@bridogg154 ??? what are you talking about? Chuck doesnt appear in several podcasts because hes an active stand up comedian and voice actor. You need to just stop commenting ignorance. thank.
Neil, you shall live forever!! What an inspiring educator! Been following you for at least 7 years. You are an inspiration along with my beloved Dr. Jordan Peterson, educators from the heart and mind! There is much love for you here, Neil ! Greetings from a border town in Mexico!
Neil you’ve inspired me to love science when no school teacher over could you bring hard facts in a way anyone can understand my favourite so far war big numbers
8Flux8 I’ll just ignore your comment because that’s making an assumed guess that anyone watching this is dumb , what I meant was the science teachers over here in Scotland aren’t engaging enough at school level so after I left looked for ways to learn new information then I came across cosmos and it’s led me here There’s a reason he’s our self proclaimed personal astrophysicist
He mentions his 6th grade science teacher, love it mine were my 7th and 8th grade science teachers they were amazing and got me hooked also got me watching the science guy lol
I know nothing about astrophysics and sometimes even struggle with some really complex words since isn't my native language and still love Neil he's so fun to listen and made everything easy to diggest.
Ever since the news of discovery of phosphine in the atmosphere of Venus were out, I haven't watched ANY since related channels commenting on it, just because I was waiting for the StarTalk edition of it!! Off we go!!
Always amazes me, the intricacy of our solar system, life & the meticulous details hidden in nature. Perhaps one day because of people like you humanity will solve the eternal riddle of the universe.
Don't think he'd doo too well, he's too theoretical and really stretches his idea too long, even when they're not complicated. Neil's guest are usually really eloquent people.
@@FrancoSciaraffia He's quite charismatic, as far as scientists go. He's no Neil or Sean, but he's better than Susskind (whom I adore listening to regardless).
I don't think he and Neil get along very well. I saw a video once where they were on the same panel answering questions and they barely acknowledged each other and when they did they seemed quite cold towards each other.
@@Metal_89 i saw this too and get the same perspective but i like both guys Lawrence did a great live performance when they do the debate but he acted different on the show
Thank you for bringing me joy during these trying times. I have been a fan of yours since I was 5. You and bill nye are the sole reason I love science and why I question life and how it works. from the bottom of my heart thank you.🙂
Please do a Cosmic Querie on Biocentrism. How it relates to Einstein's Theory of Relativity and our observation of time through the conscious mind as our neurons stop firing. Would we perceive time as Absolute Zero or Infinite upon death? Are we rooted into the 5th Dimension and beyond? This would make for a great afterlife video...
If you have the research and ideas, I don’t see why you shouldn’t do a video 🤷♂️ I’d love to see these hypotheses of yours in more detail! I love the curiosity!
@@larmufc1 gotta clarify here, those videos have actually been around for several years but it is only recently that the nyt published an article on them and the military officially confirmed that those videos were legit.
@@Tekker2234 I just want them to be addressed by an astropysist, I understand its speculation but so is possible life on venus and after all NDGT debunks physics in movies all the time 😉
Why do these have strict cut-off times? Would be much better to expand on a topic for a few min than abruptly end it. of course i am a fan, that's why i want MORE!
I totally agree, plus think venus has run away greenhouse gas causing insane global warming, any tech we develop to explore venus can help us on earth with climate change directly from suits , breathing devices all the way to terraforming could help us heal earth
@@knyghtryder3599 Yeah I hate people who say we shouldn't spend money on space exploration and "fix our planet first". There is so much we can learn (and have already learned) that can help us deal with our problems back here on Earth.
