Chamkila is such a grey character and the director made sure that he left space for the audience to decide if his actions were good or bad. No glorification, just facts as they were.
I understand why people might not like the guy himself/or his music depending on their own principles… but the movie was an artistic masterpiece according to me.
Chamkila lyrics were like very clever they don't sound like pure dirty words they were more like double meaning words. in the movie lyrics are more Straightforwardly translated 🙏
Nobody can do what diljit has done here. Non punjabi people can not judge his performance. Nobody said chamkila was hero not even movie tries to do that .Lyrics in translation lost the magic of his cleverness of writing bcz his writing was double meaning in subtle way but here these lyrics were very straightforward. For example creamy boobs is not true translation , creamy chest is the nearest to true translation as far as i can translate it properly.
The artist being beyond the concepts of good and evil as a thematic expression is something that features quite repeatedly in the works of Imtiaz Ali, and I find that beautiful. It's amazing how he manages to capture the contingent nature of these two concepts, while delving into the social/political (the khalistani separatist movement, in this case) context in which a particular form of art/artist flourishes.
alot of people are talking about diljit and hes great but pari’s performance is something else. the hardwork she has put into this film is visible, from gaining 16 kgs for the role to practising everyday for 6 months in ar arhman’s studio for the perfect pitch because the scenes in the film where pari and diljit are singing are sung live at the akhada’s, they are not lip syncing and its so satisfying. and her acting is so amazing that it doesn’t feel like watching pari, its like watching amarjot.
8:07 All the song performances in the movie were performed live. The director and Diljit talked in detail about the process and the movie in a netflix india interview with Bassi
A good movie starring Priyanka Chopra is Saat Khoon Maaf (7 Murders Forgiven) and it rightly showcased Priyanka's Potential as an actress, and it's got a good song by Usha Uthup which is inspired by a Russian folk music, after watching at I thought Priyanka really is a very good actress and the best movie of her so far according to me Loved this reaction as well❤
I also understand the criticism regarding the casting… but Imtiaz mentioned he wanted someone who can carry the traditional Punjabi musical voice texture more than the face of the actor, so I get it. 🤷♀️
I don't know, and the fact is that no one has criticized him about casting. People loved Diljit. Yes, some people did for parineeti But she was also appreciated by the audience.
@@JJK887 I know… and I love him in all the roles, I left this fun fact in answer to the rotten tomato comments Waleska and Efra read at 56:18 and 59:35, I was adding to their discussion. Didn’t you listen to them till the end?
Finally 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉 also the songs sung by parineeti and diljit were recorded live during the shooting 17:55 : Chupa means to Hide Efra 🤦🏽 18:00 Efra looked exactly like Waleska here but a bit weird 🥴🥴 31:54 an interesting conversation 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Diljit Dosanjh was exceptional in this movie! He should get a recognition for certain. It was not an easy role to portray. Very layered and raw. I loved the movie. Imtiaz Ali's Ace!
a question the movie proposes is "who decides what art people should listen to?" i think its a very interesting argument because on one hand you would think that chamkila's songs promote stalking and objectify women which can have wrong impact on the society , which is valid argument.but on the other hand, shouldn't an artist be free to express himself in whatever way he wants..the songs were enjoyed by everyone then why call them so wrong. i think this is an interesting question to ponder on
The same arguement could be said about Bhijouri music industry known for its vulgarity and misogynstic nature...on one hand i see people defending Chamkila because of this movie and then going online to bash Bhojpuri music which is doing exactly the same thing as Chamkila
It also really touches upon how subjective and even vexing morality can be. What's right or wrong for one may not be the same for another, yet there will always be groups who push the notion that only their way should be the norm. On top of that, people will jump to criticize others for being a certain way when in fact they themselves aren't really that different.
@@vedthakur8172To each their own. JA has fantastic performances, Incredible music, stunning costumes and set, intriguing storyline and gorgeous cinematography. Just because the story is more fiction than facts, doesn't mean the movie is shitty. It's a movie, not documentary. I don’t think Akbar was great either, but still JA is one of my favorite movies.
