"It is good and noble and courageous to shoot a native American in the face with a gun when they're coming at you with a bone knife for raping their daughter and stealing their home." - Walsh
@@basedtruthpiller7140 My conscience it clear. Can you say the same after using a mass shooting and the death of innocent children to push more hatred and misinformation?
And what is the non-idea thing that was so great? Slavery? Theft? Genocide? The only small good thing that might have happened through colonization is the spread of enlightenment ideals like humanitarianism and rule of law, (ideals the colonizers WILDLY fell short of except occasionally when dealing with each other).
Probably because he has a team behind him that will protect him. I'm sure if someone worked in government or many other businesses saying these things would get them fired.
All part of the gift. Just like how people selling time-shares are like "now I shouldn't be telling you this... But there's a great deal on this villa in Florida"
Colonization can have benefits. It helped modernize India legally, technologically, materially and politically. It can also be negative like what happened to Native Americans. Overall though, Walsh is right. The creation of America had a positive impact on the world if you look at what it was like before its formation. It's founding helps the western world transition into more peaceful era.
I'm so tired of them saying, "You're not allowed to to say this and you're not allowed to say that." You can say whatever the hell you want and enlightened people can call you on it.
What they mean is back in the day they were allowed to say racist, sexist, homophobic, transphobic, etc things without blowback. Now they can still say all of that but if they do they will be called out.
“Called out” means being isolated from society and being fired from your job and being blacklisted from others life without money in capitalist society is a death sentence.
@Clark Kent potentially. Not by definition. And if you had an employee who you found out is a neo nazi and us openly and brazenly posting stuff. Would you still employ that guy? Even after the public starts complaining?
Him: " colonialism by challenging traditional values and spreading foreign ideas is bad" also him: "colonialism, in which Europeans challenged the traditional values of the natives and spread their religious and secular ideologies, is good" Who would have thought he could spread transphobia, homophobia, and praise colonialism, in one soundbite?
*Martian:* So when we come and claim and colonise your planet, you're going to celebrate us as heroes, right? *Matt Walsh:* No because you're going to kill us all and erase all traces of our civilisation. *Martian:* By Jove, one of the primitives is learning!
Matt Walsh: But feel free to colonise and exterminate those trans and gays. Oh and uppity women who talk back too much and want bodily autonomy. Martian: That’s… that’s not how it works. Matt Walsh: Why not? Martian: Because you don’t get to tell the colonisers what to do. Also have you learned nothing from history? Matt Walsh: I’ve learned no group has been more oppressed than the straight white Christian male. Martian: Our records show that has never been true. Martian #2: Hearing this guy talk makes me want to make it true though.
I’d say Martians colonizing liberals is ok as judgment and not ok against conservatives because we have better values. And if the martians are conservative then yes colonizing and changing liberals would be a HEROIC thing for the world. You see….you can’t actually show any logical holes because the FACT is native Americans were savage barbaric, warring tribes with zero unity among them for centuries prior to the settlers. Colonizing winded up uniting the land under SUPERIOR morals. And the same could be said if you liberals all lived in one land grooming children, banning free speech….yup that’s when colonization of your land by a group with better values than you would be a positive good in the world. Anyway…LOVE noticing your ungrateful ilk (since you’re living with the fruits of this colonization you rage about) both in the video and comments going crazy over Walsh daring to state the obvious fact that there are always objective gradations to even colonization’s good or evil in the world.
@@davidjuliesmiththomas7983 How? He displays a complete lack of either. He's nuts, and you'd have to be nuts to hold the positions he does. There is no rational justification for it.
@Anthropomorphic Trilobite As soon as you replied, "What victories? What culture?" I new you were looking for a gotcha, or arguing for the sake of arguing. But not just you, or me, most Westerners play gotcha because it makes them feel morally superior and boosts their frail egos.
Sailing across a ocean to the unknown compared to hitching rides and walking to a already built country and sucking the government dry is the same to you in guess
@Aliam jon So you're telling me that colonizers didn't suck the countries they encountered completly dry? Do I have to remind you of slave trade? Believe what you want about illegal immigrants but they at least participate in local economy. They bring labour and pay taxes. When Europeans arrived to the Americas they only cared about stealing land and destroing local goverments
@@aliamjon4423 The way the Europeans treated the native Americans was the same as the way the immigrants from the south are treating Americans now, for you, I guess.
His obsession with trans people is downright twisted and psychotic, there is not one issue I spend that many hours of the day spending my energy hating
Colonial genocide would be good and heroic if the context was that Matt Walsh's home was colonized and only Matt Walsh was genocided. Basically something terrible can be a net positive if it only happens to Matt Walsh.
The United Nations has just come up with a new term but this time they say that it is a net neutral idea at best. It’s called *looks down at paper* Walshicide
There’s no way he’s claiming ideological colonialism is categorically bad; it’s just a double standard of “good when my faction does it, bad when my opponents do it.”
Whoa, you've abstracted that idea way too far for this guy. These people live in a world of absolute morality. Matt clearly only understands things on a "good people" vs "bad people" level
I agree with basically everything, except... For the very last comment by Emma; "He's sick in the head." No. He is not. Matt Walsh (or any other massive biggot on the right) is not mentally ill, he's perfectly sane, bigoted and hateful man. Being hateful is not a mental illness. Spreading hate and bigotry is not "crazy." It's evil. It's fascistic. Equating evil actions to being mentally ill is part of how fascism downplays the danger they pose, but also subtly redirect fear and hate towards the mentally ill and disabled. So please. Stop saying that they're "sick and crazy" when you mean "evil."
This is on the same spectrum of trying to ban CRT teaching in higher education. They want to go from denying and hiding from it to being openly proud of it.
Matt Walsh is pointing out why he should be respected because someone 500 years ago made him "top dog" while not being able to maintain that "top dog" position.
He needs to read what the Statue of Liberty has under her skirt. She doesn't want to be like those pesky judgemental Brits she wants everyone to share the US bounty.
@Aliam jon I think you missed the point--purging fascism would be a fairly comparable in impact from a eugenicist's perspective. The reason is that most people have decided that ascribing a base level of value to human life is inherently valuable to a functional society.
He's already explicitly stated that the "Great Replacement" is "just a fact." He said that after the Buffalo shooting when Cucker Tarlson was getting a lot of (well-deserved) criticism for inspiring that shooting, since Cucker always spews that nonsense on his show.