@@makisekurisu4674 Of course you can mine Venus, with the right equipment. Remember that Venus's atmosphere imprimes a force 90 times that of Earth's atmosphere. Do you know how many atmospheres are in the Marianas Trench? It is the equivalent of 1,000 atmospheres. We have submarines that have reached thst deep, did some exploration and came back up with the crew safe. Heath on Venus's surface? A mere 650 degrees C! We have developed machined thar go into volcanos that withstand thousands od degrees. Plus the dense atmosphere on Venus will help keep livivg quartes afloat really easy and provide a trove of gsses and nutrients that will make even agriculture sustainable and feasebly plus protect humans from radiation. You want to see Venus colonizad in a jiff? Just tell the US government about China's supossed colonizing plans for Venus. In ten years we would have a large floating city there😎 So, open your mind, Venus will be faster and more sustainable than Mars to be colonized. Now, why colonize Mars, Venus, our Moon, Titan, Europa, Ceres, Triton or Enceladus? That's part of being human, and we want humanity to be everywhere.
Great session. Neil, David and Paul kept us informed and entertained without being silly. I’m a Venus fan and remember from my childhood in the 50’s sifi films about rocket trips to Venus. So from a purely nostalgic and romanticized viewpoint it’s great that Venus is back in the news.
Y’all have to think that other life is probably completely different from humans they could probably live on extreme temperatures and probably breathe a different air and you also have to remember earth had the perfect conditions for its kind of life but other planets could have the perfect conditions for the planets type of life Edit: Other life are probably thinking if there was life on earth it would need the conditions of life that they are used to
They touch on this in the podcast. We only have Earth to look at for life, and we know life exists here. Life elsewhere could be similar to us as we have evidence of us, but it could be completely different. Hence they talk about life as we know it needing water, but could life use ammonia, or something else.
This is slowly devolving into a conscious inception, and I’m not enjoying it.😂 I just want to sleep, but now I’m waiting on a text from my Venus pen pal program. Fun times to be alive, for sure!
My question is why is there a quack ad for protection against 5G in the middle of the episode? Does the podcast have no control over what ads are shown during their program?
Question raised: When can you get a sample & bring it back to Earth? Answer "Think you can get it on Amazon :-D." Well played.. In truth a revisit to Venus is long overdue. Will say life found on earth in extreme environments like Antarctica & and surrounding deep sea geothermal vents in the ocean indicates such could be possible..
22:25 No, explain the single celled life which eats rock at 2Km under the crust. No! Explain the single celled life that feeds on the single celled life that feeds on rock! Let's take a step back and say, life needs a fluid. Rock moving at slow speeds is a fluid, and that life will live for millions of years before dividing.
Why fight escape gravity in the most difficult way by stopping mid flight, is 35miles too close to use the slingshot effect and collect sample while flying through the “habitable zone” or are talking about collecting surface sample without ever landing?
I would like to see Paul and Chuck on the same episode. Who would win? Chuck with the Lago hair cut, or Paul that checks with his wife. I like that some scientist also appreciate laughter.
Great episode! I love seeing topics like this discussed. I’m surprised there aren’t more episodes following the current progress with Starship in Boca Chica and other space exploration advancements.
Small disappointment that temperature measurement mentioned is Fahrenheit. Should be in Kelvin. Or at least, the equivalent temperature in Kelvin be mentioned.
So Neil I was wondering if it’s possible if phosphine could be created by a asteroid. Impacting Venus and carrying that chemical to the surface of the planet? Or maybe it breaking up into the atmosphere too. What is your take on this? Would love to hear a reply back love watching and listening to your huge fan Neil ( I’m also a veteran and was happy to fight for people like Neil to make are lives better).
leaving these shows I feel dummer and smarter at the same time. That is a goal I have for everyone who talks to me. I want to teach you something I know would be important. I also know you can teach me something of importance that I have no prior knowledge of. Knowledge makes the world go round
Hey, thanks to not only you, but all of you.. I’ve been watching you for only about a week, as a dropout it was difficult, teachers telling you different when you know it’s right. Particularly math. I’ve been on some tech stuff, managed to find I read the AMD / Nvidia leaks, did the math and knew months before others on the current release. I’ve posted on reddit, everyone disagreed and I ended up nailing it.. You’ll see me soon. I like what you just said about the “verification” process... I litterally had this happen on reddit and than gained followers afterwards.. :s
Acid loving organisms? Aren't those usually found on university campuses?
