People LITERALLY called her FAT when she CLEARLY was not. She was talking about her OWN insecurity and the effects other people can have on you. People are just looking for a reason to hate on Taylor Swift. Unsuccessful people try to tear down successful people so they feel just as bad as them!!
this scene was the scene that resonated with me the most, watching it for the first time. it’s sad it got removed because it almost shuts taylor down for having insecurities
Me to i weighed 50-75 pounds my entire child hood cause the pressures of beauty standards in the home (you could grab my ribs elementary to 8th grade thats how bad it was tho didnt understand I had an eating disorder until I turned 20 and started looking back and I just thought every one had these fears and anxiety over there body's and since I was raised with the mindset of beauty being skinny was to be protected at all cost ...so thats more so why I didnt know I had a eating disorder because I spent my entire childhood and teen yrs with it
People calling this fatphobia know NOTHING about having eating desorders. Imagine STARVING YOURSELF and always looking at those numbers and still considering yourself fat. Or in the other hand, being so depressed that you cannot stop eating. She is expressing in the music video how that happened in her mind as a person suffering from an eating desorder, but ig Twitter just wants to take people down.
EXACTLY!! people are just too blinded by themselves to comprehend that people who are considered “skinny” can see themselves as “fat” when their brains are warped by body dysmorphia. so many of these comments are giving off “if you have an eating disorder you’re fatphobic” vibes👀
When I saw this part of the mv, i really felt like i saw myself. starving, eating once a day or none at all, then getting to weigh myself and never being satisfied. in my head would echo “yup still fat” and it was a never ending, vicious and frustrating cycle. I have never fat shamed anyone, would support people’s weightloss journeys, never made comments on people’s weight/body shape. however, this didnt change how I saw MYSELF. i think TS was really showing us her body dysmorphia and her struggle with having an ED, all the media hate and pressures.
@Fun and Strum no it's not. I'm fat too, and most people miss the entire purpose of this scene. They just take this scene out of context without understanding any meaning beneath the surface. This is Taylor's INTERNAL critic. Something we all have. The internal critic isn't nice or kind. They're shitty, like this. And Taylor has been called fat in the media, which is where her insecurities come from. Telling her that she can't share them because there are people who "are actually fat" is also quite problematic, and not a good representation of the body positivity movement
@Fun and Strum That doesn't make much sense because me as a fat person trying to change my body and having body dysphoria doesn't mean that I'm fatphobic, it means that I was "taught" that being fat is bad, that is perpetuated in our childhood. The same goes to Taylor, she doesn't see a problem with other people being fat but in your brain you try to fit in a certain standard and you don't want to be fat.
I actually like the scene a lot because I can relate to a lot when it comes to my eating disorder and I hate the fact that the internet had to ruin something so good like she's allowed to tell her story
it’s literally a representation of her own eating disorder so yeah exactly. that’s part of most eating disorders. it’s not fatphobia like people are saying.
I actually prefer the new version! And I've been dealing with body dysmorphia and eating disorders for most of my 40 years on this planet. The new version is just as clear, and just as relatable for people with ED, without contributing to the stigma around the word "fat". I'm honestly proud of Taylor for taking the criticism to heart and making a small change
As a fat person, I wasn't offended by this particular scene. She was criticizing how sometimes people criticize her body for being "too fat" or "too thin, they are never satisfied with the way she looks, and she ends up feeling insecure with herself because of it. But she doesn't have to please anyone. She is a human being, not a dummy. She can have spots on her skin, pores, cellulite, stretch marks, pimples, scars, blackheads, localized fat, gain weight or lose weight, it's human.
@@miraculousgoldengirl636she's a musician, she was forced to do it because people were literally threatening to cancel her. If she thought it waa wrong (which btw it wasn't at all) she would never have added it in. Honestly the people crying about this are the same people that go 'fat isn't a bad thing' . Practice what you preach? A lot of people being offended by something doesn't automatically make it bad
Even skinny people deal with weight issues and feeling like they aren’t skinny enough. It’s not them seeking attention. It’s them being insecure, which everyone does. I personally think they are beautiful.
@@kyleemeg2171yea, the Kardashians just create affiliations with companies that do photography about child BDSM which is disgusting and inappropriate. But yet they try to preach "family"
I hate that she was pressured to delete it, as someone who has struggled w anorexia I found it refreshing that she brought it up like that and it's no one else's business, she was speaking her truth and they went after her simply bc they like to hate on her. It's HER song about HER life, ppl just need to back off.
The video was literally about self destructive tendencies and Taylor had an eating disorder that is what this scene is about, the mistake of basing your worth on something trivial like your weight
i feel like she was trying to represent how society will never be content with celebs’ bodies. they’re never “perfect”. they’re always “too fat” or “too skinny”
@@hisookey136 sure she is "skinny" but she was also told that she is just a pretty face, that she is fat, and that she must be pregnant by the media numerous times. Front page articles saying she has gained weight and must be pregnant
Imagine opening up about your personal trauma and getting cancelled for it...from people that have the same issues. I don't normally get worked up about stuff like this but this one is disgusting. The fact that people got mad about this implies that they think skinny people can't have an ED and discourages them from seeking help. Imagine how many people saw Taylor get crap for this and decided they would keep quiet so they don't get cancelled too.