It's great that you guys got to this movie. This movie really aligns with your real strength, which is reviewing music and musicians. It intertwines the two worlds, leading to much introspection on such varied themes, but foremost of all is the freedom of expression of an artist.
33:50 And that's what most of the singers do....well..at least what I have observed...and mainly from the Puniabi music industry today...that they'll sing what the audience wants to hear..and not necessarily..what they wanna sing or what they should be singing. In their interviews...I have heard this for...Honey Singh, Diljit himself, Karan Aujla...and many more....sad truth
35:28 Because militants here are religious militants. So when Chamkila transitioned to singing religious tracks or tracks about history of sikhism; it gave police the impression that he is working with militants and propogating idealogy of militia via his songs. Why police made this hot take assumption is due to riots that were going around in that period. Riots were caused by religious militia (these people wanted separate state), and government (police) was the opposing party trying to stop these people from promoting this extremism. Hope that helps! And as always great job guys! My request again is please review Lagaan the next. Please.
I have been requesting theses movies for some time now they are also based on true stories and are also sports movies, you will not be disappointed by them. “ Dangal “ and “ Mary Kom “ It’s about first famous woman wrestler and the other one is about woman boxer who is 6 times world champion
YALLL NEEED TO WATCH SITA RAMAM I BEG YOUUUUU The songs, the story, music, everything is just ethereal. I've never ever compared anything with veer zaara but this is true masterpiece. I've been waiting since my last life please guys lol
Movies I would like to recommend on different genres/types Comedy: dostana , dhamaal Horror: bhool bhulaiya Historical: Jodha Akbar , padmaavat Action: dhoom , bang bang Sports: dangal , 83 Superhero: the whole krrish series (koi mil gaya and krrish) Patriotic: fighter , Uri Biopic : 12th fail , Mary kom Not mentioning any romcoms because they’ve already been requested a lot and you know a lot of their names already PS: Feel free to disagree with any of the recommendations in replies :)
Honey Singh became like him with the controversies of bringing dirty songs...but he revolutionised the music industry in India..not only in Punjab..but he started with Punjabi
The guy in greenish turban singing baj Baja Baja was Mohit Chauhan himself 😂😂 I thought you recognised him when you said his name but you just read it😅😅
11:40 Punajabi music is also very popular because of the presence in other countries like the US, UK, Canada etc. They bring back the international/ urban music in Punjab...well...in fact...they make music there..but for people here in Punjab...but with Urban beats and International style videography and setting
14:19 those subtitles are so wrong !! Thats not what he sings. he sings " kacha dudh pinde tarke ni tere hikk te malaiyan aayiaan" which translates to "you drink raw milk in the morning thats why on your white skin cream comes"
Since you liked dostana trailer I think it would be a great comedy genre movie to start with. I’ve seen many foreigners love that movie. The thing is movies like Hera pheri are really great but it’s not that funny when you translate it to English. But movies like dostana and dhamaal are still very funny since they are situational based comedy movies.
This movie & style of camera filters reminded me of a Brazilian movie I saw 15 years ago- “Os Filhos do Françisco”- ( story of the early life of ZeZe de Camargo)
I can’t believe you guys haven’t reacted to more of recent malayalam stuff from india. Malayalam is taking india’s rap music to the international levelll…like seriously literally everyone else is reacting to them….CHECK OUT songs like BALLATHA JATHI, MALABARI BANGER, WHAT ECONOMY-S.A, KAAYI-BABY JEAN ,songs from AAVESHAM etc….ASAP!!!!!!!!…YOU GUYS ARE MISSING OUT ON A LOOOOOOT!
The lyrics of his songs were actually more subtle than the English translation. The famous line was actually "your chest is creamy" chest was used instead of breast or boobs.