Underrated joke
😂
He was referring multi cellular complex organisms.
XtreeM FaiL ohhhhh shots fired 😂 🔥🔥
@@XtreeM_FaiL Which does leave out many university students.
David Grinspoon is hands down my favorite guest each time he appears. More Grinspoon!!
Paul and Chuck are the only ones that work for this show. Also BRING DAVID BACK MORE OFTEN THIS DUDE IS GREAT!
All three of these guys are slinging zingers this podcast. Great comedy to go with the science!
Austin Newman ,Fully Agreed,Wasnt Expecting “Oh So Your In Your Parents Basement) From Neil😂😂😂
seriously big line up big laughs
Austin Newman ,Im With Paul Tho,Always After Leaving Star Talk,I Feel Smarter and Dumber At The Same Time😂
@@PafMedic Yea honestly he was treating the guy like he was his kid brother which I have never seen from Neil
th-cam.com/video/b2TOptPqgis/w-d-xo.html
Dr. Tyson has Pacific Northwest Costal Native Salish art on his wall!!!!!!! My favorite art style in the world!!!
I've always wondered where they came from. Thank you
Wait where’s chuck :(
CHUUUUUUUUCK!!!!
exactly my thought I’m hoping he’s lounging on holiday
@bridogg154 ??? what are you talking about? Chuck doesnt appear in several podcasts because hes an active stand up comedian and voice actor. You need to just stop commenting ignorance. thank.
@bridogg154 ive noticed that as well, leave politics out of ST.
AWOL !!
Acid Loving Venusian Blues. That is gorgeous
Is anyone else watching these in lockdown and are actually really interested. I am
Where are lockdowns still in effect?
I watch anything Star Talk puts out, regardless of the situation.
Yes
mrzx626 west Footscray in Melbourne if that’s where your from
th-cam.com/video/b2TOptPqgis/w-d-xo.html
Neil, you shall live forever!! What an inspiring educator! Been following you for at least 7 years. You are an inspiration along with my beloved Dr. Jordan Peterson, educators from the heart and mind! There is much love for you here, Neil ! Greetings from a border town in Mexico!
Love the beautiful Haida art on the wall.
Another great episode. Funky spoon is awesome.
Neil you’ve inspired me to love science when no school teacher over could you bring hard facts in a way anyone can understand my favourite so far war big numbers
Me too , totally agree such a way of explanation he has the ideas just come alive !
Neil dumbs down the science for dumb people. He's a translator.
8Flux8 I’ll just ignore your comment because that’s making an assumed guess that anyone watching this is dumb , what I meant was the science teachers over here in Scotland aren’t engaging enough at school level so after I left looked for ways to learn new information then I came across cosmos and it’s led me here There’s a reason he’s our self proclaimed personal astrophysicist
Knyght Ryder 100% yes you should watch cosmos it’s amazing if you have Disney + or amazon prime I think it’s on there
@@F_L_U_X wow you are so edgy dude. Since its for dumb people is that why you are here ?
The guest were awesome. One of the best episodes
He mentions his 6th grade science teacher, love it mine were my 7th and 8th grade science teachers they were amazing and got me hooked also got me watching the science guy lol
I know nothing about astrophysics and sometimes even struggle with some really complex words since isn't my native language and still love Neil he's so fun to listen and made everything easy to diggest.
i always listen to star talk at work, excellent podcast!
Ever since the news of discovery of phosphine in the atmosphere of Venus were out, I haven't watched ANY since related channels commenting on it, just because I was waiting for the StarTalk edition of it!! Off we go!!
Glad ive found your videos. Now my 10 hour shift at work is gonna go by 10x easier lol
Thank you Neil and Paul
The answer to "is there life of Venus?" should be hysterical laughter for at least 30 seconds followed by a confident "NO!"
NO MEANS YOU.