I'm almost positive Native Americans were not running around quoting Bible verses, but colonization was not about culture, they were just trying to convince them they would be better off living on small patches of land and having nothing to call theirs
The natives did not have to take this crap, they could have simply repelled the invaders. Oh wait, their societies were to primitive to mount a viable defence. If the whites tried it today, it would be different wouldn't it?
Most early colonizers had no problem killing Native Christians anyway. A prime example is the Gnadenhutten Massacre of 1782. Absolutely horrific, Nazi-level shit.
Our understanding of colonization must begin from this place: Indigenous peoples on Turtle Island (North America) have long histories of rich cultural and spiritual traditions. In turn, communities have always had their own forms of justice, conflict resolution, decision-making, and caring for the vulnerable that upheld their Nation’s values. Once Western settlements began, the influences of colonization displaced peoples from their lands. Settler governments took control of Indigenous ways of life and forced assimilation through generations of residential schooling and child welfare practices that among many things, fractured families and communities. Through colonization, imposed modes of education, religion, labor, food, and medicine, governance, and justice began a cycle of social, physical, and spiritual destruction. Colonization and the intergenerational effects of this violence upon culture, community, spirit, and body is anticipated to last generations. Additionally, Indigenous peoples are embattled with continued racism and systemic oppression. As a result, poverty, poor health, substance abuse, and learned violence are realities amongst many Indigenous people.
As an Irish guy, it amazes me that Irish Americans can be so pro colonialism. Like, do they not realize how many of their ancestors died due to British colonialism?
Yeah it’s weird how some are completely ignorant of Irish history, probably because we don’t learn much of it in schools. I’m an American of Irish descent who likes to read about Irish history (particularly focusing on the War of Independence period) and it’s even frustrating to me how other Irish Americans don’t see the parallels between the colonization of Ireland and that of indigenous peoples in America. Granted there are liberal and leftist IAs, and plenty in MA still vote Democrat or for left leaning candidates, but they aren’t as loud or attention hogging as Matt Walsh and the other MAGA chuds.
Note that as Matt says colonization was good and Sam says the other terrible things that were considered ok by the colonizers during that period, all Sam's examples are things Matt supports.
Matt Walsh is the worst kind of apologist. If he were a true Christian he would know that forgiveness won’t come until we acknowledge the wrongs we have committed in the past and do our best to make those wrongs right.
Actually Walsh is totally wrong about colonization and conquest of the Americas being uncontroversial until THE 2020 LEFT CAME ALONG: there was even a guy in the 1500s who wrote a book condemning what the Spanish were doing to Native people and there have been people pushing against these crimes the whole way
I like to point out the GI Bill. Systemic racism is impossible to argue against with that example. My parents generation benefited from it, except... Keep up the great work!
Oh yes. I remember watching Westerns in the 60s. One of the more common phrases was, "The only good Indian is a dead Indian". Folks in the past weren't inclusive, to say the least. That doesn't mean we should be ashamed of the past, but it damn sure means that we shouldn't hold up the past as the ideal.
I mean we should be ashamed of the past and then repatriate and look after the colonized folks . Just remember Europe's population would more than double or triple without genocidal colonization of 3 other continents
Exactly. How come these so called "smart" people always look at the end product, but never the production of the product. Africa wasn't always like that.
Didn't the Moors colonize Spain much as the Spanish would later colonize the Americas? And wasn't their culture more "advanced" than the one they colonized? Would Matt Walsh then praise the Moors as good and righteous?
Of course not colonialism is only good when it's white and christian, which is ironic since fucking italians and spaniards colonized the americas first and neither one of those fuckers are white, and catholics arent even considered real christians by most other denominations
Don't forget the Ottoman Empire modern day Turkey was one of the great countries or Empires at the time. The Ottoman Empire conquered Greece Bulgaria Romania Hungary Serbia Albania Armenia Palestine Syria Lebanon Jordan and Egypt. And Constantinople now modern day Istanbul. So I guess Islamic Muslim countries where better cvilizations than Western cvilization. Plus as you pointed out the Islamic Empire conquered Spain. So Muslim countries where better and brought benefits to Western countries it conquered
Perfect. Your choice of words and your wonderful tone cut open and expose his purile and dangerous version of history. Here in Australia, we too are having trouble coming to terms with our own colonial past, and we too have to endure guys like him who seek to justify, indeed warp, the telling of the past in deceptive ways. He seems so desperate to share "their" version of white-washed history. Complete dismissal of the actions of their forefathers, so as not to feel uncomfortable or God forgive, share in any feelings of collective guilt over past actions and their present consequences. Actions which have brought about the foundations upon which they now enjoy quite comfortable lives. Here in Australia we call people like him a "dickhead". Do join us. Thankyou.
White Australians are even more lucky . You guys became a majority on a continent opposite side of europe and bordering indian ocean . Indians and other Asians didn't colonize it and your top two exports are coal and iron ore
Someone needs to "colonize" Matt Walsh's house and force him on his own personal Trail of Tears journey. Then we will celebrate the people who now live in his house as being "Good and Heroic".
@@fajarfarrel932 Then they're all moral weaklings. Not because they're conservative, but because they're easily duped enough to listen to the self-proclaimed "theocratic fascist."
everything this Walsh dude is saying makes total sense if he's talking about the people who conquered North America 10 000 years ago or however long ago it was. yeah they were brave and heroic, actual literal trailblazers. and they did it without any modern technology. if he's talking about the European invaders though... then he sounds like a vile monster.
I’m sure when Walsh watched Independence Day he was angry that the alien colonizers were thwarted by the primitive humans and their backward technology. And seriously, I’d score points for Walsh if he was bold enough to openly justify the slaughter of Native Americans instead of hiding behind euphemisms while pretending to be brave.
So we're supposed to celebrate the colonizers of the past today but we're not supposed to even talk about how those that were colonized are still affected today.
What about the fact that in North America, a lot of times it was the natives who started hostilities? All the way back to the Pilgrims, they just wanted to live in peace and worked with the natives until they decided to attack them unprovoked, forcing the Pilgrims to defend themselves. The same happened with the Jamestown Colony, and then in later centuries where the United States had to engage in wars against the Cherokee, Shawnee, Creek, Lakota, Comanche and other native tribes, who instigated these conflicts and more.
