Great idea! Super cool how it stops and also dispenses in a very controlled way. You are very wise and you must be (or should be) a fantastic engineer! You think outside the box and you are a problem solver.
Without reading any previous comments I will tell you my impression of your interpretation of this object. I was searching for confirmation of my believe this was used as a water pump that worked in a shaft somehow and wasn’t expecting to see but really is an excellent interpretation. Wether this distribution was for trade or food rations or distribution to people who were to plant they all could be possibilities. I could image that think being a central hub in a marketplace or state run distribution centre to farmers. I’m sure that agriculture is the most important activity of any thriving civilization and the disc used in this way could have an important part of keep the production moving. Nice work, love your model btw, wasn’t sure about it at first but it’s all you need to demonstrate and explain things very well.
Grain is incredibly important to the lives of ancient Egyptians, life or death important. It isn't insane to think they would put that much effort into ways to sort and manage it. Most of Egyptian writing is actually just about that, grain. Storage of food, material etc. it's a major part of ancient history. If you have a better hypothesis you should present it instead of mocking his.
@@annespacedroid almost like cereals arent as important to us as they were to a early agricultural society. Also as other people pointed out in the comments of this video, this item looks most closely like a a device used for incenses and burning. Its decorative
So they go to great technological difficulty to make the delicate disk to handle grain? So using human workers to measure it out with cups, bowls or buckets didn't suffice? Sounds like replacing auto workers with robots except I cannot grasp that the Egyptians, of the era to which the disk is attributed, would seek such a labor-saving device. Qudos for trying to figure-out what this disk was for.
What makes you seem to think that it was difficult for them to achieve? You must not think very highly of these advanced civilizations who build one of the seven wonders of the ancient world, of which we are unable to replicate many of their works today without difficulty. So you do not believe that they were intelligent enough to come up with a way to utilize their workers more efficiently? Yes you would be a great king one day. Why does modern day man seems to think that ancient man was incapable of great achievements and yet modern man racks their brain attempting to figure out just how these feats were accomplished? So you probably believe that this is an incense holder because it is so delicate? I will stick with what I believe that this mechanism is a valve to control the flow of grain so that it will only require one man to dispense grain without it being a back breaking job.
I believe it is seen upside down as well as you were thinking. But I also believe that there is a reason why it tucks back in allowing maybe some kind of thick liquid to go into another container.
It’s a cool thought but you could use sandstone or wood which is much more workable and less brittle. I think it was likely an ornament of some description with no practical use sadly!
I like the thought, it has to have a functional reason for it to exist. Shame so many people come here with negative words about your ideas yet have no ideas of their own to contribute. Well done for making it work, hope your recovery is speedy sir.
As in modern day, kings, the wealthy, bribed Gov't officials collect and cherish expensive ad rare things: jewlery, artwork, cars, etc...The Schist Disc may have been passed down from generation to generation and ended up inside a kings tomb as an expensive, collectible.
Once it was discovered that this was in fact a grain dispenser everything else fell into place. Notice as I go from storage to feed that the rice starts to flows very slowly and as I get centered to the lobe the flow increases. The lobe works as a funnel and it controls the rate of feed as the disc is rotated. Notice that I am filling a 10-12” pan that also about 12-15” below the disc. Appreciate your comment.