I had been waiting for this episode of Star Talk from the moment the phosphine gas discovery was made!!! ❤
It was inevitable.
Learned about the mighty "BLUE FLAME" from the councilor at camp who was in charge of our cabin.
The man set a fine example for all of us that day.
Thanks for these videos, helps keep us drivers entertained and always learning while putting these miles away
So what I'm hearing, is we need a VENUSIAN SCIENCE ZEPPELIN
@@MrWhodatsay We have to catch up we falling behind
Don't need to be zeppelin. A boat would work.
Always amazes me, the intricacy of our solar system, life & the meticulous details hidden in nature. Perhaps one day because of people like you humanity will solve the eternal riddle of the universe.
Neil you are great to listen to and you make things interesting. Thank you.
Why don't you get Lawrence Krauss on the show? He's such a cool guy.
Don't think he'd doo too well, he's too theoretical and really stretches his idea too long, even when they're not complicated. Neil's guest are usually really eloquent people.
@@FrancoSciaraffia He's quite charismatic, as far as scientists go. He's no Neil or Sean, but he's better than Susskind (whom I adore listening to regardless).
I don't think he and Neil get along very well. I saw a video once where they were on the same panel answering questions and they barely acknowledged each other and when they did they seemed quite cold towards each other.
Or Jackie martling!
@@Metal_89 i saw this too and get the same perspective but i like both guys Lawrence did a great live performance when they do the debate but he acted different on the show
Thank you for bringing me joy during these trying times. I have been a fan of yours since I was 5. You and bill nye are the sole reason I love science and why I question life and how it works. from the bottom of my heart thank you.🙂
Absolutely loved this! Fantastic guests and fun, educational discussion!
Please do a Cosmic Querie on Biocentrism. How it relates to Einstein's Theory of Relativity and our observation of time through the conscious mind as our neurons stop firing. Would we perceive time as Absolute Zero or Infinite upon death? Are we rooted into the 5th Dimension and beyond? This would make for a great afterlife video...
no u
That would be amazing
u wot m8
If you have the research and ideas, I don’t see why you shouldn’t do a video 🤷♂️ I’d love to see these hypotheses of yours in more detail! I love the curiosity!
I'm your fan Neil, you are my favourite scientist, i admire your knowledge.
At least, self-proclaimed fan should name him correctly 🤦🏻♂️
(It's Neil, not Neal)
@@PraveenKamboj_Bablu lol
Thank you @Startalk for keeping the videos rolling!
Paul does real nice job. Please try get him more. :)
I was wondering when you were going to mention this.
But he never addressed the alien craft seen by a navy pilot and released by the Pentagon.. Interesting
@@larmufc1 gotta clarify here, those videos have actually been around for several years but it is only recently that the nyt published an article on them and the military officially confirmed that those videos were legit.
@@Tekker2234 I just want them to be addressed by an astropysist, I understand its speculation but so is possible life on venus and after all NDGT debunks physics in movies all the time 😉
@@larmufc1 astrophysicist
@@JohnyG29 thanks bro
What about tying this together with the UV absorbers that were detected in the atmosphere? Could the two results be linked?
Cool science shows to binge watch
Back at it🤩🤩
David Grinspoon and Neil deGrasse Tyson - name a better duo. I'll wait 😁
Yess🔥🔥
Why do these have strict cut-off times? Would be much better to expand on a topic for a few min than abruptly end it. of course i am a fan, that's why i want MORE!
I always think that to live in Venus's cloud tops will be better and easier than living in Mars, plus more sustainable.
floating cities on venus.. yall sleeping on venus..
I totally agree, plus think venus has run away greenhouse gas causing insane global warming, any tech we develop to explore venus can help us on earth with climate change directly from suits , breathing devices all the way to terraforming could help us heal earth
@@knyghtryder3599 Yeah I hate people who say we shouldn't spend money on space exploration and "fix our planet first". There is so much we can learn (and have already learned) that can help us deal with our problems back here on Earth.