@@barbiquearea What does unprovoked mean in this context when we're talking about the native Americans in the past? Europeans also attacked natives unprovoked, so what point are you actually trying to make? The colonizers wouldn't be any better, for doing that on land where the natives roamed freely. Then it's been proven that some of the "unprovoked" attacks by natives were either instigated or perpetrated by other white settlers. Your words are also getting a deviation from the main point though. If we're supposed to celebrate these people who committed atrocious acts against the natives today, why are we supposed to not really care about those atrocious acts? We're told that people of the past play little to no role in how things operate today when we bring up those horrible actions of the same groups of people, but we're also told to celebrate them for some of those actions. My point has nothing to do with whataboutisms, I'm just bringing up the double standard/hypocrisy of wanting people to celebrate people for how things are today but also claiming we shouldn't focus on some of these same people when there's rightful criticism of how the colonizers play a negative role in how things are today.
@@terrencelockett4072 All I'm saying is that I feel like we're not getting the full picture here. And I'm not trying to defend the colonists as you're right. They did some horrific things to the natives, and while that's been talked about, what's not talked about is how for example Apache and Comanche raiders murdering settlers on the Oregan Trail. How the men were scalped, and women and children taken as slaves and raped. Both sides did awful things, and yet we only hear about how it was the evil white man, murdering and raping the poor defenseless Indians, who would never dream of committing heinous acts onto them.
I'm a second generation American, my grandfather was deported from Ukraine so according to Matt Walsh the death under Stalin was just the cost of doing business.
How is it a surprise to anyone that Wett Mulch, the nation's leading advocate for genocide in the current decade, also celebrates previous genocides...?
None of the Daily Wire ppl are capable of friendships in the first place. They are as fake and backsabby to each other as they are to anyone else, the only thing that's real to them is money.
Children's book, stuffed toy, action figure, phallic type toy, creepy black mask, book about women, Matt Walsh bookmark inspired by Heisenberg, napsack with a purpose known only to God. These are items Matt Walsh showcases to audiences of all ages.
For hundreds of years, it was uncontroversial to say that if you recovered from a serious illness, you should go to the temple of Asclepius and make an offering.
He's just pushing Manifest Destiny Doctrine. You know " Hey like your land , so I'm going to take it because God meant for me to have it because I can take care of it better than you".
Well, if colonization and conquest done by the Europeans is a good thing, then is the “colonization and conquest” that some people on the political right the migration of Hispanics, Arabs & Africans to the United States and Europe a good thing too?
What he means to say is "brutal colonialism in the name of Christianity is good. The colonialism of ACTUALLY extolling the virtues of Christianity (encouraging tolerance, compassion, and understanding) is bad." That's probably a little closer to what he's getting at.
You are aware colonization isn't exclusive to Christians, you do realize African tribes colonized as did the Chinese and also the Mongolians, (gangus khan) one of the most brutal of them all
@@aliamjon4423 Well yes, but that's not relevant to the point I was making. Walsh is essentially referring to the colonialism that forged America; conquering lands in the name of Christ. He is falsely asserting liberals encouraging other nations to be more tolerant and compassionate to LGBTQ+ people as a form of colonialism; a bad one at that. I'm not denying other colonialism has existed. It's just not relevant to my particular observation.
@@craighaley1658 Convenient, and I love how you and others that share your beliefs sit there and judge people from the past as you benefit from everything they did
I see people express the exact same sentiment every day in TH-cam comment sections. I've met British people who will try to justify every colonial atrocity that they ever perpetrated and European Americans who say that all native Americans were cannibals who would've eventually eaten every white settler. There's a reason these people have an audience.
I'm kind of split on the topic. I'm from a country that has been under foreign occupation/domination for a long time and I can understand how it looked from the perspective of those who were f-ed by this process of conquest. However, on the other hand, I can understand the pride some like the Brits might have in having conquered 1/4 of the world. I mean, that is an absolutely incredible achievement and the greatest countries/civilizations in history were conquerors. If you look at the greatest leaders in history, names like Napoleon, Caesar or Genghis Khan will invariably pop up. I think one of my country's greatest mistakes was minding our own business and not going out trying to conquer. Why? Because if you mind your own business, someone else will make it their business to invade/conquer you. And this was the source of our backwardness compared to the West. It is a cruel reality of history and I wish it weren't so, but it is.
@@VARMOT123 My ancestors might have been assholes. For me that's not a problem. For hyper-traditionalist family worshipping lunatics that's unthinkable.
@Abu Bäytnighan in my house we learn why? How?. My kids know exactely what and why Thanksgiving is a holiday. They are also aware of where the pledge of allegiance came from and why it was introduced and promoted in schools(not that I disagree with the verbiage of the actual pledge)
The indigenous population was already weakened with disease before the colonization of North America actually happened. The area around St Louis would have rivaled the population of London.
Matt Walsh is the perfect fascist, he’s not smart enough to be an administrator of fascism but he is the perfect encapsulation of what every fascist leader desires their citizenry to be like
@@aliamjon4423 you're soooo original saying the thing that every mouth breather says when their uninformed opinion is challenged by people who have any actual background in a topic.
@@billymitchell655 Send your wife my condolences Nah fr tho at least ya got a sense of humor, that's the second most important thing for a dad to have next to a job
He's being knowingly offensive in order to get attention. Unfortunately, just by saying it, there are at least some people who will believe it and spread it.
Meanwhile when the settlers first arrived they burned down all the indigenous forests and killed all the birds. Legend has it that there was so many trees between the entire east coast and Mississippi that a squirrel would never touch the ground. The bird migrations would black out the sun for days at a time. Early miners burned all of it down for easier prospecting and Indian removal.
"We" didn't colonize, and "we" didn't own slaves. "We" have nothing to apologize for, but "we" have nothing to be proud of, either. We have to face that as Americans, slavery is our national sin, and everything in our history and political culture derives from this. We persisted in regionalism and didn't even develop modern political parties until 1968.
@@rev.chuckshingledecker The Nations practiced slavery as well, some after the Thirteenth Amendment was ratified. Black people were treated as property. Aborigines were treated as proletarians, people who have no economic value.
