits and the Essex is basically dead and inoperable. However, ideally, the Essex wouldn’t have gotten that close to a battleship EVER. Essex should have started detected the Yamato and started launching their aircraft way WAY before the Yamato could fire their guns which is how the Yamato was actually taken down in real life.
Totally Historically Inaccurate
1: 11 torpedoes and 6 bombs were able to destroy the Yamato
2: Aircraft mainly used in the attack were F6F Hellcats, F4U Corsairs, SBC2 Helldivers, etc.
3. Yamato counterflooded multiple times from listing Heavily
4. The Casualties from the Carrier lost 27 aircraft, while in reality, Only 10 were destroyed in the attack
Any Historical Inaccuracies I missed?
Yes 0:12 i refuse to believe planes could take off that fast
It is inaccurate that the Yamato did not sink even though it was hitvby many shells.
The animation shows SB2C Helldivers carrying torpedoes. The Helldiver was a dive bomber, intended to replace the SBD Dauntless.
also yamato was hit with 400 planes
知識増やそうぜ
空母エセックス級の装甲は薄かったから戦艦大和の46センチの世界最強の砲弾が命中したら轟沈の可能性もある
セKKU素!?
あと、46センチ砲の砲撃を喰らってもはっかんできるところが謎やな。投稿主はまともな知識もないのか
@@PASUFAINDAイクゥ..///
@@nekohatihatandayoそれな
1発でも砲弾がどこかしらに命中したら空母なんか行動不能になるはず
@ しかもエセックス級は甲板が薄いから即行動不能になるはず
now we got this. What's next, Yamato vs Iowa?
Or Yamato Vs Enterprise, Oh I Know! How About " IJN Yamato Vs USS Iowa And USS Enterprise "
how abut 4 yamatos vs 16 us destroyers 24 us cruisers 8 us battleships 4 us aircraft carriers
@@nationalfederationofcalradia the four yamato classes: Yamato, Musashi, Ginga (name came from SBY or Space Battleship Yamato) and Kaku (fanmade yamato class)
@@SillyLittleGoober01Yamato(大和) Musashi(武蔵) Shinano(信濃) Kii(紀伊)
would be appropriate.
@@__kamikaze7471 true.
日米露の有志連合このコメ欄でできちゃってるよ（）
😢😮😢😮😢😮😢😮😢
Bro I Will like that floating sandbox was like this.
and also Great video🖐️😔🖐️
This is just glazing lol how tf can 1 carrier kill the yamato? Plus yamato could have 5-8 shoted the carrier and the planes cant take of in those conditions glazing a dam carrier
To those who are glazing the Yamato please pay attention.
1.Japanese AAguns we’re famously horrible in ww2 and the Yamatos is not an exception(out of roughly 300 aircraft that attacked her in her final battle she shot down only 10)
2. Why would a US aircraft carrier engage a battleship within its firing range instead of its aircrafts operational range?
3. In the circumstances of the video the Yamato would smoke the US carrier(Duh)
4. It’s a video for children (but I guess we like to nit-pick)
In short, there’s a reason we don’t build battleships anymore.
*Battlecruisers Ahh Battle Start Scene*
(Heckling Starts)
Yamato: I will receive my first honor and you'll receive Dis-honor!
Essex: Do you like Lemon Juice? I heard you have Your New Hotel open for Business
空母ダイヤモンドかなんかでできてんのか？
ウルツァイト窒化ホウ酸だろ
副砲主砲が対空射撃しなかったり
横向いて射撃しなかったり
大和圧倒的に不利だけど
マジになってもしょうがないから
とりま抜刀隊じゃない曲にしてほしい！
日本語で失礼します。第二次大戦で作戦行動中に航空攻撃で沈んだ戦艦は日本は大和と武蔵で他は英国のプリンス・オブ・ウェールズとレパルスの四隻だけです。航空機や空母はけして最強の兵器ではないです。事実、シブヤン海海戦では戦艦武蔵を沈める為にアメリカ海軍はエセックス級艦隊型正規空母とインディペンデンス級軽空母の二種類の空母を15隻投入して大和型戦艦武蔵を撃沈しましたが他の大和・長門・金剛・榛名の大和型戦艦1隻や長門型戦艦の1隻や金剛型戦艦の二隻を撃沈する事は不可能でした。もしフィリピンでの艦隊戦に15隻以上の大和型戦艦がいたら多分シブヤン海海戦ではアメリカ海軍の空母の攻撃対象が分散されて一隻も戦艦を撃沈出来なかったと個人的には思います。
Japan couldn’t have had the resources to produce 15 Yamato class battleships
たらればに過ぎる
Real question: do you think it was 15 out of need, or 15 because "we want that floating hotel under the waves. Now"
Good video
He is IJN Musashi VS USS Franklin (CV-13) because it seems
この状態でなぜ戦闘機が離陸できるのか分からないw
大和は航空攻撃により沈没しているのでこれは史実として受け入れるしかない。しかし動画に描かれている状況ではあり得ないことが起きると思う。まず空母が大和の主砲弾を受けたら即、沈没はあり得るしそれでなくても艦の傾斜や滑走路の使用不能などで抗戦能力はゼロになっちゃう。最初に受けた大和の被害次第だが空母は戦場より離脱するしかないと思う。一方、大和・武蔵はその抗堪性は史実でも実証ずみだから空母が航行不能であればいつでもとどめを刺しに行けるんじゃないかな？
Hope this translates well:
Above all that, aircraft carriers hold a lot of munitions and fuel for the aircraft; a 46cm shell has a good chance of igniting all of them as well
How many planes does America have?