Thank you, I really enjoy your videos. I want to recommend several films 1. My Name Is Khan, this film, starring SRK and Kajol, tells the story of a person affected by the syndrome who lives in America. every time I watch this film I will definitely cry 2. Faana, played by Amir Khan and Kajol, one of the songs is "Chand Sifarish" you have watched it, not many people talk about this film but this is a successful film in 2006, Kajol's return after a hiatus from the world of films, chemistry with Amir Khan extraordinary, the film "Kabhi Alvida na Kehna" was originally for Kajol and was going to be paired with SRK again but she refused for the film Faana, at that time SRK was jealous because Kajol chose Amir over him 😂😂 3. Bajrangi Bhaijan starring Salman Khan and Kareena Kapoor
Chamkila is such a grey character and the director made sure that he left space for the audience to decide if his actions were good or bad. No glorification, just facts as they were.
I understand why people might not like the guy himself/or his music depending on their own principles… but the movie was an artistic masterpiece according to me.
definitely. and they didn't force people to feel like he was a good/bad guy
Chamkila lyrics were like very clever they don't sound like pure dirty words they were more like double meaning words. in the movie lyrics are more Straightforwardly translated 🙏
Nobody can do what diljit has done here. Non punjabi people can not judge his performance. Nobody said chamkila was hero not even movie tries to do that .Lyrics in translation lost the magic of his cleverness of writing bcz his writing was double meaning in subtle way but here these lyrics were very straightforward. For example creamy boobs is not true translation , creamy chest is the nearest to true translation as far as i can translate it properly.
The artist being beyond the concepts of good and evil as a thematic expression is something that features quite repeatedly in the works of Imtiaz Ali, and I find that beautiful. It's amazing how he manages to capture the contingent nature of these two concepts, while delving into the social/political (the khalistani separatist movement, in this case) context in which a particular form of art/artist flourishes.
It actually makes the characters more human
If you have time where u from..think ur from Italy
alot of people are talking about diljit and hes great but pari’s performance is something else. the hardwork she has put into this film is visible, from gaining 16 kgs for the role to practising everyday for 6 months in ar arhman’s studio for the perfect pitch because the scenes in the film where pari and diljit are singing are sung live at the akhada’s, they are not lip syncing and its so satisfying. and her acting is so amazing that it doesn’t feel like watching pari, its like watching amarjot.
8:07 All the song performances in the movie were performed live. The director and Diljit talked in detail about the process and the movie in a netflix india interview with Bassi
A good movie starring Priyanka Chopra is Saat Khoon Maaf (7 Murders Forgiven) and it rightly showcased Priyanka's Potential as an actress, and it's got a good song by Usha Uthup which is inspired by a Russian folk music, after watching at I thought Priyanka really is a very good actress and the best movie of her so far according to me
Loved this reaction as well❤
I also understand the criticism regarding the casting… but Imtiaz mentioned he wanted someone who can carry the traditional Punjabi musical voice texture more than the face of the actor, so I get it. 🤷♀️
I don't know, and the fact is that no one has criticized him about casting. People loved Diljit. Yes, some people did for parineeti But she was also appreciated by the audience.
@@JJK887 Oh I was going on those comments they read in the end. One or two were about casting, from what I understood.
@@vasudhasharma5532 oh but diljit was highly appreciated
@@JJK887 I know… and I love him in all the roles, I left this fun fact in answer to the rotten tomato comments Waleska and Efra read at 56:18 and 59:35, I was adding to their discussion. Didn’t you listen to them till the end?
Finally 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉 also the songs sung by parineeti and diljit were recorded live during the shooting
17:55 : Chupa means to Hide Efra 🤦🏽
18:00 Efra looked exactly like Waleska here but a bit weird 🥴🥴
31:54 an interesting conversation 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Diljit Dosanjh was exceptional in this movie! He should get a recognition for certain. It was not an easy role to portray. Very layered and raw. I loved the movie. Imtiaz Ali's Ace!
a question the movie proposes is "who decides what art people should listen to?" i think its a very interesting argument because on one hand you would think that chamkila's songs promote stalking and objectify women which can have wrong impact on the society , which is valid argument.but on the other hand, shouldn't an artist be free to express himself in whatever way he wants..the songs were enjoyed by everyone then why call them so wrong. i think this is an interesting question to ponder on
The same arguement could be said about Bhijouri music industry known for its vulgarity and misogynstic nature...on one hand i see people defending Chamkila because of this movie and then going online to bash Bhojpuri music which is doing exactly the same thing as Chamkila
It also really touches upon how subjective and even vexing morality can be. What's right or wrong for one may not be the same for another, yet there will always be groups who push the notion that only their way should be the norm. On top of that, people will jump to criticize others for being a certain way when in fact they themselves aren't really that different.