I know its crazy people think their helping by "cancelling" her. trying to get rid of any mention of EDs or "how could she use the word FAT?!! CANCELLED!!" because they think their helping people with EDs is so dumb
She literally opened up brutally and confessed to one of her deepest insecurities. People somehow making it their own problem and asking to delete it. 😂 Tay Tay is such an inspiration, is hard to talk about your feelings as it is. I can’t imagine how harsh it must be for her to trust others let alone talk about her feelings when everything you say “is controversial”. 🤦♀️
Honestly I think the “after” is even more effective. Like the audience doesn’t need this to be spelled out for them. It’s too on the nose that there was a close-up of the word Fat on the scale. It’s way more striking and moving that you just see alternative Taylor looking down and then shaking her head. That scale could say anything at all and she still wouldn’t be satisfied.
@@miraculousgoldengirl636IT FORCES YOU TO BELIEVE BEING BIGGER IS A BAD THING AND TO FEAR IT. THAT IS LITERALLY WHAT BODY DYSMORPHIA FORCES YOU TO THINK. FAT PEOPLE’S FEELINGS DONT FUCKING NEED TO BE PRIORITIZED IN A VIDEO ABOUT *TAYLOR’S* FEELINGS
@@miraculousgoldengirl636Taylor in a body suit is basically Taylor's brand. The before doesn't mean to show that being fat is bad, just that her brand (managers, etc) push her to be skinny, which is part of what caused her ED. She's not framing being fat as bad, she's framing her industry and brand as harmful towards her.
I feel it’s very powerful to have the “fat” part in. It shows that everyone no matter there weight, there status, there popularity we all have insecurities about how we feel and that most of the time it’s just us putting ourselves down.
Taylor wasn’t being fatphobic. She was simply sharing her experiences. I don’t think that should have been deleted because it may have helped other people through what they are going through. So they felt less alone. Sometimes it can help just to know that you aren’t alone and someone else is going through the same thing as you. Love you tay tay!!!😘😘😘
As someone who's bodypositive, this is not fatphobic. It's explaining anorexia and body dismorphia (please forgive me if I spelled that wrong) which matters just as much as fat shamming.
during her 1988 era, she was fat shamed SO SO much and she had an eating disorder, she almost fainted on stage and she was at her thinnest while people still called her fat.
I wasn’t talking about Taylor, I was talking about the people hating on her for including the scene in her video. People have been calling her fat-phobic for sharing her insecurities. 🫠
I still like the after it’s a cleaner shot and it’s not spoon fed to you, you still get the general gist while also keeping it one nicer looking longer shot
I think this is the picture of her trauma from the stigma of that whole pregnancy thing and how she took it way too much serious and have take the stress hell out of it. She had already explained well in the Miss Americana. The Masterpiece❤️.
I have some weight on me and this didn’t offend me at all. If anything, it highlights that anybody of any size can have insecurities about their weight. Y’all forget that the body positivity movement includes ALL bodies, even the ones you might deem perfect. The video was beautifully made, and she never should’ve been attacked to the point she had to change a REAL moment people go through!
Honestly preferred it before it was edited. Gave more context. There's nothing wrong with Taylor putting "fat" on the scale. She is allowed to artistically express her feelings however she wants and I'm disgusted how the "fat acceptance" cult bullied her to change it. Here's something for them: IT'S. NOT. ABOUT. YOU. Grow up and understand that you can't make the world fall on their knees to make you feel comfortable. If you don't like something, move on.
The side I saw wasn't about fat acceptance,it was people with eating disorders talking about how while talking your eating disorder experience is good, putting that isn't conductive to a recovery mindset especially when you're in the limelight
Y todo por culpa de gente que se indigna por qué ella exprese como se sintió cuando tuvo un transtorno alimenticio 😒 ahora la sociedad te dice como debes expresar tus sentimientos no vayas a ofender a los demás
Si la verdad siempre me a parecido estúpido cuando mis familiares me dicen que debo cuidar mis palabras para no ofender a nadie cuando expresó mi opinión, pero me parece estúpido yo expresare lo que veo según mi criterio y no voy a disfrazar la verdad para que los idiotas no se ofendan y luego dicen que la sinceridad es un valor muy importante, en fin la hipocresía
Totalmente de acuerdo, yo soy gordo y nunca tuve problemas con la escena original ya que como bien lo has dicho, lo del video es algo que tiene que ver exclusivamente con Taylor y no sobre los demás, pero como siempre hay gente que todo le parece mal y hay que contentarlos😒
Exacto. Pregonan amor y comprensión pero te callan si tu has pasado por eso y quieres expresarlo. Una vez más, se nota que los que más los callan son los que menos han padecido algo como discriminación o problemas mentales
Respect to Taylor for deleting that scene, cuz she doesn't want people to see "fat" as a negative thing. People call Taylor "fat" for gaining weight and not being skinny anymore, they're trying to make Taylor insecure about herself. She doesn't want people to feel the same.
i watched the mv before it was removed and as someone who has had issues with eating. this is how you feel. on the outside you may be underweight, but what you see in the mirror is someone who's overweight. and it doesn't help people called/calls her fat when she isn't at all. when you have people around you calling you ___, you're gonna end up believing it. whether if it's true or not. i'm sad she gave into deleting that scene
I wish they had left that in. I’m currently struggling with an eating disorder relapse because of literally all the other stuff in that song. It’s ridiculous how baggy my pants have become in three months.