46cm砲を耐える空母？妙だな…
Realistically no battleship ever is winning against an Essex or any other fleet carrier, provided the latter is competent. The battleship won’t even get to open fire
It is inaccurate that it did not sink even though it was within the range of Yamato and was hit by many shells, and in the first place it is impossible to defeat Yamato with a carrier-based aircraft of one aircraft carrier can't sink the Yamato.
"This is lore inaccurate"🗣🔥
i have a few questions, wouldn't yamato just list while torpedos hit in broadsides? plus battleships are better than aircraft carriers, there were some essex class carriers that were sunk and i thought yamato would just hit from the broadsides, please fix this
色々と疑問なんだが、エセックスは前方向から着艦出来るのか？飛行甲板に穴空いてるのに発艦出来るのはなぜ？そもそも大和の46cm砲にそんなに耐えれるのか？魚雷にそんなに弱いか？特攻で穴あくか？
Hope this translates well, I'll try to keep it simple for google:
I do not think planes could land from the front of the deck. Essex would not survive 46cm shells, her best hope is that they punch all the way through before detonating in the ship. I'd say any ship is weak to torpedoes as it's only a matter of time until the hull buckles. Not sure what you mean by special attack, probably google translate acting up
@biorecords1506 It says "Sorry, it can't be translated" so I don't understand.
It doesn't make sense that 460 cannons or something at close range should have won the Yamato.
bro who cares
“Bro who cares” 💀🙏🗿
@@The-idk9283 I am the one who cares
@@Ijn.yamato.kapal.kelas.pertama will is the creators idea so Yamato lose
@The-idk9283 people has the right to critique it...
At a long range. An Aircraft carrier could possibly take out the Yamato with its Aircraft but at a short range when time is essential for victory, Yamato could take out the Essex with a couple of shots
Do USS North Carolina (BB-55) vs Japanese aircraft carrier Zuikaku
У Ямато были катапульты в корме
う〜む…至近距離なら戦艦大和の主砲46cm(460mm)三連装砲はエセックス級空母を行動不能にできるほどの力はあるし、砲撃されたら航空甲板が崩れ、すぐには発艦できないはず。しかも、エセックス級空母の甲板は薄いからすぐに破壊できるはず…ちょっとこの動画には不思議な点が多すぎる
Как много тут людей каторые доверяют интернету, хотя и сомневаются.😸🇷🇺
What app or game is this?
Странно. Один залп ямато против одного налета авиагруппы. Если линкор вышел на стрельбу главным каллибром по авианоссцу. Второго налета не будет...
If the landing place is devastated won’t the aircraft not have enough to take off and land
Nah man, they just enter hard mode.
Bro why there dauntless carrying torps?
Why did they use SB2C’s to strafe the Yamato in this video…
大和の主砲と艦首のデザインがアイオワ級戦艦と同じなんよな
There is already a video about yamato vs iowa what about yamato vs montana or yamato vs gulf war iowa class
史実どおりに再現しているつもりでしょうけど空母は飛行甲板に一発でも攻撃されたら戦闘機、艦上爆撃機、艦上雷撃機は発艦などできません。
そのところちゃんと再現して欲しい
馬鹿らしい。空母が大和の主砲を喰らったら一発で轟沈だよ。
空母一隻の艦載機で大和を撃沈するのも、まず無理ですよね。
@ そもそも空母が護衛艦も無しで大和の射程内に入るなど自殺行為です。また被弾して浸水したら傾斜して艦載機の発艦もできません。まあ、そもそもどんな艦でも大和の主砲弾を喰らったら、一撃で大破か沈没ですが。
@@George211945史実だと10隻以上いましたね
@@大艦巨砲主義-m9o そもそも空母が戦艦の射程内に入るのがおかしいのです。でも待ち伏せされるなどで入ってしまい主砲で撃たれたら、これは一撃で沈むのです。
@@慎一小澤 空母の存在価値がそんな使い方だったらなくなりますよね
if you guys think you can complain about innacuracues go watch the other naval battle videos
Do a video of USS Zumwalt Level UP
👍👍👍
アメリカの、アメリカによる、アメリカのための動画。
This animation is 20 years behind than Japan's one.