@@basedtruthpiller7140 giving reasonable critique of his idiocy. Meanwhile he keeps vomiting garbage he doesn't even believe to get views. Pathetic (which is why you have man-love for him)
@@basedtruthpiller7140 Pointing out his hatred and misinformation is not an obsession. It is the right thing to do. Can you explain your obsession with Sam and why you post dozens of comments every day for years?
"Using violence to achieve your goals is great. Using ideas to sway opinions is evil." - Matt Walsh
Confession. Through. Projection.
"It is good and noble and courageous to shoot a native American in the face with a gun when they're coming at you with a bone knife for raping their daughter and stealing their home." - Walsh
@@basedtruthpiller7140 My conscience it clear. Can you say the same after using a mass shooting and the death of innocent children to push more hatred and misinformation?
@@basedtruthpiller7140 "Confession. Through. Projection." confessed by Aaron while psychologically projecting.😏
And what is the non-idea thing that was so great? Slavery? Theft? Genocide? The only small good thing that might have happened through colonization is the spread of enlightenment ideals like humanitarianism and rule of law, (ideals the colonizers WILDLY fell short of except occasionally when dealing with each other).
"...now you're not allowed to say it at all." he said, with literally no consequences.
Probably because he has a team behind him that will protect him. I'm sure if someone worked in government or many other businesses saying these things would get them fired.
All part of the gift. Just like how people selling time-shares are like "now I shouldn't be telling you this... But there's a great deal on this villa in Florida"
“Colonization is good unless it’s happening to me” - Matt Walsh
You do realize natve americans murdered and enslaved each other long before white people arrived here, right?
As you benefit from it, smh
With a surname like that he's got potato blood (his logic) so he's not 100% American
Colonization can have benefits. It helped modernize India legally, technologically, materially and politically. It can also be negative like what happened to Native Americans. Overall though, Walsh is right. The creation of America had a positive impact on the world if you look at what it was like before its formation. It's founding helps the western world transition into more peaceful era.
@@earlgrayman982 “genocide has some long term benefits actually” Jesus fucking Christ dude…
"You literally can't say the things I'm saying"
The #1 quality of someone being silenced is that you can’t hear them
It's funny how loud silenced people are and just how many platforms the cancelled have.
Can you believe people don't want you to justify genocide these days? Cancel culture run amok.
Yes, he's so right.
🤣
I'm so tired of them saying, "You're not allowed to to say this and you're not allowed to say that." You can say whatever the hell you want and enlightened people can call you on it.
What they mean is back in the day they were allowed to say racist, sexist, homophobic, transphobic, etc things without blowback. Now they can still say all of that but if they do they will be called out.
Oftentimes “enlightened” people are idiots who don’t really know if something is -ist or -phobic.
@@isaiahhill2104 then they aren't enlightened are they?
“Called out” means being isolated from society and being fired from your job and being blacklisted from others life without money in capitalist society is a death sentence.
@Clark Kent potentially. Not by definition. And if you had an employee who you found out is a neo nazi and us openly and brazenly posting stuff. Would you still employ that guy? Even after the public starts complaining?
Him: " colonialism by challenging traditional values and spreading foreign ideas is bad"
also him: "colonialism, in which Europeans challenged the traditional values of the natives and spread their religious and secular ideologies, is good"
Who would have thought he could spread transphobia, homophobia, and praise colonialism, in one soundbite?
*Martian:* So when we come and claim and colonise your planet, you're going to celebrate us as heroes, right?
*Matt Walsh:* No because you're going to kill us all and erase all traces of our civilisation.
*Martian:* By Jove, one of the primitives is learning!
The Martian will most likely reevaluate his last statement, whatever Matt Walsh says next 😂
Matt Walsh: But feel free to colonise and exterminate those trans and gays. Oh and uppity women who talk back too much and want bodily autonomy.
Martian: That’s… that’s not how it works.
Matt Walsh: Why not?
Martian: Because you don’t get to tell the colonisers what to do. Also have you learned nothing from history?
Matt Walsh: I’ve learned no group has been more oppressed than the straight white Christian male.
Martian: Our records show that has never been true.
Martian #2: Hearing this guy talk makes me want to make it true though.
I’d say Martians colonizing liberals is ok as judgment and not ok against conservatives because we have better values.
And if the martians are conservative then yes colonizing and changing liberals would be a HEROIC thing for the world.
You see….you can’t actually show any logical holes because the FACT is native Americans were savage barbaric, warring tribes with zero unity among them for centuries prior to the settlers.
Colonizing winded up uniting the land under SUPERIOR morals.
And the same could be said if you liberals all lived in one land grooming children, banning free speech….yup that’s when colonization of your land by a group with better values than you would be a positive good in the world.
Anyway…LOVE noticing your ungrateful ilk (since you’re living with the fruits of this colonization you rage about) both in the video and comments going crazy over Walsh daring to state the obvious fact that there are always objective gradations to even colonization’s good or evil in the world.
To be a conservative like Walsh, one first must rip any vestige humility or empathy from your soul.
Bold of you to assume he had any before he became a right winger.
Wrong
@@davidjuliesmiththomas7983 How? He displays a complete lack of either. He's nuts, and you'd have to be nuts to hold the positions he does. There is no rational justification for it.
You mean not allow yourself into being guilt-tripped into giving away your victories and culture?
@Anthropomorphic Trilobite As soon as you replied, "What victories? What culture?" I new you were looking for a gotcha, or arguing for the sake of arguing. But not just you, or me, most Westerners play gotcha because it makes them feel morally superior and boosts their frail egos.
"People coming across the southern border today are doing good, admirable, and heroic work. Wait that doesn't sound right."
-Matt Walsh
Those people are brown and scary don’t you realize?
Sailing across a ocean to the unknown compared to hitching rides and walking to a already built country and sucking the government dry is the same to you in guess
@Aliam jon
So you're telling me that colonizers didn't suck the countries they encountered completly dry? Do I have to remind you of slave trade? Believe what you want about illegal immigrants but they at least participate in local economy. They bring labour and pay taxes. When Europeans arrived to the Americas they only cared about stealing land and destroing local goverments
@@aliamjon4423 The way the Europeans treated the native Americans was the same as the way the immigrants from the south are treating Americans now, for you, I guess.
@@ihatetoshiba
So Americans should expect to not pay taxes and get free medical benefits, casinos from the immigrants ?