Im just glad I got to see the orig and got to be on time when it was live posted People are trying so hard to reject an actual fact just cause their perceptions are different from others invalidating the feelings and self thinking.
it’s her own experience. she wasn’t pushing this on anyone else. this is what SHE went through and chose to put it in HER music video. just leave her alone
I saw the premiere and I felt so happy for her for finally opening up about this, I have an eating disorder myself and I can not eat all day and it leads to me binge eating and it’s a horrible cycle I hate and I’m pretty sure Taylor went through something like this and you wouldn’t believe how much I felt seen to know that someone like her knows what it’s like, seeing her receiving so much hate for this makes me hate humanity more than ever, all she wanted was to tell people that it’s okay and they’re not alone
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 that's what they use to telll her, why americans are so dramatic making a scandal for every little thing. Yes now that is fatphobia🤣 yall make me laugh(btw i am fat but i don't make a drama for everything) she talks about body dysmorphia. Y'all need to chill...
@@tenebrousjones4897 what are you achieving with this? Do you really think canceling Taylor swift over a scene that is supposed to contribute to the lore of her story is going to stop eating disorders? If you care so deeply about eating disorders how about you donate to an organization, oh or call out actual harmful media that glamorizes it? Oh, you actually don’t care? Thought so
This was a reference I guess to how people and the media wanted her to be perfect...its shows that no matter how hard she tried....it always gets criticised...like you are not perfect..and another scene of it (that evil smirk behind her ) it shows how creepy those paparazzi and media are like whenever she felt low and unsafe they always use it for them and criticized
This was a very powerful scene that was cancelled because someone got their feelings hurt 🙄 i actually cried when i saw it because i felt like someone else understood me.
I think it's so sad that she put a visual to something so personal as how she felt and what lead to an eating disorder and her fans are on the sides of her bullies in making her take it down
she had an EDs. only a small percentage of people with EDs are underweight. making her change it was just mean and ignorant bc Anti-Hero is exactly about her problems and issues
“fatphobia” is the dumbest shit fr. People really putting phobia at the end of every thing just so they can have a problem to whine to others about. Cancel culture is getting so out of hand.
Im fat and Taylor deserves to be able to talk about her eating disorder and weight problems too. Fat acceptance people somehow think its okay to invalidate skinny people and its not.
What gets me is that this scene (and video in general) couldn't have been directed in any way to make it more obviously about Taylor's individual experiences, and people _still_ had to get entitled and insert their own narratives into the situation.
Fatphobia is literally the fear of becoming fat!! This was fatphobia! Luckily Taylor has some decency and heard people were actively being hurt by 2 seconds of a MV and SHE changed it. Taylor has more respect than y'all. She changed it, cause she could take the criticism, but because she knows ED effects everyone differently and SHE would NEVER want to cause someone to feel what she felt when people discussed her body.
Technically, if you have an eating disorder, by definition, yes you’re fatphobic. You’re afraid of being fat. It’s totally valid and it’s a personal thing - it’s not a fear of others but oneself, it’s deeply personal. And it comes from a fear of not being loved. Or not feeling worthy of love. But you know that’s not what Twitter was crying about. Instead of seeing her as a human who has insecurities and a voice in her head that no matter what is bringing her down about her body, they chose to take it personally and be offended - instead of understanding and relating, they chose to bully her, in her weakness, and force her to hide behind others insecurities. This is Taylor journey and she has a right to share. Of course she doesn’t want to hurt anyone - but most people watching this were more empowered realizing they’re not alone and it’s something she struggles with too.
I hate that she felt pressured to censor her art. As a person who suffered from anorexic and bulimia, I felt that image was so powerful and poetic. There are no safe spaces in art. It's raw, uncomfortable, honest and powerful. Any other way is worthless. She should of stood her ground Madonna style. You can't please everyone so tell your truth. That scale moment was part of her truth. People are so self-involved.
I am most definitely fat (very, very fat), and I had no issue with this being in the video. The first time I saw it, I did not feel like it was targeting fat people. I felt like it was about people who feel like they can’t be thin enough to meet someone’s standard. Taylor is thin. I don’t know if you could call her skinny nowadays, but she is most assuredly not fat at all. And yet she still feels like she isn’t meeting the standard for how her body “should” look. That’s madness, which is the whole point of the video. It’s the madness that comes from trying to reconcile who you are with who society says you must be. For Taylor, that’s never being thin enough. This scene represents that. It was about Taylor and Taylor’s insecurities, it wasn’t an insult to me. Yeah, I’d love to be beautiful like Taylor. No, I don’t understand how she isn’t perfectly content with her perfect, thin body. But that’s not the point. She has a mental hang up that tells her she’s fat when she’s thin, because society tells her she’s still too fat. And since she made the video, she gets to talk about her issues. Not mine. When I make a video (which I don’t plan to), then I can talk about how much my own life sucks.
I don't understand wasn't she getting dragged through the mud and called "fat" because she put some weight on?? She has every right to feel that way, wish she didn't remove it from the mv but she's too nice for y'all. Cancel culture needs to be stoped.
WHYYYYYY when she did that I FELT UNDERSTOOD, NORMAL AND RELIEVED EVEN Wtf people who shamed it are bullies, they need to be cancelled and deleted, not Taylor.
People don't understand it I'm pretty sure it was supposed to mean whenever she steps on the scale she sees herself as fat even though a different part of her knows that that's just a negative thought and not true y'all are just so pressed and trying to call anybody out for anything grow up!!!!
people got really mad about this scene because she “was saying it was bad to be fat” but she was just talking about the insecurities she sees in herself and always feeling like she’s the elephant in the room, which is litterally the whole point of the song. To put it in taylor’s words, “You need to calm down.”
