As a Vietnamese , i don't consider our war against the French an expansion of communism. It was simply the Vietnamese people's fight for independence for the sake of the nation
I agree the West misunderstands the mainly nationalist motivations of normal Vietnamese in joining the Viet Minh to fight colonialism, but when the organisation promotes communism and silences other voices, like the Sangha or Bao Dai from even having a voice it becomes a concern for many people, not just Westerners, but democrats of all nations, who see the leadership of the Viet Minh as using the ordinary people's legitimate love of nation and desire to fight against colonialism as a means to spread an undemocratic ideology. Regardless, long live independent Vietnam.
Do you try to rewrite your history? Your country could win the Imperialist France and USA by support of the network of USSR, PRC China, Cuba, Prated Laos movement which are Communist countries or leftist army.
Very interesting.I still remember the military invasion of Czechoslovakia remember standing in the main street of Breclav watching the army rolling past.I was too young to understand as it was drummed into us how great communism is.
@@Викторвиктор-р7ы Democracy doesn't bring peace, individual rights, one's right to life is what brings peace. Democracy is merely the right of a majority to screw over a minority. Idiots can't seem to figure it out. The US is the only country in all of history founded on the principles of one's right to life. Too bad so many couldn't grasp this concept and instead turned in the direction of collectivism, communism, fascism and socialism
@@Викторвиктор-р7ы We have SEEN the type of peace YOUR side brings in Ukraine.I also witnessed your kind of "Peace "when I saw the killing fields in Cambodia.
This was excellent. I especially appreciated that it showed the aftermath of the North Vietnamese victory in Vietnam, when suddenly their supporters all over the world suddenly went silent when they saw the horrors of what they had been supporting. They didn't have too much to say then.
@@piero17y65 maybe she watched the part from 4 days ago and it showed a preview of what's coming on this 1? I noticed that sometimes I'm notified about a supposed live vid coming up, but when I click to go watch it, it already has a few comments in the comments section. But any other live vid I watch, people can't comment in the comments section and have to wait until it ends or get in the live chat. Fk knows 🤷🏻♀️lol
If the Vietnamese would be honest looking back at their recent history, they should admit, that the whole fight was for nothing. The Americans were not there to enslave them or to exploit them. They just wanted to stop the spread of communism. And communism they don't even want anymore in Vietnam. So they fought for something, which they themselves abbandoned afterwards within a generation. Four million deaths for nothing. They could be like South Korea now, if history went otherwise.
"Communism simply falls apart..." - NO ! my poor Editors. . . millions had died for these fateful days, some 10 times the total death of Jews, Americans on the Viet-Nam fields, the Gulag, . . . from Before Christ to the Second World War, combined !
Who put the pressure on minority and poor nations? Of course we all know it was the western imperialists, its even in history books.. Is the world really overpopulated? Do we really have to kill each other for a few ppls gains? Why cant we work togther rather than eliminate one another..
It's weird how easily and freely you hear people in Russia describe their love and loyalty towards Lenin and Stalin but the names of Khruschev, Brezhnev, Andropov, Chernenko and Gorbachev are NEVER mentioned with such zeal if at all.
It's not true, they mention gorbi, but everyone hates him. for you, of course, he is a hero who destroyed the "evil empire", but for us he is a traitor who destroyed a great superpower and condemned millions to death and poverty in the nineties
From what I picked up, Khrushchev was a revisionist, Brezhnev comparable to Biden and Yeltsin, And Gorbachev pretty much betrayed the whole USSR. The other two I guess reigned too briefly to be compared.
Because they weren't alive when lenin and stalin were in power. To young Russians lenin is mostly just a guy with a lot of statues that they dont really ask about and Stalin isn't talked about all that much. At least that was what I gathered when I lived there. But they do revere strong leaders be it lenin, putin or peter the great. Most people I knew didn't really want to talk about history.
@@ZS-rw4qq Hahaha, Brezhnev was comparable to Yeltsin? You got to be kidding! The only thing those two had in common, that one was half-dead from old age and the other one (in his later term) half-dead from alcohol. Also: Gorbachev didn't betray the USSR, the Communist Party did. It's very easy to blame one man, but in reality that's almost never the case.
The Italian Communist Party immediately changed its name shortly before the USSR fell, in an attempt to maintain its significant support into the new era. The much diminished French party kept its name, content to coast on nostalgia.
Communism is not dead, it just smells really bad. Excellent film series for its purpose. It was short and to the point, however lacking in scope and context.
@Joseph D Atkinson I'll never understand no private property. I guess capitalism is all I've ever known. Call it whatever you want, money, work points, ownership, private property, public property. There has to be some kind if system whereby you know that what was yours when you left will be yours when you return. Why would anyone work at all not to truly have anything they can call their own? I have a 4 yr degree in political science and I still can't wrap my head around it
@@poutinedream5066 4 yr... Surprisingly, you apparently wasted your time😄Under socialism, private ownership of the means of production is prohibited. All industry and mining is in the hands of the state, not private corporations. Consumption is regulated by state planning, and not by the pursuit of profit and the market. In the USSR, there was personal property and it was easily inherited. Most families had several apartments and houses. How are you going to compete honestly in the "free" market with companies that transfer and increase their capital for tens or even hundreds of years)... "Artel"(Production Cooperative) under socialism, I think it was not a bad decision instead of private business under capitalism. And now enjoy the next global crisis of capitalism, which, perhaps, once again they will try to patch up and prolong its life due to the war😁
"Bella ciao!" ("Farewell, beauty!") is an Italian folk song, one of the most famous anti-fascist partisan songs in Italy. The song was sung in partisan detachments operating in several regions of Italy in 1943-1945. The song became widely known in the world after it was brought by the Italian delegation to the 1st International Festival of Youth and Students in Prague in 1947. "Vella ciao!" long ago became the international song of the struggle for freedom, against oppression. It is sung in different countries, in different languages. "Bella ciao!" ("Прощай, красавица!") - народная итальянская песня, одна из самых известных антифашистских партизанских песен Италии. Песню пели в партизанских отрядах, действовавших в нескольких областях Италии в 1943-1945 годах. Песня стала широко известна в мире после того, как её привезла итальянская делегация на 1 международный фестиваль молодежи и студентов в Праге в 1947 году. "Веlla ciao!" давно стала международной песней борьбы за свободу, против угнетения. Её поют в разных странах, на разных языках.
I think there shoudl be more stautes of Gorbachev. he did not fight the change despite sitting on millions off soliders, secret police ect etc. Off course he dreamed off making Communism humane and work out fine but he did accapt the loss off immense power for also himself rather than use voilence to fight it. Whould all our contemporary democratic leaders accept that? I hope so!
Горбачёв - просто слабовольный и не далёкий человек. Такие люди не должны лезть во власть. Сейчас его ненавидит вся страна и жалеет, что не состоялся суд над ним.
@@slabart12, вы не понимаете, что вы пишете. Его ненавидит вся страна. Все надеялись, что всё-таки состоится суд над ним, но к сожалению он издох безнаказанно, так же, как Ельцын. Но всё равно, время придёт и этот суд над всеми преступниками, разрушившими государство и повинными в страданиях и смерти тысяч людей на постсоветском пространстве, состоится, пусть даже после их смерти. И в учебниках истории они будут названы, как преступники.
Immense appreciation and grateful thanks! The ONLY thing you missed was Trotsky's fight AGAINST Stalinism and his creation of the Fourth International; True Socialism.
Trotsky is not real socialism! You are far from dialectical materialism as the methodology of Marxism! Trotsky is a petty-bourgeois socialist, actually a Menshevik. Voicing his theory of Permanent Revolution, Trotsky proceeded from the idealism of consciousness, and not from the real relations that existed in reality. Trotsky hoped for a revolution in the main European countries, England and Germany, but he did not even take into account the fundamental provisions of the unequal development of capitalism and the division of capitalism into colonial and metropolitan, i.e. the disparity of development, and consequently the disparity of social consciousness. The European worker, being relatively prosperous by the standards of other workers of the world due to the fact that he is in the conditions of the metropolis and the capitalist shares with him most of the surplus value, makes the revolution less possible due to less support from the population.
