I would take a hard pass. Don't mind trading away, Stoman, but I am not trading away Warren or Jones for a bad contract in Bellinger whose best years may be behind him. Also, the Yankess can't afford to trade away young controllable pitching, which has been depleted the past year.
Sign burnes and either fried or the Japanese pitcher. Stick durbin in the infield wherever Jazz doesn't play. Move Judge to 1st and get a speedster CF until Jones is ready
Yeah, I will pass hard on this one!! I would like to see Durban playing second and Spencer. Eventually playing centerfield will save us money that we can spend on pitching.
Cubs Fan here , Hoerner can play GG level SS too , No way Cubs take Stroman back, Clubhouse issues and rub with the front office , Now Bellinger and 10M from the Cubs for an arm would make sense for the Yankees and Cubs but no way would i take Belli unless 10M was sent to pay the AAV down to 17.5 looking at it from the Yankees side , He would positionally be a great fit for the Yankees
I don’t know why I’m not as nervous or anxious with the Soto situation as I was with Judge but for 700 mil we could get some really good players and I’ll always use 96 as my example that you don’t need superstars to win 😊
I can't see this deal happening. I like Hoerner, and actually wouldn't even mind trading a good prospect (not Jones) for him , but I don't want anything to do with Bellinger. He's way too expensive and inconsistent from year to year. As I understand it, Stroman burned every bit of bridge he had with the Cubs. They wouldn't touch him with a 50 foot pole.
They're still losing two pitchers for what amounts to an expensive crap shoot. I'd need Chicago to pick up some of the salary in 2025 and 2026 if necessary with regards to Bellinger. This would make the team better to an extent but not drastically.
I don't think they should do this at all. If we get soto I really think they should consider playing Jones at first see how he does in spring training and if not then I would consider signing walker to a 2 year deal but the second year is a player option
As usual, during this off season, we're using, Common Sense, when it comes, too, moves and trades. However, what we keep forgetting is Boone still has the ability, too, screw, everything up.
I don’t like that trade too much money unless send about 8 million in the deal I don’t want Horner if you lose Soto maybe I would take Bellinger Tucker is the guy would try get as a replacement for Soto if we needed to do that
No thanks. Crazy trade proposal is quite accurate. Why would anyone even consider that. I believe Dominguez' numbers will be better than Bellinger and Hoerner wasn't so hot last year. I get Stro has an albatross contract, but that's too much to give up for a pig and a poke
Cody Bellinger would be great at first we already have jazz is going to play second Caleb is going to 3rd forget about Nico let's get that Lefty starter Japanese picture
I’M OKAY WITH STROHMAN LEAVING, BUT NOT JONES. AS FOR BRINGING BACK SOTO, I’M NOT FEELING VERY OPTIMISTIC. WE SHOULD APPROACH THIS AS IF SOTO DOESN’T RETURN….DON’T MEAN TO BE A DOWNER, JUST BEING REALISTIC.
Warren and Jones are not moving the needle for me. Both are talented players but have big holes in their game. jones a 40 percent strikeout rate and only hit about 15 or 19 homers in a full season when power is supposed to be his game. Warren had an awful era and hitters squared him up and lit him up although he did strike out alot of hitters.
We need Spencer Jones in the outfield for the New York Yankees because if they don't get Soto the New York Yankees are screwed I will trade Stroman Clark Schmidt now
Verdugo is gone, we need to fill that spot out in left field!Chaz Chisholm needs to go from 3rd to 2nd base and get someone to play at 3rd! We need a first baseman! And at least we need to pick up a good starting pitcher on the Yankees rotation! The Yankees bullpen ain't up to par! Bellinger is a question mark! Not sure how much production the Yankees can get out of him! He was a very good player while playing for the dodgers but that's why the dodgers got rid of him because he's lost some finess and it's a gamble for the Yankees!
And....... Here's another One!!!!! Who did the Yankees give Up for SOTO???? BTW...Is not Coming Back and We Got NO RING TO SHOW FOR IT????? Another MAJOR PROSPECT!!! NO MO Trading the YOUTH!!!
From a purely baseball standpoint.. not a bad deal.. but from a business deal.. I'd walk away. That chisox guy... I'm not that high on him.. being star on a bad team often comes to the Yanks and makes our fanbase burn them in effigy...