Me pone tan pero TAN triste que haya sacado esa parte, literalmente ese era el mensaje de la cancion, aceptarte tal como sos y que la unica persona que puede hacerte verdadero daño eres tu mismo, por eso Taylor diciendole a Taylor que ser GORDO esta mal y luego la mira de forma malevola
i like the better version personally, taylor encourages people to interpret her music however they like, and the new scene can relate to more people, and i think the straight look down and a shake of the head is even more powerful than us seeing what the scale says
The first one is more accurate and protrays the same thing. Thats why it isnt numbers. That why its just the word. Its to show how no matter what number she saw it was never enough. Have that scene where it isnt a close up takes away from it. Where its that close you can relate. You can get into more personal terriotories. Its invasive. But with the far away shot. It takes away that personal and invasive feel. And just turns out to be just "oh. Its not good enough" compared to the "Oh. When will it be good enough" which hits closer to home
They say that’s offensive for people who are bigger than her but it’s how she feels and many people struggle with their looks even tough through other people’s eyes they aren’t fat.
I'm not really her fan (not exactly my type of music, that's all), but it annoys me so much that people can't understand such a obvious scene and just want to criticize her.
Oml I can't get over this, they're calling her fatphobic when she's only expressing her feelings about her OWN insecurities! They're always finding ways to hate on her and that's absolutely pathetic!
People LITERALLY called her FAT when she CLEARLY was not. She was talking about her OWN insecurity and the effects other people can have on you. People are just looking for a reason to hate on Taylor Swift. Unsuccessful people try to tear down successful people so they feel just as bad as them!!
When in the hell was she ever called fat ?
People want to make it about themselves
fr
yesssss
yeah. and since she CLEARLY is not it has no place in the video.
Man when are ppl gonna realize that not everything is about them, this is Taylor’s representation of HER feelings in HER song.
YES!
EXACTLY ARTIST ARENT JUST SOME MACHINE THAT KEEPS MAKING MUSIC ITS THEIR SONG NOT THE LISTENERS
Exactly
"I MUST have an opinion on everything!" 😂
the descriptor "fat" is about fat people 100% of the time.
this scene was the scene that resonated with me the most, watching it for the first time. it’s sad it got removed because it almost shuts taylor down for having insecurities
Me to i weighed 50-75 pounds my entire child hood cause the pressures of beauty standards in the home (you could grab my ribs elementary to 8th grade thats how bad it was tho didnt understand I had an eating disorder until I turned 20 and started looking back and I just thought every one had these fears and anxiety over there body's and since I was raised with the mindset of beauty being skinny was to be protected at all cost ...so thats more so why I didnt know I had a eating disorder because I spent my entire childhood and teen yrs with it
People calling this fatphobia know NOTHING about having eating desorders.
Imagine STARVING YOURSELF and always looking at those numbers and still considering yourself fat. Or in the other hand, being so depressed that you cannot stop eating.
She is expressing in the music video how that happened in her mind as a person suffering from an eating desorder, but ig Twitter just wants to take people down.
EXACTLY!! people are just too blinded by themselves to comprehend that people who are considered “skinny” can see themselves as “fat” when their brains are warped by body dysmorphia. so many of these comments are giving off “if you have an eating disorder you’re fatphobic” vibes👀
When I saw this part of the mv, i really felt like i saw myself. starving, eating once a day or none at all, then getting to weigh myself and never being satisfied. in my head would echo “yup still fat” and it was a never ending, vicious and frustrating cycle. I have never fat shamed anyone, would support people’s weightloss journeys, never made comments on people’s weight/body shape. however, this didnt change how I saw MYSELF. i think TS was really showing us her body dysmorphia and her struggle with having an ED, all the media hate and pressures.
mhm! i dont take it offensively, its just less triggering to see now
@Fun and Strum no it's not. I'm fat too, and most people miss the entire purpose of this scene. They just take this scene out of context without understanding any meaning beneath the surface. This is Taylor's INTERNAL critic. Something we all have. The internal critic isn't nice or kind. They're shitty, like this. And Taylor has been called fat in the media, which is where her insecurities come from. Telling her that she can't share them because there are people who "are actually fat" is also quite problematic, and not a good representation of the body positivity movement
@Fun and Strum That doesn't make much sense because me as a fat person trying to change my body and having body dysphoria doesn't mean that I'm fatphobic, it means that I was "taught" that being fat is bad, that is perpetuated in our childhood. The same goes to Taylor, she doesn't see a problem with other people being fat but in your brain you try to fit in a certain standard and you don't want to be fat.
I actually like the scene a lot because I can relate to a lot when it comes to my eating disorder and I hate the fact that the internet had to ruin something so good like she's allowed to tell her story
Agreed
Yeah. And sometimes what people need is someone to relate to. It could have helped lots of people like me and you.
Same, I so happy was that i can relate with what I'm feeling about anorexia.
it’s literally a representation of her own eating disorder so yeah exactly. that’s part of most eating disorders. it’s not fatphobia like people are saying.
I actually prefer the new version! And I've been dealing with body dysmorphia and eating disorders for most of my 40 years on this planet.
The new version is just as clear, and just as relatable for people with ED, without contributing to the stigma around the word "fat". I'm honestly proud of Taylor for taking the criticism to heart and making a small change
Don't delete! Cancel culture needs to chill.
Definitely
this plays on my TV and they didn't remove the scene
@@k-onenthusiast5234 the changed it to the after
Cancel culture needs to grow some thicker skin!!