The conquest of Africa, the Congo in particular, or the South African apartheid-every one of those was extremely "heroic" and "wonderful" too.
@Thomas Santa there's a railroad through the Congo, they say to construct it, an African died for every tie on the track.
Do you really believe that African tribes never conquered other tribes ?
they aren't really comparable.
So? Europeans have been fighting each other for centuries-what's your point.
@@thomassanta5686
When colonization is brought up nobody acknowledges anyone else but Europeans
*Matt Walsh is a PDF File* and there's no doubt in my mind that his closet is bursting with skeletons...
His obsession with trans people is downright twisted and psychotic, there is not one issue I spend that many hours of the day spending my energy hating
Colonial genocide would be good and heroic if the context was that Matt Walsh's home was colonized and only Matt Walsh was genocided. Basically something terrible can be a net positive if it only happens to Matt Walsh.
Remember, whoever does it is a hero BECAUSE they came and claimed his house
Hope someone sneaks into his house and "colonize" him soon
The United Nations has just come up with a new term but this time they say that it is a net neutral idea at best. It’s called *looks down at paper* Walshicide
@@vaels5682 hell no 1000% not a hero no cap
There’s no way he’s claiming ideological colonialism is categorically bad; it’s just a double standard of “good when my faction does it, bad when my opponents do it.”
Whoa, you've abstracted that idea way too far for this guy. These people live in a world of absolute morality. Matt clearly only understands things on a "good people" vs "bad people" level
@@pattyspanker8955kinda of like black people in Africa think white people shouldn't exist
He forgets the part where on of the goals was to turn native americans into Christians. What about that ideological colonization ?
I agree with basically everything, except...
For the very last comment by Emma; "He's sick in the head." No. He is not.
Matt Walsh (or any other massive biggot on the right) is not mentally ill, he's perfectly sane, bigoted and hateful man. Being hateful is not a mental illness. Spreading hate and bigotry is not "crazy." It's evil. It's fascistic.
Equating evil actions to being mentally ill is part of how fascism downplays the danger they pose, but also subtly redirect fear and hate towards the mentally ill and disabled.
So please. Stop saying that they're "sick and crazy" when you mean "evil."
hes so talented at saying what is "good" and "bad" without saying why.
“What is a bad?”
This is on the same spectrum of trying to ban CRT teaching in higher education. They want to go from denying and hiding from it to being openly proud of it.
CRT = all white people are evil?
No wonder conservatives hate education so much. Matt Walsh wouldn't be a conservative if he actually learned about history
Matt Walsh is pointing out why he should be respected because someone 500 years ago made him "top dog" while not being able to maintain that "top dog" position.
He needs to read what the Statue of Liberty has under her skirt. She doesn't want to be like those pesky judgemental Brits she wants everyone to share the US bounty.
Let's all be heroes and 'colonize' Matt Walsh.
Completely missing the point
@Aliam jon I think you missed the point--purging fascism would be a fairly comparable in impact from a eugenicist's perspective. The reason is that most people have decided that ascribing a base level of value to human life is inherently valuable to a functional society.
So is Matt Walsh saying he’s FOR “replacement theory”
He's already explicitly stated that the "Great Replacement" is "just a fact." He said that after the Buffalo shooting when Cucker Tarlson was getting a lot of (well-deserved) criticism for inspiring that shooting, since Cucker always spews that nonsense on his show.
So you admit replacement is a thing ?
@@aliamjon4423would explain the increase in the average length of penis
@@aliamjon4423 Nope, it's made up bullshit by white supremacist dingos. That doesn't stop anyone from pointing out Matt Walsh's hypocrisy.
@@aliamjon4423 It's not a thing. Go touch grass.
I am sick and tired of wealthy people being hosted on platforms that reach millions complaining about being silenced and not being able to say things.
Matt Walsh read the Dark Enlightenment manifesto and took it seriously
I'm almost positive Native Americans were not running around quoting Bible verses, but colonization was not about culture, they were just trying to convince them they would be better off living on small patches of land and having nothing to call theirs
Is that how conquest works ? The victors just give land to the conquered ? Only White Europeans would do that, no others
The natives did not have to take this crap, they could have simply repelled the invaders. Oh wait, their societies were to primitive to mount a viable defence. If the whites tried it today, it would be different wouldn't it?
Most early colonizers had no problem killing Native Christians anyway. A prime example is the Gnadenhutten Massacre of 1782. Absolutely horrific, Nazi-level shit.
@Some Person I'm pretty sure native Americans aren't a monolith. Like 💯 sure
I can tell you for a fact that the erasure of native culture was a major, open goal. There's a reason "Kill the Indian, save the man" became a saying.
Our understanding of colonization must begin from this place: Indigenous peoples on Turtle Island (North America) have long histories of rich cultural and spiritual traditions. In turn, communities have always had their own forms of justice, conflict resolution, decision-making, and caring for the vulnerable that upheld their Nation’s values. Once Western settlements began, the influences of colonization displaced peoples from their lands. Settler governments took control of Indigenous ways of life and forced assimilation through generations of residential schooling and child welfare practices that among many things, fractured families and communities. Through colonization, imposed modes of education, religion, labor, food, and medicine, governance, and justice began a cycle of social, physical, and spiritual destruction. Colonization and the intergenerational effects of this violence upon culture, community, spirit, and body is anticipated to last generations. Additionally, Indigenous peoples are embattled with continued racism and systemic oppression. As a result, poverty, poor health, substance abuse, and learned violence are realities amongst many Indigenous people.
The only reason why I know what happened to my family is because of my mother taught me.
fr as black Person I know or anyone that's a native knows about this
These people seem to be taking the mask off more and more every day
gotta throw in the "no one is allowed to say this" thing that im saying right now..
As an Irish guy, it amazes me that Irish Americans can be so pro colonialism. Like, do they not realize how many of their ancestors died due to British colonialism?
Yeah it’s weird how some are completely ignorant of Irish history, probably because we don’t learn much of it in schools. I’m an American of Irish descent who likes to read about Irish history (particularly focusing on the War of Independence period) and it’s even frustrating to me how other Irish Americans don’t see the parallels between the colonization of Ireland and that of indigenous peoples in America. Granted there are liberal and leftist IAs, and plenty in MA still vote Democrat or for left leaning candidates, but they aren’t as loud or attention hogging as Matt Walsh and the other MAGA chuds.