The seed caster or spreader is spun with the grinding wheel. It casts out the grain into a curtain. This thins the grain to help the debris and pebbles bounce out. The curtain then drops on the bounce pad set below. It's the step sifter to bounce the rocks. This set up is a later known design of step sifting. But before was more extravagant. .some sifters even made music. Some made an stored energy from static and conetic energy. These had to be grounded or a spark ark could cause fires even huge explosions. The grinding wheels can get hot and explode apart as well. If uve never seen one explode it's a treet lol. But they fly out quite far and dangerously. U would would let the grain build around to help contain it lol. A ring would develop. Anyway. I've been in the industry in many different aspects. From farm to table literally made the table and the farm tools. Made corn chips lol it's cool. U probably ate them. But the industry is the hiden key. The Egyptian dance makes fun of the works in the field. Using a pine cone. Ever wonder why they hold there hands that way. Lol
This lobed disk is with absolute sure, a blender for paint in a big barrel. It is pushed and pulled upp and down in a barrel to get homogen paint. I´ve seen (used) it in reality. It mixed paint really effektive. Ive used it myself when i painted barns with the swedish "Falu rödfärg" or in english Falu redpaint. (Falu red paint, also known as Falun red or Falu rödfärg in Swedish, is traditionally made from a pigment called Falu red pigment or Falu red paint. This pigment is derived from copper-rich iron ochres mined from quarries near the town of Falun in Sweden. The pigment consists mainly of iron oxide (hematite) with varying amounts of silica and zinc. The process of making Falu red paint involves grinding the iron-rich ochre into a fine powder and mixing it with water, flour or starch, and sometimes linseed oil. This mixture creates a thick paste that can be applied to wood, giving it a distinctive red color. Falu red paint is widely used in Sweden for painting wooden houses, barns, and other structures due to its durability and traditional aesthetic appeal.)
Could the disc be a trophy left for eternity ,when spun, creates a field , much like a magnet . The disc capable of folding 1 pole into the other, like Ed liniskillions 48 pole, hand spun, magnetic device, nullified mass.
It does not make sense to use such an enormously difficult stone to carve , for a grain dispenser. Why leave a grain dispenser , made to crazy tolerances in a pyramid with all the vases. The disc was an anti gravity device. Not the day to day device that did all the heavy lifting of the magaliths, but a trophy capable of lasting eternity. AG is about folding 1 pole into the other. Creating a field, much like a magnet, but singularly piled. Anything within this field, mass was nullified or lessoned. They still need sleds to move the massive stone, but the stone essentially weighed less.
I do not believe that the stone was carved. It is possible that it was formed into this shape much like working with clay. I have studied the megalithic stones and believe that they too are formed into place. I have done a few experiments where I have replicated the shapes of stones and I can also explain the nubs that stick out from the stone. The stone had to be lightweight if it were going to be manually turned by hand. The stone “supposedly schist would have turned easy on a wood base. The disc could have been made out of would but eventually the wood could dry out causing grain to be lodged in the wood grain. I believe the grain would flow much better across schist stone than wood. I wouldn’t say something unless I was certain what it was used for, I am an antique dealer and very good at identifying what objects are used for and it is not anything else. I don’t not believe that it was a grain dispenser, I know that it is. Sorry don’t mean to sound cocky but I know exactly what it is. Give it time, folks will soon realize.
I'm pretty sure they did this in ancient times, but not with a disk. They just had the funnel swinging and it was at rest closed. I'm leaning towards sound manipulation for some reason myself. Just a thought to explore now.
@@GWAForUTBE Haven't heard that, but I'll look into it. Tesla said everything is waves and frequency and energy. This makes me think the Egyptians were closer to knowing how waves can manipulate things. They definitely used sound for a lot of things. The great pyramid does alter the earth's magnetic field.
This is actually part of a bigger machine. The whole machine is not there, but it’s used for anti-gravity. How do you think those big stones were moved?
I agree? Pls elaborate on the rest of the machine. I believe it only needed a bearing and some angular momentum and to be placed on a huge stone. It was a trophy tho.
John this Mike fella from this channel is a shut mind, you are right on the money with it being an AG device Could you elaborate about it being part of a machine?
The disc would not be moved back and forth as I demonstrated they would have just continued around in the same direction. I would imagine with the weight of grain that pulling it around would be much easier than pushing. The base would have been made of wood to reduce friction between the base and the disc.
My apologies for the late response, I am getting over my brain surgery. I hope soon to bring some new information that I discovered about this disc. I believe that my next video will be able to set this mystery to rest once and for all. I will be showing how this object was created and that it was not carved from stone. Please be patient with me as my wife and I have opened a new business and are tied up right now. Thank you for following my channel.
To be fair, a single latch does the same thing. The complexity of the design is essentially proof this isn’t what it’s used for. But it’s an interesting theory.