Between 1944 and 1950 over 2.5 million Ukrainians were deported to Siberia under the code 58 and Khrushchev was the person implementing it under the orders of Stalin its rich coming from Khrushchev saying it was wrong.
And quite rightly they were deported. In western Ukraine, after its liberation from German occupation, thousands of Bandera gangs operated. They committed such atrocities against everyone who was suspected of being loyal to the Soviet regime that their hair stood on end: they tortured and killed in the most brutal ways not only the military and government officials, but also teachers, doctors, and ordinary peasants. Entire families were slaughtered with children. And it was impossible to stop this bloody bacchanalia for several years - almost until the mid-50s. The war was over, but peaceful life did not come. Because Bandera was covered by the local population. The only way to fight the partisan movement is to deprive it of the support of the local population. As long as the population helps the partisans, nothing can be done with them. Therefore, the fascists, fighting the Soviet partisans, carried out acts of retaliation and intimidation of the civilian population - they burned people alive by entire villages, shot the hostages. And during the Vietnam War, the United States burned Vietnamese villages with napalm, where partisans took refuge. But the Soviet government acted humanely. No one was burned alive, no hostages were shot. They simply sent them to other regions of the country - to Siberia, as well as to Kazakhstan and Central Asia. And there people, if they were not involved, except for aiding bandits, in any real crimes, then they could engage in agricultural activities in the same way as at home, in Ukraine. And you should not try to surpass Solzhenitsyn with his mythical millions of those who were shot. Not 2.5 million Ukrainians were deported, but about 200,000. And not from all of Ukraine, but mainly from the western regions. И совершенно справедливо были депортированы. На западной Украине, после освобождения её от немецкой оккупации, действовали тысячи бандеровских банд. Они творили такие зверства в отношении всех, кого подозревали в лояльности к советской власти, что волосы дыбом подымаются: истязали и убивали самыми зверскими способами не только военных и представителей власти, но и учителей, врачей, просто крестьян. Вырезали целыми семьями вместе с детьми. И остановить эту кровавую вакханалию было невозможно на протяжении нескольких лет - почти до середины 50-х годов. Война кончилась, а мирная жизнь никак не наступала. Потому что бандеровцев покрывало местное население. Единственный способ борьбы с партизанским движением - это лишение его поддержки местного населения. Пока население помогает партизанам ничего с ними не сделаешь. Поэтому фашисты, борясь с советскими партизанами, проводили акции возмездия и устрашения мирного населения - сжигали людей заживо целыми деревнями, растреливали заложников. А США во время войны во Вьетнаме сжигали напалмом вьетнамские деревни, где укрывались партизаны. А вот советская власть поступила гуманно. Заживо никого не сжигали, заложников не расстреливали. Просто высылали в другие районы страны - в Сибирь, а так же в Казахстан и Среднюю Азию. И там люди, если они не были замешаны, кроме пособничества бандитам, ни в каких реальных преступлениях, то они могли заниматься сельхоздеятельностью так же, как у себя дома, на Украине. И не стоит пытаться переплюнуть Солженицына с его мифическими миллионами расстрелянных. Не 2,5 миллиона украинцев было выслано, а около 200 000. И не со всей Украины, а в основном именно из западных областей.
1920- 1930.Красный террор. Репресии. Гулаг. Ссылки. Растрелы. Голодомор. Геноцид украинского народа. Сталиным. Большевиками. Комунистами.Сегодня расея уничтожает Украину как государство. Убивает детей, народ Украины. Геноцид.Слава Украине. Слава героям. Живе Украина. С ЕС. И НАТО. ✊🇺🇦✌️🌅
Так, Хрущов ще й займався програмою ковгоспів в Україні, яка «провалювалася» бо занадто високі були очікування та норми. А ми всі знаємо що це означає. На його руках достатньо крові та страждань українців, він продукт свого часу…
Poor for the Imperialism trying to negate all achievements of Socialist nations - who blocked American and the Western Colonialist expanding. In fact, Americans was defeated by us - Vietnam, and they did all things to prevent us being friends with many countries in the world after war, they did all things to determine that we were the danger of the world, and communism need to be deleted. Many people had died under the hands of Cololialism and Imperialism, included my grandfather and my uncles. They brought war to us, to everywhere they suppose that there is no democracy and human rights, so ? Poverty, inconsistency, etc are continuing where they came, come and are going to come. We trying to make world become better, want to be friends with all people. We overcame many years of war, know the true worth of freedom and peace, so recognizing the truth is very important, not the documetary like this. See type of "democracy and freedom" American brought to Iraq, Lybia, Syria ???
Yes, Khruschov is the good guy... Until you try to find out what was he doing in Stalin's era He's another blood-stained red criminal. Maybe not a real maniac unlike his predecessors. The most humanistic terrorist so to say
Censura desta plataforma, que usa de ideologia disfarçada. O comunismo/socialismo não morreu, como o vídeo tenta levar a pensar, mas está de roupagem nova.🇧🇷
It migrated to the West long before then. FDRs Administration was full of Communist sympathizers. Alger Hiss, for one. The anti war movements of the sixties were fermented by the KGB, as was the Liberation Theology crap in Latin America. BLM admits to being Marxists.
Although Communism would always fail in practice, as an ideology it will never die, because it is based on envy, which is eternal. There will always be people who will fall for the fairy tale that they can get something for nothing.
@@FtrollThe full mantra is "From everyone according to his abilities,. to each according to his needs." And the stupid one is you, if you really believe that this can work in practice. In reality, greed and laziness prevails - and skyrockets. I have witnessed this first-hand as I lived the first half of my life under communism. You have no idea what you are talking about.
@@befeleme nothing is perfect, but it works better in communism than in capitalism. Because you still need to be able to sell yourself and no matter how good you are.
@@Ftroll "It works better in communism"??? What???? How can you possibly say something so ignorant is beyond me. Capitalism has lifted more people out of poverty than any other system. In contrast, wherever communism tread, it left poverty and bloodshed in its wake. I could excuse your starry eyed idealism because you are obviously still young, but I can't excuse your intellectual laziness and ignorance of history. You have fallen for a fairy tale. And you probably think that you could do "better communism" than all those who tried before. That's sheer narcissism. You could not do anything better, because the communist theory is unworkable in practice, and you are not as amazing and incorruptible as you think - and even if you were, you'd be stabbed in the back by your "better selling" comrades sooner than you could say "Das Kapital". "The truth has no defence against a fool determined to believe a lie." - Mark Twain
I'm pretty sure it's a computer generated voice (text-to-speak). I doubt anyone can be so fluent in English most of the time and also f*ck up very basic words like that.
Wao sangat menegangkan teringat waktu kejadian 7 jendral Indonesia di lubang buaya di Indonesia yg melibatkan banyak korban pembantaian pada waktu itu.sangat tragis dan sampai sekarang masih berbekas trauma kawan kawan yg terlibat orangtuanya pada masa itu👍
The expression is lease on life (not of). Is the narrator attempting to say gorilla warfare (around the 3 minute mark)? Around time point 7:30, the narrator mispronounced the word contents. He seems to have a variety of pronunciations of Krushchev. Really bad narrator. Wonderful film/visuals however. Fascinating topic.
Some things are good in comunism but as a human not having option only following an eternal leader and oveiyng to him i rather die.Capitalism is good but i dont like too much tolerance in capitalism, sometimes i see it like a crazy chaos.