We been there and done that. Gleybor has a lot of talent and can hit when he wants to, but makes to many errors at critical times and makes bad decisions and is lazy.
I would take a hard pass. Don't mind trading away, Stoman, but I am not trading away Warren or Jones for a bad contract in Bellinger whose best years may be behind him. Also, the Yankess can't afford to trade away young controllable pitching, which has been depleted the past year.
warren is garbage so is stroman why would the cubs do the trade just for jones ?
Sign burnes and either fried or the Japanese pitcher. Stick durbin in the infield wherever Jazz doesn't play. Move Judge to 1st and get a speedster CF until Jones is ready
great plan.
No way!
i like it but i don't like that player option for Bellinger in 26
Yeah, I will pass hard on this one!! I would like to see Durban playing second and Spencer. Eventually playing centerfield will save us money that we can spend on pitching.
Cubs Fan here , Hoerner can play GG level SS too , No way Cubs take Stroman back, Clubhouse issues and rub with the front office , Now Bellinger and 10M from the Cubs for an arm would make sense for the Yankees and Cubs but no way would i take Belli unless 10M was sent to pay the AAV down to 17.5 looking at it from the Yankees side , He would positionally be a great fit for the Yankees
Hard hard pass on Bellenger, dude is not worth anything close to what he's getting paid.
Bellinger Won't Get Better...The Yankee Prospects Might Get Better
I don’t know why I’m not as nervous or anxious with the Soto situation as I was with Judge but for 700 mil we could get some really good players and I’ll always use 96 as my example that you don’t need superstars to win 😊
I would go for the Bellinger alone option.
If Bellinger had a better year, might consider it. Durbin can be a spark plug, so Horner is a non factor.
👎 so a no go for me
I like the players but not Bellinger's contract- pass.
Cubs would pay it down probably 10M
I can't see this deal happening. I like Hoerner, and actually wouldn't even mind trading a good prospect (not Jones) for him , but I don't want anything to do with Bellinger. He's way too expensive and inconsistent from year to year. As I understand it, Stroman burned every bit of bridge he had with the Cubs. They wouldn't touch him with a 50 foot pole.
They're still losing two pitchers for what amounts to an expensive crap shoot. I'd need Chicago to pick up some of the salary in 2025 and 2026 if necessary with regards to Bellinger. This would make the team better to an extent but not drastically.
I don't think they should do this at all. If we get soto I really think they should consider playing Jones at first see how he does in spring training and if not then I would consider signing walker to a 2 year deal but the second year is a player option
They need Soto and pitching , anything else is a waste
I'd love to get Soto, but NOT signing him would free up a lot of money to patch a bunch of Yankee holes.
This is NOT a deal I would like to see.
I pass not trading Jones in this d eal
Cubs already got us with the Rizzo deal. That's a easy pass.
As usual, during this off season, we're using, Common Sense, when it comes, too, moves and trades. However, what we keep forgetting is Boone still has the ability, too, screw, everything up.
I wouldn't do the trade .bellenger is injury prone if I trade Spencer it would be for pitching
I don’t like that trade too much money unless send about 8 million in the deal I don’t want Horner if you lose Soto maybe I would take Bellinger Tucker is the guy would try get as a replacement for Soto if we needed to do that
No thanks. Crazy trade proposal is quite accurate. Why would anyone even consider that. I believe Dominguez' numbers will be better than Bellinger and Hoerner wasn't so hot last year. I get Stro has an albatross contract, but that's too much to give up for a pig and a poke
Financially trade makes no sense unless Cubs cover 100% of Bellinger’s salary + Cubs #1 prospect.
You are high , Shaw is better than the entire yankees package coming back plus you want Belli and 27.5M , cool story Bro.
Cody Bellinger would be great at first we already have jazz is going to play second Caleb is going to 3rd forget about Nico let's get that Lefty starter Japanese picture
I’ll probably add Nester Cortes To that deal
Interesting trade but i say no good
Need to love Spencer to 1st base in triple A and get him ready
will he ever be ready ? 200k's in AA this year
Spencer trade for pitching. Bellinger is good but overpaid. Will Warren at best might work out as relief guy. Stroman yeah trade him somewhere
I’M OKAY WITH STROHMAN LEAVING, BUT NOT JONES.
AS FOR BRINGING BACK SOTO, I’M NOT FEELING VERY OPTIMISTIC.