@@I_SuperHiro_I yes but then it would not be balanced making it difficult to turn. The reason for three lobs is so that an individual did not have to turn or push back and forth. It is much easier to turn in one direction if that is the business that one is in. It has handles on so that it can be rotated, what else can the delicate handles be used for and why would they be there if not needed?
Three lobes create better balance. Second, with three lobes the disc does not have to travel as far to the next lobe. It is far better to turn a disc a one third of the way then having to make one complete circle.
ur missing half of the disc where is the loop back from the hole, what ever this is , its not a sabu disc the sabu disc was perfectly balanced and was made of stone not plastic serving dishes
I think you are very wrong! 1. Why does the disk have to be shaped with the curved edges to spread the grains?? It might as well be a hole…right? 2. Do you really think this grain spreader was so important that you were buried with it when you died? 🤔
Notice as the disc begins to dispense that is starts very slow and as you center the lobs it is at a higher rate of speed. The three lobs are so that one does not have to spin the disc back and forth but they can continue in one direction so not to break their back. It is not a grain spreader it’s a dispenser and the individual was one who dealt in grains. He would have been a merchant.
That it took 4 minutes of gasbagging to get to the demo leads me to believe this is just another exercise in the American obsession to hear themselves talk.
i thought about it being for grain just like you for a long time but i have began thinking it was something that propelled water..... maybe they ran water from the nile river through bamboo perhaps and every 100 yards or so they had the disc spinning to propel the waterflow.... work on that if you can , if you got time..... also thought it may have been a fan that acted sort of like a whirlybird. thanks for the grain demo, good job.
Propel water? There is no screwing action. The blades aren't angled like in a fan. Without that how could it propel anything? Fan, whirlybird? Again, no screwing action. You seem to have no mechanical insight... typical of the fairer sex. So I'm guessing that, by overlooking that basic fact, you are a woman who is trying to be helpful but who is out of her element. Regardless, I'd keep your suggestions coming. Maybe it is a device used in cleaning laundry and you will be the one to uncover that. 🙂
The disc is spun under the stone. The grain is dropped onto it and slung out like a curtain. The flaps help kick it out as it turns. It's a version of the seed caster for ur yard the one that spins and shoots seed out in a spiral out. It runs much faster. Then the disc but same concept. Genetic memory brings everything back. The grinding stone uses a spiral under it to move the grain. It sends it from out to in or vise versa based on how its turned. Grain grinding and sifting is a much needed art and to be able to design tools to make it easy and safer to eat. Is a big deal in the industry. Ur bread is soft and sweet because we made it to be. Lol spoiled are we. Seriously it's called a seed caster or spreader. It was hidden knowledge until me.
I've only started exploring the world of ancient artifacts - I don't really understand the thoughts that items like this have any function that we could understand when the much more incredible fact is that we have no idea how they could even make something like this with such incredible precision.... the questions should more be about how they were able to make something like this. Finding it in location X, x-number of years later - doesn't tell us it's actual age - to 'guess' that it was probably for function x because it was found along with other items that clearly have a certain function seems pointless.
There was a vase that was scanned and engineers talked about how precise it was. I believe it was unchartedx channel. If you know anything about machining it's mind blowing the precision. No measument was more than a few thousandths off. We are only now able to machine granite like the Egyptians did. I'm not even sure we could make some them as thin as they are now.
There is in no way possible that this disc was carved out of one piece of stone. I believe without a doubt that this is a dispenser. I hope to produce a video soon showing just how easy that it was made. Follow this channel.
I appreciate the throught you put into this although I would say a big flaw in this idea is the tri-lobed nature of the disc. Your demonstration leaves no reason to design this very symmetrical tri-lobed disc when for the purpose you have shown there is no reason to make it any more complex than simply one slanted area and one “storage area”, exactly as you have done in your demo. The other dispensers serve no purpose as only one person would be buying grain at the time otherwise moving the disc for one customer would interrupt the service of another. I suggest the disc was used as an impeller of some sort with whatever was driving it connected to the center ring and then it would act as impellers do today which is to say it would create an area of low pressure in the center and fling out the material to the edges (potentially inside of a casing) where the fluid or gas would then be directed into a pipe where that velocity would be converted into pressure. At least that is what it looks like to me. I would love to get a 3-D print of it and put this idea to the test.