Much of Yamatos gear was outdated by the time she entered service don't forget
Essex wouldve still won but the Yamato couldve still heavily ruined the flight deck of the Essex
if it's far away it would win
The Yamato would not get close enough to the carrier to fire its guns.
you just got helldiver'd and dauntless'd
まずあんな爆弾を飛行機に付けられないし艦首から着陸してる
Honestly in this case, Yamato will keep moving ahead or show her broadside and fire at Essex with all her guns in the 4 - 5 - 4 - 5 series. The accuracy will be better and of course, just a few shells of Yamato can sink Essex or makes her inoperable, and how the hell can Essex lets her aircraft take off especially when her flying deck is damaged that much? Is this world of warships' physics with U.S. bias 🙃
Yamato as predator
USS essex as summoner
Make Yamato vs Montana
残念だけど概ね事実だしな…
回避運動とか三式弾とかは戦略的視点では「細かい事」に過ぎないから…
2発目くらいでもうドカンと行きそうな感じするけどなぁ
@@__kamikaze7471エセックス級だったら甲板に当たってそのまま轟沈しそう
残念だかエセックス一隻でボコされる程弱くないんだわ…
Space battleship yamato vs IJN yamato?
46cm砲の威力がかすり傷やん
eh what about 400 aircraft
Impossible because uss Essex was a carrier that yamato destroyed while in okinawa
The music tho...
No, at any range that a Yamato can shoot at an aircraft carrier, any aircraft carrier? Well, said aircraft carrier is dead. There is no way that ship will survive. If it is stupid enough to stumble into Yamato or Musashi, it’s dead.
I will also point out. It took 6, 7, or 8 Essex class ships, including a bunch of secondary carriers to sink a single Yamato. The same for the Musashi.
大和の射程は最大40キロ。
艦載機の航続距離は1000キロ以上。
射程内でやり合うこと自体がナンセンス。
Dude Yamato also had planes it they were catapult launched
USA bias channel
And yes it definitely would hurt the USS Essex
戦艦大和の最終形態と言え艦首部分にレーダー(？)は搭載してませんよ。
Yamato vs Shinano.
Arizona VS Yamato
YAMATO VS IOWA
空母は被弾＝戦闘不能なとこあるんだけどな
*Mission tengo!!!*
そもそも空母が甲板前部が破壊された時点で飛行機飛ばせられないだろ。
this was rigged it was a close target and it still missed yamato should have won
Impossible 3 hits of he would explode eesex into more pieces than kaga
Use tanks too
❤❤❤❤10000000.
海上的“大象 VS 老鼠
Yamato vs uss Iowa
i don;t think any planes would take off or land from a damage runway at sea
Yamato is the strongest battle ship so it would easily defeat a aircraft carrier
USA vs Japan is crazy bruh
Yeah it was, but this video was historical inaccurate.
この結果は、嘘やろ。
空母だけに戦艦が負けないと思うし。
Umm how can planes grow bombs💣
This video is honestly just annoying my ww2 brain as this is literally impossible
Did yamato suddenly get a radar or smthn lol
戦艦大和最後まで戦ったんかー
it shell would piece essex deck and into fuel and weapons store boom it will go
われら海軍 陸軍の象徴歌を我らの誇り 大和の画像を使用するでない。
Carrier wuuld always be way out of range. Do a vid Yamato against Iowa class Battleship better
cũng hay mà
Historically inaccurate it took 18 planes for the yamato to be down
Even more wrong than him
100 something plames
Like bro made the bomber OP
史実だと400機ですね
Yamato and frens battle ship fiet3
The Essex will sink but there’s a chance that the plane will sink the Yamato
God bless America
5:15 Yankees Kamikaze
Captain of yamato so stupid for not closing in to uss essex. 😅
正面からってあまり見ない攻め方だね
護衛は？空母を攻撃するならいる気がするけど