WE SHOULD APPROACH THIS AS IF SOTO DOESN’T RETURN….DON’T MEAN TO BE A DOWNER, JUST BEING REALISTIC.
Warren and Jones are not moving the needle for me. Both are talented players but have big holes in their game. jones a 40 percent strikeout rate and only hit about 15 or 19 homers in a full season when power is supposed to be his game. Warren had an awful era and hitters squared him up and lit him up although he did strike out alot of hitters.
It's not worth it I'm sorry it's not worth us to give up our talent to the Cubs it's not worth it
Keep Jones and Warren. Stroman for a MiLB player is fair. As for Dominguez, starting Opening Day, play him.
We need Spencer Jones in the outfield for the New York Yankees because if they don't get Soto the New York Yankees are screwed I will trade Stroman Clark Schmidt now
So why can't we just get Profar? Then it's Profar, Judge, Dominguez. If no Soto, I'll take that outfield any day.
Jones hasn’t even played in triple aaa yet.. he is not ready for prime time.
I'd never include Spencer Jones in a trade for bellinger
Stupid they’re not trading Jones
I would take Nico hoerner only ¡!! They need pitching. I would not give up Jones. Stromam needs to go
I dont like it.
I’M WITH YOU 🙏🏽
If they want Bellinger, they had a chance to sign him at the beginning of 2024 season without giving up anybody.
I would pass on the deal, without a thought. Bellinger's ship has sailed!!!!!
Spencer alone could bat better than any of the two in the new future. He is a future big one, unless for some ace-type pitcher.
Why would the Cubs take back Stroman??? That's the question 🤔
I wish I knew!
Naaaa I’m
Good ,trade stroman only
Verdugo is gone, we need to fill that spot out in left field!Chaz Chisholm needs to go from 3rd to 2nd base and get someone to play at 3rd! We need a first baseman!
And at least we need to pick up a good starting pitcher on the Yankees rotation! The Yankees bullpen ain't up to par! Bellinger is a question mark! Not sure how much production the Yankees can get out of him! He was a very good player while playing for the dodgers but that's why the dodgers got rid of him because he's lost some finess and it's a gamble for the Yankees!
I don't want to part with Jones unless it is a package for a guy like Crochet.
jones had 200k'S in AA this year
@garyt19651 Never said I don't want to trade him. The target should be a young SP. Not a guy that will turn 30 next season.
NO..... NOT Trading Spencer Jones !!!!
And....... Here's another One!!!!! Who did the Yankees give Up for SOTO???? BTW...Is not Coming Back and We Got NO RING TO SHOW FOR IT????? Another MAJOR PROSPECT!!! NO MO Trading the YOUTH!!!
I didn’t want belly last offseason, and I don’t want him this offseason.
Yankees fans falling in love with prospects who never pan out. Same shit, different day.
No thanks…Ben Rice had 7hrs in what…152ab.
He also hit .177
Why would you trade Jones for an older, more expensive version of himself?
I usually don't agree with much this guy says.I would like Stroman gone.
From a purely baseball standpoint.. not a bad deal.. but from a business deal.. I'd walk away. That chisox guy... I'm not that high on him.. being star on a bad team often comes to the Yanks and makes our fanbase burn them in effigy...
not a fan of Bellinger. he's had enough down seasons that i don't feel like i could depend on him. guy could be even worse next season
👎👎👎
Bad trade at all
Guess what!!! Spencer is A Lefty!!😜
I’m a cubs fan
I would do it today
I don't mind the first trade but Bellinger is getting twice as much as he deserves.Not my money but if they don't get Soto then ok.
Yea I like the deal why not wat has Jones done anyways
trade for Bellinger....hes a perfect fit....his ability to play CF or 1B would give the Yanks much needed flexibility
Father and son Bellinger
The NYY shuld trade Srogman, Cortes, and Rodon fòr Statdr
Do it yankees
Yes trade Stroman for bellinger
Hard pass, sign Gleyber Torres!! He’s the best 2B available
We been there and done that. Gleybor has a lot of talent and can hit when he wants to, but makes to many errors at critical times and makes bad decisions and is lazy.
Yes let's get that going yes strawman ain't that at all let's jump at this deal now
that will never happen i am a die cub fan you funny
No Spencer Jones. Somebody else