Странно, что в капстранах высокий уровень жизни. И соцзащита, с вашей.не сравнить. У вас её просто нет. То что есть, как и биржа труда, конституция, право, закон... Филькина грамота. Одно, что цветёт и пахнет.... Злоба, ненависть, корупция, нищета, насилие, разруха, безработица, смертность.,ложь,шантаж. Агресия.Фашизм.Слава Украине. Слава героям .✊🇺🇦✌️🌅
@@poutinedream5066 Satire is a _very_ effective weapon against ideological tyranny. It's every bit as valid as "taking things seriously" - and you don't have to pick between one or the other. An effective satirist has _very seriously_ studied the issue they're making fun of. So, Mr. Serious - what exactly have you done? Where's all your super serious work published? Where can I watch your documentaries and read your essays?
Very, very good work. Today, in America we face cultural Marxism. The young are being mistaught. They don’t listen and seek out knowledge to verify what they are being taught in government schools. They will have to learn from their own mistakes. I find that sad.
Тепер ждёт страна после ссср .,апокалипсиуса и вайна ,потом бкдет если продолжит ,тогда взрыв землом щару все болще существу не будет, значит народ тупве стали.
Make housing affordable, and maybe we'll listen to guys like you. Until then keep spewing your neo nazi "cultural marxism" talking point 😂 I'm sure it'll come through some day...
It's all about power witch is very important for the time. Everyone was scared of atomic weapons would show to everyone that it's not going to be nothing like any war before. I just hope the leadership of certain countries have brain's enough to see that nobody will win. 🇩🇪✌️
The spread of communism reminds me a lot of the genestealer cult in warhammer 40k. Essentially a very intelligent alien lands on a human world and charms a few humans through mind control to form a cult. The cult lives underground and breeds until it can start spreading the message above ground too, infiltrating society. The mind control makes the initial victims see the gross alien as a holy savior, a god on earth. All their words are like the divine words of god himself. When the cult reaches critical mass, the original infiltrator alien calls the main hive to invade the human planet. The cult sees the invaders as their gods salvation and actually fight the humans. Right until the original alien breaks his hivemind control, causing the cult to finally see the invaders for what they are. Then the aliens consume the cult for their biomass. I always found it funny how this was so heavily inspired by the USSR. They indoctrinated intellectuals of a foreign nation, sent them back to form a communist party. The party collected more and more members in the shadows, infiltrating aspects of society. Right until they had enough believers to invite the USSR to invade and "liberate" the nation. And after the invasion was over, most of the nation would see the true colors of the USSR as they abused the satellite state for their workforce and natural resources.
Это ложь. У СССР не было государств-сателлитов и СССР не злоупотреблял никем ради каких-то ресурсов. Наоборот, СССР во все государства, с которыми сотрудничал, вкладывал свои ресурсы и очень часто безвозмездно, не получая в ответ никакой материальной выгоды.
@@dhsjfjdkek5102 A revolution against the regime of landlords and capitalist was developing the US was also innerving providing help to those who would become the Islamic terrorists.
Official reports and documentaries say that Russia as in USSR was Socialist for 100 years and not Communist. Do you know the answer if this information is true.
@@carolynetter8046 I think the terminology can just get a bit muddled. Like the USA. Some argue we are a democracy. Others say a republic. The real answer is that we are a democratic republic. Probably a similar deal.
Why would you not want to own your own stuff though? What is life without private property? How do you know what is yours and if you will keep it? What if you have something and someone takes it? So many things I don't understand about communism.
@@carolynetter8046, according to communist ideology, socialism is a transitional stage from capitalism to communism and therefore, under socialism, elements of both capitalism and communism are present in public life. And yes, in the USSR and in all other left-wing countries there was socialism, not communism. Согласно коммунистической идеологии, социализм - это переходный этап от капитализма к коммунизму и поэтому при социализме в общественной жизни присутствуют элементы как капитализма, так и коммунизма. И да, в СССР и во всех остальных левых странах был социализм, а не коммунизм.
From the beginning of this podcast through the first eight minutes, the oddities of this narrator's speech, tone, pronunciation, and articulation were evident. This fellow was a bad choice to be narrator. The visuals so far are excellent, and the subject matter is important/interesting so I'll continue watching (and wincing).
When Khrurshchev had visited Tito ,forbitten the entrance in the country to Molotov They had warned the soviets This guy NO, so MolotoV was not in the plane
Nokate nmuin lalien Tuan Manshur bin Jazan in mashan soeknain Al-Qur'an bi tabu sholat juhur Nok salat ashar ma in soeknani bi fun Puasa Ramadhan in Nanan bitabu sholat Maghrib Nok salat Isya Ma in soeknani haek Nua Eotkaim bikitab At-Tibyan Fiadabi hamalatil Qur'an Imam Nawawi al-Bantani halaman 47-48. 0:47 . Atuis lek'i Bai Sholeh Nitiono three Days or Serjana Agama Islam Negeri Sunan Gunung Djati Bandung Jawa Barat Indonesia Tahun 1993-1998.Rektor Bapak Frof.Drs.KH.Endang Soetarie Msi.
@@SeattlePioneer And what happened when the "hard line" Communists were defeated? Over 100 million people sank into brutal poverty and millions died. Yeltsin was one of the most corrupt leaders in history, who the West supported even when he shot up his own people with tanks. The "hard line" Communists were the good guys and the world would be better off had they succeeded.
Watching this series 1 to 4 has opened the eyes wide shuted...the bad potrayed comunism by the west, the missconduct of comunism purposes, the cult of Mao and Stalin...was lead international comunism in to fade away
Какая цель этого ролика - осудить коммунистическую идеологию , основанную на справедливости , миролюбии и независимости , или оправдать капиталистическую , основанную на эксплуатации своих и внешних народов , на лжи , манипуляции сознания , кровопролитии народов ради обогащения кучки мерзавцев ? Миру - мир ! Слава социализму , самому справедливому и миролюбивому строю ! Слава СССР - подавшему пример всему Миру справедливого миролюбивого общества ! Слава СССР - спасшему весь Мир от фашизма ! Слава великому Китаю , пошедшему по советскому , по Сталинскому пути ! Слава великому Сталину , великому Ленину ! Позор иудам , предавшим свой народ !
Слава принадлежит советскому солдату, спасшему мир, а НЕ советскому социалистическому государству, которое считало его и всех людей расходным материалом.
Exactly. Not much common sense or concern over why even entire countries would be driven to seek other methods and for the countries that say that kind of change could never happen to them and their system is better they can hide and watch because that kind of change is a slow and sometimes unnoticed process that takes hundreds of years. Socialism with possibly a Democratic base seems to be the best option for everyone and includes free health care and free education and low cost of living for everyone because all of the people decide in the legislation of the money gained from the distribution of manufactured goods and valuable resources. Russia was Socialist Republic USSR for 100 years and longer than anyone else such as Switzerland. But Russia became Republican Capitalist with a Democratic base in 1991 as are the reports and Ukraine that also was Socialist became Communist in 1991 as are the reports. It is clear that greed in an old and outdated Ruling Monarchy Feudal Capitalist system will prevail while those in top positions and or with elite connections profit substantially while the middle class and poor fall further behind with no free health care or free education in sight until the dying off of all of the middle class and poor that are generally not of criminal element or addicts as certain corrupt media portrays them to be. Oddly the media has never shown the many middle class and poor that attend church and know Jesus along with many homeless who not only can recite verses and entire books of the Bible but truly know and love Jesus. They die every day at the hands of corrupt imposters and embezzlement of humanitarian funds.
How is communism still a guiding force in liberal politics, especially in academia? Just listening to politically active younger people is disheartening.
You need to study more. Communism is not liberalism. I think you’re confused because conservative parties use communism threat to scare and confuse people.
It is.. my daughter is in college and that commie fist is the first thing that shows up on her feed. She gets mad over things she will never experience. Yet. She is mad at the world and envy of what others have. She has brown privilege and yet the world is telling her she’s a minority, and she’s poor and at a disadvantage. Stupid commie propaganda to make her mad and hate those that have more.
🤣🤣🤣 It's not. Let people define themselves. You don't ask a Muslim how a Jew lives or meat eater what a vegan eats, but you let conservative media tell you what is influencing liberal academia.