I 3d printed one, and swapped it out with the original plastic wheel on the bottom of my cheap push-along broadcaster, Aannnnd.... Threw fertilizer 59% farther than the original part!!
I'm building what is called a step sifter . I can show u exactly how the disc works and the way it's used. It's to cast the grain. It makes a curtain to thin the grain line. It needs be spun and no stores. . The collector idea is close but love the work . My step sifter it clear 0plastic and works off an older wisdom then the disc. But the disc comes from it as well. The tesla tower is the pebble bounce pad set. Ur extremely close. Find me message me . But it hangs under the grinding stone and makes a curtain or viel that drops down to the bounce pads. Then to the Colector and stores. I'm on face book. Look for the red car with the animated dog. Lol. But we can design the whole system together to show truth if u like.
What’s that got to do with this disc though. They are NOTHING alike in any way shape or form. You wanted to drop some knowledge about an Egyptian dish you saw at a museum and tell us about it. It’s like jumping into the comment section and saying: “I’ve seen a Dodge Hellcat at the dealership. It’s red, it’s got 707 horsepower, and it’s Mopar’s answer to the Camaro ZL1 and the new Chevy Corvette. For those who think Dodge doesn’t make good muscle cars.” Nobody is saying the Egyptians didn’t make it; the argument is HOW in the hell they were able to make it and what it’s function was. 🕵️
For those saying the Egyptians could not make this "disc" see this stone dish in the shape of two Egyptian Glyphs at the Met Libation Dish Depicting Ka-Arms Presenting an Ankh-Sign ca. 3100-2900 B.C. Early Dynastic Period On view at The Met Fifth Avenue in Gallery 101 This masterpiece of Early Dynastic stone carving has the shape of two intricately linked hieroglyphs. The two bent arms that frame three sides of the dish are read "ka," the word for "spirit" in ancient Egyptian. The loop and knot are read "ankh," meaning "life," or "to live." The combination could be interpreted as the phrase "life to thy spirit" or as the name of a person, Ankh-ka. The dish was undoubtedly used to pour a purifying liquid, probably water, that would take on the magical significance of the hieroglyphs. www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/543866?deptids=10&high=on&ft=*&offset=80&rpp=40&pos=92
Great idea! Super cool how it stops and also dispenses in a very controlled way. You are very wise and you must be (or should be) a fantastic engineer! You think outside the box and you are a problem solver.
Without reading any previous comments I will tell you my impression of your interpretation of this object. I was searching for confirmation of my believe this was used as a water pump that worked in a shaft somehow and wasn’t expecting to see but really is an excellent interpretation. Wether this distribution was for trade or food rations or distribution to people who were to plant they all could be possibilities. I could image that think being a central hub in a marketplace or state run distribution centre to farmers. I’m sure that agriculture is the most important activity of any thriving civilization and the disc used in this way could have an important part of keep the production moving. Nice work, love your model btw, wasn’t sure about it at first but it’s all you need to demonstrate and explain things very well.
Yup... cut a disk out of slate... slate.... down to nearly paper thin.... to dispense grain....
😂😅 I know right. This dude ruined his crutches for no reason. Too much time on his hands. He just sits around watching his nails grow. The f#ck?!!!🥸🕺💅
Grain is incredibly important to the lives of ancient Egyptians, life or death important. It isn't insane to think they would put that much effort into ways to sort and manage it. Most of Egyptian writing is actually just about that, grain. Storage of food, material etc. it's a major part of ancient history. If you have a better hypothesis you should present it instead of mocking his.
LOL right?!?
Oh yeah. I have a schist disc for my cereal.
Don't you?.