It’s not even cancel culture anymore… it’s just " cancel everything " 😭
As a fat person, I wasn't offended by this particular scene. She was criticizing how sometimes people criticize her body for being "too fat" or "too thin, they are never satisfied with the way she looks, and she ends up feeling insecure with herself because of it. But she doesn't have to please anyone. She is a human being, not a dummy. She can have spots on her skin, pores, cellulite, stretch marks, pimples, scars, blackheads, localized fat, gain weight or lose weight, it's human.
Yes
Littwrly anybody fat or not knows this isn't fat phobic, it's time we stop doing this because of a few weird people
@@miraculousgoldengirl636right😭
@@miraculousgoldengirl636she's a musician, she was forced to do it because people were literally threatening to cancel her. If she thought it waa wrong (which btw it wasn't at all) she would never have added it in. Honestly the people crying about this are the same people that go 'fat isn't a bad thing' . Practice what you preach? A lot of people being offended by something doesn't automatically make it bad
Even skinny people deal with weight issues and feeling like they aren’t skinny enough. It’s not them seeking attention. It’s them being insecure, which everyone does. I personally think they are beautiful.
People need to know that Taylor wasn't being fatphobic. It was part of the clip, not part of her personality! Geez...
literally! it’s representing what she sees in her mind.
It’s also perpetuating stereotypes for profit.
she is fatphobic
@@tenebrousjones4897 she literally went through an ED, this was from HER own experience.
People this is about when she had body dismorphia, not about body shamming. It didn't even show a number on the scale
Women silencing women’s art has now become empowerment . Ironic
@@angelabby2379 no it's for people like you.
@@angelabby2379 the Kardashians dont make art💀
Blame the snowflakes
@@kyleemeg2171yea, the Kardashians just create affiliations with companies that do photography about child BDSM which is disgusting and inappropriate. But yet they try to preach "family"
@@kyleemeg2171 i doubt saying fat on a scale is art
I hate that she was pressured to delete it, as someone who has struggled w anorexia I found it refreshing that she brought it up like that and it's no one else's business, she was speaking her truth and they went after her simply bc they like to hate on her. It's HER song about HER life, ppl just need to back off.
The video was literally about self destructive tendencies and Taylor had an eating disorder that is what this scene is about, the mistake of basing your worth on something trivial like your weight
i feel like she was trying to represent how society will never be content with celebs’ bodies. they’re never “perfect”. they’re always “too fat” or “too skinny”
She is skinny
@@hisookey136 she is skinny, but haters thinks differently lol
She could also think the same thing? Body dismorphic disorder exists.
@@hisookey136 sure she is "skinny" but she was also told that she is just a pretty face, that she is fat, and that she must be pregnant by the media numerous times. Front page articles saying she has gained weight and must be pregnant
It's about her ED
Imagine opening up about your personal trauma and getting cancelled for it...from people that have the same issues. I don't normally get worked up about stuff like this but this one is disgusting. The fact that people got mad about this implies that they think skinny people can't have an ED and discourages them from seeking help. Imagine how many people saw Taylor get crap for this and decided they would keep quiet so they don't get cancelled too.
Exactly it pissed me off and made me so mad poor taylor
I know its crazy people think their helping by "cancelling" her. trying to get rid of any mention of EDs or "how could she use the word FAT?!! CANCELLED!!" because they think their helping people with EDs is so dumb
She literally opened up brutally and confessed to one of her deepest insecurities. People somehow making it their own problem and asking to delete it. 😂 Tay Tay is such an inspiration, is hard to talk about your feelings as it is. I can’t imagine how harsh it must be for her to trust others let alone talk about her feelings when everything you say “is controversial”. 🤦♀️
She's one of the few celebrities who can't fully express herself Without having the world dissect every tiny thing md try to find a problem with it
@@user-ml4ps5cq3v Not “few celebrities” people treat most of them like that.
Honestly I think the “after” is even more effective. Like the audience doesn’t need this to be spelled out for them. It’s too on the nose that there was a close-up of the word Fat on the scale. It’s way more striking and moving that you just see alternative Taylor looking down and then shaking her head. That scale could say anything at all and she still wouldn’t be satisfied.
She's showing that she has insecurities other people have
Hey u Irish?
@@y0um3_20 half irish, my mom is from there, and we're going back next year hopefully
@@ciaragreen2813 really? What county is she from do you know? :D
@@y0um3_20 kilkenny
@@ciaragreen2813 oh really! I’m from Clare but we live in Mayo!
I loved the original, it was so strong and powerful to me 😓
@@angelabby2379 wth??
@@angelabby2379 What do you mean? please elaborate of you can.
@@angelabby2379 she herself literally has an Ed💀
@@angelabby2379 Diabetes and Obesity person be like:
@@angelabby2379 chronically online loser be like:
This is about Taylor’s insecurities, not theirs. This was a song about HER.
She shouldn’t have had to delete it. That’s an expression of how she has felt. It has nothing to do with fatphobia.
Skinny people aren't allowed to have feelings? Who are we to say how she feels in her own body
Yes. That is what the body positive movement is apparently about now. If you aren't fat enough then you aren't allowed to have an opinion or feelings.
@@miraculousgoldengirl636THAT IS WHAT BODY DYSMORPHIA DOES TO YOU. IT IS NOT FATPHOBIC TO BE SUFFERING WITH UR BODY IMAGE
@@miraculousgoldengirl636IT FORCES YOU TO BELIEVE BEING BIGGER IS A BAD THING AND TO FEAR IT. THAT IS LITERALLY WHAT BODY DYSMORPHIA FORCES YOU TO THINK. FAT PEOPLE’S FEELINGS DONT FUCKING NEED TO BE PRIORITIZED IN A VIDEO ABOUT *TAYLOR’S* FEELINGS
@@miraculousgoldengirl636Taylor in a body suit is basically Taylor's brand. The before doesn't mean to show that being fat is bad, just that her brand (managers, etc) push her to be skinny, which is part of what caused her ED. She's not framing being fat as bad, she's framing her industry and brand as harmful towards her.