It is a very good idea. Idea only, in practice it has been very bad in various versions and countries. The main problm seems to be the religious light "revolutionary guidance" that makes the sect members ready to sacrifice humans in millions for "the cause" or worse "the leader/party". I think it is prefect for Acdemia. Interesting but no large scale or live experiments please.
The losers didn't deserve to write history because they born to be losers and they write history based on their losers mentality,losers tactic and losers way of life.
Nokate nmuin lalien sahabat Mujahid in soeknani Al-Qur'an bi tabu sholat Maghrib Nok salat Isya Ma in soeknani bi kanan fa'i nakko fun puasa Ramadhan in Nanan. 0:47
I hold two degrees in history and this is an awful film. There is no need to misrepresent the facts to make communism appear to be a failed and brutal economic and political system. Misinformation like this merely prevents people from understanding why.
do you hold two degrees or do you hold communist propaganda firmly lodged in your head? there is no need to distort communism the facts speak for themselves
@@PhillyBatts lol at people who think their history or philosophy degrees are worth anything. Or think its a get out of jail free card of not having to say anything of substance “look I am so smart I have so many degrees so you have to believe me you peasant” just pathetic
The problem with communism is, that they have too many parades. I couldn't cpunt how many parades were held in those countries since the 1st part of this documentary
Во-первых, никакого коммунизма нигде не было, был социализм. Во-вторых, я думаю, что парадов при социализме не больше, чем при капитализме. Просто их сконцентрировали в этом фильме. Например в СССР праздничные демонстрации проходили всего 2 раза в год - на 1 мая и на 7 ноября. Вряд ли это больше, чем в США или в Европе, просто в США и Европе другие парады - парады ЛГБТ-активистов, спортивных фанатов, самодеятельных оркестров, скаутов, полицейских, пожарных, парады с предвыборной агитацией, со всякой рекламой, разные карнавалы, театральные и религиозные шествия...
Mas onleknanet Tan nmuin lalien sahabat nabi Muhammad Saw onlek fun Tuan Ustman bin Affan Nok Tuan Tamiim Addarie Nok Tuan Sa'id bin Jubair sin mashan soeknain Al-Qur'an bi faiyesam nenoes in Nanan. 0:47
Communism is so ideologically perfect that it doesn't really work. Too utopic for the imperfections of man. But I really like this wonderful video series.
Коммунисты пытались вывести нового человека и открыто говорили об этом..Считали что преступность это родимые пятна капитализма и при социализме должна изчезнуть со временем.Об этом было много книг и даже кино снимали..Но человека не переделать,он всегда эгоист,который хочет больше чем другие.
Капитализм создал фашизм и нацизм, борясь против коммунизма. А потом испугался своего порождения и стал вместе с коммунистами бороться против фашизма и нацизма.
As a Vietnamese , i don't consider our war against the French an expansion of communism. It was simply the Vietnamese people's fight for independence for the sake of the nation
I agree the West misunderstands the mainly nationalist motivations of normal Vietnamese in joining the Viet Minh to fight colonialism, but when the organisation promotes communism and silences other voices, like the Sangha or Bao Dai from even having a voice it becomes a concern for many people, not just Westerners, but democrats of all nations, who see the leadership of the Viet Minh as using the ordinary people's legitimate love of nation and desire to fight against colonialism as a means to spread an undemocratic ideology. Regardless, long live independent Vietnam.
Do you try to rewrite your history? Your country could win the Imperialist France and USA by support of the network of USSR, PRC China, Cuba, Prated Laos movement which are Communist countries or leftist army.
yes
It 's pity that you wish to rewrite your Vietnamese History!
@@rilrahoneybee9621Shame on you.
Very interesting.I still remember the military invasion of Czechoslovakia remember standing in the main street of Breclav watching the army rolling past.I was too young to understand as it was drummed into us how great communism is.
Some people even believe that today.
Зато ваша демократия несёт мир во всем мире
@@Викторвиктор-р7ы Democracy doesn't bring peace, individual rights, one's right to life is what brings peace. Democracy is merely the right of a majority to screw over a minority. Idiots can't seem to figure it out. The US is the only country in all of history founded on the principles of one's right to life. Too bad so many couldn't grasp this concept and instead turned in the direction of collectivism, communism, fascism and socialism
@@Викторвиктор-р7ы no no... Putin brings world peace and, above all, prosperity. Look no further than your puppet state economy.
@@Викторвиктор-р7ы We have SEEN the type of peace YOUR side brings in Ukraine.I also witnessed your kind of "Peace "when I saw the killing fields in Cambodia.
This was excellent. I especially appreciated that it showed the aftermath of the North Vietnamese victory in Vietnam, when suddenly their supporters all over the world suddenly went silent when they saw the horrors of what they had been supporting. They didn't have too much to say then.
How have you already watched it?
@@piero17y65 All I know is that I watched it yesterday. I don't know what's going on with this.
@@mandymulwray6789 okay and thanks for replying so quickly 👍
@@piero17y65 maybe she watched the part from 4 days ago and it showed a preview of what's coming on this 1?
I noticed that sometimes I'm notified about a supposed live vid coming up, but when I click to go watch it, it already has a few comments in the comments section. But any other live vid I watch, people can't comment in the comments section and have to wait until it ends or get in the live chat.
Fk knows 🤷🏻♀️lol
If the Vietnamese would be honest looking back at their recent history, they should admit, that the whole fight was for nothing. The Americans were not there to enslave them or to exploit them. They just wanted to stop the spread of communism. And communism they don't even want anymore in Vietnam. So they fought for something, which they themselves abbandoned afterwards within a generation. Four million deaths for nothing.
They could be like South Korea now, if history went otherwise.
"Communism simply falls apart..." - NO ! my poor Editors. . . millions had died for these fateful days, some 10 times the total death of Jews, Americans on the Viet-Nam fields, the Gulag, . . . from Before Christ to the Second World War, combined !
Who put the pressure on minority and poor nations? Of course we all know it was the western imperialists, its even in history books.. Is the world really overpopulated? Do we really have to kill each other for a few ppls gains? Why cant we work togther rather than eliminate one another..
Taiping rebellion
That is Catholicism Communism in Viet Nam and China so take your complaints to Rome.
Krushchev: 'Your grandchildren will live under communism'. The Truth: What a nightmere that would be!!!
Вы плохо себе представляете, что такое коммунизм.
🎉
Thank you for a very good overview of the Cold War and the various phases of Communism in this period. Wonderful to see film of the era.
None of this was Communism, it was state-capitalism trying to transition from a capitalist society into a socialist one and EVENTUALLY a Communist one
It's weird how easily and freely you hear people in Russia describe their love and loyalty towards Lenin and Stalin but the names of Khruschev, Brezhnev, Andropov, Chernenko and Gorbachev are NEVER mentioned with such zeal if at all.
It's not true, they mention gorbi, but everyone hates him. for you, of course, he is a hero who destroyed the "evil empire", but for us he is a traitor who destroyed a great superpower and condemned millions to death and poverty in the nineties
From what I picked up, Khrushchev was a revisionist, Brezhnev comparable to Biden and Yeltsin,
And Gorbachev pretty much betrayed the whole USSR.
The other two I guess reigned too briefly to be compared.
Because they weren't alive when lenin and stalin were in power. To young Russians lenin is mostly just a guy with a lot of statues that they dont really ask about and Stalin isn't talked about all that much. At least that was what I gathered when I lived there. But they do revere strong leaders be it lenin, putin or peter the great. Most people I knew didn't really want to talk about history.
its not weird at all. makes total sense.
@@ZS-rw4qq Hahaha, Brezhnev was comparable to Yeltsin?
You got to be kidding! The only thing those two had in common,
that one was half-dead from old age and the other one (in his later term)
half-dead from alcohol.
Also: Gorbachev didn't betray the USSR, the Communist Party did.