@@annespacedroid almost like cereals arent as important to us as they were to a early agricultural society. Also as other people pointed out in the comments of this video, this item looks most closely like a a device used for incenses and burning. Its decorative
So they go to great technological difficulty to make the delicate disk to handle grain? So using human workers to measure it out with cups, bowls or buckets didn't suffice? Sounds like replacing auto workers with robots except I cannot grasp that the Egyptians, of the era to which the disk is attributed, would seek such a labor-saving device. Qudos for trying to figure-out what this disk was for.
What makes you seem to think that it was difficult for them to achieve? You must not think very highly of these advanced civilizations who build one of the seven wonders of the ancient world, of which we are unable to replicate many of their works today without difficulty. So you do not believe that they were intelligent enough to come up with a way to utilize their workers more efficiently? Yes you would be a great king one day. Why does modern day man seems to think that ancient man was incapable of great achievements and yet modern man racks their brain attempting to figure out just how these feats were accomplished? So you probably believe that this is an incense holder because it is so delicate? I will stick with what I believe that this mechanism is a valve to control the flow of grain so that it will only require one man to dispense grain without it being a back breaking job.
I believe it is seen upside down as well as you were thinking. But I also believe that there is a reason why it tucks back in allowing maybe some kind of thick liquid to go into another container.
It’s a cool thought but you could use sandstone or wood which is much more workable and less brittle. I think it was likely an ornament of some description with no practical use sadly!
I like the thought, it has to have a functional reason for it to exist. Shame so many people come here with negative words about your ideas yet have no ideas of their own to contribute. Well done for making it work, hope your recovery is speedy sir.
Definitely a possibility. I still wonder why it would end up in a tomb, were other practical things found in the tomb or was it all ornamental?
As in modern day, kings, the wealthy, bribed Gov't officials collect and cherish expensive ad rare things: jewlery, artwork, cars, etc...The Schist Disc may have been passed down from generation to generation and ended up inside a kings tomb as an expensive, collectible.
Very smart thinking of practical uses although the lobes bent underneath would seem to get in the way of filling any type of container.
Once it was discovered that this was in fact a grain dispenser everything else fell into place. Notice as I go from storage to feed that the rice starts to flows very slowly and as I get centered to the lobe the flow increases. The lobe works as a funnel and it controls the rate of feed as the disc is rotated. Notice that I am filling a 10-12” pan that also about 12-15” below the disc.
Appreciate your comment.
@@Burdened_Crypt Occam’s Razor- the simplest solution is usually right!
The seed caster or spreader is spun with the grinding wheel. It casts out the grain into a curtain. This thins the grain to help the debris and pebbles bounce out.
The curtain then drops on the bounce pad set below. It's the step sifter to bounce the rocks.
This set up is a later known design of step sifting. But before was more extravagant. .some sifters even made music.
Some made an stored energy from static and conetic energy. These had to be grounded or a spark ark could cause fires even huge explosions. The grinding wheels can get hot and explode apart as well. If uve never seen one explode it's a treet lol. But they fly out quite far and dangerously. U would would let the grain build around to help contain it lol.
A ring would develop.
Anyway. I've been in the industry in many different aspects. From farm to table literally made the table and the farm tools. Made corn chips lol it's cool. U probably ate them. But the industry is the hiden key. The Egyptian dance makes fun of the works in the field. Using a pine cone. Ever wonder why they hold there hands that way. Lol
He has a pretty good case. I wish someone would build a exact replica and spin it to see if creates aome sort of sound
So why the 3 outlets, then? why not just 1 if it was a grain dispenser? Filling three bags/pots at once?
to dispense seeds on land.
Now that is one wild guess 🤔
You got me I guess it!🏆 Took me a whole three days to figure out that this items was a grain dispenser. 🤫
This lobed disk is with absolute sure, a blender for paint in a big barrel. It is pushed and pulled upp and down in a barrel to get homogen paint. I´ve seen (used) it in reality. It mixed paint really effektive. Ive used it myself when i painted barns with the swedish "Falu rödfärg" or in english Falu redpaint. (Falu red paint, also known as Falun red or Falu rödfärg in Swedish, is traditionally made from a pigment called Falu red pigment or Falu red paint. This pigment is derived from copper-rich iron ochres mined from quarries near the town of Falun in Sweden. The pigment consists mainly of iron oxide (hematite) with varying amounts of silica and zinc.