How is it more sustainable? You can't mine on venus.
@@makisekurisu4674 Of course you can mine Venus, with the right equipment. Remember that Venus's atmosphere imprimes a force 90 times that of Earth's atmosphere. Do you know how many atmospheres are in the Marianas Trench? It is the equivalent of 1,000 atmospheres. We have submarines that have reached thst deep, did some exploration and came back up with the crew safe. Heath on Venus's surface? A mere 650 degrees C! We have developed machined thar go into volcanos that withstand thousands od degrees. Plus the dense atmosphere on Venus will help keep livivg quartes afloat really easy and provide a trove of gsses and nutrients that will make even agriculture sustainable and feasebly plus protect humans from radiation.
You want to see Venus colonizad in a jiff? Just tell the US government about China's supossed colonizing plans for Venus. In ten years we would have a large floating city there😎
So, open your mind, Venus will be faster and more sustainable than Mars to be colonized.
Now, why colonize Mars, Venus, our Moon, Titan, Europa, Ceres, Triton or Enceladus? That's part of being human, and we want humanity to be everywhere.
Where Chuck at?
They rotate him out every once and awhile
sleeping
DrUGS
Everyone asks where chuck at?but, not how chuck doing?
When life gives you questions you.....
Do Science
when you do science you give questions to life. don't you think? since we born we questioning it every day until you're last breath when you get old
Great session. Neil, David and Paul kept us informed and entertained without being silly. I’m a Venus fan and remember from my childhood in the 50’s sifi films about rocket trips to Venus. So from a purely nostalgic and romanticized viewpoint it’s great that Venus is back in the news.
Neil, you are my hero dude
How do I get onto your show ? 🤣🤣
Thank you for everything! You've changed my life ♥️
Y’all have to think that other life is probably completely different from humans they could probably live on extreme temperatures and probably breathe a different air and you also have to remember earth had the perfect conditions for its kind of life but other planets could have the perfect conditions for the planets type of life
Edit: Other life are probably thinking if there was life on earth it would need the conditions of life that they are used to
They touch on this in the podcast. We only have Earth to look at for life, and we know life exists here. Life elsewhere could be similar to us as we have evidence of us, but it could be completely different. Hence they talk about life as we know it needing water, but could life use ammonia, or something else.
That's exactly what I thought!!!
This is slowly devolving into a conscious inception, and I’m not enjoying it.😂 I just want to sleep, but now I’m waiting on a text from my Venus pen pal program. Fun times to be alive, for sure!
Gabriel Chavez the problem is how will they consume energy when they don’t use oxygen
@StarTalk,
please touch on retrograde-orbit sometime; one of my favorite things.
Can you please use SI units? I can't be bothered to learn local measurement systems as a citizen of the earth. Thanks.
i can relate tbh
O primeiro passo rumo ao sucesso é dado quando você se recusa ao ser um refém do ambiente em que se encontra
#TALKINTELIGENCIA
My question is why is there a quack ad for protection against 5G in the middle of the episode? Does the podcast have no control over what ads are shown during their program?
David's explanations of Venus are the best I've heard.
Life finds a way as they say. I really enjoyed this one.
This guy is awesome.
Love this channel!
I love the Star talks with Paul, keep them coming!
Can someone explain what happens during breaks? Is it a livestream somewhere and then edited for youtube or do breaks just mark ads ?
My teacher just told me about this today and I got really happy and I'm especially happy that you're talking about it too :)
Thank you for making science digestible! 🐒❤️
Jon Pertwee would have absolutely loved this podcast
I hope the working title for Dr Grinspoon's book, "Venus Revealed", was "Show Me Your Venus". But that's probably hoping for too much.
"Look at my Venus"
Why doesn’t there seem to be any delay? Which app are they using? Clearly not Zoom or Google Meet.