It's very easy to blame one man, but in reality that's almost never the case.
The Italian Communist Party immediately changed its name shortly before the USSR fell, in an attempt to maintain its significant support into the new era. The much diminished French party kept its name, content to coast on nostalgia.
And so now we all live happily... in poverty and in debt
Communism is not dead, it just smells really bad. Excellent film series for its purpose. It was short and to the point, however lacking in scope and context.
How have you already watched it?
God bless America
@Joseph D Atkinson I'll never understand no private property. I guess capitalism is all I've ever known. Call it whatever you want, money, work points, ownership, private property, public property. There has to be some kind if system whereby you know that what was yours when you left will be yours when you return. Why would anyone work at all not to truly have anything they can call their own? I have a 4 yr degree in political science and I still can't wrap my head around it
Communism is death. Death to communism.
@@poutinedream5066 4 yr... Surprisingly, you apparently wasted your time😄Under socialism, private ownership of the means of production is prohibited. All industry and mining is in the hands of the state, not private corporations. Consumption is regulated by state planning, and not by the pursuit of profit and the market. In the USSR, there was personal property and it was easily inherited. Most families had several apartments and houses. How are you going to compete honestly in the "free" market with companies that transfer and increase their capital for tens or even hundreds of years)... "Artel"(Production Cooperative) under socialism, I think it was not a bad decision instead of private business under capitalism. And now enjoy the next global crisis of capitalism, which, perhaps, once again they will try to patch up and prolong its life due to the war😁
Whats the songs name at 39.00 ?
Put another device nearby and use Google speaker button
It will listen and tell you
▶️ 39:00 … ❓
Copacabana - revolution edit
"Bella ciao!" ("Farewell, beauty!") is an Italian folk song, one of the most famous anti-fascist partisan songs in Italy.
The song was sung in partisan detachments operating in several regions of Italy in 1943-1945. The song became widely known in the world after it was brought by the Italian delegation to the 1st International Festival of Youth and Students in Prague in 1947.
"Vella ciao!" long ago became the international song of the struggle for freedom, against oppression.
It is sung in different countries, in different languages.
"Bella ciao!" ("Прощай, красавица!") - народная итальянская песня, одна из самых известных антифашистских партизанских песен Италии.
Песню пели в партизанских отрядах, действовавших в нескольких областях Италии в 1943-1945 годах. Песня стала широко известна в мире после того, как её привезла итальянская делегация на 1 международный фестиваль молодежи и студентов в Праге в 1947 году.
"Веlla ciao!" давно стала международной песней борьбы за свободу, против угнетения.
Её поют в разных странах, на разных языках.
I think there shoudl be more stautes of Gorbachev. he did not fight the change despite sitting on millions off soliders, secret police ect etc.
Off course he dreamed off making Communism humane and work out fine but he did accapt the loss off immense power for also himself rather than use voilence to fight it.
Whould all our contemporary democratic leaders accept that? I hope so!
I agree. He was the only communist leader who can be described as a great man- not so much for he did, but what he didn't do.
Wow what a clever question regarding democrats in UK for sure they resign if they do mistakes, Boris Johnson one of best examples.
@@slabart12 I always watch with pleasure his interviews.
Горбачёв - просто слабовольный и не далёкий человек. Такие люди не должны лезть во власть. Сейчас его ненавидит вся страна и жалеет, что не состоялся суд над ним.
@@slabart12, вы не понимаете, что вы пишете. Его ненавидит вся страна. Все надеялись, что всё-таки состоится суд над ним, но к сожалению он издох безнаказанно, так же, как Ельцын.
Но всё равно, время придёт и этот суд над всеми преступниками, разрушившими государство и повинными в страданиях и смерти тысяч людей на постсоветском пространстве, состоится, пусть даже после их смерти. И в учебниках истории они будут названы, как преступники.
I really enjoyed this
Very much a refreshing history from a different perspective
Tôi còn bận chưa xem, nhưng likes ngay cho tựa đề. Cuối cùng thì, hôm nay tôi thấy hài lòng và thoải mái 🙃🙂. Cảm ơn quý kênh.😅
o/ Who is singing at 48:43?
Immense appreciation and grateful thanks! The ONLY thing you missed was Trotsky's fight AGAINST Stalinism and his creation of the Fourth International; True Socialism.
Trotsky is not real socialism! You are far from dialectical materialism as the methodology of Marxism! Trotsky is a petty-bourgeois socialist, actually a Menshevik. Voicing his theory of Permanent Revolution, Trotsky proceeded from the idealism of consciousness, and not from the real relations that existed in reality. Trotsky hoped for a revolution in the main European countries, England and Germany, but he did not even take into account the fundamental provisions of the unequal development of capitalism and the division of capitalism into colonial and metropolitan, i.e. the disparity of development, and consequently the disparity of social consciousness. The European worker, being relatively prosperous by the standards of other workers of the world due to the fact that he is in the conditions of the metropolis and the capitalist shares with him most of the surplus value, makes the revolution less possible due to less support from the population.
Oh, the battle of piss vs turd
Between 1944 and 1950 over 2.5 million Ukrainians were deported to Siberia under the code 58 and Khrushchev was the person implementing it under the orders of Stalin its rich coming from Khrushchev saying it was wrong.
And quite rightly they were deported.
In western Ukraine, after its liberation from German occupation, thousands of Bandera gangs operated. They committed such atrocities against everyone who was suspected of being loyal to the Soviet regime that their hair stood on end: they tortured and killed in the most brutal ways not only the military and government officials, but also teachers, doctors, and ordinary peasants. Entire families were slaughtered with children.
And it was impossible to stop this bloody bacchanalia for several years - almost until the mid-50s. The war was over, but peaceful life did not come.
Because Bandera was covered by the local population.
The only way to fight the partisan movement is to deprive it of the support of the local population. As long as the population helps the partisans, nothing can be done with them. Therefore, the fascists, fighting the Soviet partisans, carried out acts of retaliation and intimidation of the civilian population - they burned people alive by entire villages, shot the hostages.
And during the Vietnam War, the United States burned Vietnamese villages with napalm, where partisans took refuge.
But the Soviet government acted humanely. No one was burned alive, no hostages were shot.
They simply sent them to other regions of the country - to Siberia, as well as to Kazakhstan and Central Asia.
And there people, if they were not involved, except for aiding bandits, in any real crimes, then they could engage in agricultural activities in the same way as at home, in Ukraine.
And you should not try to surpass Solzhenitsyn with his mythical millions of those who were shot.
Not 2.5 million Ukrainians were deported, but about 200,000. And not from all of Ukraine, but mainly from the western regions.
И совершенно справедливо были депортированы.
На западной Украине, после освобождения её от немецкой оккупации, действовали тысячи бандеровских банд. Они творили такие зверства в отношении всех, кого подозревали в лояльности к советской власти, что волосы дыбом подымаются: истязали и убивали самыми зверскими способами не только военных и представителей власти, но и учителей, врачей, просто крестьян. Вырезали целыми семьями вместе с детьми.
И остановить эту кровавую вакханалию было невозможно на протяжении нескольких лет - почти до середины 50-х годов. Война кончилась, а мирная жизнь никак не наступала.
Потому что бандеровцев покрывало местное население.
Единственный способ борьбы с партизанским движением - это лишение его поддержки местного населения. Пока население помогает партизанам ничего с ними не сделаешь. Поэтому фашисты, борясь с советскими партизанами, проводили акции возмездия и устрашения мирного населения - сжигали людей заживо целыми деревнями, растреливали заложников.
А США во время войны во Вьетнаме сжигали напалмом вьетнамские деревни, где укрывались партизаны.
А вот советская власть поступила гуманно. Заживо никого не сжигали, заложников не расстреливали.
Просто высылали в другие районы страны - в Сибирь, а так же в Казахстан и Среднюю Азию.
И там люди, если они не были замешаны, кроме пособничества бандитам, ни в каких реальных преступлениях, то они могли заниматься сельхоздеятельностью так же, как у себя дома, на Украине.