The process of making Falu red paint involves grinding the iron-rich ochre into a fine powder and mixing it with water, flour or starch, and sometimes linseed oil. This mixture creates a thick paste that can be applied to wood, giving it a distinctive red color. Falu red paint is widely used in Sweden for painting wooden houses, barns, and other structures due to its durability and traditional aesthetic appeal.)
Could the disc be a trophy left for eternity ,when spun, creates a field , much like a magnet . The disc capable of folding 1 pole into the other, like Ed liniskillions 48 pole, hand spun, magnetic device, nullified mass.
It does not make sense to use such an enormously difficult stone to carve , for a grain dispenser. Why leave a grain dispenser , made to crazy tolerances in a pyramid with all the vases.
The disc was an anti gravity device. Not the day to day device that did all the heavy lifting of the magaliths, but a trophy capable of lasting eternity.
AG is about folding 1 pole into the other. Creating a field, much like a magnet, but singularly piled. Anything within this field, mass was nullified or lessoned. They still need sleds to move the massive stone, but the stone essentially weighed less.
No lol
@@_MikeJon_ not with a shut mind, keep researching your ridiculous grain Dispensery idea
I do not believe that the stone was carved. It is possible that it was formed into this shape much like working with clay. I have studied the megalithic stones and believe that they too are formed into place.
I have done a few experiments where I have replicated the shapes of stones and I can also explain the nubs that stick out from the stone.
The stone had to be lightweight if it were going to be manually turned by hand. The stone “supposedly schist would have turned easy on a wood base.
The disc could have been made out of would but eventually the wood could dry out causing grain to be lodged in the wood grain. I believe the grain would flow much better across schist stone than wood.
I wouldn’t say something unless I was certain what it was used for, I am an antique dealer and very good at identifying what objects are used for and it is not anything else.
I don’t not believe that it was a grain dispenser, I know that it is.
Sorry don’t mean to sound cocky but I know exactly what it is. Give it time, folks will soon realize.
1.. why would you need 4 side for this and 2... I think you need to focus more on where to find yourself some finger nail clippers.
I'm pretty sure they did this in ancient times, but not with a disk. They just had the funnel swinging and it was at rest closed. I'm leaning towards sound manipulation for some reason myself. Just a thought to explore now.
Sound manipulation? Or magnetic manipulation. I believe the disc when spun created a bi magnetic pole capable of mass nullification
@@GWAForUTBE Haven't heard that, but I'll look into it. Tesla said everything is waves and frequency and energy. This makes me think the Egyptians were closer to knowing how waves can manipulate things. They definitely used sound for a lot of things. The great pyramid does alter the earth's magnetic field.
@@robbsclassics the great pyramid was a Terraform machine. Providing Earths ionsphere and vibrating the continent's to eliminate large earthquakes.
@@GWAForUTBE Can you give me some info on this?
This is actually part of a bigger machine. The whole machine is not there, but it’s used for anti-gravity. How do you think those big stones were moved?
I agree? Pls elaborate on the rest of the machine. I believe it only needed a bearing and some angular momentum and to be placed on a huge stone. It was a trophy tho.
Anti gravity? 😂😂😂
John this Mike fella from this channel is a shut mind, you are right on the money with it being an AG device
Could you elaborate about it being part of a machine?
@@GWAForUTBE this was for beer making 🤣
@@_MikeJon_ made of metalstone and left for 1000s of yrs . This was much more than a mixer
Thats cool.. why need 3 ports though, so can fill 3 sack at once i suppose
The disc would not be moved back and forth as I demonstrated they would have just continued around in the same direction. I would imagine with the weight of grain that pulling it around would be much easier than pushing. The base would have been made of wood to reduce friction between the base and the disc.
Any updates? have you built the entire thing yet?