That's almost 100% blood and soil rhetoric
Matt Walsh isn't talking about native Americans when he's talking about heros.
i know
"You're not allowed to say this..."
- guy making more money than the next 9 people in that room combined to say exactly that thing
I hope someone goes and "conquers" Matt Welsh so he can see how heroic it feels
Missed the point
@@aliamjon4423 missed the bus to the senior home.
@@aliamjon4423 Please enlighten us.What is the point?
@@taranullius9221
Because y'all are comparing and judging the settlers from then and applying how we live today to hundreds of years ago
@@aliamjon4423 Rape and genocide are never good.
Note that as Matt says colonization was good and Sam says the other terrible things that were considered ok by the colonizers during that period, all Sam's examples are things Matt supports.
Matt Walsh is the worst kind of apologist. If he were a true Christian he would know that forgiveness won’t come until we acknowledge the wrongs we have committed in the past and do our best to make those wrongs right.
fr
Actually Walsh is totally wrong about colonization and conquest of the Americas being uncontroversial until THE 2020 LEFT CAME ALONG: there was even a guy in the 1500s who wrote a book condemning what the Spanish were doing to Native people and there have been people pushing against these crimes the whole way
He is REALLY pushing the bounds of free speech.
Love how he said that you are not allowed to say something like this right after he said it.
I like to point out the GI Bill.
Systemic racism is impossible to argue against with that example.
My parents generation benefited from it, except...
Keep up the great work!
My wife's grandpa used it to become a doctor and then put his kids and all his grandkids through college. Couldn't have happened if he was black.
@@jimgranite
I appreciate your feedback.
Folks like to pretend that it is some great mystery.
But, it's not...
Thank you!
Oh yes. I remember watching Westerns in the 60s. One of the more common phrases was, "The only good Indian is a dead Indian".
Folks in the past weren't inclusive, to say the least. That doesn't mean we should be ashamed of the past, but it damn sure means that we shouldn't hold up the past as the ideal.
I mean that is pretty much a quote from Andrew Jackson
I mean we should be ashamed of the past and then repatriate and look after the colonized folks . Just remember Europe's population would more than double or triple without genocidal colonization of 3 other continents
@@VARMOT123 naw they would have killed each other in more wars.
We should be ashamed of the past. Why are we so afraid of introspection?
Genocide is a nasty stain on our species' history, not a badge of honor.
It is true that parts of Africa are very anti gay but those anti gay attitudes were brought to Africa by Christian missionaries.
Exactly. How come these so called "smart" people always look at the end product, but never the production of the product. Africa wasn't always like that.
Genocide too was an uncontroversial idea in 1940 Germany. It used to be uncontroversial doesn't mean its cool, MAP Walsh.
Didn't the Moors colonize Spain much as the Spanish would later colonize the Americas? And wasn't their culture more "advanced" than the one they colonized? Would Matt Walsh then praise the Moors as good and righteous?
Of course not colonialism is only good when it's white and christian, which is ironic since fucking italians and spaniards colonized the americas first and neither one of those fuckers are white, and catholics arent even considered real christians by most other denominations
Don't forget the Ottoman Empire modern day Turkey was one of the great countries or Empires at the time. The Ottoman Empire conquered Greece Bulgaria Romania Hungary Serbia Albania Armenia Palestine Syria Lebanon Jordan and Egypt. And Constantinople now modern day Istanbul. So I guess Islamic Muslim countries where better cvilizations than Western cvilization. Plus as you pointed out the Islamic Empire conquered Spain. So Muslim countries where better and brought benefits to Western countries it conquered
"Oh hey matt, I just took your house, wife and kids. Because i had more and better guns than you. That makes it right, good and heroic."
It's weird how Ben and Candice don't understand that the things they are helping prop up will be used against them in turn.
I have disagreements with Sam, but this kind of stuff is what keeps me watching. Crazy take from Walsh.
"Colonization was a good thing. And some day I will learn to play this banjo behind me. Those things are equally true."
Perfect. Your choice of words and your wonderful tone cut open and expose his purile and dangerous version of history.
Here in Australia, we too are having trouble coming to terms with our own colonial past, and we too have to endure guys like him who seek to justify, indeed warp, the telling of the past in deceptive ways.
He seems so desperate to share "their" version of white-washed history. Complete dismissal of the actions of their forefathers, so as not to feel uncomfortable or God forgive, share in any feelings of collective guilt over past actions and their present consequences.
Actions which have brought about the foundations upon which they now enjoy quite comfortable lives.
Here in Australia we call people like him a "dickhead". Do join us.
Thankyou.
We use the same term here in America.
@@georgeknightley8828 great...wasn't sure because I haven't heard it used that much. Thanks
White Australians are even more lucky . You guys became a majority on a continent opposite side of europe and bordering indian ocean . Indians and other Asians didn't colonize it and your top two exports are coal and iron ore
Someone needs to "colonize" Matt Walsh's house and force him on his own personal Trail of Tears journey. Then we will celebrate the people who now live in his house as being "Good and Heroic".
Who listens to Matt Walsh? That's like having Charlie Sheen as a life coach!! 😬
No it's not. Charlie Sheen knows how to have fun. Matt doesn't. He never has fun. And he hates the fact that others have fun.
At least you could learn something from sheen
Many people listens to him, mostly fellow conservatives
@@fajarfarrel932 Then they're all moral weaklings. Not because they're conservative, but because they're easily duped enough to listen to the self-proclaimed "theocratic fascist."
He claimed you're not allowed to say it yet he just said it and nothing happened to him?
The Daily Wire supports his values so he can say what he wants. Most people don't have that luxury at their job.
Playing victim
everything this Walsh dude is saying makes total sense if he's talking about the people who conquered North America 10 000 years ago or however long ago it was. yeah they were brave and heroic, actual literal trailblazers. and they did it without any modern technology.
if he's talking about the European invaders though... then he sounds like a vile monster.
"The Republican party is an outrage machine where cruelty is the point." -Jesse Dolemore.
bro...my jaw is on the floor, matty boy is just going full mask off
Ah yes. Matt Walsh. The modern day Brawny paper towel guy...but without the muscles. He's Paul Bunyan without any of the manliness.
More like live action Ned Flanders.