@@himikotoga540Yeah. I'm intrigued people can't understand such a obvious scene.
This is like when people said the lyrics "Spelling is fun!" in Me! is childish so she had to remove the part from the song...
wait I didn't realize that was removed -
@@loganpriebe4893 people didn't like it so she removed it and then people wanted it back so she brought it back
Bro o can name like ten artists who have super childish songs
Exactly! Me! Was supposed to be less serious, people seriously can’t just have fun
So that’s what happened to that part…
I feel it’s very powerful to have the “fat” part in. It shows that everyone no matter there weight, there status, there popularity we all have insecurities about how we feel and that most of the time it’s just us putting ourselves down.
Taylor wasn’t being fatphobic. She was simply sharing her experiences. I don’t think that should have been deleted because it may have helped other people through what they are going through. So they felt less alone. Sometimes it can help just to know that you aren’t alone and someone else is going through the same thing as you. Love you tay tay!!!😘😘😘
imagine showing your ed and insecurities and then having to remove it because people think your hating
nah fr
Fr people think the whole world revolves around them
Too bad taylor can’t fully express herself 😢
As someone who's bodypositive, this is not fatphobic. It's explaining anorexia and body dismorphia (please forgive me if I spelled that wrong) which matters just as much as fat shamming.
i will never forgive twitter for making her delete that
She may not look fat to us but she can have her own insecurities without being called fat phobic
during her 1988 era, she was fat shamed SO SO much and she had an eating disorder, she almost fainted on stage and she was at her thinnest while people still called her fat.
There's a “phobic” for everything nowadays
People are too sensitive
She has ED so she feel like she’s fat. And it’s hard for her so you don’t need to be rude
I wasn’t talking about Taylor, I was talking about the people hating on her for including the scene in her video. People have been calling her fat-phobic for sharing her insecurities. 🫠
I still like the after it’s a cleaner shot and it’s not spoon fed to you, you still get the general gist while also keeping it one nicer looking longer shot
She was trying to convey self-image in a way that was personal, relatable, and universal, not in any other way
Plot twist: she just deleted it because people were selling toe pics
And they’re probably not even her feet 😂
@@elleluna4537 I bet girl payed 50K for a toe double and then didn’t use the clip
i was about to say.
@@elleluna4537 nah it's definitely hers, she was showing her feet in mvs since her debut album💀
LMAOOOO
I think this is the picture of her trauma from the stigma of that whole pregnancy thing and how she took it way too much serious and have take the stress hell out of it.
She had already explained well in the Miss Americana. The Masterpiece❤️.
Wait, did she deleted the original one and reposted with the new clips? The first one was so meaningful 🥺
I have some weight on me and this didn’t offend me at all. If anything, it highlights that anybody of any size can have insecurities about their weight. Y’all forget that the body positivity movement includes ALL bodies, even the ones you might deem perfect. The video was beautifully made, and she never should’ve been attacked to the point she had to change a REAL moment people go through!
Honestly preferred it before it was edited. Gave more context.
There's nothing wrong with Taylor putting "fat" on the scale. She is allowed to artistically express her feelings however she wants and I'm disgusted how the "fat acceptance" cult bullied her to change it. Here's something for them: IT'S. NOT. ABOUT. YOU.
Grow up and understand that you can't make the world fall on their knees to make you feel comfortable. If you don't like something, move on.
The side I saw wasn't about fat acceptance,it was people with eating disorders talking about how while talking your eating disorder experience is good, putting that isn't conductive to a recovery mindset especially when you're in the limelight
@@RedHoodedKid who are they to even say that though? how can you possibly know what will help another person cope or not
@@steph3443Exactly! Not everything is for everyone that's just how the world works and this is coming from an ed survivor
Y todo por culpa de gente que se indigna por qué ella exprese como se sintió cuando tuvo un transtorno alimenticio 😒 ahora la sociedad te dice como debes expresar tus sentimientos no vayas a ofender a los demás
Si la verdad siempre me a parecido estúpido cuando mis familiares me dicen que debo cuidar mis palabras para no ofender a nadie cuando expresó mi opinión, pero me parece estúpido yo expresare lo que veo según mi criterio y no voy a disfrazar la verdad para que los idiotas no se ofendan y luego dicen que la sinceridad es un valor muy importante, en fin la hipocresía
Totalmente de acuerdo, yo soy gordo y nunca tuve problemas con la escena original ya que como bien lo has dicho, lo del video es algo que tiene que ver exclusivamente con Taylor y no sobre los demás, pero como siempre hay gente que todo le parece mal y hay que contentarlos😒
Exacto. Pregonan amor y comprensión pero te callan si tu has pasado por eso y quieres expresarlo. Una vez más, se nota que los que más los callan son los que menos han padecido algo como discriminación o problemas mentales
Respect to Taylor for deleting that scene, cuz she doesn't want people to see "fat" as a negative thing. People call Taylor "fat" for gaining weight and not being skinny anymore, they're trying to make Taylor insecure about herself. She doesn't want people to feel the same.
i watched the mv before it was removed and as someone who has had issues with eating. this is how you feel. on the outside you may be underweight, but what you see in the mirror is someone who's overweight. and it doesn't help people called/calls her fat when she isn't at all. when you have people around you calling you ___, you're gonna end up believing it. whether if it's true or not. i'm sad she gave into deleting that scene
I wish they had left that in. I’m currently struggling with an eating disorder relapse because of literally all the other stuff in that song. It’s ridiculous how baggy my pants have become in three months.