My apologies for the late response, I am getting over my brain surgery. I hope soon to bring some new information that I discovered about this disc. I believe that my next video will be able to set this mystery to rest once and for all.
I will be showing how this object was created and that it was not carved from stone.
Please be patient with me as my wife and I have opened a new business and are tied up right now.
Thank you for following my channel.
cool! we were just thinking of a better way to feed the chickens. thanks
Nope, Nope and Nope.
Interesting, But I guess it would be too hard to put a door on a silo, but at least the grain would be protected from pests.
To be fair, a single latch does the same thing. The complexity of the design is essentially proof this isn’t what it’s used for.
But it’s an interesting theory.
@@I_SuperHiro_I yes but then it would not be balanced making it difficult to turn. The reason for three lobs is so that an individual did not have to turn or push back and forth. It is much easier to turn in one direction if that is the business that one is in. It has handles on so that it can be rotated, what else can the delicate handles be used for and why would they be there if not needed?
Why three openings then? just one would be enough.
Three lobes create better balance. Second, with three lobes the disc does not have to travel as far to the next lobe. It is far better to turn a disc a one third of the way then having to make one complete circle.
@@Burdened_Crypt Thanks,
Maybe 3 types of grain?
ur missing half of the disc where is the loop back from the hole, what ever this is , its not a sabu disc the sabu disc was perfectly balanced and was made of stone not plastic serving dishes
No wonder it's the only thing Prince Sabu owned.
I think you are very wrong!
1. Why does the disk have to be shaped with the curved edges to spread the grains?? It might as well be a hole…right?
2. Do you really think this grain spreader was so important that you were buried with it when you died? 🤔
Notice as the disc begins to dispense that is starts very slow and as you center the lobs it is at a higher rate of speed. The three lobs are so that one does not have to spin the disc back and forth but they can continue in one direction so not to break their back.
It is not a grain spreader it’s a dispenser and the individual was one who dealt in grains. He would have been a merchant.
That it took 4 minutes of gasbagging to get to the demo leads me to believe this is just another exercise in the American obsession to hear themselves talk.
i thought about it being for grain just like you for a long time but i have began thinking it was something that propelled water..... maybe they ran water from the nile river through bamboo perhaps and every 100 yards or so they had the disc spinning to propel the waterflow.... work on that if you can , if you got time..... also thought it may have been a fan that acted sort of like a whirlybird. thanks for the grain demo, good job.
Propel water? There is no screwing action. The blades aren't angled like in a fan. Without that how could it propel anything? Fan, whirlybird? Again, no screwing action. You seem to have no mechanical insight... typical of the fairer sex. So I'm guessing that, by overlooking that basic fact, you are a woman who is trying to be helpful but who is out of her element. Regardless, I'd keep your suggestions coming. Maybe it is a device used in cleaning laundry and you will be the one to uncover that. 🙂
The disc is spun under the stone. The grain is dropped onto it and slung out like a curtain. The flaps help kick it out as it turns. It's a version of the seed caster for ur yard the one that spins and shoots seed out in a spiral out.
It runs much faster. Then the disc but same concept. Genetic memory brings everything back.
The grinding stone uses a spiral under it to move the grain. It sends it from out to in or vise versa based on how its turned. Grain grinding and sifting is a much needed art and to be able to design tools to make it easy and safer to eat. Is a big deal in the industry. Ur bread is soft and sweet because we made it to be. Lol spoiled are we.
Seriously it's called a seed caster or spreader. It was hidden knowledge until me.
Who knows.. i lean towards victor schaubergers work. This would not have to rotate. Just guide water into a vortex.
I've only started exploring the world of ancient artifacts - I don't really understand the thoughts that items like this have any function that we could understand when the much more incredible fact is that we have no idea how they could even make something like this with such incredible precision.... the questions should more be about how they were able to make something like this. Finding it in location X, x-number of years later - doesn't tell us it's actual age - to 'guess' that it was probably for function x because it was found along with other items that clearly have a certain function seems pointless.