Question raised: When can you get a sample & bring it back to Earth? Answer "Think you can get it on Amazon :-D." Well played.. In truth a revisit to Venus is long overdue. Will say life found on earth in extreme environments like Antarctica & and surrounding deep sea geothermal vents in the ocean indicates such could be possible..
Yay! 3 uploads in 3 days. Loving it
Starts from 5:00
22:25 No, explain the single celled life which eats rock at 2Km under the crust. No! Explain the single celled life that feeds on the single celled life that feeds on rock! Let's take a step back and say, life needs a fluid. Rock moving at slow speeds is a fluid, and that life will live for millions of years before dividing.
I think the chance of finding life in the galaxy is large
Great! Thanks!
I want to see that movie
We need Paul Mercurio back ngl
The Flintstones takes place after The Jetsons.
First time I've seen an episode of Star Talk without Chuck. I really thought this was a Neil and Chuck show, not just a Neil show.
loved this more intelligent video!
Good stuff! Now, three plus years later, the question is still unanswered and that balloon sounds better than ever.
The questions start at 5:00.
I wonder how seasonal changes affect the evaporation and condensation of Venus's droplets.
Time for Space Race 2?
david is awsome.
Why fight escape gravity in the most difficult way by stopping mid flight, is 35miles too close to use the slingshot effect and collect sample while flying through the “habitable zone” or are talking about collecting surface sample without ever landing?
I was literally waiting for this one. Thanks mr Tyson.
Can we just have Neil explain Magic: The Gathering?
My question is, if we determine what life is by our standards, whose to say that there are lifeforms that we as humans cannot even comprehend?
I would like to see Paul and Chuck on the same episode. Who would win? Chuck with the Lago hair cut, or Paul that checks with his wife. I like that some scientist also appreciate laughter.
Great episode! I love seeing topics like this discussed. I’m surprised there aren’t more episodes following the current progress with Starship in Boca Chica and other space exploration advancements.
David is very interesting
I saw Paul live years ago. He made fun of a few of my friends. I don't know if I've ever laughed as hard as I did that night.
Small disappointment that temperature measurement mentioned is Fahrenheit. Should be in Kelvin. Or at least, the equivalent temperature in Kelvin be mentioned.
Each minds, asking different questions, without knowing, about laws of physics, any questions must give scene
So Neil I was wondering if it’s possible if phosphine could be created by a asteroid. Impacting Venus and carrying that chemical to the surface of the planet? Or maybe it breaking up into the atmosphere too. What is your take on this? Would love to hear a reply back love watching and listening to your huge fan Neil ( I’m also a veteran and was happy to fight for people like Neil to make are lives better).
Check out @bullaki for more on the Venus phosphine discovery
leaving these shows I feel dummer and smarter at the same time.
That is a goal I have for everyone who talks to me.
I want to teach you something I know would be important.
I also know you can teach me something of importance that I have no prior knowledge of.
Knowledge makes the world go round
"Pull out the hard ones", you really didn't think before that phrase was uttered....
Pills are rocky but on the Flintstones rocks can be chewy.
So nice not having Chuck there. So much more got accomplished and guess what? It still was funny! 👍🏼
are you still in touch with Lawrence ? just asking
So glad Chuck is not co hosting 😭
Nobody asked your opinion
Maybe Campbell Jr. was right in his book .. maybe there’s life on Venus, a war fought with colossal 50 engines bombers
Venus 🧡
I keep thinking about the rainforest cafe and yelling Volcano in the restaurant
Hey, thanks to not only you, but all of you.. I’ve been watching you for only about a week, as a dropout it was difficult, teachers telling you different when you know it’s right. Particularly math.
I’ve been on some tech stuff, managed to find I read the AMD / Nvidia leaks, did the math and knew months before others on the current release. I’ve posted on reddit, everyone disagreed and I ended up nailing it..
You’ll see me soon.
I like what you just said about the “verification” process... I litterally had this happen on reddit and than gained followers afterwards.. :s
How much data do we actually have on the other planets?
I've enjoyed the show, Thanks!