Guys do Guzaarish or Jodhaa Akbar for classic ones coming next week please
Vote for Jodhaa Akbar!
GUZAARISH DEFINITELY.
Guzaarish 🧡
@@afsanafatemanoor5212shitty movie potrayed akbar as good which is not true
@@vedthakur8172To each their own. JA has fantastic performances, Incredible music, stunning costumes and set, intriguing storyline and gorgeous cinematography. Just because the story is more fiction than facts, doesn't mean the movie is shitty. It's a movie, not documentary. I don’t think Akbar was great either, but still JA is one of my favorite movies.
i was just thinking that when are you guys going to post....this is a perfect movie for people that enjoy the raw music experience.
It's great that you guys got to this movie. This movie really aligns with your real strength, which is reviewing music and musicians. It intertwines the two worlds, leading to much introspection on such varied themes, but foremost of all is the freedom of expression of an artist.
Guys go for Guzarish
Congo* for 34k many more coming ❤
14:26 That's TOO much positivity dude 😂🤣 ...AND.. DEEP DIVING INTO THINGS
Guzaarish
Laapata Ladies
Piku
Jodha Akbar
12.00 that scene is just stuck in my head bro ...So so beautifully filmed... ❤
Jab we met was not done by ARR, it was Pritam
a unique story but brilliantly filmed and researched... excellent performances and direction
Vote for Jodhaa Akbar next week!!
33:50 And that's what most of the singers do....well..at least what I have observed...and mainly from the Puniabi music industry today...that they'll sing what the audience wants to hear..and not necessarily..what they wanna sing or what they should be singing. In their interviews...I have heard this for...Honey Singh, Diljit himself, Karan Aujla...and many more....sad truth
Ohh...not to forget Sidhu Moose Wala. God bless his soul 🙏
Underrated movies 🙏 but worth to watch and enjoy the acting
Sanam Teri Kasam
GUZAARISH
Kaabil
🩵💙🩵
Sanam Teri Kasam was objectively bad, Guzaarish was objectively good and Kaabil was objectively mediocre
Vote for Dil se
Guzaarish please
35:28 Because militants here are religious militants. So when Chamkila transitioned to singing religious tracks or tracks about history of sikhism; it gave police the impression that he is working with militants and propogating idealogy of militia via his songs. Why police made this hot take assumption is due to riots that were going around in that period. Riots were caused by religious militia (these people wanted separate state), and government (police) was the opposing party trying to stop these people from promoting this extremism. Hope that helps! And as always great job guys! My request again is please review Lagaan the next. Please.
Yours best reaction ever till date , hatts of to this review, keep it up lads ❤
next movie "Haider" of Shahid Kapoor its an adaptation of hamlet of Shakespeare
Bhai propoganda movie hum support ni karte or aisi cheejo se bahar logo ko bhi dur rakho apne desh ki kya image jayegi fake propoganda movie se
Laila majnu too
I think Jodha Akbar is musically great. AR killed it🔥
I have been requesting theses movies for some time now they are also based on true stories and are also sports movies, you will not be disappointed by them.
“ Dangal “ and “ Mary Kom “
It’s about first famous woman wrestler and the other one is about woman boxer who is 6 times world champion
YALLL NEEED TO WATCH SITA RAMAM I BEG YOUUUUU
The songs, the story, music, everything is just ethereal. I've never ever compared anything with veer zaara but this is true masterpiece. I've been waiting since my last life please guys lol
Movies I would like to recommend on different genres/types
Comedy: dostana , dhamaal
Horror: bhool bhulaiya
Historical: Jodha Akbar , padmaavat
Action: dhoom , bang bang
Sports: dangal , 83
Superhero: the whole krrish series (koi mil gaya and krrish)
Patriotic: fighter , Uri
Biopic : 12th fail , Mary kom
Not mentioning any romcoms because they’ve already been requested a lot and you know a lot of their names already
PS: Feel free to disagree with any of the recommendations in replies :)
Loveee all the recommendations!!