There was a vase that was scanned and engineers talked about how precise it was. I believe it was unchartedx channel. If you know anything about machining it's mind blowing the precision. No measument was more than a few thousandths off. We are only now able to machine granite like the Egyptians did. I'm not even sure we could make some them as thin as they are now.
Carved from stone? very difficult design to be grain dispenser. Making that disk from has been very costly and I bet it is not used for rises..
There is in no way possible that this disc was carved out of one piece of stone.
I believe without a doubt that this is a dispenser.
I hope to produce a video soon showing just how easy that it was made.
Follow this channel.
I appreciate the throught you put into this although I would say a big flaw in this idea is the tri-lobed nature of the disc.
Your demonstration leaves no reason to design this very symmetrical tri-lobed disc when for the purpose you have shown there is no reason to make it any more complex than simply one slanted area and one “storage area”, exactly as you have done in your demo. The other dispensers serve no purpose as only one person would be buying grain at the time otherwise moving the disc for one customer would interrupt the service of another.
I suggest the disc was used as an impeller of some sort with whatever was driving it connected to the center ring and then it would act as impellers do today which is to say it would create an area of low pressure in the center and fling out the material to the edges (potentially inside of a casing) where the fluid or gas would then be directed into a pipe where that velocity would be converted into pressure.
At least that is what it looks like to me. I would love to get a 3-D print of it and put this idea to the test.
Completely wrong thoughts
Dude, you've over engineered your lazy Susan.
Maybe, ? But original made of Schist.
Maybe.
I 3d printed one, and swapped it out with the original plastic wheel on the bottom of my cheap push-along broadcaster,
Aannnnd....
Threw fertilizer 59% farther than the original part!!
OR I KNOW.... A ROPE MAKING TOOL.. IT MAKES PERFECT SENSE
Why use stone and why so fragile?
Possible.
Uh yeah, no…
I'm building what is called a step sifter . I can show u exactly how the disc works and the way it's used.
It's to cast the grain. It makes a curtain to thin the grain line. It needs be spun and no stores. . The collector idea is close but love the work . My step sifter it clear 0plastic and works off an older wisdom then the disc. But the disc comes from it as well.
The tesla tower is the pebble bounce pad set. Ur extremely close. Find me message me . But it hangs under the grinding stone and makes a curtain or viel that drops down to the bounce pads. Then to the Colector and stores. I'm on face book. Look for the red car with the animated dog. Lol. But we can design the whole system together to show truth if u like.
???
Its an anti gravity disc
nonsense
What’s that got to do with this disc though. They are NOTHING alike in any way shape or form. You wanted to drop some knowledge about an Egyptian dish you saw at a museum and tell us about it. It’s like jumping into the comment section and saying: “I’ve seen a Dodge Hellcat at the dealership. It’s red, it’s got 707 horsepower, and it’s Mopar’s answer to the Camaro ZL1 and the new Chevy Corvette. For those who think Dodge doesn’t make good muscle cars.” Nobody is saying the Egyptians didn’t make it; the argument is HOW in the hell they were able to make it and what it’s function was. 🕵️
It was made out of a soft stone lol. And this entire video was about the "why" did you even watch it? 😂
This makes no sense.
hahaha... nice joke
For those saying the Egyptians could not make this "disc" see this stone dish in the shape of two Egyptian Glyphs at the Met
Libation Dish Depicting Ka-Arms Presenting an Ankh-Sign
ca. 3100-2900 B.C.
Early Dynastic Period
On view at The Met Fifth Avenue in Gallery 101
This masterpiece of Early Dynastic stone carving has the shape of two intricately linked hieroglyphs. The two bent arms that frame three sides of the dish are read "ka," the word for "spirit" in ancient Egyptian. The loop and knot are read "ankh," meaning "life," or "to live." The combination could be interpreted as the phrase "life to thy spirit" or as the name of a person, Ankh-ka. The dish was undoubtedly used to pour a purifying liquid, probably water, that would take on the magical significance of the hieroglyphs.
www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/543866?deptids=10&high=on&ft=*&offset=80&rpp=40&pos=92