He doesn’t even have an Ox.
@@haiasieel6099 Westboro Flanders
@@TheZombiemofo 🤣🤣🤣🤣
I’m sure when Walsh watched Independence Day he was angry that the alien colonizers were thwarted by the primitive humans and their backward technology.
And seriously, I’d score points for Walsh if he was bold enough to openly justify the slaughter of Native Americans instead of hiding behind euphemisms while pretending to be brave.
So we're supposed to celebrate the colonizers of the past today but we're not supposed to even talk about how those that were colonized are still affected today.
What about the fact that in North America, a lot of times it was the natives who started hostilities? All the way back to the Pilgrims, they just wanted to live in peace and worked with the natives until they decided to attack them unprovoked, forcing the Pilgrims to defend themselves. The same happened with the Jamestown Colony, and then in later centuries where the United States had to engage in wars against the Cherokee, Shawnee, Creek, Lakota, Comanche and other native tribes, who instigated these conflicts and more.
@@barbiquearea
What does unprovoked mean in this context when we're talking about the native Americans in the past? Europeans also attacked natives unprovoked, so what point are you actually trying to make? The colonizers wouldn't be any better, for doing that on land where the natives roamed freely. Then it's been proven that some of the "unprovoked" attacks by natives were either instigated or perpetrated by other white settlers.
Your words are also getting a deviation from the main point though. If we're supposed to celebrate these people who committed atrocious acts against the natives today, why are we supposed to not really care about those atrocious acts? We're told that people of the past play little to no role in how things operate today when we bring up those horrible actions of the same groups of people, but we're also told to celebrate them for some of those actions. My point has nothing to do with whataboutisms, I'm just bringing up the double standard/hypocrisy of wanting people to celebrate people for how things are today but also claiming we shouldn't focus on some of these same people when there's rightful criticism of how the colonizers play a negative role in how things are today.
@@terrencelockett4072 All I'm saying is that I feel like we're not getting the full picture here. And I'm not trying to defend the colonists as you're right. They did some horrific things to the natives, and while that's been talked about, what's not talked about is how for example Apache and Comanche raiders murdering settlers on the Oregan Trail. How the men were scalped, and women and children taken as slaves and raped. Both sides did awful things, and yet we only hear about how it was the evil white man, murdering and raping the poor defenseless Indians, who would never dream of committing heinous acts onto them.
I'm a second generation American, my grandfather was deported from Ukraine so according to Matt Walsh the death under Stalin was just the cost of doing business.
For some reason you're not getting it, how can you compare staying with our history ?
@@aliamjon4423 I'm not getting it either, please explain.
@@davidspears4550
It wouldn't matter to you, you're already brainwashed and in to deep in your cult
How is it a surprise to anyone that Wett Mulch, the nation's leading advocate for genocide in the current decade, also celebrates previous genocides...?
"Freedom of speech does not protect you from the consequences of saying stupid shit" Jim C. Hines
I bet Matt is the black sheep even among the Daily Wire freaks. I don’t think anyone talks to him at the Christmas party or the barbecues
This is the first relatively reasonable comment you've ever posted.
I agree ☝🏻.
@Based Truthpiller Considering you’ve never posted a reasonable comment, I don’t know what you’ll compare it to in relation.
@@xXRickTrolledXx minors are receiving gender affirming surgery.
None of the Daily Wire ppl are capable of friendships in the first place. They are as fake and backsabby to each other as they are to anyone else, the only thing that's real to them is money.
Rev. 13. [10] He that leadeth into captivity shall go into captivity: he that killeth with the sword must be killed with the sword.
Children's book, stuffed toy, action figure, phallic type toy, creepy black mask, book about women, Matt Walsh bookmark inspired by Heisenberg, napsack with a purpose known only to God. These are items Matt Walsh showcases to audiences of all ages.
The FBI needs to look into your hard drive.
@@alabamaman5994 wait weren't you republicans saying the FBI is controlled by the deep state? 🤔
@@alabamaman5994 I thought you jokers didn't like the FBI anymore.
Better check his basement.
For hundreds of years, it was uncontroversial to say that if you recovered from a serious illness, you should go to the temple of Asclepius and make an offering.
He's just pushing Manifest Destiny Doctrine. You know " Hey like your land , so I'm going to take it because God meant for me to have it because I can take care of it better than you".
Well, if colonization and conquest done by the Europeans is a good thing, then is the “colonization and conquest” that some people on the political right the migration of Hispanics, Arabs & Africans to the United States and Europe a good thing too?
Every time I think Walsh can’t get worse he hits a new low.
i agree
"Matt Walsh says something depraved while complaining how few depraved things he's allowed to say." That's the Breitbart/Shapiro Doctrine.
What he means to say is "brutal colonialism in the name of Christianity is good. The colonialism of ACTUALLY extolling the virtues of Christianity (encouraging tolerance, compassion, and understanding) is bad." That's probably a little closer to what he's getting at.
You are aware colonization isn't exclusive to Christians, you do realize African tribes colonized as did the Chinese and also the Mongolians, (gangus khan) one of the most brutal of them all
@@aliamjon4423 not to the same extent- even khan
@@aliamjon4423 Well yes, but that's not relevant to the point I was making. Walsh is essentially referring to the colonialism that forged America; conquering lands in the name of Christ. He is falsely asserting liberals encouraging other nations to be more tolerant and compassionate to LGBTQ+ people as a form of colonialism; a bad one at that. I'm not denying other colonialism has existed. It's just not relevant to my particular observation.
@@Aarenby then you really don't know anything about history
@@craighaley1658
Convenient, and I love how you and others that share your beliefs sit there and judge people from the past as you benefit from everything they did
I see people express the exact same sentiment every day in TH-cam comment sections. I've met British people who will try to justify every colonial atrocity that they ever perpetrated and European Americans who say that all native Americans were cannibals who would've eventually eaten every white settler. There's a reason these people have an audience.