И не стоит пытаться переплюнуть Солженицына с его мифическими миллионами расстрелянных.
Не 2,5 миллиона украинцев было выслано, а около 200 000. И не со всей Украины, а в основном именно из западных областей.
1920- 1930.Красный террор. Репресии. Гулаг. Ссылки. Растрелы. Голодомор. Геноцид украинского народа. Сталиным. Большевиками. Комунистами.Сегодня расея уничтожает Украину как государство. Убивает детей, народ Украины. Геноцид.Слава Украине. Слава героям. Живе Украина. С ЕС. И НАТО. ✊🇺🇦✌️🌅
Khrushchev had a choice? While Stalin was still alive? Easy for you to say.
Bullshit
Так, Хрущов ще й займався програмою ковгоспів в Україні, яка «провалювалася» бо занадто високі були очікування та норми. А ми всі знаємо що це означає. На його руках достатньо крові та страждань українців, він продукт свого часу…
Can anyone tell me the name of the Italian woman speaking at the very end?
Poor for the Imperialism trying to negate all achievements of Socialist nations - who blocked American and the Western Colonialist expanding. In fact, Americans was defeated by us - Vietnam, and they did all things to prevent us being friends with many countries in the world after war, they did all things to determine that we were the danger of the world, and communism need to be deleted. Many people had died under the hands of Cololialism and Imperialism, included my grandfather and my uncles. They brought war to us, to everywhere they suppose that there is no democracy and human rights, so ? Poverty, inconsistency, etc are continuing where they came, come and are going to come. We trying to make world become better, want to be friends with all people. We overcame many years of war, know the true worth of freedom and peace, so recognizing the truth is very important, not the documetary like this. See type of "democracy and freedom" American brought to Iraq, Lybia, Syria ???
Salutes to you, your ancestors and 🇻🇳 . Ofcs, we could add European and American imperialism in whole of Africa!
great videos but the AI voice kinda kills it
@41:00 features the winner of the Worst Revolutionary Combover of the Decade award.
Censura da plataforma. Ideologia disfarçada. Abraço 🇧🇷
That took place in 1968. I was working towards my Master's degree in France.
Wow🎉you amazing
Did not hear a thing about Allende and Chile?
What did you want to hear?
Has allende survive the coup.chile could end up like cuba or venezuela.
@@nelsonbarrios1718 ⁰
diganme por favor porque no viene subtitulada en español gracias
pues aprende ingles hombre….
Anyone know what is the song going on at 47:05?
Kruschev really tried. For his efforts he was betrayed by his own party
He was not cruel enough, true commie leader cant take just one million heads
Наоборот, не партия предала Хрущёва, а он предал и обманул партию.
The same with Gorbachev. Stalinist's would disagree, but Stalinist's aren't true Communists. So said Lenin and Trotsky.
He was a boob with plenty of blood on his hands. He went along with the insane purges and asked if he could exceed the quotas
Yes, Khruschov is the good guy...
Until you try to find out what was he doing in Stalin's era
He's another blood-stained red criminal.
Maybe not a real maniac unlike his predecessors. The most humanistic terrorist so to say
Why were some of pictures blurred out
Censura desta plataforma, que usa de ideologia disfarçada. O comunismo/socialismo não morreu, como o vídeo tenta levar a pensar, mas está de roupagem nova.🇧🇷
Beware of words ending in ISM. Given time, they usually all turn out about the same.
Communism/socialism
Fascism/ national socialism
Conservativism
Imperialism
Collectivism
Republicanism
What is the intro song ?
Didn’t end in 1993. It started its migration to the West.
And it won’t stop until we’ve mopped the map with those capitalist villains!
@@borninvincible Most of you will grow up by the time that happens.
That’s cute. Not as cute as it will be when y’all are all crying in the guillotine line 🤡
It migrated to the West long before then. FDRs Administration was full of Communist sympathizers. Alger Hiss, for one.
The anti war movements of the sixties were fermented by the KGB, as was the Liberation Theology crap in Latin America.
BLM admits to being Marxists.
@@penguinsfan251 your propaganda has no power here
Ничего, пролетарская революция неизбежна. Опыт был, предательство было. Главное учитывать прошлый опыт
The generated voice really struggling with pronunciation in this one. Good video though.
13:32 Best part. ❤
Although Communism would always fail in practice, as an ideology it will never die, because it is based on envy, which is eternal. There will always be people who will fall for the fairy tale that they can get something for nothing.
We are witnessing right now,biden presidency or in san francisco.progressive politic look so beautiful in theory,but in practice it was a disaster.
stupid nothing is given to anyone for free. just communism is when everyone according to their abilities, and not out of cunning greed
@@FtrollThe full mantra is "From everyone according to his abilities,. to each according to his needs." And the stupid one is you, if you really believe that this can work in practice. In reality, greed and laziness prevails - and skyrockets. I have witnessed this first-hand as I lived the first half of my life under communism. You have no idea what you are talking about.
@@befeleme nothing is perfect, but it works better in communism than in capitalism. Because you still need to be able to sell yourself and no matter how good you are.
@@Ftroll "It works better in communism"??? What???? How can you possibly say something so ignorant is beyond me. Capitalism has lifted more people out of poverty than any other system. In contrast, wherever communism tread, it left poverty and bloodshed in its wake. I could excuse your starry eyed idealism because you are obviously still young, but I can't excuse your intellectual laziness and ignorance of history. You have fallen for a fairy tale. And you probably think that you could do "better communism" than all those who tried before. That's sheer narcissism. You could not do anything better, because the communist theory is unworkable in practice, and you are not as amazing and incorruptible as you think - and even if you were, you'd be stabbed in the back by your "better selling" comrades sooner than you could say "Das Kapital".
"The truth has no defence against a fool determined to believe a lie." - Mark Twain
Define irony. The Right rules again with no opposition whatsoever.
Why does the narrator pronounce “Krushchev” as “Kru-chev”, (no ‘s’ or ‘sh’ sound at the end of the first syllable)?
Thats not the only word he can't pronounce
You have a French narrator speaking English as a second language. He also says "Hun-Gary" instead of Hungary.
I'm pretty sure it's a computer generated voice (text-to-speak).
I doubt anyone can be so fluent in English most of the time and
also f*ck up very basic words like that.
35 Vietnam fought France for independence. France walked away when communism stepped in. The Us stepped in to stop Communism.
Long live the Czech Republic and freedom
Again, the footage on these is unreal.
Exactly. How can this be Europe? Where are all the arabs and somalis?
@@noname-wv3ve lul
Wao sangat menegangkan teringat waktu kejadian 7 jendral Indonesia di lubang buaya di Indonesia yg melibatkan banyak korban pembantaian pada waktu itu.sangat tragis dan sampai sekarang masih berbekas trauma kawan kawan yg terlibat orangtuanya pada masa itu👍
Socialism with possibly a Democratic or Republican base is the answer. Several countries have this and it is worth having.
Love your channel I melt into another world Spaseaba. Much love from Russia
God bless Russia!
The expression is lease on life (not of). Is the narrator attempting to say gorilla warfare (around the 3 minute mark)? Around time point 7:30, the narrator mispronounced the word contents. He seems to have a variety of pronunciations of Krushchev. Really bad narrator. Wonderful film/visuals however. Fascinating topic.
Good historical documentary
According to this documentary, everything under the soviet era was a dark reality and everything under the capitalist state is heavenly glory!
And it's not true?
Some things are good in comunism but as a human not having option only following an eternal leader and oveiyng to him i rather die.Capitalism is good but i dont like too much tolerance in capitalism, sometimes i see it like a crazy chaos.
@@TheRomanianWolf, а правда?