What a perfect list 🥹🤌🏻
Waleska efra screenshot this for future reference!
But they have to watch koi mil gaya before krrish..so can you add that too..
Second this list.
Thank you guys for reacting to this movie..enjoyed it allot.. Loved the movie I can watch it again and again ❤
glad to see efra remembering chupa 🤣🤣 chuppa means hide here btw.. 🤣
he's confusing it with chu-*-ia lol
Did you guys saw mohit chauhan’s cameo? He was the main singer in the intro song
Honey Singh became like him with the controversies of bringing dirty songs...but he revolutionised the music industry in India..not only in Punjab..but he started with Punjabi
Do Guzzarish movie starring Hrithik and Aishwarya..underrated movie and underrated music album..
The guy in greenish turban singing baj Baja Baja was Mohit Chauhan himself 😂😂
I thought you recognised him when you said his name but you just read it😅😅
I think I would rewatch your reaction to Kal ho na ho for the 100th time until you react to one of my favorite movie
11:40 Punajabi music is also very popular because of the presence in other countries like the US, UK, Canada etc. They bring back the international/ urban music in Punjab...well...in fact...they make music there..but for people here in Punjab...but with Urban beats and International style videography and setting
I’m waiting for KKH ☺️☺️
oh my god yessssss im cryinggggg
Jodhaa Akbar next
Yeah that’s a very good choice
I think Efra will like it ALOT
14:19 those subtitles are so wrong !! Thats not what he sings.
he sings " kacha dudh pinde tarke ni tere hikk te malaiyan aayiaan" which translates to "you drink raw milk in the morning thats why on your white skin cream comes"
Since you liked dostana trailer I think it would be a great comedy genre movie to start with. I’ve seen many foreigners love that movie. The thing is movies like Hera pheri are really great but it’s not that funny when you translate it to English. But movies like dostana and dhamaal are still very funny since they are situational based comedy movies.
I honestly would recommend Dhamaal because I think Dostana's comedy is quite.... Tasteless for a lack of better words
You guys should watch qismat which is masterpiece of punjabi cinema
You should also watch Punjab 1984 movie. Diljit's acting is just phenomenal
I m viewing ur bpth channel for last few years you r great
It's better to watch Hrithik Roshan's debut movie Kaho na pyaar hai (2000)
This movie & style of camera filters reminded me of a Brazilian movie I saw 15 years ago- “Os Filhos do Françisco”- ( story of the early life of ZeZe de Camargo)
I can’t believe you guys haven’t reacted to more of recent malayalam stuff from india. Malayalam is taking india’s rap music to the international levelll…like seriously literally everyone else is reacting to them….CHECK OUT songs like BALLATHA JATHI, MALABARI BANGER, WHAT ECONOMY-S.A, KAAYI-BABY JEAN ,songs from AAVESHAM etc….ASAP!!!!!!!!…YOU GUYS ARE MISSING OUT ON A LOOOOOOT!
Love your reactions ❤
'Raavanan' tamil movie reaction petitioned 😬🥹
Mani Rathnam direction
A.R. Rahman musical
Aishwarya Rai Bachchan and Vikram as leads.
That sardar ji in the starting who is singing the song is actually Mohit Chauhan 😂
This can be actually applied to so many Punjabi singers. Especially Honey Singh in his initial days
Diljit is not only a a great singer but also an national award winning actor.
😊
Kuch kuch hota hai next please..🥹
I’m liked all the videos and enjoyed..❤
Parineeti Chopra was brilliant in the film, she has always been amazing. Y'all should check out some of her best films
3:56 just realized that was Mohit Chauhan special appearance 😯
I was thinking it will kuch kuch hota hai or channie express but okay with it ❤❤❤❤❤
Did you noticed Mohit Chouhan as a turban guy in first song ...with heavy voice
Ek Villain 💛
Yes please please 🙏🙏🙏🙏
There was no escaping. Everywhere there is a Punjabi audience, these 'force' people had influence. Even today.