Nowadays, people r getting too much 🙃
do some people actually not understand this is about insecurities?💀
Im just glad I got to see the orig and got to be on time when it was live posted
People are trying so hard to reject an actual fact just cause their perceptions are different from others invalidating the feelings and self thinking.
Not the girlies on Twitter thinking that Taylor was being fatphobic 💀
I genuinely hope she puts it back in the og video, people need to chill tf out
I know!!! I really want her to put it back
it’s her own experience. she wasn’t pushing this on anyone else. this is what SHE went through and chose to put it in HER music video. just leave her alone
As a person who isn’t a FAN of Taylor swift, she is beautiful and has incredible songs.She also has an amazing heart. That says a lot ❤
Ojala no la hubiera quitado, para mi es una parte muy importante del video
Just afraid to admit the sad reality they have created for so many women around the world. Shouldn't be deleted
I saw the premiere and I felt so happy for her for finally opening up about this, I have an eating disorder myself and I can not eat all day and it leads to me binge eating and it’s a horrible cycle I hate and I’m pretty sure Taylor went through something like this and you wouldn’t believe how much I felt seen to know that someone like her knows what it’s like, seeing her receiving so much hate for this makes me hate humanity more than ever, all she wanted was to tell people that it’s okay and they’re not alone
so unfair!!
SHES NOT FAT PHOBIC
@@Dior_Taylors_version i know !! its unfair people made her delete her own personal experience from her OWN video
@@dollspoYESS
This is so stupid, she is talking about her own insecurity, that she went through.
Honestly people can be idiots!
shes talking about herself. shes not trying to call anyone in her audience fat, she’s reflecting on her own insecurities. twitter needs to calm down
This scene made me feel so SEEN! I hate that the internet have to make everything problematic
The last second when the other Taylor comes behind Taylor is straight up horror movie vibes lol
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 that's what they use to telll her, why americans are so dramatic making a scandal for every little thing. Yes now that is fatphobia🤣 yall make me laugh(btw i am fat but i don't make a drama for everything) she talks about body dysmorphia. Y'all need to chill...
No cause she had an ED, it was really hard for her, she finally opens abt it and ppl start invqlidating her feelings and etc:(
Not just Americans. in Brazil the same would happen, unfortunately.
@@josenilson6509 everywhere amigo
She’s perpetuating stereotypes for profit, makes her seem skeezey
@@tenebrousjones4897 what are you achieving with this? Do you really think canceling Taylor swift over a scene that is supposed to contribute to the lore of her story is going to stop eating disorders? If you care so deeply about eating disorders how about you donate to an organization, oh or call out actual harmful media that glamorizes it? Oh, you actually don’t care? Thought so
The edited version actually makes more sense. No matter what the scale says, its never good enough.
And she has a perfect body
This was a reference I guess to how people and the media wanted her to be perfect...its shows that no matter how hard she tried....it always gets criticised...like you are not perfect..and another scene of it (that evil smirk behind her ) it shows how creepy those paparazzi and media are like whenever she felt low and unsafe they always use it for them and criticized
It's a reference to her ED
That is one of the best scenes I've ever seen. We are our own worst enemy. God girl don't take it out
That's the perfect representation of an ED imo
You can’t get mad about SOMEONE ELSES insecurity
That’s so sad they people like pressured her into deleting it it’s so annoying
this is not her being fatphobic, Taylor was bashed on for her weight countless times she is incorporating her own experiences into her own art.
In what way? She was always thin
@@sasha8982cause she was anorexic
This was a very powerful scene that was cancelled because someone got their feelings hurt 🙄 i actually cried when i saw it because i felt like someone else understood me.
LET THE WOMAN SPEAK HER TRUTH, DAMN. Everyone is so self absorbed, always thinking about how someone else's telling of their own story effects them.
This isn't fatphobic, she was showing that even slim and good looking people have insecurities.
I think it's so sad that she put a visual to something so personal as how she felt and what lead to an eating disorder and her fans are on the sides of her bullies in making her take it down
she had an EDs. only a small percentage of people with EDs are underweight. making her change it was just mean and ignorant bc Anti-Hero is exactly about her problems and issues
“fatphobia” is the dumbest shit fr. People really putting phobia at the end of every thing just so they can have a problem to whine to others about. Cancel culture is getting so out of hand.
Im fat and Taylor deserves to be able to talk about her eating disorder and weight problems too. Fat acceptance people somehow think its okay to invalidate skinny people and its not.
Respect
What gets me is that this scene (and video in general) couldn't have been directed in any way to make it more obviously about Taylor's individual experiences, and people _still_ had to get entitled and insert their own narratives into the situation.
@@user-mv5zt8qd9l SELFISH MOMENT FR (No not Taylor)
The smile in the end tho that kind of gave me the chills. But she has a very pretty smile
PEOPLE ARE SO SENSITIVE THESE DAYS!
Fatphobia is literally the fear of becoming fat!! This was fatphobia!
Luckily Taylor has some decency and heard people were actively being hurt by 2 seconds of a MV and SHE changed it. Taylor has more respect than y'all. She changed it, cause she could take the criticism, but because she knows ED effects everyone differently and SHE would NEVER want to cause someone to feel what she felt when people discussed her body.