Странно, что в капстранах высокий уровень жизни. И соцзащита, с вашей.не сравнить. У вас её просто нет. То что есть, как и биржа труда, конституция, право, закон... Филькина грамота. Одно, что цветёт и пахнет.... Злоба, ненависть, корупция, нищета, насилие, разруха, безработица, смертность.,ложь,шантаж. Агресия.Фашизм.Слава Украине. Слава героям .✊🇺🇦✌️🌅
@@TheRomanianWolf certainly not !
This history of the useful idiots was mainly good--forgetting, however, that Khrushchev was a long-time murderer himself.
O comunismo/socialismo não findou; apenas trocou de roupa. 🇧🇷
中国共产党是目前全世界的共产主义输血者
Hitler was right about one issue: that the WWII-time alliance between the West and the Soviet Union will not stand the test of time.
That wasn’t rEaL cOmMuNiSm™️ though!
Let’s just try it one more time! 🙃
bravo
no thank you
You really all in on this huh? Welp- everybody needs a passion I suppose. I take a more serious approach more seriously, but whatever
Please try on paper, only, this time.
@@poutinedream5066 Satire is a _very_ effective weapon against ideological tyranny. It's every bit as valid as "taking things seriously" - and you don't have to pick between one or the other. An effective satirist has _very seriously_ studied the issue they're making fun of.
So, Mr. Serious - what exactly have you done? Where's all your super serious work published? Where can I watch your documentaries and read your essays?
Very, very good work. Today, in America we face cultural Marxism. The young are being mistaught. They don’t listen and seek out knowledge to verify what they are being taught in government schools. They will have to learn from their own mistakes. I find that sad.
Тепер ждёт страна после ссср .,апокалипсиуса и вайна ,потом бкдет если продолжит ,тогда взрыв землом щару все болще существу не будет, значит народ тупве стали.
Make housing affordable, and maybe we'll listen to guys like you. Until then keep spewing your neo nazi "cultural marxism" talking point 😂 I'm sure it'll come through some day...
It's all about power witch is very important for the time. Everyone was scared of atomic weapons would show to everyone that it's not going to be nothing like any war before. I just hope the leadership of certain countries have brain's enough to see that nobody will win. 🇩🇪✌️
34:13 Should be vietnam instead of nepal.
Up with Ho Chi Min. Que Viva Ho chi Min. Viva Ho Chi Min.ViveHo Chi Min.
The David who crushed the Imperial Amerikan Golia.
Is the narration a computerized voice? The crazy pronunciation of Kruschev (Kruchev) might be a give-away.
Many words were oddly mispronounced in this video
A very interesting documentary of communism
Very interesting documentary για να θυμούνται οι παλιοί και να μαθενουν οι νεώτεροι.
The spread of communism reminds me a lot of the genestealer cult in warhammer 40k.
Essentially a very intelligent alien lands on a human world and charms a few humans through mind control to form a cult. The cult lives underground and breeds until it can start spreading the message above ground too, infiltrating society. The mind control makes the initial victims see the gross alien as a holy savior, a god on earth. All their words are like the divine words of god himself. When the cult reaches critical mass, the original infiltrator alien calls the main hive to invade the human planet. The cult sees the invaders as their gods salvation and actually fight the humans. Right until the original alien breaks his hivemind control, causing the cult to finally see the invaders for what they are. Then the aliens consume the cult for their biomass.
I always found it funny how this was so heavily inspired by the USSR. They indoctrinated intellectuals of a foreign nation, sent them back to form a communist party. The party collected more and more members in the shadows, infiltrating aspects of society. Right until they had enough believers to invite the USSR to invade and "liberate" the nation. And after the invasion was over, most of the nation would see the true colors of the USSR as they abused the satellite state for their workforce and natural resources.
Damn. That's brilliant
Это ложь. У СССР не было государств-сателлитов и СССР не злоупотреблял никем ради каких-то ресурсов. Наоборот, СССР во все государства, с которыми сотрудничал, вкладывал свои ресурсы и очень часто безвозмездно, не получая в ответ никакой материальной выгоды.
@@Дмитрий_Тихомиров А в Афганистане что вы потеряли , и что вы хотели там внедрить .
@@dhsjfjdkek5102 A revolution against the regime of landlords and capitalist was developing the US was also innerving providing help to those who would become the Islamic terrorists.
i was born in USSR in 1968 best country so far I lived
Germany, Canada, Estonia
Canada is far from free we have castors son ruling us, turning us in chinadistan
Official reports and documentaries say that Russia as in USSR was Socialist for 100 years and not Communist. Do you know the answer if this information is true.
@@carolynetter8046 I think the terminology can just get a bit muddled. Like the USA. Some argue we are a democracy. Others say a republic. The real answer is that we are a democratic republic. Probably a similar deal.
Why would you not want to own your own stuff though? What is life without private property? How do you know what is yours and if you will keep it? What if you have something and someone takes it? So many things I don't understand about communism.
@@carolynetter8046, according to communist ideology, socialism is a transitional stage from capitalism to communism and therefore, under socialism, elements of both capitalism and communism are present in public life.
And yes, in the USSR and in all other left-wing countries there was socialism, not communism.
Согласно коммунистической идеологии, социализм - это переходный этап от капитализма к коммунизму и поэтому при социализме в общественной жизни присутствуют элементы как капитализма, так и коммунизма.
И да, в СССР и во всех остальных левых странах был социализм, а не коммунизм.
From the beginning of this podcast through the first eight minutes, the oddities of this narrator's speech, tone, pronunciation, and articulation were evident. This fellow was a bad choice to be narrator. The visuals so far are excellent, and the subject matter is important/interesting so I'll continue watching (and wincing).
Shut up, it's great!
For a non-native English speaker, he does quite a good job.
@Brian Salomon Don't be negative by demanding not to be negative. 😜
It's not a podcast, it's a documentary from the 90s.
独裁国家は恐ろしい❤人民が可哀想過ぎます❤
Коммунизм светлое будущее человечества.
When Khrurshchev had visited Tito ,forbitten the entrance in the country to Molotov
They had warned the soviets This guy NO, so MolotoV was not in the plane
Qua hay, xin phụ đề tiếng Việt vì tôi học kém lắm
Коммунизм умер, а тоталитаризм в России остался.
Tại sao không nói sự kiện này bằng tiếng việt Nam
人民が可哀想過ぎます❤人民の為の政治家を期待しております❤
Nokate nmuin lalien Tuan Manshur bin Jazan in mashan soeknain Al-Qur'an bi tabu sholat juhur Nok salat ashar ma in soeknani bi fun Puasa Ramadhan in Nanan bitabu sholat Maghrib Nok salat Isya Ma in soeknani haek Nua Eotkaim bikitab At-Tibyan Fiadabi hamalatil Qur'an Imam Nawawi al-Bantani halaman 47-48. 0:47 . Atuis lek'i Bai Sholeh Nitiono three Days or Serjana Agama Islam Negeri Sunan Gunung Djati Bandung Jawa Barat Indonesia Tahun 1993-1998.Rektor Bapak Frof.Drs.KH.Endang Soetarie Msi.
When this was happening I thought Gorbachev was a senior citizen. Now he looks like someone who I'd go to dinner with 🤣
It's call aging my friend.. same thing happened to me.
@@jordanmarsh4693
Heh, heh! "Those were the days, my friend, we thought they'd never end...."
th-cam.com/video/y3KEhWTnWvE/w-d-xo.html
@@SeattlePioneer And what happened when the "hard line" Communists were defeated? Over 100 million people sank into brutal poverty and millions died. Yeltsin was one of the most corrupt leaders in history, who the West supported even when he shot up his own people with tanks. The "hard line" Communists were the good guys and the world would be better off had they succeeded.
How have some already watched it?
No Tiananmen Square 1989?
That never happened prole!
-ccp
Are you out of your mind? Your mother
Brainwashed bitch.