That is because liberals and lefties are empathetic and don't depend on their rewritten white washed history to make them feel good about themselves
I'm kind of split on the topic. I'm from a country that has been under foreign occupation/domination for a long time and I can understand how it looked from the perspective of those who were f-ed by this process of conquest. However, on the other hand, I can understand the pride some like the Brits might have in having conquered 1/4 of the world. I mean, that is an absolutely incredible achievement and the greatest countries/civilizations in history were conquerors. If you look at the greatest leaders in history, names like Napoleon, Caesar or Genghis Khan will invariably pop up. I think one of my country's greatest mistakes was minding our own business and not going out trying to conquer. Why? Because if you mind your own business, someone else will make it their business to invade/conquer you. And this was the source of our backwardness compared to the West. It is a cruel reality of history and I wish it weren't so, but it is.
@@VARMOT123 My ancestors might have been assholes. For me that's not a problem. For hyper-traditionalist family worshipping lunatics that's unthinkable.
Matt knows all about our country's awful history. HE DOESNT CARE!
He contests the use of the adjective "awful"
@TheEvolver311 oh absolutely. To him it's a beautiful history.
gross
I've been listening to alot of these clips... This one actually made me say " what the fuck".. out loud. This was disgusting.
Celebrate it? Like Thanksgiving?
Ahh, good point!
No one is allowed to talk about why thanksgiving is a holiday
The Pilgrims didn't come over to conquer the land but to find a land to settle in where they wouldn't have to fear religious persecution.
@@barbiqueareaThe puritans were kicked out of England because they wanted to persecute everyone else.
@Abu Bäytnighan in my house we learn why? How?. My kids know exactely what and why Thanksgiving is a holiday. They are also aware of where the pledge of allegiance came from and why it was introduced and promoted in schools(not that I disagree with the verbiage of the actual pledge)
The indigenous population was already weakened with disease before the colonization of North America actually happened. The area around St Louis would have rivaled the population of London.
LOL,..Reminds me of the Gordon Gekko character, "Greed is good". And basically, the same principle as why Europeans came to America.
Par for the course. He said that the residential school death camps for Natives was good because they 'died knowing God instead of as heathens'
Matt do you think it was heroic of the Germans to invade Poland?
He probably does.
Matt Walsh “ I benefited from slavery”
So maybe you should pay reparations?
Matt Walsh “ NO NO Im not responsible nor benefit from slavery”
nothing matt walsh says could surprise me at this point
I never thought I would hear someone say that genocide is a good thing but here we are. Sigh.
How much money would it take for Matt Walsh to try and play that banjo on film?
Funnily enough, the Banjo was invented in Africa
@@xXRickTrolledXx that's the point, even though the OP doesn't understand why.
@@alabamaman5994 What's your name? Ian or something? My brother in Christ go get a better hobby.
Banjos are fucking hard to play, I bought one as a goof for 90 dollars and I can barely make Pleasant Sounding Noise with it much less play tabs
Are you casting for a remake of Deliverance?
matt walsh is around 190 years behind the manifest destiny curve. He’s practically an intellectual neanderthal
Matt Walsh is the perfect fascist, he’s not smart enough to be an administrator of fascism but he is the perfect encapsulation of what every fascist leader desires their citizenry to be like
You need to learn what Fascism is first
@@aliamjon4423 Please explain it to us
@@aliamjon4423 considering I wrote my polisci ba dissertation on fascism it's probable that i've forgotten more about it than you know
@@trentonantis6668
Then I think you should get your money back from that college if your professor accepted it, you didn't learn a thing there
@@aliamjon4423 you're soooo original saying the thing that every mouth breather says when their uninformed opinion is challenged by people who have any actual background in a topic.
History is complex. Anyone who says differently is selling something.
Would be interested to hear his views on the plantation of Ireland, or the highland clearances, given his surname is Walsh.
ChristoFacist missionaries have entered the chat.
Matt Walsh thinks Handmaids Tale is a comedy.
Things I like are good. Things I don't like are bad. I'm Matt Walsh, I get paid to say the things.
He’s such a ghoul.
this dudes entire historical worldview is derived from watching Yellowstone
What's Evil Billy Mays up to now? 🙄
@@billymitchell655 Get well soon.
@@billymitchell655 Sorry to hear about your brain damage that is tragic
@@billymitchell655 Send your wife my condolences
Nah fr tho at least ya got a sense of humor, that's the second most important thing for a dad to have next to a job
Heroes ???? I suspect the indigenous people living there at the time the European Heroes arrived would have significantly disagreed.
He's being knowingly offensive in order to get attention. Unfortunately, just by saying it, there are at least some people who will believe it and spread it.
Cultural colonisation? Like forcing Christianity on Africa?
"claimed" this land... I've gotta remember that euphemism for future use.
And while you're at it learn how just about every country went through it at some point
Meanwhile when the settlers first arrived they burned down all the indigenous forests and killed all the birds. Legend has it that there was so many trees between the entire east coast and Mississippi that a squirrel would never touch the ground. The bird migrations would black out the sun for days at a time. Early miners burned all of it down for easier prospecting and Indian removal.
I get so mad at older generations when I see how little they cared about basically anything.
"We" didn't colonize, and "we" didn't own slaves. "We" have nothing to apologize for, but "we" have nothing to be proud of, either.
We have to face that as Americans, slavery is our national sin, and everything in our history and political culture derives from this. We persisted in regionalism and didn't even develop modern political parties until 1968.
Genocide of the Native peoples is our other National sin.
@@rev.chuckshingledecker The Nations practiced slavery as well, some after the Thirteenth Amendment was ratified. Black people were treated as property. Aborigines were treated as proletarians, people who have no economic value.
Ice cream analogy was brilliant :) . It is pure agony for an Indian to hear colonization was good. Yeah lets hear it from Bengal shall we.
It was really good for Matt and his ancestors.
Emma's face at 7:50 lmfao. That's a "bruh moment" face if I've ever seen one.
Hey everyone! Drop what you are doing! Matt Walsh desperately needs attention.
...... umm....... y'all the ones making 100s of videos about him......
@@basedtruthpiller7140 giving reasonable critique of his idiocy. Meanwhile he keeps vomiting garbage he doesn't even believe to get views. Pathetic (which is why you have man-love for him)
@@kcolonelx6181 interesting.... and what kind of crush is y'all obsession with him?
@@basedtruthpiller7140 Pointing out his hatred and misinformation is not an obsession. It is the right thing to do. Can you explain your obsession with Sam and why you post dozens of comments every day for years?
@@kcolonelx6181 'rules the thee, not for me'
Coincidentally thats also what he calls dating a minor
I'm DEAD! 🤣 🤣 🤣