Technically, if you have an eating disorder, by definition, yes you’re fatphobic. You’re afraid of being fat. It’s totally valid and it’s a personal thing - it’s not a fear of others but oneself, it’s deeply personal. And it comes from a fear of not being loved. Or not feeling worthy of love.
But you know that’s not what Twitter was crying about. Instead of seeing her as a human who has insecurities and a voice in her head that no matter what is bringing her down about her body, they chose to take it personally and be offended - instead of understanding and relating, they chose to bully her, in her weakness, and force her to hide behind others insecurities.
This is Taylor journey and she has a right to share. Of course she doesn’t want to hurt anyone - but most people watching this were more empowered realizing they’re not alone and it’s something she struggles with too.
She wasn’t being fat phobic she was showing that even skinny pretty people can be super insecure about themselves and think they are fat
I hate that she felt pressured to censor her art. As a person who suffered from anorexic and bulimia, I felt that image was so powerful and poetic.
There are no safe spaces in art. It's raw, uncomfortable, honest and powerful. Any other way is worthless. She should of stood her ground Madonna style. You can't please everyone so tell your truth. That scale moment was part of her truth. People are so self-involved.
She is so beautiful
Yo llegue a ver esa escena en el videoclip
yo
Yo x2
oii oiiii💚💙
I am most definitely fat (very, very fat), and I had no issue with this being in the video. The first time I saw it, I did not feel like it was targeting fat people. I felt like it was about people who feel like they can’t be thin enough to meet someone’s standard. Taylor is thin. I don’t know if you could call her skinny nowadays, but she is most assuredly not fat at all. And yet she still feels like she isn’t meeting the standard for how her body “should” look. That’s madness, which is the whole point of the video. It’s the madness that comes from trying to reconcile who you are with who society says you must be. For Taylor, that’s never being thin enough. This scene represents that. It was about Taylor and Taylor’s insecurities, it wasn’t an insult to me. Yeah, I’d love to be beautiful like Taylor. No, I don’t understand how she isn’t perfectly content with her perfect, thin body. But that’s not the point. She has a mental hang up that tells her she’s fat when she’s thin, because society tells her she’s still too fat. And since she made the video, she gets to talk about her issues. Not mine. When I make a video (which I don’t plan to), then I can talk about how much my own life sucks.
This is a big dub opinion
Taylor has nothing to change about her she’s beautiful inside and out ❤
why did that part get deleted yet ‘Kanye west - famous’ is still up 💀
YES.
nooo it’s already deleted!! 😭
I don't understand wasn't she getting dragged through the mud and called "fat" because she put some weight on?? She has every right to feel that way, wish she didn't remove it from the mv but she's too nice for y'all. Cancel culture needs to be stoped.
WHYYYYYY
when she did that I FELT UNDERSTOOD, NORMAL AND RELIEVED EVEN
Wtf people who shamed it are bullies, they need to be cancelled and deleted, not Taylor.
The whole point of it was showing what society/beauty standards expect people to look like and the hate she got about her body
People don't understand it I'm pretty sure it was supposed to mean whenever she steps on the scale she sees herself as fat even though a different part of her knows that that's just a negative thought and not true y'all are just so pressed and trying to call anybody out for anything grow up!!!!
Literally flashed us with those grippers like put them away 😔
people got really mad about this scene because she “was saying it was bad to be fat” but she was just talking about the insecurities she sees in herself and always feeling like she’s the elephant in the room, which is litterally the whole point of the song. To put it in taylor’s words, “You need to calm down.”
better before. body positivity and cancel culture toxic
Me pone tan pero TAN triste que haya sacado esa parte, literalmente ese era el mensaje de la cancion, aceptarte tal como sos y que la unica persona que puede hacerte verdadero daño eres tu mismo, por eso Taylor diciendole a Taylor que ser GORDO esta mal y luego la mira de forma malevola
i like the better version personally, taylor encourages people to interpret her music however they like, and the new scene can relate to more people, and i think the straight look down and a shake of the head is even more powerful than us seeing what the scale says
The first one is more accurate and protrays the same thing. Thats why it isnt numbers. That why its just the word. Its to show how no matter what number she saw it was never enough. Have that scene where it isnt a close up takes away from it. Where its that close you can relate. You can get into more personal terriotories. Its invasive. But with the far away shot. It takes away that personal and invasive feel. And just turns out to be just "oh. Its not good enough" compared to the "Oh. When will it be good enough" which hits closer to home
But it's supposed to be about her own struggles with ed and insecurities, isn't it? If so then she shouldn't have had to change it
The change is better. Gets her point across and it’s more relatable to those watching.
Bro are you trippin?🤣
I was actually happy that scene was there because i can relate to ,i can't describe how mad I'm rn with those idiot karen
When they make Taylor's issues about them, that is like next level narcissm.
They say that’s offensive for people who are bigger than her but it’s how she feels and many people struggle with their looks even tough through other people’s eyes they aren’t fat.
It’s literally about self perception and how you see yourself as something you’re not.
The fact that Taylor felt like she had to delete this scene which represented her OWN insecurity, just to not offend other people, is terrible.
I'm not really her fan (not exactly my type of music, that's all), but it annoys me so much that people can't understand such a obvious scene and just want to criticize her.
Oml I can't get over this, they're calling her fatphobic when she's only expressing her feelings about her OWN insecurities! They're always finding ways to hate on her and that's absolutely pathetic!