Watching this series 1 to 4 has opened the eyes wide shuted...the bad potrayed comunism by the west, the missconduct of comunism purposes, the cult of Mao and Stalin...was lead international comunism in to fade away
they did everything right in their time, it is foolish to talk about that time with pink eyes today. no subjunctive
Excellent series
Какая цель этого ролика - осудить коммунистическую идеологию , основанную на справедливости , миролюбии и независимости , или оправдать капиталистическую , основанную на эксплуатации своих и внешних народов , на лжи , манипуляции сознания , кровопролитии народов ради обогащения кучки мерзавцев ? Миру - мир ! Слава социализму , самому справедливому и миролюбивому строю ! Слава СССР - подавшему пример всему Миру справедливого миролюбивого общества ! Слава СССР - спасшему весь Мир от фашизма ! Слава великому Китаю , пошедшему по советскому , по Сталинскому пути ! Слава великому Сталину , великому Ленину ! Позор иудам , предавшим свой народ !
Слава принадлежит советскому солдату, спасшему мир, а НЕ советскому социалистическому государству, которое считало его и всех людей расходным материалом.
Poorly edited with historical background info lacking. Alot of gaps and skipping over events.
"Censoring History" BEST DOCUMENTARY
Love the comment section in this series, full of biased people that try to justify they're intellectual demise
Exactly. Not much common sense or concern over why even entire countries would be driven to seek other methods and for the countries that say that kind of change could never happen to them and their system is better they can hide and watch because that kind of change is a slow and sometimes unnoticed process that takes hundreds of years. Socialism with possibly a Democratic base seems to be the best option for everyone and includes free health care and free education and low cost of living for everyone because all of the people decide in the legislation of the money gained from the distribution of manufactured goods and valuable resources. Russia was Socialist Republic USSR for 100 years and longer than anyone else such as Switzerland. But Russia became Republican Capitalist with a Democratic base in 1991 as are the reports and Ukraine that also was Socialist became Communist in 1991 as are the reports. It is clear that greed in an old and outdated Ruling Monarchy Feudal Capitalist system will prevail while those in top positions and or with elite connections profit substantially while the middle class and poor fall further behind with no free health care or free education in sight until the dying off of all of the middle class and poor that are generally not of criminal element or addicts as certain corrupt media portrays them to be. Oddly the media has never shown the many middle class and poor that attend church and know Jesus along with many homeless who not only can recite verses and entire books of the Bible but truly know and love Jesus. They die every day at the hands of corrupt imposters and embezzlement of humanitarian funds.
Oh what would we do without your moral and intellectual superiority??
@@chrisconley8583 You feel inferior ?
How is communism still a guiding force in liberal politics, especially in academia? Just listening to politically active younger people is disheartening.
You have no idea what you're talking about.
You need to study more. Communism is not liberalism. I think you’re confused because conservative parties use communism threat to scare and confuse people.
It is.. my daughter is in college and that commie fist is the first thing that shows up on her feed. She gets mad over things she will never experience. Yet. She is mad at the world and envy of what others have. She has brown privilege and yet the world is telling her she’s a minority, and she’s poor and at a disadvantage. Stupid commie propaganda to make her mad and hate those that have more.
🤣🤣🤣 It's not. Let people define themselves. You don't ask a Muslim how a Jew lives or meat eater what a vegan eats, but you let conservative media tell you what is influencing liberal academia.
It is a very good idea. Idea only, in practice it has been very bad in various versions and countries.
The main problm seems to be the religious light "revolutionary guidance" that makes the sect members ready to sacrifice humans in millions for "the cause" or worse "the leader/party". I think it is prefect for Acdemia. Interesting but no large scale or live experiments please.
The new world of mankind ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Communism 💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪
Never forget that history is written by the victors, not the losers….
Always!
The losers didn't deserve to write history because they born to be losers and they write history based on their losers mentality,losers tactic and losers way of life.
Free humanity.
Nokate nmuin lalien sahabat Mujahid in soeknani Al-Qur'an bi tabu sholat Maghrib Nok salat Isya Ma in soeknani bi kanan fa'i nakko fun puasa Ramadhan in Nanan. 0:47
I hold two degrees in history and this is an awful film. There is no need to misrepresent the facts to make communism appear to be a failed and brutal economic and political system. Misinformation like this merely prevents people from understanding why.
Ask for a refund. Your degrees are worthless.
do you hold two degrees or do you hold communist propaganda firmly lodged in your head? there is no need to distort communism the facts speak for themselves
I hold three masters degrees in history as well as one in philosophy. This video went really light.
@@PhillyBatts lol at people who think their history or philosophy degrees are worth anything. Or think its a get out of jail free card of not having to say anything of substance “look I am so smart I have so many degrees so you have to believe me you peasant” just pathetic
@@bullpup1337 I don't have to say anything of substance either way... It's a youtube comment section...calm down little man.
نريد ترجمة عربية
Nokate sekau eslek in soeknain Al-Qur'an ma in soeknani bi kanan fa'i nalali haek mese aik haek Nua. 0:47
The problem with communism is, that they have too many parades. I couldn't cpunt how many parades were held in those countries since the 1st part of this documentary
When reality doesn't match the propaganda, parades are needed for re-indoctrination.
Во-первых, никакого коммунизма нигде не было, был социализм.
Во-вторых, я думаю, что парадов при социализме не больше, чем при капитализме. Просто их сконцентрировали в этом фильме.
Например в СССР праздничные демонстрации проходили всего 2 раза в год - на 1 мая и на 7 ноября.
Вряд ли это больше, чем в США или в Европе, просто в США и Европе другие парады - парады ЛГБТ-активистов, спортивных фанатов, самодеятельных оркестров, скаутов, полицейских, пожарных, парады с предвыборной агитацией, со всякой рекламой, разные карнавалы, театральные и религиозные шествия...
7:58 interesting footage
Mas onleknanet Tan nmuin lalien sahabat nabi Muhammad Saw onlek fun Tuan Ustman bin Affan Nok Tuan Tamiim Addarie Nok Tuan Sa'id bin Jubair sin mashan soeknain Al-Qur'an bi faiyesam nenoes in Nanan. 0:47
Communism is so ideologically perfect that it doesn't really work. Too utopic for the imperfections of man. But I really like this wonderful video series.
Коммунисты пытались вывести нового человека и открыто говорили об этом..Считали что преступность это родимые пятна капитализма и при социализме должна изчезнуть со временем.Об этом было много книг и даже кино снимали..Но человека не переделать,он всегда эгоист,который хочет больше чем другие.
A very good brief documentary but I am more interested in whether have we found out the vaccine for this virus!?
yeah its called education
Mas onleknanet Tan nmuin lalien sahabat nabi Muhammad Saw onlek fun Tuan Ustman bin Affan Nok Tuan Tamiim Addarie Nokate Tuan 0:47
Gorbachev wasn't a bad person, did he go too fast with his ideas?
İt was an exellent dream but they made it mess...
Over and over again in deiffrent countries. Some dreams are best as inspiration or dreams only...
Ummm. Promise heaven and deliver hell on earth.
मुने निस्चित रुपमा हाम्रा पुर्चन्दे काका को पारिवारिक क्रान्ति को बारेमा नि लास्त तिर राख्नुपर्ने भन्ने हाम्रो बेल्कुल माग हो.
人民が可哀想過ぎます❤
this one is great to watch after the stalin documentary with the ai voice, so good.
Mao fought back US, UN in korea war after fighting off nationalist in China
Cuba's song was plagiarized by Bollywood!!
"Main hoon jhum jhum jhum jhum jhumroo". Sung by Kishor Kumar 😂😂😂😂
Fin de Communismo, begining of the new Faschismo............NORMAL
I still remember going into the hole twice.
Di Indonesia Partai Komunis Indonesia (PKI) sempat memberontak pada 1948 di Madiun serta gegernya G30S/PKI pada 1965 di Jakarta
No.
USA had a new enemy in USSR.
And USSR had a new enemy in Nazis.
Капитализм создал фашизм и нацизм, борясь против коммунизма. А потом испугался своего порождения и стал вместе с коммунистами бороться против фашизма и нацизма.