Was waiting for this reaction!
Oh and they thought he was with the militants because of his devotional songs and the money he gave them.
Y'all should do -My name is Khan....SRK was just phenomenal as always
Waiting for kuch Kuch hota hai reaction... ❤️
The lyrics of his songs were actually more subtle than the English translation. The famous line was actually "your chest is creamy" chest was used instead of breast or boobs.
This might be diljit’s first movie without turban
Watch Badhai Ho! ..its hands down the funniest bollywood film ..also any movie of either aamir khan or ayushman khurana is critically acclaimed
Hum Saath Saath Hain for a 90’s family movie.
U can watch
Raazi great movie . Good music. And one of the greatest performance by alia batt and vicky . Must watch . Based on real life story
I was right ❤❤❤yeah! Finallyyyyyy
14:06 LOL ..Waleska...What was that 😂
Please kuch kuch Hota hai movies
Why does my Punjab have to endure bloodshed ALL THE TIME!? 😭😭
Also do- queen, piku, guzarish, agneepath
The man singing in the introductory is mohit chauhan Himself with pug
HERE WITH HAIDER REQUEST ONCE AGAIN
Ramleela next!!!!!!!
Just watch Katyar kaljat guslee, every song in it will give you butterflies
th-cam.com/video/1iTazEogwiY/w-d-xo.html
Guys do Mohabbatain and My Name is Khan
Here are some movie recommendations for y'all:
+ Talaash (2012)
+ Ek Villain (2014)
+ Drishyam (2015)
+ Dil Dhadakne Do (2015)
+ Ghajini (2008)
Guys why don't you try
1. Om shanti om
2. chennai express pleassssss........
17:54 those who know what he was talking about 💀💀💀💀💀
I think it's only Punjabi thing..no?
Tu jhooti main makkar you should watch
Bro you guys have reacted to every imtiaz ali masterpiece, why not laila majnu? 😭😭
letterboxd reviews are always more fun to read imo
KKHH or Mohabbatein for classic week 🩷
✨Mohabattein✨
In the starting song you can see Mohit Chauhan cameo for a few seconds 😅
Parineeti wasn't in Animal.. and also it's a violent and toxic tale with great performances and music. So it might trigger ppl lol
Honey singh had also same fame phase as him. Crazy as hell. And same kind of criticism for lyrics
There's no India without Punjab.
There's no Punjab without India.
People tried hard by leaving bad reviews because right wing don’t like diljit because he is vocal about the misunderstanding about Punjab.
Watch an old Hindi move called ‘ khamoshi the musical’ or atleast listen to all the songs from this album and review
Please watch Jagga Jasoos it's a mystery musical starring Katrina Kaif and Ranbir Kapoor❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ please❤❤❤❤❤
Thank you, I really enjoy your videos. I want to recommend several films
1. My Name Is Khan, this film, starring SRK and Kajol, tells the story of a person affected by the syndrome who lives in America. every time I watch this film I will definitely cry
2. Faana, played by Amir Khan and Kajol, one of the songs is "Chand Sifarish" you have watched it, not many people talk about this film but this is a successful film in 2006, Kajol's return after a hiatus from the world of films, chemistry with Amir Khan extraordinary, the film "Kabhi Alvida na Kehna" was originally for Kajol and was going to be paired with SRK again but she refused for the film Faana, at that time SRK was jealous because Kajol chose Amir over him 😂😂
3. Bajrangi Bhaijan starring Salman Khan and Kareena Kapoor
WATCH PIKU NEXT!!!!🙏
It’s a beautiful film showcasing the beauty of Kolkata and Bengali culture. Also the music is top-notch‼️
Waleska and Efra don’t read the comments cause they have not react to Kuch Kuch hota hai after months of viewers requesting it ✅